Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

Balpreet Singh · 02 Dec 2004

I wrote this essay for 2nd year University. In it, I was replying to western scholars who wrote that Singh Sabha changed Sikhism and killed its plural nature. This is what the Sanatanists are trying to say now. Please read over this essay. This belief that Sikh identity was "fluid" is itself a new invention. Don't fall for the propoganda. Defining a “Sikh”: Tracing the Historic Foundations of Sikh Identity By Balpreet Singh I. Introduction The issue of defining Sikh Identity has been a topic of much debate in modern Sikh scholarship. Clearly, Sikhs today form a unique and distinct community with a separate identity, but has this always been the case? Many scholars argue that different Sikh identities existed within the Panth until the latter part of the 19th century and all made an equally legitimate claim to being “Sikh”. This paper argues that the proposed fluid nature of Sikh identity is not evident if early Sikh textual sources are examined. Three distinct periods significant to the study of Sikh identity are from the time of Guru Nanak to the birth of the Khalsa in 1699, the early Khalsa period until the first half of the 18th century and then finally the Sikh Kingdoms until the Singh Sabha. By examining early Sikh identity in these three periods, it becomes clear that Sikhs indeed formed a distinct community with unique customs and practices and this distinctiveness persisted strongly until the latter half of the 18th century. At this point however, various factors triggered by the formation of the Sikh Kingdoms resulted in a weakening of the boundaries between Hindus and Sikhs and the adoption of many Hindu customs. The Singh Sabha, far from “creating” a Sikh tradition, was thus a revivalist movement in the sense that it sought to purge the Sikhs of many outside influences and re-solidify previously existing boundaries. An examination of some prior work on the topic of Sikh identity shows that many scholars hold that Sikh identity as it exists today was constructed by the Singh Sabha elites in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Perhaps Harjot Oberoi presents the most controversial stand on Sikh identity. Oberoi holds that Sikhs were not separate from the Hindu community and shared a common “territory, language, rites de passage, dietary taboos, festivals... ”. Furthermore, the “[e]arly-period Sikh tradition did not show much concern for establishing distinct religious boundaries ” and the Singh Sabha reformers created Sikh life rituals which were specifically designed to differentiate the Sikhs from the Hindus. “The ‘invented tradition’ made it possible for the Sikh public to think, imagine and speak in terms of a universal community of believers united by uniform rites, symbols and scripture ” Richard Fox holds a similar belief and states that “[t]hose who labelled themselves ‘Sikh’ in the nineteenth century embraced no single cultural meaning, religious identity or social practice...Therefore, long standing widely shared and consistent Sikh cultural principles cannot explain why the Third Sikh War [Gurdwara Reform Movement] was fought on the basis of Singh identity and over Sikh institutions. In fact, no such tradition existed” McLeod takes a less radical stance and simply outlines what he believes is the gradual evolution of Sikh identity, which finally crystallised, largely due to the Singh Sabha movement with Khalsa identity emerging dominant and “distinguished by a new consistency and a new clarity of definition.” . II. The Use of the Historical/Western Approach in Studying the Sikh Tradition Before an examination of the issue of Sikh identity can take place, it is important to first acknowledge the limitations of the historical, and specifically Western approach to studying the Sikh tradition. Noel Q. King holds the view that using methods of scholarship developed for Christianity and Judaism on other religions, is dangerous. This observation, of course, is very much linked to the debate of Orientalism: a western ethnocentrism that sees the norm as being the West and all other traditions are judged by those standards and considered mutations of the same. In the Sikh tradition, a major method of transmitting history and tradition is oral. This is not acceptable for scholars who would use the Western approach: a codified, written account is needed. A good example of this conflict can be seen in the examinations of the Rehitnama literature. Although rehit is considered to be a comprehensive guide to the Khalsa code of conduct, it was often written as a supplementary guide to the Rehit outlined by the initiating Punj Pyaaray in the Khanday kee Paahul ceremony. Desa Singh writes in the seventh stanza of his rehitnama, “that rehit which the five utter, keep that steadfast in your mind” and later in the ninth stanza writes “that is the first rehit, the one which the five Singhs said in the Paahul ceremony. The other different rehits which are spoken of, that is which I will go on to explain ”. Clearly the written rehit is secondary to the one which was orally elucidated by the Punj Pyaaray. Even to this day, many Sikh groups i.e. Akhand Kirtanee Jatha, keep the rehit and the gurmantra secret and a guard is posted at the doors of Paahul ceremonies to maintain secrecy. The rehit is passed down orally through generations or “seenaa-baseenaa” and the newly initiated are instructed to carefully listen and remember the rehit so that they too may pass it down. The modern day “Sikh Rehit Maryada” which was created in the first half of the twentieth century is in fact a western document which is formally codified in prose with sections and subsections and is not in any way a “traditional” Sikh document. Similarly, King argues that classifying Sikh documents such as the Janamsakhis under western categories i.e. that of biography is also problematic. Janamsakhis are not biographies, but in fact a category unto themselves. Thus, attempting to analyse and understand the Sikh tradition with a west-centric view is difficult and prone to error, but working within these parameters, this paper will attempt to examine the historical basis of Sikh identity. III. Early Sikh Identity Anthony Smith when explaining the establishment of “ethnic identities” refers to six foundations of ethnic identity: a name for the group, belief of common ancestry, presence of historical memories, shared culture, attachment to a specific territory and a sense of common solidarity . These guidelines are useful in an examination of the early Sikh community to see the extent to which the Sikhs were a distinct ethnic group. The Sikh Gurus, from the time of Guru Nanak attempted to create a unique community of believers who would live a lifestyle independent from the faiths around them. Guru Nanak criticised the religious practices he saw around him, declaring, “[t]he Hindus die worshipping, worshipping the idols and the Muslims die bowing their heads. The former burn the dead and the latter bury them. None of the two finds the real state O Lord! ” Guru Nanak and his successors rejected many common religious and cultural rituals such as belief in salvation through pilgrimage, ritual cleanliness, idol worship, caste, sati and asceticism . As opposed to the prevalent custom of pursuing spirituality in solitary seclusion, Guru Nanak advocated the necessity of congregation or sangat and established communities of Sikhs. Bhai Gurdas, the nephew of the third Guru and close associate of the subsequent gurus, describes how the “Gursikhs” meet daily in the congregation at the dharamsalas to sing Sodar and Sohila and “heartily associate with one another.” Guru Nanak also established what Bhai Gurdas describes as a type of Sachkhand (realm of truth) on earth in the form of Kartarpur. Kartarpur was the first of many towns established by the Sikh gurus which were “inhabited by the holy congregation.” As the Sikh community grew, subsequent gurus also introduced distinct features to the Panth. Guru Angad developed the Gurmukhi script for use by the Sikhs . Separate Sikh festivals of Baisakhi and Divali were celebrated at the sacred Baulee of Goindvaal. Distinct life cycles too had begun to evolve in the Panth . This is illustrated by the account of Guru Amar Das’s death by Baba Sundar in SGGS. Guru Amar Das instructs the Sikhs to not weep after him, as was the custom and furthermore says “do not bother with offering rice-balls on leaves, lighting lamps, and other rituals like floating the body out on the Ganges. ” All these instructions were clearly in opposition to the traditional death rituals of the Hindus. The Sikh identity emerged even more strongly by the time of the fourth Guru. Guru Ram Das “composed the wedding hymn (Lavan) for the solemnisation of Sikh marriage” as well as hymns to be sung upon the arrival of the groom at the bride's house. Guru Ram Das also outlined the conduct of one who could be called a Sikh of the Guru: she rises early, bathes, meditates upon the naam and at daybreak begins to sing Gurbani. The Sikhs now had a distinct code of conduct. Guru Arjan continued the process of giving the Sikhs life cycle rituals. Guru Arjan composed hymns that would be sung at the birth of a child and according to some, made reference to the singing of the Anand upon such a joyous occasion . Also under Guru Arjan, the Sikhs had developed a virtual capital in the form of Ramdaspur, which also housed the Harimandir, the central Sikh shrine. Both places are celebrated in various hymns in the SGGS, with Ramdaspur being particularly characterised as the ideal city. With the compilation of the Adi Granth by Guru Arjan, the Sikhs finally had a central scripture, which included a liturgy and could officially be considered a people of the word or a textual community. It was at this point that Guru Arjan could unambiguously declare “I do not go on pilgrimage to Mecca nor bathe at the Hindu holy places...to the formless One I bow in my heart. I am neither Hindu nor Muslim ” Oberoi argues that this hymn was in