Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

Parts: Part 1 · Part 2 · Part 3 · Conclusion

No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

Balpreet Singh · 22 Feb 2005

No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part 1 Based on “Khaet Jo Mandio Soorma” by Amardeep Singh Amar & Fatehnama Magazine, Feb 2005 Introduction Baba Gurbachan Singh was the last major Sikh Resistance leader to fall. The Indian Govenrment had put a RS 25 lakh reward on his head and was searching the entire Tarn Taran area for him, conducting 45 raids at one time to trap him. Baba jee escaped each time and continued to be a painful thorn in India’s side. When all the other Singhs had been martyred and the entire Indian Security Force was on his trail, he refused the order to go and hide in Pakistan and spit on the offer to surrender. He simply could not be caught. Even in the end, he was martyred not by police bullets, but by the betrayal of those he considered his own. Baba jee was a Sant Sipahi and a farsighted General. In honour of Baba jee’s 12th Shahidi anniversary falling on February 28, I will be posting the story of this Sikh hero as well as stories about his time in the struggle. Birth Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal was born on June 6, 1954 at village Manochhal in Amritsar district. His parents were Bapoo Atma Singh and Mata Gurmej Kaur. His parents were simple farmers but their family had a heritage of struggle against injustice. Bapoo Atma Singh’s uncle had become shahid in the Jaito Morcha, marching against the British Raj. Bapoo Atma Singh and Mata Gurmej Kaur Baba Gurbachan Singh was from childhood a very strong and muscular boy. He enjoyed wrestling and other sports. The family moved from village Manochahal to Nausherae Panooaa(n) when Baba jee was still young because his mother’s brothers had left for Singapore and left behind a large farm that had to be maintained. Becoming a Baba Baba jee was in the tenth grade when once he saw a boy inappropriately teasing and harassing a group of girls. Baba jee grabbed the troublemaker and beat him badly. The teacher found out and in front of the entire class asked the young Gurbachan Singh to explain why he had beaten the other boy. Baba jee explained, “Sir, he was harassing the bibis and after all, all women should be like our sisters. So, I couldn’t help myself and I did what I had to.” The entire class began to laugh at Gurbachan Singh’s use of the word “bibis” for the schoolgirls. The teacher laughed and said, “I see! These girls are “bibis” and you would be the “Baba jee. All students! From now on, everyone will call Gurbachan Singh, Baba jee!” After that day, the nickname “Baba” stuck and everyone began to call him Baba Gurbachan Singh. In the entire area, people began to know him as “Baba jee”. Days in the Army Baba Gurbachan Singh completed his education and at his father’s wishes, decided to join the army. Baba jee was 6”1 and over 200 pounds. The army happily enlisted him as an “A level” recruit. Even in the army, the name “Baba” Gurbachan Singh stuck. He was known for doing paath and being a devoted Sikh, even though he was not yet amritdhari. Every day he dedicatedly did his nitnem. One day, as Baba jee was doing nitnem, he fell into deep samadhi (meditation). The time for the daily military parade came and went and Baba jee had no awareness of it. The officer in charge of the parade demanded to know where Baba Gurbachan Singh was. The other soldier tried to explain that he was meditating but the Hindu Officer had a bias against Sikhs and refused to understand. The officer went to Baba jee and shook him into awareness. Baba jee apologized for missing the parade and explained he was reciting Gurbani. The officer responded by making fun of the Sikh faith and insulting the Gurus. Baba jee’s anger couldn’t be controlled and he tackled the officer. His fists flew and the officer shrieked for someone to help him. The other Sikh soldiers watching did nothing as they knew how much the officer hated Sikhs. The beating continued for some time when finally other officers came and stopped Baba jee. Baba jee had broken the Hindu officer’s arm and his nose. Baba Gurbachan Singh was arrested and court marshaled. After a year of prison, Baba jee left the army and returned home with a desire to dedicate his life to Sikhi. Meeting Sant Kartar Singh Bhindranvale Although Baba Gurbachan Singh did nitnem and had a love for Sikhi, he was still not amritdhari. Baba jee always attended programs by various Sants and one day he found out that Sant Kartar Singh Bhindranvale would be coming to his village for a program. Baba jee was very moved by the katha and wanted to speak with Sant Kartar Singh. Sant ji encouraged him to become amritdhari and so Baba jee did so within just a few days. After receiving the gift of amrit, Baba Gurbachan