Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

Mandeep · 13 Jan 2005

Hey, i would like to know the views and opinions of caste based alliegences in Sikh gurdwaras. I would like to know where you think Sikhism is heading in the 21st century and whether you think what is happening is a good thing or do Sikhs need to change? I am covering this topic for my disseration and would appreciate your views, thank you [%sig%]

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

Cools · 13 Jan 2005

Another 10 to 20 years and the caste based Gurdwaras will not exist in the West. Once the present Gurdwara Committees die then the future non-amritdharis will not be interested in running the Gurdwaras. So that leaves the present amritdhari youth most of all do not accept the caste system anyway. But in answer to your question, the unfortunate answer is 'Yes'.

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 13 Jan 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. imho..dont wait 10 30 years....take over the gurdwars NOW and demolish the caste system. Waiting never solved anything. IMHO the "caste" is not in the Gurdwaras..it is in the Committees who run them Jarnail Singh

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

singh · 13 Jan 2005

Singh Sabhas have already abolished the caste system. The Gurdwaras mentioned are few and far between.

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

_JoDhA_GuRdAsPuRiA · 16 Jan 2005

the ravidas gurdwara in wolves advertised in punjab times do not allow any sant to sit on stage or preach in their gurdwara. They have good and bad points. We should do kirtan in all gurdwaras this helps break caste down, gives others a sense of belonging, and allows opportunity to meet rehetvan sikh, give them sangat, give them kirtan laha, so they know what it means to be a sikh and maybe one day work toward amrit and take caste name off the gurdwara. Wishful thinking perhaps! But the sikh spirit is never say die! Ramgharia gurdwaras i attend, , i think most akj england sangat do too on samagams. Caste exist more in our brain through ignorance and manmade boundary than in gurdwaras. Some bzurg tell us so and so caste dont keep to khalsa rehat, we then end up basing stereotyped casteified assumptions due to the rehat created by a caste gurdwara, but because other castes are extremely low numbers the social exposure of amritdharis from other castes will be limited with no centralised structure .They will be overlooked and their gurdwara constitutions, manifest existance of the caste name on the gurdwara door will form the end picture without any real substance to the people coming from those caste. I can confirm many punjabi durkhan do go singh sabhas whichever is convenient. Gurdwara is gurdwara. Best way to get rid of caste is to marry in different castes provided the partner is following what you follow. I am the lowest of the low jheer who will b marrying a high caste jatt gurl next year, we havent taken amrit yet but have talked about it and will take steps towards it. I one day wish to perform kirtan on stage with my wife and children, i hope this dream can come true and we can show the world mixed marriages will be a success in sikhi and send out a strong message to destroy caste system into tiny little tookrai shred by shred into the bin where it belong. At first her family didnt like the idea of me and her marrying because they had impression jheers were not leading clean lives, and werent proper sikhs. When they actually met me in person i explained to them what i want in life, how i live, how my family are, amongst other things then they actually came to like me for who i was and realised that not all jheers are backward. The family could have been mistaken to be castist but they were not they just wanted their daughter to marry a person who lived a sikh life and not just in name and when they met me they took a liking to me. So i would suggest we socialise more with other castes and help break the misconceptions down. The more people have held onto caste the more it has actually started to crack. All the youth i know dont care about caste, the only people that hang onto it are either old people, those trying to preserve religion with culture and strangely enough some religious people. Society is different now if we cared to get out of our small ghettoes.

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 17 Jan 2005

Jodha Gurdaspuria- you wrote "the ravidas gurdwara in wolves advertised in punjab times do not allow any sant to sit on stage or preach in their gurdwara. They have good and bad points". If this is the Ravidass gurdwara on Dudley Road (Blakenhall), I can give you some of their bad points- they regularly have guys standing right outside the front door smoking cigarettes. These people aren't just passers by (as the temple is on a main road), but people who have "popped out for a quick one." This particular temple has a "community centre" of the same name, right opposite, which is hired out for weddings, parties etc, where meat, alcohol is consumed. How can any Gursikh go to one of these so called gurdwaras anyway- the FLAG is NOT a nishaan sahib. There is NO khanda in sight, NO ik onkaar. Correct me if I am wrong, but don't we believe in BHAGAT Ravidass, not GURU Ravidass? Baajan Wale Da Chela

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

.. · 17 Jan 2005

pardeep singh jio the exact same thing you describe happens in ramgharia gurdwara slough, yet the annual samagam is usually slotted here for a day ever since i can remember. Quick question is there any singh sabhas with halls used for weddings? What should be the solution in your eyes dear veerji? should we totally cut the minority gurdwaras off or establish talks with them directly on maryada?

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

uk singh · 17 Jan 2005

'Best way to get rid of caste is to marry in different castes provided the partner is following what you follow' I do not agree with this statement. To eradicate caste, you need people to follow Sikhi. Best thing to do is to marry a person who is right for you. Caste is irrelevant.

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

hayr · 18 Jan 2005

i thenk we should only marry in caste. Your blood must be pure you need to know who you are and pass it to your children. We have proud tradition, jatt marry jatt you terkan stick to terkan it how it is you are what you are born dont try to mix the two just accept yourself. I will never let my daughter marry other caste well son its mazboori but i would not like it.

