Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Hardeghi Chamach - spoon that stirs all deghchees

Hardeghi Chamach - spoon that stirs all deghchees

Kulbir Singh · 21 Feb 2005

Hardeghi Chamach Bhai Kahn Singh jee Nabha was one of the greatest scholars of Sikh Panth. Mahan Kosh the best Sikh encyclopedia even to this day keeps his memory alive. At a time when Hindus were about to swallow Sikh Panth, he along with other gursikhs of that time vigorously fought back. Bhai Sahib wrote another great book – Hum Hindu Nahee (We are not Hindus), in order to counter the claim by some Sanatanist Hindus that Sikhs were part of the Hindu Dharam. At that time (and still today) there were Sikhs who proudly subscribed to all faiths along with the Sikh faith. A person who is a Sikh cannot be a Hindu or a Muslim at the same time. A Sikh can only be a Sikh and not a Hindu or a Muslim or a Christian while being a Sikh. Many Sikhs don’t openly subscribe to other faiths but knowingly or unknowingly a lot of Sikhs are infected with other faiths i.e. subscribe to their philosophies. They don’t see any harm in bowing their head when they see a Church or a temple. I have personally witnessed this. A friend of mine, long time ago, used to bow his head whenever he saw any religious place. I told him that we Sikhs cannot bow our head and matha-tek to anyone but Guru Khalsa Panth and Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee but he in return accused me of being an extremist and even a Taliban. I was sitting there wondering how ignorant modern Sikhs had become. Anyway, Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha terms such Sikhs who subscribe to all faiths as Hardeghi Chamchay i.e. such chamchay that are used to stir vegetable of all sorts. He has written a beautiful poem that I must share with you all: Devi ko bhagat kabhee meera ko upaasha hai, Daas Sultan ko au kabhee Laal-Beghi hai|| (Depending on the circle and situation, sometimes he becomes a worshipper of Devi and at other times of Meera. Sometimes they serve Sultan (a sect of Islam) and at other times they become Laal-Beghi (another sect of Islam)) Mann meh hai aur ar mukh maahe dooji baat, Param Pakhandi, nakh Sikh Lau farebee hai|| (He has one thing in mind and something else on his tongue. He is a Param Pakhandi i.e. a great hyprocrite and a deceiver) Swarath ko maan hai, mukh parmaarath tain, Nimboo ko nichod agai karat rakebi hai || (From inside they have worldly reasons and aspirations but from tongue they speak of holyness and religion. They crush others as a lemon is crushed) Singh roop dhaari anai matt ko parchaari bhaari, Panth ko nikaaray jo chamach Hardeghi hai || (Such pakhandi adopts the appearance of a Singh but always sticks up or stands up and preaches other faiths. Such person who undermines Panth is a Hardeghi Chamach) May Guru Sahib save us from becoming Chamach Hardeghi. Let us stop becoming apologetics for other faiths. Let us become Mighty Khalsay both physically and spiritually. We hate no one but this does not mean that sell out to others. We should not undermine our Guru Sahibaan by saying that they were influenced by others and so on. Today Sikh scholars shamelessly and perhaps without realising the consequences of what they are writing, are declaring that Baba Farid is the Pitaamah of Punjabi. Others get up and say that Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj was greatly influenced by Bhagat Kabir, Bhagat Naamdev and Bhagat Ravidaas jee. Then others get up and do the work of RSS by saying that Nirgun Pooja in India was not started by Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj but was there prior to Guru Sahib. I ask those Bhadar-Purashs (learned wise men) – Is there anything that Guru Nanak Dev jee started? Pitamah of Punjabi is Farid and Pitamah of Nirgun Pooja is Kabir; then what did Guru Nanak do? If what Guru Nanak Dev jee was preaching was nothing new then why did he start a new religion? He could have started a reformist movement in Islam or in Hinduism. Why did he opt for a separate religion? Because no other faith can attain Vaheguru but Sikh Panth. The concept of Sach Khand was introduced to this world by Satguru Nanak Dev jee. The other faiths will go where they preach they will go i.e. Hindus to swarag or mukti, Muslims to Jannat, Christians to heaven, Buddhist to Nirvana and Sikhs of Satguru jee to Sach Khand which is much above all these other destinations (Read Siri Jap jee Sahib for more details). Why did Bhai Gurdas jee say that the condition of this Earth was hopeless before Guru Nanak Dev jee arrived? Earth was badly crushed with bad Karma and there was no Dharam left at all. Furthermore he declares that “Thamay koi na Saadh bin, Saadh na deesai Jag vich koya” i.e. There was no Saadhoo in the world before Guru Nanak Dev jee and without Saadhoo Guru Nanak Dev jee there was no one to console the suffering world. If Kabir jee and Ravidaas jee and Farid jee had been before Satguru jee, then why was the Earth crushed under the weight of sins and why did Bhai Gurdas jee say that there was no Saadh before Satguru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj. Bhai Gurdaas jee says very passionately that “Mitee dhund Jag Chaanan hoya, Satgur Nanak Pargatiya” i.e. The fog of ignorance dispelled when Guru Nanak Dev jee appeared in this world. Why was there fog if Kabir jee and Farid jee and Ravidaas jee and Naamdev jee had attained Vaheguru and had done bhagtee required to clear the fog? Khalsa jee, let us not play into the hands of RSS and other fundamentalist Hindus who claim that Guru Nanak Dev jee did nothing new and he did not start a new faith. They say that Satguru jee merely reformed the old Sanatan Hindu Dharam. Khalsa jeeo, Kabir jee, Ramanand jee, Ravidaas jee and others were doing bhagtee no doubt but they were not on the right track. Guru Nanak Dev jee put them on the right track. Our Janamsaakhis talk about Satguru jee meeting these bhagats in Ayodhya and winning them over. They were old and at this old age they became Guru Sahib’s Sikhs. Kabir jee, Ravidaas jee, Naamdev jee and Dhanna jee were Sikhs of Swami Ramanand jee who had started Raam Bhagtee by renouncing his Guru - Raghwa jee who was a proponent of Krishna Bhagtee. Ramanand jee preached Raam Bhagti for long time till one day he met Satguru jee. We should ponder upon the following pankitees of Ramanand jee: Satguru, Main Balihaari Tor|| Who was he referring to as Satguru jee here? We all know that he had no Guru as he had revolted against his guru Raghwa jee and had started his own branch of Raam Bhagti? Khalsa jeei, it was none other than Guru Nanak Dev jee who taught him Nirgun Pooja. After Ramanand became a disciple of Satguru jee, Kabir jee, Dhanna jee and others followed their Guru as well. Guru Nanak Dev jee introduced this world to the real pooja of Vaheguru. Before coming in human form, he helped some bhagats of previous jugs but openly he did udhaar (salvation) only in Kalyug. So was the Bhaana of Vaheguru. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Hardeghi Chamach - spoon that stirs all deghchees

