mohinder singh
singh · 04 Jul 2003
i am confused. what is the status of mohinder singh ji? i heard he is back in the jatha and akal thakt accpeted his views. but no-one is saying anthign?
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
singh · 04 Jul 2003
i am confused. what is the status of mohinder singh ji? i heard he is back in the jatha and akal thakt accpeted his views. but no-one is saying anthign?guruvah · 04 Jul 2003
jee next time pls write:b. mohinder singh SDO.u c everyone knows him as SDO.yes i was thinkin about the same question.......GurroooVaaah · 05 Jul 2003
:| Dont confuse me with the Author: guruvah. my name is GurroooVaaah ..guruvah · 05 Jul 2003
I have SEEN HIS VCD!!!! IT'S AMAZINGGGGGGGG.channi jee is playing tabla, it is very old u c .if i am not wrong it is in the US.........by the way GuroooVaah u came after i started using this username........... :PGabroo Khalistan Dah · 05 Jul 2003
i'm confusedsingh · 07 Jul 2003
so what's the answer? and why no1 saying anyhting? btw where can i get the VCD?Kulbir Singh · 07 Jul 2003
I think SDO should get pesh in jatha too. He has been admitted back to panth but everyone in panth does not become member of jatha automatically. To be member of jatha again, I think he should get pesh in jatha and admit his mistakes of giving bad name to jatha. This is only my opinion. As for his kirtan, I could not care less that he is not here. Who wants his bhangra style kirtan? At least not me. Daas, Kulbir Singhr2d2 · 07 Jul 2003
Veer Kulbir Singh, I disagree with your opinion about SDO getting peshed in JATHA. This will only add to the opinion that AKJ believes it is somehow higher that Akhaal Takht. If Akal Takht has given him forgiveness then who are we to say any different? As for his kirtan....I guess that's just a personal opinion of what some people like and what other people like.Mkhalsa · 07 Jul 2003
the problem is.. after his "peshi" he went right back doing the same katha.. his website is even up with all new stuff. So waht was the point?kps · 07 Jul 2003
Veer Kulbir Singh jee, I also **strongly** disagree with your opinion about SDO getting peshed in the JATHA. I think real, proper Gursikhs should have reviewed SDO's peshi before allowing him into the panth. The same for others. Akal Takhat is not **at this time** reliable to govern the GURU KHALSA, it is not even reliable to speak on behalf of the GURU KHALSA. If the Akal Takhat can give Badal forgiveness - I don't know what's going on over there... Nonetheless... bhangra style kirtan have you heard Bhai Tejinderpal Singh Dulla jee? Bhai Manjit Singh jee? Dya Singh of Australia? All of the popular ragees? Who doesn't do keertan to catchy tunes? bhulaa chukaa dee khima bakhshnee VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAA VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!!! -daassingh · 08 Jul 2003
vir jees i herd the akal thakt punj piare had made hinm do pesh? and akal thakt print apologee lettrer in punjab time paper? i am confused re: banagra style kirtan becoz i herd the same toons and same shahbads singed by other ppl? is it not guroo maaraj banee no matter who singed it? i woz kinda led to think sdo woz doing kirtan at akj ranesbai? can some1 explane if only painchain accpeted sdo? [%sig%]nama · 09 Jul 2003
sum of the akj(uk) singho from nottingham waz witj sdo & now tehy stuck cos they not go for peashi. it a v.big loss only nam. [%sig%]Kaur · 09 Jul 2003
whaiguru jee kaa kahlsa whaiguru jee kee fathe we no who these singhs r & they r not welcomed at ur functions & every1 with 'roti ~ beti' naata needs to be peshed to make sure! whaiguru jee kaa kahlsa whaiguru jee kee fathekps · 09 Jul 2003
Dear Sangat, Bhainjee "Kaur" has mentioned something which triggered a thought. The punj told me the same thing about "roti - beti" relations... Can somebody please give me a link to the exact written bani of Guru Gobind Singh that explicitly says "Gursikh dee roti beti dee saanj Gursikh naal" ?? Or anything along those lines? Is it truly Guru's hukam or something "made up" by the Jatha Please don't give me your opinion - give me the actual written gurbani and/or actual written rehitnama. Please dont' type it out - give me the link to the scanned copy .. or give me the address of the place I could obtain it. thanks -daas VAAHEGUROOJEEKAKHAALSAA VAAHEGUROOJEEKEFATHEH !!!ninda? :( · 09 Jul 2003
