Re: Dancing in front of guru
Rashminder Singh Oz · 17 Jan 2005
yeh i have seen such things in vcds of so called Sant baba Ranjit singh ji dadriyaan wale
i saw people clapping and some started dancing and the enviroment was totaly disrespectful and bhai ranjit singh dhandriya wale was sitting on stage with a sweet smile on his face ignoring the respect of guru ji
Bhul chuk maaf
Vaheguru Fateh
Daas
Re: Dancing in front of guru
Kulwinder Singh · 17 Jan 2005
Dancing in spiritual joy is tolerable but only mystic kind of dance ( like some Sufi do) in total love of God, Where as Giddha and Bhangra should not be associated with Nagar Kirtan.
Beware , Some people want sikhs to have some dispute in the light of Bezehti Issue, they want to label Sikhs as trouble maker.
SO BE VERY CAREFULL HOW YOU TACKEL IT.. BE 50000% CAREFULL.
DO NOT ACT IN STUPIDITY AND FALL RIGHT INTO THE TRAPE
Re: Dancing in front of guru
interested reader · 18 Jan 2005
is this harnek singh, the guy who has a farm in Stratford? He thinks he is the next baba nand singh.
I heard that his farm can have 100 akhandpaths going on at one time ina tent. These guys charge top whack money for these akhand paths. He is a business man who is raking it in?
Even his land is worth a bomb now!
Re: Dancing in front of guru
harnecks background · 18 Jan 2005
Baba Harnek Singh excommunicated
Jupinderjit Singh
Tribune News Service
Ludhiana, January 4
The controversy over the control of Nanaksar Dera at Siahar village took a new turn today when the Sant Samaj headed by Baba Sarbjot Singh Bedi excommunicated Baba Harnek Singh, the reigning Sant at the dera, for his alleged objectionable activities in Canada.
Baba Sarbjot Singh Bedi, convener of the Gurmat Sidhant Parcharak Sant Samaj told Ludhiana Tribune that the five-member panel of the Sant Samaj consisting eminent religious personalities, had excommunicated Baba Harnek Singh for allegedly drinking liquor and participating in objectionable activities in Canada.
While Baba Harnek Singh was not here to comment, a spokesman for his group rejected the Sant Samaj orders saying Baba Harnek Singh was a saint and not a member of any sant samaj from which he could be ex-communicated.
The spokesman said the Sant Samaj and other organisations had approached Baba Harnek Singh several times with a membership offer, which he had refused saying the saints should not become part of such unions or associations and should only concentrate on religious activities.
The Sant Samaj had formed the panel to probe the allegations of misconduct against Baba Harnek Singh. It was found that he was challaned in Canada for driving under the influence of liquor. The panel had given 15-day time to him to clear his position, but he chose not to respond.
Meanwhile, tension continued in Siahar village for the fourth consecutive day today as rival factions sticked to their stands and no dialogue could take place despite efforts by the Khanna police.
The report of a visit to the village by Baba Harnek Singh in next few days for participating in a function on January 13 had added to the tension as the rival group was gearing up to stage a show down at his arrival.
The Khanna SSP, Mr Parmod Ban, had already announced that no one would be allowed to breach peace of the village. Heavy police force had been deployed in the village to avoid any untoward incident.
Both groups have convened separate press conferences tomorrow to put forward their point of view.
The first incident of violence took place on October 11 between the two warring groups fighting for the control of the dera. Nine persons, including three cops were injured, one of whom died on December 25.
The villagers had been demanding the control of the dera to be handed over to Baba Mann Singh. The other group headed by Baba Harnek Singh refused as Late Sant Meehan Singh had given his gaddi to him and not to his sons about a decade ago.
Much is at stake in the controversy. The control of the dera would provide the beneficiary hold over nearby 7,000 acres in Canada, besides several thousands of acres in Punjab and other parts in India. The stakes were quite high as three lakh million dollars were said to be the earnings from one crop in Canada.
At present, Swami Kanwaljit (In charge Asian group), Mann Singh, Govinder Singh and Surjit Singh Jodhan are members of the dera headed by Baba Harnek Singh. The followers of the sect include foreigners and VVIPs. The working at the dera was normal till September 11, when its present management allegedly got the rooms there vacated, which were till now occupied by Mann Singh, Sewa Singh and Harchand Singh sons of late Baba Meehan Singh.