Singh decided to travel with Jatha Bhindra(n). He became very close to Sant Kartar Singh and also learned Gurbani Santhiya and Katha. Baba jee had memorized many banis and had a very long daily nitnem which he began very early at amrit vela. After the passing of Sant Kartar Singh, Sant Jarnail Singh became the next jathedar of the Jatha and Baba jee was also very close to him. 1978 and After In the 1970s, the Indian government sponsored Nirankari cult began to come to the forefront and publicly derided the Sikh faith and insulted the Sikh Gurus. The cult chief, Gurbachana was known to have said insulting thinks like “Guru Gobind Singh made the punj pyaray, I’ll make the sat sitaray”. He also insulted Guru Granth Sahib. On April 13, 1978, the Nirankaris had a march through Amritsar in which slogans against the Sikh religion were shouted. Singhs from the Akhand Kirtani Jatha and Jatha Bhindra(n) marched peacefully against the Nirankaris but were brutally attacked. 13 Singhs were martyred and many more were injured. Baba Gurbachan Singh had also taken part in this march and was shot in the arm. Baba jee recovering in Hospital. Sitting second from right. When the Nirankaris continued with their insulting parchaar and were protected by the Indian Government, the Singhs began to punish the Nirankaris themselves and Baba Gurbachan Singh also wanted to join this movement. When he asked Sant Jarnail Singh for permission, Sant ji kept saying that Guru Sahib was to take a very big seva from him yet. Sant Jarnail Singh asked Baba Gurbachan Singh to return to his village of Naushera Panooaa(n) and direct the building of Gurdwara Baba Dhanna Singh Kaviraj there. Baba jee accepted this hukam and returned to his village, but visited Sant ji regularly even after. Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranvale & Baba Ji Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal’s relationship with Sant Jarnail Singh was very close. Once, someone in Naushera Panooaa(n) made the accusation that Baba Gurbachan Singh didn’t even know Sant Jarnail Singh and was using his name for his own purposes. Baba Jee gathered the Sangat and traveled to Amritsar to disprove this allegation. Baba jee and the Sangat went to the roof of Guru Ram Das Langar and when Baba jee told Sant Jarnail Singh about what had been said, Sant jee replied, “Gurbachan Singh is so near to me that he can cut off my head and take it away if he wants…” When in 1982, Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranvale had gone to Bombay, the Indian Government thought it was the perfect time to capture him. The police surrounded the area and when Sant jee received word of this he thought of a clever ruse. Baba Gurbachan Singh, who had been traveling with the Jatha, was about the same height as Sant jee and wore the same style of clothes. He covered his face and lay down in Sant jee’s bed so those watching would be fooled. Until Sant jee had made his escape, Baba Gurbachan Singh continued to lie in bed and when he finally got up, the government agents were shocked and disappointed that their opportunity to arrest Sant jee had passed. Later when Baba Gurbachan Singh would volunteer for different missions to punish the enemies of the Panth like Bhajan Lal and various police officers, Sant Jarnail Singh would always say, “these are all small jobs for you. I am going to take a very big seva from you eventually…” The Gurdwara in Naushera Panooa(n) where Baba jee did seva was regulary visited by Singhs serving in the Movement. 1984 As the days of the attack seemed to be drawing nearer, Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranvale sent a message to Baba Gurbachan Singh for him to come meet him at Sree Darbar Sahib. Baba Gurbachan Singh was waiting for the opportunity. Sant jee met Baba jee very warmly and told him that an attack on Sree Darbar Sahib was imminent. Baba jee requested that finally this time his seva should be accepted and he would join Singhs in defending the Complex and become Shaheed. But Sant jee knew that this Singh would one day be a General that would shake all of India. Sant jee said that not all the Singhs should be Shaheed in the attack. That after the attack the struggle must continue and it would no longer be a struggle for greater water rights or concessions from the Center, it would only be for independence. For Khalsa Raj. Baba Jee vowed to give his all in the fight for the Panth and for sovereignty. Sant Jarnail Singh gave Baba Gurbachan Singh a siropa and lovingly ordered him to return to his village and not return until summoned. Baba jee knew this would be their final meeting. The attack took place and the Singhs defending Darbar Sahib became Shaheed after wreaking havoc on the Indian Army. Baba Gurbachan Singh knew that the “big seva” Sant jee had spoken of was now at hand. To Be Continued…. [%sig%]

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

bhopinder singh · 22 Feb 2005

great work veer ji keep it up

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

BTF · 22 Feb 2005

vaheguru dhan baba ji

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

Singhstah · 23 Feb 2005

AKAAAL!

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

Kulbir Singh · 23 Feb 2005

Can't help notice Sarblohee Baatas in the fourth picture where Baba jee is sitting after 1978 Saaka. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

jagjit singh · 23 Feb 2005

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, this book is the second in the series written by Bhai Amardeep Singh Amar. These books have been written at considerable risk, with already two attempts on his life. The last attempt caused him, his singhni and his young daughter considerable injuries. The first book, "devaa jagde rahai" was very successful in Punjab. Some of its chapters were serialised here, such as the Bhai Anokh Singh babbars Shaheedi, and how the Singhs punished Gobind Ram. Many writers in Punjab are facing threats on their lifes. From Amardeeps group alone, we know of threats to him, Baljit Singh Khalsa, Shivcharan Singh, etc. Sikh Missionary writers aswell have been threaten by RSS. Another close friend of theirs, Dr Sukhpreet Singh has recently released a large 900 page book on the RSS. He also has had some intimidation. They are all in Chardi kala, and will continue writing! But we as the sangat should support their writings, and ensure it reaches as many people as possible. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

WHere to get book? · 23 Feb 2005

Where can I get his second nook in canada? I tried the Sacha Sauda but they do not have it.

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

Kulbir Singh · 23 Feb 2005

What to write about the greatness of Baba Manochahal. I believe that many gursikhs of that time were kath-putlees who were driven by Siri Dashmesh jee himself. These gursikhs appeared in the Khalsa Panth to rejuvenate the martial spirit in Sikhs. Baba jee was one of them. Out of all Sikh militants, Baba Manochahal jee had most encounters with Police. Only Bhai Avtar Singh Brahma can be equalled with Baba jee in this respect. It is said that Baba jee used to do 11 Siri Sukhmani Sahibs a day. A person doing so many Siri Sukhmani Sahibs is protected by Siri Guru jee. He was actively involved in the Sikh struggle from 1978 till his shaheedi in 1993. After 1984, when the whole Sikh quom was lost and did not know what to do, Baba jee was instrumental in providing the Sikh quom the correct direction. He was instrumental in rejecting the new building of Siri Akal Takhat Sahib built by Baba Santa Singh Nihung at the behest of the Indian government. On April 29th, 1986, Baba jee along with other Singhs held a convention at Siri Akal Takhat Sahib and decided to demolish the old building and build a new one. Baba Thakur Singh was given the sewa of building a new building at Siri Akal Takhat Sahib. Those gursikhs who were present at Siri Akal Takhat Sahib on the day of April 29th, 1986 know how Sikh masses felt when Baba Manochahal came on the stage and declared Ailaan-e-Jung (declaration of war) with the Indian Government until the attainment of Khalistan. When Baba jee, whose voice was very much like Sant Bhindranwalay, made this announcement on the behalf of the first Panthik Committee, Singhs went crazy with joy and brio. The skies of Siri Harmandir Sahib were filled with Jaikaaras of Sat Sree Akaal. Baba jee had already gained immense popularity for have real encounters with para-military forces of India and to see him on the stage amidst hundreds of thousands of Sikhs was a very historical moment. Sikhs loved Baba jee. After making the announcement, Baba jee and his companions disappeared in the Sikhs masses, while the security forces who were present there in plain clothes were greatly agitated. In one of Baba jee’s rare video cassettes, Baba jee tells with his own mubarik tongue of two encounters with police. In one encounter, he along with Bhai Rattan Singh and another gursikh were staying at a village in Tarn Taran Tehsil of Siri Amritsar. A police informer informed police who surrounded the whole village with 5000 strong troops. Three Singhs against 5000 para-military forces was a unfair battle but not for the Khalsa soldiers. Baba jee tells that even for one second he did not get any sign of weakness or mental fatigue. The encounter went on for 4 hours and Baba jee escaped unharmed from there. Singhs fought bravely and it was a shame on police for not being able to apprehend Baba jee despite having so many soldiers. In another encounter, Baba jee was surrounded with about 5000 soldiers and got shot in his leg. Baba jee again tells with his own Mubarik tongue that he, by the grace of Satguru jee, did not feel any weakness or kamzori for even a split second. Again he fought through for 11 hours and successfully escaped. He was a Sikh from eighteenth century. What a great warrior he was. Baba jee had about 11 such police encounters including one in which they fought for 36 hours but Baba jee always escaped unharmed. He had mountain faith in Satguru jee and reciting Gurbani he used to fight his way to success. Many Police constables used to think that he had Karamaat and was able to disappear at will. Baba jee punished many informers and fake militants with his own hands. In his video cassette he tells how Singhs punished Sarbjit Singh Ropar, who had had ratted out Bhai Manvir Singh Chaheru and Bhai Tarsem Singh Kohaar. He writes that Singhs cut them to pieces and fed dogs with them. It is unfortunate that when he was alive, he was accused of being an agent of Congress just as Sant Bhindranwalay was. Most opposition came from one family that has done great harm to the Sikh cause. Guru Sahib himself will take hisaab-kitaab from them. Till the end, Baba jee stayed adamant that he would never succumb to pressure and give up his fight for Khalistan. He used to say that he is merely trying to fulfil the bachan of Mahapurakhs (Sant Bhindranwalay) who used to say that the day the Indian military attacks Siri Darbar Sahib, it will lay foundation of Khalistan. No one is perfect and according to my humble opinion one of the mistakes that Baba jee made was that he failed to control all his men and also did not have stringent checks against militants who joined his organisation. This caused many bad people to join his organisation and the evil-doings of these evil men caused embarrassment to Baba jee. As for himself, he was perfect and was unstained for any wrongdoing. Sikhs will always stay proud of his great achievements. He was a Sikh of eighteenth century but living in twentieth century. His bravery and martial spirit was unmatched. My head bows to at the feet of Baba jee. May Guru Sahib bless our quom with more gursikhs like Baba jee. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

Rick James · 23 Feb 2005

-Kulbir Singh- you wrote : "Again he fought through for 11 hours and successfully escaped.....Baba jee had about 11 such police encounters including one in which they fought for 36 hours but Baba jee always escaped unharmed. He had mountain faith in Satguru jee and reciting Gurbani he used to fight his way to success. Many Police constables used to think that he had Karamaat and was able to disappear at will." Kulbir Singh, keeping this in mind how great a warrior Baba Manochal was, dont you think that Sant Jarnail Singh ji if he wanted to escape Sri Akal Takhat Sahib during the attack he could have? If you answer yes and question that he wouldnt escape cause he was such a warrior then do u not agree that when 5 singhs hukam you, you have to consider the panj singhs as guru sahib themself and listen to that hukam. If you further agree with this, you might question that ok i agree he got hukamed to leave, then why would he not come out and continue the fight and movement especially with all the suffering are singhs and singhnees went through in the 84' riots. Well to that question then would you also not agree with this that whatever Satguru Dashmesh pita Sri Guru Gobind Singh pleases his sikh to do he must follow. Why am i saying this because for 21 years are beloved Sach Khand vasi Sant Baba Takhur Singh ji used to say that Guru ji has asked sant ji to read bani and that is what he is doing and further to that extent babaji used to say their will come a time for Sant ji to finish his seva but Guru Sahibs pleasure,strength and happiness comes from a sikh who follows his hukam. When Sant ji will continue his seva all the strength he gets from finishing this seva would be from the bani Guru ji gave him the strength to read. Secondly, i have a quarrel with you. In nummerous posts you have shown your ignorance by starting up controversial topics and debating about them. Why would a "pro ragmala veer" continue in a debate with you about rag mala not being bani cause at the end of the day your not going to convince him or her that rag mala is not bani but instead you want to show your followers that you got them on this one. Whatever discrepancy you've got and you want answers from "pro rag mala veers" try posting on Gursikhijeevan or come to Jot Parkash Gurduwara.