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

caste is wrong · 19 Jan 2005

why is caste a mans thing? i never seen or heard of a kaur into it or even pay attension to it. maybe bhenjis see something men do not, we could learn more!

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 19 Jan 2005

Hmmm...am I "Ramgharia"? No, a "Republican". But I didn't vote for Pres. Bush if that's what you are asking. Oh, no, you didn't mean Republican you meant Ramgharia? Hmm...No, not Ramgharia...perhaps you meant "redhead"? Yes, I have reddish color hair. My dad was red, you know. I have his color hair. What, you still meen Ramgharia? Hmmm...I looked that up on Dictionary.com and couldn't find a definition. References to the Caste system are ludicrous for someone like me, who is very dedicated to Gurbani and Sikhi and Seva but is not of Indian origin. As more of us westerners of all colors and backgrounds discover the TRUTH that is Sikhi, this will make Casteism even more irrelevant. My Panjabi is limited, but I think Guru Nanak's message is perfectly clear.

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 20 Jan 2005

In response to .. "What should be the solution in your eyes dear veerji? should we totally cut the minority gurdwaras off or establish talks with them directly on maryada?" How can we call these Gurdwaras? Like I said, they do NOT believe in the basic principles of Sikhi- 10 Gurus, and jyot of 10 Gurus, dhan dhan sahib sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji maharaj. They are NOT minority Gurdwaras because there are no minoritites in Sikhi. Trying to have talks with them would be a bit difficult- imagine how many "Guru Ravidass Temples" there are in the UK- would they really change the name of the temple for a start? It would be like telling a Church or Mandir to change their name to "Guru Nanak...." or "Singh Sabha..." I am sure the Gursikhs out there who hail from the non-Jatt castes go to the usual "Gursikh Gurdwaras" i.e. mainstream Sikh beliefs. Bhul chuk maaf

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

kal · 16 Sep 2005

First of all everything that's done in the name of ''sikhism'' today is wrong. Not many sikhs today abide by what Guru Nanak preached and implemented into sikhism… All these breakaway groups (ravidasi, ramdassi, namdhari, nirankari) all these should be eradicated!!!! There were ONLY 10 Guru's and Guru Granth Sahib Ji being the 11th Guru, no baghat which is featued in the SGGSJ should be given the title of GURU, as this was not the intention of the Guru's… Bhagat Ravidass is and will remain a bhagat and Bhagat Sheilh Farid etc etc….sl lets stop all these names (caste divisions) that are given to the newly formed gurdwaras now otherwise in a few years time all Gurdwaras will be sangat free buildings as many chrches are today!!! All these hyporcritical gyanis (most not all) who have no knowledge of what today's sikh youth require should be thrown out of comittees. They have no respect for anybody Khalsa fateh Ji! [%sig%]

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

Ek Kaur · 16 Sep 2005

in response to Hayr bhaji / bhenji who said... <> I wondered you mean by pure blood? The caste system has nothing to do with blood.. it is related to profession / occupation. Jatt's were farmers and Terkhans were carpenters... how does this relate to the biology of a person?

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

Singh · 16 Sep 2005

perfectly agree with Ek Kaur the caste system was a way off separating the farmers from the carpenters. Its is strictly profession & occupation driven and the traditions just went along with it. No farm owner wanted to be associated with a farm worker, who were commonly known as churea or chamar (think i spelt it right) and no builder wanted to be associated with a farm owner...hence the caste system. Every religion has its own caste system, but it is never separated by blood...is the blood of jatt supposed to be more blissful than a tarkan??? But in the western society the caste system is now a way to keep a reputation among the families strong.

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

Legolas · 16 Sep 2005

EK Kaur, These people are fools, they are so stuck in their "pure blood" castes they have no idea of thier history. There are no pure blood castes, as you say they are to do with profession. If a takhaan got a bit of land, over a number of generations he would be called a Jatt. When the ramgahria were formed they were a mixture of many castes, so no pure blood their. Every caste has always been a mixture and always will be. The sooner these backward people realise this the better. [%sig%]

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgha

Paapi · 16 Sep 2005

It will be hard to persuade the ramgharians to change their gurdwhara names. Does the sangat agree?