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 21 Feb 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Shabash Veer Ji Kulbir Singh..SHABASH. These Bhadar Purash are not true scholars....they are either influenced by the British, Christians, Hindus, Vedas, etc etc and are apologists...they "see" every religions as "SAME".God as Same etc. They fail to see IF all religions are same, then why did Guru Ji spent 250 Years trying to establish the Khalsa Gurmatt gaddhi Raah..if God is the Same as Waheguru then why go to so much trouble givign us the Gurmantar ? Why did so many Khalsa Ji prefer "death" rather than convert...after all both religions are the same !!..In fact in GURBANI, ( i think but cant recall the exact shabad off hand)..Bhagat Namdev is being advise by his mum that since Bhagat Ji always said Allah/Ram Rahim/Hari/Gobind are all the SAME...and NOW the SULTAN is KILLING him because bhagat Ji DOES NOT WANT TO CHANT ALLAH....so WHY cant he just save his life by Chanting ALLAH ALLAH instead of RAAM RAAM. Bhgat ji replies that he chanted Raam at his pleasure and will also Chant Allah at his pleasure BUT NOT when he is FORCED to.. Very good points. It was Bhai kahn Singh nabha who wrote the excellent HUM HINDU NAHIN to counter all that Araya Samaji Propoganda that Sikhs are Hindu. Jarnail Singh

