Re: panj piarey
Balpreet Singh · 25 Jun 2003
I was reading Bhai Jodh Singh's book Soan ChiRee ChaRee GaiN and he writes that when he received amrit, the punj pyaaray did not enter the hall, but took off their cholay and entered as regular sangat. He makes a point of noting this quiet and inconspicuous entery.
In Baba Surjan Singh jee's article in the "history" section, he writes that once it was discussed in Bhai Sahib's time, on how long the Punj Pyaaray remain Punj Pyaaray and it was decided that once the final ardaas for the amrit sinchaar has taken place, then the punj pyaaray return to being just normal members of Khalsa sangat.
I'm not sure how this practice of the punj pyaaray coming into sangat with all new amritdhaarees started, but I don't think it's puraatan, and I'm not so sure it's a correct practice either. I think that the punj pyaaray remain punj pyaaray so long as they are involved in the amrit sinchaar, but I'm not sure what function it serves to come into sangat, unless they are to do further seva like laying foundation stone, etc. Otherwise, once the amrit sinchaar is completed, they are just regular Sangat. I could be wrong...
Re: panj piarey
Jarnail Singh "Arshi" · 25 Jun 2003
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
IMHO, the Panj Piyaras and the newly joined Amritdharees in their new ROOP going into the Sangat and Matha Taking to Sri Guru garnth sahib Jee may be done to INSPIRE any others sitting in the sangat to join in the next Amrit Sanchaar.........
After all when Guru Gobind Singh Ji performed the First ever Amrit Sanchhar Ceremony in 1699 at Keshgarh sahib Anandpur Sahib, the PANJ PIYARAS were PARADED in front of the Thousands of Sangat ......... AND GURU JI KNELT in front of them IN FRONT of the SANGAT and took Amrit from them.
This is still VALID TODAY......Amrit Sanchaar Ceremony is PRIVATE so that it may not be unduly Disturbed/interrupted...but then the Panj Piayaras are NOT ONLY for the specific Amrit sanchaar Ceremony ONLY... they REMAIN Panj Piyaras until they decide to take of their cholas and rejoin the ordinary Sikhs sangat...when they do it not up to anyone but themselves.
IMHO this PARADE of the Panj iyaras and their AmritDharies in front of the Sangat is a POSITIVE thing ( I was always INSPIRED by their regal looking presence and finally took the decision to have Amrit when I saw another such Amrit Sanchaar ceremony....)
Dassan daas Jarnail singh
Re: panj piarey
Manjit Singh · 25 Jun 2003
Bhai Jarnail Singh "Arshi" Ji wrote:
>>>After all when Guru Gobind Singh Ji performed the First ever Amrit Sanchhar Ceremony in 1699 at Keshgarh sahib Anandpur Sahib, the PANJ PIYARAS were PARADED in front of the Thousands of Sangat ......... AND GURU JI KNELT in front of them IN FRONT of the SANGAT and took Amrit from them.<<<
I think the first Amrit sanchaar was done inside the tent(Tamboo) not outside in the public and that what the tent was all about.
As Bhai Balpreet Singh already written that Panj are Panj only until the final ardaas is done. Traditionally and historically Panj Piare's function is limited to only amrit sanchaar. For other function like laying foundation stone, Panj are/can be chosen but they are just Panj Singh do not carry the same authority as Panj Piare.
It may be inspiring if Panj come out in the sangat after amrit sanchaar but it may have other draw backs like, some people start considering/treating those singhs in a different way as they are still from Panj.
PANCH PARVAAN PANCH PARDHAAN
kulpreetsingh · 25 Jun 2003
VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAA
VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!!!
panch parvaan
panch pardhaan
panchay paavehi dargehi maan
panchay sohae dar raajan
panchaa kaa gur ayk dhiaan
Gurupyaree saadh sangat jeeo
in my humble opinion the punj pyare are the physical suroop of the Guru however, as we had discussed on akj.org (or maybe it was tapoban.org) the Guru Granth Sahib is always the parthakh pooran akaal guroo, and always higher.
This is why, even when the Punj Pyare come into the deevan of Dhan Dhan Maharaaj Guru Granth Sahib Jee, the sangat does not bow to them, but respectfully stands. The Punj pyare does not singh "Dhan Punj Pyare" but sings gurbani.
For example, when Guru Gobind Singh jee had mercy upon me and blessed me with learning naam drir at the Vancouver smagam this spring, afterwards all of the people who received naam and the one abhilaakhee who became a Singh, joined in the sangat with the Punj Pyare and the Punj Pyare sang:
"sur nar mun jan anmrith khojday su amrit gur thay paaiaa
paaiaa anmrith gur kirpaa keenee sachaa man vasaaia
jee janth sab thud upaa-ae eik vaykh parsann aaiaa
labh lobh ahankaar chookaa satgur bhalaa paaiaa
kahai nanak jis nu aap thutaa thin amrith gur thay paaiaa"
(the sachee baanee of Guru Granth Sahib)
in any case the point being I don't think you should say that the Punj Pyare are not Punj Pyare after the amrit sanchar.
Some punj pyare could not even be Punj Pyare IN THE AMRIT SANCHAR because they are jhootay, pakhandee Sikhs. However let's not even consider the horrible situations where poor misguided abhilaakhees receive khande-ke-pahul from politically-corrupted non-rehitdharee just-for-show jhootay pakhandee Sikhs.
