Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Shaking Head During Simran

Shaking Head During Simran

Darshan Singh · 19 Jun 2003

Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa Vaheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!!! Piyario, just the other day I was listening to some kirtan and while I was doing simran my head instinctively moved from side to side. I remembered a post put up by Bhai Kulbir Singh Jee a few years back on AKJ.org about how we shouldn't shake our heads while doing simran. I tried to remember the reasoning but my memory seems to be failing me. I was hoping perhaps Bhai Sahib or other learned members of the sangat could please enlighten this lowly daas on this topic. I tried to figure out what causes me to shake my head while doing simran and the only reason I could come up with for myself is the fact that I listen to a lot of "hip-hop" music and I bob my head to it. Perhaps this is carrying over to when I do simran while listening to kirtan. If some light could be shed on this topic it would be greatly appreciated. Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa Vaheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!!! Daas, Darshan Singh

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

..... · 19 Jun 2003

isnt' shaking your head like saying NO NO NO to vaheguru ji, i think it is okay if you nod though, becausing then yoru head is goin up and down and its like you are saying yes yes yes... i can be wrong on this too and i would apreciate it if someone with knowledge can answwer this question and also fix me if i have said anything wrong. [%sig%]

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

Singh · 19 Jun 2003

I remember that post that Bhai Kulbir Singh Jee wrote on this topic. I think it was called "swinging heads". He basically said that swinging the head from side to side was not the way the Panj Pyaras taught us. Anyone who has had Naam Drirh knows that the movement during Naam Simran as taught by the Panj Pyaras is not from side to side. [%sig%]

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

Original Giani (OG) · 19 Jun 2003

that is correct!!!...

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

r2d2 · 19 Jun 2003

What difference does it make? I never listen to any music at all and I still "move" during simran sometimes. It's not intentional and honestly trying to STOP moving takes my attention away from Simran! Perhaps I'm doing something wrong, perhaps not. I leave it to Waheguru to correct me. Why should it matter what a person moves during Simran? I'm not meaning it to be disrespectful of Guru Jee or Gurumantar.

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

A · 19 Jun 2003

I think also, we bob our heads cuz we are getting raas from the tunes and therefore loosing out raas from the gurmantar..... we should be trying to focus all our efforts and energy into spiritual form rather than losing it by movement..... i dont think its a big deal though, but just be concious of the fact that u meant to be getting raas from the bani and gurmantar rather than the musical tunes its done too....

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

Indy · 20 Jun 2003

There is one thing shaking ones head and another when the whole body starts moving and the individual in question begins to seem out of control. Does not seem appropriate in front of Guru Granth Sahib Maharaaj. This practice is particularly endemic amongst the youth.

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

jagjit singh · 20 Jun 2003

waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, I have seen alot of people particularly youth shake their heads, some extremely violently. This practice always seemed strange to me. Sometimes a person is in GurRass, and does not know what they are doing. But I do think many of these Gursikhs do know what they are doing. If you violently shake your head, your brain knocks against your skull, a similar practice to headbanging, an extreme form of dance by neo-Nazis. This creates a dulling sensation in the mind. I do feel to many Gursikhs do this and think this sensation is some kirpa from bani, when it fact it is not. It is extremely dangerous practice and will probably lead to memory loss. Bhai sahib Rama Singh Ji, and bhai sahib Jarnail Singh Ji, I have seen both often go to youth particularly and tell them not to do this. They always state that simran should be done in one "Livv" with the sangat. All the sangat should be doing simran together, and it should be able to be heard clearly. Your mind concentrates on the Gurmantar that you are repeating. Personally, I have found if you fold your hands while doing abyass, it also helps. I do not know why, maybe you are in a posture of mercy, or of begging, but it feels far better than folding arms, or arms at the side. Essentially abyass is about practice, the more one does, the more blessings one recieves. waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

Original Giani (OG) · 20 Jun 2003

There is a technique of doing simran. That technique is taught by the five beloved ones only. Now the technique does involve moving your head up and down... only one shall know the technique that has taken Amrit and has been taught the “Gur Mantar Jap” by the five beloved ones… So please, grace yourselves and learn the proper technique of “Gur Mantar” this up coming Amirt Sinchar… "Anyone who has had Naam Drirh knows that the movement during Naam Simran as taught by the Panj Pyaras is not from side to side."(Singh)

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

Mkhalsa · 20 Jun 2003

I have seen many gur pyare that get so much into naam that they are shaking.. soon this shaking just becomes a vibration.. but i have seen such things as headbanging (shaking and if they are sitting next to a wall their head hits) or other things, and I am sure that they do not know what they are doing. I think it happens out of so much raas that they cant control the power or energy and they just begin to shake as they do not have the control to just hold it all in. I personally do not think it is wrong, because if you watch someone who has been doing simran for years that shaking eventually just becomes a vibration, and in many the shaking stops all together eventually.

