Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Q...?

Q...?

singh · 25 Jan 2005

in Bhai Randhir Singhs autobiography did the alchemist in Hazaribagh prison attain enlightenment without getting naam from the Panj Piyare? after Bhai Sahib prayed for him?

Re: Q...?

. · 27 Jan 2005

surely someone has read the book?

Re: Q...?

Mkhalsa · 27 Jan 2005

He was lucky enough to get naam drirh straight from guru sahib. Guru sahib himself did kirpa on this gursikh as he could not actually get naam drirh elsewhere, being in jail and all. I know of a few other gursikhs personally that this has happened to. Naam drirh from panj pyare obviously just gets you there faster and teaches you proper vidhya of naam.

Re: Q...?

... · 27 Jan 2005

didn't bhai sahib himself also receive naam straight from guru sahib while in prison as well?

Re: Q...?

jss · 27 Jan 2005

so you're saying that it's possible to get naam straight from guru sahib??? how so???... isn't this one of the things that YOU use against "sant/babas".... why the exception all of a sudden....

Re: Q...?

confused???? · 28 Jan 2005

so there's exceptions? you don't need the panj for naam simran?

Re: Q...?

gur ka laal · 28 Jan 2005

i thought guru gobind singh ji gave the naam giving ability to the panj, and no one but the punj can give that gift, no one person can, each of the 5 beloveds musit give u naam, i heard that Guru gobing singh ji himself didnt give naam to anyone after his pyaray were established, that gift was handed to the punj, if guru sahib was to still give naam then why pass that ability to his his punj.

Re: Q...?

asdf · 28 Jan 2005

when there was no material possibility, then i think that you can step outside of the worldly boundaries....not sure though as worldly maryada is observed by one and all the same.

Re: Q...?

WHY WHY WHY · 28 Jan 2005

Whats going on why why why I ask this world will be destoryed why I ask

Re: Q...?

Mkhalsa · 28 Jan 2005

haha, I knew this would happen. How could I use naam drirh against sant babas? Please tell me, I may want to use that argument, as I dont ever remember doing so. haha.. I won't pretend to know how any of this works, but I will explain from teh best of my ability. We all know there are different stages of naam simran, beginner, saas giraas, ajapaa jap.. Now while someone may start off without naam drirh and still do simran insanely with devotion, if they are lucky, perhaps they will move up to the next stage within 10 yeras, if not, perhaps they could be 50-60 before they even realize that there is something more (I know of quite a few cases like this as well). Now, wouldnt it be easier to just learn how to do it from guru sahib himself? when he has made the path to sikhi so easy for us, and made it so easy for one to gain avastha and do bhagti at an alarming rate, why not jump at that oppurtunity? Thats pretty much what I can say.. Also, if you are gonna say, well why not learn a higher stage, as far as I can see, saas saas simran is the last stage that can be taught, ie the last stage that is done outside and inside.. etc Please do correct me if I am wrong here singho.

Re: Q...?

Manpreet Kaur · 28 Jan 2005

ahh what if punj pyareh didn't give you naaam dhir?

Re: Q...?

anon · 28 Jan 2005

>> Now while someone may start off without naam drirh and still do simran insanely with devotion, if they are lucky, perhaps they will move up to the next stage within 10 yeras, if not, perhaps they could be 50-60 before they even realize that there is something more >> If you so simran insanely with devotion, if you are lucky, you will move to the next stage within 10 yeras or when you are 50-60. wow I did not know that before. I guess you learn something new everyday...

Re: Q...?

jus wondering · 29 Jan 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh manpreet bhenji has a point, what if the punj pyareh do not give you naam drih?? [%sig%]

Re: Q...?

asdf · 29 Jan 2005

MKhalsa can you tell me some more secrets about the naam simran?

Re: Q...?

Mkhalsa · 29 Jan 2005

>>Author: Manpreet Kaur Date: 01-28-05 20:22 ahh what if punj pyareh didn't give you naaam dhir?<<< Go back and ask them to at the next amrit sanchar! >>Author: asdf Date: 01-29-05 10:09 MKhalsa can you tell me some more secrets about the naam simran?<< No, as this moorakh doesnt know any secrets of naam simran. I suggest you go ask guru sahib or panj pyare.

Re: Q...?

. · 29 Jan 2005

Yea i wana kno too!