Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Tsunami and God

Tsunami and God

Rain drop · 10 Jan 2005

Dec 8, 2005; noted sikh writter; in The Hindutan Times; writes his comments about the catastrophe "Tsunami", which took place on Dec 26. He defines 3 types of catastrophes. First one is man made and second partially man made. Third type is God caused, called "Act of God". Being a non believer, he throws a question for believers. " How does that square with the popular conception of God being almighty, just, benign, forgiving etc.? What wrongs had the victims of the tsunami done to deserve His wrath? I would like my readers, particularly, those who believe in His existence, to enlighten me on the subject. Do not throw scriptural texts in my face; I do not subscribe to any. As for myself, I belong to Somerset Maugham's creed: ' I am deeply religious man who does not believe in God'. I believe in the goodness of men and women." Let us not discuss the ills of the writer. The question is ever green from the non beleivers. What answer we have. Be brilliant. That man is clever and sharp witted. We can post this thread to him. Even otherwise, we need explain this simple puzzle.

Re: Tsunami and God

water drop · 10 Jan 2005

'The only certainty in life, is death'

Re: Tsunami and God

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 11 Jan 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalasa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. Read Babarvani in Guru Granth Ji..when in front of the eys of Guru nank Ji a Tsunami named BABBAR and His Mughals Armies...smashed into Sultanpur Lodhi and demolished everything.... Guur Ji asks Waheguru...Etee maar payee KURLANEH...TENKEE DARD NA AIYAH.... OH my Beloved Satguur ji, the people suffer so much...Dont YOU feel the people's PAIN ?? We can ask God the same question today.... and we will get the same answer GURU NANAK JI has given us in babarvani. Jarnail Singh/

Re: Tsunami and God

Kulbir Singh · 11 Jan 2005

After reading other baani of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj and after reading his history, it is hard to believe that he could have said to Vaheguru: “AITEE MAAR PAYEE KURLAANAI, TAI KEE DARD NAA AAIYA||” Our Satguru jee is such who said: JO TUDH BHAAVAI, SAAYEE BHALEE KAAR (Whatever you do is good, O Vaheguru). Then how could Guru Sahib have questioned Vaheguru in case of Babar’s attack? In the previous pankiti Guru Sahib clearly writes that “Aapon dosh na deyee karta, Jamm kar Mughal charaayia” meaning Vaheguru is clear of any fault and he punished the residents of Aimnabaad through Jamm roop Mughal Babur. So who was saying "Tain kee dard naa aaiya" ? It could have been that Guru Sahib is recording what the suffering residents were saying. Nothing in this world happens without a reason. No one gets punished without a mistake and no one gets rewarded without a good Karam from his or her past. Vaheguru’s justice is perfect and no one ever can escape from it. Having known that Vaheguru’s justice is perfect and that whoever suffers anything suffers because of his or her own bad deeds, we as fellow human beings cannot forsake compassion. While Vaheguru’s justice is being served we should serve our fellow human beings and other creatures without complaining to Vaheguru for punishing them. Whatever he did is perfect and well deserving. Gursikhs of our all-knowing Satguru jee cannot pass naïve statements like “Vaheguru did very bad in Tsunami” and so on. Such statements are against Gurmat and are based on ignorance. They don’t know how perfect Vaheguru is. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Tsunami and God

hmmm · 11 Jan 2005

bro kulbir singh ji said "Nothing in this world happens without a reason. No one gets punished without a mistake and no one gets rewarded without a good Karam from his or her past. Vaheguru’s justice is perfect and no one ever can escape from it. Having known that Vaheguru’s justice is perfect and that whoever suffers anything suffers because of his or her own bad deeds, we as fellow human beings cannot forsake compassion. " but what about rapes, oppression, and when someone kills a member of someones family for stupid reasons? surely that cant be gods justice on earth but something that contravenes gods natural laws because its wrong to hurt innocent person or rape anyone. and we gotto act back when someone does wrong huna?

Re: Tsunami and God

Kulbir Singh · 11 Jan 2005

------------- but what about rapes, oppression, and when someone kills a member of someones family for stupid reasons? surely that cant be gods justice on earth but something that contravenes gods natural laws because its wrong to hurt innocent person or rape anyone. and we gotto act back when someone does wrong huna? ------------- I never wrote that we should not act back when something goes wrong. It is our duty to fight back to oppression. I was just stating reason why something bad happens. No oppression happens without a bad karma from the past. Once the cycle of karmic debt starts, it is hard to eliminate it. In one life one may have slapped someone and in the next like he or she gets punched. This way the balance remains for long time, till one party decides to forgive or japps naam that too eradicates karma. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Tsunami and God

Sahibzaadeyian dee prernaa · 11 Jan 2005

Poorbulay janama dey karmaa daa husaab vee poora kurnaa peindaa hai. eis leyee chungey karam kurnaa, waheguru dey keetey daa bulaa mannunna, bhulaan bukhsaun waastey ardaas kardey rehnaa, aapney dhurum tey guru dey hukum noo munn lainaa hee chugaa hai. Without questioning God, the almighty.hmmm wrote: > bro kulbir singh ji said > > "Nothing in this world happens without a reason. No one gets > punished without a mistake and no one gets rewarded without a > good Karam from his or her past. Vaheguru’s justice is perfect > and no one ever can escape from it. Having known that > Vaheguru’s justice is perfect and that whoever suffers anything > suffers because of his or her own bad deeds, we as fellow human > beings cannot forsake compassion. " > > but what about rapes, oppression, and when someone kills a > member of someones family for stupid reasons? surely that cant > be gods justice on earth but something that contravenes gods > natural laws because its wrong to hurt innocent person or rape > anyone. and we gotto act back when someone does wrong huna? [%sig%]

Re: Tsunami and God

hmmm · 12 Jan 2005

wow thats interesting stuff thanks for your info kulbir singh ji thats very helpful for me to understand more about it.

