Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Is Sikhi the only Way to God

Is Sikhi the only Way to God

nobody · 17 Jul 2003

> Try hard to understand that > > and that Guru Gobind Singh ji planted ONE flower in Sat > Kartar's garden, not the ONLY flower. >Please backup your assertion that Guru Gobind Singh jee planted one >flower of Sikhi in garden of Akal Purakh. I don't think you can say that >Sikhi is just one of many flowers in this garden. >It seems like you believe that Sikhi is one of many ways to Sikhi. Does >Gurbani backup this claim? >Daas, >Kulbir Singh Veer Ji what is the difference between sikhs that think khalsa(amritdharis) will rule the orld, or muslims that believe just as strongly they will rule the world, or christians that passionately believe that Jesus is the ONLY way and that...wait for it....they will rule the world? Why do people of all religions including sikhs have this need to believe they will rule the world? How does that help the indiviual on the spiritual path, when Guru Nanak Maharaj ji says that he says no hopes of living and no anxiety about dying. Why do we live in hopes of having khalsa raaj? Why not focus ondoing simran every moment and trust in AkalPurakh doing the right thing for ALL his children. Next question, SiriGuru Granth Sahib ji has many bhagats bani in it. They were not Amritdhari khalsa of Guru Gobind Singh ji? So there are many flowers in Sat Kartars Garden. Its not more complicated than that. Even gurbani says that the bhagats come in every age. So it means there were divine souls before guru nanak dev ji maharaj, during the ten satgurus time on Earth and Akal Purakh will keep sending his bhagats for all time. Planting more and more flowers. That is the beauty of Siri Guru Granth Sahib ji that teaches us what other religions find hard to accept, that there is many ways to the top of the mountain. Religion is not Truth, religion is the PATH to Truth. At the top of the Mountain, there is no more paths, just Truth....Guru Gobind singh ji himself says that I bow to God who has no religion (Namastang Amajbe). And funnily enough if you hold these universal views close to your heart, you will have more love for ALL people of the world and guess what they will have more love for you and think yes Sikhi is truly a great religion, and decide to join sikhi becuase it is differnt from all the narrow minded people in other religions. The one eyed people as bhagat kabir ji calls them in gurbani. thanks

Re: Is Sikhi the only Way to God

. · 17 Jul 2003

everything else some wise gurmukh will answer u. khalsa raj isnt a dream its written in our second most important script the guide dasam granth ji which tells us of many things, what kind of things sikhs will face and have, how sikhs will suffer then prosper. (amazing thing is a lot of the stuff written down has already come out and is coming out true such as water shortages, sikhs being killed off, unchastity, how sikhs will take birth in various places across the world and how gorey were reincarnated as sikhs drinking and doing sins and bringing home multiple partners at the time while future sikhs will come from pathan, french, white, russian, chinese, hindu and turk wombs. How shaheed singhs stay close to sikhs then will move away when they see sins committed, how shaheed singhs help the panth. So much is written down ul have to read it yourself and that will explain khalsa raj in detail going through the chapters. All this mentioned is in the sau sakhi chapters of dasam.

Re: Is Sikhi the only Way to God

Balpreet Singh · 17 Jul 2003

From an earlier discussion with someone about the unique nature of Gurmat and 'salvation'. From the very inception of Gurmat, it has been declared a unique and distinct path: Guru Amar Das instructs the Sikhs to not weep after him, as was the custom and furthermore says “do not bother with offering rice-balls on leaves, lighting lamps, and other rituals like floating the body out on the Ganges. ” All these instructions were clearly in opposition to the traditional death rituals of the Hindus. These lines are found in "Ramkali Sadd" Bhai Gurdas writes: "the Guru has created the mighty Gurmukh panth. This panth keeps itself away from the boundaries of the Vedas and the Semitic scriptures...” (Bhai Gurdas, 23.19) SGGS over and over stresses the importance of "Gurmat Naam". Without Gurmat Naam no one can find Akaal or reach sachkhand. Gurmat naam is only available in the house of Guru Nanak: "Nanak kai ghar keval, naam" . Keval means "only". Without naam, no one can find God. GurbaaNee is clear about htis fact: naanuk naam binaa ko mukath n hoee Translation:O Nanak, without the Naam, the Name of the Lord, no one is liberated Where is this naam to be found? From the Guru. bin gur naam n paaeiaa jaae Translation:Without the Guru, the Naam cannot be obtained. Satguru Nanak is the only true Guru who has preached naam, and given gurmat-naam. As for other acts of "religion", this is what Guru Nanak says: theeruthh thup dhaeiaa dhuth dhaan || Pilgrimages, austere discipline, compassion and charity jae ko paavai thil kaa maan || these, by themselves, bring only an iota of merit. suniaa mu(n)niaa man keethaa bhaao || Listening and believing with love and humility in your mind, a(n)thurugath theerathh mal naao || cleanse yourself with the Name, at the sacred shrine deep within....... So, unless someone receives Gurmat Naam from Guru Nanak, there is no liberation. They will be rewarded for their good karma, but not liberated. They don't want liberation! Christians are content with heaven, and they wil recieve it. But then they will enter the cycle of births and deaths again, hopefully in a life which will bring them closer to liberation. Gurmat Panth's respect of all religions goes as far as saying that they are not sent to eternal hell, they will get what they work for. Like Harmandir Saahib: God is open and available to all directions and all people of the world, but the path to God is ONE. Gurmat About other faiths: eik jainee oujhurr paae dhhuruhu khuaaeiaa || Some are Jains, wasting their time in the wilderness; by their pre-ordained destiny, they are ruined. panna 1285 hi(n)dhoo a(n)nhaa thurukoo kaanaa || The Hindu is blind; the Muslim has only one eye. panna 875 In many other places it is made clear that Gurmat, the way of the Giani, who meditates on Gurmat Naam is the only path to akaal. Others will get their heaven etc. but not find akaal. As for bhagat-baaNee being from "Muslims and Hindus", it's a proven fact by the likes of Giani Gurdit Singh in his books and others that the Bhagats, under the leadership of Ramanand jee all became Sikhs of Guru Nanak after meeting him. The Fareed in BaaNee is the descendant of the first and this is borne out by the fact that the language used is not 12th century but contemporary to Guru Nanak. Giani Gurdit Singh's book is very big and contains a lot of proof about the Bhagats being Sikhs, but two important points are that the most puraatan pothees ie. Goindvaal Pothees refer to the bhgats as "Bhagat Babay Kay" or Bhagats of the Baba (Nanak). Also, the Bhagat's Banee in SGGS is not found in their own collections. Ie. Kabeer's baaNee in SGGS is not found in his Beejak. The BaaNee they recited after becoming Sikhs is the one in SGGS and not found in their original collections. All faiths will get what they work towards. Only Gurmat has a concept such as Sach Khand and God-Realisation in such a clear way. Thus, Gurmat is the only path to Sach Khand and merger with Akaal.

