Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Kulbir Singh · 05 Aug 2004

This is an excellent statement by Jatha in India. Irrespective of which group of Jatha released this statement, it was long overdue. Jatha has been sleeping for too long and must wake up to such threats as change in maryada of Takhat Sahib. It is okay if Jatha wants to stay mostly religious and avoid politics but to keep quiet on vital Panthik issues concerning Maryada is wrong. It is a matter of great concern that the maryada of Siri Akal Takhat Sahib has been changed by force and it must be restored as soon as possible. I appeal to all other Panthik organisations to unite and ensure that old Takhat Sahib maryada is restored. Daas, Kulbir Singh Restore traditional Takht ‘maryada’, says jatha Tribune News Service Chandigarh, August 5 The Akhand Kirtani Jatha International (Prabandhki Pehchan) today at a meeting appealed to the Akal Takht to restore the old, traditional “maryada’’. This requires that bhog of the akhand path at Akal Takht must end with shabad of "Mundavani", and not at "Ragmala", as the practice was for quite some time now. A spokesperson of the jatha, Mr Satnam Singh, told TNS that the Jathedar of Akal Takht was appealed to restore the old practice. The Jatha meeting reiterated that it had always accepted, acknowledged and abided by any edict issued by Akal Takht . Any religious or Panthic issue before any other Takht, on which there was difference of opinion, must also be adjudicated by Akal Takht in conformity with’’ panch pradhani’’, it added. Mr Satnam Singh giving an example of such a controversial issue, quoted the case of Sikh scholar Giani Gurdit Singh’s book, "Mundavai", which is being currently debated at Takht Patna Sahib. "Such matters should be handled by Akal Takht, as it is an important issue

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

- · 05 Aug 2004

>old, traditional “maryada’’< how is this maryada old and traditional? >panch pradhani’< what's panch pradhani?

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Rashminder Singh OZ · 05 Aug 2004

VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsaVaheguruJeeKeeFateh yes u r ritght bhai sahib kulbir singh ji we must do something now we been quite from so long and the outcome was some people used this time and made raag maaalaaa so sacred for people lets get togeather and take step now we should appeal all other organisations to come in front at akaal takhart sahib for raag maalaa issue Deg Teg Fateh

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 05 Aug 2004

WAHEGURU jI KA kHALSA WAHEGURU jI kI FATEH. Although I am not a AKJ member...on this issue of Raagmala I fully support this stand of the Jatha. The wrong decision to begin reading of Raagmala has had very unfortunate consequences as far as Malaysia is concerned. Major Gurdwaras that had not read raagmala for over 80 years were forced by the sangat to commence reading raagmala and cited the practise at Akal Takhat as the reason for it. Raagmala is NOT GURBANI and the Akal takhat must take a decision to standardise the Maryada on this point. Dass jarnail Singh

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

harjinder Singh · 06 Aug 2004

Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki Fateh Bhajis/Bhenjis, I am a firm believer that Ragmaala is Gurbani and know that it has been read for the last few years at the Bhogs of Akhand Paths at Sri Akhal Takhat Sahib. I also know it was not read at Takhat Sahib prior to 1984 - but am not sure when this was agreed to not read it (could someone please clarify - with any resolutions of SGPC to this effect). If the Jatha want to make an issue out of this and then say that they are only doing this to protect Maryada of Takhat Sahib or directives of SGPC/Akhal Takhat Sahib - then I would argue they should then accept the whole of the SGPC dirtectives on Maryada eg. consumption of meat, 3 Bani's in Amrit Sanchars & Kes as a Kakkar. Before anyone goes off on one, I'm not trying to initiate an email war, but rather pointing to the fact that many people say they obey all directives passed at the Takhat Sahib and then shun away from some of them. My point being that the Jatha should rather say we disagree on these issues and not make the claim of "obeying all directives" as this is hypocritical. To clarify I don't see a problem with the Jatha saying Keski is a Kakkar as it is a good thing for all to wear Keskis and I myself don't agree with the SGPC Rehat Maryada on many points. Sorry for any offence caused - hopefully Bhai Kulbir Singh can answer my raised points, I pray this doesn't turn into a 30 post topic. Bhul Chuk Maff Karna Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki Fateh Harjinder Singh

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

A Singh · 06 Aug 2004

Yep, we should resolve it and ensure that it retains it's due respect and status as an integral part of the Sri Guru. How can those who don't even possess knowledge of Raag, those in a Jatha which never sings Kirtan in Raag, those in a Jatha which has only been in existence for barely 50 years be able to comment let alone decide accurately upon matters concerning the Raag Mala!

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Masard GanDaa Singh · 06 Aug 2004

Maybe the Jatha should do some research on what the actuall maryada of the Akal takht. The long raihraas and Ragmala was read there from Bh. Mani Singhs till about 1930 and Bhae Mani sINGH gUTKA WHICH IS STILL AVALAIBLE has this long raihraas. It has only been since about 1930 that these changes have been implemented. It was the Gargaj Khalsa that by force changed the maryada to suit there needs which is what I think the Jatha is doing to push there Ragmala point. The real maryada is the marayad of the time of Bh.Mani Singh,not this shaved down marayada of today. Why has not the jatha ever stood on the point that there are people who do Amrit Sanchaar seva there that eat meat and drink but because they are SGPC they have to do the duty. Why have they not stood up on this point which is far more important than ragmala. Why have they not spoken up on the issue that most of the SGPC people are alcoholic drinkers??? Everybody has there own hidden agenda, I just think they are doing this to push there point. When the SGPC has taken the decision to read it or not it is your choice, then what is the fuss about, just follow there what the decision????