Re: Tsunami and God

Rain drop · 13 Jan 2005

'The only certainty in life, is death' said "water drop". Certainly; so. The death; is no cruelty to the dead. HE sends and takes back. "Life" goes on after death. Soul is changing clothes, they say. Please carry on, other posters. Veer Kulbir Singh Ji kindly explain this " Jagat Tamasha".

Re: Tsunami and God

stuck · 13 Jan 2005

human hand behind tsunami earthquake? http://www.jatland.com/forums/showthread.php?t=7085 this brings me to an important question about this thread. If supposing it was man made , the sheer devastation it caused, lives lost, would the tsunami still fall under gods will? personally i dont think so because its not naturally ordained but then some people also say whats to happen does anyway whether its someones hand in it or naturally.

Re: Tsunami and God

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 13 Jan 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. There is an email being sent around here locally by the "santbaba"types..quoting Gurbani like the shabad..Dukh Daru sukh rog bhaiyah.... and claiming that GOD sent in the TSunami to PUNISH, make us DUKHEE so that we would then remeber HIM and become Sukhee.. Thse Singhs claim God is PISSED OFF ( their word not mine) off an on and so he sends such disasters to wake up people. These Singhs claim to be staunch Damdai taksaal/sant baba this and that...etc but all this rubbish about misinterpreting Dukh daru Sukh Rog bhiyah..type of upset GOD is a DIRECT copy from the Bible/Koran/western religions tradition...and Zillions of Light Years Miles AWAY from the PYAAR Bhariyah WAHEGURU of GURBANI. I was just a little off with my tuchh understanding of Aetee maar payee kurlaneh tein kee dard na aliyah....and Veer Kulbir Singh ji removed that doubt from my mind with his wonderful clarification..but these "Pakkeh shudh" Singhs are way beyond on the deep end with their pissed off gods. I will post the entire mail with my comments later.( this will make them angry them some more but what the heck...IF their GOD is pissed off so who cares if they are upset off as well) Jarnail Singh

Re: Tsunami and God

jagmeet singh · 14 Jan 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh i want to just ask rain drop that what he thinks about the sikhs of 18th century when Ahmed Shah Abdaali attacked sikhs and approx more than 40,000 sikhs were killed on that day, and the day is called Big Holocaust in the sikh calender. But the sikhs still thanked Akaal purakh and again asked for Sarbat da bhala in the ardaas. So what they have done at that time, what was there fault. But we have to believe blindly in the God. Whatever he do, we should not put question marks against his deeds. at that time, half the sikh population was killed. bhulan chukan di maafi waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Tsunami and God

Rain drop · 27 Jan 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Following is the text of the letter, I have written to Khushwant Singh. Sangat please comment, if feel so. I may be wrong at many points. Daasra -------------------------------- Dear Khushwant Singh Ji Ref. your write up, “God awful tragedy” (Jan. 8, 2005) and the question thrown towards the readers, to justify the ‘cruel’ role of God in the tsunami disaster; who is otherwise known as “just, benign and forgiving etc.”. I try few sentences for that. First of all, I want to cross-question your statement. If you do not believe in God, then why and how you question His Justness. If He is non-existent, then how can one ascribe cruelty or kindness to Him? Your question is self contradictory, technically. Anyway, let us proceed further. In Punjabi, there is a phrase i.e. Aap Mre Jag Parloh. English equivalent I know not. That is a disaster for the humanity; if one dies himself. We know that Death is certain for all. The ultimate reality. Then, where is the surprise; if it comes to individuals separately, one by one, separated on time scale or comes collectively to many. If death is the process of making us zero, then zero multiplied to one unit or to two million units, means the same result i.e. zero. So, the genuine conclusion; with a big catastrophe which leads many dead, should be that He is the creator as well as the destroyer of one and all. People in general, who do believe more or less in God, speak about His vast powers after such tragedies. Further; if collective death to many puts question on His benignity, then why we conveniently forget that He is taking care of millions at the same time. Two lakh make a very little fraction of the total human population (about 60000 lakh) on this earth. He maintains all of us physically as well as mentally, also spiritually. He nourishes animal and plant kingdom also. Also, the life on other planets. He had been doing so in the past also. It is no less wonder that He saves in mother’s womb and later, for each moment of our existence. A little lapse in the systems; man is no more. A little lapse in the paths of the planetary bodies; a big bang; the earth is no more. It is all His mercy, we are here. Miseries of the tragedy effected are really painful. But, who on earth is without miseries. Man has learnt to live with those. And, if a human triggered tragedy kills many, whom we are going to blame? So, it is better and wise to bow before His will; than to try explaining His wisdom or motives, in different actions. In the last; why you abstain from the Holy Scriptures? Forget earlier ones. Gurbani is written by the Gurus Themselves. Guru Gobind Singh Ji is the latest; with His divine descriptions. Looking back to about three hundreds years, for help on a subject, is no illogical. Rather, it will be very ungrateful on our part, if we do not accept His writings; as final word on the subject of “God”. Just find and read, what He has to say about God and His kindness. Read His “Ten Swayas” --- Deenan Ki Pritpal Kare Nit------. Yours sincerely, -----------