Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sants

Sants

NaamBiyaasi · 03 Apr 2003

Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh SatNaam Sahai Do Sants exist in this day and age? Or did they stop after the time Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji was delivered? Please give your opinion, and any verses from Gurbani that may have assisted in the formation of these thoughts. Thankyou Dhan Guru Nanak Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Sants

Kulbir Singh · 04 Apr 2003

> SatNaam Sahai > What is "Satnaam Sahai". I have never heard of this slogan in any history book. Traditionally we the Sikhs have been writing "Akal Sahai" and we should stick to it. > Do Sants exist in this day and age? Or did they stop after > the time Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji was delivered? Please give > your opinion, and any verses from Gurbani that may have > assisted in the formation of these thoughts. Of course sants or gurmukhs exist to this day. The whole vadiyaayee of the house of Guru Nanak is that it will produce sants or gurmukhs in every age. These gursikhs are the players of the highest states of gurmat spirituality but they do not start their own thing. They stay part of the Khalsa Panth and always stay gursikhs and do not try to become a Guru or anything else like this. If there were no sants and gurmukhs in this world today, this world would come to an end. This whole world is standing or existing today because of the naam kamaayee of these gurmukhs. The earth and the universe exists with the energy produced from the naam kamaayee of the gursikhs. For this reason it is obligatory for Guru Sahib to always have gursikhs of chardi kala in the Panth Khalsa. Those who say that there are no sants or gursikhs today should read the great book of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee - Sant Pad Nirnai. In that book Bhai Sahib clearly states that the Gurmukh Sants always exist in the panth and these Gurmukh Sants don't call themselves sants or Gurus but stay as humble gursikhs. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Sants

Singhnee · 04 Apr 2003

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!! Please read a book named "Sant padd nirNNay" by Bhai sahib bhai Randhir Singh Jee. He has made it clear in his book that for whom "sant" word is used in Gurbani. In Gurbani sant and saadh words are used for Guru Sahib jee and for Gurusikhs. For Guru Sahib: " Satgur sant milai shant paayeeai kilvikh dukh katay sabh door ll" (ang 744) "Amrit bachan saadh kee bani" (ang 1198) "Sant kirpa te mitay moh bharamll" (ang 183) for Gursikh: "Ham santan kee ren pyaaray ham santan kee sharnaa" (ang 614) "Aavho sant pyaareho akath kee krenh khaaNNi" (ang 918) "Har ke sant sunho jass kaani" (ang 667) These are few examples Gurbani is full of this kind of panktees. Bhai Sahib jee gave 39 examples at the end of his book "sant padd nirNNe" where sant and saadh pad is used for Guru Sahib jee. So sabh tou vadda sant is Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee and then Gursikhs of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee are sant. There can't be any other sant. Those are pakhandi sants who let people mathaa tek and give them naam. Naam's daata is only and only Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee through panj pyaaray NO ONE ELSE. And there's only ONE NAAM that is able to take one to sachkhand. "Teraa ek naam taaray sansar" THAT GURMAT NAME IS ONLY AT GURU NANAK'S GHAR(HOME) "Nanak kai ghar keval naam" So Gurbani clears it for all of us that no one else has naam thing it's only Guru Nanak's property through panj pyaaray. I heard a saakhi about pakhandi sant who was born as a sapp(snake) in his next jooni and his chellay were keeRRay who were eating his body. Someone can tell this story in detail I don't remeber it more than that. Bhul chuk muaaf jee. Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!!

Re: Sants

Kulbir Singh · 05 Apr 2003

Vaheguru jee ka Khalsa Vaheguru jee kee fateh!! > Kulbir Veerai, > > You sound like a very arrogant individual. Please talk with > respect when responding to others in this sangat. It would be > appreciated. You cannot talk about Sikhism with an Ego. I hope > you take this advice. Sat bachan veer jeeo. I will try my best to shed my ego. Please do kirpa on me, so that I may obey your hukam of not expressing ego, when talking about Sikhi. If you have felt ego in my postings, then there is a good chance that I did have ego when writing them. Without non-stop kamaayee of Naam and Gurbani, it is impossible to get rid of ego. Only with the kirpa of Guru Sahib and benevolent veers like you, can a person realize his or her faults. Thank you again for pointing out my weakness. I should however mention that I did not intend to write arrogantly and nor did I mean to hurt your feelings. I do get some bir rass when I see material deviations from Gurmat. > > When I say Fateh or SatNaam Sahai I am addressing Our Beloved > Before talking further. I am not addressing yourself, or > others. Just Our Beloved. Further, to start off answering the > question I have posted with: > You see, Bhai Gurbaksh Singh (Banda Bahadur) started the slogan of "Fateh Darshan" and to this date many Sikhs criticize him for this. We have to be very carefull when making such new additions. When we have been blessed with fateh and other manglacharans like Ik Oankaar Sat Gurprasaad or Akaal Sahai, then what is the need to make up a new one? This could result in a division of panth. > >>>What is "Satnaam Sahai". I have never heard of this slogan > in any history book. Traditionally we the Sikhs have been > writing "Akal Sahai" and we should stick to it. <<< > > What does my way of Addressing Our Beloved have to do with > your definition of what a Sikh is to say to his Master? I > suggest you Read Gurbani a bit further to see the source of the > "slogan" you refer to a SatNaam Sahai. If you wish to find > sources in History Books that is Your parogative. But the past > according to SatGur Kabir, does not exist, only the present. It is pretty shocking to see you suggesting that Bhagat Kabir jee was a Satguru. The all knowing Guru Arjun Dev jee himself has written "Bhagat" before his name and not "mahalla". We should not try to become greater than Guru Sahib and we should never ever call anyone other than the ten Gurus, Satguru. Satguru are only the 10 Gurus and no one else. > Every Sikh will practise Sikhism differently, as we have > different lessons to learn. If someone wishes to start off a > sect with the disguise of Bana, or Non Bana, that again is > there parogative. Which ever company you keep, your focus > should be God Oriented. I humbly beg to differ. There is only one way by which a Sikh can practice Sikhi and that way is the way of Guru Sahib. Sikhi is one, Guru is one, Naam is one, baani is one and his way is one. Whether you follow a living Guru, > Gursikhs, Sants, you have to realise you still have to face the > 5, and overcome them. I again suggest that your assertion that one can follow a living Guru is fine, is totally wrong. Today only Guru Granth Sahib jee and his Panth Khalsa is Guru. No living person can be a Guru. I am sure the Sikhs today are pretty sure about this. Here the books written by Bhai Randhir > Singh are revered. Others that kept company with him, also > have their writing often time revered. Is that not exactly > what you are preaching we not do according to your dialogue? > Follow a Guru? > No sir! We do not follow Bhai Randhir Singh jee's Sikhi. Bhai Sahib himself is a follower of Guru Nanak and we all follow Guru Nanak's Sikhi just as Bhai Sahib did. Bhai Sahib was one of the greatest Sikhs and as such deserves all the respect a Gursikh should get. We do learn a lot from his books as these books are written by a Sikh of high spiritual state. > > Agreed. But this Panth transcends religious barriers, hate, > eliticism, sexism, and Ego. Within the hirda of one Guru > Piyaarai, resides the strength of the faug and the Khalsa > Panth. I am pretty convinced that you belong to a sect that follows a sant or a living Guru. I don't think a Khalsa can agree with you. > Singhnee Bhenji, > Thankyou for the quotes for GurBani. The Lone Sant gives > Naam. It is SatNaam's Property. No way can a sant give naam. Only punj pyaare can give naam and only such naam can get us somewhere. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Sants