Nottingham Singhs are the reason that SDO peshed, I think labelling them as SDO followers is wrong. How else were they going to bring him back to sikhi to get him to stop? they are the ones that infiltrated and did it through pyaar and it worked. So why should we start attacking them? there are many singhs that have done similar things in the past, but everytime they are misunderstood and outcast. This is sad...Kaur · 10 Jul 2003
whaiguru jee kaa kahlsa whaiguru jee kee fathe ninda? :( wrote: > Nottingham Singhs are the reason that SDO peshed, I think > labelling them as SDO followers is wrong. y they get SDO pesh then? they followers thats y! > > How else were they going to bring him back to sikhi to get > him to stop? but when did he stop? > they are the ones that infiltrated and did it > through pyaar and it worked. no it didnt! > So why should we start attacking > them? there are many singhs that have done similar things in > the past, but everytime they are misunderstood and outcast. > This is sad... cannot compare with purtan singh. whaiguru jee kaa kahlsa whaiguru jee kee fathe [%sig%]Daas · 10 Jul 2003
Is that why there is a video of them sitting with him singing all his messed up stuff ?? don't kid urself they went there to get him peshed!!!, they went cus they couldn't let go of him !!! and he confused them more than they know !!! why did they continously request meetings to discuss his galat vichaar against gurmat ???? only when he was peshed did they admit their guilt and the fact they had gone against the hukamnama of roti behti de saanj ??? their are many gala which could be put up but don't try and fool the sangat with "Nottingham Singhs are the reason that SDO peshed, I think labelling them as SDO followers is wrong" hopefully they have understood their galatee and can move on. Far as SDO is concerned I cannot understand what the Akal Takhat have done in this case, his site is running, he has continous jormehla going on, wheter or not he is doing his galat parchar I don't know cus now his site doesn't label with the correct dates. We really need detroit sangat to investigate and present proof on the matter as he is based there. It is sad that a majority of people couldn't say he was galat maybe that would have made him realise his bhul earlier (indeed if he has now). I do agree that before he does kirtan in any AKJ smagam he does need to get peshed from AKJ India as they were the first ones to chuck him out or ban him due to his galat parchar. We shouldn't continue to make mistakes of the past and cover up what is wrong.KS · 10 Jul 2003
If anyone has been accepted by Akal Takht Sahib then why is there any debate ? The word of the Akal Takht Sahib is from God himself.Khalsa Soulja · 10 Jul 2003
Seems to me that SDO was a AKJ creation and remains a ''problem'' only to the AKJ ? No-one else in the WWW has any problem with him or have heard of him. Can some learned person please explain why is there so much controversy ? [%sig%]r2d2 · 10 Jul 2003
"roti behti de saanj" ..explain. What does this mean?kps · 10 Jul 2003
to answer r2d2's quesiton roti beti dee saanj means that a gursikh should only eat from a gursikh, and a gursikh should only give his daughter in marriage to a gursikh i highly doubt the guru EVER said this because the guru would have said roti, beta, beti dee sanj why not marry your SON to a gursikh? why not marry your SELF to a gursikh? some "jathedar" probably wrote this in poetic form in one of his "granths" or an unverifiable "rehitnama" and it has become accepted in the jatha as "guru's hukam" although it probably was never written by Guru gobind Singh I humbly request anybody to provide proof (a scanned picture or a link to a scanned picture or the address of a place where the hard copy can be obtained) Any hukamnama by Guru Gobind Singh jee that says that? Please provide. bhul chuk maaf karnaa -daas VAAHEGUROOJEEKAKHAALSAA VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!!Ranjit Singh · 10 Jul 2003