Re: Is Sikhi the only Way to God

singh · 17 Jul 2003

>>>>>>>>Gurmat naam is only available in the house of Guru Nanak: "Nanak kai ghar keval, naam" . Keval means "only".<<<<<<<<< From my limited understanding I am not quite sure this line has the meaning attributed to it here. Nanak ke ghar keval naam expresses that Nanak's house/religion is all about naam, filled with naam rather than other things. This line is not suggesting, as I understand it, that naam is only available from Nanak's house or that without Sikhi there is or can be no naam. Sikhi to the max singh's translate it in the following way; bhairo mehalaa 5 || Bhairao, Fifth Mehl: eaehu ahaeraa keeno dhaan || God has given this gift. naanak kai ghar kaeval naam ||4||4|| Nanak's home is filled with the Naam, the Name of the Lord. ||4||4|| [%sig%]

Re: Is Sikhi the only Way to God

singh · 17 Jul 2003

Following on from my last post, I forgot to further comment on this point <<<<<<<>>>>>>>>> Now just on the other thread there is the mention of puratan bhagat parhlad. This bhagat clearly did not get his gurmantar from the house of Nanak as he was before Guru's time. He japped raam raam and in his regard Gurbani mentions (From Asa di Vaar) aasaa mehalaa 4 || Aasaa, Fourth Mehl: har jug jug bhagath oupaaeiaa paij rakhadhaa aaeiaa raam raajae || In each and every age, He creates His devotees and preserves their honor, O Lord King. haranaakhas dhusatt har maariaa prehalaadh tharaaeiaa || The Lord killed the wicked Harnaakhash, and saved Prahlaad.

Re: Is Sikhi the only Way to God

Kulbir Singh · 17 Jul 2003

singh wrote: > >>>>>>>>Gurmat naam is only available in the house of Guru > Nanak: "Nanak kai ghar keval, naam" . Keval means > "only".<<<<<<<<< > > From my limited understanding I am not quite sure this line > has the meaning attributed to it here. Nanak ke ghar keval naam > expresses that Nanak's house/religion is all about naam, filled > with naam rather than other things. This line is not > suggesting, as I understand it, that naam is only available > from Nanak's house or that without Sikhi there is or can be no > naam. > > Sikhi to the max singh's translate it in the following way; > > > > bhairo mehalaa 5 || > Bhairao, Fifth Mehl: > > eaehu ahaeraa keeno dhaan || > God has given this gift. > > naanak kai ghar kaeval naam ||4||4|| > Nanak's home is filled with the Naam, the Name of the Lord. > ||4||4|| Keval means only. How can we translate "Keval" to mean filled with? On what basis? If we say that Guru Nanak's house has only Naam then we violate the following pankiti: SACHAI SAHIBA KYAA NAHI GHAR TERE|| GHAR TAAN TERE SABH KICHH HAI, JIS DEVE SO PAAVAI|| Gurmat Naam is only in the house of Guru Nanak. Other houses have Kirtam naams i.e. qualititive naams but not Sacha naam i.e. Naam Gurmantr. Without the turu Guru, Naam cannot be obtained and who else is a true Guru but Guru Nanak and his 10 manisfestations? Please provide a Gurbani pankiti to backup your claim that other religions have Gurmat Naam. If they don't have Gurmat Naam, then they certainly cannot reach Sach Khand. Yes they can reach high stages but not to Sach Khand. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Is Sikhi the only Way to God

Kulbir Singh · 17 Jul 2003

>>>>> <<<<<<<>>>>>>>>> Now just on the other thread there is the mention of puratan bhagat parhlad. This bhagat clearly did not get his gurmantar from the house of Nanak as he was before Guru's time. He japped raam raam and in his regard Gurbani mentions (From Asa di Vaar) aasaa mehalaa 4 || Aasaa, Fourth Mehl: har jug jug bhagath oupaaeiaa paij rakhadhaa aaeiaa raam raajae || In each and every age, He creates His devotees and preserves their honor, O Lord King. haranaakhas dhusatt har maariaa prehalaadh tharaaeiaa || The Lord killed the wicked Harnaakhash, and saved Prahlaad. >>>>>>>>> First of all we need to realize that Bhagat Prahlaad was saved just as many bhagats from olden times were saved. They were saved and not taken to Sach Khand. They ended up in great heights of this creation but that does not mean they went to Sach Khand. Dropadi was saved from getting naked by Vaheguru and the elephant was saved from the crocodile. Then Ajamal was saved from Jammdoots and Ganika was saved from Jammdoots. Does it mean that whoever was saved from a difficult time ended up in Sach Khand? The concept of Sach Khand was unknown to humankind before Guru Nanak’s arrival Guru Nanak Sahib told the world about Sack Khand and that there are many regions and realm below this eternal place. Bhagat Prahlaad did not have Satnaam and did not go to Sachkhand at the time he was saved by NarSingh Avtaar. Now maybe he has taken birth in the house of Guru Nanak and ended up in Sachkhand. Ajamal and Ganika were saved from Jammdoots but that does not mean that they went to Sach Khand. Sach Khand is a realm of Gurmukhs and only ones who have Gurmat Naam can reach there. If it was possible to get salvation without Gurmat Naam, why did that jogi sit in smaadhi waiting for Kalyug and Guru Nanak. I am talking about that yogi who was discovered when the sarovar of Santokhsar was being dug. This yogi told the sangat that he had found out through his mystical powers that no matter what he does, he cannot get to the ultimate goal of being united with Vaheguru. He found out that in Kalyug when Guru Nanak Sahib arrives, he will be delivered. The first question he asked was whether it was Kalyug and if Guru Nanak Sahib had arrived. After getting Naam from Guru Arjun Dev jee, he left for Sach Khand soon after. He had massive bhagti but without the stamp of Gurmat Naam, no one can get to Sach Khand. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Is Sikhi the only Way to God

singh · 17 Jul 2003

<<<<<<<<>>>>>>>>> This is a very bold statement veer ji! I have never come across this line of argument before. Where has this been stated or alternatively if this is an inference how do you draw it? The line from gurbani which I previously stated was aasaa mehalaa 4 || Aasaa, Fourth Mehl: har jug jug bhagath oupaaeiaa paij rakhadhaa aaeiaa raam raajae || In each and every age, He creates His devotees and preserves their honor, O Lord King. haranaakhas dhusatt har maariaa prehalaadh tharaaeiaa || The Lord killed the wicked Harnaakhash, and saved Prahlaad. The word used here is 'tharaiaa'. We read this idea of par othara, thanra, liberation, swimming the world ocean etc many a time in Guru Granth sahib. It is used not only in respect of saving bhagats as per the above line but also in relation to liberation through naam simran. For example gourree mehalaa 5 maajh || Gauree, Fifth Mehl, Maajh: har har naam japae jap thariaa jeeo || Chanting and meditating on the Name of the Lord, Har, Har, I have been saved. eihu ajar naanak sukh seheeai jeeo ||4||2||167|| Nanak endures this unendurable celestial bliss. ||4||2||167|| Now, is the word 'tharia' of the above line materially different from the one used in the line about Bhagat Prahlad? If it was so would Guru ji not have made that distinction clear by prefacing tharna with Sachkhand for one and not the other? As I said I have not come across this line of argument before, perhaps its just me. A humble benti therefore to comment further on this. [%sig%]

Re: Is Sikhi the only Way to God

to · 17 Jul 2003

Guru Raamdas Jee writes on ANG 995: dhroo prahlaad bidar dhaasee suth guramukh naam tharae (Dhroo bhagat, Prahlaad bhagat, son of a Dasi Bider—all of them became Gurmukhs and crossed the world over.) So this Tukh indicates that Dhru, Prahlaad, and Bider got Naam and became Gurmukhs. But Guru Nanak Dev Jee was not born in there Yug, but is not possible that maybe Guru Nanak Dev Jee came to them in his spiritual form and gave them Naam Dhi Dhaat? Since they did naam simran, it is not possible that they also reached Sachkhand?

