Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

SANATAN SIKH SHASTAR VIDIYA

SANATAN SIKH SHASTAR VIDIYA

Indy · 26 Jun 2003

SANATAN SIKH SHASTAR VIDIYA by Harjinder Singh 'the man in blue'. During the June 7 British Sikh Consultative Forum meeting in Walsall we were given a document written by Nihang Nidar Singh, a gatka teacher who calls himself a 'Sanatan Sikh Shastar Vidiya Gurdev'. It's main theme is that gatka has moved away from the original Sikh martial art. He is probably right, but he seems to have forgotten that even in the days of Maharaja Ranjit Singh the traditional way of fighting with sword, spear and bow and arrow, was on the way out. Modern gatka is a good method of learning coordination of movement and control over your body. Actual war is with modern weapons, not with traditional Nihang techniques. Chatka Gatka Ustad Nihang Nidar Singh seems to be confused about Sikhi. A few examples will show what I mean. He writes about a traditional pluralistic Sikhi consisting of Udasis, Seva Panthis, Nirmalas and Akali Nihang Singhs. Sikhi is not a narrow doctrinal religion. If you stick to the belief in One God, Guru Panth and Guru Granth, and follow the Reht Maryada, that will leave you a lot of freedom for your own individual religious experience. But Nidar Singh wants to include people in the panth who do not follow Guru's teachings. Udasis fought with Guru Gobind Singh against the Rajas and the Mughals, they looked after Gurdwaré, but they are not Sikhs. Nidar Singh contrasts this 'pluralistic' Sikhi with that of the 'British Raj accommodating' (or Angrez) Sikhs, who later developed into the Singh Sabha movement. In reality things were quite different. When the British Raj treated the Sikhs well, there was peace. At other times the Sikhs and the British disagreed, like in the time of the Singh Sabha movement, over who should control the historical Gurdwaré, and there was a serious conflict. Nidar Singh reminds me of some western scholars, who also deplore that the Sikhs moved away from the 'pluralistic' Hindu tradition under the influence of the Singh Sabha movement. Nidar Singh tries to divide the Khalsa in different ranks, based on military skills. Obviously if the Khalsa is doing building work, we will choose builders as our leaders, and when we are waging war, we will follow experienced warriors. But our Guru made farmers, tailors and traders into fighters, and he did not want to create a 'caste' of fighting men, or of builders for that matter. Do not forget that our war against injustice involves more than physical fighting. Our gatka 'Ustad' also favours celibacy, another Hindu tendency. Nidar Singh's gatka might be interesting, and I am in favour of other approaches than just the almost ballet type of gatka popular these days, but he does not know much about Sikhi ! Gurdwaré beware, do not let this person teach his un-Sikh ideas to the naujawan ! This column appeared in issue 71 of the Sikh Times

Re: SANATAN SIKH SHASTAR VIDIYA

NOT AMRITDHARI YET · 30 Jun 2003

SOME PEOPLE R USING THAT SHASTERVIDIA SITE AS INFO PROPAGANDA ON OTHER SITES TO CLAIM SIKHS R HINDUS..

Re: SANATAN SIKH SHASTAR VIDIYA

Bira Chahal · 24 Feb 2005

well the chief warrior of the uk got busted 2 times out of 3 by a 22 year old amritdhari wrestler from west london whos only been doin wrestling for 3 years. The chief warrior also feels paranoid and insecure about 2 of his students, former 3nd generation trainees of freestyler jo johal who has over 40 years combat experience. I hear the chief of buddah dal declares his fighting form to be the best. then why does he feel so worried about 2 youths? What makes him feel his form is the best? has he challanged every other martial art form in uk? the guy is crapping his whack of 2 youths, let alone their trainers, or the original trainer. What a shame the chief is scared of jo johal (a radaswami) and his students. An akali nihung jathedar of the uk is worried about a radaswami trainers fightng styles. Hahaha. I would like to see mr sharp tooth challenge jo johals boys and see who wins. He wont be able to stand against 3rd generation students, let alone the trainers or the man himself. There are plenty of people who do not go round boasting about their skills, strength, achievements bravery warriorism or go to colleges and unis holding demos to win support. Anyone can hold a kirpan, tegh jump up n down for an hour. I would like to see these new age nihungs face students or ex students of johals old club who train for hours, run barefoot for 2 miles on the streets, then fight the 5 best fighters, then the fight the trainers, then jump on the streets to fight skinheads on a friday night. So mr sharp tooth should not just make websites his form is the best and issue one challange then sit down and rest that pot belly. He should go up and down the country as the likes of jo johal did for decades and challange every nook and corner to a showdown and proove mr sharp tooth is the best or at least working towards it by developing. But that is not prooved sitting in his own house and asking for challanges at his own akharey when no one even knows him or his style. The facts are he would get mashed he knows it, hand on hand he wont be standing against many uk fighters. So instead of asking sikhs here to go to his akhara let us see how brave he is by challanging other martial artists , kickboxers, freetstylers, wrestlers, kabbadi boys openly at their own akharey. Common niddo give yourself some credit.