response to an older verse by Kabir and “is only reinforcing Kabir’s thought” which followed the Sant tradition of rejecting traditional orthodoxies. Pashaura Singh refutes this argument and argues that this hymn was used to clarify Kabir’s beliefs and declare independence from both the Muslim and Hindu identities . Besides the words of the gurus to provide insight into what it meant to be “Sikh”, the vaars of Bhai Gurdas also outline many distinct features of Sikh identity. Bhai Gurdas makes it clear in his vaars that the disciples of Guru Nanak are the “Gursikhs” who follow a distinct way of life. Bhai Gurdas reiterates the conduct of the Gursikhs, who wake “early in the morning” and meditate upon the mul mantra and gurmantra, followed by a recitation of Japji. Later they go to the congregation of other Gursikhs and sing Gurbani. The Gursikhs celebrate the anniversaries of the gurus. Amongst the followers of the Gurus, Bhai Gurdas records a mixture of all the castes who are all considered equal in the eyes of Guru Nanak and God . Furthermore the “Goddess and gods are neither served nor worshipped” by the Gursikhs, who also place no faith in omens such as “the twelve signs of the zodiac, incantations, magic...lunar and week days," etc. This clearly is a break from the common culture of the Punjab at the time. The Gursikhs had a separate initiation ceremony or the Charan-Amrit, where the Guru’s feet were washed and the water drunk by the new Sikhs .Bhai Gurdas goes further and says “Hindus and Muslims have started two separate ways...they all are not equal to even one hair of a Guru’s Sikh, who has effaced his sense of ego” Also, “the Guru has created the mighty Gurmukh panth. This panth keeps itself away from the boundaries of the Vedas and the Semitic scriptures...” There appears to be a clear distinction between the Gursikhs and the other communities and the presence of a separate Sikh identity. Another important feature of the Vaars of Bhai Gurdas, is the condemnation of heretic sects which originated from the Sikhs. True Gursikhs recognise the authentic lineage and unity in spirit of all the gurus from Guru Nanak to Guru Hargobind . Followers of other gurus are false and mislead. The followers of Prithi Chand, the Meenas (scoundrels), are particularly condemned for much of the 36th vaar. The “faces of the Meenas are blackened”, “the way of the brazen faced Meenas leads towards hell” . All other pretenders to the Guruship are also condemned: “[t]hose who without merit call themselves Guru, are sluggish dissemblers .” All these references clearly refute Oberoi who claims that “the history of Sikh tradition is radically different from, say, early Christianity which from the very beginning had a dominant concern with demarcating believers and non believers...Such modes of exclusion, of publicising the boundaries of belief and practice were quite alien to early Sikh tradition” Even Guru Angad, in what is a clear reference to Sri Chand and his followers wrote, “What kind of gift is this that one gives to oneself? The true gift is that which is received by serving the Master to his satisfaction. ”The Sikhs had sufficient boundaries to exclude deviant/heretic sects from the community and furthermore condemned them as illegitimate pretenders. An independent source that collaborates much of Bhai Gurdas’s writings on the Sikhs is the Dabistan-i-Mazahib. Dabistan was written around 1645 as an account of various religions and gives a separate chapter to the Nanak Panthis or “GuruSikhs”. Dabistan presents the Sikhs as a unique community who “do not believe in images or idol-temples” and clearly presents the Sikhs as separate from the Muslims and the Hindus: “To be brief, Nanak’s followers scorn images. Their belief is that all Gurus are Nanak...They do not recite the mantras of the Hindus and do not pay respect to their idol-temples. They do not count the avtaras for anything. They do not have any attachment to Sanskrit, which the Hindus call the language of angels” . One masand, Debi Chand, is described as being so strict that “neither a Hindu nor Muslim can approach him ”. Although this is clearly not a common or even acceptable Sikh practice, it shows that clear boundaries existed between the “believers” or Gursikhs and the other communities. The author of Dabistan also confirms other distinct features of Sikh identity i.e. the rejection of the caste system , the commemoration of Baisakhi , etc. There are also references to the Minas who are condemned by the Sikhs and also that Sikhs “have held that the Udasi, that is, a religious recluse, is not of commendable faith” . This reference clearly applies to the followers of Sri Chand who were ascetic monks. The writer of Dabistan was in contact with various Sikhs of his time and also claims to have known the sixth and seventh gurus personally, thus his account or Sikh identity is certainly reliable. If all textual sources on the Sikhs are examined, it becomes clear that a distinct Sikh identity did exist. Returning to Smith’s six foundations for ethnic identity, the Sikhs fulfil all the requirements. The community was collectively named the “Gursikhs”, they claimed spiritual ancestry from Nanak, they had historic memories in the form of stories about Nanak and other Gursikhs as illustrated by the narrations in the Vaars and Dabistan. The Sikhs shared a culture that included food taboos , common social practices, language, worship etc. In accordance with the need for a territory, the Sikhs were attached to a piece of territory i.e. the Punjab and specifically to various towns established by the gurus and specifically to Ramdaspur, which was celebrated as the Sikh capital. Finally, there certainly existed a sense of common solidarity that is noted by Bhai Gurdas and in Dabistan in that Sikhs were noted to always help each other and were welcome in each-other’s homes . Thus it is clear that the early Sikh community had a distinct identity which was by no means fluid. The early Sikhs were a separate community with distinct boundaries. IV Sikh Identity from 1699 to the Mid 1700s Perhaps the single most defining event in the formation of Sikh history was the establishing of the Khalsa in 1699. Numerous authors have questioned whether the Khalsa was truly given a rehit and external discipline as extensive as is seen in today’s Khalsa, indicating that it is more likely that the Khalsa rehit was developing well into the 18th century. The rehitnama literature also does not codify the rehit in any exhaustive way. However the discovery of Bhatt Vehis or contemporary records of professional bards, sheds considerable light on the events of Baisakhi 1699. The Bhatt Vehi “Multani Sindhi Pargana Thanaysar” is described by Piara Singh Padam as the oldest account of this event : “Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji, tenth Guru, son of Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji, in the year 1752 on Tuesday-the Vaisakhi day-gave Khande ki pahul to five Sikhs and surnamed them as Singhs. First Daya Ram Sopti, Khatri resident of Lahore stood up. Then Mohkam Chand Calico printer of Dawarka; Sahib Chand barber of Zafrabad city; Dharam Chand Jawanda Jat of Hastinapur; Himmat Chand water carrier of Jagannath stop up one after the other. All were dressed in blue and he himself also dressed the same way. Hookah, halaal, hajaamat, haraam, tikka, janeu, dhoti were prohibited. Socialisation with the descendants of Prithi Chand, followers of Dhirmal and Ram Rai, clean shaven people and Masands was prohibited. All were given Kangha, Karad, Kesgee, Karhaa, and Kacheraa. All were made Keshdhaaree. Everyone’s place of birth was told to be Patna, of residence as Anandpur. Rest, Guru’s deeds are known only to the Guru. Repeat Guru Guru, the Guru will help everywhere” This account leaves no doubt to the existence of the five kakaars (although not explicitly referred to as such) from the inception of the Khalsa nor ambiguity regarding the establishment of taboos and social boundaries and restrictions. An accompanying question on the Khalsa, is whether it was defined as the only legitimate “Sikh” identity or if it was simply an option and non-Khalsa Nanak-Panthis could also claim to adhere to an equally legitimate form of Sikh identity. Sainapati, the writer of Gursobha in 1711, declared that “it was the wish of Gobind Singh that all Sikhs turn Khalsa .” Similarly in the Amarnamah by Nathmal, a document appended to a copy of the Gursobha and dated October 8, 1708 the Guru “commanded the Sikhs to be courageous and to come to him for taking amrit ”. It thus seems that Khalsa identity was indeed intended for all Sikhs and was not simply one amongst many possible identities they could assume. The Sikh identity also became much more exclusive after the advent of the Khalsa. As written in the Bhatt Vehi, the Khalsa was forbidden from associating with Meenas, followers of Dhirmal, Masands, followers of Ram Rai etc. Almost all rehitnamas from Chaupa Singh to Daya Singh prohibit the Khalsa from associating with these heretic groups. Furthermore, the Khalsa is also marked as being a separate and unique faith. Guru Gobind Singh is recorded in the Amarnamah as saying “Do not even think of following the Hindu path. Always have faith in the Akal Purakh I worship ” Another interesting feature of the Khalsa, is the further development of rites de passage. Despite Oberoi’s assertion that the Singh Sabha created unique life cycle rituals, old Sikh texts tell a much different story. The Amarnamah records that Sikh children should be administered amrit at birth and again during mid-life and that “at the time of death, amrit is a source of comfort” . The Khalsa rejects the Hindu custom of dying upon the ground and that “Sikhs must not do what the Brahmin commands...Sikhs should be ashamed of worshipping Brahmins...” The Bhai Daya Singh rehitnama insists that “[d]o not solemnise marriage without Anand marriage” Thus the Khalsa indeed had distinct life cycle rituals which continued the Sikh tradition of being independent from the Hindus. An interesting