Forum
Singh's Pride
Singh's Pride
warrior*princess · 21 Jan 2005
vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh
I'm not really sure how to start what I need to say and have been wanting to say this for a long time amongst other issues that the sangat really needs to take serious note on. It may sound like a minor concept, but somehow it means everything.
In regards to Singh's, my plea is; please be proud of your beard. Just the way a lion looks so brave and courageous, the same way the beard on a Singh makes him look beautiful and true.
Any Singh who is willing to leave his beard flowing, has some sort of pride and deep bravery towards Sikhi and life. This is what makes another Sikh proud upon seeing such an image.
There is no need to feel alienated when walking the streets. So what if some people don't like the beard, do/did you really need their acceptance or approval!!?
I think that it is all to do with self-esteem within yourself. If you wear something with pride, you will be percieved with the same notion by other eyes.
Having the beard is one of things that makes a Singh complete.
I have seen those that tie it back or attempt to do a tuck.. frankly it is not attractive but more importantly it seems as though the singh wants to hide and not be courageous. Ultimately, this style seems to hinder the pride of the dastaar and very image of the Singh.
For those that do tie it, I don't want them to feel that i have misjudged them...who am i to judge another.. but do consider this, if you do think you are truly brave inside, then why not leave your beard free. Maybe we are lackking self-esteem here.
Now Think! If this message came from a Singhni... why do you fear the opinions and thoughts of others when there are Sikhs who approve of a Singh with an open beard.
Afterall, isnt being courageous one of the true features of a Singh! Let everyone see what a true Singh is made of!
Re: Singh's Pride
Dil · 21 Jan 2005
Dear princes,
I am very happy about your chardikala vichaar about sikhi. This chardhikala is only by the grace of god. Infact every sikh should keep his beard flowing and it should not be tied.
Practically every one may have to compromise with the circumstances.
If you keep your beard open, you may be deprived of some good job oppurtunities in western world. If you are self relient or enterpreneur then you may be able to follow sikhi in better terms.
But what I think more important of all is the bring the change into your way of your life style (sikhi vichaar) as as rehat maryada.
If we are able to devote more sincerely to guru. then we need not care or worry about our rehit. Guru will inspire us. We will be inspired from our inner self.
I know one business person, who appear to be puran gursikh. In fact they use wrong practices to keep their business running. Their staff abuse them always and openly say they never expect that sikh should like that. Every six months they keep their office moving and never make payment to owner of the complexes. Never like to pay the staff in time.
So I think we must concentrate more on sikhi way along with outer look.
Re: Singh's Pride
Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 21 Jan 2005
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji ki Fateh
Warrior*Princess ji,
I wonder if maybe not enough of us Kaurs have really made a point of telling our men how good they do look with their long beards. I think they really are handsome as well.
Although, I have also seen that not all beards are quite alike. My dearest uncle has a beard that is long and very uneven. He chooses to tie his beard.
A neighbor of mine is not Sikh, he is Jewish, but also keeps an uncut beard and says that Jewish tradition says not to tie a beard either...but he must, as he is in construction and the long beard has once caused him an injury.
So...as much as I love the look of the lion's mane, I do think it is important to leave the decision up to the particular Singh as long as they are not cutting their beard. I would much rather see a Singh folding a beard than cutting it....and I would not want to tell a man how to manage his beard any more than I would want a man to tell me how to always tie my hair.
But the roop sure is beautiful....
Re: Singh's Pride
Kulbir Singh · 21 Jan 2005
I totally agree with Bhain jee Warrior Princess's comments. Singhs should be proud of their Gursikhi appearance. A Sikh without a flowing open beard does not look like a Guru kaa Laadla Singh.
Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee in his book - "Sachiyaan Daariyaan" - writes that many gursikhs who tie their beard suffer from inferiority complex and others do so to please their spouses who prefer tied and tucked up beards. Bhai Sahib further writes that such gursikhs are very weak and don't have the Khalsa spirit that would have made them proud of their appearance.
The appearance of a person who has tied his beard is similar to that person who trims his beard. In essence by tying their beard they silently express that it is better to have trimmed-beard appearance as opposed to Khalsa appearance that requires fully open and flowing beard.
Who cares if people or even our wives like our open beard or not. We should only care if Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj likes our appearance. Like they say in pind - Aapaan lokaan kolon amb lainay aa - who cares what people think.
Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwalay went a step ahead of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee and said "Tunni Munni ikk baraabar" i.e. ones who trim and ones who tie their beard are of same level. Sant jee made this strong statement to prove his point that tying beard is a very big weakness on the part of gursikhs.
There are ones who think and even have the audicity to say it out that tying beard gives them a clean and tidy look. What a shameful thing to say. They in essence say that Siri Guru jee (our ten Guru Sahibs) did not have a tidy and clean look. How shameful of them to even think like this. What can they get from Guru Sahib if they have such insidious opinions?
The height of defyness of Sikhs who tie their beard is when they come to the presence of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee tying their beard. They have no fear of Guru Sahib.
May Guru Sahib give us taufeeq (good wisdom) to follow rehit.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Singh's Pride
Mkhalsa · 21 Jan 2005
>>>others do so to please their spouses who prefer tied and tucked up beards.<<<<<<
JoraDhaAkhyaPurkhKumavdhaySayApvithAmaydhKhula
Those who act according to orders of the opposite gender are impure filthy & foolish.
Ang: 304
Re: Singh's Pride
jss · 22 Jan 2005
what about the surgeon performing open heart surgery...is he too a coward??
what about scientists working in labs who prefer to tie their dari simply to protect it?....
there are many other careers in which it is simply more practical to have your beard tie....it has NOTHING to do with being brave or not....has NOTHING to do with your sikhi......
i worked in a research lab this summer and i would tie my beard only because i didn't want it to burn off with all the chemicals and reagents we use...was i being cowardly?
i think you cannot just make blanket statments like the ones tha kulbir singh ji has provided...YES...i AM disagreeing with what bhai randhir singh ji or sant jarnail singh ji said...cuz sometimes you have to look at circumstances...
frankly i'm surprised that kulbir singh ji even brought up these gurmukhs...aren't you the one who always says not to base arguments on what other gursikhs said...rather some solid proof like hukam from guru ji or gurbani????
Re: Singh's Pride
SSS · 22 Jan 2005
>>>>>>I have seen those that tie it back or attempt to do a tuck.. frankly it is not attractive but more importantly it seems as though the singh wants to hide and not be courageous. Ultimately, this style seems to hinder the pride of the dastaar and very image of the Singh.<<<<<<<
I usually tie or tuck my beard on many occasion *NOT* because i want to hide my identity or that i am afraid of anyone. One have to accept and respect all type of people and their different lifestyle.
>>>>>>Let everyone see what a true Singh is made of!<<<<<<
One cannot find True singhs that easily. If I see singh with open dhari and their unique peharava that doesn't mean he is *True Singh*. I have to keep sangat with that person for quite bit of time and then only my mind will know whether this person's sangat is good or bad for my soul. IF that person is bad then it also does not mean i go on street and shout "These types of people" are bad. If one has to use judgment for their personal reason then he needs to look into character much deeper rather looking on pehrava [Outer appearance] which can be deceiving sometime.
[%sig%]
Re: Singh's Pride
Jarnail singh gyani · 22 Jan 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa waheguru Ji ki fateh.
IMHO this practise of tying beards beagn with Maharaja Sher Singh one of the sons of Maharaja Ranjit Singh.
tying a beard seems to me to be trying to have both worlds..have the cake and eat it too....that is have the LOOKS of a TRIMMED....and yet satisfy ones self that i am not trimmed but have a long beard.