Re: Is Sikhi the only Way to God

nobody · 18 Jul 2003

satnaam satnaam satnaam ji waheguru waheguru waheguru ji wonderful wonderful wonderful Akal Purakh Ji, look at all the hoops we are jumping through if we believe no one got to sachkhand before guru nanak maharaj? And that no one had naam before guru nanak maharaj. If we believe that, then the life of the bhagats who gave mind body and soul to Akal Purakh Ji has to be re-written. We have to start believing that they became sikhs of guru nanak dev ji, or that they must have been spiritually divne naam by guru nanak ji hundred of years before he took human form, or that the bhagats were reborn as the punj piaray (yes i have heard that too). Please it is my humble request that we open both our eyes instead of being one-eyed like the Muslims. Put aside what we think we know and read siri guru granth sahib ji with an open mind for Truth and accept what siri guru granth sahib ji is saying to us. Do not try and impose our beliefs onto siri guru granth sahib ji meaning we have to rewrite history and make supernatural explanations for something that is very simple. Very simple example is look at gravity. Did gravity only come into existence when the apple fell on Newton's head and he had his 'A-HAA moment'? In a similar way spiritual laws have always been there and the great souls have revealed the Truth. But as time goes on the Truth gets buried in rituals, superstitions, lack of understanding etc and more great souls arrive on Earth and reveal the Truth again in a simple way for the people of their time and place. And Guru Nanak Maharaj Ji revealed it in a very simple, humble and easy way for one and all. And more than that Guru Sahibs also looked back at explained very simply who the great souls were from the past and what they did so we can learn that they too were True and worthy of respect and worthy of having bhagat bani included in siri guru granth sahib ji. Because when the soul merged with the Ocean of Sukh, Akal Purakh, then there is no ego and it is only Akal Purakh speaking through the body of the bhagat or the SatGuru Ji and it is all the Word of God. People at the enlightened stage are referred to as Gurmukh by Gurbani. Guru Nanak Maharaj as well as being called Satguru, Guru, Baba, also is refered to as Gurmukh by Bhai Gurdas Ji, even Patanjali the founfer of Yoga gets referred to as Gurmukh Patanjali ji, and there are 5 more people in Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji who are called Gurmukhs like Raja Janak, Prahlad, Dhru, Vidura, Vibheeshana By becoming a Gurmukh, Prahlaada meditated on the Divine, and was emancipated (sggs 591). Dhruva, Prahlaada and Vidura the slave-girl's son, became Gurmukh, and through the Divine Name, crossed over: the ocean of worldliness (sggs 995). By becoming a Gurmukh, Janak lovingly centered his consciousness on the Divine Name (sggs 591). The Gurmukh Vibheeshana reveals the secret — how to kill the Raavana of ego (sggs 942). (more explanation of who these great Gurmukhs were is on http://www.gurbani.org/webart158.htm ) So if all these great souls were Gurmukhs, then they are part of the Gurmukh Panth as quoted earlier >Bhai Gurdas writes: "the Guru has created the mighty Gurmukh panth. >This panth keeps itself away from the boundaries of the Vedas and the >Semitic scriptures...” (Bhai Gurdas, 23.19) So you have to ask yourself if they were all on the Gurmukh Path, then what do we all have in common. And the simple answer is that on the Gurmukh path, the soul needs the Satguru who blesses it with the Gurprasadi Naam , and congregates in the Sat Sangat. Just as each age has bhagats , each age has had Satguru's and Gurprasadi Naam. Bhai Gurdas Ji does not reject all that has gone before Guru Nanak Dev Ji . The Guru Sahib do not reject all that has gone before, no they openly embrace the True Ones to their chest and put them side by side with them in Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji and say to us Sikhs (students) ---> learn from ALL these Gurmukhs my friends. What Bhai Gurdas Ji does emphasise is that just as previous ages had their own SatGurus and naam. Now is the time of Satguru Nanak Maharaj and His Naam, and just as in previous ages there was guru -disciple relationship you can do that with guru nanak ji and satnaam waheguru. That is what the last verse of Var 1 means to me where he describes the origins of Waheguru. If we stop thinking of Naam as only the word "Waheguru", you will realise that Naam is actually the light ,power and divine amrit of the Eternal Being. Naam is energy , naam is the force that permeates the Creation , read sukhmani sahib ji about naam. And Siri Guru Granth Sahib ji says in places that the shabad itself is naam l. When the Satguru blesses you with naam, gurprasadi naam , He has blessed you with a way of getting intune with the Naam that pervades all around us. ( http://www.gurbani.org/webart22.htm REALIZATION OF THE SHABAD OR NAAM ) http://www.gurbani.org/webart20.htm SHABAD-NAAM-BANI-GURBANI: WHAT IS IT? ) servant of God servants (trying to be!)

Re: Is Sikhi the only Way to God

nobody · 18 Jul 2003

You said veer ji: > bhairo mehalaa 5 || > Bhairao, Fifth Mehl: > > eaehu ahaeraa keeno dhaan || > God has given this gift. > > naanak kai ghar kaeval naam ||4||4|| > Nanak's home is filled with the Naam, the Name of the Lord. > ||4||4|| >Keval means only. How can we translate "Keval" to mean filled with? On >what basis? > >If we say that Guru Nanak's house has only Naam then we violate the >following pankiti: > >SACHAI SAHIBA KYAA NAHI GHAR TERE|| >GHAR TAAN TERE SABH KICHH HAI, JIS DEVE SO PAAVAI|| ----- naanak kai ghar kaeval naam ||4||4|| Nanak's home is filled with the Naam, the Name of the Lord. ||4||4|| This translation means In the House of Nanak there is Only Naam. And if you have Naam , you have everything, Naam permeates everything. so it is not contradictory to the second SACHAI SAHIBA KYAA NAHI GHAR TERE|| GHAR TAAN TERE SABH KICHH HAI, JIS DEVE SO PAAVAI|| Infact you know as well as i do that all of SGGS Ji teaches us not to ask for anything but God's prasises and Naam (mango daan takur naam), to ask for anything else is nothing but headaches.... (sir dukha ka dukh). And by fulling with naam, with nothing but naam we enjoy all the happinesses , all the sukhs all the pleasures we thought we were going to get from worldly things....lakh kushiaa patshaheeiaa je satgur nadar karaay...if the satguru gives us the lok of grace we enjoy hundreds and thousands of kingly joys. There is no contradiction veer jee. thanks

Re: Is Sikhi the only Way to God

nobody · 18 Jul 2003

IF you accept that in the Gurmukh panth there have been many Gurmukhs as mentioned pre-Guru Nanak Dev Ji, and that they were each a flower in Sat Kartar Ji's garden. Then when those flowers were trampled on by the tyrants, out of joy Akal Purakh created another beautiful flower with thorns - the Khalsa ..Khalsa akal Purakh kee fauj, Khalsa Pramathma kee mauj. And this Khalsa Fauj was to protect the saints and destroy the tyrants as Guru Gobind Singh Ji has written about his autobigraphy. Isn't that beuatiful that as Khalsa we are here to protect the saints and destroy the tyrants. We are not here to destroy the saints and become tyrants. We are here to protect the bhagats that are on the gurmukh panth (even thought they may not be khalsa fauj or look like us or follow our religious lable). Akal Purakh ji is so beaautfil and loves His bhagats and is hungry for your love, gobind bhau bhagat ka bhukka

Re: Is Sikhi the only Way to God

. · 18 Jul 2003

ad sach jugad sach hai bi sach nanak hosi bi sach. this means the truth was there from the start in all the yugs. was there a satguru in each yug to deliver mankind? it really puzzles me y there wud be a satguru only in kal yug and not in the previous 3. y wud mankind wait for aeons and aeons to be delivered? and is there any tukh to indicate there was a satguru in each age or only one in kal yug and not in the previous 3?