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Concerned Singh · 06 Aug 2004

VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh! Would it not be more fruitful for all Sikh brothers and sisters to concentrate on more pressing issues? The major disrespect which is threatened to take place in Northampton on Sunday 22 August is a prime example. If we cannot tackle gross examples of such misconduct, why are we even bothering to call ourselves Sikhs of our beloved Guru? Let us be more united in our approach - it is truly amazing what the Sangat can achieve when it is united and focused on doing Seva of Sri Guru Granth Sahib. PLEASE come to Northampton Gurdwara Sahib tomorrow night at 9 pm to meet with the committee and stop this - we all have committments but surely a few hours may make all the difference.

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Singh · 06 Aug 2004

"The Jatha meeting reiterated that it had always accepted, acknowledged and abided by any edict issued by Akal Takht . " The above does not hold true, when you consider how the Jatha has never accepted the United hukam of the Guru Khalsa Panth in the form of the Sikh Rehat Maryada, issued by the Guru Panth from Akal Takt Sahib. People should research how the Guru Panth has issued this Maryada for all members of the Panth, and not so personality groups can pick and choose what suits them from the confirmed Guru Panths Rehat.

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Meharban Singh · 06 Aug 2004

Posts by Veer Harjinder Singh and A Singh in defence of Ragmalla, I want to respond. Please allow me. 1. Sant Jarnail Singh Ji Bhindrawale did not allow his followers to interfere with the earlier practice of "No Ragmalla" at Sri Akal Takhat, when he was there immediately before 1984. This shows his "Maturity Level as a Sikh Leader". However, after him, they used their MANMARZI at Takhat. 2. Rehatmaryada (by SGPC) reads that Ragmalla, till any new decision is taken about it, continue with the local & earlier practice. 3. Our ancestors, probably found an amicable solution to the debate, by not allowing IT at Akal Takhat and by not forcing it at other places. May be Akal Takhat at that time represented TAT KHALSA, which was not under the influence of MAHANTS AND SANTS. 4. When one says earlier Maryada should be restored, he is not bound to say we agreewith everything. But he does mean that "any decisions taken by force and being continued due to fear "should be discontinued. ( Anyway,Takhats never say eat meat, do not wear Keski, do three not five path. ) 5. Of course Jatha may be wrong on many issues, its men know no rag, but RAGMALLA decision is simple, VEER JEEO : all rags referred in RAGMALLA are not there in GURBANI and all rags present in GURBANI are not there in RAGMALLA. Veer Harjinder Singh Ji, I am really sorry, if I am unable to touch the point you emphasized. Daas.

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

me · 06 Aug 2004

funny how certain contibutors to this forum, will either begin a topic subject, then say nothing else thereafter, and only see logic in their own view point or stance and will even put across 'questionable' stories to back up there claims...

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Kulbir Singh · 06 Aug 2004

My intention behind starting this thread was not to debate whether Raagmala is baani or not. The issue here is that it was wrong to change maryada of Siri Akal Takhat without following the proper protocol. Such unceremonial changes are very harmful for Panth. I have heard some Singhs say that since Raagmala was not read at Siri Akal Takhat Sahib, Sikh Panth had to endure Operation Blue Star. Well, now Raagmala has been read at Siri Akal Takhat Sahib for last many years but Panth has gone towards more dhehindi kala (downward). In any case, to bring any change in maryada, the clergy at Siri Akal Takhat Sahib must follow proper protocol. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Mkhalsa · 06 Aug 2004

>>>>If the Jatha want to make an issue out of this and then say that they are only doing this to protect Maryada of Takhat Sahib or directives of SGPC/Akhal Takhat Sahib - then I would argue they should then accept the whole of the SGPC dirtectives on Maryada eg. consumption of meat, 3 Bani's in Amrit Sanchars & Kes as a Kakkar. Before anyone goes off on one, I'm not trying to initiate an email war, but rather pointing to the fact that many people say they obey all directives passed at the Takhat Sahib and then shun away from some of them.<<<<<<< This is pretty funny sounding to me. The Jatha has followed akal takht since forever. The jatha has never gone against akal takht and if it ever did I would leave it in a heartbeat and never return. The Jatha is the most panthic organization! Does Akal Takht Maryada say you HAVE to eat meat? where does it say that, it just says its optional. Does it say you HAVE to read only 3 banis? where does it say you cant do more bania? Where does it say you cant wear keski all the time? tell me this? The SGPC maryada does NOT say you cannot go above and beyond what is stated. If the Jatha wants to follow gurmat moreso than SGPC and have a stricter rehat *WITHOUT* violating anything in the maryada, HOW IS THAT WRONG?! >>>Maybe the Jatha should do some research on what the actuall maryada of the Akal takht. The long raihraas and Ragmala was read there from Bh. Mani Singhs till about 1930<<<< Wheres your proof? historical documentation? anything? I find it funny that the jatha is always being accused of going against akal takht when AKJ is the only jatha that follows akal takht maryada to a near T. All other jathas publish their own maryada ie Taksal, Nihangs, Nanaksar, etc What does AKJ hand out at their samagams? SGPC Maryada, plus some books that show we should go above and beyond it to have a stronger maryada. We should always be working for more rehat, why stay at hte bare minimum (SGPC)?? I have never seen any other Jatha stick by akal takht time nad time again, never argue against akal takht and hand out SGPC literature as well. So these accusations are entirely baseless and are just nonsensical attacks on a very panthic jatha, i would venture to say, the most panthic. Now let the your an "akjer" attacks start.....