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

Kulbir Singh · 20 Jun 2003

Veer Jagjit Singh and Veer OG has already covered most of the points against swinging your head left and right during dhuni i.e. saying Vaheguru Vaheguru. I did write something couple of years ago on akj.org but I don’t have it saved anywhere. In the nutshell, what I had written was that when doing dhuni, it is not right to swing your head left to right as the shabad or naam does not travel that way. Those who have had naam drir from Punj Pyaare know very well that doing naam left and right only hinders concentration. I just want to add one more thing. Vaheguru does only that much kirpa as much we can sustain. If Vaheguru senses that a Sikh starts vibrating or shaking his head with attainment of just very little concentration (let alone having a spiritual aatmik experience), then that gursikh does not get more kirpa. If a Sikh keeps all the kirpa inside and does not express outside or tries not to do so, then that gursikh, gets more and more kirpa because Vaheguru senses that this gursikh is capable of handling more kirpa. This is why, Gursikhs who get some aatmik experience try to keep it inside but again baani says that they cannot hide it. How do you hide something when it appears on your forehead and the whole world can see it? So Guru Pyaariyo, let us try to keep shabad rass inside. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

Balpreet Singh · 20 Jun 2003

I think the following passage from puraatan Narangvaal Smaagams article previously posted on this site is good guidance about how puraatan Singhs handled this: "A lot of Naam loving brothers and sisters arrived at the Narangvaal Smaagam. No flashy clothes or individuals with unfocussed consciousness were seen. No Nigureys or atheists were around…what work did they have here? But despite this, the meditation on Gurmantar was not done openly. In fact, if some soul was totally struck by the nectar and the Naam Khanda began to go, it would continue to enjoy that condition for the entire night and the keertan would continue in its own place. Some serious individuals would lovingly try to stop them and would say "keep it secret. Meditate within your heart".

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

m · 24 Jun 2003

WJKKWJKF Moving head may help in the beginning, later on one feels he is wasting energy/strength gained, through strong physical movements. May be, better it is, if the mind & surat is getting envolved all the time. Things should be "written" on the heart itself. Why waste it physically/outwardly. If some says it is created out of RAS gained in Simran, may be he is right. M Singh

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

Original Giani (OG) · 24 Jun 2003

"it is not right to swing your head left to right as the shabad or naam does not travel that way." (KBS) As KBS Verji stated above should clear up any doubts you may have in which direction your head should flow. Also I stated in my recent reply, that there is a technique of doing simran. That technique is taught by the five beloved ones only. Now the technique does involve moving your head up and down... only one shall know the technique that has taken Amrit and has been taught the “Gur Mantar Jap” by the five beloved ones…

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

r2d2 · 24 Jun 2003

but sometimes when you even look at many famous kirtanees (admin cut) they all in some way move their head when they're doing simran too during when they're doing kirtan.. is that wrong also?

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

Kulbir Singh · 24 Jun 2003

I think the conclusion of this thread lies in the post of Balpreet Singh. He has hit the nail right on the head by quoting from Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee's times. Ones who don't try to keep the anand inside but express it by swinging heads left to right, should try to keep the anand inside. Here is what he quoted: >>>>>> A lot of Naam loving brothers and sisters arrived at the Narangvaal Smaagam. No flashy clothes or individuals with unfocussed consciousness were seen. No Nigureys or atheists were around…what work did they have here? But despite this, the meditation on Gurmantar was not done openly. In fact, if some soul was totally struck by the nectar and the Naam Khanda began to go, it would continue to enjoy that condition for the entire night and the keertan would continue in its own place. Some serious individuals would lovingly try to stop them and would say "keep it secret. Meditate within your heart >>>>>>>>>>> I thinking swinging head left to right while doing simran does not make any sense. At least the singhs of akj who have been taught naam by punj pyaare know that swinging head left to right is a violation of the Gurmat Vidhi (technique) of Naam Abhyaas. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

