Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Golden Temple to get trained women ragis

Golden Temple to get trained women ragis

Tribune News Service · 22 Jan 2005

Golden Temple to get trained women ragis Tribune News Service Amritsar, January 22 The women ragis who will be well versed with the Gurmat raagas will be available for presenting their performance from the Golden Temple from next year for the first time, thanks to Punjabi University. Bibi Jagir Kaur, President, SGPC, had publicly announced that whenever there will be trained women ragis, they would be given a chance to perform kirtan from the sanctum sanctorum. Dr Gurnam Singh, Prof and Head, Department of Gurmat Sangeet and Head of Gurmat Sangeet Chair, Punjabi University, Patiala, said that half of the students of MA, Gurmat musicology, being run by the varsity were girls.

Re: Golden Temple to get trained women ragis

Singh · 22 Jan 2005

[sarcasm on] OH MY GOD. Society as we know it, is going to collapse. The panth will now fall into a complete period of darkness and disgrace. May god help us all.

Re: Golden Temple to get trained women ragis

theorist · 23 Jan 2005

i think the women should have the same uniform that is demanded of the males raagis, EG. baanaa, dastaar etc...

Re: Golden Temple to get trained women ragis

gkd · 23 Jan 2005

singhs will be filled with kaam, what 2 do? [%sig%]

Re: Golden Temple to get trained women ragis

Singh · 23 Jan 2005

I hope they wear dastars.

Re: Golden Temple to get trained women ragis

blech · 24 Jan 2005

What about the men??

Re: Golden Temple to get trained women ragis

. · 24 Jan 2005

wow. it only took them 100 years. good on ya jagir kaur

Re: Golden Temple to get trained women ragis

Kabadi · 25 Jan 2005

dont give any respect to jagir kaur, isnt she a kurri maar?

Re: Golden Temple to get trained women ragis

Anon Singh · 25 Jan 2005

These trained Ragi Singhnis should strike Bibi Jagir on the head with their dilrubas, sairangis and other weighty classical instruments.

Re: Golden Temple to get trained women ragis

Rashminder Singh · 25 Jan 2005

hope they all wear dastaar else i dont see any chardikala

Re: Golden Temple to get trained women ragis

Kulbir Singh · 25 Jan 2005

------------ dont give any respect to jagir kaur, isnt she a kurri maar? ------------ While there is a high likelihood that Bibi Jagir Kaur actually got her daughter killed but there still is a possibility that she did not commit this crime. She has not been convicted by Law and the case is still going on. Another thing is that the Kurri-maar rehit that was included in Khalsa rehit pertained to new-born daughters and not grown up daughters. In those days, people used to kill their new born female babies and to curb this evil practice Guru Sahib strictly ordered his Sikhs to not indulge in such practice. Bibi Jagir Kaur is accused of killing her grown up daughter who ran away with a monna guy and brought disgrace to her family. While killing in such circumstances too is a paap but is not classified as a Kurri-Maar Kurehit. This is just my opinion and I very much could be wrong on this. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Golden Temple to get trained women ragis

jss · 25 Jan 2005

kulbir singh ji, wasn't jagir's daughter pregnant with a daughter herself....that's wht i heard....if that's true, THEN she not only killed her daughter but also killed an infant yet to be born....

Re: Golden Temple to get trained women ragis

sahajdhari · 26 Jan 2005

jagir kaur is a kurri maaar !!!!!!!!! :@, one of the biggest sinners shaping the future of the panth disgusting!

Re: Golden Temple to get trained women ragis

tree cutter · 26 Jan 2005

well a kurri is a girl maar is to kill so she killed the girl. and i maybe wrong but i have heard it was to do with the fact that the boy was from a poor family or out of caste not sure. But we do not know for fact what the motives were so we should not assume what i said or assume it was to do with him being a mona. I have never in my life heard of anyone killing their daughter for going with a mona. Something very similar happened in scotland. A family got their daughter killed after she ran off with a low caste. But because he had converted to buddhist, the papers said it was out of religion and blamed sikhi for it. This looked very bad nationally for sikhs who were now being looked upon for honour killings on par with pakistanis. Then the recent case of mr dosaanj on triple murder attempt on his daughter 's male friend. I do not believe its to do with religion but more to do with culture. Mr dosaanj was a mona. The papers again claimed it was dishonour to sikhism thats why he did it. This is all crap, its about dishonour to the mans name in society why do these people use sikhism as a defence point?