question that arises, is regarding the status of the Sahajdharis in the Panth. Oberoi writes that “Sahajdhari Sikhs totally inverted Khalsa categories of thought and religious boundaries.” But was the Sahajdhari identity considered an acceptable form of Sikh identity? The Bhagatratnavalee helps answer this question. The Bhagatratnavalee is a text attributed to Bhai Mani Singh but due to textual references to the Bhai in the third person is likely not by him. “The work may be dated between AD 1706....and AD 1737.” The Bhagatratnavalee includes a conversation between the Sahajdharis and Guru Gobind Singh in which the Sahajdharis seem to differentiate between themselves and “Sikhs” or the Khalsa. The Sahajdharis allow that they are indeed not fully Sikhs and the Guru also encourages them to adopt Khalsa practices while acknowledging that they are not yet ready to abandon many Hindu customs. There are clear directions that the Sahajdharis should eventually embrace the Khalsa identity. When the Sahajdharis wonder what ceremonies to perform for their young sons who used to undergo the ritual shaving or Bhadun, Guru Gobind Singh orders “give Paahul to the sons of the Sahajdharis”. The Sahajdharis are even told “those of you who are Sahajdhari Sikhs, if you can keep your form complete like the keshdharis, it is good” The Sahajdharis complain “At the time of weddings, we would call the Brahmins to read the Vedas and the hymns of marriage. Now the Sikhs say ‘you should marry by reading the Anand, do not call the Brahmins.” The Guru advises them to first do Ardas and the Anand, followed by whatever practices they followed previously. Subsequently the Sahajdharis say that the “Sikhs say now that the Vahiguru has revealed the Khalsa, you must not perform the ceremonies of the rest of the world”. Discussions with the Guru address different issues including death rituals, the practice of Sharadh, bathing at the Ganges etc. Overall, the Sahajdharis complain that the “Sikhs” are telling them to abandon Hindu life rituals and the Guru in response attempts to slowly wean them away from the Hindus and towards the Khalsa. This account of the tension between the Khalsa and the Sahajdharis is also cited by Sainapati who writes that the “Khatris in particular were opposed to the injunction regarding keeping the hair uncut because ceremonially cutting of the hair was a part of their ceremonial practices” and that they largely opposed the Khalsa. Nonetheless, what is made clear in the Bhagatratnavalee is that the Sahajdharis were not considered to have a legitimate Sikh identity but “Sahajdhari” was a halfway house between Hindu and Sikh. Although the dichotomy between Sahajdhari and Khalsa may have existed to some extent within the Panth, outside observers were very clear on who the Sikhs were: they were the Khalsa. Emperor Bahadur Shah’s court records regarding the Sikhs note: “Sikhs used to become Sikhs through the mediation of Masands...Guru Gobind Singh dismissed the Masands by one stroke of pen and established the Khalsa....Among the community of Khatris, a great disturbance occurred and marriage and kinships [between the Khalsa Sikhs and others] were given up” Later, when the Sikhs under Banda Singh attacked the Punjab, the records read “The Sikhs of the Khalsa have established their authority in Sarhind and have decreed that no one should kill any animal.” When the Mughal rulers ordered the persecution of the Sikhs, the official orders read “to kill at sight all the followers of Guru Nanak wherever they are found.” Indeed, this order was directed towards the Khalsa Sikhs, but they were simply referred to as the followers of Nanak. The clearest association between Khalsa and Sikh can be found in the writings of Qazi Nur Muhammad who in 1764 wrote: “the Sikhs are the disciples of a Guru and that fortunate Guide had lived at Chak. The ways and practices of these [people] are derived from Nanak who showed to the Sikhs a separate path. His [last] successor was Gobind Singh, from whom they received the title ‘Singh’. They are not from amongst the Hindus. These miscreants have a distinct religion of their own” Thus it is clear that Khalsa identity was considered the true and complete expression of Sikh identity and was recognised as such by all Sikhs as well as outside observers. V. Late 18th Century to the Singh Sabha. By the latter half of the 18th century, the Sikhs began to gain power over a large part of the Punjab. However, observers of the Sikhs now began to notice some heterogeneity: there now existed the Khalsa and the Khualasah. George Forester in 1783 notes that the Khualasahs form a sect amongst the Sikhs who “cut off the hair of their heads and beard and in their manners and appearance resemble the ordinary classes of Hindoos” . But even at that point, Forester notes that “I have been informed that matrimonial connections are occasionally formed between the Hindoos and Khualasah Sicques” . This would indicate that intermarriage between the Hindus and Sikhs, even amongst the non Khalsa Sikhs, was rare. Ghulam Ali Khan in his account of the Sikhs in 1808 also notes that the Khualasah exist but that they are much smaller in number and “of one thousand, or rather ten thousand persons, one can find only one or two persons who cut their hair.” Although the Khualasah only became apparent at this time, the term had existed much earlier. The term occurs in Sainapati’s Gursobha and refers to those who had “abandoned the Khalsa code of life” Thus the Khualasah seem to be a by-product of the persecution the Sikhs faced and refers to those who could not keep the Khalsa identity under such intense pressure: rather than being another type of Sikh, they were in fact “patit” or apostate Khalsas. As the Sikh Kingdoms become established and Khalsa becomes the ruler of the Punjab, heterodoxy and diversity became more prevalent amongst the Sikhs. The now numerous Khualasah began to be referred to as “the disciples of Nanak” while the Khalsa were “those of Govind-singhu.” Accounts of Nanuku-shakhees, Nirvanees, Ukalees and Nimullus” became common. H.H. Wilson was able to even make a catalogue of “Nanak Shahis” which included the Udasis, Govind Sinhis and Suthra Shahis. The Khalsa themselves began “copying the ceremonies of the Hindoos” while ignoring previous dietary taboos on intoxicants and meat. The Sikhs were beginning to take part in “popular religion” as described by Oberoi: witchcraft, omens, sorcery, ancestor worship etc. “An integral part of Sikh sacred practices in nineteenth-century Punjab was the worship of the goddess Devi....Durga, Kali, Kalka, Mahesri” All these were clearly practices that the Sikhs had rejected and abandoned in the past, but now they again became common amongst them. Idols were installed the Golden Temple complex of Sikh Gurus and Hindu gods and lower caste Sikhs could visit the Golden Temple only at certain times of the day. Even reverence for the Guru Granth Sahib became lessened as “men from the body of guru lineages and other holy figures...occupied this hallowed position” The distinct religious identity of the Sikhs had eroded and the assimilation into Hinduism had begun. This was the setting for the revolutionary Singh Sabha movement. VI. Conclusions By examining early Sikh identity in textual sources, it appears clear that the Sikhs were a distinct group with separate beliefs and practices and were recognised as such by outsiders and the Sikhs themselves. However, sometime in the late in the 18th century a process of identity dilution began to take place, to the extent that within 100 years, different types of Sikh identity became possible and the Khalsa tradition had been contaminated with many Hindu and rural Punjabi practices. The question of course is why this happened. I propose four factors which resulted in the dilution of Sikh Identity: 1) Loss of Sikh institutions due to persecution in the early 18th century 2) The advent of Sikh rule under the Misals; 3) Influx of converts; 4) Influence of village culture when Sikhs settled back into rural life. The central Sikh institution has since the time of Guru Nanak been the Dharamsala. With the general persecution of Sikhs from the time of Banda Singh Bahadur until the latter part of the 18th century, the Dharamsalas had to be abandoned and the control fell into non-Khalsa hands. Udasis and Hindu devotees of the Gurus took control of the dharamsalas and “began to act independent of Panth and Panthic ideology and reverted to old Hindu religious practices. ” Udasis “believed in the Vedas, the Puranas and the Shastras” and were even classified as a Hindu sect by Cunningham in his book History of the Sikhs. Sikh dharamsalas began to be operated in a fashion similar to Hindu temples with the treatment of Guru Granth Sahib as an idol, the actual installation of Hindu idols and restrictions on lower castes in worship. Even the celebration of Gurpurabs was Hinduised with sharadhs being held in memory of the Gurus . When the Sikhs became rulers of the Punjab, the dharamsalas remained in the hands of non-Sikhs and thus rather than promoting true Sikh ideals, dharamsalas promoted a Vedantic and Hinduised mutation of Sikhism. The Akali movement in freeing the Gurdvaras and dharmsalas, was therefore an important step in reviving the Sikh tradition. The second factor in the dilution of Sikh identity was the evolution of the Misal system and the rise of Sikh power in the Punjab. In 1769, Kesar Singh Chibbar wrote that with the rise of Sikh power, “in ten years all would be chaos and nothing left of the Sikh tradition in Punjab. Even the Adi Granth would disappear from circulation...Khalsa Sikhs had quickly turned their backs on the fundamental teachings of the Sikh gurus .” The rise of the Misals contributed to the formation of a new caste system within the Sikhs as different Misals needing to form unions to protect and increase territory began to appeal to caste as a unifying force. The majority of Misal heads were Jats, but other castes too were represented i.e. Ramgarhia, Kalals, etc. But because Jats were