Re: Hardeghi Chamach - spoon that stirs all deghchees

Kulwinder Singh · 25 Feb 2005

Vir Kulbir Singh Ji, First of all my congratulations on writing such good post with fantastic good theme, In which several points are raised, I totally agreed with you on the central theme of the post where you have highlighted that some Sikhs bow in front of somebody or something apart from Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, That is very sad indeed and I hope through the Jagritee ( awaking) in the penth , we will see changes and people moving towards Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Although I agreed with the central theme of the article you have posted but I feel I need to say what I feel from my understanding is different from you never the less there are points where we agree 100% too. Like doing matha Tek to Just Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is acceptable to a Sikh. You have written “We should not undermine our Guru Sahibaan by saying that they were influenced by others and so on “ Vir Ji if there are 1 million people who see the Sun and say it is bright does not mean that somebody who said before some one else is some how more intelligent then other, It is a fact and wise people are saying the facts and that is similar in all the religious Bhagats and Saints who have same theme in their message. No you have said that “some people saying that Baba Farid is the Pitaamah of Punjabi” Well my understanding is that Punjabi is a dialogue which existed well before even Baba Farid Ji was born, But the fact is that the text of now days Punjabi in real terms Gurumukhi is creation of Shri Guru Angad Dev Ji that is why it’s name is Guru Mukhi as it originated from Guru’s Mukh and all the world is united on this fact. The written language of Punjab before Guru’s Time was Lunday very few people know that written language these days. You have written that some people claim ”Nirgun Pooja in India was not started by Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj but was there prior to Guru Sahib” That is not actually unique in India, Islam actually believe in Nirgun ( Just Light form) of GOD. Never mind the Islam version of my point think about the next point. What about Dusht Daman Ji ? Kalgidhar’s Previous Janam ? You have written “If what Guru Nanak Dev jee was preaching was nothing new then why did he start a new religion? “ Their was other Bhagat Jans who was trying to put people on the right path, but the Amazing Personality and the Wide understanding what Guru Nanak Dev Ji had nobody else had, and that is fact, why on earth then all the Bhagats’s who’s Bani is included in Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji have their own small following across India or in some regions but My Patsha Shir Guru Nanak Dev Ji’s Garden of blessings has developed well beyond the boundaries of India, Languages, Races, Cultures and Countries, That is purely because all others have seen the right thing but did not manage to show the right path in the most straight way to the rest of the world, That is the main reason Guru Nanak Dev Ji came to this world to give us the direct Link with the GOD. Also the scope of Guru Nanak Dev Ji’s knowledge is unparallel to the rest of the world till this day and I believe it will remain to be that way for the entire life of known and unknown universes. Bhai Gurdas Jee when he says “Mitee dhund Jag Chaanan hoya, Satgur Nanak Pargatiya” He is 100% right then in Fogy day you may have people who have small lights in their hand to show some people the way forward, But when the Sun comes out it Just unparallel to any other light anybody carrying at that time, and brighten up the whole earth and show way to all living things. The comparison of another light form on earth with Sun is very unfair as There is nothing equal to SUN When it comes to showing brightness that is same with the Guru Nanak Dev Ji, what he has shown us and the rest of the world And still shows to the Whole world Via Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is unquestionably great and unparallel to any to any other brightness any body have shown to humankind. You have written “let us not play into the hands of RSS and other fundamentalist Hindus who claim that Guru Nanak Dev jee did nothing new and he did not start a new faith. They say that Satguru jee merely reformed the old Sanatan Hindu Dharam “ To be perfectly Frank If Sikhism is reformed Old Sanatan Hindu Dharma then Nuclear Thermal Plant of energy is modified version of putting your hand under your arm pits and occasionally rubbing them together to make your self warm. I think my statement is clear, how I understand both religions, Do not get me wrong, I have very great love & respect for Hinduism ‘s positive aspects, where it enlightens and concentrate on humanity. But My Guru Nanak’s creation and understanding is well beyond any comparison with any religion on this earth and beyond. You have also