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

garja singh panjab · 23 Feb 2005

was Baba gurbachan singh ji manochal sarbloh bibeki?

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

Singh · 23 Feb 2005

Baba ji was not Sarbloh Bibeki although he did respect that rehit and liked eating out of batay. He was bibeki at one point though.

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

Kulbir Singh · 23 Feb 2005

Rick James, You asked me why Sant jee could not have escaped at will if Baba Manochahal was able to escape so many times. My answer is that I have no doubt that Sant jee could have escaped not one but million Blue Star Operations but given the kind of bachans he did before the attack it seems unlikely that he escaped. I believe that Sant jee like his elder brother Shaheed Bhai Gurbaksh Singh (who got shaheed in the late 1700s) got shaheed at Siri Akal Takhat Sahib. I don't think it is against Gurmat to not believe that Sant jee escaped instead of getting shaheed. As for your second question or your quarrel with me because I am anti Raagmala and write anti-Raagmala posts. You also wrote that there is no point in debating because it does not change anyone's views. I humbly disagree. I personally was a very staunch supporter of Raagmala until I read the other side. It is perfectly according to Gurmat to do vichaar on these issues and it is perfectly according to Gurmat to bring awareness in Sikh Panth regarding issues like meat and Raagmala. What is wrong in telling others the truth about Raagmala? The disunity comes only if you are intolerant to other peoples' views. We also advocate Keski and if it hurts other peoples sentiments, what can we do about it? We try to do the right thing by preaching Guru Sahib's rehit. The target of my postings on Raagmala is not mainly the pro-Raagmala segments but mostly the AKJ youth who do not believe it to be baani but don't really know why. It is perfectly in our rights to acquaint Sikhs of the reality of Raagmala. And our pro-Raagmala veers should not get offended by it because they too do a lot of parchaar in favour of Raagmala and even make up stories about Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee and other gursikhs like Bhai Sahib Sobha Singh jee Dilwali. In any case, I appeal to gursikhs that this thread is about Baba Manochahal. Let us talk about him, his achievements and his greatness. Why start the Raagmala debate in this thread? Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 24 Feb 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. Baba Ji Manochahal....one of the gleaming pearls in the mala of shaheeds..I have no words worthy to describe what is in my heart..What a magnificent Jathedar of Akal Takhat...the "chamcha jathedars" seem pale beside this shining sun.. A Million Thanks to veers like Balpreet Singh Ji for giving us this opportunity to read about these mahaan shaheeds of the Guru Khalsa panth.. May Waheguru Ji Bless you. Jarnail Singh

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 24 Feb 2005

In any case, I appeal to gursikhs that this thread is about Baba Manochahal. Let us talk about him, his achievements and his greatness. Why start the Raagmala debate in this thread? Daas, Kulbir Singh _____________________---- yes why indeed ?? imho there are already more than enough threadsa about raagmal going on.... Jarnail Singh

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

??? · 24 Feb 2005

whens part 2 coming??

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

SSB · 24 Feb 2005

Pyare jio, this book is the second in the series written by Bhai Amardeep Singh Amar. These books have been written at considerable risk, with already two attempts on his life. The last attempt caused him, his singhni and his young daughter considerable injuries. The first book, "devaa jagde rahai" was very successful in Punjab. Some of its chapters were serialised here, such as the Bhai Anokh Singh babbars Shaheedi, and how the Singhs punished Gobind Ram. Many writers in Punjab are facing threats on their lifes. From Amardeeps group alone, we know of threats to him, Baljit Singh Khalsa, Shivcharan Singh, etc. Sikh Missionary writers aswell have been threaten by RSS. Another close friend of theirs, Dr Sukhpreet Singh has recently released a large 900 page book on the RSS. He also has had some intimidation. They are all in Chardi kala, and will continue writing! But we as the sangat should support their writings, and ensure it reaches as many people as possible. -------------------------- where could i get them in the UK

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

sanatan santra · 24 Feb 2005

is there anything else that can be done besides just purchasing the book about the harrassment our singh ji and his family are facing? This is very unfair, do we have top lawyers there who can help? and when the rss is threatening is that their goons and do they say they are rss openly? proof would be needed and then submitted to punjab high court. If that dont work can we tajke it to international tribunal?

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

Khalsa84 · 24 Feb 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh where can we get these books from?? how many books are there in total? if somebody knows where we can get the books from, please let us know. it would be great to read about our Mahaan Shaheeds. Waheguru.

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

KCF · 08 Mar 2005

LISTERN TO WWW.AKASHRADIO.COM ON 9TH MARCH 8 - 10PM UK TIME LIVE DISCUSSION ON BABA MANOCHAHAL [%sig%]

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

Inderjit Singh Dhiman · 12 Sep 2005

gagan damama bajeyo.. pareyo nishane ghao... khet jo mandeyo SOORMa abb joojhan kao dao....

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

Lionking · 14 Sep 2005

Thanks for bumping it up Inderjit SIngh joe. yes when is part II coming?

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

Siddharth · 14 Sep 2005

<> How cleverly has the anti-Hindu sentiment been disguised. Do we know which "Hindu" officer this was? Do we have a name? I mean what is this rot? This has clearly been included to incite Sikh anger against the Hindus. Why doesn't anyone even question this? Regards, Sid.

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

singh · 14 Sep 2005

There are four parts. Below is the link to part 4 and you can follow all the way back using the links at the tops of the posts "continued from..." Final Days: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Conclusion

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

Singh · 14 Sep 2005

Siddharth I am sure the name and details of the Hindu Officer can be provided, it is just not mentioned in the post, so what. Is that such a crime and responsible for Sikh/Hindu tensions (lets just let your right wing brothers off the hook, as butter would not melt in thier mouths). It’s funny and blatantly contradictory how you seem to take such offence with this technicality when your own Indian Government has through its media and other avenues forget simply not naming an individual but has blamed the entire Sikh Nation for a number of atrocities (without any proof I may add) So Siddharth its wrong to say a Hindu Officer did something wrong, but its fine for Hindu’s to blame the entire Sikh Religion for atrocities without naming any individual. The coin flips two ways, and you are obviously ignorant of this fact. What I question is your double standards and integrity. Look forward to hearing your reply.

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

min · 14 Sep 2005

Bhai Siddharth Jee, Sikh in the military have faced discrimination in the past. This is no secret, I myself have a relative who faced similar discrimination. The great Sikh generals such as Jagjit Singh Arora, Subegh Singh also faced discrimination. Please visit the following link to read the story of Narinder Singh who like many Sikh youth in the armed forces had to face discrimination in the Indian Army. Why I shot my boss BTW, before you claim that Narinder Singh also hated Hindus, you should know that Narinder Singh was born in a Hindu family. By bringing awareness about instances in which Sikhs have faced discrimination does not mean hate is being propagated against the Hindus. If an African American is discriminated against and tells people about it, does it mean he is spreading hate against white Americans?

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

Siddharth · 14 Sep 2005

<> Great - Please provide the same. <> I don't know if the GOI had any proof but I do. Two members of my own family were murdered in cold blood by Sikhs in Amritsar (1987) and the indirect perpetrator migrated to Germany in the late eighties. No clue how or where he is now. <> I don't care what you question - You can't even provide your name on this forum. Why are you such a coward? So much for your integrity. Please read my posts carefully in the future. Where have I said that I support right wing Hindus? I have always maintained, and will continue to do so, that militancy in any religion is wrong, especially in Hinduism, since I belong to that faith and can speak for it. My question was totally different and you have construed it differently. Regards, Sid.