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Khalsa · 06 Aug 2004

I am not against AKJ or anything like that nor I want to discuss whether raag maala is bani or not. But if we are talking about puratan maryada then I think until 1849 Akaal Takhat Sahib was under control of Nihung Jathebandis like Akali Phoola Singh Ji. And those nihungs were good and true gursikhs. All Nihung Jathebandis read raag maala so until 1849 raag maala was being read at Akaal Takhat Sahib. Why not restore that Maryada? SGPC does say Amrit Banis are only three not more. Of course they don't say don't read more but Sikhs know that Banis are five in the morning. Meat is not forced but why call it "optional". If AKJ is following akal takhat sahib ever since then when Keski was changed to optional did jatha follow that too? if no then why did they start reading short rehraas sahib? During Bhai Randhir Singh Ji's time Jatha used to read JapJi Sahib with Akhand Paath Sahib like Taksal which is not being followed by Jatha now. May I ask why? rehraas changed many times did all jatha members change it too? Micheal Odwayer was given seropa at Akaal Takhat Sahib, did jatha follow that too? If no then I say Jatha has not been following Akaal Takhat Sahib ever since. Keski is optional and Kes are kakkar so jatha should follow that too and make keski optional. and Mkhalsa correct me if i am wrong but AKJ does have its own maryada which can be found on akj.org.uk. why not put SGPC maryada on akj sites?? AKj is very panthik but just because you do not know how panthik other jathebandis (taksal, nanaksar etc.) are does not mean they are not panthik. This is very stupid action to take. Why not take action against government who has locked up our thousands of brothers in jail since 84? Why not help the victims of 84? Why not get together with all jathebandis and come up with one neutral maryada that is acceptable by all? If I offended anyone please forgive me. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Mkhalsa · 06 Aug 2004

First off, Panchain does NOT speak for akhand keertani jatha. Akhand Keertani Jatha did not release this statement. Akhand Keertani Jatha is CONSTANTLY fighting for families of shaheeds, constantly fighting to help gursikhs. They just dont brag about it. >>>>During Bhai Randhir Singh Ji's time Jatha used to read JapJi Sahib with Akhand Paath Sahib like Taksal which is not being followed by Jatha now. May I ask why?<<<< 1) It wasnt a strict maryada 2) its a nonsensical tradition why not pay attention to the bani being read instead of sitting their reading another bani and distracting everyone? COMMON SENSE. Regarding times when bad decisions were made at akal takht sahib, AKJ stood with the rest of the panth (SARBAT KHALSA) and GURMAT against mahants and other idiots that may have been in control. Either way, the jatha has always stood with the panth. To this day, no other jatha can say this. Every other jatha is still bickering over ridiculous issues with akal takht sahib and the rest of the panth. One example is Baba Jarnail Singh Jees Shaheedi. I guarantee you 100% if the panth made a decision that raag mala is bani, I would read it, bhai kulbir singh jee would read it, the entire AKJ would read it. why? because the panth would have spoken on the issue. This again proves my point that AKJ is the most panthic jathebandi. Now I am tired of talking about jathas, what a waste of time.

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Khalsa · 06 Aug 2004

Mkhalsa Ji, I did not say AKJ is not Panthik. In fact, I stated clearly that AKJ is very panthik. "1) It wasnt a strict maryada 2) its a nonsensical tradition" maryada is maryada and why have traditions?? Bhai Sahib Ji did it. Why? Just a tradition or just felt like doing it? Many things are not being done today in the Jatha for example, listening to Akhand Paath Sahib before taking Amrit. and this holds true for every jathebandy because all jathebandis have changed big time since 84. "why not pay attention to the bani being read instead of sitting their reading another bani and distracting everyone?" JapJi Sahib is not read loudly. Perhaps you should study why this Bani is read with Akhand Paath Sahib. What about when Jatha does kirtan during Akhand Paath sahib?? why not listen to Paath instead of sitting there doing kirtan and distracting everyone?? First you said Jatha stood with Akaal Takhat Sahib and now you say Panth. This proves you speak without any knowledge about Akaal takhat Sahib's history and puratan maryada. and of course, one decision should be made regarding Raag Maala whether Bani or not. Until then, lets try to make ourselves better gursikhs with Naam Simran. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