Re: Is Sikhi the only Way to God

nobody · 18 Jul 2003

What is the Satguru? The Satguru is the person who has no ego, no 5 vices, has completed their journey to Akal Purakh and merged in the Ocean Of Sukh - God. God manifests inside that body as pure light (hyot) and amrit. Satpurakh jin jaaniaa Satguru tis ka nao. The one who has realised the Eternal Being it called the Eternal Guru (satGuru). Sukhmani Sahib. And rare ones like Guru Nanak Dev Ji Maharaj have been given the Hukam to take humility and Amrit naam to the suffering humanity. (As written by Bhai Gurdas Ji) But it is actually God himself that has manifested inside those great souls..pargatio jyot. Bhai Gurdas Ji gives the example of wood have fire hidden within it, the ones on fire can set others on fire to. Just as Guru Nanak Dev Ji blessed Bhai Lehna Ji with the Jyot and transferred Gods Light on into 9 more human satguru jis. So even in previous ages God manifested in great souls as pargatio jyot and as Satguru administered Naam in that age. Bhai Gurdas Ji in his first Vaar pauri 40 summarises what went on before. "In Satyug, Visnu in the form of Vasudev is said to have incarnated and ‘V’ Of Vahiguru reminds of Visnu. The true Guru of Dvapar is said to be Harikrsna and ‘H’ of Vahiguru reminds of Hari. In the the Treta was Ram and ‘R’ of Vahiguru tells that rembering Ram will produce joy and happiness. In Kalijug, Gobind is in the form of Nanak and ‘G’ of Vahiguru gets Govind recited. The recitations of all the four ages subsume in the soul of the common person. When joining four letters Vahiguru is remembered, the soul merges again in its origin." Translation by Dr Jodh Singh Vaaraan Bhai Gurdas. The point being, that in previous Ages Satyug : SatGuru Vasdev Gave the Naam as "Vishnu", Dvapur Yug: SatGuru Harkrishna gave the Naam as "Hari" Treta Yug : Satguru Ram gave the Naam as "Ram" Kaljug: Satguru Nanak called God Govind and gave the Naam as "Va He Gu Ru" and by reciting VaHeGuRu you are effectively reciting all the Naams gone before. Even we asked Bhai Rama Singh ji there are so many naams in SGGS Ji so why not recite the others like Ram or Har? He replied ask the peolle who ecite those names how long it takes to reach God? Waheguru is much quicker, much more powerful in this AGe, Kalyug. In this Age of Ka, Guru Nanak has come to ferry the souls across the world Kal Taran Gur Nanak aaiyaaa. and singing Gods praises is the highest form of worship (rather than reading religious texts veds, semitics texts, bathing, following rituals etc) Kaljug meh kirtan pardanaana simply put there is a time and place for every guru and every naam this is the time for Guru Nanak Maharaj , Satnaam Waheguru and Shabad Kirtan. And Gurmukh panth contis all kinds of bhagats who love God, and Khalsa Fauj protects all bhgats that may still be following the Satgurus and Naams of previous ages - they still work just slower. Sikhi is not the only way, it is the latest way, the fastest way , the blessed way in this time and place.

Re: Is Sikhi the only Way to God

#Singh# · 18 Jul 2003

For sure all the Bhagats whose Bani is in Guru Granth Sahib Ji had Naam and Amrit. Just by reading their bani it is very clear. They too received this from Guru Ji. Guru Ji was not only here when Guru Nanak Dev Ji were born, but Aad Sach, Jugaad Sach, Hai Bhi Sach, Nanak Hosi Bhi Sach. It is true that we must all receive Amrit and Naam from Guru Ji before we can get to Vaheguru. Nobody has ever gotten to Vaheguru without going through Guru Ji - Gurbani makes this very clear.

Re: Is Sikhi the only Way to God

to · 18 Jul 2003

Nobody Jee wrote: > Bhai Gurdas Ji in his first Vaar pauri 40 summarises what > went on before. > > "In Satyug, Visnu in the form of Vasudev is said to have > incarnated > and ‘V’ Of Vahiguru reminds of Visnu. > > The true Guru of Dvapar is said to be Harikrsna > and ‘H’ of Vahiguru reminds of Hari. > > In the the Treta was Ram > and ‘R’ of Vahiguru tells that rembering Ram will produce joy > and happiness. > > In Kalijug, Gobind is in the form of Nanak > and ‘G’ of Vahiguru gets Govind recited. > > The recitations of all the four ages subsume in the soul of > the common person. > > When joining four letters Vahiguru is remembered, > the soul merges again in its origin." > > Translation by Dr Jodh Singh Vaaraan Bhai Gurdas. > > > The point being, that in previous Ages > Satyug : SatGuru Vasdev Gave the Naam as "Vishnu", > Dvapur Yug: SatGuru Harkrishna gave the Naam as "Hari" > Treta Yug : Satguru Ram gave the Naam as "Ram" > Kaljug: Satguru Nanak called God Govind and > gave the Naam as "Va He Gu Ru" > > and by reciting VaHeGuRu you are effectively reciting all the > Naams gone before. > Nobody jee, i would like to point out that this particular Pouree in Bhai Gurdas dhia Vaaraa is disputed as not being authentic. Many schollors such as Bhai Vir Singh jee are of the opinion that this Pouree is not authentic and was added by someone other then Bhai Gurdas Jee.