KPS, I don't have the proof you're looking for, but I think you're mistaken when you keep saying that this is a 'jatha' thing. 'Roti beti dee saanj' is a term widely used throughout the panth. Check hukamnamay from the Akaal Takht that were issued to throw anybody out of the panth. I'm pretty sure they usually mention not doing 'roti beti dee saanj' with these people. It's a fairly common phrase in the panth. Actually, I've heard it used more often outside the jatha than within.Balpreet Singh · 10 Jul 2003
KPS, This concept of being politically correct didnt' exist at the times of the gurus. I feel totally comfortable with the term "roti-beti dee sanjh". Adding "beta", etc. would be done in present times as assurance that Sikhi is indeed egalitarian. Gurmat and Sikhs of the past didn't have such issues. Egalitarianism wasn't something they felt insecure about or needed to prove: it was a reality. In the puraatan document "40 Rehitnamiyaa(n) Dee Saar" found in the book "Khalsa Panth Day Rehitnaamay" published by Chatar Singh/Jeevan Singh on pg. 45, the hukum is written "Vahiguru jee daa Khalsa, Khalsa jee noo(n) hee Kanyaa Dayvay" meaning the Khalsa should only give it's women to other Khalsa. The Bhai Daya Singh rehitnama, on pg. 30 of this book says "Sikh ko Sikh putree daiee, sudha suhda mil jai. Daiee BhaadaNee ko sutaa, aih mukh amee choiaai" meaning "A Sikh should give a daughter to a Sikh. If she is given to a Mona, it is like putting amrit into the mouth of a snake" As for roti dee sanjh: read the bibek article in Gurmat section for relevant quotes. A lot of things and terms common among Sikhs today are from an oral tradition. You won't find Guru Gobind Singh jee's writings covering a lot of topics ie. 5 Kakaars, gurmantar, etc. So asking for "quotes" is really a western approach to studying Sikhi. Roti-Beti dee saanjh is a common term used in all jathebandees, and indicates all social relations should be kept within the Khalsa and other Sikhs. Hope that helps.huh? · 10 Jul 2003
"Dass", what do you mean "his site doesn't label with the correct dates"? I happened to run into the site yesterday and it has dates??kps · 10 Jul 2003
Balpreet Singh veerjee, VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAA VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!! I don't think it's a western approach to ask for "quotes" I don't think the "western" approach to certian things is wrong, afterall Sikhi approaches the universe from all angles - there are four doors to the harimandir sahib - and Sikhi united the four castes Furthermore, Guru Ram Das made clear "bani guru, guru hai bani, vich bani amrit saarai" and Guru Amar Das made clear "satgur bina hor kachee hai baanee" So I cannot accept - at least at this point - unverified rehitnamas for guidance of my Sikh rehit I would rather - at least at this point - go by Guru Gobind Singh jee's writings, Bhai Gurdas jee's writings, Bhai Nand Lal jee's writings and the Guru Granth Sahib - all of which are the absolute truth. The vaars (Bhai Gurdas, Bhai Nand Lal) may not be Guru's bani but are considered, and have been since the time they were written, the key to Guru Granth Sahib and to Sikhi. bhul chuk maaf karnaa daasMkhalsa · 10 Jul 2003
Kulpreet Singh, veer jee, bhai sahib, pyareo... by the same token.. who verified Guru Granth Sahib Jee?? Were you there? did you watch guru sahib write every akhar of dhur kee bani?? is that the only way something is verified for you? why do you beleive in guru sahib if you havent verified it yourself? what about dasam granth, surely you know the history behind that, how is that verified wehn the granth as a whole was compiled later? some things are a matter of faith, and trust.. religion isnt science.. stop worrying aobut everything and take things at face value.ninda? :( · 10 Jul 2003
>>>y they get SDO pesh then? they followers thats y!<<<< no thats not why.. please stop assuming if you do not know what truly went on... they wanted SDO to stop his wrong parchar, that is a noble cause. Its not because they followed him. Think about how many peoples sikhi they saved (or could have saved) if they got or get him to stop?? even if he was ex communicated, people still followed him.. best thing was for him to admit he was wrong and denounce what he said... through his peshi.. please look at the larger picture!Balpreet Singh · 10 Jul 2003