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

sharanjeet kaur · 17 Sep 2005

Captain Falcon [1] wrote, in 1896 "The back-bone of the Sikh people is the great Jat caste, divided and sub-divided into numerous clans----. The Jats are thoroughly independent in character, and assert personal and individual freedom, as against communal or tribal control, more strongly than any other people". As far the origin of the Jat Sikhs or in that matter other Jats, Major Barstow [2] remarked in 1928, "It is from these Scythian immigrants that most of the Jat tribes are at any rate partly descended. They thus colonized the Punjab, Northern Rajputana (modern Indian state of Rajasthan), and the western half of the Gangetic Doab (western part of the modern Indian state of Uttar Pardesh in northern India), and a considerable proportion of the inhabitants of these countries are undoubtly of Scythian origin". In regard to the characteristics of the Jat Sikhs Captain Bingley [3] quoted Thomason in 1899, "they are manly without false pride; undemonstrative; independent without insolence; reserved in manner, but good-natured, light-hearted, and industrious. No one could be associated with them for any time without conceiving both respect and liking for them". Approximately one third of Jats in South Asia follow Sikhism. They make up the majority of Sikhs. Even though there are no up to date accurate available statistics, some people say their number is as high as 85%. As per the A.D. 1888 census returns [4,5] figure for the total number of baptised Sikhs in India was 1,706,909 and the Jats accounted for 66%. Their association with Sikhism is deep rooted. ) Furthermore, Latif [7] said, "This vast delta (area surrounding the birthplace of Guru Nanak in Punjab called "Richna Doab"), during the period immediately preceding the establishment of the Sikh religion, was inhabited by the Jats and Bhattis (to the best of my knowledge Bhatti is also the clan name of some Jats). In addition, the world reknown Professor Ellsworth Huntington [8] of the Yale University remarked, "----the Sikhs are the only one of these ---that has experienced any appreciable selection---. That as important religious selection took place among them in early days seem clear. People do not accept a new faith unless there is something in their temperament which responds to that faith----. Colonel A.L.H. Polier (died in A.D. 1795) [9] wrote, "Originally and in general the Siques (Sikhs) are zemindars (landowners) or cultivators of land, and of that tribe called Jatts (Jats) which, in this part of India, are reckoned the best and most laborious tillers, though at the same time they are also noted for being of an unquiet and turbulent disposition. This tribe of Jatts (Jats) is very numerous and dispersed in all the country from the Sind (presently, a province of Pakistan or river Indus) to the southward far beyond Agra (a city in northern India). In another document Polier [9] said, "But what is more to be admitted is that those Seik (Sikh) Sirdars (Chiefs), whose territories border on the King's were but very lately of the Jauts (Jats) and of their caste and tribe ---- they have put on their iron bracelet, fifty of them are enough to keep at bay a whole battalion of the king's forces, such as they are". Griffiths, J. (his document dated February 17, 1794 A.D.) [10] said, "The Jaats (Jats) are said to observe some institutions similar to the Seiks (Sikhs), wear their hair and beards in the same manner, and are part of the same people, who under Swrudge Mul (Suraj Mal----consult Chapter 5 for more information on this powerful king of the Jats), etc., formerly possessed many of the countries in the North India---". Francklin, W. (Documented during A.D. 1798-1803) [11] wrote, "Considerable similarity in their (Sikhs) general customs may be traced with those of the Jauts (Jats); though these, in some districts, apparently vary, the difference is not material, and their (Sikhs) permitting an interchange of marriages with the Jauts (Jats) of the Doab and Harrianah (probably same as the modern Haryana state of India) amounts almost to a conclusive proof of their affinity of origin. The Seiks (Sikhs) allow foreigners of every description to join their standard, to sit in their company, but excepting in the instances of the Jauts (Jats), they will not consent to intermarriages----. If indeed some regulations which are in their (Sikhs) nature purely military ----be excepted, it will be found, that the Seiks (Sikhs) are neither more or less than Jauts (Jats) in their primitive state". Browne, J. (Major and who written the first book in English on Sikhs "History of the Origin and Progress of the Sikhs" in A.D. 1788) [12] said, "The people known by the name of Sicks (Sikhs), were originally the common inhabitants of the provinces of Lahore and Multan (now both in Pakistan), and mostly of the Jaut (Jat) tribe ----". Francklin, W. (documented during A.D. 1798-1803) [11] wrote, "The Seiks (Sikhs), in their person, are tall, and of a manly erect deportment; their aspect is ferocious, their eyes piercing and animated; and in tracing their features a striking resemblance is observable to the Arabs who inhabit the banks of the Euphrates (river in modern Iraq)". This is an interesting observation on and appears to have some historical connection because General Sir Sykes [13] says in his book that a large number of Jats from the Indus Valley were taken to the marches of the Tigris (river in modern Iraq) in eighth century A.D. For more information on this topic the reader is directed to Chapter 3. Regarding the founding of Khalsa (baptised Sikhs or saint soldiers in A.D. 1699) by Guru Gobind Singh, the tenth and the last Guru of the Sikhs, Lt. General Sir MacMunn [14] wrote, "The Jats of the Punjab, sturdy and quarrelsome, flocked to the new brotherhood (Khalsa), and he (Guru Gobind Singh) soon had a force which enabled him to try conclusions ----with the forces at Delhi (Emperor of India's). A strong religious sense did animate these warlike, muscular Jats----. The Jat tribes about the Sutlej and the Ravi rivers hastened to join the faith----. No longer would they turn the cheek to their persecutor, and they began to group themselves by tribes and confederacies known as Misals----". In the eighteenth century Sikhs were very successful in establishing twelve principalities or confederacies called Misals (Misal is a Arabic word means alike or equal [4]). At least nine of these Misals were founded by the Jats. The history of each of the Misals founded in the eighteenth century by the Jats is briefly described below [6, 7, 15-17]. Bhangi Misal This powerful Misal of the Sikhs was founded by Bhim Singh of the Jat background. Bhim Singh was succeeded by his nephew named Hari Singh belonging to the Dhillon clan of the Jats. Hari Singh's sons, Jhanda Singh and Ganda Singh played an instrumental role in strengthening the Misl. Also, they are credited for constructing the Bhangi fort at Amritsar (the holy city of the Sikhs in Punjab) and enlarging and beautifying the town with many noble edifices [7] in the later part of the eighteenth century. Kanhya Misal The first chief of this Misal was Jai Singh, a Jat of the Sandhu clan belonging to a village named Kanah, fifteen miles from Lahore (now in Pakistan) [7, 16]. The name of the Misal is derived from the name of Jai Singh's village and one time the Misal was the strongest of the Sikh confederacies north of the river Sutlej in Punjab [7]. Nakai Misal The chief of this Misal was Hira Singh, a Jat of the Sandhu clan [7, 16]. The area lying between Lahore and Gogaira (now both in Pakistan) was called Naka country and during the middle of the eighteenth century A.D., Hira Singh took possession of it; thus the Misal became known as Nakai Misal. Singhpuria Misal This is also known as the Fyzulpuria Misal after a village near Amritsar (Punjab) called Fyzullapur. The Misal was founded by a Jat landlord named Kapur Singh who later on was popularly known as the Nawab (Chief) Kapur Singh [7]. He died at Amritsar in A.D. 1753. Krora Singhia Misal Sometimes it is also known as the Panjgarhia Misal, from the village of its first chief, Karora Singh. Karora Singh belonged to the Jat background [7] and the Misal was popularly known after his name. Nishanwala Misal Two Jats named Sangat Singh and Mohar Singh were the founder of this Misal [7]. These two warriors were the standard-bearers of the assembled Khalsa (baptized Sikh or pure) army, hence, the name Nishanwala was given to this Misal. Sukerchakia Misal This Misal was founded by Charat Singh, a Jat of the Sansi clan and grandfather of the Maharaja (great King) Ranjit Singh, the ruler of the Sikh empire of the nineteenth century [7]. The Misal is named after the native village of Charat Singh, called Sukerchak in Amritsar district of Punjab or Manjha country [15]. Phulkia Misal As per Latif [7], the chief of this Misal was a Jat named Phul of the Sandhu (Sidhu?) clan; thus the Misal is known by his name. Phul had seven sons who became the ancestors of the royal families of Patiala, Nabha, and Jhind States (now in modern Punjab). Ramgarhia Misal Latif [7] wrote, "The founder of the Misal was Khoshal Singh, a Jat of Mouza Guga near Amritsar, Punjab. After his death he was succeeded by Nodh Singh of Sahangi also near Amritsar. Three most daring brothers named Jassa Singh, Mali Singh, and Tara Singh of Tarkhan (carpenter) background and belonging to Mouza Sarsang in the Lahore district (now in Pakistan) became devout followers of Nodh Singh. After the death of Nodh Singh, Jassa Singh became the chief of the Misal. The Misal seized the fort of Ram Raouni (Fortalice of God) and then renamed it as Ramgarh (Fort of the Lord [17])". Later on the Misal was popularly known as the Ramgarhia Misal.