said “Khalsa jeeo, Kabir jee, Ramanand jee, Ravidaas jee and others were doing bhagtee no doubt but they were not on the right track. Guru Nanak Dev jee put them on the right track. Our Janamsaakhis talk about Satguru jee meeting these bhagats in Ayodhya and winning them over. They were old and at this old age they became Guru Sahib’s Sikhs.” Dear Vir Ji by ignoring or undermining other achievement we have nothing to gain, Anyway I accept the Kami of Bhagts as I accept the Kami of Dusht Daman Ji too. Also I am sure knowing you that there are many accepts of Janam Sakhis which you do not accept, am I right Vir Ji ? Vir Ji Satguru is word which is used to describe a true Guru that is all in text form in sikhi we have some where different understanding of Satguru. Think if Ramanand Jee meet Guru Nanak Dev Ji, you think he would have been able to keep his writing without mentioning the name Nanak that Maha Sagar of Knowledge experience which you refrying that he did experienced it. Vir Ji when we label other Bhagats and Saints as Sikhs it only diminish the Glory of our Guru Ji, as from him being with such a great heart to accept intelligence from all corners of the Asian sub continent it Just make our Guru like any other religion’s tolerance and acceptance of others intelligent. By show respects to others we become more respectable rather then labelling other as unqualified to reach the highest level in spirituality, Just make us very small, narrow minded and Bigot full of Arrogance and that is no way near to What Our Guru Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji are, Our Guru Ji are Sarb Sanjai Guru of the world in the most amazing way the reciprocal philosophy influenced Bhagats Just shine in Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji like a well structured mosaic of Gems. Vir Ji Our Dear Gyani Ji have said “These Bhadar Purash are not true scholars....they are either influenced by the British, Christians, Hindus, Vedas, etc etc and are apologists...they "see" every religions as "SAME". How can Hinduism is same as Islam ? and Islam is same as Christianity ? and how on earth Sikhism is same as others ? that is strange thing even to say. They all are religion apart from that what is similar. That is like saying a cotton, Silk, leather, Steal Body cover and Plastic Body suit and Just Plants to cover the body are all same things, apart from being used to cover the body they have great differences. Gyani Ji say “then why did Guru Ji spent 250 Years trying to establish the Khalsa Gurmatt gaddhi Raah.” I think I have explained this question on the top. Gyani Ji Also saying “if God is the Same as Waheguru then why go to so much trouble giving us the Gurmantar ? My Ans: BE IN NO DOUBT AT ALL GOD AND WAHEGURU IS ABSOLUTELY SAME THING. The idea of more then one God is absurd and childish. Need for Waheguru as Gurumantar: Simple reason, God, Gopal, Ram, Krishan, all names are associates with this world and address THE GOD with references to the earth, i.e. he is Generator, Operator, and destroyer, Ram mean he is everywhere on Earth, Gopal mean then who look after the Earth and so on. Where as Waheguru is completely different dimensions in representing and refereeing to THE SAME GOD. As Amazing true enlightener – there is no connection of this name with the earth as Shri Guru Nanak Dev Ji’s Big thinking express that HE is Wow and HE is the final truth, that was the case before this earth was created that will be the case after this earth is gone. I hope above explanation clear things. Gyani Ji also write “Why did so many Khalsa Ji prefer "death" rather than convert...after all both religions are the same !!.. “ Gyani Ji two thing first all religions are not same and also it is simple human rights issue, Everybody should have choice, no force should be used to change people’s opinions. That is why Guru Teg Bahadur Ji gave his life for the protection of Human rights well before any United Nations Declaration of human rights in the world, other wise giving his life for the protection of Hindus does not make sense. Also one more thing you both have used reference to Bhai Khan Singh Ji Nabha who I admire a lot but I ask you both do you agree with Bhai Sahib Ji on all the things he says or not ? I sincerely hope that I have not offended you or Gyani Ji in this post,If I have then I am sorry, Sincerely Sorry, I still consider you both to be better Chardi Kalawale Sikhs then me by any standards and I feel bad even when we debate and I have to present my point of view which is against your point of view, I hope I am successful in explaining my respect and love towards you two. No doubt we have difference of opinion and I will disappoint you many times and I will get disappointed many time but that does not change the fact that we are all connected via our real father Guru Gobind Singh Ji. please forgive me for any offence I have caused in present or in the past. Your moorakh brother, Kulwinder Singh

Re: Hardeghi Chamach - spoon that stirs all deghchees

dil · 25 Feb 2005

VGKK,VGKF; I totally disagree to Mr. Kulbir Singh statement. It is not his fault. He might have been brought up in such atmosphere. I ask one question to all. If some hindu, muslim or christen converts into sikhism, we are very happy and try to present him as a great person. We consider him in our good book. But if some sikh goes patit and trims his beard and cuts his hair or converts to other religion. We say bad about him. Same way if people of other religion bow in front of Guru Granth Sahib. We feel very good and appreciate and we like them very much. We consider them in our good book. We want that whole world should bow in front guru granth sabih. Same way if you want to be in good books of others start learning to respect ideas of other people and also respect other religions too at least show off in front of your freinds of different religion. But remain strict in your heart. We must be an example to others. To make others bow in front of Guru Sahib, we must respect other's feelings and go some steps with others. This is the way muslims converts peole to their religion. We must also follow this way. Slowly slowly impart information about sikhism to those persons and not keeping yours self isolated. It is a fact that no one got their religion by choice but by birth only and if some converts his religion, it all is due to their Karam of previous lifes as we sikhs believe. So now on wards try learning respect other religions. Sorry for hurting some persons. VGKK, VGKF;

Re: Hardeghi Chamach - spoon that stirs all deghchees

RK · 25 Feb 2005

>Same way if you want to be in good books of others start learning to respect ideas of other people and also respect other religions too at least show off in front of your freinds of different religion. < I think there are many ways of respecting someone elses religion without bowing down to it. And just because you respect their religion, does not mean you should put Sikhi down, as all religions that promote bhagti of Vaheguru are good, but only sikh religion is the one that can get you to Sachkhand. obviously a Sikh will feel hurt if a fellow Sikh cuts his or her hair and becomes patit. They are giving away their only chance to meet Vaheguru, to get mukti from this world, and to reside forever in Sachkhand. Instead, they are trapping themselves in the 8.4 million life forms and moving away from Vaheguru. Who would not be upset at that? You say we should remain strict in our hearts, but I think you need to show your beliefs in all your actions instead of keeping it hidden in your heart.

Re: Hardeghi Chamach - spoon that stirs all deghchees

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 26 Feb 2005

"It is a fact that no one got their religion by choice but by birth only and if some converts his religion, it all is due to their Karam of previous lifes as we sikhs believe." I'm remebering that for the next person that denigrates me for not being a "Sikh by birth" (in other words...not being born to Sikh or Panjabi parents)

Re: Hardeghi Chamach - spoon that stirs all deghchees

RK · 27 Feb 2005

>I'm remebering that for the next person that denigrates me for not being a "Sikh by birth" (in other words...not being born to Sikh or Panjabi parents)< No one is Sikh by birth. Sikhi is not a religion you can be born into, like other religions such as Hinduism. You have to adopt guru ji as your guru , that is when you become a Sikh

Re: Hardeghi Chamach - spoon that stirs all deghchees

kulwinder Singh · 28 Feb 2005

Anybody who become Sikh by choice is a better Sikh by default rather then one who become purely because of their birth and have not progressed since birth towards Sikhi. I do not believe in the previous life thing 100% may be their are some who become due to that but large majority become, because they understand Sikhi and the message of Guru Nanak Dev Ji, other wise we are playing down on the choices of others, some time very hard choices people make in their life which in return surly enlighten them from Gurubani but never the less I do not have heart or understanding to play anybody's choices down in this manner. Redwhiteandblue Ji I admire you for your choices and understanding and those who say you are not Sikh by birth is something negative in any sense believe me they possibly could not be better Sikhs themselves. May Guru Nanak Dev Ji Bless lot of others like you, So people like me can learn by taking examples from you. Best Regards. Kulwinder Singh [%sig%]