most numerous, they gained power over the Sikh Kingdoms and a new caste system was formed, which was not the same as the Hindu Varnashrama Dharma. Jats occupied the supreme position, followed by Ramgarhias, Khatris, and the Ramdasias and Mazahbis . Another product of the rise of Sikh power was the creation of various sects within Sikhism. It became a good business decision to start a sect and open a “dera” or monastery in the Sikh Kingdoms. Because of state patronage, the number of Udasi monasteries increased from about 12 in the middle of the 18th century to over 250 in the reign of Maharaja Ranjit Singh . Most of these establishments received land or money grants from the state. The families of the Gurus also were patronised by the state i.e. the Sodhis, Bedis, Bhallas and Trehans. Amongst the various types of Sikhs listed by Oberoi , many are simply followers of different schools of Udasi thought i.e. Ajit Mallis, Guru Ditta Baba, Suthra Shaahee, etc. Others are followers of the Sodhis i.e. Barbhag Singh Guru. What is clear however, is that Khalsa identity was still the most common identity with the Sikh Kingdom itself being called “Sarkar-i-Khalsa” and the vast majority of Sikhs returning themselves as Khalsa in the census of 1881. Thus, it is clear that state patronage by the Sikh Kingdoms facilitated the development of various types of Sikh identity. A linked factor to the establishment of the Sikh Kingdoms is the influx of converts into Sikhism. Sita Ram Kohli had estimated the number of Khalsa Sikhs to be around 20000 in the middle of the 18th century. By the 1881 census, the population of Sikh had risen to 1.8 million. This was a direct result of mass conversion to Sikhism. It paid to be Sikh in a Sikh Kingdom. The new converts however were not dedicated to maintaining the faith nor many of the tenets. Malcolm in his Sketch of The Sikhs remarks how the new converts continue to follow the rituals of their old faith. Such mass influx was responsible for the revival of Hindu rituals and beliefs in Sikh society with life cycle rituals reverting to those of the Hindus. The final factor in the dilution of Sikh identity was the immersion of Sikhs back into village culture. It was fairly easy to maintain a strong sense of identity and distinctiveness amongst the Sikhs when persecution forced them to live together in bands apart from village culture. Once the Sikh Kingdoms had been established, Sikhs returned to live in villages and many old caste and cultural customs were re-established. An example of this is the worship of ancestors. It is a common custom amongst Punjabis to worship ancestors and a British observer remarked that “[t]he worship of the sainted dead, though contrary to the injunctions of Gobind Singh, is universal among Jats, whether Sikhs, Sultanis or Hindus ”. Other Punjabi customs such as considering certain days sacred to the sun and others to the moon also became common. All such rituals had been condemned by the Gurus and noted as absent amongst the Sikhs by earlier observers, however immersion in village culture resulted in the weakening of Sikh identity. Thus, this paper has argued that Sikhs had a well-defined and distinct identity into the middle of the 18th century but was at that point diluted. Khalsa identity has also been shown to have been the most common Sikh identity, and in fact synonymous with Sikh and “Nanak-Panthi”. The Singh Sabha reformers did not re-invent the Sikh tradition: they simply revived it. Life cycle rituals that Oberoi describes as being innovations were recorded at the time of the Gurus and not elite creations. Pockets of Sikhs who followed the old traditions also existed in the late 19th century when much of the Sikh tradition had been diluted and boundaries lost. The dera of Baba Ajaipal Singh in Nabha has been recorded by Bhai Kahan Singh as a bastion of Khalsa ideals. It was in fact this dera that inspired the Namdhari movement. Macauliffe also records that “amid the general corruption of the religion of Gobind there are to be found about one hundred Sikhs at Naderh in the Dakhan, who are said to have up to present time preserved intact the faith” . These Sikhs initiate Brahmins and Sudras into the Khalsa and “Brahmin weds Sudra and Sudra weds Brahmin” He also notes the rejection of Brahminism amongst these Sikhs. The Akhand Kirtanee Jatha of present times also compares well to the descriptions given of the original Sikhs . The study of Sikh identity has often begun with only an in-depth study of the Sikh practices of the late 19th century. This is problematic. To achieve an understanding of Sikh identity, it is crucial to reflect upon older accounts from the time of the Gurus and also outsider descriptions of the Sikhs before the time of the Sikh Kingdoms. These accounts describe a community which is distinct in all ways from the Hindus with a separate way of life. The Singh Sabha movement thus cannot be considered simply as a result of elite instrumentalism but must be considered in the light of early evidence. Under such an analysis it becomes clear that the Sikh revival in the late 19th century was just that: a revival. Most certainly not a set of artificial innovations. Annotated Bibliography 1. Ed. Barrier, N. Gerald & Singh, Pashaura. Sikh Identity: Continuity and Change. Delhi: Manohar, 1999 This is a collection of essays from a Conference held in Michigan in 1996, which had the same title as the book. Essays in Parts 2 and 3 are useful as they discuss "early markers of Sikh Identity" and the development of Sikh identity under the British. 2. Ed. Darshan Singh. Western Image of the Sikh Religion: A Source Book. New Delhi: NBO, 1999. A collection of accounts by westerners ranging from those in the late 1700s to 1914. Remarks on early Sikh identity can be found. 3. Fox, Richard G. Lions of the Punjab: Culture in the Making. Berkeley and Los Angeles, 1985. Fox's theory that Khalsa identity was arbitrarily chosen from a melieu of identities by the British will be examined by my essay. He also looks at the gurdwara reform movement. 4. Gandhi, S.S. Sikhs in the Eighteenth Century. Amritsar: Singh Brothers, 1999 This book is useful in identifying factors which resulted in the dilution of Sikh identity later in the 18th C. 5. Ganguly R. & Taras, R.C. "Ethnic conflict on the World Stage" in Ganguly & Taras Understanding Ethnic Conflict Used for defining "identity" and applying to early Sikhs. 6. Ed. Grewal, J.S. & Habib, Irfan. Sikh History from Persian Sources. Delhi: Tulika, 2001. Collection of Persian sources of Sikh history. Sources are all non Sikh. The most important work in the collection is Dabistan Mazahib which is an early essay on the Sikh faith, written in 1645/46. It clearly identifies Sikhs as distinct from other communities in terms of beliefs if not appearance. 7. Grewal, J.S. Contesting Interpretations of Sikh Tradition. Delhi: Manohar, 1998 Grewal attempts to address recent issues in Sikh scholarship, including a discussion of Oberoi's work. This is a fair and unemotional assessment of all recent scholarship. 8. Grewal, J.S. Sikhs of the Punjab. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1990. A general overview of the history of the Sikhs. Useful for background information. 9. Gurdas, Bhai. Varan. Trans. Jodh Singh. New Delhi: Vision and Venture Press, 1998. The vaaraan are useful in identifying early Sikh lifestyles and Sikh practices, in the time of the first 6 Gurus. 10. Ed. Mann, Jasbir Singh et. Al. Invasion of Religious Boundaries. Vancouver: Canadian Sikh Study & Teaching Society, 1995 A collection of essays by Sikh academics and others who react mainly to Oberoi's work. This is a mixture of useful objective essays and those which are clearly emotional and not academic in nature. 11. McLeod, W.H. Who is a Sikh? Oxford: Oxford Press, 1989. A general overview of the question of Sikh identity but also makes certain stances such as the evolution of the Khalsa rehit took place over years and was not given by Guru Gobind Singh in it's entirety in 1699. Also acknowledges the multiplicity of Sikh identities by the 1800s and their legitimacy. 12. Nabha, Kahan Singh. "Sikhs We are not Hindus" trans. Jarnail Singh. Willowdale: Sikh Social & Educational Society, 1984 Good translation of the original, useful for quotations on differences between Hindus and Sikhs. 13. Oberoi, Harjot. "From Ritual to Counter-Ritual: Rethinking the Hindu-Sikh Question, 1884-1915 in Sikh History and Religion in the Twentieth Century, edited by J.T. O'Connell et.al, Delhi: Manohar, 1988 14. Oberoi, Harjot. The Construction of Religious Boundaries. Chicago: U of Chicago Press, 1994 Oberoi's work is the main motivating factor behind this essay and his views have been described in detail in the report, but overall belief is that Sikh identity did not have a distinctive form until it was given by the Singh Sabha. 15. Padam, Piara Singh. Panth Tay Panth Daa Vaalee. Patiala: Kalgeedhar Kalm Foundation. 1999 Historical records of the Khalsa and its principles. 16. Padam, Piara Singh. Rehitname. Chatter Singh Jeevan Singh printers, 5th Ed. 1991 This is a collection and critical assessment of rehitnamas. It evaluates the authenticity and time period of the rehitnamas. It is in Punjabi. 17. Rahi, Hakim Singh. Sri Guru Granth Sahib Discovered. Delhi: Motilal Barsdidass Publishers, 1999 This is a thematic selection of hymns from SGGS on various topics such as the Gurus on Hinduism, Islam, God, Ritual, etc. 18. Ganda Singh. Hukumnamay. Patiala: Punjabi University, 1985. This is a collection of authentic hukumnamas by Gurus and important Sikhs. 19. Gurtej Singh. Chakravuh. Chandigarh: Institute of Sikh Studies, 2000. This book contains a translation of the Amarnamah which gives a details on the Sikhs daily life practices and the death ritual of the Khalsa Sikhs. 20. Ed. Harbans Singh. The Encyclopaedia of Sikhism vol 1-4. Patiala: Punjabi University, 1998 Excellent resource on Sikhism. 21. Sulakhan Singh. Heterodoxy in the Sikh Tradition. Jalandhar: ABS Publications, 1999 Description of the Udasis and their sects.