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

Malwai Jatt · 18 Sep 2005

Excellent post by sharanjeet kaur. I would like to comment on something regarding Jatts. A great deal of people have been posting here and on other sites, spreading vicious lies about what a Jatt is. This is no better than what the RSS and Shiv Sena types do with distorting Sikhi, I have selected a series of comments made which are baseless lies, which are attempts to destroy the Jatt community. "The caste system has nothing to do with blood" Jatts have nothing to do with caste. Jatts are a distinct ethnic group with separate lineage, consisting of sub-Clans, such as Gill, Sidhu, Brar, Mann, Dhillon and Dhailwal. Jatts descend from Sycthians as do Rajputs. In particular Jatts come from the great Massagetae tribes of Scythia, otherwise known as Gatae -> Gat -> Jat. Jatts have their own glorious history preceding Sikhi. Each Jatt Clan has its own history. We have our own physical and mental traits. Excellent reading is "Jattan da Itihas" by H.S Duleh. "Jatt's were farmers and Terkhans were carpenters" When Jatts arrived into Punjab from Central Asia they conquered the lands, ever since we have been land-owning farmers. Jatts are prominent in other occupations ranging from the Army to doctors. Tharkans are a separate group with their own gotras like Sagoo, Panesar, Channa and Bansal. "If a takhaan got a bit of land, over a number of generations he would be called a Jatt." This is the most ridiculous thing I have ever heard. I have no comments to make on such a blasphemous statement. It seems many people lack any knowledge of history and anthropology, what a shame, but regardless, you will never destroy the Jatt identity.

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

shamshira · 19 Sep 2005

Ancient jatts "Sacae" is the name, the Persians give to all Scythian tribes and they wore trousers (even today Punjabi Jat ladies wear baggy trousers and their men folk used to or still wear tight trousers especially during the winter months called "Churidar Pajama")----armed with the bows of their country, daggers (one of the requirements of a baptized Sikh is to wear a dagger), and the sagaris, or battle-axe". The archeological findings witness [10] that the Scythians carried swords as long as two and half feet as well as short double sided daggers called "akinae". Furthermore, Scythians and their cousins Sarmatians worshipped the iron sword called "scimitar" ("Samchhir" in modern Punjabi?), in fact, as late as fourth century A.D. as per Ammianus Marcellinus [17] Alani or Alans (a branch of Massagetae)" after the manner of barbarians a naked sword is fixed in the ground and they revererntly worship it as their god of war,----". Jatts During the Sikh Era A prominent Sikh historian Khushwant Singh [25] (not a Jat himself) wrote, "They (Jats) brought with them certain institutions, the most important being the "panchayat", an elected body of five elders, to which they pledged allegiance. Every Jat village was a republic ---". Ammianus Marcellinus [17] wrote, "Just as quiet and peaceful men find pleasure in rest, so the Halani or Alani (Massagetae) delight in danger and warfare. There the man is judged happy who has sacrificed his life in battle,---". Lt. Gen. Sir MacMunn [9] said, "The opinions of experienced officers and the experience of the World War (I) have placed them (Jats) among the best of the Indian martial classes". He went on to write "---enthusiatic support of the British Government, and devoted and distinguished service in the World War (I) has been the reply of the modern Jat, whether Sikh, Hindu or Moslem in religion, to such suggestions". Furthermore, the general said, "How the Jats have kept up their war-like proclivities through the ages, how the Jat who is Sikh has been so prominent and faithful a soldier of the Crown, or how the Hindu Jat came to such great fame in the World War (I), for one their battalions (i.e., 6th Jat Regiment) to receive the title of "Royal", will be told in the course of this book". Specifically, with respect to the Sikhs, Captain Bingley [22] wrote in 1899, "Whenever fighting is going on, be it in China, the straits, Burma, or East Africa, there the Sikh to be found. Offer him good pay, and there is no service, however difficult or dangerous, for which he will not gladly come forward". Ammianus Marcellinus [17] wrote, "They (Alani or Massagetae) do not know the meaning of slavery, since all are born of noble blood, and moreover they choose as chiefs those men who are conspicuous for long experience as warriors". With respect to the modern Jats, Captain Bingley [22] said, "From the earliest times Jats have been remarkable for their rejection of the monarchical principle, and their strong partiality for self-governing commonwealths. One of the names by which they were known to the ancients ----kingless----". [%sig%]

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

jagpreet kaur · 19 Sep 2005

the crux of the point has to be much deeper than the name sake of a gurdwara. each community has its own way of life while being sikh. Has abiding by gurmat gotten rid of tribal identities ? then what were the splits in akj delhi and punjab about? instead of blaming jatts, akj, or calling other sikhs ignorant and manmukhs it is time some of you researched jatt history and its emergance into sikhism. Ek kaur i understand where you are coming from, you have been misinformed by people or wrong info with good intention this drive for unity. Please choose your sources based on unbiased evidence. somebody wrote "the caste system was a way off separating the farmers from the carpenters. Its is strictly profession & occupation driven and the traditions just went along with it. " wrong. jatts are an ethnic people migrating from the west into punjab and pakistan with seperate ways demonstrating independance warlike tribal concious with characterictics found only amongst other jatts .carpenters are unrelated to jatt way of life and sprang from the hindu cradles with hindu influences. some tirkans today too own land in central punjab and jatts own building firms in england and america, both groups still maintain their own distinct characteristics well after sikhism was established with changing scenarios a jatt remains a jatt and a tirkan a tirkan. somebody wrote "No farm owner wanted to be associated with a farm worker, who were commonly known as churea or chamar (think i spelt it right) and no builder wanted to be associated with a farm owner...hence the caste system" Francklin, W. (Documented during A.D. 1798-1803) [11] wrote The Seiks (Sikhs) allow foreigners of every description to join their standard, to sit in their company, but excepting in the instances of the Jauts (Jats), they will not consent to intermarriages----. If indeed some regulations which are in their (Sikhs) nature purely military ----be excepted, it will be found, that the Seiks (Sikhs) are neither more or less than Jauts (Jats) in their primitive state". what seems to hurt the jatt bashing brothers is the insistance of jatt sikhs preffering to marry within jatts. somebody wrote "Every religion has its own caste system, but it is never separated by blood...is the blood of jatt supposed to be more blissful than a tarkan???" the blood of all is blissful but a jatt remains a jatt a tirkan a tirkan. Jatts are always distinct from tirkans ethnically historically culturally for thousands of years with a warlike tendency to sikhism which was best demonstrated in recent times in 1984 while giani zail singh and the tirkan community rallied in favour for the government, Such attitudes are prevelant today in reference to 1984 with derogatory anti jatt comments hurled at sikh militants . somebody wrote "But in the western society the caste system is now a way to keep a reputation among the families strong." jatts are not a caste but a distinct group of people. IF you wish jattsikhsto stop calling themselves jatt sikhs then stop calling white sikhs white sikhs. lead the way by stop calling yourselves rehals sembhis bhimbras bhogals marry your own children to chumars and take off ramgharia signs off gurdwaras stop wearing starch turbans and wear bana and join the mainstream. If this change is not visible then all this jatt bashing is wrong. be proud of your heritage with love and respect others.