JSS · 06 Aug 2004

MKhalsa in your attempts at telling the sangat of how good the jatha is...and i'm not disagreeing with you on that...the jatha has done a ton of seva for the panth.....you've said that akj has never gone against akal takt or sgpc maryada....BUT isn't telling people that keski is kakar and not kes...disagreeing with akal takt maryada?...it is one thing to say that "we understand kes is the kakar, but we like to wear keski to show our devotion"...that is called meeting the minimum and going beyond... BUT many times on akj sites other jathas have been put down by the akjers because they don't consider keski as kakaar...other jathas that ARE following akal takt maryada to a T...not just nearly..... i don't have anything against the jatha...i know many awesome gursikhs in the jatha...its just those singhs that run around on the net making claims that we all know aren't true....how can you make a claim that akj is the MOST panthic?....do you know all the jathas that exhist out there...do you know all the maryadas that are given during each and every amrit sanchar?...honestly... people should start posting more responsibly.. "Every other jatha is still bickering over ridiculous issues with akal takht sahib and the rest of the panth" sorry to burst your bubble again...i know of a couple of jathas right off the top of my head that make your statement totally false... also...further on the so-called unity b/w sgpc and akj...you routinely on other sites call nihungs that eat meat "nangs"....is that not in some form saying that the akal takt approved sgpc maryada is wrong???...how can you say that you support sgpc and akal takt when you look down on others who follow sgpc maryada....if that's the case...are you saying that it's okay for there to be three banis in maryada..are you saying that that's an okay maryada for amritdharis to follow?...cuz if not...then that's not unity.... also about rediculous issues?....hellooo...raagmala?...there are 1430 angs of guru granth sahib ji...why don't we focus on the getting through the first 1429 and thoroughly implementing those in our lives before we start "bickering" over the last one....or how about we try to just follow even the first ang?.....

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

gupt singh · 07 Aug 2004

although akj do feel strongly and united about this particular stance it would be far more appropriate by analysing the current situation at hand first in terms of the current state of affairs. the sikh faith is degenerating with the sgpc and hasdone since its inception.The only real way fwd is for akj to form an alliance with ddt sikh khalsa panchayat and other serious panthic organisations that are committed to the development of sikh faith. After a political merger such groups shouldwork actively to win the elections and boot sgpc out of power. The firststep is to putour sacred instituitions into the hands of the khalsa and agree not to cross differences once in power. Instead use the power correct to at least make sure the daswand system is allocated properly andnot into private pockets, and increase dharmic parchar with a loose federation of all groups( would you rather see more sikhs of various shades with acceptance or none at all?). If there is no pyar or acceptance of each other than we will always remain entrapped with the giant sgpc draining the resources of the hard earned workers in punjab we are then responsible for the consequences. Just think for a moment where we head with such a move made above. This causes further splits realistically howeverpassionate we feelaboutit we have a million other issues tosort out first. Its betterto make collective decisions at a timewhen the sgpc hegomy will go as far as beating up women and men tryeing to hold a sarbat khalsa for the welfare of the panth.

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Mkhalsa · 07 Aug 2004

>>>Many things are not being done today in the Jatha for example, listening to Akhand Paath Sahib before taking Amrit.<<< I totally agree with you. This needs to happen again, its an important tradition. >>What about when Jatha does kirtan during Akhand Paath sahib?? why not listen to Paath instead of sitting there doing kirtan and distracting everyone?? <<< I am VERY MUCH against this!! Last year at california samagam the akhand patt was going on and all of a sudden 'the keertanis' showed up with vajas and tablas and had keertans. This year, I am hoping the same does not happen. >>First you said Jatha stood with Akaal Takhat Sahib and now you say Panth.<< Either way same thing. I hate it when people take apart what I am saying as I am not a good writer/speaker. Nitpicking is ridiculous, its obvious what I meant to say. >>>This proves you speak without any knowledge about Akaal takhat Sahib's history and puratan maryada.<<< Thats true, I am a very ignorant person. >>>BUT many times on akj sites other jathas have been put down by the akjers because they don't consider keski as kakaar<< Who has ever done that? tell me so I can go tell them off. >>>further on the so-called unity b/w sgpc and akj...you routinely on other sites call nihungs that eat meat "nangs"....<<< I dont call them nangs because they eat meat, you are sorely mistaken. I call them nangs because they DARED to call Shaheed Bhai Fauja Singh a nang. they dared to call great gursikhs like bhai randhir singh a nang, they dared to attack a jathebandi. They dared to insult our panths shaheeds. For this they are maha nangs and that will never change unless they present themselves to tyaar bar tyaar khalsa and admit their mistakes. and gupt singh, that is a very good idea. A political merger would be a great thing. I think thats kind of what sant samaj tried to do, but they are just too santish for the whole panth to get behind. It needs to be more neutral and not controlled by all dera dwellers.

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Harbhajan Singh · 07 Aug 2004

Waheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!!! Sangat Jeeo!!! The statement sent out By AKJ is a important one to notify all sangat that the pre-agreed marayada in which Ragmalla wasn't read at the Akal Thakt should be restored. The agreed marayada makes sense. Until there is not a definate conclusion to the Raagmalla debate then the marayda should be restored. AKJ is anti Raagmallaa and this is our stance. We should not shy away from it. If others stance is Raagmalla is bani then that is their veiw. We should respect that as well. The point of this announcement is that some so called panthic bodies are a law upon themselves. Once they get hold of something they want to make sure that there way of doing things is the best way. In response to those who think Jatha should be concentrating on other things Jatha does. It just blab about it. Jatha as a bodie does parchar through Keertan programs and camps. Many of Jatha youth and elders are involved in different organisations and trying to do there own bit of parchar. But on a important issue like this it is right to make an announcement. Eventhough the announcement was made by Panchain which is a seperate bodie to the Original Jatha it shouldn't be taken as not an overall veiw of the Jatha. Those in the know, KNOW that all Panthic bodies are split or have differences among their members ;) Also people should stop making statements and present proof. We need proof that it wasn't read before 1984. Not just someone saying and then asking for proof of when it passed not to be read. Also Jatha should stick to all maryada of the SGPC. OK if you tell us we will do it. Will you stop printing your rehat marayda and also do what you ask of us? No course you wont because basically you believe in what Jatha believes except for some issues which tear us apart and make us like totally different. AKJ.org.uk on their website have - Gurmat Rehit Maryada - Points of Contention (by Bhai Manmohan Singh). I just read the article and it states Jathas view on certain points of contention in regards to the SGPC Rehat marayda. Nothing wrong in that at all. Jatha is just putting it views forward. If Jatha was promoting and printing that as an Official rehat Marayda then that would equate it to other organisations, and I would wish Jatha not to do this. I wouldn't say Jatha is the most Panthic as Panth is the whole collection of Sikh organisations. Jatha is a intergral part of the Panth as are the other organisations. Calling false Nihangs: Nangs is a way of countering what the these cowards called jatha shaeeds and active members of the Jatha. get your facts right before you post. The word Nangs has stuck to the UK Nihangs because most people see these Shiva worshipping Macdonalds eating Tesco Chicken shopping geezers for what they are. Well if we come down to the crux of the matter and that is most of the other organisations who are Pro-Raagmalla think Jatha is a pain in the neck for ringing this subject up. Jatha also knows their isnt going to be much agreement over this and would keep taking this stance. I therefore commend this. And the those on the other side of the fence are in their rights to make their own statemnts countering Jathas as they see fit. Also Gupt Singh. There are a few powerful Sikh political and religious bodies in the Panth who have the most money and say. This list I would not include Jatha or DDT, eventhough Sant Samaj has members of DDT and promotes Sant Poojah. So glad they got trounced in the elections, to many communications with the RSS is always a no-no. The bodies in power do not want to align themselves with AKJ or DDT. So getting together will be very hard in deed. It's still a dream but with Guru Jee's kirpa anything can happen. So keep hoping and doing ardas you never know what can happen. Bhul chuk Marf Karna Waheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh [%sig%]

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Singh10 · 07 Aug 2004

"they are just too santish for the whole panth to get behind. It needs to be more neutral and not controlled by all dera dwellers" What is wrong with that? If someone is taking the lead and doing something good, if you cannot help, you shouldn't stand in their way and oppose them. What is wrong in dwelling in a dera. There was a time when the Khalsa used to have deras in jungles. If the panth followed sants, naam abhiasee people, rather than following people who are politically corrupt, we would have SachKhand on earth.

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Singh10 · 07 Aug 2004

Prophecy Of Success of Khalsa One day Akalis submitted themselves before Sant Attar Singh Ji Maharaj. They asked Sant Ji, "Kindly let us know the worldy way." Sant Ji observed, "The day when the Guru Khalsa selects five leaders and one chief and when all will obey them, all projects, schemes, and works will be succesfully performed. However (while making selection) honesty and impartiality must be excercized. None should be patronised. Whatever is in the minds must come out. But when selection has been made all must obey them till they are alive and they must strictly observe the laws and rules laid down by the Satgurus. They must be obeyed. If you do not do this, then those who go high are thrown down on the ground."

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Mkhalsa · 08 Aug 2004

hmm sounds a lot like what bhai rama jee said.

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Singh · 09 Aug 2004

MKhalsa, "The Jatha has followed akal takht since forever. The jatha has never gone against akal takht and if it ever did I would leave it in a heartbeat and never return. The Jatha is the most panthic organization!" I’m sorry Mkhals perhaps you simply do not know about the Sikh Rehat Maryada by the Guru Khalsa Panth issued from Sri Akal Takt or you are trying to convince others and perhaps your self that the Jatha is following the Sikh Rehat Maryada issued from Sri Akal Takt I have nothing against the Jatha but it DOES NOT in your words “followed akal takht since forever” as it does not accept the Sikh Rehat Maryada, which is not only issued from Sri Akal Takt but is the only Rehat Maryada stamped and confirmed by the Guru Khalsa Panth. The Jatha has its own rehat which contradicts the Sikh Rehat Maryada in many ways. For instance in the Sikh Rehat Maryada Kesh is the Kekar, only halal meat is banned and other things like picking up your hairs rather than letting them go down the drain after isnaan etc are not included. However the Jatha follows these things in their rehat maryada, so how has the Jatha been following the Akal Takt???. Please can you explain how in your words “The Jatha is the most panthic organization!", when the Jatha does not follow the combined hukam of the Guru Khalsa Panth in the form of the Sikh Rehat Maryada. How can you claim the Jatha is the most panthic organization when it does not follow but infact contradicts the only Rehat which is 100% pathentic in the sense that it has been agreed by and stamped by the Guru Khalsa Panth?? Your statement simply makes no sense. I think its important to know how Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Ji was prepared even to wear a colored Keshera if a hukam from Akhal Takt said it was ok (in his great biography), however the Sikh Rehat Maryada is more than just a issue from Sri Akal Takat but is issued by the Guru himself in the form of the Guru Khalsa Panth, and therefore groups like the Jatha who as you claim are Panthic should accept the Panths decision and Rehat Maryada rather than continue with their own Rehats opposing Maryada's. Should'nt we accept that no one groups in higher than the United Panth and we should truly accept the hukam from the Panth rather than saying one thing but in reality doing and preaching another.

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Harpartap Singh · 09 Aug 2004

VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh! It's so sad that there are 23 posts on this topic already yet when the issue of taking Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji to hotels, bars etc has been raised there was not nearly the same 'enthusiasm'. We need to work TOGETHER - pragmatically on issues we all agree on which are dear to our Guru and our Panth...