Khalsa · 05 Apr 2003

Vaheguru jee ka khalsa vaaheguru jee kee fateh! >>>We should not try to become greater than Guru Sahib and we should never ever call anyone other than the ten Gurus, Satguru. Satguru are only the 10 Gurus and no one else. <<< Veer Kulbir Singh Ji I think you forgot to mention Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee. So Satguru is only 11 gurus and nobody else. :)

Re: Sants

Kulbir Singh · 05 Apr 2003

My apologies to Veer Khalsa. I forgot to mention Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. Thanks for being vigilant. I referred to 10 Guru Sahibaan in the context that no other human form can be Guru but our 10 Guru Sahibaan. Of course on the Gurgaddi now is Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Sants

Kaur · 06 Apr 2003

i see that there is a dispute over some words, but i can't seem to locate them.. WHo wrote the following to Kulbir Singh Jee? I can't find it anywhere. "> Kulbir Veerai, > > You sound like a very arrogant individual. Please talk with > respect when responding to others in this sangat. It would be > appreciated. You cannot talk about Sikhism with an Ego. I hope > you take this advice. Kulbir Singh wrote a lengthy response to each of the paragraphs that the other individual wrote, but that entire post is not on this page. or is it? i can't see it. Help me out. I'm an idiot.

Re: Sants

singhindenial · 06 Apr 2003

veerji, naambiyaasi! it seems like you have issues. bhai kulbir singh jee, is a devout gursikh. He is only trying to keep the tradition for those of us who chose to follow sikhi (this way) as you put it. He has every right to defend sikhi. I would suggest you refrain from being arrogant yourself. what have you offered? vahegurujeekhalsavaehegurujeekeefateh!

Re: Sants

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 12 May 2006

I agree 110% with Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji. No one can find even one "Sant" (titled..not gupt) in the 250 years of Guru Kaal..and even after that to 20th Century....ALL without exception were called BHAI..and some very exceptional ones were called BABA..but no SANT. Gurbani says Bhag Hoa GUR-SANT milaya....and Sri Guru Granth Ji is the Gur-SANT. None other can take precedence as Intermediary between Sikh and His Guru. Many so called great SANTS have stories about them as they...had snakes doing chaan over them ( same as Guru nanak ji) or lions and tigers guarding them....etc etc. This is all utter bakwaas and has no Basis in GURBANI. This is just PR exercise to blow up these sants as bigger than big !! in actual fact they were good for nothing whellahrrs who didnt marry, had no job, did no Waand Chhaknna as per Gurbani, no kirt etc etc - did everything AGAINST GURBANI and Gurmatt. There are many such pakhandees in Punjab today who are claiming to be Partakh Guru nanak ji, Guru Gobind Singh Ji, who have caught AK47 bullets in their Beards ( of all things !!)..and their Chelas are writing simialr books about their "greatness"... The indisputable fact is that EACH SANT DERA has their OWN MARYADA..so NONE is TRUE....as being "brahmgianis" they should realise which is TRUE Maryada ?? They hold the VOTE and the politicians love them for that...always we read of one or the other great sant jumping from badal to captain or vice versa.. The "great souls" who really matter are doing huge naam kamaai in GUPT...no titles, no deras, no followers doing dhol dhammakka..world stand on them...and their dharam....those living in paalatial deras, driving around in luxury vehicles going on overseas parchaars to rich countries ( ever heard of anyone going to Indonesia where the rupiah is so low a MILLION people must matha tek to just get Rupees 8,000 !!!)..much prefer Canada or UK where just ONE Pound will get 70 rupees..are just MAYADHAREES. these cults of santnaam gurparsaad and like sounding ones are altogether different..they are spreading gurudom straight from day one..The FATEH of GURU GOBIND SINGH stings them like POISON....becausue that is the fateh of the KHALSA PANTH. Various Organsiations in Punjab are waking up...the Khalsa Panth is waking up from deep slumber....these sants and guurus will soon disappear..taking with them their GHONA MONA "amrtidharees by the lakhs"

Re: Sants

lol · 12 May 2006

Many so called great SANTS have stories about them as they...had snakes doing chaan over them ( same as Guru nanak ji) or lions and tigers guarding them....etc etc. This is all utter bakwaas ^^ which sants, name a few. This is all utter bakwaas and has no Basis in GURBANI. This is just PR exercise to blow up these sants as bigger than big !! in actual fact they were good for nothing whellahrrs who didnt marry, had no job, did no Waand Chhaknna as per Gurbani, no kirt etc etc - did everything AGAINST GURBANI and Gurmatt. ^^ again, name a few. i want to know which sants from the past you are talking about. Lets not get into the stories u were spreading about your father joining the shaheed fauj, then again i believe you but how can u believe that? I thought it was all about the guptness *chuckles*.

Re: Sants

Bhudysut · 18 May 2006

Vahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vahiguru Ji Ki Fateh Dear Veer Ji's & Bhan Ji's Please be very vigilant when replying to this individual. I am fairly sure that this NaamBiyaasi is either Harjit Lakhan or Multani or one of Narinder Garewal's other chelay. They are asking these sorts of questions (and other questions and other related issues) to various knowledgeable Gursikhs on various forums to either a) create confusion/doubt or b) to confirm their own twisted version of Sikhi or c) use answers given on the various forums and somehow distort meanings to suit their own interests. They have done this on various other places and have often used Gurbani to defend Narinder's scandalous behaviour (e.g. used Bani to defend him when he called himself 'higher than Nanak'). I have a beanti to Sangat. Dass requests that you do not become angry at him for saying this, but only understand why I have said this. Akaal Sahai Singh

Re: Sants

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 18 May 2006

Akal Sahai Singh ji is probably 110% RIGHT. Lol ji..How come you never read that a SNAKE was seen sheltering the Great Sant...whose thread is on going on this forum...as great so and so. Ask his chelehs first...and if they say this is NOT TRUE..then i will try and get the proof. They have also Side tracked the FACT that no body..not the sgpc..not the Akal Takhat..no one ever bestowed the title of SANT/Sharomani Sant whatever on this great "sant Ji". just PR... IF however you refer him as BHAI ATTAR SINGH JI..then i recognise any Gurmatt related work he has doen..like setting up schools and such...the self imposed title of sant negates all the good work...because that is KHASMEH KARREH BRABERI...

