Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Grahsthi Jeevan

Grahsthi Jeevan

VikariSingh · 13 Jun 2003

Most of the puratan sikhs were having Grahsthi Jeevan. I don't know but there might be some who did not entered into Grahsthi Jeevan. So we can say sikhs prefer Grahsthi Jeevan. Is this just our tradition or is it binding by Gurmat? If there is a choice what are the advantages/disadvantages(from Gurmat point of view)? Sangat's views please.

Re: Grahsthi Jeevan

singh · 13 Jun 2003

Vikari singh We are supposed to lead a life by being married, like a normal human then overcome all the bekars. There are singhs today who get married have children and then leave there wives and kids and take no resposibility those type of singhs should be kicked out of the panth

Re: Grahsthi Jeevan

Jarnail Singh · 14 Jun 2003

Waheguru Ji ka Khalksa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. IMHO since ALL our Gurus were married and had children at least by their EXAMPLE we have to be Grishthi. In Gurbani there is not a SINGLE mention of "UNgrishthi" life being GOOD. Sadhu life of being ungrishthi is HINDUISM not GURMAT. Only by LIVING IN this World of MAYA can we be really strong and fight Maya... what is the point of saying you have conquered the urge to steal when you ahve NO OPPORTUNITY to steal anything......ONLY if you Regularly get the "opportunity" to make with a million Bucks and still you dont steal then you can say you have conquered this bikaar. RUNNING away to the Caves and Jungles is NOT GURMAT by GURBANI . It is MANMAT and BRAHMINISM. Jarnail Singh

Re: Grahsthi Jeevan

Hmmmmm. · 14 Jun 2003

waheguro je ka khalsa waheguro je ke fateh. greeshthi jeevan, is hukam. with out greeshthi jeevan there would be no future genertaion and no khalsa raaj. Greeshthi jeevan also shows that the panth is being continued and that you are living a life of both man/woman. -Daas

Re: Grahsthi Jeevan

curious · 15 Jun 2003

how do u define gristi jeevan as marriage? and not perhaps just a householders life as in live work socialise etc? y does it have to mean marriage automatically?

Re: Grahsthi Jeevan

curious · 15 Jun 2003

as for khalsa raj shud sikhs not be preaching actively for the purpose?

Re: Grahsthi Jeevan

Grehsthan · 16 Jun 2003

Waheguru jee ka khalsa, Waheguru jee kee fateh!! Singh wrote: >>>>Vikari singh We are supposed to lead a life by being married, like a normal human then overcome all the bekars. There are singhs today who get married have children and then leave there wives and kids and take no resposibility those type of singhs should be kicked out of the panth <<<<<<<<<< Singh jee there are many singhnie who (most of the time) leave their husband's house for their parents. Why don't parents kick them out when they do so. Are'nt they suppose to stay at their singhs' house after marriage? do'nt you think parents and brothers should not interfere in their doughters and sisters grehsthee jeevan? I don't believe that a singh who's a real singh by following Guru's rehat will be leaving his singhni and kids. I saw singhs trying their best to adjust with their dhilee singhnies even. Most of the time problem rises when singhnies parents interfere in their life. Parents should leave them alone to live their life. There are many problems in our society (not talking about other societies here) when husbands are shraabee or they have other bad habits but singhs don't have those abbs(bad habits) but they could have other smaal problems which could be solved by talking(with love). I also belive that if husband and wife have any disagreements they should discuss it home in a locked room not infront of people (even friends or family). It's a very close relationsh which stands on TRUST. If one/both of them start involving others into this relationship then small problems become bigger and sometimes end up leaving each other.

Re: Grahsthi Jeevan

Sarbloh Badman · 16 Jun 2003

Is it true Bhindranwale left his family when he became Damdami Taksal Jathedar or is that a load of rubbish?

Re: Grahsthi Jeevan

jujhaar · 18 Jun 2003

grest jeevan cud mean live in society dont run away to the jungles work for its betterment, social interaction with people to spread the word of bani, dont seclude urself from humanity actively become part of it daily an contribute.help humanity progress in various fields ( technology, advancement, group activities, communal harmony, creating peace, and yes y not marriage, but y just marriage?) it could mean a whole range of things.

Re: Grahsthi Jeevan

Kulbir Singh · 18 Jun 2003

>>>>>>> Is it true Bhindranwale left his family when he became Damdami Taksal Jathedar or is that a load of rubbish? >>>>> Sant jee did not leave his family to lead Damdami Taksal. Since his responsibilities as a jathedar of Taksal, were very time consuming, he was not able to give as much attention to his family as ordinary people do. He sacrificed his personal life for the sake of Panth. This does not mean that he left his family. To say that he abandoned his family is pure ninda. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Grahsthi Jeevan

Jarnail Singh · 18 Jun 2003

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. It is NINDIA to say SARDAR Jarnail Singh Ji Bhinderawaleh "left" his family to do sewa of the Guru Khalsa Panth. Both Gresthi Jiwan and Sewa of the Panth can be done SIMULTANEOUSLY. After all Guru Nanak Sahib Jee also "left" his family when Guru Ji went on his JOURNEYS around the WORLD........if Guru Ji had not done so how could He accomplish His God Given Task of saving the World. The trouble is that some chughalkhors and nindaks are quick to spot "faults"....... GURBANI says of these....AAp na dheh chul bhar paani..teh nindeh jo GANGA ani......These people CANNOT give a SIP of WATER but do NINDIA of those WHO BRING the WHOLE GANGA RIVER..

Re: Grahsthi Jeevan

-- · 19 Jun 2003

Grehsthan wrote: "Singh jee there are many singhnie who (most of the time) leave their husband's house for their parents. Why don't parents kick them out when they do so. Are'nt they suppose to stay at their singhs' house after marriage? do'nt you think parents and brothers should not interfere in their doughters and sisters grehsthee jeevan? I don't believe that a singh who's a real singh by following Guru's rehat will be leaving his singhni and kids. I saw singhs trying their best to adjust with their dhilee singhnies even. Most of the time problem rises when singhnies parents interfere in their life. Parents should leave them alone to live their life. " There are many generalizations in the above quote that it would be completely insulting to state these generalizations as overall truths... but just a quick note as to the foundation of the argument: It is not the 'husband's house' it is the 'wife and husband's house', maybe one of the first steps is to stop assuming the wife is coming into the husband's life, but more of it being a partnership together. This post is also insulting to sisters by stating 'dhilee singhnees'. Let's please get beyond these disparaging comments. There are indeed many problems that can occur, but one should also never expect for the wife to leave all her relations once she gets married, and not go to her parents (who are also her family) when she needs help. In Punjabi culture the wife is expected to leave everything, while in SIkhi culture we have no such preconditions. Guru Ram Das Ji went to live with his wife and inlaws (Guru Arjan Dev Ji) when he got married. What it all comes down to is to respect each other and families.