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Mkhalsa · 09 Aug 2004

>>>Please can you explain how in your words “The Jatha is the most panthic organization!", when the Jatha does not follow the combined hukam of the Guru Khalsa Panth in the form of the Sikh Rehat Maryada. How can you claim the Jatha is the most panthic organization when it does not follow but infact contradicts the only Rehat which is 100% pathentic in the sense that it has been agreed by and stamped by the Guru Khalsa Panth?? Your statement simply makes no sense. <<< Singh, I already explained, probably more than once. I am sorry you didnt read my post, I will re post it here: Does Akal Takht Maryada say you HAVE to eat meat? where does it say that, it just says its optional. Does it say you HAVE to read only 3 banis? where does it say you cant do more bania? Where does it say you cant wear keski all the time? tell me this? The SGPC maryada does NOT say you cannot go above and beyond what is stated. If the Jatha wants to follow gurmat moreso than SGPC and have a stricter rehat *WITHOUT* violating anything in the maryada, HOW IS THAT WRONG?! On top of this, AKJ is the only organization that does not publish its own rehatmaryada but rather distributes SGPC's along with information about why we should follow MORE rehat. Which again, is perfectly in line with akal takht sahib. Proving this just sounds so egotistical and I think I will stop replying here. Please read my previous posts to understand where I was coming from. If you want to go after someone, why not go after those who blatantly disregard the maryada, without even saying they follow it, and publish their own with many things that contradict SGPC's.

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

jss · 09 Aug 2004

Sorry mkhalsa veerji... once again...you've made a false statement by saying that the AKJ is the only jatha that doesn't publish it's own rehit....i could name a couple of jathas that don't do this... also one question....you say that the jatha has no problem with SGPC rehit...it merely follows a more strict version....then in that situation...say a an amritdhari singh comes to an akj samagam who eats meat and only does the 3 banis...would he be allowed to take part in seva?...keertan?...do chaur sahib seva...do ardas?.... because if he wasn't allowed to do this...that means the akj rejects the SGPC rehit, not simply following more strict version.... also..how about amritdhari bibis who don't wear keski...would they be allowed to do kirtan?...actually i already know the answer to that one..cuz someone i know was not allowed to do kirtan at a rensabaii simply cus she didn't wear a keski, even though she was amritdhari.....now...is that not saying that her rehit isn't good enough...which by logical progression would mean that the akj REJECTS kes as kakar.... and since kes is listed as kakaara in sgpc maryada...it would be very logical to conclude that AKJ rejects sgpc maryada..... this is not an attack on the jatha...i respect it for its beliefs even though i may not agree on everything with them...but you my veerji are making statements that are not true and these statements may inadvertantly mislead readers....i'm sure you're not trying to do it on purpose, but please refrain to make invalid statments.... waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

MKhalsa · 10 Aug 2004

jss jee... i am in your charna. you make sense. but again, jatha follows a much stricter rehat and enforces it. but underlying thing is sgpc. its the same thing, trust me ;) shall i list everything the jatha agrees with sgpc on? wow 2-3 things we have a problem with, not a big deal with a book that size. >>>would he be allowed to take part in seva?...keertan?...do chaur sahib seva...do ardas?....<<< ive seen it happen, of course after participating in samagams with jatha many people change. meat eating is disgusting and i think this is something most jathas agree on. most meat eaters do not even follow sgpc maryada but claim to use it to back up their theorys. They do not eat chatka, so therefore they have no defense.

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Singh · 10 Aug 2004

Mkhalsa, Thanks for your reply and attempt to show how your views are not a contradiction. You claim that the Sikh Rehat Maryada and the Maryada followed by the Jatha are the same and not contradictory based on in your words “Does Akal Takht Maryada say you HAVE to eat meat? where does it say that, it just says its optional. Does it say you HAVE to read only 3 banis? where does it say you cant do more bania?” I am sure you know that in the Jatha eating meat is 100% banned and is regarded not just as a sin but one of the four Kurehts. This is not a slight difference from the Sikh Rehat Maryada which does not ban meat but a totally different and opposing stance. Is not having different Kurehts from the Panths Sikh Rehat Maryada Violating it?? Likewise the Sikh Rehat Maryada clearly states that Kesh is the Kekar and not Keski, which is not mentioned. Whilst the Jatha as you already know believe that Keski is the Kekar, without which an amridhari does not have the 5 ks but only four, as Kesh is regarded as not a Kekar. Hence this contradicts the Sikh Rehat Maryada. Likewise the Nitnem as per the Sikh Rehat Maryada is 3 bani’s and any additional bani’s although excellent are not the prescribed nitnem. But someone who does 3 bani’s as Nitnem in the Jatha is not following the Rehat of the Jatha which rejects 3 banis completely. Therefor Mkhalsa with the Sikh Rehat Maryada you can indeed still be a vegetarian, wear a Keski and indeed do as many bani’s as possible. However the Rehat followed by the Jatha strongly opposes and is against doing 3 banis, does not consider anyone without a Keski as having the 5 k’s and even considers Sikhs who eat meat as patits. This is not a slight difference but blatantly shows how the two Rehats are different, on basic issues like Kekars Kurehts. Having different Kekars, Kurehts is in fact a violation of the Sikh Maryada, just like preaching and having a Maryada which believes eating garlic is a Kureht, and anyone who does less than 10 bani’s is not doing his nitnem. With your way of thinking anyone can follow their own Maryada and make their own rules but still claim to follow the Sikh Rehat Maryada. I think you’ll find this was why the Khalsa Panth got together and issued the Sikh Rehat Maryada in the first instance.