KPS, You say that Guru Granth Sahib is your Guru, and you want quotes from BaaNee or from Bhai Nand Lal or Bhai Gurdas on this issue. You're forgetting a major source of guidance: Guru Khalsa Panth. Rehit is something that we are told by the Punj Pyaaray when they are in Guru Form. Rehit was something oral. Even written rehitnamas like the Bhai Desa Singh one, says in the seventh stanza , “that rehit which the five utter, keep that steadfast in your mind” and later in the ninth stanza“ that is the first rehit, the one which the five Singhs said in the Paahul ceremony. The other different rehits which are spoken of, that is which I will go on to explain ”. Clearly the written rehit is secondary to the one which was orally given by the Punj Pyaaray. I repeat: you will not find mention of kakaars, nitnem baaNees, and many other smaller rehits in the baaNee of Guru Gobind Singh jee or SGGS. Rehit is an oral tradition passed down from amrit sinchaar to abhilkaakhee who then him/herself goes and repeats the rehit if in position of Punj pyaaray. Looking for quotes on all rehits is a futile enterprise. To get rehit, we have to go to Guru Panth, which gives rehit as Punj Pyaaray at amrit sinchaar. The only issue is to find pooran rehitvaan Khalsa who will give this updesh, and in this day and age, I admit it can be difficult. But EVERY punj pyaaray jatha will say "sikh dee roti beti dee sanjh Sikh naal".? · 10 Jul 2003
wow, i didn't know sikhs "give away" their daughters!!!! i thought sikhs were different, believing in equality and the exact same rules for men and women.!! if it says beti then why not beta? even according to the akaal takht, it says "a sikhs daughter must marry a sikh" - but why can a sikh man marry whoever he damnwell wants to? i thought we (women) were persecuted and treated like property in all other religions, but sometimes it seems like sikhism is likewise.Mkhalsa · 10 Jul 2003
The published Akal Takht Rehat Maryada of 1912 talks about sarbloh bibek and how to keep it and that it should be kept. If you want a quote thats probably the best source, I beleive that some singhs in vancouver have copies (WHICH SOMEONE IS SUPPOSED TO SEND ME *HINT HINT SINGHO*).Kulbir Singh · 10 Jul 2003
>>>>>>> wow, i didn't know sikhs "give away" their daughters!!!! i thought sikhs were different, believing in equality and the exact same rules for men and women.!! if it says beti then why not beta? >>>>>>>> You should understand the real meaning behind this statement. Who says "give away". You can't translate the pankiti of rehitnama literally and then make a big deal out of it. "beti deni" or "kaniya deni" simply means that a Gursikh should not marry his daughter to a non-Gursikh. In countries like Canada, if a daughter is infected with the terrible disease of Western thought, then she probably will not give her gursikh dad a chance to do so and would get married herself. If one's daughter is such, then there is no blaming on a Gursikh. A Gursikh daughter, follows the wishes of her parents and elder Gursikhs in important decisions like marriage. Of course Gursikh parents too would consult their daughter in case of marriage. >>>>>> even according to the akaal takht, it says "a sikhs daughter must marry a sikh" - but why can a sikh man marry whoever he damnwell wants to? >>>>>> Who says that a Sikh man can marry anyone? Don't derive literal meanings of Punjabi statements. >>>> i thought we (women) were persecuted and treated like property in all other religions, but sometimes it seems like sikhism is likewise. >>>>>> It may be done in Punjabi culture but not in Sikhi culture. Daas, Kulbir Singhkaur · 11 Jul 2003
ninda? wrote : > they wanted SDO to stop his wrong parchar, that is a noble cause. > Its not because they followed him. y they r in the video with sdo ? y they not stop sdo then if he doing "wrong parchar" ?Sevak · 11 Jul 2003
Regarding Bhai Mohinder Singh SDO, my 'benti' is that we should extend 'daya' to our own mankind as well as we do to animals. If we can't "forgive" then life will be full of 'vair' and 'virod'. [%sig%]What ? · 11 Jul 2003