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

ns · 03 Dec 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh Balpreet Singh Ji, very well written concise to the point. Santan Sikhi is prospering so well in the UK. Their leaders here like Niddar Singh and Parmjit Singh (author of the book Warrior Saints) are doing the duty in a professional way. Recently they have held lectures about Santan Sikhi all over the London Universities, they were done and advertised very professionally. I wonder if anyone went to them and put them on the spot, I to be honest have just got back from India and haven't had the time.Just imagine the influnece they are having on the youth in the UK. There is nothing to counter it, Taksal and AKJ are weak in their own internal division, Sikh missionary people are quite, don't know why. There needs to be a counter presentation of Sikhi as stated by yourself and it also needs to be done professionally. AKJ,BOSS,TAKSAL are great at having their own camps and rehansbahi programmes, kirtan programmes. But when it comes to working together collectively to put an unemotional case to people like Niddar Singh, Parmjit Singh than it's all nill. Something urgently needs to be done as I keep saying, we are sleeping away.. I have seen the adverisement of their lectures, they are sponsered by a big organisations like the London Metrepolitan Police. And let me tell you they are so clever in organising the right type of events for the youths.They know a wide variety condemn them for alchol, drugs etc.. and guess what ,these guys are plannig to set up a drug clinic /rehab units for the youth who have come under the influence of drugs...Has any other organisations such as Taksal,AKJ,BOSS,or anyone else even thought about this in the UK? I doubt very much. Sad state of affairs!! The above essay is great but what we need is people to go these Nihangs and challange them where ever they go and in every even they organise put them on the spot.

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

miss pink · 03 Dec 2004

why are they not sikhs also they are doing parchar we shuld also do parchar in universities but our sikhi is sumtimes 2 stict and boring

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

ns · 03 Dec 2004

Miss pink don't post if you dont' have anything valueable or constructive to add, look for something else other than Sikhism to give you spice and coulors to your life. Admin Jeeo, why does such gibberish get through ???

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

ms. blue · 03 Dec 2004

dear miss pink, i don't think anyone has said they aren't sikhs. where did you get that from? parchaar of a twisted new philosophy (snatanism) does not mean parchaar of sikhi is being done - quite the opposite is taking place. if you go research the type of parchaar they are doing you would be greatly disgusted, unless of course you are in the same mindset as them. im curious what is it about sikhi that seems to be so boring to you? i realize keeping a strict lifestyle may not appeal to everyone, but what exactly is it about sikhi that's 'boring'? [%sig%]

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

Singh · 03 Dec 2004

Balpreet Singh, I'm curious, what mark did you get on this essay? Its very well written by the way. [%sig%]

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

Balpreet Singh · 03 Dec 2004

The essay was sumbitted to Prof. J. T. O'Connel at the University of Toronto and he gave it a 95.

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 03 Dec 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh. CONGRATS veer Balpreet Singh ji. An essay after my own heart..IF it had been submitted to me..I would have given it...99% Straight A. Not being in the Uk I am not too much into what these Niddar singhs and co. are doing but going by their Warrior saints etc they are professional - no doubt about it. The way i see it..these OPPOSING forces have one thing in common....they are UNITED in DIVERSITY.... but we are DIVIDED even when UNITED !! Jarnail Singh.

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

Deep Singh · 04 Dec 2004

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh! Respected Balpreet Singh Ji, I had a wonderful time reading the paper. So what happened is (as foretold by Dasmesh Pita, Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji): Jabb Lagg Rahe Khalsa Nayara, Tabb Lagg Tej Deo Mein Sara Jabb Eh Gahe Bipran Ki Reet, Mein Na Karo In Ki Parteet (sorry for wrong spellings etc) Guru Sahib left the "Khalsa" when the Sikhs started following un-Sikh practices, and that ended in the defeat of the Sikh Kingdom. Sikhs lost two wars, and have never regained the control of their homeland. Bhul Chuk Maaf Ji

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

Babur Baig Mirza · 05 Dec 2004

Balpreet Singh Your essay has prooved the religions just divide humanity. Many thanks for re-enforcing my belief in this. Regards Babur [%sig%]

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

Deep Singh · 05 Dec 2004

I just found something that bothers me... You wrote: >> Anthony Smith when explaining the establishment of “ethnic identities” refers to six foundations of ethnic identity: a name for the group, belief of common ancestry, presence of historical memories, shared culture, attachment to a specific territory and a sense of common solidarity . These guidelines are useful in an examination of the early Sikh community to see the extent to which the Sikhs were a distinct ethnic group. << But, are Sikhs a distinct ethnic group or a distinct religion? I thought all the tribes [jatts, ramgarhia, rajputs etc] were ethnic groups, but Sikhs were and are a distinct religious group. I believe there is a difference between ethnicity and religion. Which of these groups do Sikhs as a whole belong to? Also, if Sikhs are an ethnic group, it would be hard to place Maharastari Sikhs in 'Sikh ethnic group' (at Hazoor Sahib, also Sikligar Sikhs etc), and also in modern times American-Sikhs, not to speak of African American Sikhs..... Bhul Chuk Maaf Ji, Deep Singh

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

Balpreet Singh · 05 Dec 2004

My use of Smith's definition of Ethnic Group was essentially used to show that Sikhs formed a separate group from the mainstream (Hindus). I obviously have not tried to show that it is based on blood-lines. It was an attempt to show that the community was unique, distinct and well defined.

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

Deep Singh · 05 Dec 2004

Babur Baig Mirza Ji, Your post made me start thinking... It is an 'accepted truth' in the modern world-view that religion divides humanity. Truth....but with some preconditions. Think of a situation where humanity has lost its face; religion ('dharm') arrives as a saviour. Think of a situation where humanity is already divided along ethnic/racial lines; religious communion ('sangat') revives the humanity in us. It has happened to me too many times. When i sit, talk and share my views with my fellows, mostly non-Sikhs, we arrive at similarities beyond the religious distinctions. How they have had their week, if they have experienced something that they wanted to share, if they feel they have come any closer to reality. These things go beyond the religious garb. But, let us imagine a situation where my fellow starts saying, 'oh friend, your religion is nothing but a simplification of past religions, what is so special in it?' I may or may not agree. At the end i have to start recalling differences, and we enter an atmosphere of tension and division. However, if my friend looks at me as an individual, as who i am, and what i have done...or what he has done...if we individually have come any closer to God...then we have a great conversation. We help each other, and sort out our tensions. The paper written by Balpreet Singh Ji is a reply to those who have already entered this discussion. They have glorified the past, without learning from it. And now, they want to illusionize the present without taking part in it. The present is bound to the past, but it has its own glory. What about the future.... In unity we see the differences, in division we seek the unity. Thus, the *face* is created. What is better? At the end it comes down to the individual, religions are social structures meant to strengthen the indvidual. The outcome lies beneath that *face*. [%sig%]

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 06 Dec 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. IMHO it is not "religions" per se that "divide" humanity.....it is the same old ECONOMICS.... the lands, the wealth, the women....language, customs.... Look at East pakistan West pakistan..SHACKELED together on the basis of RELIGION...and then look at what happend in 1970..what the Westarn pakis did to the women and children of their co-religionists in Bengal..even Animals dont do that to other animals.... the underlying FIGHT was about POWER/Land/property etc. A common religion failed to hold Pakistan's two halfs together...and in spite of that dismal failure the Muslim World keeps on stressing on the fight to "get Muslim kashmir" to join their co-religionists in pakistan..not a single other reason being given except ISLAM..but what the Pakistanis obvioulsy want is the LAND of KASHMIR ?? Why are the BIHARIS/UP BHAIYAS/MOHAJIRS etc that went to pakistan treated like DIRT ?? becasue they didnt bring any LAND...they came empty handed only with their " ISLAM "..a totally useless commodity in a land full to the brim with islam !! look closely and it is the SAME story everywhere..all around the world "religious minorities" ant separation/independence/ ?? why ? to OWN their own piece of FREE HOLD Territory thats why !! For this same reason can we the SIKHS live in peace in a Khalsitan we create ?? ( if we do)..Will the Jatt Sikhs give up their lands/share to their co religionist "XXX Sikhs" Will the "American Sikhs" moving to Amrtisar be accorded the same treatment as local Amrtisari Sikhs in Amrtisar ?? Will NEGRO SIKHS from Africa get to do the SEWA at harmandir sahib exactly the same as the locals who have been monopolising this for centuries and refused even to SIKH BIBIS ( their own wives and daughters !!) Look at Israel..ALL JEWS came to israel to make their HOME..BUT all "jews" are not "equal" there....some are more equal than others...same old story everywhere else. The Communists in Russia claimed to treat everyone as equals...didnt happen....Khruschev was MORE EQUAL than old Russi Joe.there were "MORE EQUAL" rail coaches for the communist party officials, and the ordinary russians...although no such thing as First Class/second Class/Third Class was written on the coaches OUTSIDE as in the other countries !!! a mere eyewash !! Jarnail singh

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

A Singh · 07 Dec 2004

Dear Jarnail Singh Jee, "Gyani" Notwithstanding an informative and well meaning post (and a great concluding point), please could you refrain from refering to Pakistanis as "Pakis", this may well have been an oversight on your part, however in many part of Canada and the UK, this is a racially offensive term (meted out indiscriminately to all of South East Asian appearence, with Sikhs being "Pakis with towels on their heads"). Thanks, A Singh.

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

khalistani · 07 Dec 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! nothing except man divides itself religion does not devide man man divides man think bout it did guru je tell us to hate hindus so we shud all be blonde, blue eyes, etc. doesnt our race divide us then too? wat bout eye colour we shud think before talking all shall be proven after death, or here before death if u are blessed with vaheguru worship bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 07 Dec 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. " In Malaysia "Paki" is from Pakistan ( orang Pakistan) and "Indi" is from India (orang India) "Nepali" orang gurkha is from Nepal.. and we Sikhs are often referred to as Bai ( Bhai) Orang Bai !! No body takes offense. Before the "Banglas" ( orang Bangladesh) came along in their hundreds of thousands, everybody from the Subcontinent was called "Bengali"...even the White Portugese were called White Bengali because of their beards.. In this region there is no such thing as you implied on the word paki..and we have a lot of them who visit our gurdwaras every sunday to have free langgar/punjabi food which they cant get elsewhere. However I do know that in your area of the world such racilist terms do exist. I hope in time they disappear. Jarnail singh PS. I sense a deep sense of "resentment" in the way you put the word GYANI in QUOTES behind my name in your reply !! Its just a academic word You wouldnt treat a DR. Jarnail Singh..the same way would you ( Jarnail Singh Jee, "DR" or write - Jarnail singh jee , "SANT" ?? I have never seen anyone being written to that way.....maybe the paki thing is really bad over there it spills out into more things than one. Bhul Chuk maaf if i am wrong.

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

A Singh · 08 Dec 2004

Dear Jarnail Singh Jee "Gyani", Thanks for coming back to me and clarifying matters from your side. Indeed the term 'paki' does still retain a generic racist context here in Canada as well as in the UK. Perhaps, given the international nature of this forum, it's best we avoid this term. As per the use of "Gyani", Bhai Sahib, as you may have seen elsewhere, I will either refer to you as Gyani Jee or here punctuate the word "Gyani" so as to identify you from anyother Jarnail Singh -no resentment on my part, in fact I'm glad you use this title, as it certainly helps take away from the generic sense in which Gyani is abused these days (i.e. most people think of Gyani's as being simpletons and uneducated), given your writing style and arguments, this does help change this misconception.

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

10th regiment · 08 Dec 2004

good essay

Just bumping this thread...

jagroop singh · 08 Dec 2004

to keep it alive so everyone can read it - especially our 'Sanaatan-inspired' brothers...

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

A Singh · 09 Dec 2004

Balpreet Singh, Good to see a decent attempt to challenge the issues raised and claimed by the Sanatan Sikhs to put forth their ideologies rather than the previous ramblings with the immature website of dolls, which only went to further prove some of their accusations concerning the inability of Sikhs today to assess their claims. Whilst I like your points, an issue I do have with your essay is that the references seem to largey taken from modern era sources (I do note the use of Piara Singh Padam's rehitnamas and other secondary sources refering back to traditional one's), the majority of your source do appear to be post 1980s. I have the same issue with many of the existing material on the Sanatan Sikh websites in that their source material does not go all the way back to the likes of the initial contemporary sources, however they have used many earlier sources than those you have brought forward in your assessment, so it would be worthwhile for any future expansion (by yourself or anyone else continuing from where you have started) to look more into these as well. Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

