Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Bhai Talwara jee blamed for Kala Afghana's excommunication

Bhai Talwara jee blamed for Kala Afghana's excommunication

Kulbir Singh · 13 Jul 2003

In a press statement, Rajinder Singh of Khalsa Panchayat alleged Bhai Joginder Singh jee Talwara to have played a vital role in the excommunication of Kala Afghana. If Bhai Talwara jee did play a role in this, I personally am proud of his efforts. We need people like Bhai Talwara jee who have influence in the political circles of the Panth. It seems like Bhai Rajinder Singh of Khalsa Panchayat is tilted towards Kala Afghana and this is very disappointing for this daas. I had high hopes on Khalsa Panchayat convener Bhai Rajinder Singh. If he holds negative views about panthik saints and scholars like Bhai Randhir Singh jee, I am not very upbeat about the future of our Panth. I hope I have misunderstood Bhai Rajinder Singh jee's statement. Could someone please confirm. Daas, Kulbir Singh Khalsa panchayat removes panch Ex-communication of Kala Afghana Tribune News Service Amritsar, July 13 In a significant development, the Shiromani Khalsa Panchayat (SKP) today removed Mr Kashmir Singh as its panch for supporting the Sikh clergy which led to the ex-communication of Mr Gurbax Singh Kala Afghana, a Canada-based cop-turned-Sikh scholar. This was stated by Bhai Rajinder Singh, convener of the SKP, while talking to TNS here today. He alleged that the ex-communication would create division in the Panth. Mr Kashmir Singh was one of the five panches of the SKP. He said he had not received any communication from Bhai Rajinder Singh either in writing or verbal regarding his removal as panch. However, he said he would not react on his expulsion as he had acted as per his conscience. Since Mr Kala Afghana had indulged in blasphemous acts, it was his “religious duty” to present the case before the clergy against him, he said. Bhai Rajinder Singh who had been spearheading the campaign for the removal of Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti on “corruption” charges, said the clerics had again tried to create a wedge in the Panth by pronouncing ex parte ex-communication. While ex-communicating Mr Kala Afghana, the clergy had announced that it would initiate action against those who extended support to him. The clergy had also pronounced that Mr Kala Afghana had been violating edicts issued from time to time and had failed to appear before Akal Takht though he had been given sufficient time to clarify his position. However, Bhai Rajinder Singh alleged that Jathedar Vedanti had backtracked on the promise to appoint a 10-member committee of Sikh intellectuals to resolve the matter. He claimed that Mr Karnail Singh Panjoli, a youth Akali leader (close to Mr Gurcharan Singh Tohra), and Mr Kanwarpal Singh, spokesman of the Dal Khalsa, had been mediating between supporters of Mr Kala Afghana and Jathedar Vedanti. During mediation, Jathedar Vedanti had agreed in principle to constitute the committee giving due representation to both groups and neutral persons. However, he did a volte-face, saying that the “efforts” had been leaked out, he said. The SKP has pleaded before the clergy to review the edict to avoid an ugly situation. However, sources close to the high priests said the edict once issued could not be reviewed. Bhai Rajinder Singh said Mr Kala Afghana had to face the music for his “bold writing” and criticism of Bhai Randhir Singh, founder of the Akhand Kirtani Jatha. He alleged that Bhai Joginder Singh Talwara, member of the jatha who was critical of the clergy for absolving Mr Parkash Singh Badal, had played a vital role in the ex-communication of Mr Kala Afghana

Re: Bhai Talwara jee blamed for Kala Afghana's excommunication

Navjot Singh · 14 Jul 2003

Their leader Rajinder Singh was approached many times, through his lawyer Navkirin Singh regarding Kala-Afghana, but he continues to take a pro-Kala Afghana stand. He also has close relations to Gurtej Singh OISS, a staunch supporter of Kala who was representing him at Akal Takht Sahib. So this statement is no surprise. We have been told that there is a large split amongst the Pachayat due to this issue. Many believe that some of the leaders in this group (and even the groups itself) was planted to by certain agencies to create havoc and confusion within the Panth, and now we are seeing proof of this. Their leaders seem to carry a personal grudge against Vedantee, for them anything Vedantee does is wrong. They really don’t seem to care about the harm Kala and his group are doing to the Panth, they see Kala as an ally against their common foe (Vedantee.) I really haven’t been impressed by their leadership whose habit seems to be backtracking on every ultimatum they give. If you study any of their press statements their leaders don’t seem very mature, and many Singhs are suspicious of their intentions. Another item to note is that the Kala lobby is working hard to establish a Khalsa Panchayat office in North America. With leaders such as Rajinder Singh it is just a matter of time before that happens. Hopefully this group will clean house and oust those who are working against Panthic interests. - Navjot Singh

Re: Bhai Talwara jee blamed for Kala Afghana's excommunication

question · 14 Jul 2003

what is khalsa panchayt? what do they stand for? is it a different panchayt from akji panchayt?

Re: Bhai Talwara jee blamed for Kala Afghana's excommunication

Kulbir Singh · 14 Jul 2003

Shiromini Khalsa Panchayat is totally different from the Parbandhaki Panchayan group of AKJ. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhai Talwara jee blamed for Kala Afghana's excommunication

tarlochen singh uk · 14 Jul 2003

the panchayn word defines the management of 5 not a jathedar or whatever the adopted term is now. yes the akji prabandhki panchayan is different from the khalsa one, and well done to talwara ji for making a stand and upholding our jathas core principles.

Re: Bhai Talwara jee blamed for Kala Afghana's excommunication

lost individual · 14 Jul 2003

I dont get it, what did Talwara Ji stand up against? The fact that Jatha doesn't need 5 leaders? please explain in detail...

Re: Bhai Talwara jee blamed for Kala Afghana's excommunication

Kulbir Singh · 14 Jul 2003

lost individual wrote: > I dont get it, what did Talwara Ji stand up against? The > fact that Jatha doesn't need 5 leaders? please explain in > detail... This was not about whether jatha should have 5 or 1 leader. Talwara jee played a role in getting Kala Afghana kicked out of panth. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhai Talwara jee blamed for Kala Afghana's excommunication

Sukhdev Singh · 14 Jul 2003

veer kulbir singh, now that kala is kicked out of the panth, he will not carry on as a sikh individual? i do not think by kicking out someone from the panth is going to change that individual, no matter how gravely his sins are.

Re: Bhai Talwara jee blamed for Kala Afghana's excommunication

Kulbir Singh · 16 Jul 2003

Based on a news in ajitjalandhar.com today. The statements by supporters of Kala Afghana in today’s paper are very alarming. Some scholars have questioned the jurisdiction of Siri Akal Takhat in excommunicating Kala Afghana from Panth. The panth at this time is on a very crucial junction. Many scholars led by IAS officer Sardar Gurtej Singh, editors of Spokesman and many others have openly revolted against the Akal Takhat decision to oust Kala Afghana from Panth. They are planning to do a big conference to discuss the strategy to counter this assault on Kala Afghana. They have gone so far in attacking the Akal Takhat decision that they are now questioning the right or jurisdiction of Siri Akal Takhat in ousting a person from Sikhi. This is a very bad occurrence. This is going to make our Panth very weak. I think they are being very short-sighted in this case. I deeply appreciate the panthik sewa of Sardar Gurtej Singh, Spokesman and other scholars standing in favour of Kala Afghana and I appeal to these scholars to not to undermine Siri Akal Takhat and it’s jurisdiction in order to support Kala Afghana. I also have a fear that these respected scholars, whose services are critically needed by the panth, will be reduced to dust if they don’t stop challenging Siri Akal Takhat. I don’t want this to happen and I hope that instead of fighting Siri Akal Takhat Sahib, they will try to persuade Kala Afghana to admit his mistakes and ask for forgiveness from Panth. And please stop comparing Kala Afghana’s excommunication from Panth to that of great scholar and Gursikh – Professor Gurmukh Singh. Professor Gurmukh Singh was ousted from panth, by not Panth but by Hindu-minded pujaaris (priests) who were subsequently thrown out of their positions of authority. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhai Talwara jee blamed for Kala Afghana's excommunication

SS · 16 Jul 2003

who was Professor Gurmukh Singh? and why was he excommunicated?