Re: Coma? Soul?
warrior*princess · 10 Jul 2003
I will try to find it, but i think in Gurbanee it says how being in a coma is a very horrible state for a human to be in.
I.e. one is neither alive nor dead. The body lays in pain without being able to move.
Re: Coma? Soul?
Kulbir Singh · 10 Jul 2003
We cannot generalize what happens to the jeev-aatma when a person is in coma.
In some cases, it is possible that the aatma suffers punishments and has to go through hell being stuck in the body that is not functioning. Imagine if the aatma were conscious that it is in a coma but cannot do anything about it. The aatma may be aware of what is going on but cannot signal this to anyone. It has to endure years of suffering. Just the pain of lying on back for years can be extremely painful.
On the other hand in some cases where the jeev-aatma has been living life according to Gurmat, the punishments previously ordained by Vaheguru are greatly reduced (not eliminated). In such cases, the jeev-aatma would not feel anything and Coma would be very much like a deep sleep.
It all depends on one’s karma.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Coma? Soul?
Jarnail Singh "Arshi" · 11 Jul 2003
Waheguru jI kA kHALSA
Waheguru jI kI FATEH.
IMHO, only Waheguru knows the TRUTH.
All rest is mere conjecture. Man doesnt even know where in our body the soul resides.
Everything is in the HUKM......... WE who have all our faculties around us SHOULD make the outmost of them and jaap the Naam while there is TIME.......who knows what may happen next........the boy in coma has :lost" 19 years....or HAS HE REALLY ? how do we know......Gurbani tells us that even in the WOMB, the unborn foetus is in LIV and direct contact with Waheguru japping His Naam.... the same could be TRUE of a Comatose Body ?? ONLY WAHEGURU KNOWS. Its idle time waster for us to speculate on Waheguru's Work...We must concentrate on OURs.
Dassan dass Jarnail singh
Re: Coma? Soul?
jagga sandhu · 13 Jul 2003
if they are not concious in a coma then wud the soul be there or somewhere else? i remember reading bhai rama singhs book when he was in a coma state he was in a different place.
Re: Coma? Soul?
domalla premee · 13 Jul 2003
Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh
The soul is there so long as the body remains alive. It is there till death comes. The soul trapped in a body that is experiencing a fully comatose or peristent vegitative state can simply not give expression because there is damage to the brain. A person is literally trapped in this body and helpless. I have seen people who have had a stroke whose only way of expression was through the eyes. I can't imagine being in that situation. Yet if you read Gurbanee aloud and being in mind (silent simran) with the Guru touch them gently you can see the respirations, heart rate and blood pressure slow and decrease and their brow relax in peace. If you are there when they are dying and recite Gurbanee they become more peaceful. Gurbanee and simran really touch others in ways they may not understand at the mind and senses level but certainly the all-knowing soul yearns for it. The soothing benefit is always transferred to the receptor so naturally benevolent is it by nature.
dass