Re: Is Sikhi the only Way to God

Kulbir Singh · 18 Jul 2003

aasaa mehalaa 4 || Aasaa, Fourth Mehl: har jug jug bhagath oupaaeiaa paij rakhadhaa aaeiaa raam raajae || In each and every age, He creates His devotees and preserves their honor, O Lord King. haranaakhas dhusatt har maariaa prehalaadh tharaaeiaa || The Lord killed the wicked Harnaakhash, and saved Prahlaad. The word used here is 'tharaiaa'. We read this idea of par othara, thanra, liberation, swimming the world ocean etc many a time in Guru Granth sahib. It is used not only in respect of saving bhagats as per the above line but also in relation to liberation through naam simran. >>>>>>> The word taariya or Udhaar has many meanings. It depends on the situation in which these words are used. Taariya means that Bhagat Prahlaad jee was saved from Harnaksh. For some word udhaar means getting delivered from a simple worldly problem e.g. Mainu udhaar lai Rabba! For others udhaar means to get mukti i.e. deliverance from 8.4 million life forms. Tat Gurmat Udhaar is going to Sach Khand and this became possible only after the advent of Guru Nanak Dev jee. When Guru Nanak Dev jee gave the Satnam to this world, then bhagats from this world started going to Sach Khand. We should realize that bhagats from many worlds reside in Sach Khand - Tithai Bhagat Vasai ke Loh|| >>> Now, is the word 'tharia' of the above line materially different from the one used in the line about Bhagat Prahlad? If it was so would Guru ji not have made that distinction clear by prefacing tharna with Sachkhand for one and not the other? As I said I have not come across this line of argument before, perhaps its just me. A humble benti therefore to comment further on this. >>>>> Yes as I stated above there is a difference between Tarna used in one place and used at other place in Gurbani. It depends on the situation. >>>>>> dhroo prahlaad bidar dhaasee suth guramukh naam tharae (Dhroo bhagat, Prahlaad bhagat, son of a Dasi Bider-all of them became Gurmukhs and crossed the world over.) So this Tukh indicates that Dhru, Prahlaad, and Bider got Naam and became Gurmukhs. But Guru Nanak Dev Jee was not born in there Yug, but is not possible that maybe Guru Nanak Dev Jee came to them in his spiritual form and gave them Naam Dhi Dhaat? Since they did naam simran, it is not possible that they also reached Sachkhand? >>>>>>>>>> Gurmukh Naam means Vaheguru Mantr. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee in his book "Gurbani diyaan Lagaan Maatraan dee Vilakhantaa" writes that where ever "Gurmukh Naam" come together, it means "Vaheguru Naam". In the pankiti above, it says that Dasee-sutt Bidar, Prahlaad and Dhroo jee swam across this ocean by getting Gurmat Naam. This probably happened somewhere in the past. Please ponder upon the following pankitis that prove that these bhagats did indeed meet Guru Nanak Dev jee in some form or the other: gwvau gun prm gurU suK swgr durq invwrx sbd sry ] gaavo gun param guroo sukh saagar dhurath nivaaran sabadh sarae || I sing the Glorious Praises of the most exalted Guru Nanak, the Ocean of peace, the Eradicator of sins, the sacred pool of the Shabad, the Word of God. gwvih gMBIr DIr miq swgr jogI jMgm iDAwnu Dry ] gaavehi ga(n)bheer dhheer math saagar jogee ja(n)gam dhhiaan dhharae || The beings of deep and profound understanding, oceans of wisdom, sing of Him; the Yogis and wandering hermits meditate on Him. gwvih ieMdRwid Bgq pRihlwidk Awqm rsu ijin jwixE ] gaavehi ei(n)dhraadh bhagath prehilaadhik aatham ras jin jaaniou || Indra and devotees like Prahlaad, who know the joy of the soul, sing of Him. kib kl sujsu gwvau gur nwnk rwju jogu ijin mwixE ]2] kab kal sujas gaavo gur naanak raaj jog jin maaniou ||2|| KAL the poet sings the Sublime Praises of Guru Nanak, who enjoys mastery of Raja Yoga, the Yoga of meditation and success. ||2|| If you read the whole Saviyye of Guru Nanak Dev jee, written by the Bhatts, you find out that all the old bhagats sing praises of Guru Nanak Dev jee. This means that they got their salvation through Guru Nanak Dev jee. No other explanation for this. It would be understandable if they were singing the praises of Vaheguru but they are singing the praises of Guru Nanak Dev jee. This proves that whoever got to Sach Khand got there through Guru Nanak Dev jee. >>>>>>>We have to start believing that they became sikhs of guru nanak dev ji, or that they must have been spiritually divne naam by guru nanak ji hundred of years before he took human form, or that the bhagats were reborn as the punj piaray (yes i have heard that too). >>>>>>> It is both. They were given Naam by Guru Nanak before Guru Sahib came on this Earth in human form and the bhagats from old times did get born again in Guru ghar to get real udhaar. >>>> Please it is my humble request that we open both our eyes instead of being one-eyed like the Muslims. Put aside what we think we know and read siri guru granth sahib ji with an open mind for Truth and accept what siri guru granth sahib ji is saying to us. Do not try and impose our beliefs onto siri guru granth sahib ji meaning we have to rewrite history and make supernatural explanations for something that is very simple. >>>>>> To you also, I appeal to not read baani with the eyes of modern knowledge and education. It is not about being politically correct. We are talking about facts here. Gurbani makes it clear that no one can get to Vaheguru without the "Satguru". Satguru is made of two words. Sat meaning True and "Guru" meaning divine teacher. Sat or the truth can only be one. Therefore, true Guru can only be one and that true Guru is none other than Guru Nanak Dev jee. BIN SATGUR KINAI NAA PAIYO, BIN SATGUR KINAI NAA PAAIYA|| (No one has attained Vaheguru without Satguru) SABH TEY VADDA SATGUR NANAK, JIN KAL RAAKHEE MEREE|| (Guru Nanak is the greatest of all, who has kept my lajja in this Kalyug) Guru Arjun Sahib is saying that Guru Nanak is the greatest of all. Why question this assertion by saying things like "Sikhi is just another flower in Sat Kartar's garden?" >>>>>>>> And Guru Nanak Maharaj Ji revealed it in a very simple, humble and easy way for one and all. And more than that Guru Sahibs also looked back at explained very simply who the great souls were from the past and what they did so we can learn that they too were True and worthy of respect and worthy of having bhagat bani included in siri guru granth sahib ji. Because when the soul merged with the Ocean of Sukh, Akal Purakh, then there is no ego and it is only Akal Purakh speaking through the body of the bhagat or the SatGuru Ji and it is all the Word of God. >>>>>>>>>>>> What does it mean by the first pauri of the Sudha saviyee we do everyday? SAARAY HEE DEKH KO DEKH RAHIYO MATT, KOYOO NAA DEKHIYAT PRANPATI KE|| SREE BHAGWAN KEE BHAAYE KIRPA HOON TEY EK RATEE BIN EK RATEE KE|| Guru Gobind Singh jee maharaj is clearly writing that he himself has looked at every religion (matt) of this world but has found none reaching Vaheguru Pranpatee. In the end he writes that since they lack the real love (ratee) for Vaheguru, they are not worth even a cent (rattee). Is there any room for argument here. Guru Gobind Singh jee makes it clear to us that none of the religions of the world reach Vaheguru. He writes that only Gurmat reaches him. Raam Rahim, Puran Koran, Anaek kahai matt, humm ek naa maniyo|| Simrit shaster bed sabhai, baho bhed kahai, hum ek naa janiyo|| Does this not reject every holy book and religion of the world? What more do we have to say? Dear Nobody jee, you mentioned previous bhagats being called Gurmukhs. I have already written that all these bhagats were Sikhs of Guru Nanak as written in the savviyye of Bhatts. >>>>> This translation means In the House of Nanak there is Only Naam. And if you have Naam , you have everything, Naam permeates everything. so it is not contradictory to the second SACHAI SAHIBA KYAA NAHI GHAR TERE|| GHAR TAAN TERE SABH KICHH HAI, JIS DEVE SO PAAVAI|| Infact you know as well as i do that all of SGGS Ji teaches us not to ask for anything but God's prasises and Naam (mango daan takur naam), to ask for anything else is nothing but headaches.... (sir dukha ka dukh). And by fulling with naam, with nothing but naam we enjoy all the happinesses , all the sukhs all the pleasures we thought we were going to get from worldly things....lakh kushiaa patshaheeiaa je satgur nadar karaay...if the satguru gives us the lok of grace we enjoy hundreds and thousands of kingly joys. There is no contradiction veer jee. >>>>>>>> What I am saying is that the house of Guru Nanak is capable of giving even worldly things to his Sikhs. There are many shabads that are in reference to this e.g. the shabad of Bhagat Dhanna jee where he asks for virtually every worldly thing. So to say that Guru Nanak's house has only Naam would mean that it is not capable of giving anything else. Of course I agree that through Naam everything else can be attained. There are many pankitis in Gurbani that state that Naam is found from True Guru only and as explained above True Guru is only one - Guru Nanak Dev jee. I ask you. Who else is the true Guru of status of Guru Nanak? Mohammad? Jesus? Krishna? Rama? There is none. These prophets don't come close to even the Sikhs of Guru Nanak, let alone Guru Nanak himself. >>>And this Khalsa Fauj was to protect the saints and destroy the tyrants as Guru Gobind Singh Ji has written about his autobigraphy. Isn't that beuatiful that as Khalsa we are here to protect the saints and destroy the tyrants. We are not here to destroy the saints and become tyrants. We are here to protect the bhagats that are on the gurmukh panth (even thought they may not be khalsa fauj or look like us or follow our religious lable). >>>>>> No one said that the other bhagats or good people of other religions go to hell? All I am saying is that they go where they want to go. If a Muslim does not even work towards Sach Khand, how can he go to Sach Khand. Same holds true for a Hindu. A Hindu does not aim for Sach Khand. Why would he go to Sach Khand then. They will go where they are working to go i.e. Mukti, Jannat or Swarag etc. These realm as written in the Giyan Khand waali pauri, lie below Sach Khand. They don't even know about Sach Khand. Maybe we should translate extracts from Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee's books to prove that Gurmukh Naam is only in Guru ghar and access to Sach Khand is only through Guru Nanak. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Is Sikhi the only Way to God