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

jagroop singh · 10 Aug 2004

Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, May i humbly say that whilst i was an onlooker as this thread developed, i can't hold back any more... What an ABSOLUTE waste of time - the most spiritually desolate thread currently on this website; nothing but Jathebandi-bashing posing as 'constructive debate'. The question is: > Let's get on with our jeevans, leave out all these language games and accept that in Sikhi there are different schools of thought regarding Rehit...accept it...embrace it...LIVE WITH IT. The discussion is not centred around differences of opinion any more which can be useful in terms of developing our Sikhi; it has now veered off into 'i believe i live according to SRM / no you don't / yes i do etc.' At the end of the day, Siree Guru Sahib Ji and Vahiguru alone know your full intentions...why you do something and view certain Asools/practices as important/non-important etc...what more is there to say? Pls forgive this outburst. Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Kulbir Singh · 10 Aug 2004

Many contributors under this thread have claimed that Jatha does not follow the SGPC maryada. I believe that this is an erroneous statement. The SGPC is the minimum common rehit maryada that all Sikhs should believe in. It does not stop you from following more rehit. As an example, it tells you to recite 3 baaniyaan at amritvela along with Naam Abhyaas. If Jatha or other panthik organisations promote 5 baaniyaan it does not in any way negate the SGPC maryada because the 5 baaniyaan promoted by Jatha include the 3 baaniyaan that SGPC tells you to recite. Most Jatha Singhs also do Siri Sukhmani Sahib along with their nitnem and this does not violate the basic nitnem. It is foolish to make an issue out of this. Regarding eating meat, Jatha does not support eating meat and this does not violate the SGPC maryada because the SGPC maryada does not make it mandatory for Sikhs to eat meat. As for Dastaar, again the SGPC maryada does not prohibit one from wearing a dastaar. There is nothing wrong in promoting Dastaar as a Kakaar. Please remember that promoting Keski as a kakaar does not undermine Kesh in anyway. If Jatha had given the option of cutting hair and keeping Keski instead of that, then it would have violated the SGPC maryada but as things are, Jatha is the strongest supporter of Kesh. Violation of cutting hair is one of the 4 Bajjar Kurehits. The issue being discussed under this thread was using proper protocol to alter old maryada. The un-ceremonial change in maryada of Akal Takhat is what was the issue here. I don’t know why some people started attacking Jatha. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Singh · 10 Aug 2004

Kulbir Singh, Please can I refer you to my post above for Mkhalsa. You are basically saying the same him as Mkhalsa, however this has already been concluded in my post. Please refer to it rather than making the same response which has already been given and already concluded as a contradiction. Therefor please prove how the Jatha follows the Sikh Rehat Maryada with new ideas rather than the same ones which have already been answered in my post. The two Rehats are different, as although anyone who follows the hukam of the Guru Panth as all members of the Panth should (IE accepts the Sikh Rehat Maryada) can keep a Keski, be a vegetarian and do as many bani’s as he or she likes, the Rehat proscribed by the Jatha DOES NOT allow eating meat, non Keski and Prohibits 3 Bani’s. Therefore the Rehat by the Jatha is not the same but clearly contradicts the Sikh Rehat Maryada. Only if the Jatha’s Rehat also allowed the flexibility of eating meat, non Keski, and 3 Bani’s as the Sikh Rehat Maryada does for keeping Keski, not eating meat, doing 5 bani’s can they be regarded as some what the same. But as you know the Jatha’s Rehat does not allow for this and hence has aseparate Kureht, Kekars etc from the Guru Panth. This is not a hard thing to understand. In prevouse posts you have also said that the Sikh Rehat Maryada or SPGC Maryada as you keep calling it is wrong, which is the view held by most members of the Jatha. How can anyone realisitically consider themselves a member of the Panth whilst at the same time preaching against it's hukam for example Kesh being the Kekar and saying that the united Guru Panth was wrong and they are right.

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Amar Singh · 10 Aug 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh It should be made clear that there is infact no such thing as an SPGC Rehat Maryada, but only the SIKH REHAT MARYADA. This is issued by the Guru Khalsa Panth (if anyone cares to research its history) and has written in crystal clear words on the front page the SIKH Rehat Maryada, and not the SPGC Maryada. Who made this Maryada - the Guru in the form of the Guru Panth. And who should follow it, all Sikhs who consider themselves part of the Khalsa Panth. Just wanted to make this point before the admin close this thread. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

jss · 10 Aug 2004

kulbir singh ji.... if what you say is true, then that jatha is at no fault and not contradictory with sgpc.... BUT.... i have witnessed many times when other amritdhari singhs have been discrimnated against only because they follow the "basic sgpc" rehit...how do you explain this discrimination???????? neither you or mkhalsa have addressed this issue; instead you both go toting the same line about "how the jatha is just following more strict rehit" this is not a thread attacking the jatha...simply discussing certain aspects of it...we can ALL learn something from it if we try to be rational and discuss instead of being on the defensive....