Re: Sants

European Sikh · 18 May 2006

Bhudysut, Or it could be Pehowa wale's chelaye!

Re: Sants

Giani Ji · 19 May 2006

I know of one sant at this present day and age: Sant Maharaj Giani Sahib Jarnail Singh Arshi Ji

Re: Sants

Bundha · 19 May 2006

I think people like Kulbir Singh cannot get past the word ‘sant’. Bhai Randhir Singh Ji was a mahapurkh of the highest order, now, if you wish not to call him that then that is your choice and if Bhai Sahib Ji wished not to be called this, again that is his wish but his spirituality cannot be questioned. Now, Bhai Randhir singh Ji brought people to sikhi and jorr’d them to the feet of Guru Nanak Dev Ji. But as soon as anyone talks about anyone else doing the same then suddenly these people cannot get past the word ‘sant’ and dismiss everything - “ no, they are deraywalley” “ no, they cannot stand Gurus Fateh” “ no, they are leading people astray” Did Bhai Randhir Singh Ji lead people astry? If he did not can there be no other Sikh who can do the same? Did Baba Nand singh Ji lead people astray? Did Sant Ishar Singh Ji lead people astray? No. And no true Sant Mahapursh will, they will lead people to Guru Nanak Dev Ji’s charan. This is where you people get a mental block – Sukhmani Sahib astpadhi 15 (I think) says “Sant ke dhoor karr ishnaan…….” This is the stage that Guru Arjun dev Ji gives his beloved saadh sants. “Arshi” can rant on as normal, nobody takes the slightest notice. As normal my post will not get through. [%sig%]

Re: Sants

Mr. Singh · 19 May 2006

how'd kulbir singh come up in this? i've seen posts of his talking about 'sant Jarnail Singh Jee' and other sants. do a search and see for yourself before jumping to conclusions about people.

Re: Sants

Singh · 19 May 2006

The difference with Bhai Randhir Singh was he lived a life like a normal Gursikh. He did not dress up in white clothes and white dastar or affix the title "Sant" to his name. He treated himself as the Dhoor of the Sangat. He did not set himself up as someone for people to come to. Infact his writings show there were occasions when Gursikhs asked him questions for example related to Bani Tukhs and although he gave an answer he would also scold them and say "Why ask me? I am not a Gyani". I have no doubt that Bhai Randhir Singh was a Gurmukh, Mahapursh, Sant, Chardi Kala Gursikh, but for someone to elevate themselves above the level of the rest of the Sangat is completely wrong. A Gurmukh sits in the Sangat knowing he is still the Dhoor of the Sangat.

Re: Sants

righton · 19 May 2006

"I have no doubt that Bhai Randhir Singh was a Gurmukh, Mahapursh, Sant, Chardi Kala Gursikh, but for someone to elevate themselves above the level of the rest of the Sangat is completely wrong. A Gurmukh sits in the Sangat knowing he is still the Dhoor of the Sangat." WAHEGURU!!!

Re: Sants

akali warrior · 19 May 2006

These type of people burn up with jealousy when they see the vadaiaee of God's true saints, because they themself are empty inside. Like the saying, kia vigrhia tera, kia hoya nksaan, baas santa di sobha dekh ke mere nikal gei praan. They burn up in their envy; Gods saints get their true glory in the hereafter, in this world the people only burn up in their jealousy by seeing the glory of the great saints. Like I said before, if you are a son of your mother, talk to my face. It easy to hide and say things when you dont have a straight response in front of you.

Re: Sants

Jarnail Singh Gyani "arshi" · 20 May 2006

bundha ji....says..no one takes notice....and then TAKES NOTICE..and even wastes his time replying....same like his "sants" who SAY one thing and do another..Khasmeh karreh baraberee swaal jawaab dovehn kareh..mudho kuntha jaiyeh.. IF you like i can quote from SANT SAROVAR...book of attar singh ji on several anti-gurmat practises..like having a SNAKE come to him to do sewa of a ..sant....trying to be copy of GURU NANAK...or "disappearing" in the Godawari for a week ( compared to guru nanak ji who went in only three days !! sant ji can last LONGER underwater ) IF NO ONE really takes no notice...there would be no ranting of the sant chelas...and trying to be sarcastic..writing FALSE NAMES about ME..or questioning my REAL NAME ??? or existence...personal attacks etc etc all hardly what a REAL SANT would teach his chelas to do....PROOF that these are FALSE SANTS !! Compare to what a REAL SANT SAYS in Sri Guru Granth JI... Guru Arjun Ji sits on a hot plate and declares TERA BHANNA MEETHA LAGGEH....Bundha ji sits at his computer and spits venom...and self declares..MY POST WONT GET POSTED..will be deleted..AANTARYAMEE CHELA of the antaryamee snats...lol. ( did you see your post???) antaryamta is a failure.

Re: Sants

anjaan · 20 Jun 2006

Guru Arjun Ji sits on a hot plate and declares TERA BHANNA MEETHA LAGGEH Veer ji, the correct dhuk i think you were looking for is: 'thera KIYA meetha laggeh' Vaheguru Ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Sants

satnam · 21 Jun 2006

If you read Bhai Bala Jees Janam Sakhi, which is approved by majority of jathebandis, says that when jeeta Randhawa asked Guru Nanak Dev jee that after you who will be the Guru, then Guru Sahib told him that in Kalyug, there will be 9 more Gurus after him, and then it will be shabad guru, Guru Granth sahib jee until end of Kalyug. He also said that he will come to this earth 74 times in form of sants and will follow Guru Granth sahib as Guru, but very few people will recognize him. So Guru Nanak Dev Jee is still present in form of Guru Granth Sahib and also in form of Sant Mahapurkh also. But very few people can recognize him. What ever Guru Nanak has said is true. I also know that very few people can digest this fact and will start doing Nindia, but i recommend everybody to read this janam sakhi first.

Re: Sants

Singh · 22 Jun 2006

Jarnail Singh Ji, You keep talking about sants bestowing the title on themselves, could you please provide concrete proof of widely accepted mahapurkh like Baba Nand Singh Ji, Baba Isher Singh Ji (Rarasahib), Baba Attar Singh Ji asking people to call themselves sants. These great Gursikhs only life mission was to bring people to Guru Ji's charan, I have met many people who are Gursikh of high calibre that have had these Mahapurkhs sangat, and have found Guru Ji's charan as a result of their Akaal Purkh ordained kirpa. You need to get off your high horse, and learn to focus on peoples positive attributes rather than constantly slandering Guru Ji's servants. Before you set your self the task of critising Gursikhs, you should first of all try and reach their great level of naam bhagti, which if you ever did, would change you so much, that we wouldn't have to hear your nindia on this or other websites again. In fact we may hear you even saying something postive about everyone instead.