gill n cheema · 18 Jul 2003

wat about the verse where guru nanak says all religions r like one thread going to the same place?? and when he mentions that whichever door they come through save them oh lord

Re: Is Sikhi the only Way to God

Balpreet Singh · 18 Jul 2003

I havn't read the above mentioned shabad, perhaps it could be posted or maybe a reference? The below shabad and its interpretation clear up all my doubts though: bilaaval mehalaa 3 || pooraa thhaatt banaaeiaa poorai vaekhahu eaek samaanaa || eis parapa(n)ch mehi saachae naam kee vaddiaaee math ko dhharahu gumaanaa ||1|| sathigur kee jis no math aavai so sathigur maahi samaanaa || eih baanee jo jeeahu jaanai this a(n)thar ravai har naamaa ||1|| rehaao || chahu jugaa kaa hun nibaerraa nar manukhaa no eaek nidhhaanaa || jath sa(n)jam theerathh ounaa jugaa kaa dhharam hai kal mehi keerath har naamaa ||2|| jug jug aapo aapanaa dhharam hai sodhh dhaekhahu baedh puraanaa || guramukh jinee dhhiaaeiaa har har jag thae poorae paravaanaa ||3|| kehath naanak sachae sio preeth laaeae chookai man abhimaanaa || kehath sunath sabhae sukh paavehi maanath paahi nidhhaanaa ||4||4|| This shabad, according to Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh jee shows the special nature of Gurmat vs. all other faiths (Gurmat Gauravta, 281). This shabad makes clear that in other Jugs, theose faiths were based on the transitory trai-guN, and none could give salvation. All adherents could not get salvation and had to come to Kaljug to be saved if they came onto the path of Guru Nanak. The rest of this post will be based on Bhai Saahib's Gurmat Gauravta. (interpretation) The perfect Vahiguru, creator has himself created the creation. Because it was created by Vahiguru, it is also considered perfect. In all this creation, only Naam's greatness has been kept central. This naam is only available in the Guru's house. Only by Gurmat Naam can one be saved. No other adherent of another faith should have the "gumaan" or ego that they can find true salvation. Whoever, through great fortune, get's wisdom from Vahiguru, that fortunate Gurmukh gets Gur-deekhyaa/Gurmantar from the door of the Satguru and is immersed in the true form of Guru-Vahiguru. Whoever has faith and trust in GurbaaNee from the heart, in side them, Gurmat Naam will take hold. The salvation of the 4 Jugs (epochs) will happen now in Kaljug. Humanity will get the one Gurmat Naam, and then they will be saved. Abstinence, controlling all sense organs, going to pilgrimage, etc. are all the faith of the earlier epochs, which was followed before. But these faiths were not salvation-giving by any means. In imitation of the religious acts of earlier epochs, even today in this epoch (Kaljug) there are countless misguided seekers who keep doing the old religious acts, but they cannot be saved by taking on these faiths. In Kaljug, whichever seeker repeats the praise of Gurmat Naam, they will be ferried across. The praise of Vahiguru's Naam is the true giver of salvation. Look and study the Vedas and Puraanas, and you will see that in each epoch there were epoch-specific religious acts/faiths that are stressed and none of these can help find Vahiguru. In this Jug, only that person is accepted who has received gur-deekhya from the Guru and has meditated on Gurmat Naam. Guru Nanak Sahib says that only such naam-drenched, Guru-blessed Gurmukhs have their love attached to Vahiguru and all ego is erased from their minds. Gurmat naam is so amazing that those who say and hear Gurmat Naam all find hapiness. By accepting and meditating on Gurmat Naam, the true treasure, Vahiguru, is found. kalijug oudhhaariaa guradhaev || mal mooth moorr j mughadh hothae sabh lagae thaeree saev ||1|| rehaao || thoo aap karathaa sabh srisatt dhharathaa sabh mehi rehiaa samaae || dhharam raajaa bisamaadh hoaa sabh pee pairee aae ||2|| (Gurmat Gauravta, 447) This Shabad makes clear that Guru Saahib has saved those in Kaljug, and htis has been happening since the time of Guru Nanak Saahib. Due to extreme ignorance and pollution, people had become fools, but they all have been attached to the sevaa of Akaal Purakh ie. bhagtee. The Bhagtee increased so much that Dharamraaj saw this and was astonished that all of creation has come to the feet of the Satguru ie. recieved Sikhi. This means that Guru Nanak's mission of saving souls will only finish when all of creation is saved. And then Dharamraaj will be shocked/amazed. this time will surely come, when the entire world will accept the Khalsa Faith. I was personally amazed to see that this shabad goes so far as to say: sathajug thraethaa dhuaapar bhaneeai kalijug oothamo jugaa maahi || Kaljug is the best of all the Jugs...this evil epoch is the best! Why? Because finally Guru Nanak, the giver of Gurmat Naam, has shown a path to Sach Khand and given the amazing gift of Gurmat Naam to humanity. We have an amazing treasure available to us...how unfortunate if we dont' take this opportunity and "loot" naam and find our true place with Akaal Purakh.

Re: Is Sikhi the only Way to God

nobody · 21 Jul 2003

ik oankar satgur prasad|| gur nanak kee vadaaiee, pargat bhaae sagala jag antar. Guru Nanak's greatness has become manifested throughout the world Thanks for spending time reading and replying veer ji. Beofer anyone thinks I am being anti-khals, let this fool say I love Guru Nanak Ji Maharaj’s lotus feet. Guru Nanak Maharaj glory resounds in all the worlds. There is no other way for me except the feet of guru nanak maharj ji. It is the ONLY way for me. But I do not believe it was the only way for everyone pre-Guru Nanak maharaj. Or even now in this day and age. POINT 1: You said << Nobody jee, i would like to point out that this particular Pouree in Bhai Gurdas dhia Vaaraa is disputed as not being authentic. Many schollors such as Bhai Vir Singh jee are of the opinion that this Pouree is not authentic and was added by someone other then Bhai Gurdas Jee. >> The Akal Takhat Rehat marayada is that Bhai Gurdas Ji’s vaars and SGGS Ji are authentic. And Bhai Gurdas Ji’s vaars get printed with that 40th verse. So it is official, if there is dispute then it has not been accepted by the Panth as that verse gets included in all published material. >> If you read the whole Saviyye of Guru Nanak Dev jee, written by the Bhatts, you find out that all the old bhagats sing praises of Guru Nanak Dev jee. This means that they got their salvation through Guru Nanak Dev jee. No other explanation for this. It would be understandable if they were singing the praises of Vaheguru but they are singing the praises of Guru Nanak Dev jee. This proves that whoever got to Sach Khand got there through Guru Nanak Dev jee. >> Guru Nanak Ji had a name only for his body. Before the body existed why would the name Nanak exist? We have made a myth and mystery of Guru Nanak Dev Ji’s life here. We are destroying the simple mission that Guru Nanak Maharaj came to show us. That even a simple humble person like him was blessed to the highest stages, and we too can be blessed to unite with God. And Guru Nanak Maharaj’s bani and life and amrit naam is the ladder left for us to walk in. ..santa ka marag dharam kee pauree… If you read Guru Nanak Maharaj’s bani you will see that he was was searching and longing for Akal Purakh himself and underwent many penances himself (as written by Bhia Gurdas Ji like eatng sand and poisonous leaves) and he went through all the stages of doing seva and simran, jap and tap , yearning, loving, and ultimtely divine union with akal purakh the True Husband. He BECAME Satguru , he was blessed with that mission and naam and gareebee from akal purakh in his life on Earth. He was NOT Satguru in previous lives, he was NOT already Satguru in Sachkhand before he came to Earth. His soul elevated to that state through his great yearning and feeling for the suffering of humanity. Things did happen to him as a child, great miracles, but he was not Satguru until after he had his divine communion with akal purakh in the river when he went missing for three days. He came back after that with a mission. Bhai Nand Lal Ji writes of the divine communion with Guru Nanak Dev Ji and clearly says that God was so pleased with Guru Nanak Dev ji that he anoited him as satguru. ( I will post the translation later). The praises of Guru Nanak Maharaj are happening in sach khand all the time at every moment. Great souls who have been blessed with darshan of such realms in their samadhi see such things. Even domalla premee bhenjee on the ‘what made me interesteed in sikhi’ thread wrote that her husband Jagdeesh Singh, had a vision of Bhai Randhir Singh ji and the singhs and singhnian in full bana sitting at the feet of Guru Nanak Dev Ji maharaj singing his praises. “The next morning in Amritvela time my husband was awakened. He had had a vision of Sach Khand. There was an incredible sound of keertan filling the Universe and he heard the voice of a high-pitched voiced keertanee with small glasses and brownish complextion but very bright and red. All the Khalsa were wearing dastaar and bana (men and women) and sitting on a dais was Guru Nanak Devjee with a flowing white beard and even more glowing face. My husband fell weeping to the feet of the Guru and he said: "You don't need to cry anymore for you have come to your house." http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=141&t=141 The great souls in the Saviyye, like Bhai Randhir Singh ji are singing praises of Guru Nanak Maharaj ji. The Bhatts (poests) who wrote these were blessed with samadhi and vision of these realms and scenes by Dhan Dhan Guru Arjun Dev ji. Why are you trying to re-write thousands of years of history of great souls by introducing a link to Guru Nanak Dev Ji that never existed on this Earth? When your soul reaches sach khand, ALL the great souls already therre and in lower realms will be singing your praises too. When Guru Nanak Dev Ji became Satguru those great souls sang his eternal praises and still do. They didn’t sing praises before he existed. POINT 2: MEANING OF SATGURU You said “Satguru is made of two words. Sat meaning True and "Guru" meaning divine teacher. Sat or the truth can only be one. Therefore, true Guru can only be one and that true Guru is none other than Guru Nanak Dev jee. BIN SATGUR KINAI NAA PAIYO, BIN SATGUR KINAI NAA PAAIYA|| (No one has attained Vaheguru without Satguru) SABH TEY VADDA SATGUR NANAK, JIN KAL RAAKHEE MEREE|| (Guru Nanak is the greatest of all, who has kept my lajja in this Kalyug) Guru Arjun Sahib is saying that Guru Nanak is the greatest of all. Why question this assertion by saying things like "Sikhi is just another flower in Sat Kartar's garden?" What is the difference between Sat and Sach? We tend to use them both to mean Truth. Actually Sach means truth right here right now. Sat means Truth past, present and future i.e. Sat means ETERNAL. The only ETERNAL BEING is SAT PURASH i.e. God. When Sat Purash becomes maifested inside a human body, then it is God Himself that is the SatGuru. The individual self is obliterated ..no more ego. And the indivdual soul no longer is separate from the ocean. When SAT PURASH manifested in a person called Nanak he became SAT GURU. ..God acting as Guru within that body. “Sat Purakh jin jaaniaa satgur tis ka nao” The one who has realised the Eternal Being is known as the Eternal Guru. The second quote you give , you have placed the coma after Nanak. But there is no coma in gurbani. It is also translated as SABH TEY VADDA SATGUR NANAK JIN KAL RAAKHEE MEREE|| Nanak: The Sat Gur (God as Guru) is the greatest of all, the One who has kept my honour in this Kalyug. Someone told me that when the word Gur is used it refers to God as Guru, when the Word Guru gets used it means God in the human body as Guru.