NaamBiyaasi · 26 Jun 2003

Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh Many people have different breathing techniques, focus on different things during meditation, experience different visions, experience different smells....the experiences during meditation can be vast. With regards to head movements, body movements, be very careful. If God brings something outside of you from within, and wishes to express it, let Akaal do His Play. But if you have an intention inside, be cautious of it. Any thing, whether it be a mystical experience, body shaking, and even the smell of such things as parshaad and roses during meditation, be wareful of. Things can give you more focus On Naam, or they can take you away from it. The focus upon the meditation for a Sikh is Naam. Naam cannot be described, so I will not foolish try to. Each will experience it as Akaal shows them. Whatever technique you may use in meditation, use it to focus on Naam, Alone, versus the experience and the enjoyment of the experience. If the enjoyment of the experience during meditation, is upon the experience itself, be weary. If it is done whole-heartedly, and not rooted in any desires, may we be so Blessed. Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

Navjot Singh · 26 Jun 2003

Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji stated: >>swinging head left to right is a violation of the Gurmat Vidhi (technique) of Naam Abhyaas. I am sorry but I had to jump into this one, I think this is definitely crossing the line. Can Bhai Sahib reference or elaborate on how this is a violation of Gurmat Vidhi ? Just by saying that the Panch Piyaaray Dhrrir the Naam in only one manner during Amrit-Sanchaar does not prove anything. Every other person I run into has their own philosophy and and rule-set on Gurmat, that is fine, as long as those rules are for themselves, and not forced on others or generalized for the entire Panth. Let us all try to keep an open mind through these discussions. We sometimes have a tendancy to box ourselves in with our own rules and guidelines, without considering their practical and Panthic implications. Regarding Simran : I think terms such as "vigorous headbanging" or "headshaking" are definately an exaggeration. We can all agree that casual movement of the head is common during Amrit-Vela Naam-Abhyaas, but it is usually a mixture of vertical and horizontal head movements or sometimes no head movements except at the naval/abdomen area. Some Singh once told me that the Toronto Singhs consider the horizontal movement of the head borrowed from Hinduism. This is rediculous. According to many of the Singhs who have spent a good part of their lives with Bhai Randhir Singh Ji, and others who attended the samgams of those times, Naam-Abhyaaas even in those days was done by many in small movement of the head up and down and OR sideways (maybe not vigorous swinging) but more importantly, no one was criticized for the way their head moved. Our concentration should be on the Dhun of the Shabd, not what others are doing. I doubt if there is an "official" or correct way to do Simran, as long as one does is with Prem and one's concentration is on the Dhun. "Dhun(i) meh Dhian(u), Dhian meh Jaania Gurmukh Akath Kahaanee" If we are to only do Simran in the technique way the Panj Piyaaray show us, then we would be stuck sitting in a Veer-Aasan position with our backs tilted forward, necks scooping down. That doesn't seem too comfortable of a position. It also means we could not do Simran in any way except "Pasantee" (Suaasaa naal) since that is the only way converyed to us via the Panch. We know that's not true because Bhai Mani Singh Ji in "Gian Ratnaavali" says : "Baabay Kahaiaa Chaar Baaneea hun. Pehlay Paraa, Doojee Pasantee, Teejee Madham, Chauthee Baikhare. Par soeey Banee Visaikh hai jo Yuk Dil hoe kay Kartar noo(n) Yaad Kardee Hai" (Gian Ratanavali, Pauree 36) Bhai Mani Singh Ji's own words conclude, whether it is via Para, Pasantee, Madhama or Viakhari, the best method is the one via Guru-Kartar can be remembered in "Yuk Dil". Bhul Chuk Maar Karnee Ji - Daas, Navjot Singh

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

Balpreet Singh · 26 Jun 2003

I think instinctively, if one is doing the Gurmat Vidhee of naam abhyaas correctly, the head moves a certain way. Naam abhyaas is supposed to hit the dasam duaar and then churn within as well. I don't see how this would be possible if one is swinging the head horizontally. As for the bata and beer-asan example, I think that the new Singh/Kaur is in that position to receive amrit dee daat. They are leaning forward not because it's a special position, but so that they can have amrit put into their hands, face and kes. In other words, the body position is incidental and taken up only to receive amrit. When the head is moved by the punj pyaaray, it's not an incidental movement. They tell the new Singh/Kaur that they are about to impart naam and the moving of the head is THEN done. I'm not sure if my point is clear, but moving of the head is not incidental...it is part of the instructions and begins only when naam is taught. Sitting in a forward lean and other body positions condusive to receiving amrit are NOT part of the instructions when punj pyaaray give gurmat naam abhyaas vidhee: the person just happens to be in that position when naam is taught. But as I said before, movement of the head is intuitive if the vidhee is known, so I dont' see it being much of an issue.