Re: Sants

sanjsingh · 22 Jun 2006

This world has never been and will ever be without a living teacher that can guide people. When ur born your mother and father teach u how to walk, speak and so on. When ur in school the teachers teach u bout education at evey step in a human life u always hav to take advice, help or guidance of others. A great singer will still have an ustad who will teach them bout singing so when it comes to god we think we know eveything and any1 who try's to teach us about god we slag them of and think we know everything. that's always been humans misunderstanding. When Kabir, christ buddha. mohammed, moses was here no1 took notice of them when they left there mortal coil every1 said oh they were saint's and started to worship them after. Whoever has found god has found him while he/she is alive nobody can find god after death. Kabir Said "je nevi rab nu hasil kitha jhinde jee hasil kitha". [%sig%]

Re: Sants

satnam · 22 Jun 2006

There are three forms of God, which are always present in this world. One is called sargun and other is called Nirgun and third shabad Guru . God is present everywhere that is Nirgun, God comes in form of body that is Sargun, Guru Granth sahib jee is a shabad God. Problem is that every body talks about nirgun and bani guru, but dont like to talk about sargun. But truth is that without sargun you can find nirgun and also cannot understand Bani Guru. For example When you eat sugar, sugar is sweet. So sugar is sargun and sweetness is nirgun. Means we have to eat sugar first to find its sweetness. All the Bhagats mentioned in Guru Granth Sahib never found Nirgun without sargun . All of them had to do sangat or sargun first to attain Nirgun God. So God comes in form of a human body also, some people call him sant, other baba, some bhai and some Mahapurakh.

Re: Sants

satnam · 23 Jun 2006

Top Most Guru is Guru Granth Sahib, Only that sant is valid who tells sangat that he is a sewadar and ultimate Guru is Guru Granth Sahib and tell Sangat to Become Amrit Dhari.

Re: Sants

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 23 Jun 2006

Author: satnam Date: 06-23-06 16:30 Top Most Guru is Guru Granth Sahib, Only that sant is valid who tells sangat that he is a sewadar and ultimate Guru is Guru Granth Sahib and tell Sangat to Become Amrit Dhari. >>>>>>>>>>>>>><<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<>>>>>>>> and bottom line is..there are not many of those....OTHERWISE there wont be so many MILLIONS of MONAS, alcoholics, drug abusers among the SIKHS of PUNJAB... But there are PLENTY of Out and Out LIARS of the worst kind who continue to say they are Chhakkaing "Amrit" to MILLIONS by the DAY !!! Those "Millions" must be "disappearing" in an invisible well ??? or they are "Amrtidharees" in the Sant ji 's DREAMS....anybody with just one "good eye" can see the REALITY of these False Claims....just go to PUNJAB and COUNT the Dastardharee Amrtidharees in each village...you will find YOU have MORE FINGERS on your ONe Hand than Amrtidharees !! Sorry I am dont buy such ****-**** !! Read Santaan de Kautak....3 rd Volume out and FOURTH on the way....( Some genuine mistakes but mostly the TRUTH)

Re: Sants

fk · 24 Jun 2006

all those who slander the saints will be crushed like the poppyseeds.

Re: Sants

sanj singh · 24 Jun 2006

satnam. i know what i'm about 2 say is not gonna be liked and i'm sorry, every1 is intiteld to their own opinion and i do respect urs, but to say the only sant is valid who tells sangat the he is a sewadar and ultimate guru is Guru Granth Sahib and tells sangat to become Amrit Dhari is in my view in incorrect and quite narrow minded. Before i explain i have great respect 4 ppl who are Amrit Dhari and generally i don't like arguing over what's what cos it ant really worth it i just get on with my own simran and dhyan and let others do there's. Before the Siri Guru Granth Sahib was written how did past mystic's reach the lord were is the amrit? (inside). Guru Nanak Dev Ji rejected the Vedas as we all know he also rejected the caste system, which i don't like aswell. The point is that every mystic i have studied has said the lord is inside of man and no where outside " when tho single eye is lit the whole body shall be full of light" but man is against man and fights over buildings, land and mine is this mine is that others are different from us so were gona slag them off. The truth is the truth and sometimes the truth is not liked this is my view i'm not speaking on behalf of all radhasoami's. In reality every soul is god and god is everywhere ppl might say that but not every1 will have full belief about this statement cos until they don't see god inside there own body they won't and can't see the lord inside of every1 not just humans but animals, insects, plants and so on. Life is short i don't know how old u are but let's face it u and me aint gonna be here in 100 years time cos the life expectancy is about 70/80 nowadays (i'm not sure though, but it's all written anyway from above). I go to satsang at my local RS centre bout every 2 weeks or so (i try anyway) and i still go to the gudwara aswell cos to me it don't make a difference, where the lord's name is taught, spoken and heard is a very good place. People have this view that Baba Gurinder Singh think's his a guru, he himself has said on many occasion's that he does not think his above any1 or any holy book or past sants, he makes it very clear the real guru is shabad which is inside of every1 he is just trying to help u how 2 see and hear that shabad 4 urself and how to become ur own master of your own mind. In this day and age where my generation (i'm 25) has gone abit mad with drugs, booze, clubs and so on (although im a nobody to judge any1) baba ji in my view is tying to do his best in getting the youngsters of all this crap and teaching them about god, and that has to be a good thing and nobody can debate that. Finally i think the real guru is shabad which is inside of man and that shabad has to manifest in humans (cos that's where it is) to teach and communicate to others and then to finally manifest in other humans also after teaching them about it. In reality we are all baba's, sant's, sadhu's and saga's it's just a matter of realizing this potential and working towards it. There's a saying in India every sinner has a future and every saint has a past. I'm sorry if i offended any1 [%sig%]

Re: Sants

Satnam Singh · 24 Jun 2006

Jarnail Singh Jee, all the Sants which are sent by Guru Nanak for certain duty in this world, always tell people to become Amritdhari. People keep it or not it is upto them. So after death when Dharmraj asks that you guys were sent to sikhs home and why did not you take amrit, so these guys can not say that no body told them about Amrit. Real sants mission is to tell Kalgidhar patsha's hukam to every sikh to become Amritdhari. Sanj you come under RS sect, which is diffrent then sikhs, so you should listen to your Guru. Your Guru will take care of you. Kalgidhar patsha wants sikhs to become amritdhari. People from other religion can become Amritdhari and become Kalgidhar patshas sikh if they want, it is not forcible.