Re: Is Sikhi the only Way to God

Kulbir Singh · 21 Jul 2003

Vaheguru jee kaa Khalsa Vaheguru jee kee fateh! >>>>>>> Beofer anyone thinks I am being anti-khals, let this fool say I love Guru Nanak Ji Maharaj’s lotus feet. Guru Nanak Maharaj glory resounds in all the worlds. There is no other way for me except the feet of guru nanak maharj ji. It is the ONLY way for me. But I do not believe it was the only way for everyone pre-Guru Nanak maharaj. Or even now in this day and age. >>>>>> I believe your statements that you love Guru Nanak and that for you there is no other way but Guru Nanak. You write that you don’t believe that even today Guru Nanak’s way is the only one that can take one to Sach Khand. May I ask you which other faith can go to Sach Khand and what means will they employ to go to Sach Khand? You said >>>>>><< Nobody jee, i would like to point out that this particular Pouree in Bhai Gurdas dhia Vaaraa is disputed as not being authentic. Many schollors such as Bhai Vir Singh jee are of the opinion that this Pouree is not authentic and was added by someone other then Bhai Gurdas Jee. >> The Akal Takhat Rehat marayada is that Bhai Gurdas Ji’s vaars and SGGS Ji are authentic. And Bhai Gurdas Ji’s vaars get printed with that 40th verse. So it is official, if there is dispute then it has not been accepted by the Panth as that verse gets included in all published material. >>>>>>>>>>> I don’t think Siri Akal Takhat has consensus on this particular pauri. All Vaars may be getting printed with this pauri, but many have a note that this vaar is not Bhai Gurdas jee’s baani. I have Bhai Vir Singh jee’s translation at home and Bhai Sahib clearly writes that this pauri does not seem to be baani of Bhai Gurdas jee. Anyway, I personally don’t care about it. >> If you read the whole Saviyye of Guru Nanak Dev jee, written by the Bhatts, you find out that all the old bhagats sing praises of Guru Nanak Dev jee. This means that they got their salvation through Guru Nanak Dev jee. No other explanation for this. It would be understandable if they were singing the praises of Vaheguru but they are singing the praises of Guru Nanak Dev jee. This proves that whoever got to Sach Khand got there through Guru Nanak Dev jee. >> >>>>>>>>> We have made a myth and mystery of Guru Nanak Dev Ji’s life here. We are destroying the simple mission that Guru Nanak Maharaj came to show us. That even a simple humble person like him was blessed to the highest stages, and we too can be blessed to unite with God. >>>>> But does Gurbani not say that divine lightform of Vaheguru himself came in this world and got known by the name of Guru Nanak? Here is a pankiti to prove that: JYOT ROOP HAR AAP, GUR NANAK KAHAAIYO|| >>>> If you read Guru Nanak Maharaj’s bani you will see that he was was searching and longing for Akal Purakh himself and underwent many penances himself (as written by Bhia Gurdas Ji like eatng sand and poisonous leaves) and he went through all the stages of doing seva and simran, jap and tap , yearning, loving, and ultimtely divine union with akal purakh the True Husband. >>>>>>> The baani that Guru Sahib has written where he is searching for Vaheguru is for us Kaljugi jeevs. He may have felt the pain of the humankind and uttered shabads like that. Now where Guru Nanak Sahib or other Guru Sahihbaan write that they are troubled by Kaam, Krodh etc., should we derive that our Gurus had problem with Kaam Krodh? NOOO WAAAY!!! Such shabads are written for us Kaljugi jeevs. As for the penance that Guru Nanak Sahib went through as described by Bhai Gurdaas jee, that was necessary to show the humankind how to japp naam. Same way Guru Arjun Sahib started the shahidi in Sikhs. Our Guru Sahibaan took the human form and stayed within the human limitations to achieve the utmost spiritual state. This was to show us how to do bhagtee. This does not mean that Guru Sahibaan were doing bhagtee as they were separated from Vaheguru. Guru Nanak Sahib was united with Vaheguru from the beginning. >>>> He BECAME Satguru , he was blessed with that mission and naam and gareebee from akal purakh in his life on Earth. He was NOT Satguru in previous lives, he was NOT already Satguru in Sachkhand before he came to Earth. >>>>>>> Vaheguru Vaheguru Vaheguru Vaheguru!!!!! Tu Satgur chahoo jugeen aap aapai Parmeshar|| qU siqguru chu jugI Awip Awpy prmysru ] thoo sathigur chahu jugee aap aapae paramaesar || You are the True Guru, throughout the four ages; You Yourself are the Transcendent Lord. suir nr swiDk isD isK syvMq Durh Duru ] sur nar saadhhik sidhh sikh saeva(n)th dhhureh dhhur || The angelic beings, seekers, Siddhas and Sikhs have served You, since the very beginning of time. Awid jugwid Anwid klw DwrI iqRhu loAh ] aadh jugaadh anaadh kalaa dhhaaree thrihu loah || You are the Primal Lord God, from the very beginning, and throughout the ages; Your Power supports the three worlds. Agm ingm auDrx jrw jMimih AwroAh ] agam nigam oudhharan jaraa ja(n)mihi aaroah || You are Inaccessible; You are the Saving Grace of the Vedas. You have conquered old age and death. gur Amrdwis iQru QipAau prgwmI qwrx qrx ] gur amaradhaas thhir thhapiao paragaamee thaaran tharan || Guru Amar Daas has permanently established You; You are the Emancipator, to carry all across to the other side. AG AMqk bdY n sl´ kiv gur rwmdws qyrI srx ]2]60] agh a(n)thak badhai n saly kav gur raamadhaas thaeree saran ||2||60|| So speaks SALL the poet: O Guru Raam Daas, You are the Destroyer of sins; I seek Your Sanctuary. ||2||60|| This shabad has been addressed to Guru Ramdas jee but in fact it is being referred to the Guru Jyoti i.e. Guru Nanak’s Guru jyoti. Does it not make clear that this Guru jyoti has been the Satguru from the beginning? What more proof do we need that Guru Nanak Sahib did exist as a Guru from the start of this creation. POINT 2: MEANING OF SATGURU >>>> SABH TEY VADDA SATGUR NANAK JIN KAL RAAKHEE MEREE|| Nanak: The Sat Gur (God as Guru) is the greatest of all, the One who has kept my honour in this Kalyug. Someone told me that when the word Gur is used it refers to God as Guru, when the Word Guru gets used it means God in the human body as Guru. >>>>>> To do so would be a violation of Gurbani Grammar. If “nanak” was being addressed, it’s aunkad in the end would have been removed as is the case anywhere a noun is addressed. E.g. Eh Mann meriya, tu sada chalo Har naalay|| The aunkad has been removed from the end of “mann” because it is being addressed. The only meaning of that pankiti is that Guru Nanak is the greatest of all. One who had kept my honour in Kalyug. All other meanings are against Gurbani Grammar. Please refer to Professor Sahib Singh jee’s Gurbani Viyakaran for more details. I don't understand what you are going to gain by saying that Guru Nanak is not greatest of all and that he is one of many bhagats in this world. Please have shardha. Only Guru Nanak's way is true. All other ways are incomplete (not false). They go only so far. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Is Sikhi the only Way to God

singh · 21 Jul 2003

My thanks too to Kulbir Singh and Balpreet Singh for taking the time to reply. I have learnt one or two new ideas from your posts so I am grateful. From my limited understanding, I am not convinced that Guru sahibs talked about different contexts in respect of mentioning par otharaa/liberation for the bhagats as oppose to guruan ke sekh. But I am no expert by any measure, in fact I am just a beginner. Therefore I'll leave it here, save to quote one shabad which quite incidentally I was hearing the keertan and viakhia of just yesterday; go(n)add || Gond: (Bhagat Naam Dev - Pa 873) mo ko thaar lae raamaa thaar lae || Carry me across, O Lord, carry me across. mai ajaan jan tharibae n jaano baap beet(h)ulaa baah dhae ||1|| rehaao || I am ignorant, and I do not know how to swim. O my Beloved Father, please give me Your arm. ||1||Pause|| nar thae sur hoe jaath nimakh mai sathigur budhh sikhalaaee || I have been transformed from a mortal being into an angel, in an instant; the True Guru has taught me this. nar thae oupaj surag ko jeethiou so avakhadhh mai paaee ||1|| Born of human flesh, I have conquered the heavens; such is the medicine I was given. ||1|| jehaa jehaa dhhooa naaradh ttaekae naik ttikaavahu mohi || Please place me where You placed Dhroo and Naarad, O my Master. thaerae naam avila(n)b bahuth jan oudhharae naamae kee nij math eaeh ||2||3|| With the Support of Your Name, so many have been saved; this is Naam Dayv's understanding. ||2||3|| [%sig%]

Re: Is Sikhi the only Way to God

domalla premee · 23 Jul 2003

Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh Whoever quoted from the post I wrote about the vision of Sachkhand needs to be very clear of one thing. What goes on in Sachkhand is the praise of GOD via simran and keertan. It reverberates through the universe in a thundering current...Everything is Akal Purakh....None of the Gurus led the Sikhs to worship them.......EVER.......Gurbanee makes this so clear......Naam Japo..... So sorry for the comfusion. dass

Re: Is Sikhi the only Way to God

Soulja · 23 Jul 2003

Gurfateh Is there a translation available of the Sau Sakhis online? If anyone knows, Il be grateful if you could let me know where? Gurfateh