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

Kulbir Singh · 26 Jun 2003

Veer Navjot Singh jeeo, I will attempt to answer your questions to the best of my ability. Let us keep our minds open. My personal aim in debating this is only to learn and to do parchaar of Gurmat. I will definitely agree to you if I get convinced. I will not keep my mind blocked. Guru Sahib kirpa karan. > Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji stated: > > >>swinging head left to right is a violation of the Gurmat > Vidhi (technique) of Naam Abhyaas. > > I am sorry but I had to jump into this one, I think this is > definitely crossing the line. Can Bhai Sahib reference or > elaborate on how this is a violation of Gurmat Vidhi ? Just by > saying that the Panch Piyaaray Dhrrir the Naam in only one > manner during Amrit-Sanchaar does not prove anything. Why does it not prove anything? We all know that Naam is the jurisdiction of Guru Sahib/Punj Pyaare. They not only give naam but also teach how to japp naam. If a Sikh who obtains Naam from Guru Sahib and learns the technique from there but does not use that technique, then is that Sikh not committing a violation of Gurmat? It is not appropriate to go into details of Naam Abhyaas technique but one thing is for sure that the ones who get naam dee vidhi from punj pyaare should stick to it. If one is to develop his own way of doing naam then what is the point of taking naam from Punj and learning naam from Punj? > Every other person I run into has their own philosophy and > and rule-set on Gurmat, that is fine, as long as those rules > are for themselves, and not forced on others or generalized for > the entire Panth. The first statement is confusing. How can one’s own rule-set be Gurmat? If something is Gurmat then it is applicable on the whole panth and if it is not Gurmat, then it is not applicable. There is no such thing as ones own Gurmat. > Let us all try to keep an open mind through these > discussions. We sometimes have a tendancy to box ourselves in > with our own rules and guidelines, without considering their > practical and Panthic implications. I agree with you totally. May Guru Sahib do kirpa on us and may we have an open mind. > Regarding Simran : I think terms such as "vigorous > headbanging" or "headshaking" are definately an exaggeration. > We can all agree that casual movement of the head is common > during Amrit-Vela Naam-Abhyaas, but it is usually a mixture of > vertical and horizontal head movements or sometimes no head > movements except at the naval/abdomen area. Some Singh once > told me that the Toronto Singhs consider the horizontal > movement of the head borrowed from Hinduism. This is > rediculous. I don’t know where the horizontol movement of head came from and I am not sure that I ever said that it was borrowed from the Hindus. My memory is weak and if I said something like this, please remind me. > According to many of the Singhs who have spent a good part of > their lives with Bhai Randhir Singh Ji, and others who attended > the samgams of those times, Naam-Abhyaaas even in those days > was done by many in small movement of the head up and down and > OR sideways (maybe not vigorous swinging) but more importantly, > no one was criticized for the way their head moved. Reading Bhai Sahib’s books on Naam Abhyaas, it is clear that the shabad travels “Ardh-urdh” i.e. up down from Navel to Dasam Duaar. According to Bhai Sahib’s book, the shabad travels from Navel to Dasam Duaar and then down to Navel. If the Gurmanter is being japp with pooran GurmatVidhi, then definitely the bodily movement will be consistent with the inner movement of the shabad. The swinging of the shabad horizontol is not consistent with the inner movement of the shabad. So this is the wrong way. Mere veer jeeo, this daas has pointed this out not out of hurting someone's feelings but the aim is to propogate the correct principle of Gurmat. Please don't misunderstand my motive. Our > concentration should be on the Dhun of the Shabd, not what > others are doing. I doubt if there is an "official" or correct > way to do Simran, as long as one does is with Prem and one's > concentration is on the Dhun. "Dhun(i) meh Dhian(u), Dhian > meh Jaania Gurmukh Akath Kahaanee" Who says that Naam is only listening to the dhun (sound)? Bhai Sahib in his book “Gumat Naam Abhyaas Kamaaayee” very clearly writes where “Vaahe” starts and ends and where “Gurrrrrrrrrrrooo” starts and ends. Without regard for this important fact, a lot of rass is lost and Bhai Sahib mentions this too in that book. Yes, I agree that listening to the dhun coming out of Naam, irrespective of whether this dhun is Baikhari, Madham, Para or Pasanti, is a must. The dhun must be audible to the seekr. If the seeker does not stay in the dhun, then everything is a waste. If a seeker is able to listen, then it does not take too long to get spiritual experiences. > If we are to only do Simran in the technique way the Panj > Piyaaray show us, then we would be stuck sitting in a > Veer-Aasan position with our backs tilted forward, necks > scooping down. That doesn't seem too comfortable of a position. Bhai Sahib jeeo, punj never tell you that you can do simran only in Bir-Aasan. I should mention that simran in this aasan is most beneficial and puraatan Singhs used to stay in Bir Aasan for hours. Punj Pyaare clearly state in their updesh that Naam Gurmanter is to be recited all the time sleeping, eating, walking, running, working etc. > It also means we could not do Simran in any way except > "Pasantee" (Suaasaa naal) since that is the only way converyed > to us via the Panch. Bhai Sahib jeeo, how did you derive the meaning of Swaas Swaas simran to be “Pasantee” alone. Swaas Swaas simran can be done in Baikhareee form, Madham form, Paraa form and Pasanti form. Of course the seeker begins with doing abhyaas in Baikhari form. As the seeker of Naam progresses in his spiritual path, he is able to do simran in Madham, Paraa and Pasanti form. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee writes about this in his books. > We know that's not true because Bhai Mani Singh Ji in "Gian > Ratnaavali" says : > > "Baabay Kahaiaa Chaar Baaneea hun. Pehlay Paraa, Doojee > Pasantee, Teejee Madham, Chauthee Baikhare. Par soeey Banee > Visaikh hai jo Yuk Dil hoe kay Kartar noo(n) Yaad Kardee Hai" > (Gian Ratanavali, Pauree 36) > > Bhai Mani Singh Ji's own words conclude, whether it is via > Para, Pasantee, Madhama or Viakhari, the best method is the one > via Guru-Kartar can be remembered in "Yuk Dil". Veer pyaare jeeo, as I mentioned before, whether one chooses to do Baikhree, Madham, Paraa or Pasanti, still one MUST STICK TO THE GURMAT VIDHEE. Doing abhyaas in these forms or baanis, does not mean doing simran in more than one way. The Gurmat vidhi still stays the same. In case of Para, the Singhs lock the pawan in their naabhi and still continue abhyaas in Gurmat Vidhee. The vidhee does not change. The shabad still travels in vertical fashion. Veer jeeo, I know this is a sensitive issue and if you can believe me, then believe me that I was not interested in getting into this issue. I am not sure who started this thread and I did not respond to it first and when I did, I was not into it. I know this much. When Guru Sahib wills, one follows Gurmat and does naam abhyaas. Aseen vichaare kee haan. Sabh kuchh Sache Paatshaah de hath hai. Bhul chukk dee maafi bakshani. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