Re: Sants

Singh · 24 Jun 2006

jarnail singh, Don't quote biased anti-sant authors who make mistakes, provide solid evidence that the babai I have mentioned earlier ever asked anyone to call them sant, or if they ever did anything else except bring people to Maharajs charan. Stop bundling Mahapurkh and con artists in teh same boat, just because sangat decided to call these great Gursikh sant, and todays con artistis give themselves this title, don't confuse the 2. If you want to talk about fakes, then have the guts to use their name and provide solid evidence, stop sterotyping and generalising, you are unlikely to ever have the darshan of the greatest naam abyisee of the likes of Baba Attar Singh Ji and Baba Nand Singh Ji. Yes, you may have darshan of the greatest truth, Maharaj, but what is the point if all that comes out your mouth is swear words and venom. Grow up, you are over 50 years old, start talking and acting as such. I know 10 year olds with more manners, compassion and focus than your comments show. If you are going to slander, do it clearly, so that we know who you are talking about and can respond appropriately. You bring no revelation in your posts, we all know that there are more sants than you can shake a stick at today, that does not mean that you should bundle great mahapurkh of past times in with todays fakes, have some fear of offending Guru's servents. Now make it clear who you are talking about and provide evidence, not biased authors.

Re: Sants

Jagvinder Singh · 24 Jun 2006

In my humble opinion, the word "SANT" should only be reserved for our guru sahibaan. No one else even comes close to deserving that kind of respect.

Re: Sants

Satnam Singh · 24 Jun 2006

Jagvinder Singh jee, you should read Bhai Gurdas jee dian waaran, and also Bhai Nand Lall jee's bani, you will find out about sants and sadhus. http://www.sikhitothemax.com/Page.asp?SourceID=B&PageNo=&ShabadID=5774&Format=2 Read about this, it says Sants existed even before Guru Nanak Dev jee and Sants used to do Kirtan also. Pooran Sant Mahapurakh exist all the time on this earth, but only people who have extra ordinary good karam can find them. Pooran sants are not every where, they are one in billions, even if you see them with your eyes, if you dont have lot of punn(Good Karam), you cannot recognize them. It is only by Kirpa of Guru Granth Sahib jee, you can find them. These kind of Sants are abhaid(one) with Guru jee.

Re: Sants

KHALSA UK · 24 Jun 2006

Jarnail Singh, please show some pyaar, what u are doing is pure slander. That loser book by the loser writer - Santan De Kautak - it should not even be called a book but a germ to humanity, most people with even a little brain know how biased that book is and how stupid the comments are in there, it basically disses EVERY mahapurkh of the past - and I mean EVERY MAHAPURKH!!!!! (including a popular one on this discussion board) The writer needs a slap on his face, face made black and taken around THE WORLD on a donkey along with his CHELE who support him and read his dirty filth!!!!! His chele need whips on their backside and slaps on their face, even the wells of HELL prob do not deserve to have the writer, his book and his chele in there. Im sorry if this offends anyone but it is the truth. waheguru ji ka khalsa! waheguru ji ki fateh!

Re: Sants

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 24 Jun 2006

Author: Jagvinder Singh Date: 06-24-06 09:01 In my humble opinion, the word "SANT" should only be reserved for our guru sahibaan. No one else even comes close to deserving that kind of respect. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>><<<<<<<<<<<<<< 110% CLEAR and CORRECTLY SAID. Can anything be more "clearer" ?? I am afraid not..so "Singh Jio" take the hint. Your 10 year olds dont come close to the 5 year old BABA ZORAWAR SINGH JI....He is not called "SANT" too and He gave his LIFE for SIKHI/GURMATT. Please for ONCE..can YOU please provide the NAME of any SANT ( From your LIST...who gave His LIFE for SIKHI/GURMATT. ( Not necessary to say Jarnail Singh becasue that Shaheed is already on my list...that "name" you provide will make it to THIS Shaheed List in no time) I am sorry to be this way..but no amount of "scare mongering" about ninda and jamraaj and all is going to STOP me from Continuing to say that the Only SANT is GURU SAHIB. ( Guru Sahib being the MASTER will SAVE me from the hordes of sant chelas... and their Jamraajs !!!..I can Guarantee that) Jarnail Singh the Non-Sant beleiver for all time

Re: Sants

Satnam · 24 Jun 2006

http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=981 5TH Guru says this in sukhmani. Slandering the Saints, one becomes a wry-faced malcontent. Slandering the Saints, one croaks like a raven. Slandering the Saints, one is reincarnated as a snake. Slandering the Saints, one is reincarnated as a wiggling worm. Slandering the Saints, one burns in the fire of desire. Slandering the Saints, one tries to deceive everyone. Slandering the Saints, all one's influence vanishes. Slandering the Saints, one becomes the lowest of the low. For the slanderer of the Saint, there is no place of rest. O Nanak, if it pleases the Saint, even then, he may be saved.

Re: Sants

Satnam · 24 Jun 2006

Gyani Jarnail Singh jee, please read this story, it is approved by Tapoban admins. http://www.tapoban.org/Sant%20Juaalaa%20Singh%20jee.pdf This story might help you understanding about sants.

Re: Sants

satnam · 26 Jun 2006

Khalsa UK you gave the perfect answer.

Re: Sants

Jagvinder Singh · 26 Jun 2006

Dear Satnam ji, its nothing to do with the slandering of saints. its very simple. the word Sant should never be used on anyone, it was specially reserved for our gurus only. I think there is a modern day misconception about the word sant. its being likened to the english word "Saint". both meanings, in my opinion, which are worlds apart.I dont know about the puratan meaning of the word sant, and i wouldnt trust any gurbani translations on that word, because, i feel, even the writer has been confused about the word "sant" and "saint". its the herd mentality we are born n brought up with. Even i used to be like, woah, sant this and sant that.Personally, after a while, i felt that , referring to a living person as "sant" was just wrong. cos personally, i felt, while reading gurbani, the word sant was used to refer more to the guru himself or the attributes of the guru. Baba budha ji himself, was never bestowed the title "sant" in his lifetime, in the time of our gurus. and the service he did is unparalled in history, and will never ever be matched by any of us murakhs. Baba, bhai, veer, bhagat is okay.

Re: Sants

... · 26 Jun 2006

Sant show true path to the ahlakee. They are like the lighthouse/chana munara!! Then the sikh can go in right direction to reach the goal.