Re: Hardeghi Chamach - spoon that stirs all deghchees

bhujangan · 28 Feb 2005

>>> I do not believe in the previous life thing 100% may be their are some who become due to that but large majority become, because they understand Sikhi and the message of Guru Nanak Dev Ji, other wise we are playing down on the choices of others,<<< Although I agree with you that these choices in some cases are really hard, that also has to do with karam. Some people have all the facilities they need to lead a gursikh life, but still they do aalas(laziness), this is their bad karam. Others have so much working against them and yet they still stick to it, this is also their past karam. This is not playing down the choice of these people, for these people are extremely lucky that because of their good past karams, they are able to lead a Gursikh life, after all, at the end of the day, everything is in the hands of Guru ji/Vaheguru ji, and we are mere puppets in this game.

Re: Hardeghi Chamach - spoon that stirs all deghchees

Kulwinder Singh · 01 Mar 2005

Dear Bhujangan, your sentiments are correct in saying "everything is in the hands of Guru ji /Vaheguru ji, and we are mere puppets in this game." But on the earth we can not run away from our own efforts towards achieving something better then other living things on the planet as human we have been give opportunity to progress so the opportunity is another word for choice any human can make, But It is also true that without HIS approval we will not have these choices. Thanks Kulwinder Singh

Re: Hardeghi Chamach - spoon that stirs all deghchees

dil · 02 Mar 2005

Dear RK, " No one is Sikh by birth. Sikhi is not a religion you can be born into, like other religions such as Hinduism. You have to adopt guru ji as your guru , that is when you become a Sikh." I must make it clear to Mr. RK to understand again and again that neither we get sikhism or hindusim by birth nor by choice or adoption. You Must understand that it is agin not your choice to adopt Guru Ji, It is all due to previous karma and if guru ji interested to bless you, guru ji will wake you up and ask you to adopt guru ji. If guru ji's kirpa is not there then even if you are born in the family of saints or some very religious sikh family, you will be distracted from the path of guru ji. I know one reknowned akj family. He took birth in a hindu family. Later by the grace of Guru ji, he and his family converted to sikhism and had amrit from akj. They had been chardikala gursikh family. One of their son is Mona and never like to go to gurudwara even. So belive me now later when you achieve your destination and contented, you will find without guru ji's kirpa and purab karam you cann not be a sikh. Soryy if I hurt some hard liners.

Re: Hardeghi Chamach - spoon that stirs all deghchees

Jogi · 05 Sep 2005

hello I think this topic is a waste of time if you are a true sikh If you remember the story of Guru Nanakji - he was at ease with all religions because he was sure and confident on his own. He travelled to all the holy places of Hindus and Muslims even to Mecca. That most of the early Gurus were Vaishnavite Hindus who had no problems with their earlier roots.

Re: Hardeghi Chamach - spoon that stirs all deghchees

.... · 05 Sep 2005

Could somone please explain how Sheikh Farid became a Sikh of Guru Nanak Dev Ji. I was asked this by someone and i didn't have an answer to give

Re: Hardeghi Chamach - spoon that stirs all deghchees

John Singh · 05 Sep 2005

Why then does Guru jee refer quite a bit to the beds in banee. Like in Alahaneeaa _ragg vadhans) for example he says something along the lines of get together and call pandit Gopal and read the puranas and bedas. But Guru Gobind Singh says in the svayaa we read in raihraas that he does not beleive in any of the beds or puranas? Please explain this in detail.

Re: Hardeghi Chamach - spoon that stirs all deghchees

Singh · 05 Sep 2005

I ask one of the Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib viaakarn students to do their magic and explain to John Singh the REAL meaning of Ramkali Sad.