Re: SANATAN SIKH SHASTAR VIDIYA

Rocky · 24 Feb 2005

Finally someone of the 'older' generation has raised an opion against Nidar Singh! Better late than never. Now can someone in Coventry run this article down to Guru Nanak Parkash Gurdwara, Harnall Lane and show the committee. Maybe now they will stop Nidar Singh from having his akhara in a so called 'Sikh Fedaration' (more like Sleep Fedaration) run Gurdwara.

Re: SANATAN SIKH SHASTAR VIDIYA

Info!! · 24 Feb 2005

'Rocky' I dont think you will get much support from Harnall Lane Gurdwara. They are anti-AKJ as they come. Some of their youth will blantantly cuss AKJ to wannabe Amritdharis. Then they come to Rehnsbhais and act all that. But they should be made aware Jatha have known about the Anti-AKJ propaganda for years and basically decided to ignore them. Pity some Jatha youth also get conned by them. Why call them Sleep Federation they are ISYF, if the kettels black call it black!!! If you show the article to them be prepared to explain it as well, because they might not get the jist of it. [%sig%]

Re: SANATAN SIKH SHASTAR VIDIYA

kaur · 24 Feb 2005

what has anti- or pro-akj or anti- or pro-federation got to do with this. surely aren't we guru's sikhs? why create divisions in the panth? if u guys keep chatting like this, u're falling right into the trap of niddar - whose sole aim is to divide up panthic khalsa unity and chardikala the gursikhs examples whom we allegedly are trying to follow never called themselves akj, federation, etc., they just called themselves khalsa. we seriously need to get out of this mentality of associating ourselves with jathebandis. fine, we learn from ppl in a jatha who act together, but our ultimate allegiance belongs only to the khalsa raj karega khalsa

Re: SANATAN SIKH SHASTAR VIDIYA

A Singh · 24 Feb 2005

You are free to challenge the Gurdev of the Akhara, in this case Nihang Nidar Singh. It is simple, enter the Akhara and stand to the left hand side, as this is reserved for those who wish to challenge the Gurdev, if you win, then by marayda, you can take over and teach the akhara. Shastarvidiya was demonstrated to Krishna Godhania (one of the leading authorities on Filipino Martial Arts in the UK and Europe www.krishnagodhania). And further more, both masters compared their respective deadly arts. Krishna interviewed Nidar Singh and this was published in the a magazine called Martial Arts Illustrated last year. Krishna has also sponsered Nidar Singh's latest article on the traditional talvar. Which you can read in MAI latest march edition. If Krishna has recognised this deadly art, then why ignore this fact - ask Krishna what his opinion of Nidar Singh is? Here is a link to MAI: http://www.martialartsltd.co.uk/mai/latest.htm

Re: SANATAN SIKH SHASTAR VIDIYA

Lodhi · 25 Feb 2005

This will be the first and last message. If this teacher claims he/his system is undefeatable then the challenge is open to mr niddar singh/his students to come down to; Punjabi Centre, Ley Street, Ilford, Essex. Tuesdays Wednesdays or Fridays After 6pm. We also have space reserved for challanges contact ali/jag at our base, or if your teacher feels very confident he may ask for jo in which case a time slot will be allocated. Unfortunatly we have no time for propaganda/showmanship or wasting time on internet sites hence, appreciate your teacher's timely response please visit our centre direct on the time indicated. As this will be the last time I visit this site we look forward to seeing your teacher and his display. All the best , good luck :-) [%sig%]

Re: SANATAN SIKH SHASTAR VIDIYA

jugroop singh · 25 Feb 2005

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Veer 'A Singh' ji, i got a chance to read the interview a few months ago in MIA. i found it interesting aside from one thing; Niddar decided to, in a seemingly proactive and un-prodded manner, refer to 'terrorism in Punjab' in a blanket/generalised sense. The implications were that any non-Sikhs (i.e. over 99.9% of the readership) who may have had a passing awareness of the fact that there was a 'situation' in Punjab a few years ago involvong Sikhs, have now been left with the impression that the Sikhs involved were all terrorists who ran around with AK47's. my thoughts were: > Why did Niddar proactively, without seemingly any encouragement from the interviewer, decide to bring-up the complex and largely unrelated issue of 'terrorism in the Punjab' during this interview? >This is especially given the fact that he would have known that there would not be the possibility to go in depth into the issue? i.e. it is largely irrelevant given the subject matter. In my view, it was a complete cock-up and he should seriously 'review' his interview techniques... VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: SANATAN SIKH SHASTAR VIDIYA