avidya · 23 Feb 2005

WaheGuru ji Ka Khalsa WaheGuru ji Ki Fateh I only got round to writing my response to this last week. I've written a response to the first section. I shall add more when I get the time. Please have the maturity to understand this is the opinions and formulations of myself and no one else! A reply to Balpreet Singh’s Defining a Sikh essay part 1 I initially read your essay when you first put it up on Tapoban. It is well written, and a good essay for year 2 university. I raise here a few problems with both the conclusions drawn and the materials sited. This is part 1 on pages 1 to 7. 1) Firstly, I feel it is an oversimplification to box identity formation into three historical periods. This is stated matter of fact but on what grounds are you stating there such three clear historical periods of identity formation? Even a browse through the writings of Dr. Trilochan Singh (the translator of Autobiography of Bhai Randhir Singh as it turns out), points out that Guru Har Rai, Guru Tegh Bahadur and Guru Gobind Singh ji are the founders of 6 Udasi lineages (called Bakshishs rather than the char dhuan lineages created by Baba Gurditta). Where does this fall in this oversimplified three stage argument? 2) I am confused on what your argument is. At the top of the essay you have stated that the essay is an attempt to deny the plurality within Sikhi, yet your essay has only outlined in the introduction that it is arguing that modern Sikhi was not invented at the end of the 19th century. Most samprda scholars would 100% agree with this later point that it was not ALL invented in the late 19th century. Instead, aspects of Sikhi has been reinterpreted through skewered eyes. 3) The use of cultural theory on ethnic identity formation seems to be a poor choice for defining an emerging religious identity within a fixed geographical location. I cannot see how it is applicable to the issue at hand? I shall return to this later. 4) There is a failure (whether knowingly or not) to depict the broader picture of what was happening within medieval India at the time of early identity formation, which is a flaw with much of pseudo scholarship. Bhakti Sants established similar traditions in different parts of the country with similar rejections of identity labels, rituals, orthodoxy, etc. The Dadupanthis in Rajasthan, the Pranamis, the Kabirpanthis, Vallabhacharya not to mention the preceding bhagats from Sri Guru Granth Sahib itself were all challenging accepted orthodoxy in both Islam and Brahminism. Equally similar ideas were being presented across the board. Remember that Sufis also were frequently flirting with perceived heresy in rejecting sharia, such as the infamous case of Sarmad shaheed. Let us be clear on this point. To my understanding, there is a definite modification of practices that predate the historical origins of Sikhi (satsang, Naam bhakti, singing aarti, bhajan/kirtan, nishkaam seva, etc) but not a rejection as such. Likewise the Gurus assembled the devotees on occasions such as Divali, Holi, and Vaisakhi yet didn’t reject such occasions. It is not a revealed tradition that is like nothing before it. Instead it is a honing in, a purification, a clear vision, unbound by orthodoxy or ritual. Your mistake is that you are still writing within the context of clearly demarked and codified religious units. Your arguments are limited when placed in a historical contextualisation. 5) The Sanatanists as you see them, have not denied that there is a sikh identity as such, otherwise you and I would probably not be having this conversation. What traditional Sikhs reject is the reinterpretation as a revealed tradition, and the subsequent distortions of history and maryada made to facilitate such an understanding. 6) Now your sources. You place a great weight on the validity of the Dabistan as quoted here below; The writer of Dabistan was in contact with various Sikhs of his time and also claims to have known the sixth and seventh gurus personally, thus his account or Sikh identity is certainly reliable. If the Dabistan is as reliable as you make it out to be, you must by a consequence also accept other things stated in the Dabistan such as that Guru Hargobind decreed the eating of meat and hunting, that Guru Nanak ‘held the muslim rosary in his hand, and wore the sacred thread…offered prayers the Islamic style, and offered the gayatri and puja’. Furthermore, contrary to your claims, the Dabistan is actually for the most part evidence of the traditional understanding of the Gurus and Gurmat. Evidence is also there of a later textual practice of linking the Gurus themselves with puranic historical bhagats (a theme commonly found in later Sikh texts up to the late 19th century), such that Guru Nanak was said to be Raja Janak in a previous life according to those Sikhs the author of the Dabistan spoke to, and their explanation of this is linked to a story from Yog Vashishta quoted by Sikhs to the author. So on what grounds do you accept the first line of the Dabistan but no doubt believe these other statements are ‘misinformation or misunderstanding’? 7) The criterion on which ethnic identity is formed is not applicable here as mentioned earlier. You incorrectly conclude that by the time of Guru Hargobind they had met all criteria, yet a specific nationalist/punjab dialogue does not arise arguably until the existence of the Sikh Raj in the 19th century. Prior to this it is the Sikhs against the state (although the misaldar period is arguably important here). Punjab was a focus as either literal home of the Sikhs ancestors or the house of the Guru for Sikhs further a field in Dhakka, Afghanistan, eastern states of Assam, etc. As for shared culture, yes, taking on the social norms and roles within Indian society. Do remember that the Gurus themselves married within caste, and if anything were propagating a horizontal understanding of caste (rather than a vertical one). However, I could equally apply these ethnic criteria to star trek fans and argue that they are just as distinctive an ethnic/religious group, as they meet just as many of the criteria as early Sikhs do. 8) Charan amrit is the common form of diksha from the traditional guru-shishya discipleship in India, not a ‘separate form of initiation’ as you state.

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

bhopinder singh · 23 Feb 2005

GREAT WORK KHALSA JI EVEN BABA BUDHA JI STARTED AT EARLY AGE. so their is a precedent

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

Balpreet Singh · 23 Feb 2005

a reply to the reply. 1) I’m not sure how your first point is saying anything at all. The Udasis came into the Sikh fold with Baba Gurditta (a grihsti) becoming the head. After that, Udasis were Sikhs. A number of Sikhs were appointed or themselves became preachers of the Sikh faith and have been labeled “Udasis”. How does this at all contradict anything? To answer your question, this would fall clearly in the first period I outline. These are all events that are before the creation of the Khalsa. 2) I’m not sure you read the essay very closely. I’ve had it read by different scholars including Dr. Pashaura Singh and Dr. Mcleod. Dr. Mcleod did give me a written response to the essay but it did not include any of these points. My essay shows that a single Sikh identity (free of pluralism) is not a British creation. The Sikh Gurus created a Sikh identity and to call the Khalsa as one identity amongst many (that was chosen by the British to become the main identity) is not correct. 3) I’ve already made clear that my use of Smith’s characteristics was to show that the Sikhs were separate from the mainstream. They had their own way of life. 4) I’m a simple person. I’ve never fit very well into “academia” because I don’t like using big words to say little things. Unfortunately your point doesn’t make any sense to me. What I could grasp was your comment that Sikhs are just one of many groups who rebelled against the convention. Yes. Point being? Even then, I don’t think any group was as distinct as the Sikhs. The Sikhs did gather at common festival times, but the fact that they gathered together as Sikhs and with the Guru as opposed to joining in with others in the usual celebrations says something to me. They did not join the mainstream, they stayed apart. 5) This isn’t a point. It’s a statement, that I’ve tried to address in the essay. 6) I’ve never liked the “take it all or take none” approach. For some reason when I’ve argued with those pushing Santanism, they’ve always tried to insist on it. Dabistan is a generally accepted text. And I’ve put no special emphasis on it, in fact I’ve mentioned it last in the list of evidence. Guru Hargobind eating meat is plainly incorrect since his own hukumnamas forbid it. There is a community in the Shivalik hills near Naina Devi that maintain a Gurdwara. They say that Guru Hargobind Sahib came there and their forefathers suffered from disease. Guru Sahib forbid them from eating meat and fish and said they would be cured. Even today they believe that if anyone in their community eats fish or meat they fall sick again. Back to Dabistan. The line that you refer to about Guru Nanak performing Puja is in just one version and I don’t think is part of the original text. As for the comment on Sikhs saying Guru Sahib was Janak: lots of Sikhs you’ll meet today will say things that I don’t agree with. Dabistan still however paints the Sikhs as independent of the Hindus and not mixing with them. 7) I’m not sure you’ve read the passage carefully. I’ve used ethnic Identity only to show that Sikhs were separate and distinct as a group from the mainstream. That the Guru’s promoted or accepted even a horizontal caste system is to me blasphemy and just stupid to accept as a Sikh. I am a Sikh first and a “researcher” after. The Gurus may have married “in caste”, but their own bani says to not even ask about caste. Caste means nothing in Sikhi. If you are going to say it has a place, then I can label that as nothing but anti-Sikh. 8)Charan Amrit is not the standard initiation used. Shaving of the head and the thread are used but not Charan Amrit. I could be wrong, but please do let me know on what basis you have said it is common? I can think off the top of my head that in the book on Sadhus, even it labels the Udasi method of initiation (charan amrit still) as being unique.

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

avidya · 24 Feb 2005

Dear Balpreet, Thank you for the reply. It was very interesting and insightful to see how you responded to these issues, particularly since a number of the points you failed to see as in anyway important or proving anything. Here is an unordered response to your above points; 1. Yes, others have charanamrit for example the Kabirpanthis have an elaborate initiation including what is called 'charan amrit', the water of the mahant's washed feet. There are other examples also. 2. The 'cut and paste' approach to scriptual text is fine, however on what grounds do you choose to accept and choose to ignore certain aspects of the Dabistan? If you are to say 'Gurbani', then I agree, and I would argue that a more traditional understanding of Gurbani caters for these aspects better than a reformist understanding and hence can account for these issues that arise all too commonly in historical sources. In other words, the Dabistan is further testimony to the fact that if reformists continue to hack away at and view history and traditions based on certain fundamental assumptions that were not prevalent at the time of the Gurus, then in the name of cleansing it of suppossed outsider influence over time there will be even more confusion when it comes to reading such sources, and hence quite literally more non-gurmat behaviour. 3. The issue of caste is interesting. I hold caste of no value and never have, but how it is to be understood from original sources is interesting. Either they are all misguided and shouldn't be trusted, or it is more complex. I have developed my own answer to this that explains away the existence of caste sensibility in historical texts, and allows for a firm belief of absolute equality. I also have ideas on why this historically was the case. 4. I have no understanding of what snatanism is and reject it as being a purely modern construct. To my mind there is only pavittar sikhi and there is distorted sikhi. It is as real as 'Akhandkirtanijathaism'. 5. On the issue of painting the broader picture of what was happneing during the medieval period (I didn't think I was using big words in this part - identity formation is the biggest I can see)...your 'so what' means you didn't understand. Here it is again - you are talking about Sikhi as though existing in a vacuum, accompanied only by 'Hinduism' and 'Islam' and are pointing to similarities and differences raised by texts like the dabistan as markers of what you may choose to argue is a seperate new revealed tradition. What I am showing you is that the bhakti movement as a whole shows a similar rejection of idol worship, rejection of taking on religious labels, rejection of holding to any life rituals, of kirtan, of bhakti marg, of emphasis on naam - yet - and this is the reason why I posted it - these bhakti traditions did not hold themselves to be newly revealed traditions akin to semitic faiths like Islam and Christianity, they were instead trying to wake people up to realise that aatm is beyond labels, trying to get people to recognise truth in it's purest form devoid of sectarian influence. Hence we have kabir panthis, dadu panthis, nanak panthis historically. 6. Yes, I have read your ethnic identity point and I am simply saying that it doesn't apply as it is like myself applying mechanical engineering ideas to molecular research - one set of ideas is devised to explain something quite different (although related in the case of ethnic identity). My point is, it was a bad choice for comparison, as it is again looking at the reality through a skewed vision. 7. On the issue of Udasis the problem that arises, that you feel doesn't mean anything at all is really blindingly obvious when looking at your own response above. You have chosen to accept those early Udasis from bakshishaan lineages and those Udasis from the chaa dhuaan as 'sikhs' but I'm pretty certain that you would describe much of the practices that they themselves instituted and were accepted by the Gurus as 'anti-gurmat'! This either means that you take a line as is often the case these days of 'the early udasis were actually like I am now, but countless scholars since have changed their lifestyles and practices under brahmanic influence' or it means you need to reassess what it meant to be a 'Sikh' during that time. I shall work on the next section in due course.