Re: Sants

Harcharan Singh · 27 Jun 2006

Page 87, Line 16 ਹਰਿ ਕੇ ਸੰਤ ਸੁਣਹੁ ਜਨ ਭਾਈ ਹਰਿ ਸਤਿਗੁਰ ਕੀ ਇਕ ਸਾਖੀ ॥ har kay sant sunhu jan bhaa-ee har satgur kee ik saakhee. O Saints of the Lord, O Siblings of Destiny, listen, and hear the Lord's Teachings, through the True Guru. Guru Ram Das Could veer Jarnail Singh Ji kindly explain the above tuk. Is Guru Ji not talking to the sants, as he is the satguru? Also veer ji, sant opinion aside, please listen to Sri Guru Gobind Singh Sahib Ji when he tells us: Hukum 21 - Kisae di ninda, chugali, atae eirkha nahi karni More people will listen to you if you speak with love, respect, wisdom and without anger, speculation and generalisation. Vahe-Guru

Re: Sants

... · 27 Jun 2006

Sant are GOD's true sons. They can have various avastha; even in their harsh language can be blessings. Mahapursh, enlightened souls can do as they please; there was a mahapursh that would throw a stick at anyone who try to come near them; and then there are those that show love to all. It can depend on what duty God has given them or it can depend on their avastha or circumstance of that time. The avastha can go down to that of a average human; or it can go up to that past even Guru Sahib. Baba Nand Singh once went into an avastha wherein even the birds that flew over Nanaksar were liberated/attained salvation. Baba MahaHarnam Singh made the comment; even our Guru Sahiban did not go into such a state while they were on this planet and encouraged Baba Nand Singh to not do so as well. God children have no limit and can do as they please. There is even avastha wherein the person does not remember to eat anything or go to washroom; and they need to be told when to process their bodily functions. They are near to GOD, but do not let it on.

Re: Sants

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 28 Jun 2006

Guru Piyare veer harcharan Singh jio, Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh. Here is the explanation of the Tuk on Page 87/line 16...taken from Sri Guru Granth Darpan.. http://www.gurugranthdarpan.com/0087.html The "Sant Jan/Bhai..are all the SADH SANGAT ( meaning ALL of US) and we are being advised by Guru ji to FOLLOW the SATGURU's TEACHINGS...which we are really supposed to do as instructed by the entire Gurbani in Sri guru Granth Sahib jee Maharaj ji. No "individual" sant is alluded to in this tuk. It is a COLLECTIVE NOUN...and the words Jan/Bhai etc are PLURAL. Guru Ji is NOT giving the "instructions/advice" as The SATGURU...Guru Ji is giving the advice in his humble capacity and the SATGURU is WAHEGURU..and we are supposed to FOLLOW the teachings or the WAYS of SATGURU-WAHEGURU who resides in our HEARTS ( read the entire shabad..) Thank You veer...always willing to listen..learn..un-learn and re-learn..as many times as possible... Jarnail Singh

Re: Sants

... · 28 Jun 2006

Baba Nand Singh was once in an avastha (state of conciousness) where they gave daan to anyone that passed by them . . . . any wish that a passerby may have had became fulfilled, just by being in their holy presence. Baba MahaHarnam Singh advised BabaJi that it would be recommendable not to stay in such a state as Guru Sahib themself did not do this while they came in their human (pargat) form in body.

Re: Sants

Areed! · 29 Jun 2006

I agree with the above post by "..." - Than Than Mahpursh Waheguru Deh.

Re: Sants

Harcharan Singh · 29 Jun 2006

Thank you Veer ji. My point was that sant does and can refer to people who aren't Guru Sahiban. Agreed in this case Guru Ji is talking about sadh sangat, but I would say Guru Ji is talking about sadh sangat as it used to be, all highly spiritual people, I don't think the words were meant for non-spiritual people. I agree the word Sat-Guru is used for both Vahe-Guru and previous Guru's to whom Guru Ji considers himself a humble servant. Page 31, Line 10 ਸੰਤਾ ਸੰਗਤਿ ਮਿਲਿ ਰਹੈ ਜਪਿ ਰਾਮ ਨਾਮੁ ਸੁਖੁ ਪਾਇ ॥੧॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ santaa sangat mil rahai jap raam naam sukh paa-ay. ||1|| rahaa-o. Guru Ji tells us to find and remain within the company of spiritual persons, I agree that this does not mean specifically individual mahapurkh, but people of a truthful, spiritual and obedient (to Guru) disposition in general. But at the same time it not not exclude those rare idividuals who have a higher spiritual concience. I do not personally see a problem with people wanting to call rare individuals sant, sadh, mahapurkh, bhai, baba or whatever (I prefer baba myself), the real problem lies with (as Jarnail Singh Ji says), peope who are capitalising on this pyaar from sangat, and passing "themselves" (not sangats decision) off as spiritual liberators. I would not say people like Baba Shaam/Harnaam/Randhir/Attar/Nand/Isher/Jarnail Singh Ji were fakes. The problem with fakes lies with uneduacted sangat, not fakess, fakes have and always will exist, sangat however has become more and more disorientated over the years. No amount of banning titles etc is going to make one bit of difference, nor slandering people (right or wrong), what we need to do s simply focus on the sangat, and educate them as to what Sikhi is. It is then their choice to follow a fake, follow Guru Ji or be blessed and find the sangat of a true gem. Vahe-Guru

Re: Sants

Satnam · 29 Jun 2006

Jarnail Singh jee and Jagwinder singh jee you guys are Mahapurash too as you guys have lot of knowledge. You guys believe in AKJ Ideology also. Since Bhai Saab Bhai Randhir Singh Jee called Mahapurakh Juala singh jee as Sant jee, that means He respected sants too. You guys need to be flexible, not stiff like rock. http://www.tapoban.org/Sant%20Juaalaa%20Singh%20jee.pdf

Re: Sants

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 29 Jun 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI Fateh. Veer Harcharan Singh Jio...IF only everyone in all those huge crowds surrounding the deras and samgams.chhadding jaikaras upon jaikaras after every line of fake beswadee tukbandi...had the understanding you have...all these fakes would pack up and disappear.. The amount of fake adulterated tuk bandi going under the name "kirtan"...is having far reaching effects....more and more youngsters are asking...."Can some veer provide me with the full "SHABAD" that so and so sant ji did kirtan of....First line of this "GURBANI" is.."AA giya baba waid rogian da.... Please provide the Page Number of Granth Sahib Jee raag etc. I get hundreds of such "request" monthly from all over the world or hundreds of such tasteless jingles.."Hath jorr singh betheh guraan de charnee..BUT Strangely requests for GENUINE GURBANI SHABADS are few and far between !! simply because these fakes with large following almost always NEVER sing any Genuine Gurbani... It is our duty as Sikhs to bring about change...encourage GURBANI at any cost... It is a FALLACIOUS ARGUMENT that GURBANI is "difficult", not easy, hard to understand etc etc- Guru Arjun Ji Sahib gave His LIFE for this same Gurbani..and by NEGLECTING/SETTING ASIDE GURBANI we commit the act "chandu/Jehangir" did 400 years ago when they "martyred" Guru Ji's physical body...only difference is ..we "martyr" His "Gurbani body".... Guru ji gave this wadmullee daat of Ilahi Gurbani.....and if "anyone" preaches this, lives this, i have no problems with "respecting" him/her. Rest assured..IF anyone can rise up to the Lofty standards set for such people in GURBANI..then I RESPECT them. Thank You.

Re: Sants

Satnam · 24 Jul 2006

Sant Ka Sang Wad bhagee paieea sant kee sewa naam dhiyayea.

Re: Sants

Satnam · 24 Jul 2006

Santan sangath mil rehai jap raam naam sukh paae . Remain united with the Society of the Sants; chant the Name of the Lord, and find peace. Bhagat Kabir jee says, santa maano dhoothaa ddaano eih kuttavaaree maeree || I honor and obey the Sants, and punish the wicked; this is my duty as God's police officer. Guru jee Praise har ke sant in his bani as follows, nanak maathhaa sant charan . Nanak lays his forehead on the feet of the Sants. sant sehaaee jeea kae bhavajal thaaranehaar || The Sants are the helpers, the support of the soul; they carry us cross the terrifying world-ocean. thisai milai sant khaak masathak jisai bhaag ||5|| He alone is blessed with the dust of the feet of the Sants, upon whose forehead such pre-ordained destiny is inscribed. ||5|| sant janaa kai sa(n)g houmai rog jaae || Associating with the humble Sants, the disease of egotism is eradicated

Re: Sants

Satnam · 24 Jul 2006

Guru Arjan Dev jee say in Guru Granth Sahib as follows, sant charan kar sees dhhar har naam dhhiaavo ||1|| I place my hands and my head upon the feet of the Sants, and meditate on the Lord's Name. ||1|| sant janaa kee raenukaa lai maathhai laavo ||1|| rehaao || Obtaining the dust of the feet of the Sants, I apply it to my forehead. ||1||Pause|| paav malovaa aap thiaag santa sang samaavo ||2|| I wash their feet, and renounce my self-conceit; I merge in the Sants' Congregation. ||2|| santeh charan maathhaa maero pouth || I touch my forehead to the feet of the Sants. anik baar sa(n)theh dda(n)ddouth ||1|| Countless times, I humbly bow to the Sants. ||1|| santeh charan dhhoe dhhoe peevaa || I wash the feet of the Sants, and drink in that water. santee jeethaa janam apaar || The Sants are victorious in this priceless human life. har kae sant sadhaa paravaan || The Sants of the Lord are accepted and approved forever.

Re: Sants

humkire · 24 Jul 2006

WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH dearest benjis and veerjis , sometimes i wonder whether we are really after '''truth'' or just parrots of our brainwashed biased attitudes .a person after truth holds nothing sacred but questions everything . i started of in my life like any of you out there with this respect thingy about saints .infact it was my hobby from very yung to read about the lives of saints . but sikhi ,wen it entered into my heart like a thunderbolt ,made me a democratic person ,seeing all as my brothers and sisters ,and never ever putting anyone on a pedestal by giving him some sort of a title ,apart from our TEN LIVING MASTERS(GURUS) AND ETERNAL GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE. our panth today has a lot of rot and a lot of problems .unfortunately ,this ''sant tradition'''has become a source of this rot . A sikh's only heroes should be our 10 GURU JEE'S AND GURU GRANTH SAHIB,full stop . of course throughout our history ,there have been great gursikhs,and there are ,and there will be ,increasingly more . however ,sikhi doesnt divide the citizens/constituents of the panth into a 2 tier system .that is against the core teachings of GURU GRANTH SAHIB .no one should either join the title of sant before their name and neither allow anyone else too .the most beautiful title we can give each other is bhai sahib or benji .this is because we are a fraternity of equals .and when five amrit dharees are together for a purpose we call them panj piaras -the five beloveds of GURU JEE.,isnt that so romantic ,mystical ,and wet . we need to become visionaries ,planning sikhi revolution wherever we are ,not hero worshipping a few among us .sikhi is THE FORCE. sikhi is not some religious crap with a complicated stifling bag of tricks with some saints and paralysing structures and irrelevant institutions and backward looking 'tightening the noose around the neck' ,rather than empowering history . in my entire life ,i ve met many so called individuals which will be classed into genuine and fake ''''saints'''.however ,the one sikh who far surpassed them in his spirituality was a poor old sikh man ,who never ever wanted the world to even know that he existed ,leave alone call him a saint .this sikh man ,lived in a poor part of kuala lumpur in malaysia in a tiny room above a coffee shop in an area called ipoh road ,drank just a pint of milk a day ,and wanted no visitors . we need to think new .we need to think fresh .sikhi requires no more ''sants '' and jethabandis .sikhi requires a closely knit family of brothers and sisters who can sit together,eat together and pray together .every generation has its own problems and requires its own solutions .sikhi today and tomorow requires a family of equals who will stick together and fight together .and wen we need leaders ,lets send forth the blazing five -the panj piareh . let us denounce our committment ,our loyalties ,our trust in individual jethabandis and sants .but let us be one panth and one family,if we really care for sikhi .this is wat our focus has to be on ,not on the veneration of a few guys here and there in the name of sainthood . i am no hero worshipper or saint hater ,but ,very objectively ,i do urge all of you to read the various posts of veer kulbir singh and giani arshi jee ,very very carefully over and over again ,rather than ,get all upset and emotional.these are two sikh brothers ,who make a lot of effort to present the teachings of GURU GRANTH SAHIB on this matter in a very honest and humble way ,need to be complimented for their efforts instead of being constantly attacked . sikhs are created to be lions ,and lions dont hero worship each other ,but carry out their individual tasks of being masters of the jungle ,as bhai gurdas says .lions dont bow to each other but shine in their individual glory and might,and yet work very closely and connectly ,with one another to achieve their aims .this two tier system is sapping the very life out of khalsa panth and needs to be rooted out asap. i am sorry for sounding a bit harsh ,but truth can be very harsh .we need to focus on the democratic structure of the panth GURU GOBIND SINGH bequethed to us ,not the sant and jethabandi tiered structure of the panth that is fast emerging in the last 50 or more odd years . sikhi is about ''''life''''' ,not about feeling old and ving people call you '''baba '',no matter wat yur age .sikhi is about being xcited to be an innocent child of GURU GOBIND SINGH ,not some vip called a sant . no no no ,we want to play and frolic and love eternally GURU GOBIND SINGH ,as his children .we dont want to walk around being made to feel like vips called '''saints'''sikhi is about becoming GODS child and being infused with VITAL LIFE ,not about feeeling like some grand maestro or pope or godfather . WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH

Re: Sants

Satnam · 24 Jul 2006

This is Kalyug, there are 99% fake and 1% real. Duplicacy only exists of a real genuine thing. Lot of us after seeing fake , start doing nindia of real sants also. it is very hard to find a real sant, that is why Guru Arjan dev jee said, sadh ka sang nahi, kuch qaal. that means you need to work hard to find real sant. Everyone should jap naam and do ardas to Guru Jee, so that you can meet a real sant in your life. Guruan de Guru Guru Granth Sahib, sangat karni maha purkhan dee jo Guru Granth Sahib naal Jorran. Jere aapne naal joran uhna naalon karna kinara.