Singh · 25 Feb 2005

WJKK WJKF. so basically some ppl at ilford have challenged Nihung Niddar Singh, well all i got to say why advertise it on the web, we not go to one of the akhara's whether in cranford or slough and challenge Nihung Niddar Singh?Indy wrote:

Re: SANATAN SIKH SHASTAR VIDIYA

kamal · 25 Feb 2005

I don't think the interview was by accident- he want's to portray the sikh masses as fanatics, so that his version of Sikhi is seen as more acceptable to westerners

Re: SANATAN SIKH SHASTAR VIDIYA

Anon · 25 Feb 2005

Niddar will now make an excuse like "I cant go to Essex" or "he has to come to me, its Maryada!" or "Internet challenges don't count" or perhaps "my dumalla is too loose". I can guarantee you this challenge will not be taken up. If Niddar is a true Fauji he will try but my feeling is he is not and this challenge will be swept aside and forgotten.

Re: SANATAN SIKH SHASTAR VIDIYA

BirRaas Singh · 25 Feb 2005

Is the use of shastar going to be allowed in this so called yudh, and is this essex yodha going to stipulate any "banned moves"? What next? get head guards? padded gloves? gumsheilds? lol If your not prepared to fight with weapons, sit back down your not real warriors

Re: SANATAN SIKH SHASTAR VIDIYA

. · 26 Feb 2005

"Bira Chahal Date: 02-24-05 06:35 well the chief warrior of the uk got busted 2 times out of 3 by a 22 year old amritdhari wrestler from west london whos only been doin wrestling for 3 years. " niddar sinh been doing shastervidia for what 17 years? How many actual competitions has he entered in the west? He did not turn up to the yudh contest in td and made up some excuses the rules were not good enough for him. he becomes a lion with few selected parties, but on a bigger scale i think he is scared of getting his chitter bashed and ruin the name he has built up.

Re: SANATAN SIKH SHASTAR VIDIYA

RavinderSingh · 26 Feb 2005

BirRaas Singh wrote: >Is the use of shastar going to be allowed in this so called yudh, and is this essex yodha going to stipulate any "banned moves"? What next? get head guards? padded gloves? gumsheilds? lol If your not prepared to fight with weapons, sit back down your not real warriors< Vaheguru gave us natural weapons first.. our body, hands, feet, elbows, knees etc. These r our weapons.. not heard of hand to hand fighting then?! The real warrior can also fight without shaster in his hands.. or do u only feel BirRas with a weapon in your hand?

Re: SANATAN SIKH SHASTAR VIDIYA

singhji · 26 Feb 2005

yo yo yo every1 wagwaan, is da whole world loosing it??!!!!! foundation of sikhi is tollernce, (cut a long story short story sikhs believe in something, hindhus disagree, hindhus go 2 golden temple hav an attack masses of sikhs die) on a smaller scale nihangs belive in summat others disagree decide 2 harass them (it does happen, verbally,physically the way they are treeted at camps and reansabhis an stuff) so they get harrased cus of there beliefs, samething happened in 1984, why do sikhs cry over 1984 but do the same thing 2 nihangs. sikhism believes in tollerance if u are a gursikh agree 2 disagree lets nihangs live theres u live yours, petty fighting and scool yard "cum 2 my yard staa me an my posse do u ovah) this is bull crap- no 1 will get no where, u hav all missed the point of sikhi-just let them be and if they wrong im sure dharam raaj will sort dem out if not what a waste of time u guys hav had crying all over the place. its like mughals if ure not muslim or hav disbelief in our ways we convert u or harass u- sikhs let ppl liv there lives if they wrong theyyl get punished. dont play the role of god, and concentrate on ur naam abiyaaasss or this cussing will not do u ne good. youve got a chance 2 break the cycle of life dont waste it arguin like 3 yr olds in nursery. FIX UP LOOK SHARP AKAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAALLLLL

Re: SANATAN SIKH SHASTAR VIDIYA

singh · 26 Feb 2005

singhji, did you actually stop for a few seconds and think before you posted? Tolerance? What are you going on about? Who's harrassing who? Who's been issuing challenges for several years now? Niddar. Who's been attacking and belittling every panthic group out there? Niddar and his band of nakli nihungs. People are simply responding to his attacks, which is natural. I find it strange that certain people (such as yourself) sit quietly by while these people carry out all sorts of attacks and propoganda, but as soon as somebody responds, you cry foul. A very principled stand that you have there.

Re: SANATAN SIKH SHASTAR VIDIYA

singhji · 27 Feb 2005

im sure if you look on the actual website it says the challenge is not out of ego but 2 take the khalsa panth a step further, if u beet him u take his place the brotherhood progresses, u have taken his challenge out of context. Niddar singh has never physically put down a panthic jatha just told his opinion which he is entitled to- or in sikhism are we not aloud 2 voice our opinions.

Re: SANATAN SIKH SHASTAR VIDIYA

Admin · 28 Feb 2005

This topic is now closed. Admin