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

Ek Kaur · 21 Sep 2005

Is a drive for unity so bad if it holds hope for peace? What is to be gained from perpetuating division in the name of caste... in the name of sect... in the name of history or whatever! Sorry not interested in academic justification for synthetic systems deconstructed by Sikhi. These distinctions may have evolved over history through migration through cultural development. But who created those distinctions? God?! The Gurudwara is the door to the Guru and ultimately to Waheguru. Why name it after man made divisions?! Was it our Guru who called one of our first Gurudwaras "Harmandir Sahib" "Hari Mandir"... "house of god"?! Then why do we name Gurudwaras today after sects of people? <> Isn't our heritage the Guru Granth Sahib and the Khalsa Panth which should be void of synthetic division...?

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

Ek Kaur · 21 Sep 2005

p.s. I'm not "bashing" any particular division... I'm just saying any such division shouldn't exist amonst GurSikh. e.g. I want to call my-self a Sikh thus I don't identify with the Ramgharia tag my ancestors gave me because the two cannot exist together. A sikh is a disciple of the Guru and is nothing else.

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

ek sengh · 21 Sep 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh sikhs are one people as ek kaur states but that does not mean you are forced to give up your identity or marry into othr races to just proove that. You can still b individuals and liv as sikhs. jatts are not a caste ek kaur ji they are an ethnicity there is nothing wrong in that. A lot of things in culture are good such as family structures respect home izzat community upliftment that have worked well in the past. sikhi deconstructs the hindu caste system which jatts were never part of to begin with. Please look up the terms jathera. Brahmins are the only ones claiming jatts were vaish. jatts in the hindu fold have only recently convertd to hinduism as per arya samaj drives prior to that pre islam era jatts were always at war with hindu ideology evenwhile a small percentage of jatts became agnikula rajputs at the behest of brahmins. Jatt culture is something which needs to be studied rather than dismissed as anti sikh. You will find it has more in common with sikhi than against it. The anti terkan attitudes are merely a reaction to the heavily brahminised version of sikhism promoted by ramgharia gurdwaras via sants sanatan ideologues committe regulations and most of all th design of sangat and pangat structures within the ramgharia gurdwaras which are direct slap in the face to guru jis ideals. The other bridge which need constructing is the ancient punjabi values versus moderate kenyan outlook. It would b wrong to assume or dismiss both in bad light as both can give good to sikh community. jatt culture actually encompasses mankind if you study it once you will find jatts have absorbed many tribes towards jathood. Jatts can b very open minded take a look at singh sabha regulations as per committe runnings you will find jatts terkans bhappe all together even in a jatt majority abiding more by khalsa conducts whil ramgharia gurdwaras are solely run for ramgharia sikhs. now ramgharia ideology and its existance coms into question more than jatts do. Punjabi sikhs have twin heritage of sikhism and panjabiat which many world cultures groups do not have we have a maboli, virsa, community, respect, and religion stretching back since punjabi civilisation began. I agree with you the ramgharia tag and sikh do not go together as you do not belong to the ramgharia misaaal which is now defunkt. A jatt sikh however is an ethnicity which is entirely different rspects from an 18th century misaal. By having an ethnic identity does not make one less of a sikh or more. If you choose to have no ethnicity that is you wish bhenji but please do not force it on the majority of sikhs who are proud of thir khalsa sikh and punjabi heritage which stretches miles throughout history. stay in chardi kala waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

Ek Kaur · 28 Sep 2005

<> Respected Veerji, my stance on the topic of caste or of the naming of Gurudwaras was not one based in Punjabi or any other culture or heritage. It was one based in religion. I should write here that by culture I mean “a way of doing things” and the Punjabi way of doing things is not always the Sikh way of doing things. This is a whole new debate. My argument was that if you are amritdhari then the below applies... "…Thereafter, Guru (Gobind Singh) ji pronounced, ‘on your rebirth in the Khalsa Panth, your PREVIOUS LINEAGE, caste, creed, calling, customs, beliefs and superstitions, etc. STAND ANNULLED from now onwards. Transforming you into the Order of Khalsa,'..." http://www.sikhreview.org/march2001/chronicle.htm: (Historians amongst us will question this source and I'm afraid I can't present a Hukamnaama by Guru Gobind Singh ji but as far as I know "Sikh Culture" has always believed this to be true. There may well be valid sources to back this and I would request learned Sikhs to present them so that I may also learn of the roots of our beliefs) <> Respected Veer ji, It's not simply MY wish... I believe it is the wish of the founder of the Khalsa as demonstrated above. The founder who also says, Jaap Sahib Chhapai style of verses, by Thy Grace 1. “O Lord, Thou art without any form, symbol, caste, class or lineage. None can describe Thy form, hue, garb or shape” So veer ji, I believe that if we embody atmaa (soul) which upon the demise of its body seeks to meet with the Parmatmaa (eternal / complete soul) then we have no lineage because as Guru Gobind Singh Ji says above, Parmatmaa has no caste, class or lineage. This is my interpretation and you may so choose to ignore it. Re the subject of naming Gurudwaras: IMHO The door of the guru which leads to the house of God should be named with the upmost reverence as opposed to being named after man made divisions like "Ramgharia Gurdwara" which means what? the door to the ramgharia guru??!! Makes no sense. On an academic note: I have assumed ethnicity and lineage to be the same. We could have another discussion about this relationship, for instance is lineage set within ethnicity which is based on geography and so wasn’t the soil all joined before it split through earthquakes or is ethnicity based on lineage which is all down to man made divisions… etc, but I don’t know how it will help the original question about the naming of Gurudwaras. I have expressed some opinions and probably in quite a harsh manner. I personally find divisions in Sikhi pointless and hurtful and this is the reason for my defensive nature. I sincerely apologise for any offence caused but I reassure that none was intended. Thank you very much for bearing my somewhat baseless ranting. I shall not rant anymore… well I’ll try not to… ;o)