What we are talking about is five pooran rehitdharee gurmukh Khalsas (which are very rare). Those five pooran rehitdharee gurmukh Khalsas are Guru suroop whenever and wherever they are in bana, together.
Just like a Khalsa does not stop being a Khalsa from certain hours of the night, five pooran rehitdharee gurmukh PAKKAY full-fledged real honourable truthful complete absolute stainless KHALSAS are the punj pyare wherever they go.
bhul chuk maaf karnaa - please correct me where applicable
guru dee kirpaa naal may we have bibek budhee
stay in chardeekalaa jee,
VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAA
VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!!
Re: panj piarey
Gurmukh Singh · 25 Jun 2003
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
I just have one question. When Panj Pyare enter the main hall why does the sangat need to stand and stop kirtan. I mean Sangat is sitting in the Hazoori of Guru Granth Sahib Ji and no matter whoever comes no one is supposed to stand. This is what I have read in Rehat Maryada. I remember reading that one time Sant Sundar SIngh Ji Khalsa Bhindranwale was doing Kirtan and Guru Gobind Singh Ji appeared in Sangat and put His hand on Sant Ji's head and sat down to listen Kirtan but Sant Ji didn't stand up even then. We are sitting in the presense of Saccha Patshah, Jahra Jahoor, Juggo Jug Attal the greatest of all Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji and no one is greater than Guru Ji so why stand. I thik Panj Payre should come in the main hall but no one should stand and kirtan should not be stopped. Some Ragis leave the Shabad in half and Panj Pyare starts doing Kirtan without finishing the other one. I think this is disrespect. Panj Pyare are roop of Guru Ji but this is so because of Guru Ji. Guru Ji said that "Khalsa Mero Roop Hai Khaas" so one who said it must be greater. Guru Ji is already there so why stand? Sitting does not make it disrespect because we are sitting in Sangat in presense of Guru Sahib Ji. Let me know if I am wrong.
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: panj piarey
Jarnail Singh "Arshi" · 26 Jun 2003
Waheguru Ji Ka Khlasa
waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
This is the first I am hearing of sangat in the Guru's darbar standing up to welcome the Panj piyarae......and the Punj Piyarae taking over the kirtan half way...etc etc.
IMHO this is all wrong. In all my life in Malaysia I have NOT seen this at all. All the Panj Piyare do is LEAD the way into the Darbar Sahib, stand in a line and all the Newly joined Amritdhariees join them and then they all MATHA TEK to Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee and Do a parkarma and go out one of the side doors... the KIRTAN goes on as normal, the Sangat is seated as Normal.
And you are RIGHT.... the Panj Piyaraes are panj piyares ALL the TIME....as EACH one of US should ASPIRE to be all the time.....If we can be KHALSA all the TIme why should the Punj Piyare be "temporary". IMHO their "DUTY" at Amrit sanchaar is Temporary.
Secondly it is a TOTAL FOLLY on our part to "judge" a Panj Piyara. When a person BECOMES one of the PANJ PIYARAE then he sheds his "normal" and BECOMES a Bhai Daya Singh...Bhai Dharam Singh...Bhai Mohkam Singh Ji etc
I am sure if we begin to SHANKAA on the "panj piyaras" private life.....EVEN GURU NANAK SAHIB JEE was called BHOOTNA, DIWANA..and many things...which PANJ PIYARA can SATISFY each and everyone in this world that eh is Pooran Gursikh???? If we go to Akal Takhat....some one will say...I "know" that panj piyara..he drinks at night.....that one is a golak chor...that one used to be womaniser...... if we go to ANYWHERE ELSE in this WORLD..there will be SOME ONE SOMEWHERE who will "know" such things about any Panj Piyara.......When the panj are chosen by the sangat and Sudhaee kar by the jathedar.....IMHO GURU JI HIMSELF is PRESENT in the Panj...they are NOT NORMAL but GURU ROOP and it is very stupid of anyone to see them as Normal people. SO PLEASE dont raise such issues and shankaas...NO ONE is MORE Panj than anyone else....the SAME GURU JI Is in EACH PANJ PIYARAS...whether they are at Akal takhat, Tapoban Sahib, Damdami Taksaal or a small village like Talhan or town in malaysia.
The Sangat ONLY gets up when a Different Saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib jee is brought into the darbar ( from some Gursikh's home for example). I have heard that even this should NOT be done because SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE is ALREADY seated on HIS THRONE and there is no need to stand up...by standing up for one sroop that is SAMAPATI the Entire sangat is DISRESPECTING the Saroop that is PARKASH and is in Attendance on the THRONE.
This brings me to another shankaa . I have seen some people come into the Darbar and MATHA TEK to all THREE or FIVE Saroops of Sri Guru Granth sahib Jee that are PARKASH one by one, then go to the BACK of the palki sahib and do the threesome/fivesome once again..... then Go to the Door of Sach Khand sahib and matha Tek to the Samapati sroops.....isnt this utter ritualism??? IMHO no matter how many sroops are PARKASH in the darbar sahib ( including many that are smapati in the Sachkhand sahib)...THERE IS ONLY ONE GURU on HIS THRONE and we MUST Matha Tek ONLY ONCE.
Dassan daass Jarnail singh
Re: panj piarey
Gurmukh Singh · 26 Jun 2003
well said singh ji. I have seen Sangat standing up in USA when Panj Pyare enter the hall with new Amritdharis. So I wanted to know why? I don't believe in it but I thought they might have a reason. Waheguru JI Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh