Forum
Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 10 Mar 2005
Continued from:
"Jot" some questions
What I had written under the thread "jot some questions" was my understanding of Gurbani and vague rememberance of books of Bhai Sahib. Herein, I am referencing quotes from Bhai Sahib's books that would be of great interest to the seekers of Vaheguru and his mahal.
Bhai Sahib was a Sachyaar Purash and had a very buland Takheeyal and an extremely Azeem Parvaaz-e-khyaal-o-rajoo. To translate his works perfectly is just impossible for a mortal being and an keet-e-naacheez like me. Therefore, I entreat before sangat to ignore my mistakes and accept this translation.
Translated from page 71-72 or Sach Khand Darshan by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee:
Bhagat Ravidaas jee in love (Shabad: Beghampura Shehar ko nayo on ang 345 of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee) gives Sach Khand the name of Beghumpura i.e. the place where there is no sorrow (Be-Gham-pura) because in Beghampura there is no sorrow, worry, anxiety and nor is there any tax as in this mortal world. There is no worldly riches and wealth there. There is no fear of sin and nor there is regression and degeneration of mind there.
Bhagat jee is saying that they have attained a very great dwelling-place where there is always happiness. Governments or kings in this land don’t change like worldly governments and kings. Kingdom of Vaheguru always stays eternal. This city of Beghampura is very densely populated and very prosperous too. Since Beghampura is the place where Vaheguru resides (in his pure form) this dwelling is just as famous as Vaheguru himself. In this city, Bhagats loaded with the wealth of Naam and accepted by Vaheguru reside and they are fully knowledgeable of the secrets of the palace of Vaheguru. They can enjoy the bliss of this palace as they please i.e. there is no stopping to them. If they will, they can come back to this world (Earth) at their will as per the Gurbani hukam “Gurmukh aaye jaaye nisung”. In this dwelling of Sach Khand one realises what real freedom is. Bhagat jee declares that only those ones who reside in Sach Khand are his friends. Only their friendship can last in the mortal world and the Sach Khand world.
*********Translation over**********
Above Bhai Sahib jee has clearly stated that Bhagats are very much alive and not decimated in Sach Khand. They are not only alive but at will they can come to this world or go anywhere they want. There is total freedom to them. They can go anywhere unhindered.
If we read the article, “Akal Purakh dee Dargaah” in Andithee Duniya, we get clear understanding that Bhagats do in fact reside in the next world and they don’t lose their identity. I will herein give few quotations from Bhai Sahib’s books to prove this point:
Andithee Duniya quotations are from Edition 6, 1990.
1) Page 96 of Andithee Duniya:
In the dargaah of Vaheguru (Har Dargaah andar), reside millions and billions of servants or bhagats of Vaheguru, who reside with Vaheguru in such manner that they don’t lose sight of him even for one moment. This unseen and unreachable (for mortal beings) world exists totally away from the sight of the worldly people of this world (our world – Earth). This world of Nirankaar or Vaheguru is much more densely and prosperously populated than the mortal world. Exact Punjabi quote is: Ih duniya (Sach Khand) aisee hee ghugg vasdee hai jaise ke drishtmaan duniya (physical world i.e. mortal world); sagon uh vadere ghugg vasdee hai.
Yatha Gurvaak (refer to the Gurbani Hukam below).
KOT MEHAL JA KAE DARBARE ||
NIMAKH NIMAKH VASAI TIN NAALAY ||
2) Page 96 of Andithee Duniya
SOOKH MEHAL JA KE OOCH DUYAARAY ||
TAA MEH VAASEH BHAGAT PYAARAY || (Ang 739)
Billions and Billions of khoohaniyaan i.e. regiments of Bhagats reside in the eternal and true Sachkhandee Darbaar of Vaheguru. By the kirpa of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj ones who have collected the true wealth of Naam took this wealth with them to Sach Khand.
Khoohani means a regiment that contains x number of soldiers, infantry, elephants, horses etc. Bhai Sahib used the world khoohani to describe the colonies of Bhagats there.
3) Page 88 of Andithee Duniya
The existence of the dargaah (darbaar) of Vaheguru is such a notion that a gursikh must have faith in and it is pure Gurmat to do so. According to Gurmat there is Nirankaar’s Khand i.e. Sach Khand and there is the Darbaar of Vaheguru too. Yathaa Gurvaak:
NIRANKAAR KAI DESH JAAHE, TAAN SUKH LAHEH MAHAL ||
The happiness-giving palace and the land of Vaheguru Nirankaar is surely there in the next world. O Gursikho, believe this truth without any doubt.
There are many more examples I can give from Bhai Sahib’s books that will prove beyond doubt that the Bhagats don’t die in the next world or don't cease to exist; and not only do they exist but they stay in full bliss. The bhagats have full freedom and at their will can come to this mortal world of ours as well. "Gurmukh aaye jaaye nisung" is the pankiti that Bhai Sahib has quoted to prove this.
I personally was having hard time swallowing some of the assertions by my veers and bhains that stated that Singhs like Baba Deep Singh jee and Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee had decimated into Vaheguru. Verily, they are still alive and at their will can come to this world.
Bhai Sahib also writes that since there is no maaiya in Sach Khand, Bhagats don’t have to do any effort to do bhagtee there because their surtee just does not go out of Naam and Sifat Salaah. What a great world this is. Oh! May we become citizens of this world.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
avidya · 11 Mar 2005
Gurfateh
This sounds very much like a Christian idea of heaven. I have never heard such a katha from gurmukh scholars before. Did Bhai Sahib recieve any training under Christian scholars? I've not read his autobiography but where did Bhai Sahib receive his schooling? Is it possible that he was inspired by Christian thinking which no doubt changed his ideas on sachkhand?
very interesting
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
. · 11 Mar 2005
wowwwwwwww thats all i can say
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 11 Mar 2005
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
<<<<<>>>>
Gurmukh aiye jaiyee NISAANG..could have no other meaning. It is difficult for us to imagine a state of "merger" and yet "distinct".
Thank you veer Kulbir Singh for a thought provoking read. I agree 110% with you about the difficulty of "translating" Bhai sahib ji's THOUGHTS....it is a wonder that he himself managed to write down all this in a language we would understand with difficulty....much less translate to another foreign language....
Jarnail Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 11 Mar 2005
Avidiya, that was really strange of you to have suspected that Bhai Sahib was trained by Christians. You should listen to katha by other Mahapurakhs and you will find references in there how Mahapurakhs even after their physical demise helped the living Mahapurakhs.
If you suspect Bhai Sahib of being influenced by Christians then I accuse you of being influenced by naastik (atheist) Buddhist notion of decimation (nirvana) or the impotent belief of Vedanta that we become shuniya after death.
It is really our great luck that this atheist and naastik faith of Buddhism was cleaned out of India by Shankracharya, and it is great that the growing influence of Shankracharya's Vedant was countered by the Bhagti movement and by Chaitaniya Mahaprabhu's Prema Bhagti movement.
And don't forget Bhai Sahib seldom writes anything without Gurbani backup. If some Gurbani notion does not match your current notion, you cannot doubt the Gurbani notion but your own notion. Didn't Bhai Sahib write Gurbani Shabads to support what he wrote? Are you now going to suspect that our Guru Sahibaan were somehow influenced by Christians?
Despite repeated requests from me, you still have not written what your understanding is about the Bhagats in Sach Khand and if they retain their consciousness. I had asked you a couple of questions in the previous thread but you keep writing that your response is "staring at my face". I could not deduce answers from you extremely terse and concise response. You should explain it more.
It is easy to just criticise Bhai Sahib's or anyone else's writings but much harder to write your own. Let us hear from you and then we will comment on your comments.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
J Singh · 11 Mar 2005
While debating this topic with you yesterday, it was weighing on my mind as to why you hadn't referred to Bhai Sahib. I am not going to refute what such an azeem Gursikh has written. So, I will reserve my understanding and comments about "jeev-atma" & "Parma-Atma" to myself and will keep on learning more, hopefully.
>>>>They are not only alive but at will they can come to this world or go anywhere they want.>>>
Again, I will not dare to disagree what great Bhai Sahib has written but it's also Gurbani that reminds us that Vaheguru runs everything and it's His hukam ("will") that rules. It's His show. We should look at Gurbani message in totality as well as a pankati or a shabad at a time. Why would Bhagats want to leave the "ultimate state of anand" to go anywhere at "their own will"? I am a bit confused.
“Gurmukh aaye jaaye nisung”
It would be good to see the whole shabad posted.
I don't know why you keep on thinking that being ONE with Vaheguru is somehow decimating and destroying oneself. How is being one with Vaheguru, jyoti jyot sammauna, or going back to your own mool origion (Paramatma) is decimation or destruction of jeev-atma? What really is the difference then if a jeev-atama never becomes part of Vaheguru and stays in a state of "NEVER-ENDING" anand FOREVER and EVER. Does it still keep it's physical roop. i.e. does Baba Deep Singh ji still keep their "physical roop with full gursikhi baana" while being merged in Vaheguru-Jyot? You are saying that nothing really COMPLETELY become Vaheguru's own jyot, and Vaheguru-jyot is separate from jeev-jyots. I think we are all an ansh of Vaheguru (sabhe ghat raam bolle) like a drop of water is to Ocean.
As we say at Gurduara Sahib, jai koi galti ho gai hove ta bacha samaj be maaf karna.
vjkk vjkf
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 11 Mar 2005
--------
You are saying that nothing really COMPLETELY become Vaheguru's own jyot, and Vaheguru-jyot is separate from jeev-jyots.
---------
Veer jeeo, I have never said this. I do believe that Bhagats become ikk-mikk with Vaheguru and stay there in pooran anand but in doing so they still retain their real-self because how else would they have anand? To have anand one has to exist. Simple as that.
As our vadde veer Arshee Gyani jee said, it is hard to understand how one is merged in Vaheguru and still retain distinctness. Yes it is hard to understand but at this stage when we cannot understand how this happens, let us be patient till the time Vaheguru jee will show us how it happens.
---------
Why would Bhagats want to leave the "ultimate state of anand" to go anywhere at "their own will"? I am a bit confused.
---------
It seems like this is the beauty of being in Sach Khand that one never really leave anand of Vaheguru but can still go anywhere. What to talk about Sach Khand, Bhagats who live in this trai-gunn-sampunn Maiya-full world are able to stay merged in Vaheguru, then why won't the bhagats who reside in Sach Khand, where there is no sign of maaiya be able to stay merged in Vaheguru and still be able to come here or go anywhere they want?
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
J Singh · 11 Mar 2005
I guess, only Vaheguru can really reveal this mystery. I am being truthful by saying that I can not comprehend jeev-atma being distinct or separate from Vaheguru and yet being COMPLETELY Vaheguru-jyot. The state of ultimate anand to me means to sammauna in the true origin we came from; but who am I to question what great soul like Bhai Sahib has interpreted.
vjkk vjkf
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Dogma · 11 Mar 2005
"It is easy to just criticise Bhai Sahib's or anyone else's writings but much harder to write your own"
- Kulbir Singh.
"I have read the books written by “Khojee” i.e. Jaswant Singh. I found them very dry."
- Kulbir Singh.
Veerji, just as you have opinions about other people's writings, realize that other people might have their own opinions about Bhai Sahib's writings. I LOVED Bhai Sahib's autobiography. I thought it was an AMAAAAZING book that I learned ALOT from. But I know that my wife found it boring and "dry". Go figure? :)
Also, Avidiya just made a comment regarding some of Bhai Sahib's thoughts on Sach Khand and how HE thought they paralleled some christian ideology. You could have easily just told him that Bhai Sahib was NOT influenced by Christian Ideology in the least. No need to go OFF on him. Plus I suspect that Avidiya pretty much made his post to push your buttons a bit, and I think he succeeded... I think anyone who has read Bhai Sahib's writings KNOWS that his ideas are founded in nothing but Gurmat.
"It is really our great luck that this atheist and naastik faith of Buddhism was cleaned out of India by Shankracharya, and it is great that the growing influence of Shankracharya's Vedant was countered by the Bhagti movement and by Chaitaniya Mahaprabhu's Prema Bhagti movement"
WHOA, what did the Buddhists ever do to you veerji? lol!
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
avidya · 11 Mar 2005
Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji Ki Fateh
Kulbir Singh ji,
No one is accusing anyone of anything, just an observation. No need to get annoyed. As to you accusing me of being influenced by 'atheist and naastik' buddhist ideas, first a correction. Naastik specifically means one who rejects the Veda, which implies you hold the Vedas in high esteem. From your prior posts that seems unlikely, so please use the term correctly.
Secondly, you haven't understood Advaita Vedanta as it does not accept shuniya. That is a completely incorrect statement and I recommend you read a simple introduction to any form of Vedanta to correct that.
Thirdly, another inaccuracy regarding your comment that the medieval bhakti tradition countered it, Advaita Vedanta is still the foremost darsana realistically, so this is again an inaccurate comment and has certainly not been 'countered' as you suggest. The Bhagwad Gita which sets out bhakti yog is itself considered Vedantic in principle.
Fourthly, contrary to your pleas that I haven't answered your question, I have a number of times. Here it is again.
'Now if you reject the idea of a physical worship, and accept that actually Waheguru in it's ultimate form is nirankar and nirgun, then you must also accept that the aatma itself if it is to be the same as waheguru is also not sagun in it's purest form but is in essence nirgun'
I assumed you could take from that Waheguru in it's shudroop is nirgun, since aatma is also nothing other than that, it is also nirgun - without qualities - and hence, considering Paratma's attributes is bliss itself, thus the bhagat is bliss itself in that highest stage, and hence the brahmgyani is nirankar itself (brahmgyani aap nirankar). This would make the description of sachkhand a metaphor emplyed by the Guru for that highest state, otherwise it would imply sagun pooja as the highest state as that of a differentiated aatma, sat in a darbar or court, worshipping the ruler of that court. If Waheguru is nirankar, then the court is nirankar and the bhagat at the highest level is nirankar.
Take for example the following from Bava Akhree bani by Sri Guru Arjun Dev ji;
nirgun thae sargun dhrisattaaran
then
janam maran man mohu badtaaeiou
dhuhoo bhaath thae aap niraaraa
where we see two there is only one;
brahm deesay brahm suniai ek ek vakhaaniai
Aatm pusaaraa karanahaaraa prabh binaa jaaniai
So how can there be anything other than Prabh? How can we maintain some independence? We cannot. The lover and the beloved have become one, and the lover is forever in bliss.
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
hmm · 11 Mar 2005
i think they are still distinct just like gurmukhs who after their shaheedi and naam kamaiee merge with waheguroo but are still able to make it back to this world on their own account
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 11 Mar 2005
------------
Veerji, just as you have opinions about other people's writings, realize that other people might have their own opinions about Bhai Sahib's writings. I LOVED Bhai Sahib's autobiography. I thought it was an AMAAAAZING book that I learned ALOT from. But I know that my wife found it boring and "dry". Go figure? :)
------------
Dear Dogma jee, I don’t dispute what you have written. You are correct in saying that different gursikhs and their writings on other people produce different effects. It is fine if your wife found Bhai Sahib’s book dry and boring. I don’t have any qualms over this but the reason I made my earlier comment about Avidiya was that he had been only criticising but not giving his understanding about the issue. Being critical is fine but we should also offer alternative solution.
-----------
Also, Avidiya just made a comment regarding some of Bhai Sahib's thoughts on Sach Khand and how HE thought they paralleled some christian ideology. You could have easily just told him that Bhai Sahib was NOT influenced by Christian Ideology in the least. No need to go OFF on him.
----------
Sat Bachan jee. I will be more careful in the future.
------------
Plus I suspect that Avidiya pretty much made his post to push your buttons a bit, and I think he succeeded...
------------
Hehe! Perhaps you are right.
--------
WHOA, what did the Buddhists ever do to you veerji? lol!
---------
This is a funny comment and brought muskraahat (smile) on my face. Well, Buddhists never really did anything to me personally. I am apprehensive about them because of their atheist nature. They along with Jainism are the only religions in the world that don’t believe in Vaheguru.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
S Singh · 11 Mar 2005
An interesting debate going on here. Kulbir Singh Jee has proven his beleifs using Gurbani.
Avidya jee can you also quote Gurbani to prove your points becuase it seems like the lack of Gurbani quotes in your posts means your beleifs are not supported by Gurbani. and in my opinion NOTHING is above Gurbani. So please quote some Gurbani to prove your argument against Kulbir Singh(who actually does quote Gurbani).
pula chuka di khima....
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 11 Mar 2005
Avidiya jee,
--------
No one is accusing anyone of anything, just an observation. No need to get annoyed. As to you accusing me of being influenced by 'atheist and naastik' buddhist ideas, first a correction. Naastik specifically means one who rejects the Veda, which implies you hold the Vedas in high esteem. From your prior posts that seems unlikely, so please use the term correctly.
--------
I know that according to the Hindu religious dictionary, the word “Nastik” means one who does not believe in Vedas but if you look at any current dictionary of Punjabi, the word Naastik means an atheist. As an example you can refer to th Punjabi University published “Punjabi English Dictionary” and you will find that the Vedic definition of this word is not even mentioned. You should realise that this word has now become a generic word and as such its meanings have taken on more broader meanings. There are many examples of such words. Pundit, Jihad, Mecca, Brahmin etc have all been adopted by English and the meanings too have become broader than their original meanings. Hopefully you will now realise that when I was referring to the word “Naastik” I did not mean one who does not believe in Vedas.
----------
Thirdly, another inaccuracy regarding your comment that the medieval bhakti tradition countered it, Advaita Vedanta is still the foremost darsana realistically, so this is again an inaccurate comment and has certainly not been 'countered' as you suggest. The Bhagwad Gita which sets out bhakti yog is itself considered Vedantic in principle.
---------
Yes Bhagti yog is a Vedic principle but not a Vedantic principle. Vedant started by Shankracharya was a Shaiv movement whereas the Bhagti movement was a Vaishnav movement. You should read about Chataniya Mahaprabhu’s life where he successfully defeated Shankracharya’s dry philosophy and countered its growth from Central India. Central India and East India because of the Bhagti influence is predominantly Vaishnav.
I made a distinction between Vedic and Vedantic because depending on which school of thought you read about, the Vedic interpretation is different. Both Shaiv and Vaishnav schools claim to be Vedic but they differ greatly.
-------------
I assumed you could take from that Waheguru in it's shudroop is nirgun, since aatma is also nothing other than that, it is also nirgun - without qualities - and hence, considering Paratma's attributes is bliss itself, thus the bhagat is bliss itself in that highest stage, and hence the brahmgyani is nirankar itself (brahmgyani aap nirankar).
-----------
This is purely a Vedantic notion that the aatma realises one day that he is the doer of everything and he himself has created everything. When you say, “Brahmgiyani Sabh Srisht ka Karta” it does not mean that a Brahmgiyani Sikh created everything. We all know that Vaheguru alone has created everything and there are several Gurbani pankitis to prove that Vaheguru created everything.
This notion of “Aham Brahmasiya” of Vedanta is such a Haume-full notion and has no place in Gurmat. Gurmat believes in Bhagtee of Vaheguru and in the notion that Vaheguru is always in control whether it is the first generation or the last generation.
To become ikk-mikk is one thing but to become “him” or to cry out “AnalHaqq” or “Aham Brahmasiya” is a Vedanta notion that has no place in Gurmat. A Sikh does not become God as Vedanta (as I understand it) preaches. Aatma is aatma and Paratma is Paratma. Aatma does become one with Vaheguru and there is no doubt about it but Gurmat does not preach the decimation of aatma in this process. The aatma does retain some identity even though it is one with Parmatma. If it loses identity, please show a Gurbani pankiti that says that it ceases to exist. I have given many pankitis that show the condition of Bhagats in Sach Khand.
----------
So how can there be anything other than Prabh? How can we maintain some independence? We cannot. The lover and the beloved have become one, and the lover is forever in bliss.
----------
In my opinion, this whole paragraph of your is self-contradictory. First of all you say that there is nothing other than Prabh. Then you say that the lover and the beloved have become one. Then you say that the lover is forever in bliss. How can you be in bliss, when you don’t exist?
----------
This would make the description of sachkhand a metaphor emplyed by the Guru for that highest state, otherwise it would imply sagun pooja as the highest state as that of a differentiated aatma, sat in a darbar or court, worshipping the ruler of that court. If Waheguru is nirankar, then the court is nirankar and the bhagat at the highest level is nirankar.
-----------
Nirgun means one that is beyond 5 elements and 3 gunns of maaiya. So Vaheguru and his darbar is that for sure. You call Sach Khand a metaphor. I suggest that you do more Gurbani paath and you will realise that it is not at all a Metaphor but a reality. Sach Khand exists for sure. It is very childish to think that the latter part of Siri Jap jee Sahib that explains the five khands is all metaphoric. Guru Sahib kirpa karan.
Vaheguru is nirgunn, his darbar is nirgun and so are all the bhagats residing in Sach Khand because they are beyond 5 elements and 3 gunns of maaiya.
Mool Mantr defines the Nirgun saroop of Vaheguru but it also calls him a “Moorat”. Verily, he is a moorat i.e. a hastee, a shakseeyat but not of 3 gunns of maaiya and 5 elements. He is a moorat but a Nirgun Moorat that we can comprehend only if we ourselves reach that Nirgun state. But he is there. He can be seen but with eyes that can view the nirgun.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
yo · 12 Mar 2005
bhai sahib gained through immense bhagti.
why do avidia feel bhai sahib be influenced by anyone? Then what is bhagti? is everything literal and taught but not experienced? this goes against sikhi with the touchstone of gurbani. Gurbani teaches sikh to jap naam and everything is obtained, bhai sahib is that example. His experiences speak for themselves what gurbani says. Bhai sahib is not an ordinary person who was ever influenced aby anyone, he was ardent self soul and stood like a rock when everyone else was being swallowed by british and hindus.
If bhai sahib was a british whatever you call it as sanatan websites claimed in past then how comes bhai sahib was in jail fightig against british injustice? giving major portion of his life not only for sikhs, not only for indians, but for fighting against imperialism which was wrong.
Christianity and sikhi are worlds apart. Every religion is worlds apart from sikhi. No religion is the same, no amount of anyones influence determines the outcome, look at what the bible and Gurbani say about ultimate goal, there is your difference.
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
** · 12 Mar 2005
Does samaahi in the tuk below mean to decimate? I wonder if it can be compared to a drop of water that can join into an ocean and leave at will.
Bhai Sahib has provides such an insightful view into some details of Sach Khand. I wonder what they do up there during the day/night if there is some sort of concept of day/night up there?
mehalaa 5 ||
Fifth Mehl:
kabeeraa hamaraa ko nehee ham kis hoo kae naahi ||
Kabeer, no one belongs to me, and I belong to no one else.
jin eihu rachan rachaaeiaa this hee maahi samaahi ||214||
The One who created the creation - into Him I shall be absorbed. ||214||
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulwinder Singh · 12 Mar 2005
Dear Vir Kulbir Singh Ji
You have written,
“It is really our great luck that this atheist and naastik faith of Buddhism was cleaned out of India by Shankracharya, “
How come a Sikh can say the above is beyond my imagination, this “LUCK” you have mentioned was the first documented genocide of mankind in resulting in your “Cleaned” India.
Just because you claim them to be “Naastik”, for you their killing has become a “LUCK” ?
Your above comment are very disturbing, and indeed they are worst then Rajiv Gandhi’s Comments after 1984’s Massacre of Sikhs around India after Indria Gandhi’s death.
Vir Ji you need to look into your heart see if you can see how much wrong you have been if you hold this opinion form what ever length you had these opinions.
Wheatear somebody is atheist or not, Sikh or not, or even Anti Sikh over Guru Ji never ever will endorse the above opinion, He will indeed be against those who chose to resort to violence and operation to achieve what ever they want to achieve.
Our Guru Teg Bahadur ji gave his life to protect the human rights of those who have beliefs contrary to his own, How would you think your comments will be taken by Guru Teg Bahadur Ji ?
I very strongly condemn your comments, as they are insulting to the humanity.
Kulwinder Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Van Singh · 12 Mar 2005
Kulwinder Singh wrote:
"this “LUCK” you have mentioned was the first documented genocide of mankind in resulting in your “Cleaned” India."
What 'documents' if any are you refering to? just curious...
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
kulwinder Singh · 12 Mar 2005
No genocide documentation is going to be found like a library catalog of events, what I refereed to as documented was in sense that It is written in the history that it happened, even Indian history books have references to this, when this "clearance” begin and Buddhism virtually disappeared from India in short period and survived Buddhist people settled in Sri Lanka and in the South and Some went to The North to Himalayas and China and some went to East of India.
If you want some better detailed references then you need to read the History of these places, written by Buddhist Monks.
I hope that answer you question.
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
info · 12 Mar 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
“It is really our great luck that this atheist and naastik faith of Buddhism was cleaned out of India by Shankracharya, “
I agree with Veer Kulwinder Singh's views on the above mentioned statement by Kulbir Singh. I think Bhai Sahib Kulbir Singh needs to rethink about his statement. I have for the very first time heard this statement from a gursikh.
No matter what budhist did or what they believe in, their killings were nothing but GENOCIDE. Today most of our documented human rights bodies reports, sikh history books use the same genocide to compare it with the genocide of sikhs being currently carried about the followers of the same Shankaracharya.
Veer Kulbir Singh Ji tomorrow a muslim may write:
“It is really our great luck that this atheist and kafir faith of Sikhism was cleaned out of India by Hindus (followers of Shankracharya)"
How will this statement feel. No body and noone has any right to kill other just because the other person's beliefs are different then our own.
I hope you will try to rethink about what you have written. A true gursikh should never feel happy at killing of other innocent people. Millions of budhist were killed those included innocent bibis and kids as well. Just because there religion's philosophy is not of our taste doesn't means that shankarcharya gets the right to kill them.
Dass,
Sarbjit Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 12 Mar 2005
-------
Bhai Sahib has provides such an insightful view into some details of Sach Khand. I wonder what they do up there during the day/night if there is some sort of concept of day/night up there?
--------
Veer jeeo / Bhain jeeo, according to Bhai Sahib's books, there is no concept of day and night there and there is no Pataal or Akaash there either.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 12 Mar 2005
Veer Kulwinder Singh jeeo,
You have misunderstood my post and have really over-reacted to my comments. I was not condoning any genocide or massacre as you have understood. Shankracharya, whom I credited for cleaning India of naastiks like Jains and Buddhists did not commit any massacre or genocide in his life time.
Shankracharya was a very gifted person and a born genius who lived only till the age of 34. While he was still under age 10 he had mastered all the Vedic knowledge available at that time, including memorising all 4 Vedas, mastering Upanishads and Simratees etc. When he was till in his teen years, he set out to eradicate the naastik or atheist philosophy from India.
Since Ashoka, India had pretty much become a Buddhist country though there was a very strong presence of another atheist religion – Jainism. Then Kanishka, though he belonged to different sect of Buddhism as compared to Ashoka, greatly helped in establishing the Buddhist Faith. Then the great king of India Harsh Vardhan too became a Buddhist in his later years. By getting political support Buddhist faith spread far and wide outside of India too. Hyung Sung same to India when India was the capital of Buddhist Faith and has written very interesting accounts of Indians of that time, especially about the kingdom of Harsh Vardhan. This way most kings subscribed to one of these two atheist religions.
Shankracharya set out and reached one of the most powerful kingdoms of that time and challenged the Buddhist scholars to have a debate on atheism. Shankracharya who was still a teenager at that time had only couple of followers and against him were the topmost scholars of Buddhist and Jain religions who numbered in hundreds. The condition that Shankracharya and the opposing scholars agreed upon was that the losing side would accept the faith of the winning side and the king too would follow suit.
The topic of the debate was the existence of Vaheguru. After this agreement one of the greatest debates of mankind commenced and it lasted several days or even weeks. The genius Aastik scholar – Shankracharya – single-handedly defeated all scholars and established the truth of Vaheguru’s existence. Ethics were still high at that time and many defeated scholars accepted Shankracharya as their leader and accepted his faith. The king too accepted his faith. This way, Shankracharya went from kingdom to kingdom and eradicated the atheist faiths of Buddhism and Jainism.
In his short life of 34 years he successfully started the downfall of Buddhism from India. I have never heard that Shankracharya himself was involved in any genocide or that genocide even took place while he was alive. This is the futile Dalit propaganda that accuses and slanders the pious Shankracharya for something he did not do.
I have heard that some staunch Buddhist kingdoms and Agni-Vanshee Kshatriya kingdoms had wars in which many innocent people were killed the Agnee-Vanshee Kshatriyas defeated Buddhists. It is quite possible that they may have killed many innocent Buddhists and I don’t condone such killings.
Shankracharya started or reintroduced the Vedant philosophy that is not fully in agreement with Gurmat Dharam but nevertheless one thing most faiths have in common is that they all believe in the existence of the super power Vaheguru.
The Vedant philosophy is very good when compared to the atheist philosophy of Buddhism but is very dry very compared to Prema-Bhagee philosophy of Bhagti lehar in general and Chataniya Mahaprabhu in particular. Chataniya who lived many hundred years after the original Shankracharya defeated the Shankracharyas (descendents of original Shankracharya) in Puri in a great debate that took place there.
While Prema Bhagtee and some Sufi movements were good and sweet but not as sweet and superior as Gurmat. Gurmat offers such great inducements as compared to its nearest competitors that it is not wise to even think of comparing it to any other faith. Gurmat is Parmo-Dharma.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 12 Mar 2005
---------
I hope you will try to rethink about what you have written. A true gursikh should never feel happy at killing of other innocent people. Millions of budhist were killed those included innocent bibis and kids as well. Just because there religion's philosophy is not of our taste doesn't means that shankarcharya gets the right to kill them.
---------
While I don't possess the attributes of a true gursikh but nevertheless, I don't condone killings of innocent people and I hope my previous post on this subject will dispel misunderstandings about my earlier statement. I had not anywhere mentioned that killings of Buddhists was right. It was not even in my mind when I wrote the original comment. Our dear friend Bhai Kulwinder Singh got upset at this poor daas in haste.
Veer Kulwinder Singh jee ne, "raayee da pahaaR banaa ditaa".
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
.......... · 13 Mar 2005
what is history is gone we will not know what happened then because people who write history officially are biased like 84 onwards the official version that millions read is that sikhs were "terrorists".
I think its shaky ground to be on one side or the other because we just do not know what the condition was.
I always respected buddhism far beyond hinduism due its simple approach to life, no caste, no desires, with some spiritual inclincation and treating people nicely. Now when i look at hinduism, why are hindus mostly athiest? worshipping material elements? caste, rituals? one may believe in the existance of God the other may not but hinduism seems to have caused greater harm to the world than buddhism did.
I think it would be easier to live in a practicing buddhist country for a sikh than to live in in moghul country where they acknowledge the existance of god but eat meat, chop parts of your body off, take your wives away, stop you from worshipping in public, harrass you because you do not worship the same book as theirs, all in the name of God. At least a buddhist is prescribed to leave you be.
I have heard some brahmin claims they were harrassed by buddhists but obviously thats what they say about sikhs now hence the justification for gulakara.
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 13 Mar 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
IMHO Veer Kulwinder Singh Ji and others have indeed jumped the gun...and fired from the hip....now the shoe is on the other foot.
Shankarchaya set some conditions for debate and won...imho Guru Nnak Ji also "defeated" the Great Sidhs and Yogis of His time..But with one big difference..Guru nanak Ji's Path was PREMA BHAGTEE and has no Pre-conditions..that the defeated MUST accept. Wherever GURU NANAK JI went, He DEFEATED and DEMOLISHED the opposing views with PREM...and went on his way...at hardwaar, at jagan nath Puri, at Mecca..Guru ji's Way was shown to be the Correct Way.
The Offical GENOCIDE of Sikhs going on since 1947....and the comments of demons like Indira and Rajiv..are a different kettle of fish alltogether. These have nothing whatsoever to do with the "merits" of their religion..but politicla expediaency to control India at all costs and destroy anyone - Sikh or Dalit, Muslim or Christian, Kashmiri or nagas.....who stands in the way of this domination.
Buddhism thrives in those countries which earlier also had ATHEIST Leanings...confusionism, taoism, shintoism etc are all atheist religions and have intermingled with Buddhism so much that they are all the same today more or less..thus it had to go from India which had theistic leanings from early on. China has Never had a THEISTIC Base...in its civilisation whcih is as old as India if not older.
Jarnail Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
avidya · 13 Mar 2005
Waheguru ji Ka Khalsa WaheGuruji Ki Fateh
Kulbir Singh ji,
Thank you for your reply. The comment about Bhai Sahib was only a thought as I was reading the post, it was not meant as a provocation and I was suprised by the reaction.
If you knew the actual meaning of 'naastik', not the supposed everyday usage, I doubt you would have used it. This issue also arises using modern parlance punjabi/hindi for defining certain terms in gurbani, and I'm sure you would have criticised such a translation.
Your reply still shows some grave inaccuracies - that Sankarcharya was a shaivite and created vedant, whereas others were Vaishnav and were not vedantists is simply wrong. Vedant is SIMPLY referring to the Upanishads (end of the vedas). You have confused the term with Advait Vedanta. There is even a dualist form of vedanta as it is simply an attempt to explain the underlying philsophy of the upanishads.
Again the comments about Vaishnavs were completely incorrect. In terms of Vedant, there are four main schools. Sankarachrya is one and the dasnami samprda is shaivite. The other three; Ramanuj - creator of Vasistadvaita and Vallabhacharya - creator of Shudhadvait and Madhavacharya - creator of Dvaita vedanta were all strict vaishnavs responding to Advait Vedanta from a Vaishav perspective to uphold vaishnav bhakti marg. It is also worth noting that Ramanand, the vidya guru of Kabir, descends from Ramanuj.
Contrary to your earlier claims, shuniya is a buddhist philsophy not vedantic - nothing can come out of void to Adi Sankaracharya's mind.
No, your 'self-contradiction haume-vad' criticism of my understanding of 'Brahmgyani aap nirankar' testifies your lack of understanding of this issue. I shall use a simple analogy here to explain it;
If I pull out a tooth, that tooth is nothing but me...but does it amount to what I am? I hope not!
Likewise when the Guru states the above he is showing that the aatma is now part of Waheguru and ONLY waheguru remains NOT 'I am God'! That is completely the other way around! While ego is there then that aatma can only be still believing it is something other than waheguru. If you read through Gurbani, it is impossible to reach such a stage with haumai!
S Singh, quotes for you from the first few pauris of Sri Akaal Ustat by Guru Gobind Singh ji;
'Advai Alakh Purakh Abgiaamii
Sabh ghat ghat ke antarjaamii'
and further on;
'Bidiaa ke Bichaar ho ki Aduai avtaar ho ki
suptaa ki soorati ho ki supta ki saan ho'
So the word 'aduai' or 'advai' (non-duality/monism) is used repeatedly (it also arises in Gyanbodh as well if I remember correctly) in Guru Gobind Singh ji's bani to describe the attributes of Waheguru.
Even the elementary text 'Philosophy of Sikhism' by Gyani Dr. Sher Singh published by the SGPC, after having drawn comparisons with other philsophies states categorically that in essence Sikhi holds the same understanding of the final state as Vedanta, the distinctive differences lie elsewhere such as the means to that goal and the nature of maya. He even goes as far as seeing the closeness of Vallabhacharya's pushtimarg and comments that they may have even met and discussed.
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
singhnee · 13 Mar 2005
Waheguru jee kaa khalsa, Waheguru jee kee fateh!
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
This sounds very much like a Christian idea of heaven. I have never heard such a katha from gurmukh scholars before. Did Bhai Sahib recieve any training under Christian scholars? I've not read his autobiography but where did Bhai Sahib receive his schooling? Is it possible that he was inspired by Christian thinking which no doubt changed his ideas on sachkhand?
<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<
Mr. avidya jee, It depends on your choice of kathaakaars you have listent to. Sachkhand is not a fairy tale which could be discussed by having worldly vidyaa/degrees by most of our kathaakaars at Guruduaaras to make money. Only one who has experienced it can discuss this topic. Only one who has visited Sachkhand could tell what's going on in there not just any scholar kathaakaars. I doubt your sikhi knowledge after reading your above misleading post. Christians' heaven and our Sakhkhand- how can you compare those two? Did you get education from christian school? Please read Bhai Sahib's books to get more knowledge about sikhi and Waheguru darshans.
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
ms · 13 Mar 2005
if you really read bhai sahibs books he never hsa ever said anything without gurbani following it and i think you should read everyone of his books before you make any subjections on his life and unditthi duniya is one of the best books i've ever read
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
anon · 13 Mar 2005
vjkk vjkf
"there is no concept of day and night there and there is no Pataal or Akaash there either."
what is pataal and akaash, Mr Kulbir Singh
vjkk vjkf
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 13 Mar 2005
Avidya,
I did not understand your response to the following question I raised to you:
----------------------------------------
----------
So how can there be anything other than Prabh? How can we maintain some independence? We cannot. The lover and the beloved have become one, and the lover is forever in bliss.
----------
In my opinion, this whole paragraph of your is self-contradictory. First of all you say that there is nothing other than Prabh. Then you say that the lover and the beloved have become one. Then you say that the lover is forever in bliss. How can you be in bliss, when you don’t exist?
-----------------------------
Please let me know how the lover can be in bliss when he does not exist?
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 13 Mar 2005
-------
what is pataal and akaash, Mr Kulbir Singh
---------
I think what Bhai Sahib meant was that in Sach Khand, there is no sky and land or anything below the land as in the worldly sense.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulwinder Singh · 13 Mar 2005
Kulbir Singh Ji,
I do not know whether Shankracharya was personally responsible or not, One person’s name is not that important as in the case of 1984 of Sikh Massacre, should we be happy to say that Rajiv Gandhi was not personally going around killing Sikhs, as mater of fact there is no witness to suggest that, Indeed Rajiv Gandhi’s order brought the Army in the streets which stopped the Killings does that make difference to you ?
Majority of accused congers people are accused of inciting Killing rather then doing themselves ? Many of them have long Political careered and I am sure some of them were very knowledgeable, Does that make it any difference to you ?
I am bothered about the your “Cleaned” India and with “LUCK” Words.
Vir Je read below what your “clean” India mean through the eyes of the History.
================Below is copy from the internet Please read ===========
The Sunga dynasty (185–73 BCE) was established in 185 BCE, about 50 years after Ashoka's death. After murdering King Brhadrata (last of the Mauryan rulers), military commander-in-chief Pusyamitra Sunga took the throne. An orthodox Brahmin, Sunga is known for his hostility and persecution towards the Buddhist faith. He is recorded as having "destroyed monasteries and killed Monks" (Divyavadana, pp. 429–434): 84,000 Buddhist stupas which had been built by Ashoka were destroyed (R. Thaper), and 100 gold coins were offered for the head of each Buddhist monk (Indian Historical Quarterly Vol. XXII, p. 81 ff cited in Hars.407). A large number of Buddhist monasteries (viharas) were converted to Hindu temples, in such places as Nalanda, Bodhgaya, Sarnath, or Mathura.
See also: Sunga empire
Above text is from site: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Buddhism
Do you see any similarities between the treatment of Bhudists and Sikhs, that is why my heart just cried when I read your “Cleaned” and “Luck” bit of the statement.
================Below is copy from the internet Please read ===========
The massacres and oppression perpetrated by Brahmanist zealots out of religious
hatred for Buddhists in ancient times are a matter of the historical record.
Yet, for reasons best known to themselves, Brahmanists have been trying to
conceal the hideous, blood-stained record of Hinduism.
The truth must be told.
As the revival of Brahmanical Hinduism progressed, atrocities against Buddhists
increased both in strength and in number. As Goyal [394] notes, "According to
many scholars hostility of the Brahmanas was one of the major causes of the
decline of Buddhism in India." The hatred poured out against Buddhists in Hindu
scriptures offers ample evidence of this. To quote Goyal again [394-5]:
"Yajnavalkya (I. 271-72) declares that the very sight of a Buddhist monk, even
in dreams, is inauspicious. The Brhannaradiya-purana lays it down as a
principal sin for a Brahmana to enter the house of a Buddhist even in times of
great peril. The drama Mrchchhakatika shows that in Ujjain the Buddhist monks
were despised and their sight was considered inauspicious. The Vishnupurana
(XVIII 13-18) also regards the Buddha as Mayamoha who appeared in the world to
delude the demons. Kumarila is said to have instigated King Sudhanvan of Ujjain
to exterminate the Buddhists. ... The Kerala- utpatti describes how he
exterminated the Buddhists from Kerala."
Earlier Post 7th Century Assualts on Buddhism
The Chinese traveller Yuan Chwang (Huen Tsang), who visited India in the
seventh century records the oppressions of Shashanka, the king of Gauda, who
was a devotee of Shiva. Yuan Chwang's account reads, "In recent times
Shashanka, the enemy and oppressor of Buddhism, cut down the Bodhi tree,
destroyed its roots down to the water and burned what remained." [Watters II
p.115] He also says that Shashanka tried "to have the image (of Lord Buddha at
Bodhgaya) removed and replaced by one of Shiva". Another independent account of
Shashanka's oppressions is found in the Aryamanjushrimulakalpa, which refers to
Shashanka destroying "the beautiful image of Buddha" [Jayaswal, 49-50].
Another prominent seventh century murderer of Buddhists was Sudhanvan of
Ujjain, already mentioned in the quotation from Goyal above as having been
supposedly instigated by Kumarila Bhatt. Madhava Acharya, in his
"Sankara-digvijayam" of the fourteenth century A.D., records that Suddhanvan
"issued orders to put to death all the Buddhists from Ramesvaram to the
Himalayas".
Nalanda Destroyed by Hindu Zealots
Even after the Islamic invasions of India, Brahmanist bigotry and hatred for
Buddhists was not subdued. According to Sharmasvamin, a Tibetan pilgrim who
visited Bihar three decaes after the invasion of Bakhtiaruddin Khilji in the
12th century, the biggest library at Nalanda was destroyed by Hindu mendicants
who took advantage of the chaos produced by the invasion.
He says that "they (Hindus) performed a Yajna, a fire sacrifice, and threw
living embers and ashes from the sacrifice into the Buddhist temples. This
produced a great conflagration which consumed Ratnabodhi, the nine-storeyed
library of the Nalanda University". [Prakash, 213].
Numerous destroyed Buddhist shrines were converted into Hindu temples after
their destruction. Ahir [58] notes that "The Seat of Buddha's Enlightenment was
in the possession of a Hindu Mahant till 1952. Huen Tsang, tells us that in the
seventh century A.D. not only was the Bodhi Tree at Gaya cut down by the
Shaivite Shashanka, but that that worthy tried to install an image of Shiva in
place of that of the Tathagata. One easy conclusion: there was not at that time
an idol of Shiva at the spot; now, there is a shivalingam in the temple. The
Indian Supreme court has not given its verdict in the case after 50 years!
Similarly, at Kushinara, where the Buddha had entered into Mahaparinirvana, the
cremation stupa had been converted into a Hindu temple, and on top of it stood
the temple of Rambhar Bhavani when Cunningham discovered the site in 1860-61.
Among the shrines which still continue to be dedicated to Hindu gods mention
may be made of the Caityas of Chezrala and Ter in Andhra Pradesh which are now
Shiva and Vishnu temples respectively. The temple of Madhava at Sal Kusa,
opposite Gauhati in Asam, was once a sacred shrine of the Buddhists. ... And
the famous Jagannatha temple at Puri in Orissa was also originally a Buddhist
shrine. Similarly, the Vishnupada temple at Gaya was also once a Buddhist
shrine." As Rajendralal Mitra notes in his famous work of 1878 [quoted in Ahir,
59] the feet of Buddha at Gaya were rechristened the feet of Vishnu and held as
the most sacred object of worship in the new Vishnupada temple.
Hinduism's record of violence and bigotry against the peaceful followers of
Lord Buddha is unparalleled. I trust this marshalling of the available evidence
for the benefit of readers who may not have had access to it will impel
Brahmanists to accept and apologise for the crimes committed in the name of
Hinduism.
Bibliography.
Ahir, D.C. "Buddha Gaya Through the Ages", Bibliotheca Indo-Buddhica Series No.
134, Delhi 1994.
Goyal, S.R., "A History of Indian Buddhism", Meerut 1987. Jayaswal, "An
imperial history of India", Lahore 1934.
Joshi, L.M. "Studies in the Buddhistic Culture of India", New Delhi 1967.
Marshall, John, "Taxila" Cambridge University Press 1951.
Prakash, Buddh, "Aspects of Indian History and Civilisation", Agra 1965.
Taranatha, "History of Buddhism in India", Indian Institute of Advanced
Studies, Simla, 1977.
Vaidya, P.L. ed. "Divyavadana", Darbhanga 1959.
Watters, T. "On Yuan Chwang's Travels in India," ed. by T. W. Rhys Davids and
S.W. Bushel, London 1904, 1905.
More on the Brahmanist genocide of Buddhism in India:
The above Information is from the site:
http://www.geocities.com/pak_history/buddhists.html
=====================================================
You also Saying “The Vedant philosophy is very good when compared to the atheist philosophy of Buddhism”
Yes Discrimination on the bases of caste is much better
Then the fine simple living message for all ?
Who do you think Guru Gobind Singh Ji would side with , He said do not even think of going near the Brahmin philosophy.
I am looking forward to your reply.
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 13 Mar 2005
Kulwinder Singh jeeo,
You are blowing this out of proportion. My earlier post had mentioned only Shankracharya and my comments were limited to him only.
For the matter of this debate, we have no need to worry about the battles of Hindus and Buddhists. My views on Hinduism are very well known and you know how I believe in the supremacy of Gurmat Dharam i.e. Khalsa Dharam. We have had debates on the topic of the supremacy of “Teesar Mazhab Khalsa, Upjaiya Pardhana”.
Regarding going the Brahmin way, why are you telling me about it? I don’t support going their way. You were the one who were having hard time swallowing this truth that only Gurmat Dharam reaches the top zeniths of spirituality.
On killings of Buddhists or anyone for that matter, I am against it and condemn it. And I repeat that according to my knowledge, Shankracharya was not involved in any kind of violence against anyone. If you have any proof of it, please present it here and I would accept it if it is authentic.
My comments were relevant to only Shankracharya and not to Rajput kings who fought Buddhists after and before Shankracharya. And about Shankracharya too, I was only praising his efforts to counter the naastik or atheist growth in India. I don’t fully support his philosophy and think that his philosophy in many ways is not in accordance with Gurmat. Hence, we cannot support it one hundred percent.
And please don't make a mountain out of a mole.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
.......... · 13 Mar 2005
u gotto see kulwinder singh ji bhai kulbir singh is a good panth wala singh he would never mean anything bad. Sometimes we say things they can be taken the wrong way or even the words come out wrong, but i have full faith that bhai kulbir singh never meant anything as bad as it appeared to you. He has always stood up for the panth clearly in the past and is respected member .
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
avidya · 14 Mar 2005
Gurfateh ji,
To your repeated question;
Because the maya has gone and the lover is nothing but the beloved. And the beloved is bliss, the beloved is now only bliss also. Again you don't seem to get it so here's an another analogy;
The drop remains ever potentially an ocean which has the quality of great depth. Until the drop merges in the ocean it can never truely experience depth. Once it has merged, the drop no longer exists INDEPENDENTLY as such, there is only ocean. Before the drop pines for the depth of the ocean, now it has depth, it has become ocean again.
Hence once the lover and the beloved meet, the lover no longer independently exists, as there is only the beloved which is bliss.
NOW please answer my questions;
1. This darbar you describe, just what is it made of and where is it?
2. What exactly is within the darbar, and what is being worshipped?
3. How is the worship being performed - in other words, with what (with the mind for example)?
Please explain. Prior you've said you're not sure, but please try to think independently and argue for the statement.
Thank you
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Singh · 14 Mar 2005
Bhai Kulbir Singh,
When I read your assertion that complete union does not happen even in Sach Khand, I thought to myself, "Kulbir Singh is wrong on this one!" Having read all the posts on this topic, I am now convinced that your understanding on this matter is correct. The Gurbani Tukka used went furthest to convince me.
I write this to say thanks for the post and your efforts to respond to the debaters - I have gained much and I'm sure others have too. Thanks to the debaters for your opinions too, as this process aids the understanding.
I also wanted to clarify one thing. I agree now that in Sach Khand, the Jeev Aatma is still "physically" independent from Vaheguru because as the Tuk from Japji Sahib explains, the creation has been created and God now watches the play unfold. However, one the creation is all destroyed, it all goes back into Vaheguru and it is at that point that the Bhagats merge back into God.
Do you agree?
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
J Singh · 14 Mar 2005
Kulbir Singh ji, I am surprised that you don't see any difference between Buddhism and Atheism? You do know that Buddhism atleast believes in compassion, equality, reincarnation, state of Nirvana (enlightenment) through samadhi. I agree that it doesn't come anywhere near our beloved Sikhi belief of jeev-atma becoming ONE with Parmatma through naam-jaap (becomes Parmatma and staying forever in bliss as it merges back to the ONE jyot it came from :-). Not being "physically" independent from Vaheguru as nothing is "independent" of Akaal-Purkh). Singh, I don't fully agree with your interpretation of Japji Sahib. Only Vaheguru is "Sach" and He is everywhere. Everything else is jhooth (koord, naashvaan).
I had checked out of the discussion but thought I ask this question.
vjkk vjkf
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 14 Mar 2005
Avidya,
1) First you said this:
“So how can there be anything other than Prabh? How can we maintain some independence? We cannot. The lover and the beloved have become one, and the lover is forever in bliss.”
Then you wrote this:
“Hence once the lover and the beloved meet, the lover no longer independently exists, as there is only the beloved which is bliss.”
First you write that the lover is in bliss but now you have written that the beloved one is in bliss. Could you please make up your mind as to who really is in bliss? Is it the lover who is in bliss or the beloved one?
2) Another important point is that according to Gurbani, even while living in this physical world, Bhagats become one with Vaheguru and also stay in total bliss. Many Mahapurakhs of this avastha have lived in Sikhi from time to time. If they are able to be merged in Vaheguru and still be conscious of themselves while in this world, why can’t they be the same in the next world?
If they don’t get destroyed while in this world, why would they get destroyed in the next world. Is this how Vaheguru rewards them i.e. by sucking them in his being and destroying them?
3) The implications of believing that after this physical life, Bhagats and Gurus get merged in Vaheguru and lose their independent standing are very extreme for us. We all do ardaas before 10 Guru Sahibaan despite knowing that they have left their physical bodies long time agoIf our Ten Guru Sahibaan have merged in Vaheguru and lost their separate identities, then who are we doing ardaas before? Are we to say that it is then wrong to do ardaas before out Ten Guru Sahibaan who have merged in Vaheguru? I don't think this can be the case. Guru Sahib are merged with Vaheguru but still can listen to our ardaas and answer it.
Now to answer questions asked by Avidya jee:
---------
1. This darbar you describe, just what is it made of and where is it?
------------
Gurbani does not mention what Sach Khand is made up of. About describing Sach Khand Gurbani says that it is like chewing iron i.e. it is impossible to describe it. Let us do bhagti and reach that level to see what Sach Khand is made up of. In one of his books Bhai Sahib lovingly challenges the reader of his book to do Naam dee Kamaayee and verify for himself what has been written by him.
-------------
2. What exactly is within the darbar, and what is being worshipped?
-------------
As I mentioned before, Sach Khand is beyond the 5 elements of this world and also beyond the three gunns of maaiya. To the best of my knowledge that has been derived from Gurbani and Bhai Sahib’s books, Vaheguru is the one being worshipped by Bhagats there. The form of bhagtee is Sifat-salaah.
There is Vaheguru in Sach Khand, there is his Mahal as per my original post in this thread and there are Bhagats. Please refer to the original post in this thread for details on his darbar.
-----------
3. How is the worship being performed - in other words, with what (with the mind for example)?
-----------
Mann’s real form is Jyot Saroop as per Gurbani pankiti “Mann tu jyot saroop hain, apna mool pachhaan”.
Again Bhagtee or worship is done with the same things (mann or whatever you want to call it) as it is done by a Brahmgiyani in this world.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
J Singh · 14 Mar 2005
>>> Vaheguru is the one being worshipped by Bhagats there>>>
Going by your interpretation: Vaheguru has His own mahal in Sachkhand. Bhagats (jeev-jyots) pachhaan their mool and get merged into His-Jyot saroop; but yet they are doing Bhagati of Vaheguru in this mahal! What for? Isn't the whole point of doing bhagati to attain SachKhand, to be one with pritam pyaara Vaheguru? What are they doing bhagati for when they are already there (I am assuming you mean without their human "blood and flesh" form), merged in Vaheguru? Is being in forever bliss or anand to do bhagati of Vaheguru while being merged into His jyot? Gurbani doesn't say that. You have already said that bhagats have their own free "will"!
>>>>Again Bhagtee or worship is done with the same things (mann or whatever you want to call it) as it is done by a Brahmgiyani in this world.>>>>
So the jeev-atma still carries it's "mann or whatever we choose to call it" after it's 84 gets cut and it achieves SachKhand, a state of permanent bliss.
vjkk vjkf
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 14 Mar 2005
J. Singh
--------------
Going by your interpretation: Vaheguru has His own mahal in Sachkhand. Bhagats (jeev-jyots) pachhaan their mool and get merged into His-Jyot saroop; but yet they are doing Bhagati of Vaheguru in this mahal! What for? Isn't the whole point of doing bhagati to attain SachKhand, to be one with pritam pyaara Vaheguru? What are they doing bhagati for when they are already there (I am assuming you mean without their human "blood and flesh" form), merged in Vaheguru? Is being in forever bliss or anand to do bhagati of Vaheguru while being merged into His jyot? Gurbani doesn't say that. You have already said that bhagats have their own free "will"!
-------------
As far as I know from Gurbani and books of gurmukhs, bhagats cannot live without the jeevan-kanee of Naam. I think bhagti automatically happens when a bhagat reaches the top stage whether it is this world or the next world. Bhagats are the embodiment of Bhagtee.
--------------
>>>>Again Bhagtee or worship is done with the same things (mann or whatever you want to call it) as it is done by a Brahmgiyani in this world.>>>>
So the jeev-atma still carries it's "mann or whatever we choose to call it" after it's 84 gets cut and it achieves SachKhand, a state of permanent bliss.
-----------------
I have written before too that the spiritual state of a bhagat or any person does not change after the jeev-aatma leaves this human body. Whatever means it was employing to do bhagtee before continue to happen in the next world. I don’t think sifat-salaah of Vaheguru can ever stop, no matter how big the spiritual state is.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 14 Mar 2005
-------------------------------------
Is being in forever bliss or anand to do bhagati of Vaheguru while being merged into His jyot? Gurbani doesn't say that.
---------------------------------------
J Singh veerjee:
The human beings through which Gurbani came into this world were already Sach Khand vaasees.
Their spirituality was already absorbed in awareness of sach khand.
They only came to this earth for the purpose of preaching the infinite truth.
They did not need to come here for their own purposes, it was hukam.
So whatever they wrote in their Gurbani is very important and relevent.
God themself made this bani come out from the mouth of the human bodies that these divine souls were in at that time.
So let's read what these "already in Sach Khand" souls wrote about doing bhagti while they were already merged in the jyot.
naanak bhagathaa sadhaa vigaas ||
Guru Nanak dev ji says that the Bhagats are "sadaa vigaas" - Sadaa is a long time. It's not a day, or a week, or a year. It's sadaa. Forever. Always. From the beginning of this creation to the end of this creation.
So how are they "vigaas" for all this time? How are they in bliss?
thaeree bhagath thaeree bhagath bha(n)ddaar jee bharae bia(n)th baea(n)thaa ||
thaerae bhagath thaerae bhagath salaahan thudhh jee har anik anaek ana(n)thaa ||
Guru ji says that your "bhagat" is a "bhandaar" that is "bhariyaa hoyaa" and is "biant beanthaa"
What is "beanth" ? Anth means end, Beanth means endless.
Endless is a long large amount! Bhagti is not temporary, or for a few jugs, it is not limited to some number of jaaps or paath or pooja, the amount of bhagti that can be done - is beanth.
So the bhagats do bhagtee - which is endless, and are "sadaa vigaas"
But how does this prove that their being "sadaa vigaas" is caused by the "beanth" "bhandaar" of "thayree bhagath" ?
bhagathaa man aana(n)dh hai sachai sabadh ra(n)g raathae ||
Guru ji clearly says that Bhagats have Anand in their Mind because they are "rang raathae" or "steeped in the colours" of the "sachai sabadh" or the true divine word.
So the true divine word allows bhagats to do bhagtee, which is beanth, and thus they are "sadaa vigaas"
But who says that they are still doing bhagtee after death, or do they really die?
naa ouhi marehi n t(h)aagae jaahi ||
jin kai raam vasai man maahi ||
thithhai bhagath vasehi kae loa ||
karehi ana(n)dh sachaa man soe ||
Those who have God's name in their mind never die or get robbed of their wealth - which is the beanth bhandaar of bhagti. The bhagats of countless worlds live in the divine realms of God's truth - and with God in their minds, they feel anand and are sadaa vigaas.
But STILL - who says they want to be there? Who says that is their ultimate goal? Who says that is the ultimate goal of our life?
raaj n chaaho mukath n chaaho man preeth charan kamalaarae ||
breham mehaes sidhh mun ei(n)dhraa mohi t(h)aakur hee dharasaarae ||1||
The bhagat does not want kingdoms, heavenly abodes, or even muktee and liberation from birth and death.
The bhagat wants to be in love with the feet of the Guru.
And to always be under the protection of the Guru.
Not the head of the guru, not the hands, the feet.
This gives you an idea of the "mindset" of a bhagat. They are not looking for a "khulee chhutee" or "freedom" from God's hukam.
hukmai andar sabh ko - Bhagats know this and they love it. They love hukam and instead what they want is to become hukmee banday. To live according to their Sahib's will. Not to be free from it - but to live by it.
The bhagat - somebody like Baba Budda Ji - is so humble that even after so much bhagti - he still just wants to be in love with the feet of the Guru.
Such a bhagat could have the wealth of a million planets and all the worldly pleasures - but the bhagat does not want this.
Even for a brahmgyani The feet of the Guru is the highest they want to look directly. Anything above that is like staring directly into a million suns. The bhagat feels that he would go blind.
Their is a folk tale that when Guru gobind SIngh ji looked into the eyes of Mado Das Bairagi (soon to become Baba Banda Singh Bahadur), that Mado Das fainted right there on the spot.
If the Guru looks at you - whatever the Guru is thinking will vibrate in your every cell. It is so strong for a normal worldly person like us.
The bhagat is a sacrifice to his Guru - he would do bhagti of his Guru for billions of years, if that is what pleased his Guru.
He feels that all of the great souls of Brahma, Vishnu, Shiva, Sidhas, Munis, Indras, or other demigods or fairy gods are of no importance and they are not his goal. He could reach so many stages but he is not pleased with anybody else. He is pleased with the vision of his Thaakur, the ultimate God.
The vision and the love of his thaakur's feet is what gives him peace, bliss, anand, for all time.
Afterall, what is everlasting bliss for a saint?
sukhaa kee mith kiaa ganee jaa simaree govi(n)dh ||
Guru ji says how can the happiness of Govind simaran be measured?
Simran on Guru ji, or "bhagti" from the beanth bhandaar of truth, is the only thing that keeps bhagats in sadaa anand, whether on this earth or in sach khand.
saadhh sa(n)gath sach kha(n)dd hai bhaao bhagath abhaasee||
Bhai Gurdas ji says that Saadh SAngat is sach khand, where Bhaao Bhagat Abhyaas is done - practicing of loving devotion.
So if "that" sach khand and "this" sach khand are the same - that what happens in "this" sach khand (saadh sangat) and what happens in "that" sach khand (darbaar of Vaaheguroo) must be the same - i.e. bhaao bhagat abhyaas.
please forgive my mistakes
vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa
vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Singh · 14 Mar 2005
Amazing Post "Kar Kirpa".
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
J Singh · 15 Mar 2005
"kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa" ji,
I agree with some of your points above but none of the pankati you have quoted state that being in forever bliss or anand is to do bhagati of Vaheguru while being merged into His jyot in SachKhand. I have had the change to read my exchange with our great Bhai Kulbir Singh ji, so you know what I believe.
