Confused
Gurpreet Kaur · 01 Jul 2003
Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh
I have two questions.
1. Was the section 'Chritro-pakhyaan' from the Sri Dasam Granth Guru Ji's actual self-composed Bani? Or was it a translation of the ancient Vedic or Upanishads to reveal their true natures to the Sikhs still following Hindu scriptures?
2. Who wrote the real Rehit-naama? Was it one of the Guru's? Which one is the 'right' one to follow?
Many Thanks
Gurpreet Kaur
Gurfateh
Re: Confused
Kulbir Singh · 01 Jul 2003
Gurpreet Kaur wrote:
> 1. Was the section 'Chritro-pakhyaan' from the Sri Dasam
> Granth Guru Ji's actual self-composed Bani? Or was it a
> translation of the ancient Vedic or Upanishads to reveal their
> true natures to the Sikhs still following Hindu scriptures?
We should not discuss about the authenticity of Dasam Granth as it is against the hukamnama of Siri Akal Takhat.
I don't think Charito Pakhyaan is a translation of Upanishads. It is more like a collection of folk tales from different lands. Chandi Charitter and Chandi kee Vaar do seem like translations of Markande Puraan. Chaubees Avtaar seems like translation of Puraans like Sri Mad Bhaagwat Puraan. I have read that Puraan and the stories in that Puraan are very close to Chaubees Avtaar's Krishna Avtaar.
> 2. Who wrote the real Rehit-naama? Was it one of the Guru's?
> Which one is the 'right' one to follow?
The place of Rehitnaama's in Sikhi is same as Hadeeth have in Islam. Only those Rehits are good that are according to Gurbani. All Rehitnamas were written by Gursikhs but over time have been contaminated (per Pyaara Singh Padam).
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Confused
singh khalsa · 02 Jul 2003
1 quick question. what was the hukamnama passed by the Akal Takhat on the Dasam Granth. We are not allowed to question its authenticity? if this is true. its good because too many ppl question it.