Re: Dancing in front of guru
harnecks background · 18 Jan 2005
Nanaksar Sikh Sect Leader Accused of Various Transgressions
The Sikh Times, Jan. 30, 2003
The following allegations were recently posted on an Internet discussion group by a person who wished to remain anonymous. The allegations refer to Harnek Singh Grewal of the Baba Buddha Ji Nanaksar Gurdwara Gursikh Temple which has two locations as follows:
224-226 Foleshill Road, Coventry, U.K. CV1 4HW
18691 Westminster Highway, Richmond, B.C., Canada [Phone: (604) 270-7369]
It is with great regret that I must speak out on the activities of the Nanaksar Coventry sect. Their baba [spiritual leader] whom they call 'Maharaj Ji' must answer to the following charges from the sangat [religious community]:
1. At the age of 67 he has recently been enjoying the sexual company of a 22 year old girl who has recently had his baby.
2. He has not married this girl according to any custom (let alone according to Sikh custom).
3. She is a brahmin [upper caste] Hindu who does not believe in Sikhism.
4. He is currently facing charges in Canada of misusing the money collected from the sangat. He has built a huge mansion there and is planning another in Coventry [U.K.].
5. He has been tried and charged with drunk driving offences. Documents with evidence are available from the Alberta court (in Edmonton [Canada]). Certain individuals from the sangat in Coventry are also in possession of copies of the evidence.
6. He does not believe in amrit [Sikh baptization].
7. He regularly travels and stays at hotels and uses the sangat's money to finance these trips.
8. He has regulalry been seen, filmed, and photographed in boxer shorts and with his hair down at beaches in Canada.
9. He has promoted promiscuity amongst his children-followers.
10. He believes Osho Rajnish [the late Hindu cult leader who was extremely popular in the U.S.] to be a prophet greater than Guru Nanak [Sikhism's founder].
11. His system of philosophy consists solely of Osho's teachings.
12. He believes that sex can take a person to God faster than nitnem [Sikhism's daily regiment of prayers].
13. He has totally floundered every single teaching of his predecessor who believed only in the Guru Granth [also known as 'Adi Granth'] and only preached nitnem and amrit.
The sangat is requested to petition the gurdwaras on Foleshill Road and New westminster Highway in Vancouver and ask for this imposter to be removed.
Re: Dancing in front of guru
harnecks background · 18 Jan 2005
more background info on this dodgy baba
http://www.asianpacificpost.com/news/article/145.html
Re: Dancing in front of guru
Jagpreet Singh · 20 Jan 2005
The 'new' Sants are all a waste of time. All are after brownie points from the Sangat. All they want to do is be liked and have groupies and own a Mercedes.
Unless "Sant Baba Gurdev Singh ji" openly condemns Harneck Singh, then he's just a waste of time. Why can't the Nanaksar Jatha kick this Harneck Singh out? Why can't they act like proper Singhs and stand their ground?
I am so disheartened by the whole Sant sytem. It's a joke. We sould ban the title as it is just abused. At this specific point in time there is NO SANTS out there. Just MERCEDES hungry individuals.
Nagar Kirtan AND Dancing in front of guru
Mandeep Singh · 20 Jan 2005
wjkk
wjkf
Here is something that IS VERY interesting.
Now i accept (if it can be called that) the above replies etc.... but lets go and take another view of this dancing in front of guru:
now at the bi-annual nagar kirtan in southall, we generally speaking, have all these floats etc.. and various groups represented. Now, looking at this thread it has for the first time that the BHANGRA groups that are presented/invited with their DHOLI's and DJ's (they now even have their own trucks now blaring BHANGRA!) are committing the 'same' crime!
DISCUSS
Bhul chuk maaf karni,
daas,
Mandeep Singh
Re: Dancing in front of guru
Jagpreet Singh · 21 Jan 2005
Author: khalsaa
Date: 01-20-05 19:23
"At this specific point in time there is NO SANTS out there."
Maybe that is what you think. I can recommend that your pray to Guru Sahib for some better sangat. I have seen Sants and they are there at this specific time!!
==========================================
I hope I have the darshan of such Gurmukhs but unfortunatly I have been on the receiving end of 3 well known "Sants". All have done things which made me question their motives.
A well known 'Sant' who now resides in London seems more worried about upgrading his Merc every 2 years.
I have met 'Sants' that live off the kamai of Baba Isher Singh Rarewale or Baba Nand Singh and claim to be of that background. Then they are standing in off-licences doing Ardaas for the success of someones business!
When a 'Sants' sangat is full of monay, then you need to question whether he is actually promoting any SIkhi at all.
Re: Dancing in front of guru
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 17 Feb 2006
is this the SWAMI KANWALJIT..and the SAME NANAKSAR that veer Akal Singh writes about in the report above ?? doesnt LOOK LIKE a place GURU NANAK would like to be associated with ??
DID GURU NANAK or the other Nanaks ever ACCUMALATE such WEALTH for their own USE ??...any "property" of our GURUS..anywhere today ?? Then WHY all this filthy wealth for nanaksar DERA...worth fighting over ??
from: http://www.tribuneindia.com/2003/20031011/ldh1.htm
Tension over control of Nanaksar dera
Jupinderjit Singh and Mahesh Sharma
Tribune News Service
Siarh (Payal), October 10
Tension prevails in this village following a confrontation between two groups of the Nanaksar Thath of the late Sant Meehan Singh Dera over its control. Heavy police force has been deployed in the area for the last two days to prevent any law and order problem.
While one group consisting mainly of the village residents prefer the chairmanship of the dera trust in the hands of the three sons of the late saint, the other group is supporting the continuation of the Baba Harnek Singh as the trust head.
The villagers have accused Baba Harnek Singh of indulging in certain activities bringing a bad name to the sect. On the other hand, supporters of Baba Harnek Singh allege that the controversy has been created because of the political interests of some Congress leaders in the area and the power of the sect abroad.
The civil and police administration has called a meeting of the two groups tomorrow to find some amicable solution of the matter. Sources said there was not much chance of a compromise by the either party, whose supporters were ready for any eventuality.
The control of the dera would provide the beneficiary hold over near 7000 acres of land in Canada, besides several thousands of acres in Punjab and elsewhere in India. The stakes are quite high as three lakh million dollars are said to be the earnings from one crop in Canada only.
DSP (Payal) Amrik Singh said the police would try to solve the matter across the table only.
The police was kept on tenterhooks by the supporters of both the groups since yesterday morning. Today an akhand path on the occasion of Pooran Mashi was held. The function went off peacefully.
A visit by a team of The Tribune to the spot revealed that tempers were running quite high in the rival camps even though the administration had succeeded in keeping them at bay. Sources said Punjab Chief Minister Capt. Amarinder Singh was being regularly informed about the developments.
Sources close to the present chairman Bhai Sahib Harnek Singh informed that he had been installed by founder chief of the sect, Sant Baba Meehan Singh, before his death around 10 years ago. For all these years he has been looking after all the religions places and property worth millions of pounds in international market.
Baba Harnek Singh was made chief by Baba Meehan Singh, who ignored his sons, including Mann Singh, Sewa Singh and Harchand Singh. At present, Swami Kanwaljit (Incharge Asian group), Mann Singh, Govinder Singh and Surjit Singh Jodhan are members of trust headed by Harnek Singh.
The number of followers of the sect is in lakhs, including foreigners and VVIPs. The affairs at Siarh Thath were told to be normal till September 11, when the present management allegedly got the rooms vacated which were till now occupied by Mann Singh, Sewa Singh and Harchand Singh (sons of the late Baba Meehan Singh). Residents of the village initiated a move to install Mann Singh, eldest son of the founder as head of the organisation and chairman of the trust.
Mr Kanwaljit Singh (husband of the village sarpanch Ms Balwinder Kaur) said: “There are serious allegations against Harnek Singh which will be made public shortly. Sangat wants only a family member of Sant Meehan Singh to be chief of the sect.”
On the other hand supporters of Harnek Singh alleged that some political forces with vested interests have been trying to disrupt the harmony among the followers of Sant Baba Meehan Singh. They accused opponents of distributing defaming pamphlets at the time of the Chhapar Mela.
Re: Dancing in front of guru
Maninder Singh · 17 Mar 2006
Please note that Nanaksar is very common name for Gurdwara. I can assure you that Baba Gurdev Singh Ji with headquaters in Smadhbhai India is branched in Brampton & Vancouver Canada, Houston U.S.A. and Birmingham U.K.
Harneck Singh's Nanaksar never had any affliation with those created and run by Baba Gurdev Singh Ji. They are 2 diiferent Jathas and not related in any way.
Re: Dancing in front of guru
Amrik Singh Khalsa · 04 Apr 2006
Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh.
Brothers and Sisters, I would first of all take this opportunity to state the fact that Sant Baba Gurdev Singh JI Maharaj's nanaksar jatha has nothing to do with Harneck Singh Nanaksar Gurdwara. Sant Baba Gurdev Singh Ji is a direct deciple of Baba Isher Singh Ji who was instructed by Baba Isher Singh Ji himself to set up his own Dera (Nanaksar in Smadh Bhai - India) after he passed away. Baba Isher Singh Ji asked Baba Gurdev Singh Ji to do this as He knew there was hatred and jelousy shown towards Baba Gurdev Singh Ji from other Deciples. Therefore Baba Ji moved to Smadh Bhai Nanaksar after the second master (Baba Isher Singh JI) passed away.
It is a very well know fact that Baba Gurdev Singh Ji was one of Baba Isher Singh Ji's most closest deciples and Baba Isher Singh Ji showed much love towards them. Baba Isher Singh Ji even changed their name from Bhupinder Singh > Baba Gurdev Singh Ji.
JUST BECAUSE OF HARNECK SINGH'S MISTAKES SANT BABA GURDEV SINGH JI'S NAME SHOULD NOT BE BROUGHT DOWN, SINCE THE TWO NANAKSARS ARE NOT EVEN LINKED! Why should an innocent persons name suffer as such if they are not involved?
The are some claims that Baba Gurdev Singh Ji has been involved in battles over land where by 13 people were killed. This ''information or claim'' is not true as THEY DO NOT HAVE ATTACTCHMENT TO WORDLY THINGS AS SUCH.
Guru Arjan Dev ji's definition of a SANT: '' A SANT IS HE WHO LIVES HIS LIFE ACORDING TO THE BANI''
BABA GURDEV SINGH JI DOESNT EVEN OWN A PENNY TO THEIR NAME LET ALONE GETTING INVOLVED IN BATTLES OVER LAND!!!!!
They only travel to and visit the nansaksars that they have opened and run SO THEREFORE THEY ARE NOT INVOLVED WITH HARNECK SINGH and his name should not be brought down due to others actions or false claims.
I pray that Vaheguru, Guru Granth Sahib Ji and Sant Baba Gurdev Singh Ji may bless a fool like myself.
Brothers and Sisters, If we do not know much about and have not met Baba Gurdev Singh Ji who are we to say they are true or false? Bye doing this and judging does that not make us false?
Sangat Ji, we have all heard of the saying ''Men are all the same''. But are they really? Well we all know that yes, there are good men out there who are genuine in their hearts yet we say this statement because of another mans mistake. Please my Brothers And Sisters do not loose faith and think there are no saints out there. Vaheguru would not leave us alone in this world without his saints and Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj. Let us not judge all as a result of the mistake of some.
Brothers and Sisters thankyou for taking time to read this. I have no doubt that Vaheguru will bless you all and I pray that he blesses even me - a fool and the biggest sinner.
Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh.
Re: Dancing in front of guru
....VahGuroo.......VahGuroo... · 10 May 2006
Why is the Kirpan not worn by Sant Gurdev Singh and the other Bahingams? They only wear Kirpans at Amrit Sanchars?
Not Sant bashing, would just like to know as I really like the atmosphere in the Southall Nanaksar Gurdwara but am uncomfortable that the Kirpan is not worn by the sewadars.
Re: Dancing in front of guru
Tired Veerji · 06 Jun 2006
They don't wear kirpans. You can see through their white chola, there is no gatra. I have often wondered why they don't wear their kirpans. The only time I have seen them with kirpans is when they are doing an Amrit Sanchar.
Re: Dancing in front of guru
Baljit Singh · 26 Jul 2006
Why is it we all jump at the chance to criticise so many sants. Guru Sahib's bani has tort us take somebodys goodness and not always look at there faults.
If somebody has 100% proof of someone disrespecting Guru Granth Sahib JI or if someone is wearing the blessed bana given to us by Guru Gobind Singh Ji and in some form is going against the principles of Sikhi then yes action should be taken, but not by posting your views on the net and killing the faith of people that are tryin to get into sikhi and are having a hard time fighting against kaljug as it is. If people have so much anger towards certain sant, then instead of taking it out on the keyboard do something about it, approach these people and try to get a result.
People shouldn't get dis-heartened from all sants because of a few that wasn't able to live in Guru Sahib's hukam, they obviously don't deserve the title 'sant'.
Gurbani has stated that there would be many fakes but not forgetting also stated that there are such beings that come to this world that are 'Dhan' and are only here to help us raech our goal for havin human form of life.
If anybody wants to do darshan of a true Mahapurkh, a sant that only praises Dhan, Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, and is so humble that it is hard to believe, then do darshan of Baba Gurdev Singh Ji.
Before anyone decides to have an opinion towards Babaji, like 'Japreet Singh' did, please compare the difference in the jeevan-way of life, then have some thought on weather we should all be carefull with what we say. How many people have we inspired to live the life of Sikhi? These are the type questions we need ask ourselves.
Re: Dancing in front of guru
Hardeep Singh (Vancouver, BC) · 30 Jul 2006
My grama was the only member of the family that was close to Guru Granth Sahib Ji. It was Sant Baba Gurdev Singh Ji that brought our entire family into Sikhi. This all started in the year of 1967 in Nairobi, Kenya.
If it wasn't for them we would be not be blessed.
No normal person can start 17 Gurdwara's around the world, have Raagis do kirtan for no price or salary, there is no golak (money chest) infront of the Guru Sahib. Kirtan duty is from 3:30am to 6:30am and 4:30pm to 8:30pm / 7 days a week.
I myself was a mona and took amrit in 1998 when Babaji came to Vancouver, BC.
All the people that have posting against Sant Baba Gurdev Singh Ji, have you ever changed someones life that they will taken amrit?
Are you able to acomplish the accomplishments listed above?
If you have never met a true Sant please don't do any "nidhya".
WJKK WJKF