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

Ek Kaur · 28 Sep 2005

<> Veer ji, I agree whole heartedly. Ok sorry. No more ranting - promise :o)

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

khalsa · 28 Sep 2005

i've read all posts and i'm very disappointed by reading post giving the history of "jatts" and many are proud to be jatts. these people are either fool, murakh or ignorant who still call themselves jatts. when u become sikh there is no cast u r sikh. if u think ur forefathers were jatt that is y u want to stay jatt "correct". why don't u stay and live naked through ur entire life because when u were born u were naked why change. if u want to known as sikh do not mention your cast. [%sig%]

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

098 · 28 Sep 2005

caste system, if you want to call it, been their for ever....and still exists. It will be very hard to to abolish it. Ramdasi, Ramgarhia are not part of caste system but more of a division between Sikh's based on historical frictions upong their leaders.

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

Parwa · 24 May 2006

Someone wrote: "Every religion has its own caste system, but it is never separated by blood...is the blood of jatt supposed to be more blissful than a tarkan???" the blood of all is blissful but a jatt remains a jatt a tirkan a tirkan. Jatts are always distinct from tirkans ethnically historically culturally for thousands of years with a warlike tendency to sikhism which was best demonstrated in recent times in 1984 while giani zail singh and the tirkan community rallied in favour for the government, Such attitudes are prevelant today in reference to 1984 with derogatory anti jatt comments hurled at sikh militants ."--------- What about KPS Gill and Brar? Bothe Jatt Sikhs and both responsible for mass murdering Singhs. Besides I have heard from reliable sources from teh ground that most of the killing of Singhs, post 1984 were actually done by Jatt Sikh military and policemen. Caste is crap.

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

Paapi · 26 May 2006

I thought I would share my 2 cents on this topic. I think we are missing the point of 'caste' in Sikhi. Whether it is a cultural thing and just a occupational thing, that is irrelevant because it has become no different to the caste system in Hinduism. Im sure it would be ok if people called the farmers jats and the carpenters tarkhans... but only if it ended there since it would be just names for proffessions and a quick category of background.... however, ramgharia today is not 'carpenter', 'jat' today is not farmer... they have become seperate castes where people from one is better than the other.....they cant even share the same Gurdvara...... Once a Sikh takes Amrit and becomes a Khalsa, he drops all 'his' culture and background. That persons mother and father change, his/her place of birth changes, his/her occupation changes.... they no longer remain 'jats' etc since they have enrolled with the Khasla army and now work for Dhan Guru Gobind Singh Ji... they have NO differences.... The longer communities hold on to these MEANINGLESS and dividing beliefs about being from different 'cultural backgrounds' or however you wana put it, the longer it will take for complete ekta in Sikhi. The Guru's didn't just go on about the Hindu caste system for no reason. We should see were Sikhi is heading and infect headed, and take lessons from those teachings ourselves. Lets pull down any barriers we may perceive there to be... we are all the sons and daughters of the same Guru. Forgive me if my views upset anyone.

