Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

High priests ban books by Kala Afghana

High priests ban books by Kala Afghana

Kulbir Singh · 04 Apr 2003

High priests ban books by Kala Afghana Varinder Walia Tribune News Service Amritsar, April 4 The Sikh clergy at a meeting, at Akal Takht secretariat here today banned books by Canada-based cop-turned Sikh scholar Gurbax Singh Kala Afghana for allegedly distorting Sikh history. Reading, buying or re-printing of the controversial books have been banned. The Sikh high priests have also summoned Mr Kala Afghana to explain his position by May 10 at Akal Takht. Earlier, Mr Kala Afghana was allowed to clarify his position via video-conferencing as he had pleaded that he could be arrested as he entered India for his links with Sant Jarnail Singh Bhinderanwale. "Ill health" was another reason for seeking exemption from appearing at Akal Takht. However, the video conferencing could not he held due to non-cooperation of the SGPC which did not provide needed infrastructure to the Sikh high priests for conferencing with Kala Afghana. Mr Kala Afghana authored a set of 10 books — "Bipran Ki Rit Ton Sach da Marg". The foreword to one of the books of Mr Kala Afghana was written by Mr Gurtej Singh, National Professor of Sikhism. The meeting was attended by Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti, Jathedar Akal Takht, Giani Balwant Singh Nandgarh, Jathedar Takht Damdama Sahib, Giani Tarlochan Singh, acting Jathedar Keshgarh Sahib, Giani Bhagwan Singh, Head Granthi Akal Takht and Giani Jagtar Singh, Granthi Golden Temple. The Sikh high priests have also decided to seek clarification from Mr Jarnail Singh Dogranwala, husband of Bibi Bhajan Kaur Dogranwala, an SGPC member from Kapurthala District, allegedly for assaulting Mr Harjinder Singh, a 'parcharak' of the SGPC's Dharm Parchar Committee. Mr Harjinder Singh had complained that Mr Dogranwala pulled his beard. He had alleged that he was deputed by Mr Jaswinder Singh Advocate, an SGPC member to arrange a 'religious one act play' at Kapurthala. However, when he (Harjinder Singh) went to the house of Mr Dogranwala to inform him about the proposed play, he was allegedly beaten up. Akal Takht today turned down the request of Prof Manjit Singh, a former Jathedar, Keshgarh Sahib, for seeking report from the SGPC as to why he was removed from the post. The high priests, however, decided that the matter was sub judice as case was pending with the Sikh Judicial Commission challenging the removal of Prof Manjit Singh. It was also decided to pose a question to Prof Manjit Singh, whether he had any faith in the SGPC, Akal Takht or the Sikh judicial commission. The high priests were of the view that though Prof Manjit Singh had not filed a petition before the Sikh Gurdwara Judicial Commission. He had got it done by proxy.

Re: High priests ban books by Kala Afghana

singh · 12 May 2006

which jathebandi working openly against kala afgana I dont know any one jathebandi's name? If any body know please told me

Re: High priests ban books by Kala Afghana

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 14 May 2006

1. First of all there is no such thing as "high Priests" in Gurmatt. 2. Secondly there is NO EXCOMMUNICATION or banning of any books etc in the Sikh Rehat Maryada - anyone disputes this please provide the page number and relevant quote. 3. These High priests are political appointees of persons who have HIJACKED the Sikh religion....thus they have absolutely no moral ground. 4. They are appointed and sacked at will of the political MASTERS..and their Hukmanams are politically motivated. 5. So far not one genuine case has been satisfactorily settled...the aggrieved parties ahd to go to CIVIL COURT to get justice. as BEFORE..these high prists are not that high....they have vested interets as the following history proves... Important Note: Bhai kahn Singh nabha was very aggressive and outspoken... his writings especially HUM HINDU NAHIN angered the High priests of that time..BUT they didnt lift a finger to EXCOMMUNICATE Kahn singh nabha becasue he was BACKED 110% SOLIDLY by maharaja Hira Singh nabha State.... the High priest then EXCOMMUNICATED a POOR SIKH who had no backing..Prof GURMUKH SINGH - who was REINSTATED By the High priests a few years back !!! ( Without any attempt by prof Gurmukh Singh to seek Forgiveness..etc becasue he is already long dead ..but even when ALIVE prof Gurmukh Singh just IGNOREd the High priests.) I may be wrong..but i have Downloaded ALL KA Books, Read them thoroughly...and ENJOY them immensely. There is PLENTY i DONT AGREE WITH.... PLENTY I ABHOR.....but still a lot of GURMATT is there....I also LOVE and Respecct my father Guru gobind Singh ji just as much as the next Singh ...and I SUBSCRIBE to Rozana SPOKESMAN... (sent extra to be LIFE MEMBER and PATRON )and PRINT EXTRA copies to distribute in the Gurdwaras...because CONTRARY to whatever the HP say..there is not an iota of anti-gurmatt in RS..BUT PLENTY of Anti Gurmatt in the Jalandharee Akhbaar which badal LOVES and the HP supports as Panthic ??? a lot of people may not like this "attitude" of mine...but then i always had an independent mind...I LOOK to ONLY MY GURU..for GUIDANCE...Manukh kee tek birthee jaan...High priests are just as human as KA - BOTH can be RIGHT and BOTH can be WRONG !!! BUT NOT my GURU SAHIB....

Re: High priests ban books by Kala Afghana

some12 · 14 May 2006

ahah Heigh priests who can be fired. retarted.