"If we can't "forgive" then life will be full of 'vair' and 'virod'." I think the above is somewhat misleading, mainly because we humans are no one to forgive anyone, guru ji will decide on ones karams if this SDO's karams are marea then he will be punished, if yours or mines are marea we will be punished simple as that. I really think some people should come out of the illusion that SDO was a jatha problem, if he was a jatha problem than panth would have not kicked him out, what he was saying was on the same level as (admin-cut) kala afghana, and if he is still saying the same thing he should get chucked out again !!!!maanas · 11 Jul 2003
I am hearing lot of vauge discussion about Bhai mohinder singh. Can some tell specifically what he said lately (after coming from Akal takhat) against gurmat (gurbani)?? · 12 Jul 2003
oh and btw, i was implying men can marry who they want because the rehat maryada says that a sikh's daughter must marry a sikh, but it says nothing about a sikh's son.. this was further verified when i read the english version of the maryada and it said the exact thing tht was stated above.cheque please · 12 Jul 2003
sdo and nottingham singh ( and some sangat too ) like "goorh" ( treacle ) and "maaki" ( fly ) situation.curious · 12 Jul 2003
Who is Mohinder Singh, pls explain, thank you.Jarnail Singh "Arshi" · 13 Jul 2003
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. IMHO is this guy so important to have the MOST mails on this message board...even more than important questiuons on Rehat etc. ? I wonder ????? who he is as I havent even heard of him. Forgive me for my ignorance. I also heard he ahs a website where he strays from gurmat ?? Has he. If he has I would like to have the URL to go have a look myself. Dassan Daas Jarnail singhsomeone · 14 Jul 2003
if the sangat stock togethr, situation woud be bettr. but sangat run separte horses & go oposite idea's. only peeta ji know! [%sig%]Jarnail Singh "Arshi" · 22 Jul 2003
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. A veer Ji was kind enough to send me the website address of Mohinder Singh Ji. It turned out that I had been visiting that site for quite some time...only i didnt know it was SDO Mohinder Singh Ji doing the kirtan and katha. Frankly I am confused as I didnt see or hear anything against Gurmat. The Articles at ShabadVartara are well researched and have lots of merit. We have been printing them out and distributing them to the local sangats in and around Kuala Lumpur and not a single objection from anyone. I would be grateful to any vveer ji bhen ji on this message board to clarify any anti-gurmat parchaar on this site. We will then correct ourselves. Dassan daas jarnail SinghMkhalsa · 23 Jul 2003
The thing with people like him is that you DONT KNOW.. a lot of anti panthic elements start by preaching gurmat and somehow it gets twisted.. with Bhai Mohinder Singh it is a very complicated issue... He has said things against importance of kakkars/rehat.. even against kesh.. please be very careful with what you distribute to sangat as you may be brainwashing without even knowing it...Ajit Singh · 24 Jul 2003
Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh Where would you like me to start, SDO in his anti gurmat katha condemned Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, to a mere book which couldn't even remove a fly, he degraded the whole amrit sanchar cermony, he continously stated that the guru ship finished with Guru Tech Bahadur Ji and said modern sikhs have distorted history and invented the whole amrit sanchar ceremony, totally condemned Bhai Gurdas Ji dee varaa, changed Gurbani urcharaan to suit himself e.g satgur into sategur. Totally denounced Guru Amar Das Jis seva as another distortion of history, he says there is no paras kala in gurbani, No need to meditate on Gurbani, just understand message. Panee (water) rerkana - read bani, Dudh (milk) rerkana - nam japo. He says no need to wear Kirpan, keep nuclear bomb if you want to keep weapon. Veer Ji I could go on and on and have the proof but as he has now done peshi and no one has bought any more evidence against him into the open (even though his website is still going there isn't enough proof to suggest his involvement they we're planning live broadcasts which may have proven wheter or not he has changed but they never done them) IMHO the website from which you have downloaded and handed out literature from is one of the worst anti gurmat sites there