People who tie their beards look so funny when they open them... the beard is all stringy looking and out of shape.....some open only on Sundays to go to Gurdawara....some open only during akhand paath/samagams etc.
Some with Snow White beards covered with BLACK Jaali nets...look even weirder....those tuckers and tiers waste so much money on Fixo and all that gooey stuff..i pity them..
At one time ALL Govt servants etc used to TIE their beards...then some youngsters decided that they wouldnt tie their beards...and wonder of wonders no one objected....it was all self - censorship..now we have lawyers etc who go to court with flowing beards, teachers go to schools wth flowing beards...I never tied my beard from the day it began to grow until i retired from Singapore Govt Teaching service...no one ever objected
I agree it is a sense of inferiority complex that makes people tie their beards..LET them FLOW....the Sight of a Khalsa Ji with a LONG Flowing Beard flying in the wind is a sight for sore eyes..MY Flowing Beard was the reason for many hundreds of photographs many tourists and my students, strangers i met on the bus, at the supermarket etc took with me...children always smile when they see me...SANTA CLAUS !!!
and more importanly the thought that GURU JI LOVES ME in this form is a plus....
Jarnail Singh
Re: Singh's Pride
yo · 22 Jan 2005
kulbir singh i love looking at what you write and it always affects me. I am now coming to the conclusion that sikhs should not then enter jobs where they are required to tie their beards.
Re: Singh's Pride
Hari Singh Nalwa · 22 Jan 2005
I'm guess it alright to tie it when it is required for the occupations. A cook would have to wear a hairnet over the beard, a police officer might have to tie it up.
Re: Singh's Pride
bhopinder singh · 22 Jan 2005
khalsa ji
please read the book BADGES OF BONDAGE written by gurfateh singh khalsa
what is the thought behind tying beard, look smart
theirfore tuni muni ik brabar
and keep on going
BADGES OF BONDAGE is a small book and explains the history of tying
Re: Singh's Pride
jss · 22 Jan 2005
"I am now coming to the conclusion that sikhs should not then enter jobs where they are required to tie their beards."
that's insane!!!!!!!!!...so you're gonna say that sikh's shouldn't be surgeons? be scientists??? cuz they don't want to tie their beards??? that's warped...congratulations kulbir singh and company...look what you have started....
Re: Singh's Pride
hmm · 22 Jan 2005
so "yo" you don't agree that sikhs should become doctors, or heart surgeons.etc. where tied up beards are required if not to keep it clean, but to keep it neat whilst operating, to prevent it getting in the way of the patient. these people help millions and billions of people. so who do u think these jobs shoudld be left to? if not sikhs?
Re: Singh's Pride
singhnee~22 · 22 Jan 2005
its not only singh's pride, its also singhneea's pride as well. i see that many girls wearing a distraar are starting to become more materialistic. They used to be so chardikala, and follow their rehit maryada no matter what others said... and now i see them either bleaching or laser removle. it really hurts to see girls doing this kind of stuff. There's younger kids who used to look up at them and see true singhneea, even kids as young as 5 got inspired and started wearing a distaar, now they see their 'hero' bleacing etc... i think that we just need to remind our selves that as long as Guru Ji knows ur the most beautifull person on this earth...then nothing else matters. It really truly hurts not only people who look up to u, but Guru Ji as well.
Re: Singh's Pride
ji · 22 Jan 2005
warrior princesses intentions are good and the way she wrote that i bet a lot of thought n feeling went into it But if a man ties his beard it aint jus about lookin gud.
two of the most built big genetic warrior amritdhari singhs from my area have tied beards. Their amritvela is rock solid for at least 7 8 years, the seva they do is something that i think most people here wouldnt even know or dream about here.
Their work requires them to tie beard. Personally speaking their two of the most handsome singhs you would find. I think its wrong to judge a person by their appearance. one handshake and your hand will be crushed for two days.
I have never come across an amritdhari singh with a tied beard who has cut his kes off, but what bhai kulbir singh i have sure seen on non amritdhari kesdaris do tie it then end up cutting it. But if they keep rehat like panj banis n watch their panj chors i think they wouldnt cut it off.
Re: Singh's Pride
Dil · 22 Jan 2005
VJKK,VJKF;
So as per Yo only profession suitable is truck driving. Even some people do noy hire a taxis with driver having flowing beard. Ir have your own business.
VJKK,VJKF;
Re: Singh's Pride
Mkhalsa · 22 Jan 2005
i know two gursikhs who are practicing neuroligists and their dharis are VERY LONG compared to most people. They simple put their dharis under their shirts/labcoats..
BIG DEAL!
if you HAVE to tie it on the job for safety/cleanliness, then tie it only when you are at the job and theres no need to put chemicals in your dhari that are harmful to it.
Re: Singh's Pride
Kulwinder Singh · 22 Jan 2005
The above topic show that how shallow some people are that the out look for you is very important as you must look Sikh, you may not behave as Sikh but MUST LOOK SIKH, it is almost sad to bring tears to my eyes.
The whole point of Sikhi is not to be judgmental about anybody else. as the link between man and God is direct. but never mind anybody else even Sikhs have opinion about each other on the outlook.
To me if you have understanding of Sikhism and follow the philosophy of Sikhism in daily life to deal with anything then you are better Sikh rather then somebody who wear full Bana but have nil knowledge of Sikhism.
Grow up my friends, Sikhi is in understanding our Guru is knowledge.
and Package is not the real goods, the substance is so worry about the substance.
Thanks
Re: Singh's Pride
............ · 23 Jan 2005
but mkhalsa to a person who ties their beard they may feel its a compromise and majburi. Then if they tied it at one place and not at anther they may feel they now have two projected faces to live with and if a guy has a beard down to his tehd that may be a bigger difference to tieing it. It may become harder for a person to deal with having different projections in public.
It depends on each individual i believe we should respect a persons choice whether they tie or leave it open, and neurologist case i get you but in others like using certain machinery you cannot get away it. When you bend lower to use it the gravity also pushes your beard down if you have a heavy set of kes, even one kes getting caught will proove fatal, So from majburi it is vital to tie or get another job.
stay in chardi kala gurmukh pyarey
Re: Singh's Pride
jehlla · 23 Jan 2005
princess that was one beautiful post, thank you kindly for that.
I beg to differ on point. Policemen have to tie beards or face the risk have having their beards pulled when arresting rowdy people.
My beard comes down past my waist, i always left it open till my early building days i was preparing a thick black chemical that would be used as adhesive. As i churned it my beard kes caught over the side of the tin and pulled a good few off, when i took my head back i also had this horrible black stuff over the bottom tip my thara. Thats when i decided you are compelled to tie it where the need be, in a builders environment its more practical to tie it than leave it open as you are constantly chopping and changing activities where you may be required to tie thara, but the nature of the work requires you to be on the ball, sharp, and quick you do not have time to run to a room and make sure its tied up then loose again and tied up for another activity. This does not affect the foreman who gives orders but those who are carrying out a number of practical tasks in short moments.
I hope you can understand that and hopefully not feel its always about appearance sakes.
I would not feel comfortable discussing personal rehat issues, but i would like to confirm i have never felt like cutting my thara off just because i feel compelled to tie it, it has not affected me in any way or made me tendhi kala. I feel quiet happy in fact :-) Guru ji has blessed me on the marg of sikhi where so many on this planet do not have the privelidge as we do, as well have having access to clean resources daily and saad sangat who always give us immeasurable support and benefit.
waheguru waheguru waheguruuuuu waheguruuuuuuuuuuuuuuu waheguruuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu
Re: Singh's Pride
Jarnail singh gyani · 23 Jan 2005
kulwinder singh ji,
"looking" like a Sikh is way more easier than "behaving like a sikh.
This is the answer i give to people who say SIKHI is "INSIDE", outside ( rehat) is of no importance at all..its what you have inside that counts..
To these I say it is so EASY...to keep long hair,...it just keeps growing..night and day ( in fact to CUT it you have to do something !!)..BUT controlling your KAAM, KRODH, HAUMAII which is INSIDE is infintely MORE DIFFICULT..so you tell me whcih is Easier..OUTSIDE rehat or INSIDE CONTROL ??
Looking like a Sikh, Behaving like a Sikh..BEING A SIKH are all interconnected..one cannot exist without the others....thats why Guur Ji says: Rehat piyaree mujh ko "SIKH" piyara nahin...here the "sikh" is the person....a person calling himslef sikh, (inside) is of no use if he doesnt have the commitment to SHOW it.
That said, IF your JOB absolutely requires dharrie tying...do it..its NOT the END of the DAY...but know the actual reason behind it. Thats all. A lot of people i know who DONT WORK..but still Tie their dharries... matter of habit.
In fact some years ago a Akali minister of Revenue came to malaysia for a visit..and as a young boy i was surprised that he had been tying his dharrie so tightly pulled to one side, that he was completley BALD on one side and had a few long hairs on the side his beard knot was...HE COULDNT OPEN his dharrie even if he wanted to because he looked basolutley RIDICULOUS !! He was minister of revenue in an akali govt..his JOB didnt require any tying of dharrie.
Jarnail Singh
Re: Singh's Pride
jehlla · 23 Jan 2005
bhai jarnail singh made an important point to consider the intention behind a tied beard.
Re: Singh's Pride
Kulwinder Singh · 23 Jan 2005
Dear Jarnail Singh Ji,
In deed it is much harder to behave like Sikh then look like Sikh, the point I raised was not to criticise somebody just be cause they tie their beard, If that is the only thing you have against somebody then you ( not Dear Jarnail Singh ji you in person) are surely narrow minded.
It is fake Sikhs who look like Sikhs but actually not even qualified to be called humans, give Sikhism bad reputation. You rather have people who do not portray themselves as Sikhs but behave like Sikhs, rather then other way around, It only diminish the value of real Sikhs,
You rather have rough gold covered in mud then fake metal polished and sold to you as gold.
What you think Dear Jarnail Singh ji ?
Re: Singh's Pride
lakhvir singh · 24 Jan 2005
WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh.
I respect all those Sikhs of the Guru who respect their kesh. Whether that respect comes through keeping it tied or letting it flow, it doesn't really matter. But a GurSikh blossoms and shines when the beard is flowing. That is why our Gurus were so inspirational and loved by millions. Not one questioned their appearance. It is in those revered ways that we follow today.
I used to keep my beard tied when I became a keshdhari again (I used to be clean shaven), but soon I began to detest tying it. I felt it was so 'enslaved', like a flower struggling to bloom. Finally, I could take it no more and ignored whatever anyone would think of me. I still believe that a Sikh's true and humble image is in an open dhaara.
But those whose occupations do not help in keeping their beards open and flowing, I think it is understandable when they need to roll up their sleeves. I respect them for not burning under the circumstances and ending up to the extent of trimming it, or even worse still, doing away completely with their Sikhi roop.
I think that World War Sikhs looked really smart, and exhibited a look of steel when they tied their beards. They were Sikhs who compromised not with their faith but chose to protect their kesh no matter what they were going through. Sikhs who tie their beards look good, but I always think that they would look the best if they let it flow. But that's just me. It's up to the individual of how they tackle their challenges.
With the Guru's Grace, I have found strength in letting my beard flow. People stare at me, some even jeer and mock my appearance, but I'm not in the least affected. It is what my Guru thinks of me is what matters to me. The rest just don't matter.
I was 'adviced' or 'warned' by my own family and friends that if I let my beard flow, no Sikh girl would like me or even think of marrying me. I was the least bothered about that. I'm still not interested in getting married to any girl who does not love the roop and gift of the Guru. Why get married to one who herself is not proud of her Guru? There is no way that she can even respect me for what I stand for. I know that some Singhni, somewhere, is out there who will accept me for who I am as a Sikh, because I seek none the less in return.
I humbly salute those brave Singhnia who love the Guru and His Sikhs and themselves walk the path of the Guru. I'm touched by the original post by warrior*princess - I know exactly what she stands for, and no matter what anyone else says, I know her stand is that of the Guru's. I respect you for that.
In my humble little opinion, I would only say that kesh of a Sikh deserves respect - it is a part of the Guru. I find tying my beard to be disrespecful of the Guru's gift, so I do not tie it. Whether anyone else believes likewise or not is up to their interpretation. Only just keep in my mind whether what we do, or not do, is Manmat or Gurmat.
Another point is those that those that do tie their beards, it becomes an easier choice to begin to trim because it comes with enough of its own headaches. This is how youth turn to trimming too. They find a short-cut to their headaches of struggling to keep their beard 'neat and smart'. As the Nishaan Sahib, or a country's flag, rules the air when it gracefully swims in the breeze, in the same way, the open beard is the sign of a GurSikh's roop in full bloom.
If you ask the Guru how He would like you best, in a tied beard or in an open one, my inner voice says Guru's choice would be that of what his roop was, because He has elevated His Sikh to His own image, and in such a Sikh, He verily sees His own reflection.
WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh.
Re: Singh's Pride
Manpreet Kaur · 24 Jan 2005
My observation on this is that a Singh just doesn't look proud of his Guru roop when his dhaRee is tied or smothered down to his face with sticky stuff or even worse THAT HAIR NET THING! It looks MUCH MUCH better flowing naturally. They look like thay are insecure about it straight up! Whether its poofy, loooong, or just little moocha...SINGHS IT LOOKS BEAUTIFUL!
My father always leaves his dhaRee flowing and I love it. Theres uncles of mine who choose to tie it up and only leave it flowing when theres an akhand paat or on weekends. I'm always telling them it looks better natural without the sticky stuff because IT REALLY DOES. Would Guru really want us to tie it up(trimmed look) or put all these chemicals on it to "keep it in place". Its like the bibiyan bleaching and plucking issue. JUST LEAVE IT NATURAL! Trying to change it to make it look more neat and clean doesn't make sense.
If it has to do with your work, then tie it up at work and take it out right away and make sure that your not just tying it up for the wrong reasons you know. Personally, if it were under my control I would make a rule that Singh hadda leave their dhaRees flowing long and natural....it just looks right! It makes them glow! Plus, I've always loved it when I saw a BaBa riding his bike on a windy day and his dhaRee is split in half flowing over his shoulders:D
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Singh's Pride
Kulbir Singh · 24 Jan 2005
------------
Personally, if it were under my control I would make a rule that Singh hadda leave their dhaRees flowing long and natural
----------
Beautifully said Manpreet Kaur. Shabaash! If you ever stand for president or leadership role in Sikhs, you have my vote. Make sure you pass this law though.
Many Singhs mentioned that they are into certain professions where they have no choice but to tie their beards. My brother-in-law used to work as a machinist sometime ago and used to tie his beard at work. He never used fixo or other sticking materials. He never tied his beard from home and never pressed beard hair on the cheeks. He used to tie a small knot below his chin before entering the plant and immediately open the knot as soon as he got out. Apart from this, he actively sought change of career and today he is working in the IT field and keeps his beard open. In such circumstances it is probably acceptable to tie beard and that too for the sake of safety of the beard.
Those who say that tying beard is a personal thing and has nothing to do with rehit maryada are mistaken and misled. Tying beard must be causing difference in spiritual state because spiritual state is achieved not by hard work alone but also by kirpa of Guru Sahib and kirpa of Guru Sahib cannot befall on a person who disobeys and does chalaaki with Guru Sahib.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Singh's Pride
an opinion · 24 Jan 2005
Of all the myriads of real problems out there, I think this one regarding open beard vs tied-up beard is one of the least important.
In fact, I don't think it's a problem at all. There seems to be an assumption that those who tie their beards have some unconcsious desire to be clean-shaven or are somehow not proud of their appearance. This is simply not true. There may be some, a few, who may feel like this but it is utterly ridiculous to make such a broad generalization.
In some situations, there is no choice (working conditions) and in others, it is a choice. Please don't automatically assume that the choice is being made because the Singh is not proud of his appearance.
My own situation: I wear my beard open the vast majority of the time, probably 362 days out of the year. Sometimes, however, I do tie it up to, gasp, change my appearance. Does tying up my beard on these occassions mean I'm not proud of my appearance? Heck no. I do it because I want to, whether for a change of pace or because I think it might look better with a particular suit, and there is nothing in gurbani or rehit restricting it.
Lets be proud of all our Singhs who maintain their kes, instead of looking down from our high and lofty pedestals and demeaning those who choose to tie their beards.
There are enough divisions in Sikhi without introducing new ones. It never ceases to amaze me how people will choose the most insignificant difference to gratify their own ego - in this case, picking a minor difference to prove to ourselves that we are better Sikhs than those who tie their beards.
Re: Singh's Pride
akj singh 4eva and eva amen · 24 Jan 2005
vjkk vjkf
i have a dhari and its gr8! i would NEVA EVA NEVA tie it up it would feel stupid as well as look dumb. as for tying it up to go with a suit?????? thats not very cleva, appearance counts for nothing, who cares how you look, the most important thing is to stay in guru's roop and not change what he has given, if he gives flowin dhari then keep it, it looks and feels BEAUTIFUL. if my job said i had to tie my dhari up id quit staright away without delay. KEEP UR DHARI UNTIE PLAEZ
vjkk vjkf
Re: Singh's Pride
asdffaaaaa · 24 Jan 2005
Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh
My brother never ties his beard even with a suit, I remember one wedding we went to and everyone told my brother (even after seeing the video of the wedding ) that he was the best lookin guy there and the groom didnt even match up.
my brother had a suit,a turban, and a flowing beard: the Singh look is unbeatable.
Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Singh's Pride
J Singh · 25 Jan 2005
Kulbir Singh Ji, how about singhs who don't wear full baana and wear "colorful" clothes? How about singh with regular trikoni (one with sharp front edge) pagg? Are they also disobeying and doing chalaaki with Guru Sahib? How about singhs who eat too much and allow themselves to get out of shape. Aren't they really disobeying Guru Sahib? No need to go on and on...
Do you really believe that singhs who tie their beard can not achieve spiritual heights? If yes, what do you base your belief on? Is it Guruji's hukam that prohibit us from tying? You do tie a topknot (joora) under your dumalla, right. Don't you see any difference between a tied and trimmed beard!!!
You mentioned Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwalay who, among other things, also said that a hindu should become a good Hindu and a Muslmaan should become a good muslmaan. Do you concur with that? Please respond specifically. You are a highly respected and very well read member of this forum, one who people look up to with admiration. Please judge people based on sikhi rehit, not your own preferences. We shouldn't distort rehit and make up new rehit to fit our personal biases.
Bhul chuk maaf karni.
VJKK VJKF
[%sig%]
Re: Singh's Pride
Mkhalsa · 25 Jan 2005
I have read in a rehat maryada that says dhari should be parkash..
Dhari should always be open. This is a historical fact. Until you prove to me guru sahib said that it is ok to tie dhari, then it is not ok.
Why? because, the reason we have flowing beird and dastar is to be in guru sahib's own image. And in order to have his image, we should have flowing beard.
So if guru sahib didnt say its ok to tie dhari anywhere, then its not ok.
Re: Singh's Pride
gkd · 25 Jan 2005
hey jsingh what do u say? that a hindu shoudl'nt be a good hindu, or a muslim a good muslim?
Re: Singh's Pride
Manpreet Kaur · 25 Jan 2005
"Rehat piyaree mujh ko "SIKH" piyara nahin"
I was just wondering where Guru ji says that, for my own knowledge. If you could shine some light Jarnail Singh ji:)
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Singh's Pride
an opinion · 25 Jan 2005
Dear Veer ji -
You assume far too much. Your reference to "chalaaki" shows the contempt you hold these other Singhs in and how you ASSUME what they are doing is "chalaaki" and how you ASSUME Guru ji's kirpa cannot fall upon them. I'd leave issues of kirpa to Guru ji alone and refrain from looking down at other Singhs. Thank you.
Kulbir Singh wrote:
> Those who say that tying beard is a personal thing and has
> nothing to do with rehit maryada are mistaken and misled. Tying
> beard must be causing difference in spiritual state because
> spiritual state is achieved not by hard work alone but also by
> kirpa of Guru Sahib and kirpa of Guru Sahib cannot befall on a
> person who disobeys and does chalaaki with Guru Sahib.
>
> Daas,
> Kulbir Singh
Re: Singh's Pride
an opinion · 26 Jan 2005
On that same note, Mkhalsa, please prove where Guru ji has said it's not ok to tie the dhari.
You argument is flawed - You could make a similar argument saying prove to me where Guru ji has said it's ok to wear Nike shoes.
If Guru ji has disallowed the tying up of dharis, I will be the first to stop tying my beard (I only tie it up two or three days a year anyways). I'm not saying this to be argumentative - if you can substantiate what you say, I have no problems not tying my beard. If not, then you are simply pushing your own opinions, or the opinions of others, as Guru ji's hukum or rehit.
Mkhalsa wrote:
> I have read in a rehat maryada that says dhari should be
> parkash..
>
> Dhari should always be open. This is a historical fact. Until
> you prove to me guru sahib said that it is ok to tie dhari,
> then it is not ok.
>
> Why? because, the reason we have flowing beird and dastar is to
> be in guru sahib's own image. And in order to have his image,
> we should have flowing beard.
>
> So if guru sahib didnt say its ok to tie dhari anywhere, then
> its not ok.
Re: Singh's Pride
confused · 26 Jan 2005
vjkk vjkf
what one single sensible reason can anyone give me for having to tie up their dhari? (if its work, quit and get anova job) tying up dhari is like ur ashamed of it, if ur a sikh u shud show tht by having big turban and long dhari (UNTIED)
VJKK VJKF
Re: Singh's Pride
J Singh · 26 Jan 2005
No gkd ji, of course I didn't mean that. What I am saying is that we tend to pick 'n choose whatever suits our argument when it comes to great old gursikhs. Lot of sikhs rightfully believe that, in order to achieve sachkhand, one must become a Guru ji ka sikh. i.e. what's the point of becoming a good Hindu or Muslmaan if the true path of Sikhi is right there!
VJKK VJKF
Re: Singh's Pride
charanjeev singh · 25 Jul 2005
"and kirpa of Guru Sahib cannot befall on a
person who disobeys and does chalaaki with Guru Sahib."
i absolutely disagree with that statement. I believe Kirpaa of Guru Sahib can fall unto anybody at anytime. Guru Sahib is not like us. Guru Sahib is very very unique. A statement like that seems to have a lot chaalaki behind it in my opinion (example; i do this; you give me that)
Re: Singh's Pride
Singh · 25 Jul 2005
I’ve always left by beard open, it’s never been an issue for me of any kind. However now I am joining the Police I will slightly tie it and exactly like having it open it simply is not an issue for me. I’m the same person and my rehat is the same. The only difference being sad so called know it all people who have nothing better to do but point fingers at others may look down on me, well who cares.
Re: Singh's Pride
Amar Singh · 25 Jul 2005
The narrow minded idea that Singh’s who tie their dahri are not proud of the saroop or are in some sort of duality does not hold. Just look at the hundreds of thousands of Afghani Singh’s. These true Singh’s have so much love for Sikhi and the Sikhi saroop that they left their homes, properties and even families but did not leave their Sikhi when the Taliban ordered them to become refugees or accept Islam. Who can dare to say these people are not proud of Sikhi or the saroop just because they tie their beards (almost every single Afghani brother ties his dhari). These Singh’s went through all sorts of hardships and everyone of them is Keshdhari, hence just because someone ties their dhari does not make them any less of a Sikh, as proven by the Afghani Sikhs.
Sad how people think that just because they don’t like the look of someones dhari the person tying the dhari is in some way a lesser Sikh to them. How dare someone who has done nothing for Sikhi sit back on thier computer and criticise such Sikhs (Afghani Sikhs) as having no “Singh’s pride”. Its sad that for some narrow minded people the real actions and sacrifices of Singh's speak less, but thier dastar style or dhari length seems to hold more importance.
BTW The SIkh Rehat Maryada does not ban tying the dhari. Nor has Guru Sahib ever said its okay to wear a belt, wear socks, wear a shirt for instance but we still do. As for Guru Ji's own image I take it that you all also carry exactly the same weapons, wear exactly the same clothes, have the same height, ride a horse, keep a hawk on your arm, have a quiver of arrows and bow strung across you etc.
Re: Singh's Pride
Mehtab Singh · 25 Jul 2005
I agree word per word with Bhai Amar Singh. Its not forbidden according to Reht Maryada. I am a manmukh and I tie mine to college. Tried gel initially but I hated it, so use oil now. The best part is this : no one can say its tied, coz it doesn't look close to tied. They think "thats all he has"...LOL!!! Not a single person has been able to guess that I actually tie it coz I don't let it stick to my face like other gel-users do. Makes me wanna puke! Surprisingly I used to walk around with an open one in US, but here in the middle east I tie it...lol. US people need to know more about Sikhs, and so I felt I should keep it open. Over here, people know Sikhs and respect them a lot. If a college going student keeps it open, they may think you are a fanatic, something a Sikh should NEVER become ([i]actually I look forward to shocking my college in the near future by going with it open...ONE DAY!!...lol[/i]). So I wouldn't say I do it to impress someone, or to look modern. If I believed in "When in Rome, do as the Romans do", I'd still probably be a mona..lol. I have my own reasons, and yes I do beg Guruji for strength that one day I may go out without tying it ([i]by the way its tied up only for few hours in a day, so don't jump on me...LOL[/i]) Its the easiest thing to pass judgements and give advice when you yourself are not in that particular situation. Lets not judge or look down on those Singhs who tie their beards for certain unavoidable reasons/circumstances, or who are just getting used to it. Putting someone down is the easiest way of losing them for good.
Re: Singh's Pride
charanjeev singh · 25 Jul 2005
Mehtab Singh, well said. May Guru Sahib Keep His Pavitar Glance on you eternally, and even more than that.
waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh
Re: Singh's Pride
RoopKaur · 25 Jul 2005
>I have my own reasons, and yes I do beg Guruji for strength that one day I may go out without tying it (by the way its tied up only for few hours in a day, so don't jump on me...LOL)<
I think the fact that you ask guru ji for strength shows that you realise it is a weakness to tie your beard.
All of the mahaan Sikhs we respect as a panth today never tied their beards and were against this practice. This should serve as a clue to us. Although mahaan Sikhs like Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Ji, Sant Gurbachan Singh Ji, etc disagreed on some things, but on many gurmat asools they were in total agreement, and this is one of those things they agreed on.
An old rehitnaamaa does infact say that a Sikh should have a 'sidhee dharee'. And guru ji also says that that is a beautiful dharee "jo gur charnee lagan". How is a tied up dharee supposed to do this?
Another point that comes to mind is the sakhi of when Sri Chand Ji visited Sri Guru Ram Das Ji, one of the first things he asked guru ji was why he grew his beard so long. Guru Ji replied to dust the holy feet of saints like you. After such an answer from our own guru ji, how can we tie our dhareeaa up and say it is not against gurmat?
Re: Singh's Pride
RoopKaur · 25 Jul 2005
>Putting someone down is the easiest way of losing them for good.<
We are here discussing gurmat. I am sure the purpose of this thread is not to put people down, but to raise awareness that one should not tie their beard. All gurmat asools should be looked at, and I do not see one that supports tying the dharee, while many are against it. I dont think this should be seen as a put down, but as a way of guru ji showing us what is right and wrong through the medium of this forum.
Re: Singh's Pride
Mehtab Singh · 25 Jul 2005
hanji RoopKaur bhenji you are right. please do ardas for this manmukh...plzz :) ...i admit i m weak in rehit :( ...infact i need ardas of everyone here! help me plzz...i have no sangat either to inspire me...
thanks all...cant wait for the day i stop this crap of tying it...need more strength!
Re: Singh's Pride
Singh · 26 Jul 2005
RoopKaur
"An old rehitnaamaa does infact say that a Sikh should have a 'sidhee dharee'. "
Guru Ji may or may not say many things in so called old rehitnaamaa'a, which one are you refering to? I thought the practise of tying the dhari was not done in Guru Sahibs time in the first instance but over 100 years later.
"And guru ji also says that that is a beautiful dharee "jo gur charnee lagan". How is a tied up dharee supposed to do this?"
You are being very foolish to say the least. First of all don't post unless you can provide refs as its a waste of everyones time, as no one can even check what your saying. If you are thinking about the shabad I think you are you need to understand Gurbani before misrepresenting it. Putting your dhari on the feet of the Guru is NOT actual but means full devotion and humility towards the Guru.
Likewise in the Sakhi with Guru Sahib, Guru Ji is not saying keep an open dhari and go around washing peoples feet with it. Guru Sahib was was showing his real humility and not preaching why we must have long beards. Its almost funny that we forget the meaning of a sakhi or Gurbani and actually use it to put others down, when the sakhi or Gurbnai is revealing the exact opposite ie humility.
Re: Singh's Pride
Kulbir Singh · 26 Jul 2005
--------------
"An old rehitnaamaa does infact say that a Sikh should have a 'sidhee dharee'. "
Guru Ji may or may not say many things in so called old rehitnaamaa'a, which one are you refering to? I thought the practise of tying the dhari was not done in Guru Sahibs time in the first instance but over 100 years later.
--------------
The fact that there is a mention of having a “sidhee daaree” in rehitnama proves that tampering with the natural appearance of the daaree is not acceptable in Gurmat.
----------
"And guru ji also says that that is a beautiful dharee "jo gur charnee lagan". How is a tied up dharee supposed to do this?"
You are being very foolish to say the least. First of all don't post unless you can provide refs as its a waste of everyones time, as no one can even check what your saying. If you are thinking about the shabad I think you are you need to understand Gurbani before misrepresenting it. Putting your dhari on the feet of the Guru is NOT actual but means full devotion and humility towards the Guru.
---------
Roop Kaur is not being foolish but it is you who is being foolish here. True, Guru Sahib means that we should be humble at heart but we should not ignore that the metaphor too has to be true in order to use it as an example. As an example, if Guru Sahib is saying that may he use his hair as chaur to Guru Sahib, Guru Sahib must have long hair to say so. Same way, in order to use the metaphor of touching Guru Sahib’s feet with daaree, one must have daaree as opposed to applying the disgusting sticky material to tie the beard.
As I wrote before, many veers currently for one reason or the other tie their beard. Fine. The problem is when they try to justify and prove that their such cowardly act of tying beard is Gurmat.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Singh's Pride
Singh · 26 Jul 2005
Wow Kulbir Singh you have really out done yourself here. I know you occasionaly take Gurbani at a wrong angle ie trying to argue what angle the Dastar should be based on the Shabad, Gur Mil Uooch Dhamala, lol.
The metaphor of touching the Guru’s charan with the Dhari is exactly that, a metaphor symbolising humility in front of the Gueu. In another shabad Bhagat Kabir Ji talks about doing chaur sahib with the Kesh over Akal Purkh, hence this is obviously not physically possible and is once again a metaphor symbolising humility. Using your rigid thinking I guess you would take Guru Sahib saying keeping the charan in your heart as involving some sort of psychical operation.
Further to the above using your incorrect analyses of the dhari against the Guru’s charan does not hold, as what about Bibia and the young. Are you saying that because they do no have dhari’s they cannot be proper Sikhs as Guru Sahib is saying wipe the Guru’s charan with your dhari.
As for the Rehatnama which one of Guru Sahib’s Rehatnama are you talking about?? I thought you guys always argued that the practice started at Maharaja Ranjit Singhs time, hence perhaps when this practise actually begun this so called Rehatnammah of Guru Sahib’s was adapted?
No one is trying to justify tying the dhari as being Gurmat or not, just as much as no one is trying to justify what type of jura to do. The issue is a non issue for the Panth, but only an issue for narrow minded people who think of themselves as Tat Gurmukh’s while the Sikh’s like those of Afghanistan who have proven their love for Sikhi they shamefully regard a having no Sikhi pride.
Re: Singh's Pride
RoopKaur · 26 Jul 2005
>The issue is a non issue for the Panth, but only an issue for narrow minded people who think of themselves as Tat Gurmukh’s while the Sikh’s like those of Afghanistan who have proven their love for Sikhi they shamefully regard a having no Sikhi pride.<
No one said they did not have pride. What we are discussing here is whether we should be tying dharees or not, whether it is according to gurmat. So far no one has given a reason as to how tying a dharee helps us or is beneficial for our Sikhi? Teh afghani Sikhs must have a lot of pride but probably do not realise that it is wrong to tie up dharee. MAny of us make innocent mistakes like that, but when we realise that it is not right, we (should) stop.
I understand that the dharee on guru jis charn is a metaphor, but like the above post said, how would you wash the feet of guru ji with a tyed up beard? This has nothing to do with bibiaa or children because the metaphor has to do with dhareeaa and not with individuals. And why is doing chaur Sahib of Akal PUrkh impossible? I do not understand what you are trying to say there.
Although you call this a non issue, it is from this so called small issues that bigger issues come from. It is imperative that we start saving and sticking to our puraatn rehitaa instead of letting them be washed away under the waves of open mindedness and modernism.
Re: Singh's Pride
Singh · 27 Jul 2005
RoopKaur
Pan Ji what can I say. With the deepest respect firstly please re-read some posts on this thread, where it has been asserted again and again that those Sikh's who tye the dhari are ashamed of the Saroop and/or have no pride. I don't feel that I have to cut and paste comments fyi, as its clear. The title of the post speaks for itself.
As for the Afghani Sikh, let me tell you they are not stupid as you imply. They know about Gurmat if not more than Punjabi Sikhs and practise it. Just becouse they are doing something which you do not approve of albeit not banned in Sikhi anyway it does not mean they don't know what’s right and wrong in Sikhi. Just because you do not approve does not mean its an innocent mistake, nor due to their lack of knowledge. Suggesting it shows your own arrogance.
As for your vichar concerning washing the feet of the guru with the dhari it IS A METHAPHORE and not something which Guru Sahib is telling us to physically do. Hence it has no relevance to tying the dhari as its not intended as being a physical rite, but is intended to show submission to the Guru. The point about Woman is simply that the bani is A METHAPHORE as Gurbani is intended for all and hence woman can not wash the Guru's feet with thier dhari which shows its A METHAPHORE. In exactly the same way if you care to research Gurbani Bhagat Kabir ji talks of doing charu sahib over Akal Pukh with his Kesh. This is also A METHAPHORE unless you think you can do chaur sahib over Nirankhar with our mortal Kesh. Sorry if you could not understand what I was saying.
As for your comments about Rehatnammas its interesting how people who cannot even follow the Sikh Rehat Maryada talk about old Rehatnammas which in many cases have been corrupted. The only Rehat Maryada which people want to follow is the Maryada which suits thier group accept it or not.
Do not argue with fools, O mortals. Meditate on the Lord, in the state of Nirvaanaa. ||5|| Page 1070, Line 12 -- Guru Ram Das
Re: Singh's Pride
Common Sense · 27 Jul 2005
-----
The problem is when they try to justify and prove that their such cowardly act of tying beard is Gurmat.
-----
Right kulbir Singh, you are the only brave soorma warrior here and all other Gursikhs who tie their beards are cowards.
What is next, all the singhs who wear jeans, pant-shirts, tikoni turbans, kesri keskies, and the list goes on and on, are also cowards. Come on, don't be shy now, lol.
It's not just about tying beard. It's about looking, dressing, acting, behaving just like yourself! Keep it up Singh.
Re: Singh's Pride
Kulbir Singh · 27 Jul 2005
Common Sense,
-------
Right kulbir Singh, you are the only brave soorma warrior here and all other Gursikhs who tie their beards are cowards.
-------
I am no soorma and nor I have claimed to be one. By being sarcastic, you cannot change the truth that tying beard is a weakness and a cowardly act. The fearless Khalsa of Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee goes out without inferiority complex (of having a beard) and with full shaan sport a flowing beard.
---------
What is next, all the singhs who wear jeans, pant-shirts, tikoni turbans, kesri keskies, and the list goes on and on, are also cowards. Come on, don't be shy now, lol.
-------
Guru Sahib's Singhs and Kaurs wear baana with full confidence and as much as possible, they avoid wearing the Western attire.
--------
It's not just about tying beard. It's about looking, dressing, acting, behaving just like yourself! Keep it up Singh.
---------
Shabaash to you for giving very good lesson to the visitors on this site. Perhaps you will get Sach Khand by putting doubts in the minds of Gursikhs who want to sport an open beard. Again Shabaash to you. Keep up the good work. Guru Sahib will probably give you a big shabaash for speaking in favour of mercilessly tying your beard and applying that poo (human excretion) kind of material on your beard to tie it. Shabaash Common Sense. Bahut Khoob!! Subhaan Allaah!!!
1) The fact that a lot of Sikhs tie beard or that a lot of Sikhs in the past have been tying their beard does not make tying beard a Gurmat Asool (principle). Just because the majority does it does not mean that it is acceptable to Guru Sahib. The reality is that Tatt Khalsa or the real Khalsa of Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee can never show the weakness of tying his beard. Only Kachay Pillay Shehri (urban people), Sukh-rehniye (delicate) Sikhs do this. Tyaar bar Tyaar Khalsa of Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee can never do the manmukhi karam of tying his beard. A person who ties his beard can never have kirpa of Guru Sahib.
2) Think about it. When Guru Sahib says that don’t cut your hair from any part of the body, he logically has a picture of Khalsa in his mind. The hair of the head are tied since we wear a Dastaar but why how can any Sikh justify tying the beard?
3) Tying beard gives you the look that you would get if you had trimmed your beard. In other words, the Sikh who ties beard is making a mute statement that the look of trimming beard is better than that of the flowing beard. When Guru Sahib told us not to cut hair and have a dastaar on your head, he must have had an image of a tyaar bar tyaar Khalsa in his head. To break this image by tying beard is wrong.
4) A person who ties beard can never do sewa in Punj Pyaaray while his beard is tied. This proves that such person is not tyaar bar tyaar.
5) As for doing such jobs where one’s beard can get in the way, one does not have to tie one’s beard by using fixo or other such despicable lotions. One can do a lose knot underneath and open it as soon as the job is done. I know one Gursikh, who used to work as a machinist. He used to do up a lose knot while on the machine and open it immediately after his work was done.
6) It is hard to believe that to do the job of a warrior i.e. something like military or police, one has to tie one’s beard. Saying that they tie their beard because it can be pulled in cases of scuffles is a lame excuse. A lot of things can happen in accidents. Police personnel get shot in the head while on duty. What do they do to cover their head and face, all the time? Police personnel can get slapped or punched on the face. What do they do to protect their face? Whatever they do to protect from getting punched can be applied to protect your beard. If you talk about beard, what about your hair in the head. Turban can come off really easily when in scuffles. Can’t they pull your hair then? What would you do then? So the essence of the story is that just because there is a chance that your beard can be pulled does not mean that you would became a cat and tie your beard. Stay a Babbar Sher and never tie your beard.
7) People tie beards for different reasons. Some tie it for job and others tie it since they can't face the society. The worse ones are those ones who tie beard to make their wives happy or for other kaam reasons. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee calls such deplorable Sikhs Vehshi Dangars (savage beasts).
Tying beard is a big weakness that Sikhs must get rid of. Guru Sahib kirpa karan.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Singh's Pride
Common Sense · 27 Jul 2005
The fact is the tying beard is NOT prohibited by my Guru Sahib's rehit. I follow the rehit of my Guru Sahib, not some made-up stuff by some Kachay Pillay internet preachers who want nothing but control everyone else like taskmasters. I love and respect everything about great puratan Singhs but I am not about aping what they wore and I am not going to go to work with my kashera and a wrapped-around blanket alone. I am a Singh (a lion of Guru Sahib) who goes everywhere with full confidence and without and superiority complex, not some sheep who follows everything that some aira, gaira, nathu-khaira leads them to believe.
---------
What is next, all the singhs who wear jeans, pant-shirts, tikoni turbans, kesri keskies, and the list goes on and on, are also cowards. Come on, don't be shy now, lol.
-------
Guru Sahib's Singhs and Kaurs wear baana with full confidence and as much as possible, they avoid wearing the Western attire.
--------
Than stop being a hypocrite Singh. Apply your logic to everything in your life. If you believe that western ways are against Gurmat (yourmatt), STOP using your car or any western means of transportation, heat/air conditioner/gas, Internet, tv, money/education/banking systems, English language, and the list goes on and on. Almost all the advancement in science, engineering, medicine, and many many other fields were made by non baana wearing people but you use them everyday. Guru Sahib choose those people over you!! LIVE WHAT YOU PREACH.
Guru Sahib is my maan-taan
Re: Singh's Pride
Kulbir Singh · 27 Jul 2005
Common Sense,
-------------
The fact is the tying beard is NOT prohibited by my Guru Sahib's rehit. I follow the rehit of my Guru Sahib, not some made-up stuff by some Kachay Pillay internet preachers who want nothing but control everyone else like taskmasters.
--------
How do you know about this fact? Today you are saying that tying beard is not prohibited and tomorrow someone like you is going to say that dyeing beard is not a problem. As for who is a kacha pilla, one who ties beard or one who doesn’t? Sangat knows the answer very well. Try saying with your beard tied, in a Gurdwara that you are not a Kacha Pilla and then see how many laughters you will prompt. Try doing sewa in Punj Pyaaray with you tied beard. Try doing katha with your tied beard.
. If you had been humble after tying beard and had accepted your mistake then it would have been okay but now I have no hesitation in saying that you are not only Kacha Pilla but "Maha Kacha Pilla", "Charuaasi daa maal", "Dabroo Ghusroo".
---------
I love and respect everything about great puratan Singhs but I am not about aping what they wore and I am not going to go to work with my kashera and a wrapped-around blanket alone.
---------
Very nice! You love what puraatan Singhs do but you are going to imitate what your real heroes i.e. the Goray do. You love Puraatan Singhs but you are going not going to wear what they used to wear because (as it evident from your sarcastic post) you don’t want to go to work with your kashera and a wrapped-around blanket alone. Well then go to work with the baandar kachhee (that baandars wear, monkey underwear). You don’t like kashera. Fine. Go wear a baandar kachhee then.
------------
I am a Singh (a lion of Guru Sahib) who goes everywhere with full confidence and without and superiority complex, not some sheep who follows everything that some aira, gaira, nathu-khaira leads them to believe.
---------
You are a lion of Guru Gobind singh jee but as you stated, you are not going to wear a kachherra. To me you sound like a jackal, who is scared to be like other lions. What kind of lion are you then who is scared to wear a kachherra to work along with chola (something you call blanket wrapped around, shabaaash)? It is pseudo-lions like you who have done damage to Sikhi.
-----------
Than stop being a hypocrite Singh. Apply your logic to everything in your life. If you believe that western ways are against Gurmat (yourmatt), STOP using your car or any western means of transportation, heat/air conditioner/gas, Internet, tv, money/education/banking systems, English language, and the list goes on and on. Almost all the advancement in science, engineering, medicine, and many many other fields were made by non baana wearing people but you use them everyday. Guru Sahib choose those people over you!! LIVE WHAT YOU PREACH.
-----------
Even though you call yourself “common sense” the above paragraph is more of a non-sense. There is no prohibition on using the advancements of science and these cannot be compared to rehit. To compare tying beard to learning English can only come from so called “common sense” like you.
----------
Guru Sahib is my maan-taan
--------
“Guru Sahib is my maan-taan, but I will mercilessly tie my beard and apply poo on it”. Shabaash! If Guru Sahib is your maan taan, then why are you justifying tying your beard?
I will repeat that I have nothing personal against individuals who tie their beard but persons like you who do chori and then seena-zori i.e. who first violate rehit and then want to justify their actions, are doing big damage to Sikhi. If you want to drown in this ocean go ahead and drown, but why are you inspiring others to follow you and like cowards tie their beards.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Singh's Pride
dear Kulbir Singh · 27 Jul 2005
Dear Kulbir Singh -
Please do not assume someone tying their beard is cowardly or ashamed of their appearance or ignorant of Sikh rehit.
Having read through this long thread, I have seen very little in the way of strong argument for why tying beards is anti-gurmat or cowardly or anything else. These are simply opinions, nothing more.
Furthermore, I fail to see how wearing a chola is gurmat and wearing clothes like jeans or shirts is anti-gurmat. Cholas were simply the type of clothing worn during a particular period - they were worn by muslims, hindus and sikhs alike.
Also, I doubt it if all Sikhs, from Guru Nanak Dev Ji's time to Guru Gobind Singh ji's time wore the same type of clothing. Even during Guru Gobind Singh ji's time, I doubt if all Sikhs wore the same type of clothing. It was just clothing! What was important was the Punj Kakkars.
If you look today, Nihangs wear different clothing than those typically worn by the Damdami Taksal, by people like Sant Jarnail Singh ji Bhindranwale. Is one group wearing 'bana' and one group not? Is a pajama kurta 'bana'?
Its only clothing - if someone feels comfortable in a chola, excellent but also excellent for that person who likes wearing his long kurta-kachera combo and that person who favors t-shirts and sweat pants.
respectfully yours,
one singh
[%sig%]
Re: Singh's Pride
Common Sense · 28 Jul 2005
I don't wear a kashera??? Where did you get that from? What part of 'I love and respect everything about great puratan Singhs but I am not about aping what they wore and I am not going to go to work with my kashera and a wrapped-around blanket ALONE' don't you understand? Where is your bebek-budhi Singh? Wrapped-around blanket Doesn't mean chola. It means the chaader that puratan Singhs used to wear with kashera. Atleast read before posting. If you can't even understand a simple line, how could you ever understand the message of my Guru Sahib.
Go ahead and wear a kashera with a chaader to your work/office BUT REMEMBER you are not going to become a fearless saint-warrior by imitating and aping what puratan singhs wore. A jackal can't become a lion by JUST dressing up like one!
----
“Guru Sahib is my maan-taan, but I will mercilessly tie my beard and apply poo on it”.
-----
As I said on the other thread, it's your contempt and hate towards thousand and thousands of great Singhs who tie beards that is making me start tying my beard.
-----
Even though you call yourself “common sense” the above paragraph is more of a non-sense. There is no prohibition on using the advancements of science and these cannot be compared to rehit. To compare tying beard to learning English can only come from so called “common sense” like you.
-----
You are the one who is making up your own rehit left and right and telling people how western ways are all against Gurmat. Apply it to yourself and STOP using everything western. There is no prohibition on tying beard, wearing jeans or pant-shirt.
I follow the rehit of my Guru Sahib who is full of prem, not stuff preached by some kacha-pilla aira-gaira nathu-khaira leader type who changes sikhi everyday to accommodate his needs.
Re: Singh's Pride
RoopKaur · 28 Jul 2005
Some reasons why Singhs should not tie their dharee:
1. Singhs are shers, and shers are proud of their mane. Can you imagine a sher with his main all stuffed up into a cagelike gauze?
2. Singhs should be the image of Guru Gobind Singh Ji, and guru ji always had a prakash dharee
3. Singhs should look at the beautiful faces of the chardi kalaa Gursikhs of our times, who all support a flowing dharee.
4. SInghs should learn from gurbani, even if they are metaphors, they should think about their implications. Singhs should think about the reason why guru ji used the metaphor of a flowing beard.
5. Many mahaan Singhs have spoken against this practice. If we dont follow the jeevans of chardi kalaa SInghs, whos will we follow?
6. By wearing the dharee a person is trying to fit a a look defined by society. What is wrong with the look defined by our guru ji with a dastaara on our heads and a flowing dharee that we fall to the one defined by society?
Now give my ONE way tying up the dharee helpd you in your SIkhi.
Re: Singh's Pride
RoopKaur · 28 Jul 2005
Singh,
To say one might not know about gurmat is not to say they are stupid. There is no person out there besides guru ji who knows everything about gurmat. We are always learning, as we are Sikhs. Please do not get too sensitive and read too much into what I wrote. Every person is always learning.
To so called COmmon Sense
To talk against wearing bana and calling this aping other SIkhs has got to be one of the lowest things I have read. If we dont do rees of puraatan Singhs who's rees will we do, yours? Sikhs have lost a lot of their puraatan reetaa and new dhillaa are being entrenched into our community. For example, we are losing the dastaaraa, and the patka has plagued our panth now, and after the patka, the next epidemic which we are seeing is monaa pun. Same with dharee, we went from a beautiful flowing dharee to a tied one and now we are seeing this trend of trimming and next step getting rid of it altogether. Before you write against aping puraatan SInghs and "modernising" please think deeply about the future of the panth as well as we keep changing puraatan traditions.
Re: Singh's Pride
Common Sense · 28 Jul 2005
So called Roop Kaur, you seems to be having selective reading problems. I am responding to all the insults and hatred being dished out to thousands and thousands of Singhs who tie their beards. Don't you consider those Singhs to be brothers! Why would I be against banna and open beard. I am against people who spew venom against Singhs wearing jeans, pant-shirts, not keeping complete sarbloh bebik, and the list goes on. If you want to do it out of pyar, by all means, do it but don't demean others who don't submit your wishes. Believe it or not, Guru Gobind Singh ji Maharaj's dress was very very similar to the pehraava of that time. Pick up any history book of that time and you will see people like shivaji and others wore very much the same dress. The difference is they were GURU SAHIB!!
Re: Singh's Pride
Shaaktishali Sha Soora · 28 Jul 2005
VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh
The real reason so many people have started to tie their beards and are making so many excuses about this is because the way Kalyugs working now. He’s made beards seem abnormal due to the way white people think of it like. Remember that in all the other Yugs every person had dhari and they fought great wars as well without the concern of it being pulled BECAUSE it was treated as a normal thing not something abnormal that should not be there since everyone now thinks it gets in the way of things. Kalyug lives to corrupt Sikhi by making anything it’s about seem weird and annoying to others. As Kalyugs used everyone that’s not a Sikh, think negative about keeping a beard even though it’s a completely normal thing to have. It’s what makes a man basically a man unless if any of you are trying to be like women. Leave the beard open freely show the world it’s a normal thing to have eg. it doesn’t get in the way of anything, etc.
jug jug faer vattaaeeahi giaanee bujhehi thaahi ||
In age after age they change; the spiritually wise understand this.
I personally think it’s a ridiculous thing to tie your beard, I know that some of the Sikhs who went to those British wars tied their beard but to me they looked ridiculous and nothing like Guru Gobind Singh ji’s type children.
Now this is to Kulbir Singh Jee concerning western clothing,
I disagree with your statement about Gursikhs wearing western clothing. I’v read every post on all your arguments and I think what you’re saying is rarely concretely good advice. Since I know a lot of Sikhs here in Britain that wear bana at Ransbaeaa and have committed sins such as adultery. The outside does not reflect on your inside. Western type of clothing should be aloud to be worn and not just Bana. The soul should be focused on, remember that the soul turns ugly due to the sins and not the clothing you wear on the body. So he/she that wears western clothing should not be judged as a sinner due to what I’ve mentioned before about the Sikhs who wear Bana and have done wrong things. Its upto the Gursikh what he/she wants to wear.
vaes karae kuroop kulakhanee man khottai koorriaar ||
She may wear good clothes, but the bride is ugly and rude; her mind is false and impure.
What is the point on arguing on minor worldly problems when the most important thing is to do Naam Bhagti and dye your soul in the colour of Vaheguru Jee.
parehar sabhae saak s ra(n)g ra(n)geevanaa||
Repudiating all worldly connections he must remain dyed in the colour of the Lord.
VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh
Re: Singh's Pride
RoopKaur · 28 Jul 2005
>The outside does not reflect on your inside.<
But your inside should reflect your outside. Just like our face shows when we are happy sad etc, that is how a Sikhs SIkhi and commitment to guru ji should show on the outside. To wear the dress of someone else is to submit to them. I understand that in some cases it may be difficult to wear bana, but one must try to wear the Khalsa uniform at all times if posssible, to show that we are the ghulaams of GUru ji only, not western society.
I agree that people wear bana and do commit acts they should not, but this does not mean that we should not wear bana. There are people who support the look of Sikhs but do not do the acts of Sikhs, now should all Sikhs stop wearing dastaars? Of course not. A person is judged on their acts, and wearing bana is just another act of devotion to guru ji.
Re: Singh's Pride
Admin · 28 Jul 2005
Topic Closed