Re: Sants

dass · 25 Jul 2006

Sant Attar Singh Ji Mastuana Wale Sant Teja Singh Ji Sant Baba Nand Singh Ji Kaleran Wale Sant Ishar SIngh Ji Kaleran Wale Sant Ishar Singh Ji Rare Wale Sant Baba Puran Singh Ji Kericho Wale Sant Baba Norang Singh Ji Sant Gurbachan Singh Ji These are absolute gems of the panth who saved Sikhi and with the 10th Masters kirpa helped thousands of Sikhs return to the khalsa fold by administering Amrit. True Sants / Brahmgianis always lead the Sikhs to the Shabad Guru and Amrit.

Re: Sants

abc · 25 Jul 2006

True enlightened soul can show the sikh the true path. Other people can only take you for a ride where you will fall off the cliff at the end. Only enlightened soul can help you reach the final destination.... That is reason we should follow the saint; I even heard mahapursh bachan wherein they state that only one who has obtain atam gian should be allowed to do katha. Anyone else will shoot the arrow here or there; they will say word of knowledge w/o realizing afflictment of the congregation. Enlightened soul can realize the state of the individual and process enlightenment accordingly.

Re: Sants

humkire · 25 Jul 2006

hi das veerji , wat about knocking off those ''sant '' titles before all those names and fix bhai sahib instead as per gurmat style .will that pinch you painfully somewhere ? has the power of wat a bhai sahib means ,i.e a sant sipahi ,degenerated in your eyes to a point where you need to stubbornly fix a title b4 any of those names to distinguish them as being somewhat special to the rest of us and hence immediately catapulting the sangat into a two tiered panth which is not wat GURU GOBIND SINGH JEE left us as our inheritance . these bhai sahibs have done what they needed to do and gone ,now you need to do what your generation needs you to do if you love khalsa panth .you need to think as to wat is the most suitable future structure of the panth in meeting with the needs of the panth and keeping intact the structure that GURU JEE left us to follow, which is a fraternity of equals headed by the institution of the PANJ PIAREH .these guys you mentioned are NOT to be hero worshipped as saints .they are to be respected as sikhs of GURUJEE ,full stop ,if indeed any of them are . sikhi is not some fragile chineware depending on these guys to prop up sikhi as if sikhi is an invalid .these guys instead have needed sikhi to be sikhs of GURU GOBIND SINGH MAHARAJ .get that clear in your mind .sikhi owes them nothing to bestow titles of saints on ANY of them ,but they owe their last drop of life and blood to sikhi for getting them out of the matrix and bk to the eternal feet of GURU GOBIND SINGH ,if indeed any of them have reached there . its time to get this sant recognition-veneration disease out of our system and get back on track of hero worshipping our 10 GURU SAHIBS and GURU GRANTH SAHIB MAHARAJ and NOBODY ELSE . this is where the matter stops and im sorry but there is no further room for discussion .veer kulbeer singh and gyani arshi singh jee have given adequate references to prove this point and its time to get rid of these softy softy saint based- saint propped up ,image of sikhi that lurks in our mind . stop looking bk at this people and focus on the contribution you can make to spread ,SIKHI -----THE ULTIMATE FORCE of the universe among all the peoples of the world .that is your real challenge ,bhai sahib .become a sikh revolutionary .think the unthinkable ,dream the impossible and do the undo-able ,to make your life be a positive contribution to the unification of the panth as well as spread of sikhi b4 the day of death comes and denies you this golden oppurtunity .and no matter how great you shine as a ''sant sipahi'' and khalsa of GURU GOBIND SINGH MAHARAJ ,always stay humble to never ever allow yurself to be titled by anyone as a saint ,but take pleasure in being a lowly humble sikh of GURU GOBIND SINGH JEE .

Re: Sants

Harcharan Singh · 26 Jul 2006

Humkire Ji, Just one point, why shouldn't we look back at the great souls dass ji has mentioned, do most people on this forum not look back at Bhai Randhir Singh Ji for inspiration and guidance? Quote "stop looking bk at this people and focus on the contribution you can make" What fault is it of the great Gursikh aforementioned if today's sangat wishes to bestow sant on their name? We should never undermine the contribution of Guru Ji's true servants, but rather celebrate it. ਬਾਬਾਣੀਆ ਕਹਾਣੀਆ ਪੁਤ ਸਪੁਤ ਕਰੇਨਿ ॥ baabaanee-aa kahaanee-aa put saput karayn. The stories of one's ancestors make the children good children. ਜਿ ਸਤਿਗੁਰ ਭਾਵੈ ਸੁ ਮੰਨਿ ਲੈਨਿ ਸੇਈ ਕਰਮ ਕਰੇਨਿ ॥ je satgur bhaavai so man lain say-ee karam karayn. They accept what is pleasing to the Will of the True Guru, and act accordingly. On another point, could somebody point out why some people refer to Bhai Randhir Singh Ji as Bhai Sahib Bhai Randir Singh ji? If Bhai alone was good enough for Bhai Manni Singh Ji and Bhai Gurdaas Ji, then why do we today attach Bhai Sahib before Bhai, I have seen this title used more and more increasingly, an example is Yogi Bhajan Ji. Vaheguru.

Re: Sants

humkire · 26 Jul 2006

veer harcharan singh jee , yes of course thats what i meant ,veerji . by looking back, i mean ,dont start getting fixated on them ,and dont start hero worshipping and venerating them. of course ,we should derive inspiration and draw lessons from the past ,but, for the purpose of bettering our present and future . i am not suggesting whose fault it is for these titles to be b4 their name ,only that bhai ''' ''''' singh is more than enough,as u suggested .that will keep us all equal as children and sikhs of GURU JEE . also i agree that every true sikh's life is worthy to be celebrated ,but the best of all celebrations is our continous daily celebration of walking and talking with our living eternal GURU JEE . hope you understand that the gist of my post is our need to be unified as one family, and to be futuristic in our vision .to get out of present constricting mindsets and to see sikhi as THE ULTIMATE FORCE SWEEPING THROUGHOUT THE UNIVERSE.AND FOR THAT ,WE NEED TO BE SOLIDLY UNITED AS ONE FAMILY

Re: Sants

abc · 28 Jul 2006

The avtaar of the 21st century Sant Attar Singh Mastuana Sahib. NOTHING MORE NEEDS TO BE SAID!!!

Re: Sants

humkire · 28 Jul 2006

abc veerji , sorry to sound harsh and rude ,but not an avtaar of the 21st century ,but perhaps a humble beggar at the door of the ETERNAL AVTAAR ,GURU NANAK DEV ,( and who would appreciate being called bhai attar singh) ,and perhaps a dog at the door of GURU GOBIND SINGH ,just like the great bhai nand lal called himself .and there is a lot more ,that can be said about the truth of this statement . WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH