Who is Satguru - Debate with Radhasoamis
Admin · 28 Feb 2005
Attached is a post by Justin under the thread "Who is Satguru". We appeal "Khoji2" and "Gurdaspuria" and other friends who have similar views to start a new thread if need be but leave this thread to be a debate between Khalsa and Radhasoamis. An appeal to all contributors to engage in an intelligent debate and keep the atmosphere serene and harmonious. No name calling. Admin. Author: justin Date: 02-28-05 09:34 Kulbir Singh, I agree that Radhasoamis don’t do this kind of stuff i.e. agar-batee Dhoop jyot etc. They use Varnatmak Naam to get to Dhunatmak Naam. This Dhunatmak Naam they try to get to is not achievable by their Aalti-palti aasan. Only Gurmat Naam can get one to the jyot-vigaasi form of Naam i.e. that form of Naam that is holding the whole universe together. ----------- How can you be so sure if you haven't seen the other side of the coin ... by your reason all people before Guru Nanak Dev Ji for 1500 years and more could not realize God ... because they could not be Sikhs ... logic is lacking here as God can not be so unfair and biased towards our Sikhism. ----------------------------------------------------------- Over here you are wrong. There are several references in several of the books published by Radhasoami Beas in which they have written that “a book cannot be Guru”. Who are they targeting when they say that a book cannot be Guru? Charan Singh himself said in one of his cassettes when doing translation of sunaiya pauris of Siri Jap jee Sahib. He said something along the lines that a book or pothi cannot be Guru. ------------------- I do not agree with you here .... what He has suggested that just by mere reading it you shouldn't think that you can realize God ----------------------------------------------------------- You ask if any saint had no Guru. The answer is that Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee had no human Guru. His Guru was Vaheguru himself and Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee himself has written this. Ponder upon this pankiti: APRAMPAR PARBRAHAM PARMESHAR, NANAK GUR MILIYA SOYEE|| ---------- This is your understanding of the bani ... nothing has been documented in any books of that time ... that He did not have any guru. Sant either directly come from God but still they need a spark or if tru sant bestows his daya mehar on somebody and uplifts and make him a sant or a person becomes one through abhyaas and daya mehar of a sant/guru. Jesus was a Saint directly from God but still he needed baptism from St John. -------------------------------------------------------- Then why do you, O Radhasomis believe that only if one comes to your Guru one can reach Anami Lok, Satlok and Radhasoami Dhaam? Do you believe that anyone can reach the top level i.e. the Radhasoami Dhaam without your Guru? I have read in your books where you have written very clearly that all religions are within the realms of “kaal” and only your faith i.e. the Radhasoami faith can take you to Radhasoami Dhaam. ----------- This is your misconception. Anyone who does abhyaas and can concentrate and wants to be one with God can make spiritual progress. I definitely believe that if a person takes naam daan of any true saint/guru, he can reach sachkhand. I do not have any idea of any such book that you have mentioned. I am talking of RSS Beas, of others I can not comment. ------------------------------------------- What is so hard about seeing the light? This fake light can be seen by anyone who thinks that he wants to see the light and does paath? Anyone can hear those so called mystical sounds like bell, flute etc if your mind wants to listen to it. The real thing is if you hear Anhad Shabad – the real ones and not some flute, dhol, bell or water fall etc. as you guys preach. ----------------- I am again saying "If RS say that you can see light within then if no body has seen it in the past 100 years ... then it would not have been in existence now .... " Jesus said .. "If thy eye be single..your body shall be full of light" .. Can you try to explain this statement? "This fake light can be seen by anyone who thinks that he wants to see the light and does paath?" ... I am not talking here of imagination .. it does not remain for long. I bet that once you have darshan of your guru inside then you can have darshan of any of the guru sahibaan within who can take you to the almighty because they are one with Him and then once you have settled your karmas you can be one with Him for ever. I can quote many vaaks from gurbani where guru sahibaans have mentioned about such sounds ... they have not mentioned just for the sake of it. I do not have it now as I do not have strong memory like yours. The bells that we have in church, bells we have in mandirs, the candles we have in church, the jyot we have in religious places, the instruments that we have found for ourselves ... like shankh, mridang, sarangi are nothing but the reflections of inner spiritual heights into day to day life. Hindus started idol worship only in that way ... initially that was made for their concentration for meditation but over the ages they were happy only with aarti and puja ... meditation all forgotten. Do you ever wonder why we have guru sahibaans photos on calendars doing meditation ....(if we leave the historical depictions)? I remember, one hindu saint has said ... naam ki mahima main kya karun ... naam ki mahim to raam bhi nahin kar saktay ... how can such a statement come from a hindu ...because he knows that sants are above devi\devta\avtaar .... he does not follow sikhism then how could he talk about Naam .... why bible starts with "Word is God". Bible also speaks about such sounds. ------------------------------------------------------ No they don’t have faith in Ten Guru Sahibaan. Then how dare they say that Kabir was the Guru of Guru Nanak Dev jee? According to Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee Kabir is called a Bhagat while Guru Sahibaan are called “Mahalla”. There is a difference. Guru Sahibaan are above everyone else. ------------------------ Nobody has said Kabir Sahib was guru of Guru Nanak. Tell me one book where this is mentioned. Kabir sahib was a saint and preached what Guru Sahibaans were preaching .. its only because of that His vaani is present in SGGS. ------------------------------------------------------ Gurmat is greatest of all. This Sahansar-Dal-Kanwal i.e. the lotus with 1000 petals is nothing at all and nor is Bhanwar Gufaa anything for Khalsa. Khalsa does not go this route. This is the route of the Jogis. Who wants to see Sahansar-Dal-Kanwal? I don’t. This is a much lower state. Gursikhs aim from Vaheguru and that is it. Anything short of Vaheguru himself is not acceptable to Gursikhs. ----------------------------- RS does not say that the aim is to see lotus .. the aim is to see God/Waheguru. Lotuses just falls in the route. Somebody mentioned that Bhai Randhir Singh has mentioned about this ... why he mentioned the route of yogis .. Just that below dasham dwar these lotuses are inverted and pale and above it they are straight and bright. I again say that any abhyasi can make spiritual progress under a true guru ... if you have found a true guru and you believe Him and do abhyaas .. you can make spiritual progress .. no need to affiliate to RS then. ---------------------------------------------- Impossible!!!!! This is a blatant lie. Bhai Bala’s Janamsaakhi that you are reading is distorted and also this janamsaakhi is not a book of authority in Sikh Panth. ----------------------- Giving an authority to a book in current era can also be due to pressures and political motives. Try getting the oldest manuscripts that existed before RS foundation was laid .. then you will be able to see it without bias. I just read it in a public library in Jalandhar. ------------------------------------------------ Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee is the Satguru while Kabir jee is a Bhagat. This makes it clear. Bhagat jee is great but he is not a Guru and he never claimed to be one either. He never gave Naam. ---------------------------- Bhagat is due to the fact that India had a Bhakti movement during Kabir Sahib's time. Kabir Saheb never gave naam ...then you are mistaken ... he gave naam to Ibrahim Adham - King of bukhara, Dharamdas to name a few ... Dharamdas was the one who got the guru gaddi after kabir sahib. Kabir sahib also had 21 gaddis after him. Sant Ravidaas whose baani is in SGGS gave naam to Sant Peepa who was a rajput king. Sant Peepa's few couplets are there in SGGS. Any saint can give naam IF AND ONLY IF he has a hukm from God/waheguru because by giving naam dan he has to take the responsibility of making him one with God. ---------------------------------------------- By all this discussion I am not in any way trying to say that to be one with God you have to be an affiliate of RSSB.. just that you need to have a true guru and do abhyas with the will to be one with God .. Rest all depends on His daya mehar. If you find that Guru in SGGS ..you can go ahead. Why a jew who does not see guru or saint in SGGS can not be one with God? Everybody, irrespective of religion (may be a hindu or a jew) , if he sees SGGS as his/her Guru then he/she can continue with that and do nit nem and abhyaas. Rest all is in the hands of God. We can just pray for His daya mehar. Author: justin Date: 02-28-05 12:02 Bhopinder Singh Ji, I do not think you have read Bible and that is why you are biased Bible starts with "Word is God" ... Word here is the "Shabd" that you are talking about "But the Word of the Lord endureth for ever. And this is the Word which by the gospel is preached unto you." Bible ... "And take the helmet of salvation, and the sword of the Spirit, which is the word of God" ....here Spirit is your "Surat" Bible ... "The words that I speak unto you, they are spirit, and they are life" "And the Word was made flesh, and dwelt among us" that means the saint was "Shabd Swaroop" and had come as human being. Bible ... "Know ye not that you are the temple of God, and that the Spirit of God dwelleth in you?" Guru Nanak Ji says "kaaya mahalu mandiru ghar hari ka, tis mahi rakhi jyot apaar" Bible ... "He hath given us of his spirit" Guru Nanak Dev Ji .. "Aatam mein raam, raam mein aatam" Kabir Sahib .. "Kehu kabir ih ram ki ans" Light Within ... guru nanak sahib says... "Antar jyot sabad dhun, jagai satgur jhagaru nibaire" ------------------------------------------------------ I am not saying that there are things in SGGS that have already mentioned in Bible 2000 years ago ... what I mean is all saints come from the almighty and their innner spiritual experiences are same and hence they speak similar things ... just the way changes a little due to language and era. you will see similar kalaam from many sufi saints .... Guru Nanak Dev Ji .. "ghar mahi ghar dekhai dayee, so satgur purakh sujan" Sultan Bahu "naam faqeer tis da bahu, ghar vich yaar vikhalay hu" ---- Kabir Sahib "Bin satgur pawaye nahin, kotin karay upaaye" Guru Nanak Dev Ji "Satgur bajhau ghor andhara, dubi muaye binu paani" Tulsidas "Gur binu bhav nidhi tarai na koi" ------------------ Again I am saying ... it does not matter whether you find your guru in SGGS, RSSB or anywhere else ... without a true guru you can not have spiritual progress and we should not compare saints ... peer milay tay peed na jaaway, taan us peer ki dharna hu murshid milya rushad na man nu, oh murshid ki karna hu jis hadi thi nahin hadayat, oh haadi ki fadna hu I have many gursikh friends but we never crossed each others ideology and we respect each others path. And most of the time I am on with them for various events.