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

dass · 27 Jul 2006

Ramgharia means custodians of the fort of Waheguru. The Ram is derived from Guru Ram Das Ji. How can one call the name of a fort a 'caste'....bizarre, schismatic thinking ! What is wrong with naming a Gurdwara Sahib after a fort that was defended by puratan sikhs ? The problem is that Sikhs have labelled themselves as Ramgharia because Jassa Singh just happened to be a carpenter...and so, through certain inferiority complexes, felt that labelling the baradhari 'Ramgharia' would impart an exhalted position; ie the word Ramgharia has become a covert name for tharkhan. This is a shame because the original ramgharia regiment was all inclusive (jats, chumaars, jheers, tharkhans), in the spirit of the puratan Khalsa. And no, this is not a 'get out of jail' statement because history attests to this. I attend a Ramgharia Gurdwara Sahib. It is a Gurdwara Sahib where there is immense 'Shaanti'. There are no punch ups. All jaat paats (yes...difficult for some to believe on this forum) attend the Gurdwara Sahib, all the gianis. kirtanees and those Khalsas who distribute the Parshaad are from all jaat paats. All jaat paats share the akhand paath service, united in the name of the Khalsa. The only problem is and which constantly bugs me is that the committee is purely from tarkhaan and lohaar background. The committees at Ramgharia Gurdwars Sahibs have forgotten what an incredible puratan gursikh jassa singh ramgharia was and that they are not acting in the spirit of the khalsa nor in jassa singh's name. I can understand that discrimiation has taken place between jaat paats. The majority of Sikhs are from the 'jat' background and want to hold onto power. Power and greed are commonplace in all jaat paats. All jaat paats are guilty of this. Traditionally, a Singh Sabha Gurdwara Sahib(yes....sorry to say but the vast majority of Singh Sabha committees are purely composed of Sikhs of jat ethnicity) does not let in other jaat-paats. This is the reason why the other jaat paats established Gurdwaras under the Ramgharia banner or Ravidas banner or the Bhatra banner. I must say, I find these distinctions quite amusing. The blood of heros flows in the veins of all sikhs, no matter what their ethnicity or profession. I often laugh to myself when a jat says that they are the backbone or custodians / guardians of Sikhi and then a tharkhan quotes that some of the great Sikh heros were tharkhan.....this is small minded egotistical thinking that we should shed from our psyche. Will i continue to go to the Ramgharia Gurdwara Sahib. Yes....because the sangat has piaar for one another and the gurdwara sahib runs smoothly and i go to pay my respect to the Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. This Ramgharia Gurdwara does not have a meat and booze hall associated with it ( and I hope will never have recourse to this). Ultimately, it is not the name of the Gurdwara that needs to be changed.....it is views of the committee that have to be changed from within and this will happen with younger Khalsas that are sprouting in every Gurdwara Sahib. Gurfateh...Dass [%sig%]

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

J.A.T.T · 29 Jul 2006

The Ramgarhia community are a caste group of the Punjab region in India. Most are Sikhs, mainly from the Tarkhan tribe.

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

tribe troobe · 31 Jul 2006

whats in a tribe? gurus call uniting humanity is thus in scribe The message of gurbani let us not jibe and enjoin to the eternal spiritual vibe beware of mayas bribe!

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

dass · 01 Aug 2006

JATT Ramgharia is not a caste.....you need a brain transplant. Read Dass's post. Dass

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

Non-Sikh · 02 Aug 2006

dASS: You are the one that needs a brain transplant. "The Ramgarhia community are a caste group of the Punjab region in India. Most are Sikhs, mainly from the Tarkhan tribe." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ramgarhia

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

lalio · 02 Aug 2006

castes or tribes they all come from one couple adam and eve in material form. The souls come from one source from God. Life is not forever on earth so we may be in a different world.

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

Sardar · 02 Aug 2006

[size=24]The thing is people are stupid. It is not Guru Ravidas Ji but it is BHAGAT RAVIDAS JI. Noticed i replaced it with BHAGAT and removed GURU? Yea so get that over your head for those who think He is a Guru and not a Bhagat.[/size] [%sig%]

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

Dalbir · 03 Aug 2006

Vaar 1 Pauri 17 Anachy of the ages - Bhai Gurdas jugagaradhee jab hovehae oulattae jug kiaa hoe varathaaraa|| During the down fall of an age, people setting aside the duties of the age behave contrary to their nature. auTy iglwn jgq ivc vrqY pwp BRSt sMswrw] outhae gilaan jagath vich varathai paap bhrashatt sansaaraa|| The world gets engrossed in remorseful activities and sin and corruption prevail. varanaa varan n bhaavanee khehi khehi jalan baans angayaaraa|| Different sections(castes) of society develop hatred for one another and finish themselves through squabbles as the bamboos, due to their mutual friction, producing fire burn themselves as well as others. nindhaa chaalai vaedh kee samajhan nehi agiaan gubaaraa|| Condemnation of the knowledge starts and in the darkness of ignorance nothing remains visible. baedh granthh gur haatt hai jis lag bhavajal paar outhaaraa|| From that knowledge of the Vedas which gets man across the world ocean even the knowledgeable people get away. sathigur baajh n bujheeai jichaar dhharae n gur avathaaraa|| So long God does not descend on earth in the form of true Guru, no mystery can be understood. gur paramaeshar eik hai saachaa shaah jagath vanajaaraa|| The Guru and God are one; He is the true master and the whole world craves for Him. charrae soor mitt jaae andhhaaraa ||aa|| He rises like sun and the darkness is dispelled.

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

Dalbir · 03 Aug 2006

This bit seems strange? baedh granthh gur haatt hai jis lag bhavajal paar outhaaraa|| From that knowledge of the Vedas which gets man across the world ocean even the knowledgeable people get away.

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

lagah · 22 Aug 2006

thanks brother, i am chamar i liked your comments.jats are being proud to be jat only.even he is illitrate,bad apple,thug or whatever most of them they never proud of their quality but jat. i am chamar i am educated intelligent lot of ither quality i can be proud of.hundreds of jat families respect me cause of quality. but most of jat they just proud they are jat.even they dont know the meaning of jat. only education will bring all castes together we must pay attention on the education . thanks