are, why ? because they knowlingly have twisted gurmat, history, gurbani to present a logic which to those who don't know will seem okay, but when you compare these views to gurmat and ask those who have done khoj it is evident that they are trying to lead the sangat down a total different path, the biggest problem is that most of the time you won't notice it but the one time you do it will be too late as you will except it without question. Sajeat raho sangat jio, recently that fake Narinder singh was uncovered for the fraud he and his followers are in the same way stay alert, anything that questions the fundamentals of sikhi must be avoided. My benti is stay away from his site, there are so many other sites which propogate gurmat in the correct manner. Why not download from them, this whole topic of wheter or not SDO has reformed will always be open to debate, hopefully he has and will see out the remaining years of his life according to Gurmat if he hasn't then the truth will come out and he may face explusion once again if the Akal Takhat deem it so. Bhul Chuk Maf Karna Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Ji Ki FatehSS Khalsa · 24 Jul 2003
Waheguru jee ka Khalsa Waheguru jee kee Fateh I agree with Veer Jarnail Singh jee. I also have been going to the site. I could not find any thing wrong or anti Gurmat. The site does not even mention Bhai Mohinder Singh's name. The site is purely dedicated to Gurbani of Shri Guru Granth Sahib jee. I could not find any claims made by veer AJit Singh or Mkhalsa. Waheguru jee ka Khalsa Waheguru jee kee FatehAjit Singh · 25 Jul 2003
Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh, So on the first page where it state is Bhai Gurdas Jis Bani the key to gurbani ? the article if you have read it goes on try and disprove that Guru Ji gave this status to Bhai Gurdas Jis Bani, so one of the generally accepted facts about sikh history is questioned ?? why would you even bother wanting to look at the rest of the site. Do you think the creators of this site are wiser than Guru Ji that they have suddenly come across something new and now have the right to question what Guru ji did. Bhai Gurdas Jis Bani is the key to Gurbani, Bhai Gurdas Ji was one of the most blessed souls in sikh history, lets not be fooled by those who have no concept of Gurmat and its higher values. The reason I bought to light the gala I did is because Veer Jarnail Singh jee requested an insight into what the site was about, like i have said before this site is a waste of time and should have been removed by now if the Akaal Takhat had done their job properly, there was no point in peshing SDO if this site was continuing. If you still think the site is okay that is up to you but please don't try and make it sound like everything is Gurmat on that site cus it is far from it. Bhul Chuk Maf Karna Vaheguru Ji Ka Khlasa, Vaheguru Ji Ki FatehKulbir Singh · 25 Jul 2003
>>>>>> I agree with Veer Jarnail Singh jee. I also have been going to the site. I could not find any thing wrong or anti Gurmat. The site does not even mention Bhai Mohinder Singh's name. The site is purely dedicated to Gurbani of Shri Guru Granth Sahib jee. I could not find any claims made by veer AJit Singh or Mkhalsa. >>>>>> I concur with Ajit Singh jee that Sikhs should stay away from this site. I have not visited this site lately but there used to be a lot of anti-Gurmat stuff on this site. Most people just love anti-Hindu stuff or anti-Brahmanisim and if a site contains strong element of anti-Brahmanism, many Sikhs believe that it must be Gurmat then. Kala Afghana started off with anti-Brahmanisim writings and once he had a following, he introduced his real agenda. Same strategy was employed SDO too. He would speak against pakhand and other brahministic practices in Sikhs and slowly got carried away and started questioning every tradition of Sikhi. A Sikh must obey Guru Sahib's hukam that a Sikh must stay away from "Bipran kee Reet" i.e. the traditions of Brahmins. Kala Afghana and his supporters think that the essence of Sikhi is anti-Brahminism. This is where they are wrong. They classify even Naam abhyaas as brahminism. One wonders that if Naam abhyaas and doing paath is also Brahminism then what is Gurmat? Daas, Kulbir Singh