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

Kharkoo · 14 Sep 2005

Dhan Shaheed Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochal Dhan Shaheed Sant Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa Bhinderanwale 'Rick James'... you have fell into the trap of the GOI.... people like you r waiting for sant ji to return which he will not do... and you are the people who say that when sikhi will drop to its lowest point sant ji wil come back... first of all you guyz r willing to tolerate all the rss bullshit becuase you think that sant ji is coming back... its been 21 years.. he aint comin back... this nonsense about him leaving akal takht makes him sound like a 'chiken'.. if you listen to sant ji's speeches you will know that he would NEVER leave akal takht while fighting the army.. If you check saintsoldiiers.net, baba gurbachan singh himself (in a video) said the sant ji told him that he would never run away even if he knew the tanks would be rolling over his body... Even the jathedar that was selected after baba thakur singh has admited that sant ji is shaheed... Baba Ram singh has also admitted him to be a shaheed. Why would sant ji not let baba manochal take part in the attack.. cuz he knew that he was going to take shaheedi and that he needed someone to take over for him!!! Dhan Shaheed Sant Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa Bhinderanwale

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

Singh · 15 Sep 2005

Siddarth. Siddarth, what does it matter if I use my name or not. Your real name could be Gangoo Bhamin as far as I know. Okay if you insist my name is Samsher Singh, happy now. I did read your half wit post, and obviously now that it has been questioned you have changed your tune. You were clearly implying that simply because the Hindu Officers name was not given the original post was in your very own words: “How cleverly has the anti-Hindu sentiment been disguised. Do we know which "Hindu" officer this was? Do we have a name? I mean what is this rot? This has clearly been included to incite Sikh anger against the Hindus. Why doesn't anyone even question this?” I simply exposed the FACT that your very own Hindu brothers have not named a single person for numerouse crimes, but have gone light years further by blaming the entire Sikh nation for atrocities. The Indian Government did this to create Sikh/Hindu tensions, far greater than any post here. A shining example being your Hindu brothers going around on government vehicles blaming Sikhs for poisoning Delhi’s water supply in order to create tensions in the build up to the 84 anti Sikh riots. So why complain when the original post does not give a Hindu officers name, when your own people have gone much further.

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

Singh · 16 Sep 2005

Siddarth wrote " I have always maintained, and will continue to do so, that militancy in any religion is wrong, especially in Hinduism, since I belong to that faith and can speak for it." Perhaps you need to therefore ask your local Pandit what is written in the Bhawati Geeta, Mahabarat etc which are all tales of war/militancy. Didn't Ram Chander and countless others in Hinduism use militancy. Oh yes i forgot, Ram Chander left numerouse people dead for the sake of his own wife (selfish act), but when someone fights in defence of woman who are being raped by Indian police Officers like Bhai Fauja Singh they are suddenly called militants. You may claim the numerous Hindu stories of war/militancy were fought for a good cause, however one mans militant is another mans freedom fighter. As for the "Sikhs" you claim killed 2 of your family members please name them. If you are so concerned with the name of the Hindu Officer being revealed please likwise reveal the names of the ACTUAL PEOPLE who killed your family members. By giving a name of a group leader and saying he was indirectly responsible is not good enough.

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

angel · 16 Sep 2005

i am interested in the famous encounter that took place in village rataul tarn taran between the punjab police and the btfk manochahal group, and why did the btfk shoot dead the dig border range ajit singh, and who was lt general lakhwinder singh the leader of the group of singhs who fought the police in that encounter

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

nav · 17 Sep 2005

this encounter was baba gurbachan s manochahals greatest in rataul tarn taran in may 1991 five singhs took on the punjab police crpf army

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

Samsher Singh · 18 Sep 2005

Nav (or anyone else), please give more details of this battle.

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

indy · 18 Sep 2005

up to 30000 police and army had surrounded the singhs, the cops usedthe villagers as human sheilds i will get more info later dhan lt gen lakhwinder singh ji

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

no-one · 18 Sep 2005

where can we get the books from in the uk?

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

Frank · 11 Dec 2005

Did Babajee get married and have any children ? If so where are they located now? Do they still have to encounter police harrasement etc, etc? What sorts of issues are they facing?

Re: No Surrender: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal Part I

Zorawar singh · 12 Dec 2005

he was married and had children. One of his boys was born during Operation Blue Star.