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

Singhnee · 24 Feb 2005

hahahaha!

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

chandigarh campus · 24 Feb 2005

sanatanism is fairy tales. grab hold of any reseach, historical, scriptural, archeological. Sikhs are independant religion. If we take the sanatan belief as it is, then that means we accomodate older religions, then hinduism would also have to accomodate jewish religionm because it is much older. ancient egypt customs. but where are the top hats, the synagogues, the rabbis, pyramind culture, preserved by rss by hindus by ghandi ? why havent hindus preserved king pharos memory? yet sikhs are expected to follow and accept hindu ctustoms. Hinduism is not real. so what exactly do sanatanists want us to follow?

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

Balpreet Singh · 24 Feb 2005

1) You made charan amrit seem like the mainstream/common initiation ceremony. And now you’ve named the Kabir Panthis as the others. They aren’t that displaced from Guru Nanak as I believe Guru Nanak was Kabir’s Guru. At any rate, that’s another debate. Fact is that charn amrit is not the common initiation ceremony used. It's not common at all. 2) The part of Dabistan I have ignored, I already told you was only present in one of the versions and not in all of them. Now if someone was to ask a Sikh today about Sikhi, what would he say? Could everything he said be considered to be true? Dabistan’s writer cannot not know all things about history with certainty. But he can see the Sikh community in front of him and those comments (that they are a separate group) can be accepted as true because he’s an eye witness to it. 3) Ok. 4) Yes. I too have an idea of what is pure Sikhism. And I think we both know where we stand on this issue. 5) You wrote, “these bhakti traditions did not hold themselves to be newly revealed traditions akin to semitic faiths like Islam and Christianity” Great. They may not have. The sources I’ve cited, including Sikh and non Sikh sources, have shown that the Sikh were different in this regard and considered themselves to be separate and distinct. They were Sikhs and nothing else. I still don’t understand what point you’re trying to make here? I question whether you’ve actually read the essay. 6) You keep saying it’s a bad choice. How so? I’ve already said that the Sikhs met all conditions to be a distinct group. How does this not apply?? 7) I don’t think that the Udasis we see today are an accurate replication of the Udasis that were created by the Gurus. Udasi simply means a parcharak to me. Do you think the Gurus told them to revere Shiva and worship statues of Sri Chand? What makes you think that these practices we see today were instituted by the Gurus? The various Udasi groups do not share a common set of practices even. Let’s be straight. I have used many sources to show that the Sikh identity has always been well defined (please refute this if you can) using Bhai Gurdas and other sources. I have shown that Khalsa identity was the culmination of Sikh identity. What do you want to prove? That Sikhs were never really defined and a part of Hindu society? That the unique Sikh identity was the creation of the British who wanted segregated communities?

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

Singhnee · 24 Feb 2005

I apologise for above message(hahaha) under my name. Actually my son typed this message and posted it. He is very young he does not know any thing about message boards. He was watching me posting messages and in my absence he tried to do the same thing. Later he told me that he has written something to Balpreet Singh cause he likes him. Then I checked and found his silly message. Please ignore it.

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

avidya · 24 Feb 2005

WaheGuruji Ka Khalsa WaheGuruji Ki Fateh Balpreet ji, What am I trying to prove? Please don't take this badly my friend, but this typifies the general approach to intelligent discussion - McLeod, who you wrote to, sets out to analyse Sikh textual sources and is accused of being a 'Christian missionary' because he 'MUST have an agenda'. I set out countering your proposed 'reponse to Sanatanism' essay, and you ask me 'what am I trying to prove?'...my only agenda is to present Sikhi as it is. Who am I? I am hindu and not hindu, I am muslim and not muslim, I am christian and not christian, I am buddhist and not buddhist, I am zoroastrian and not zoroastrian...I am a Sikh who recognises the Truth in all and wishes to realise that eternal pure truth that has existed and will exist, whose only religion is truth. I know I'm on the wrong forum for such a mindset, but this is where your essay is posted! Your essay is your essay. You posted it as a response to your new construct, 'Sanatanism'. I am critiquing your essay. I am giving you a nice simple response and pointing out what I see as problems with your points. Now on this issue of Udasis...well by the same token, surely a muslim could argue that Guru Nanak was a muslim and that his modern day followers got it wrong. How would you set out to challenge that? By no doubt pointing to historical written material which all testifies that the Guru was certainly not a 'muslim' (although I see no problem with him being honoured as a peer for muslim followers). Now surely you would feel particularly frustrated at the ridiculousness of such an argument in light of historical texts and tradition? The same it is with your faintly ridiculous Udasi comment - ALL textual materials by both Udasis and non-Udasis, all oral tradition as well has always denoted them as having practices, dress and beliefs contrary to your above statement. Udasis preached gurmat always, they taught gurbani, but their practices and approaches differ very much from what you would accept as acceptable. A simple question for you to look into is why 'chaa dhuaan' and from where does this influence of having a dhuaan come from? If you understand that, then you will understand quite a lot about the mindset of the Udasin. I shall read the next section and respond to that part in due course.

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

Balpreet Singh · 24 Feb 2005

Avidya, I question your intentions because your points seem to be eloquently worded but have no foundation. Regarding the Udasis; I dont' claim to be an expert on them, but as per my knowledge, the chaar dhuaans pre-date Guru Hargobind Sahib and the bakhsheeshs are those Udasi lineages that claim to have been started after being accepted into the Sikh fold. That the earlier sects would use dhunees does not surprise me. Baba Sree Chand was an ascetic and probably took on those practices used by others like him. He was not a Sikh until the time of Guru Hargobind Sahib and the Udasis were rejected by the Panth. The earliest literature on the Udasis comes in the time of Raja Ranjit Singh which is well after the time we are studying and well after I've said Hindu influences were brought into the Sikh community. Sulakhan Singh on his book on the Udasis writes, "On the whole, an attempt in the later Udasi literature has been made to impose a cloak of unity on certain developments of their history of the earlier period, which were independent of one another. Neither founders of the dhuans nor those of the bakhshises of the 17th century had any conncection with one another." (21) He also says "There appears to have been no connection between teh avrious Sects or Orders of the Udasis" (37). The Udasis, in the absence of the Sikhs (who were being persecuted) took on a very Hindu outlook and now are essentially just like other Hindu Sadhus (with some Sikh influence still apparent). The Udasis we see today are NOT the Udasis of the times of the Gurus, nor can we say the Parcharaks who you labelling "Udasi" that were sent by the Gurus were anything even remotely like this. On a different note, please do explain why Bhai Gurdas insisted so much on independent Sikh identity and other observers also confirmed this?

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

avidya · 25 Feb 2005

Gurfateh Balpreet ji Your quoting Sulakhan Singh whose book, although useful for printing Santren's text at the back, is certainly written with his bias (the title itself 'Heterodoxy in Sikhism' gives that away). Now to your claim the earliest literture by Udasis arises at the time of maharaj Ranjit Singh. This really is testimony to the fact that you don't know what you are writing. Should I start making a list of the numerous writings of Baba Sri Chand, Baba Gurditta, the adi udasis, the bakshishaan and what about the references in gurbilas literature? Get yourself a copy of Piara Singh Padam's 'Sikh Samprdavali' and read up before making incorrect comments. Even if we are to accept his claim of a lack of unity among early Udasis, that doesn't in any sense alter what has been said earlier.

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

singh · 25 Feb 2005

Interesting debate. So Avidya, what's your response to the question Balpreet Singh asked you about Bhai Gurdas Jee?

Re: Sikh Identity: A Response to "Sanatanism"

aanjan · 09 Aug 2006

Avidya does not like to answer straight questions