Kulbir Singh · 26 Jun 2003

> "Baabay Kahaiaa Chaar Baaneea hun. Pehlay Paraa, Doojee > Pasantee, Teejee Madham, Chauthee Baikhare. Par soeey Banee > Visaikh hai jo Yuk Dil hoe kay Kartar noo(n) Yaad Kardee Hai" > (Gian Ratanavali, Pauree 36) > > Bhai Mani Singh Ji's own words conclude, whether it is via > Para, Pasantee, Madhama or Viakhari, the best method is the one > via Guru-Kartar can be remembered in "Yuk Dil". Veer Navjot Singh jeeo, I wanted to comment on your translation of this passage of Bhai Mani Singh jee shaheed. Bhai Sahib is not mentioning 4 methods namely Baikhari, Madhama, Pasanti and Para. These are not four methods but are four kinds of baanees. There is only one method or techineque of naam jaap but this method can be executed in Baikhari, Madham, Pasanti or Para baanee. Guru Baba jee is clearly saying that, that baanee (not referred to Gurbani but it means something like a form of sound) is best through which one is able to do bhajan with "yak dil" i.e. with full concentration. We clearly know that amritvela is the time for Baikharee baanee abhyaas only. Even the top most Singhs start with Baikharee baani abhyaas. Then slowly, if the need be, they can go to Madham, Pasanti or Paraa. But in no way, this changes the Gurmat vidhee. The Gurmat vidhee stays the same in all four baanees. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

conspiracy theory · 26 Jun 2003

Could somebody please explain "Baikhari," "Madhama," "Pasanti," "para," "vidhee," "naabhee" PLEASE KEEP IN MIND YOU ARE TRYING TO TEACH SIKHI TO CANADIANS HERE - SOME OF THEM NEED HELP WITH THE GURMUKHI !!!! Be like baba nanak and teach Sikhi in the language of the Guru, *AND* the language of the land VAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA VAHEGURU JI KI FATEH

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

(^_^) · 27 Jun 2003

Well said CT.

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

Navjot Singh · 27 Jun 2003

Bhai Kublir Singh Jeeo... The point of my previous post was not to start another discussion on the methods, techniques, or bannees, but just indicate that we need to be careful in labeling anything that doesn't seem right to us as a violation of Gurmat or Gurmat-Vidhi. I just proivided the quote (not translation) of Bhai Mani Singh Ji's verse to merely point out that even Bhai Mani Singh Ji states it is not the method, technique, banee form, or stage of simran (as some call it), that is important but the remembrance of Kartar. Since I am not a Naam abhyaaasee, myself, I really don’t have the knowledge or experience to really discuss any of this. >The first statement is confusing. How can one’s own rule-set be Gurmat? > If something is Gurmat then it is applicable on the whole panth and if it is >not Gurmat, then it is not applicable. There is no such thing as ones own >Gurmat. Bhai Sahib Ji, there are many example of such rules : - wearing of Pajamis by Singhs (in some Jathas one can not do tabya di seva with a Pajami, but at Sri Darbar Sahib it is the opposite) - wearing of a Farra/Farlla in Dummalla (in Many Nihang Dals, only Singhs that have earned a Farlla can perform Panj Piaray do seva, on other Jatha there is not such restriction). These Jatheybandies enfore such rules on thier members, but can not do the same to the rest of the Panth. Again, we must consider their practical and Panthic implications. - Navjot Singh

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

Kulbir Singh · 27 Jun 2003

> The point of my previous post was not to start another > discussion on the methods, techniques, or bannees, but just > indicate that we need to be careful in labeling anything that > doesn't seem right to us as a violation of Gurmat or > Gurmat-Vidhi. Let me clear my stand on this. I am one hundred sure that no matter how you do naam, it will have some benefit for sure. Even doing japp of Raam Raam or Kishen Kishen. All I was saying is that akj that has the gurmat vidhi should do it with gurmat vidhi. That is all. If I said something wrong, I am sorry for that. > > I just proivided the quote (not translation) of Bhai Mani > Singh Ji's verse to merely point out that even Bhai Mani Singh > Ji states it is not the method, technique, banee form, or stage > of simran (as some call it), that is important but the > remembrance of Kartar. I really don't think this is what Bhai Sahib means here. He does mean that no matter what baani you use but he is not saying that no matter what "method" you use. There is only one Gurmat Vidhi. There cannot be two truths. Truth can only be one. Rememberance of God is possible only through Gurmat vidhi. All other methods are incomplete. Only Gurmat is full truth. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

me · 28 Jun 2003

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh! I THINK PEOPLE JUST SHAKE THEIR HEAD TO STAY AWAKE! Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh!

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

question · 28 Jun 2003

Waheguroo Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguroo Ji Ki Fateh! Author: conspiracy theory Could somebody please explain "Baikhari," "Madhama," "Pasanti," "para," "vidhee," "naabhee" Why was this question ignored? I would like to know too and I am sure others would too! Thank You Waheguroo Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguroo Ji Ki Fateh!

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

warrior*princess · 02 Jul 2003

Don't waste time worrying about who shakes their head etc.. Close YOUR eyes and concentrate on Naam....once Guru jee guides, you have NO control over your body whatsoever! Ho Thihn Kai Balharnai Jinaa Naamai Lagaa Pyaar || I am a sacrifice to those who are in love with the Naam. (Guru Amar Das ji) (ps. Bhai Rama Singh jee and Bhai Jarnail Singh jee only stopped those members of the sangat that werent in the same rhythm of saas graasss/ naam simran as the others) Vaheguroooooo *infinity!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

KHALSA · 26 Jul 2003

ITS AMAZING HOW PEOPLE WANT ANSWERS FOR EVEYTHING AND TO KNOW WHATS CORRECT AND NOT. SWING OF SIDE TO SIDE:? ISNT THAT AN INDIVDUAL EFFEECT OF WHAT THE PERSONS EXPERIANCING OR FEELING? ''RAAGS'' NOW THEN, WHEN PEOPLE SING ''RAAG'' THEIR HEADS DO NOT ONLY MOVE FROM SIDE TO SIDE BUT: UP AND DOWN, BACK AND FOURTH, ALL SORTS.

Re: Shaking Head During Simran

l · 31 Jul 2003

waheguru