Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Punjab has been foolishly generous

Punjab has been foolishly generous

Kulbir Singh · 17 Aug 2004

Lets hope that Punjab smartens up now. The issue of water is very important for Punjab. There is a danger of Punjab becoming a desert if something is not done soon. Firstly they should stop growing rice crop and secondly they should withdraw from stupid agreements with non-riparian states that ensure that 60% of Punjab water is going out to other states. Daas, Kulbir Singh Punjab has been foolishly generous: Boparai Tribune News Service Chandigarh, August 16 Punjabi University Vice-Chancellor, Swarn Singh Boparai today welcomed the statement of the Prime Minister on the need for a ‘’national and holistic’’ view of management of water resources of the country. Responding to the statement made by Dr Manmohan Singh in his Independence Day message from the Red Fort, the Vice-Chancellor said the present national water policy was ‘’flip flop’’, as no riparian state shared its waters with non-riparian states, except Punjab, which ‘’foolishly’’ showed its generosity by parting with 60 per cent of its water. In a signed statement Mr Boparai said the current water policy was a ‘’tasteless recipe’’ for the riparian states and it was time some ‘’economics’’ was injected into it, making it ‘’edible’’ for riparian states. As the present national water policy took a one-sided view, that of beneficiary states, it was, therefore, partisan and pressureistic. A look at history would show that Rajasthan, Patiala and other princely states availed of water from the riparian Punjab on payment of royalty to the donor and there never was a controversy. The statement said that since Independence Punjab had been labelled “rebellious,” even after it gave much water than all other states put together, while the donor states had become ‘’arrogant, over-bearing and greedy’’. Giving an example, Mr Boparai said that in post-Independence India, coal and crude oil, two other natural resources, played a vital role in development of the country and resource-rich states happily shared their bounty because of the royalty they received. The coal-rich states got an annual royalty of Rs 500 crore to Rs 700 crore. The same was true of crude oil.

Re: Punjab has been foolishly generous

S Singh · 17 Aug 2004

Yes that would be really clever to stop water flowing from Punjab. I bet our Sikh brothers settled in Bikaner would really appreciate that move. Yes by all means cut the area under paddy cultivation, then you need less water and it makes very little difference if other states do get this water. 60% of farm land in Punjab is not irrigated by canal water so how will stopping the water supply to other states help prevent this from turning into desert if the groundwater level keeps to drop ? Stop the water and you will see other states retaliate. Just remember what happened to the Arabs during the oil blockade.

Re: Punjab has been foolishly generous

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 18 Aug 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki afteh. punjab was not foolishly generous....it was looted.- right left and centre. it had no choice in the matter and any attempt at redressing ther injustice was labelled rebellion and anti-india... forget about water and electricity and food grains...what about language, capital city, universities, industry, job craetion, army recruitment...is there any sector where punjab was not discriminated against and looted shamelessly. it is a historical fact...for thousands of years punjab was looted by foreign invaders from as far as turkey...and when Guru Gobind Singh Ji created the Khalsa to STOP those looters...fresh new looters even more shameless than the foreigners appeared in delhi...and they are still there the only sure way to stop these looters once and for all is khalistan. dassan dass jarnail singh

Re: Punjab has been foolishly generous

M Singh · 20 Aug 2004

May be it was looted earlier, but presently it is showing foolishness, many times.

Re: Punjab has been foolishly generous

partinder singh · 20 Aug 2004

i think sikhs need to take a stand and bcome khalsa, they have become hindu sikhs over, proud to be hindustanis , khalistan wont help anything jarnail singh ji... i think we jus need to stick togethar and rpotest.

Re: Punjab has been foolishly generous

ns · 20 Aug 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh foolish or not, looted or not, Punjab is in a sorry state due to not one problem but many issues but the basic one being::: "dharm bina sab dalee maleee haaain" Punjab was and is supposed to be an example to world of what Sikhee actually is no matter what the consequences, but alas till we have practising Sikhs it won't happen. It 's always mentioned Khalistan is the answer, look at Panjab now , if tomorrow it became Khalistan what difference would it make, none till the people change their ways. I can certainly say that Khalistan will be made but it doesn;t seem that the foundations will be laid from Punjab but elsewhere.. Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh