Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Interesting conversation with an Isaayee Bibi

Interesting conversation with an Isaayee Bibi

Kulbir Singh · 04 Mar 2005

Most days I walk home from the train station. It is about 2 km walk to home and I look forward to it because I do my regular Siri Sukhmani Sahib while walking home. One day as I was walking a lady unexpectedly patted on my shoulder while we crossed each other and smilingly remarked, “Good man”. I was somewhat confounded but continued doing my paath as I smiled back at her. The next day again she met me on my way back home and this time she stopped and intimated something that I could not make out as it was hardly audible, but it was something about Bible. She had a dishevelled look and was wearing old albeit clean clothes. Around her neck she had a hand written poster that had the following note: “This world is polluted. The pollutants are Homosexuality, Incest, Adultery, Fornication, Abuse, Murder, Cheating………..” She asked me directly, without hesitating, “You look like a good man but are you free from these pollutants?” I was taken aback by her sudden exclamation but replied calmly, “by the grace of God, I am”. “But you know that you still must come to Jesus. You must open your heart to Jesus.” “I think Jesus was a good man and I appreciate his good deeds and his sacrifice.” “Appreciating is not enough. You must open your heart to him”, she persisted. “But one heart can do only one love. My heart has already opened up for my Guru and has fallen in love with him. There is no chance in this life of loving anyone else”, I said using the analogy of Ghalib in one of his shayers, that one heart is good for only one love (Dil bhee yaa Rabb, kayee diye hotay). “You must realise that unless you wash yourself with the blood of Jesus, you cannot be purified”, she said strongly. Till now I was in no mood to engage in a religious debate with her but she forced me to have expostulations with her. I decided to go ahead and engage in a small debate with her. She was a bit agitated but I was calm, by Guru Sahib’s kirpa. “I don’t understand how blood can purify anyone or anything”, I replied back. “You see Jesus gave his blood for us. We must wash ourselves and our souls with his blood. Until we do that, we cannot get purified”. “Tell me one thing ma’am. If you behold a person washing his clothes with blood, what would you think of him.” “WHAT”, she cried. “Okay, let me rephrase. If you witness a person, taking shower with blood, instead of water, what would you consider such person doing? Won’t you find him demonic and fiendish?” She paused for a moment and seemed perplexed at the direction I was taking. She probably had never looked at this from this direction. A long pause ensued. I continued, “Blood is blood, whether it is Jesus’ or someone else’s. Blood stains our clothes. Then how can it purify our hearts?” “I told you before, that Jesus’ blood is different. It is special blood. Your Nanak cannot save you”, said she stuttering. When she brought my Guru’s name on her tongue in a detestable manner, I got a bit upset but understood that she was a bit frustrated. “Okay tell me one thing. Are you a spiritual being or a physical being? Are you this body or someone living in this body?” “Well, we are body, soul and spirit. Actually, I am a spiritual being but I am also body”, she said while trying to figure out what to say. “Make up your mind ma'am, whether you are a body or someone living in the body”, I told her. “Well, I don’t know if I am body or soul or spirit. Perhaps I am all three”. “Just as your body is wearing your clothes but your body is different from your clothes, same way you are wearing this body to be in this world but you are not your body. The fact that you say “My body”, proves that you are separate from you body. Just like your body changes clothes, you change your bodies. Bible talks about hell and heaven. Well, who suffers hell and who enjoys the bliss of heaven if your body is getting decomposed here in this world? This alone proves that you are not your body but an entity living in this body” A long silence ensued my discourse. She was somewhat dumbfounded. “I guess you are right. I am an entity living in this body as my entity but I don’t understand why I need my body to be here in this world”, she asked inquisitively. “In order to stay and function in this enchanted world made of 5 basic elements, a body of 5 elements is required. Our astral body or our spiritual body cannot function in this world and same holds true vice-versa”. “What vice-versa”, she asked. “Vice-versa, meaning; our physical body cannot go to the next world because next world is out of this enchanted world made of 5 basic elements. So in the next world we carry our real body and stay in our real-self.” “I see”, she said. “Now think about it ma’am; how can blood of Jesus i.e. a physical thing of 5 basic elements clean your spiritual self or soul?” She stayed quiet for quite bit. In the end she said, “I will have to think about this more deeply. I have never looked at spirituality from the angles you have pointed out today. I regularly go this way and I am sure to bump into you sometime soon. We will continue our discussion. At this time I don't know what to say. Thanks for your time and see you again.” “See you and bye”. I resumed my paath from the ashtpadi I had left before expostulating with her and reached home, thanking Vaheguru for being with me. Daas, Kulbir Singh PS: Isaayee means one who believes in Isa Maseeh i.e. Jesus Christ. Moosaayee is one who believes in Moses i.e a Jew.

Re: Interesting conversation with an Isaayee Bibi

nice · 04 Mar 2005

is this your personal account with this person bhai sahib or are you posting something another person wrote and sharing with us?

Re: Interesting conversation with an Isaayee Bibi

Kulbir Singh · 04 Mar 2005

It is my personal account. This incident ocurred very recently. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Interesting conversation with an Isaayee Bibi

anon · 04 Mar 2005

vjkk vjkf jus out of curiousity kulbir singh, how quickly do you do sri sukhmani sahib as 2km cant take more than 20-30 minutes at most and sukhmani sahib surely takes at least 1 hour to do, sorry if i have gone off topic, i was jus wondering wjkk wjkf

Re: Interesting conversation with an Isaayee Bibi

Kulbir Singh · 04 Mar 2005

--------- jus out of curiousity kulbir singh, how quickly do you do sri sukhmani sahib as 2km cant take more than 20-30 minutes at most and sukhmani sahib surely takes at least 1 hour to do, sorry if i have gone off topic, i was jus wondering ----------- It takes me about 30 minutes to do one Siri Sukhmani Sahib. Some days I can do it in around 30 minutes and at other times it takes me about 40 minutes. A good paath that you can do quite audibly takes about 40 minutes. The 30 minute paath is not very audible, though done not in surtee but using rasna. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Interesting conversation with an Isaayee Bibi

anon · 04 Mar 2005

vjkk vjkf thanks for the reply but me being a dumb person doesnt understand ''though done not in surtee but using rasna''. could you explain please? thank you bhai sahib vjkk vjkf

Re: Interesting conversation with an Isaayee Bibi

Kulbir Singh · 04 Mar 2005

-------- ''though done not in surtee but using rasna''. could you explain please? -------- Paath done loudly involves speaking or singing and is fully audible to one's ears and to others too. Paath done with rasna (use of tongue) but without the use of lips, is not audible to the ears from outside but we can still hear it. Rasna is involved but we don't fully talk. Employing this way of doing paath one can do paath faster than normal. Paath done fully in surte does not employee any part of the physical body and is done fully in surtee or mann. More paath in rasna we do, more automation of surtee paath happens. Surtee paath happens only when we listen to paath carefully. Gursikhs say that there comes a time when paath in surtee goes on without effort and we just have to listen to it. Paath done this way is quite fast. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Interesting conversation with an Isaayee Bibi

Rashminder Singh · 04 Mar 2005

THANX bhai sahib ji gr8 post waheguru

Re: Interesting conversation with an Isaayee Bibi

anon · 04 Mar 2005

vjkk vjkf thanks for the explanation bhai sahib:) vjkk vjkf

Re: Interesting conversation with an Isaayee Bibi

beautiful.. · 04 Mar 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh Veer Kulbir Singh, Thank you for sharing this story with us all. That was a fine example by which you were able to give 'crystal clear' understanding of what our beloved Guru's has given onto us. No doubt that you have helped this lady see the world in a very different light, not picking faults with any other faith, but the Bible was in fact written many years after the passing of Christ, and complied many years later, thus some discrepancies could exist! Thoroughly enjoyed the lesson you were able to give us… Thank you. Kulbir Singh Dhillon UK Wala

Re: Interesting conversation with an Isaayee Bibi

rain drop · 05 Mar 2005

Well done

Re: Interesting conversation with an Isaayee Bibi

Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 05 Mar 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru ji Ki fateh. well done. we can only "debate" intelligently with these types IF we "know" our GURU JI well. I always maintain that those" sikhs" who get "converted" are not "sikhs"....they dont know a thing about their Guur or their faith. They were just "born" into Sikh families ad carried on behaving like "sikhs"...and when the next "salesman" came along they fell for the sales pitch like a nine pin. This is the Main reason why NOT a SINGLE SIKH out of thousands and thousands tortured most horribly, given the juiciest inducements, wealth, princesses, palaces, governorships..laalach to "convert", or just "cut their hair", or just repeat the Kalma..etc CONVERTED or wavered from their SIKHI. Now a days many so called "sikhs" convert just for a fistfull of dollars, a lorry license, a buiness opportunity, a job offer, a promotion etc etc. The "converters" alos know that these types of "converts" are actually trash..but they are just for numbers...so many converted... how many remain converted ?/ not necessary !!! Sikhi is the Game of LOVE...GURU JI demands we come to the play wearing our head on our palm...and once we have doen that..we NEVER convert !! Thats why there is No such thing as a"born Sikh"...its a CHOICE we have to MAKE...Amrit is a CHOICE..a Commitment....Life long commitment..made voluntarily. "Amrit sanchaars" held just to "make numbers" produces sikhs who can fall easily as they never had the commitment in the first place. I frimly beleive IF Guru Ji had prepared Amrit and declared that he was going to "chkaa amrit" to all..... many many more than the Five would have rushed forward..BUT Guur Ji demanded the HEAD first. Secondly Jeewan...Leading by EXAMPLE is the best way for parchaar...as Kulbir Singh ji has shown. I doubt the lady will ever "pangga" with Kulbir Singh again...there are "easier" targets !!! Jarnail Singh

Re: Interesting conversation with an Isaayee Bibi

Sohangani · 05 Mar 2005

When Christians refer to the blood of Jesus Christ, they don't mean physically washing yourself in blood, although 'Wash yourself in his blood' is the language they often use. This idea of washing in blood, is refering to the spirit of Jesus Christ and is represented in practice as baptism- immersion in or sprinking of water. This bibi is a believer, not an intellectual who can engage in debates with other religious people. It is not fair to say that her entire belief system is false because of how confused Veerji was able to make her (although Veerji I do understand it was not your intent to confuse her). Many Sikhs can also be easily persuaded/confused by people well versed in other religions who are skilled debaters. This conversation between Veer Kulbir Singh and the Isaayee Bibi could have easily happened the other way around between a knowledged Christian and your everyday Sikh. Judging by the content of this conversation, I don't think either Veerji or the Bibi had the correct understanding of what they were debating about. Sohagani [%sig%]

Re: Interesting conversation with an Isaayee Bibi

time? · 05 Mar 2005

i have done patt of sukhmani sahib once (just started yesterday) i spoke the words out loud... it took me almost 2 hrs do complete it. question is i have, is this normal for a begginer of sukhmani sahib? i know i will be able to do it faster but im just wondering if 2 hrs is normal for someone who just started... could kulbir singh answer this?

Re: Interesting conversation with an Isaayee Bibi

singh · 05 Mar 2005

Sohagani, Your everyday sikh won't go around trying to convert seemingly orthodox christians, or try preaching to them about Guru Nanak Dev Jee. If someone wants to show someone the 'true' path, they themselves should first know and understand it.

Re: Interesting conversation with an Isaayee Bibi

MKaur · 05 Mar 2005

I somewhat disagree with Sohagani. What Kulbir Singh ji said was very clear and it is evident that he KNEW very well what he was talking about. I would have never been able to give an explaination like that. *Thumbs Up* for that. I enjoyed this incident. If you bump into her again...please share ith us the conversation. Thanks

Re: Interesting conversation with an Isaayee Bibi

Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 05 Mar 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Dera sohagani jio, you write: When Christians refer to the blood of Jesus Christ, they don't mean physically washing yourself in blood, although 'Wash yourself in his blood' is the language they often use. This idea of washing in blood, is refering to the spirit of Jesus Christ and is represented in practice as baptism- immersion in or sprinking of water.<<<< IMHO it would be physically "impossible" to wash in Jesus' real blood as he is long gone...this is "play" on words.. Next we will hear that they Dont "actually Eat" jesus's body....although they do this every sunday at communion...and "dotn actually drink his blood" either when they are given wine to drink. ( that would make them "cannibals"..and they are not cannibals maybe "spiritual cannibals ) BUT where did this "idea" came about.... from SACRIFICE....everybody eats the SACRIFICIAL LAMB....and here Jesus is the sacrificial lamb..and anyone who beleives in Jesus has to EAT his body and drink his blood...whether we call it "spiritual" or otherwise is debateable. IMHO this is WHY the lady couldnt debate with Kulbir Singh Ji..because she had not a leg to stand on. This whole idea of "sacrifice for someone else" is not acceptable in GURMATT as we are all RESPONSIBLE for our OWN doings...NO one ( not even so called God's son) can do it for us. Merely "beleiving/opeing ones heart" WILL NOT absolve our DOINGS/SINS..we have to APPLY the CURE which is Naam Japp/Naam kamiiaii/Kirt kamaii/Waand chhakna etc etc...individually. Jarnail Singh

Re: Interesting conversation with an Isaayee Bibi

anon · 06 Mar 2005

vjkk vjkf a 2 hours reading of sukhmani sahib is perfectly normal for a first time, even after many readings many people take over 1 hour to read it at the fastest vjkk vjkf

Re: Interesting conversation with an Isaayee Bibi

Admin · 06 Mar 2005

Benti to S. Gurcharan Singh Kulim. Please email us at [address removed] to discuss your concern. Admin.