Hukmnama...dilemma
Jarnail singh gyani · 25 Jan 2005
waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru ji Ki fateh.
A student recently came to me with a personal question.
He like many others is in the daily habit of going to matha tek in the local gurdwara, have darshan of Guru ji, and read the Hukmnama written on the Notice Board.
Now withe the mushrooming of "Daily Hukmnama from Darbar sahib Amrtisar" everywhere including mobile phones etc... he questions which Hukmnama takes precedence ? The local one or Amritsar one ? Can we just disregard the local one (IF we have already heard the Amritsar one or Vice Versa ) /? IF one has already heard the Amrtisar Hukmnma in the Car while on the way to Gurdwara is it still advisable to read the local one ??
Some of his friends who used to go to the Gurdwara for the daily reading of the Hukm have stopped doing so since they can now hear the hukm from Amrtisar... Is the hukmanam from Amrtisar actually 'discouraging" local Visits ?? Shouldnt we be encouraging local Visits and local HUKMNamas that are more Persoanl and emaningful ??
What do the sangat think ?? Valuable input for my students.
jarnail singh
Re: Hukmnama...dilemma
Chand-Tora SIngh · 26 Jan 2005
OR you can take it as several advices from Maharaj?
One might say - Don't slander
other might say stay away from ego
etc :D
Re: Hukmnama...dilemma
Kulbir Singh · 26 Jan 2005
The hukamnama at Darbar Sahib – Siri Amritsar Sahib is for the whole Panth. In 1984 and other big events it was observed and is recorded that the Hukamnamas from Siri Darbar Sahib were in accordance to the events taking place. These hukamnamas were for the whole panth to obey and pertained to the whole panth as opposed to an individual. This is just my opinion, that's all.
I personally believe in hearing the hukamnama directly from Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee at home or at Gurdwara Sahib we go to in the morning.
I don’t think hearing or reading hukamnama from Darbar Sahib can replace going to the local Gurdwara Sahib and hearing hukamnama there.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Hukmnama...dilemma
Kulwinder Singh · 28 Jan 2005
Most Important thing to understand is that Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is available to nearly all Sikhs for the Darshan and Daily Hukamnama. The whole point of being in Sikhism is it is very local and very personal path for everybody. The Darshan of Shri Darbar Sahib Amritsar is Ultra Mega useful but , GOD is everywhere and Guru also want you to do Sangat Darshan.
So if you just read the hukam nama daily from the internet and do not reflect in your life or learn anything from it , the usefulness of it is then limited to just being a ritual, and Guru Nanak want us to be away from just rituals if they do not serve any meaning in life's betterment, If you go to do the darshan yourself then it connect you more with other Guru Sikhs, but again If you go to the temple just as ritual and learn nothing, change nothing then it is also not very fruit full, although I do not discourage anybody from following it, if that is what they do. But the Idea of having love for the Guru is you want to change your life and learn more from Guru.
It is paramount that you go to your local Gurdwara then just surfing the internet.
Khalsa is being active, being local, being personal being aware, being tackling the local issues, helping local, national and international needs.
Internet serve great deal of good for humanity, but still doing something physically is far more fruitful then digitally reading.
These are my personal feelings. I do not intend to hurt anybody if I am doing that then I am sorry. Take what you like from the writing other wise just ignore it. Everybody is individual and Everybody have their own way and style, But always remember we Only have One GURU SHRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI, we are all children, some are very wise, some are learning, some are starting point, some do not listen and some like me are right naughty.
Thanks , Guru Kirpa Kare, we all see love in each other eyes and words.
Re: Hukmnama...dilemma
Jasvir kaur · 30 Jan 2005
my dad used to say at the end of his katha/kirtan/lecture...
Sadh sangat Ji, jo aap ko Gurmatt ansaar lageh, parwaan karna, jo meri matt lageh sutt denah...
Do the same to every post...Take the Good, the Gurmatt..and discard the rest. That way we learn from each other and dont argue..because what is arguable is always personal opinions ( like I have on Sant babas)..
love for all like Kulwinder singh ji says above..
Jasvir Kaur
Re: Hukmnama...dilemma
Kulwinder Singh · 30 Jan 2005
Thanks Jasvir Kaur ji for kind words.