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

warrior*princess · 10 Aug 2004

This whole threads discussion didnt even stick to the Subject.. I agree with Jagroop singh jee, what a waste of time on debating the different maryada.. at the end of the day, everyone will do what they believe in, so just leave it*. Live your life the best way you can, your example will shine and people will see whats True through Guru jee's kirpaa. I understand that we would all like every Sikh to be practising the same thing as every other Sikh, but in this kalyug things are different.. Hopefully one day there will just be TRUE Khalsa following one reht, thats it. All this is upto Akal Purakh. Everyone needs to accept each other and think of ourselves as lower to the other person. Vaheguru jee can twist a persons life within one second, and we could suddenly be like the person we opposed. Point being, Vaheguru jee does everything, its Vaheguru jis will..we are to accept it and remember that we should be open hearted and understanding of others AND then work from there. *IF we feel Sikhi needs justifying along the correct path, then lets do Sikhi Parchaar, and not debate. The more I hear about whats going on, its so saddening...the whole unity issue is collapsing at times. What happened about being humble and understanding... ??? EVEN if we dont agree with someones lifestyle practice, we still shouldnt be attacking one another. [If they are doing baistee of Sikhi religion, thats a diff story] If Guru Sahib jee gives us Gian, lets not forget that we musnt use it in Ego nor vain, because Guru Sahib jee can also take it back. [e.g. wise to a fool, beggar to a king] Other than that the best Seva is to simply be a Sikh.. With debate, even this is starting to seem like the most complicated step for those who are trying to get onto the path of true Sikhi. Also, we need to stop saying that someone is panchayn, akj etc etc... We are Sikhs first, and then dependent on the reht that is followed. Otherwise its starting to sound like the battle of groups, when this is most certainly not the case. Guru Sahib jee only wants us to be Khalsa. Its so stupid to see the amount of moaning i literally hear from people about akj and then to read it. Everyone needs to just practise what they believe in, and learn to respect one another. Maybe there should be a site, where akj's stance is clearly defined then there wont be like a million statements or repetition of the same debate over and over again. Personally i believe there is only one true reht, which can be enhanced upon by personal preference. At the end of the day, only the truth lasts forever, it is up to us to use common sense and find out about history, read banee and live Sikhi. We should all pray that Guru Sahib jee guides us all,and BEG for Kirpaa as much as we need to. Meanwhile we should accept each other. I think sometimes we are probably more friendly to our friends that aren't even Sikhs!! When Guru Sahib jee did parchaar, they did so lovingly. Whoever wanted to be led by Guru jee, followed. Whereas the others continued their lifestyle. Guru jee did not attack them, but instead strengthened parchaar with pyaar. Lets use the same tactic. Lets not forget that maybe in our past life we lived a Sikhi lifestyle but not the one at present. Just imagine ourselves in the position of another person, and how would we want to be treated..??!! [forgive me if i offended anyone]

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Mkhalsa · 10 Aug 2004

hmm.. first off, it is sgpc rehat as this is a draft, it was never finalized by akal takht as the singhs ended up never getting around to meeting to create a final draft. so this is a draft that sgpc publishes as "sikh rehat maryada" (as far as i am aware) I have heard of older drafts (1912) which talk about keski requirements, sarbloh, no meat etc. regarding meat, the original version of the current publication of "sikh rehat maryada" says Kuttha is banned. If you read the article on akj.org called points of contention (which clearly lays out issues akj has with sgpc maryada) you will see why meat is against sikhi. The maryada clearly says kuttha is banned. kuttha has always meant something that is killed!! the asterisk and note were unceremoniously added later saying that jhatka is ok. this is wrong. similar to how raag mala just started being read at akal takht without any input from panth, without any command, rouge people just implemented it without any authority to do so. same with this asterisk for kuttha. so basically jatha only disagrees slightly with the current publication. only 2 issues, keski and nitnem bania. BUT even if one were to take amrit at an amrit sanchar run by sgpc, i beleive they say you are to read the banis read at amrit sanchar, would this not be a contradiction of the 3 banis? unless they make amrit with japji sahib, jaap sahib, svaiye, rehras, and sohila? so again, its not a disagreement, just a different interpretation. as for keski.. thats another issue i wont get into. so technically, you can say theres only one disagreement between jatha and current SRM, which jatha hasnt violated, just extended upon.

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

distribution free · 11 Aug 2004

there are like thousands... of girls who attend akj rainsabhaees, keertans and smagams around the world - who do not have the self confidence to keep the hair on their face uncut, unshaved, unbleached. there are like thousands of singhs in the waiting... who are monay right now and just need an older brother to teach them how to tie a dumaalaa and what the meanings of jaap sahib are. but it's really unfortunate that these youth are struggling while people are busy making sure gianis don't read rag mala after the akhand paath. [%sig%]

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Meharban Singh · 11 Aug 2004

I am very much convinced, Rag Malla is not by GURUS, but I always respect the feelings of those who think Rag Malla is certainly GURBANI. Their stance shows; they are really good believers. They are very simple and innocent sikhs. A person, who is sure, Ragmalla is GURBANI; and wants to read it always; has a better standard of devotion for the GURU. He is not ready to part with the words of the GURU. (He should not leave it if he is sure about his stance). He is not so called "wise or clever" enough and will not easily surrender to so called "logic." DASS

Re: Restore traditional Takht maryada, says jatha

Admin · 11 Aug 2004

This thread is now closed. Nothing constructive is coming out of it. Admin.