Re: Golden Temple to get trained women ragis

Jarnail singh gyani · 26 Jan 2005

waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru ji Ki fateh. Although I "agree" with Kulbir Singh on the "kurri maar" in Sikh Rehat Maryada....he has taken a rather "technical" view just like "defence" lawyers take !! A Kurri is a GIRL..and someone who kills a GIRL for any reason and at any age fits the description of Kurri Maar. Otherwise those who BURN their Nuuhaan/wives/ for DOWRY would "escape" this Law Otherwise those who KILL their teenage daughters for the transgression of forbidden love would escape this Law Otherwise those who kill their wives to marry again/marry their mistress etc would also escape. GURU JI cited this LAW in the REHAT for ....SPECIFIC FEMALE FOETAL ABORTION/KILLING/DISPOSAL..because this was MOST PREVALENT at that time ( IT still is judging by the mushrooming number of clinics where a Foetus can be checked for GENDER and then ABORTED..leading to a serious DECLINE in the Female Population of PUNJAB) But no matter if the Law is sepcifically meant for the foetal abortionists/newborn girl baby killers...the Dowry Killers and Love Killers should also get classified and hanged under this Rehat law. AS even Bhagat kabir Says..Larrka mareh na koi....NO one KILLS a MALE.( forgive me if this is out of context) ..even though it may be illegetimate/low caste/black in colour/deformed etc etc..a MALE is always "treasured"..a Male may marry a low caste/non religious/even a prostitute... people will accept ands say..koii nee jee mundae eddhan de he hunde hai.. BIBI Jagir Kaur being a person of high position..has been "accused"...she should have RESIGNED immediately...so as not to bring aDAAG to her post...BUT she ahs clung to power in spite of that....and she is guilty of "clinging to power"..and doesnt have my respect. Jarnail Singh

Re: Golden Temple to get trained women ragis

tree cutter · 27 Jan 2005

one other thing i do not understand why do these men not get their sons killed when they do exactly the same thing, if its such a disgrace? why ONLY the girls? hence kurri maars even more. who are they to play God and decide the fate of another life? a life is supposed to be a gift from God. Then they have the audacity to use sikhi as some kind of a bargaining point in court and make us all look like lunatics on news. It is not about sikhism it is about their own honourable name in society. they cannot deal with the shame and find retribution is the only way. i hope punjabis sikhs change from inside from peoples homes first. Guru ji gave all the equality and freedom to sikh women, but after they left men turned back the clock pre sikhism and pushed women down again. Then we moan and whinge when a girl leaves and blame her as if its the families "bad karam". down down with inequality, and Jagir Kaur although this is good step we need much more reform and she knows it. But the politics surrounding her are male dominated hence her moves will always be strategic whilst balancing her own reputation with it, and i very much doubt she will bring more reform.

Re: Golden Temple to get trained women ragis

banoh singh shaddoh bling · 27 Jan 2005

if we want to promote equality it has to start at home in our daily lives too with our sisters, mums, wives, daughters. We must share responsibilities where we can, and work as a unit, co operate and communicate as individuals and equal parts of a whole. If we sort it out daily in our homes, then the ragi bit will fall in place. In my early days into sikhi, i knew a person who had just taken amrit. She told me " my brother is like gods gift to my family, they give him everything, hes got it all, attension, brains, looks, a future, but i am just a girl to them". I never payed attension to what she meant, i thought we all go through random moments. A lot happened - That person is now not even a sikh and has changed religions. Theres a lot more to it but i wil not say. But we better change our attitude quick and fast or we will loose out. Put yourself in that position. Woman ragi is not enough. Women should be pardaans, in charge of panthic affairs, i would love to see a singhani president of khalistan, Singhanis representing us on every front and having their respectful rightful place in sikhi as equal to man in every way. It would be good if sgpc changed their rules to include amritdharis from outside india. power to singhaniz!

Re: Golden Temple to get trained women ragis

Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 31 Jan 2005

I agree with Giani JS Arshi ji, Banno Singh and tree cutter.They have echoed all I could have said. I have verhemently written against bibi jagir Kaur elsewhere for the simple reason that she has not acted with a sense of responsibility.rather with love for the KURSI has been greater for her than the humilation of the PANTH>SHOULD SHE BE FOUND TO BE INDEED GUILTY OR INVOLVED IN THE KILLING OF HER DAUGHTER. Bibi Jagir Kaur is only the tip of the iceberg of the mentality that prevails the political leaders of the Panth-main jivaaa'n Panth doobe!! Any Sikh,including Dr Harjindar Singh Dilgeer, who in order to give some credance to Jagir kaurs act, wrote that it is the religious duty of any Sikh father to kill a daughter who bores an illegitimate child-is NOT a Sikh. While there is no doubt there is severe pain when an errant child commits any act of disrepute,but to then use religion for its cover, is GROSSLY misrepresenting the Sikh religion and MISLEADING the SIKH people by their pathethic mitigation. Dr HS DILGEER then tried to get out of this situation,by claiming all sorts of childish excuses to what he really meant,does NOT excuse that he is wrong in his views,which really have NO place in todays society. My concern is it is not time for female Sikh ragis to celeberate.While no conditions out of ordinary are attached to the male Sikhs, why did the women deserve to have conditions attached to their doing kirtan in the Harimander sahib.The answer is- they have yet again been treated LESS favourably than men.Is this another ploy to keep women OUT of the harimander sahib kirtan? Equallity does NOT come with conditions attached to one sex, and a more favourable avenue to the other sex!Which is exactly ,what has happend, and it is called SEX DISCRIMINATION-yet again!!! When will the Sikh clergy wake up and realise they are caught out yet again and are really living in the 18th century!!!! Really, have they any sense ?NO.Vedanti had NO business to advise Sikhs of canada in the affairs of their own country. Why does he NOT look into the 1984 holocust and get the justice that the Sikh victims deserve,instead of interfering stupidly into the Canadian affairs!!!!! Gurcharan Singh Kulim