Here is my response to some of your comments:
>>>The human beings through which Gurbani came into this world were already Sach Khand vaasees>>>
Human Being are not SachKhand vaase (even Kulbir Singh would agree with me). It's Vaheguru who is Sach and he "wills" jeev atma to go and realize that "will".
>>>Their spirituality was already absorbed in awareness of sach khand>>>
Their spirituality? Please read my line above.
>>>>They only came to this earth for the purpose of preaching the infinite truth.>>>>
There is only one "Khasm" and everything happens within His hukam.
>>>So whatever they wrote in their Gurbani is very important and relevent. God themself made this bani come out from the mouth of the human bodies that these divine souls>>>
That I completely agree with :-)
>>> naanak bhagathaa sadhaa vigaas || >>>
bhagathaa(n) is plural here, and it doesn't apply to any particular bhagat. Bhagats remain in bliss while doing bhagati here in their human form.
>>>> thaeree bhagath thaeree bhagath bha(n)ddaar jee bharae bia(n)th baea(n)thaa ||
thaerae bhagath thaerae bhagath salaahan thudhh jee har anik anaek ana(n)thaa || >>>>
Beautiful, just great pankati!! There are beanth (countless, endless) bhagats who are "salaahan" Vaheguru. How can there be any shortage of His bhagats! And, it's not singular "thaera", it's "thaeree" bhagat.
>>>
naa ouhi marehi n t(h)aagae jaahi ||
jin kai raam vasai man maahi ||
thithhai bhagath vasehi kae loa ||
karehi ana(n)dh sachaa man soe ||
>>>
We have already covered these Japji Sahib pankatian in the "jot some questions" thread. I just want to add that quite often (In my humble opinion), the meaning of Gurbani isn't quite as literal as we like to make it to be. As we know, in one of the above pankani "thaeree bhagath thaeree bhagath bha(n)ddaar jee bharae bia(n)th baea(n)thaa ||", "bhanddaar" doesn't mean that bhagats are real bhanddaars.
>>>
raaj n chaaho mukath n chaaho man preeth charan kamalaarae ||
breham mehaes sidhh mun ei(n)dhraa mohi t(h)aakur hee dharasaarae ||1||
The bhagat does not want kingdoms, heavenly abodes, or even muktee and liberation from birth and death.
The bhagat wants to be in love with the feet of the Guru.
And to always be under the protection of the Guru.
Not the head of the guru, not the hands, the feet.
This gives you an idea of the "mindset" of a bhagat. They are not looking for a "khulee chhutee" or "freedom" from God's
hukam.
>>>
Sat bachhan, I agree but charan or feel isn't used for "flesh and blood human feet" as you imply (unless you believe that Vaheguru has a "human form" in SachKhand). Please read more about what charan often means in the context of Gurbani.
>>>
Afterall, what is everlasting bliss for a saint?
sukhaa kee mith kiaa ganee jaa simaree govi(n)dh ||
Guru ji says how can the happiness of Govind simaran be measured?
Simran on Guru ji, or "bhagti" from the beanth bhandaar of truth, is the only thing that keeps bhagats in sadaa anand, whether on this earth or in sach khand.
saadhh sa(n)gath sach kha(n)dd hai bhaao bhagath abhaasee||
Bhai Gurdas ji says that Saadh SAngat is sach khand, where Bhaao Bhagat Abhyaas is done - practicing of loving devotion.
>>>>
Saadh Sangat helps us connects with Vaheguru in this World through "naam-japp" that's why keerat and sift salah of Vaheguru is so important here in this World in Human form.
I guess, if it's in our bhagg, we will find out with Guru kirpa.
vjkk vjkf
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 15 Mar 2005
Veer J. Singh jeeo,
-------------
Kulbir Singh ji, I am surprised that you don't see any difference between Buddhism and Atheism? You do know that Buddhism atleast believes in compassion, equality, reincarnation, state of Nirvana (enlightenment) through samadhi.
----------
We should not forget that there are atheists who are very upright morally and are people of high probity. There are atheists who like their Buddhist cousins are very compassionate, loving and good natured persons. A religion that does not believe in the supreme power of Vaheguru is not even fit to be called a religion.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
aho · 15 Mar 2005
but bhai kulbir singh jio what about a religion that divises a caste system that affects 1 billion people? makes them pray to murtis instead of wahgurus naam, and makes people doubt in rituals and dualism and prescribes high castes to put hot lead into th eears of low caste if they hear sacred hymns is that fit to be called a religion?
hinduism
is it fit to call a religion one that tells a person to kill, rape, invade, pillage lands in the name of god?
christianity islam.
so then the only religion that would be fit to be called a rleigion would be sikhi innit.
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Singh KJ · 15 Mar 2005
>>>so then the only religion that would be fit to be called a rleigion would be sikhi innit.>>>
Aaho...
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 15 Mar 2005
J. Singh jeeo,
Although your post was not addressed to me but I am taking the liberty to comment on it. Hopefully you will not mind.
-----------
We have already covered these Japji Sahib pankatian in the "jot some questions" thread. I just want to add that quite often (In my humble opinion), the meaning of Gurbani isn't quite as literal as we like to make it to be. As we know, in one of the above pankani "thaeree bhagath thaeree bhagath bha(n)ddaar jee bharae bia(n)th baea(n)thaa ||", "bhanddaar" doesn't mean that bhagats are real bhanddaars.
---------------
Bhandaar here means exactly what the literal meaning is. Bhandaar means khazaana or treasure.
Teri Bhagat(I), Teri Bhagat(I) bhandaar jee Bharae, Beant Beanta ||
(note the bisraam I placed. On this particular pankiti out of this whole shabad, the bisraam should be after "bharae" and not "jee")
O Vaheguru, Bhandaars of your bhagtee are abundant and full. Bhagat(i) here does not mean Bhagat but Bhagtee. Mostly when the word “Bhagat” has “sihaari” in the end, it means Bhagtee.
-----------
Sat bachhan, I agree but charan or feel isn't used for "flesh and blood human feet" as you imply (unless you believe that Vaheguru has a "human form" in SachKhand). Please read more about what charan often means in the context of Gurbani.
-----------
Raaj na chaahau, Mukat na chaacho, Man preet Charan Kamlaa rey ||
This pankiti that our veer “Kar Kirpa Sabh Reyn Theevaan” quoted tells us a lot about the condition of bhagats in the next world. Gurbani here clearly rejects Raaj bhaag and Hindu / Buddhist concept of Mukti. Guru Sahib asks for Charan Kamal kee Preet. This pankiti proves many points:
1) Mann is present in the next world but becomes jyot form. Since Guru Sahib is asking for Mann dee preet, this proves that Mann is there in the next world.
2) This pankiti proves that forever and forever, Bhagats stay absorbed in the Charan Kamal kee preet. In order to have this preet, one must exist. How can one have preet, if one does not exist and have decimated into the ocean called Vaheguru? When this metaphor of ocean and drop is used it means that bhagats stay absorbed as drop and Ocean. It should not be taken as decimation or non-existence of a Gursikh.
And of course, Guru Sahib is not referring to Charan Kamal of flesh and blood. When ever the word Charan Kamal appears in Gurbani, it means the Nirgun Darshan of Vaheguru or it means Japping Naam. To "Urdhaar" Charan Kamal in "Hirda" means to Japp Gurmantr Naam in Hirda. In later spiritual states it also means to have Darshan of Vaheguru inside. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee writes that Charan Kamal of Vaheguru in form of Noor do appear inside Bhagats in their later states of spirituality.
-----------
Saadh Sangat helps us connects with Vaheguru in this World through "naam-japp" that's why keerat and sift salah of Vaheguru is so important here in this World in Human form.
-----------
According to Gurbani, the topmost avastha is sustained only and only through sifat-salaah. Ponder upon the pankitis like “Tithai Sitoo Seeta, Mehima maahe”. This proves that in that topmost avastha too, one is doing sifat salaah or mehima of Vaheguru. How can Bhagats live without this food of Naam? Impossible. Yes this is a different thing that in the next world, one does not have to do any effort to do bhagtee since there is no distraction of Trai-gunni Maaiya.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
J Singh · 15 Mar 2005
Kulbir Singh ji, you know what I believe and fully respect your understanding of Gurbani, so there is no need for us to keep on going at it. Now I don't want to start another debate :-) but we all recite Japji Sahib everyday and the pankaties you and "kar kirpaa" Bhai Sahib are referring to belong to KaramKhand, not SachKhand (in my "tusch" opinion).
Here is the mesmerizing shabad:
karam khand kee baanee jor
tithai hor naa ko-ee hor
tithai jodh mahaabal soor
tin mahi raam rahi-aa bharpoor
tithai seeto seetaa mahimaa maahi
taa kay roop naa kathnay jaahi
naa o-hi marahi naa thaagay jaahi
jin kai raam vasai man maahi
tithai bhagat vasahi kay lo-a.
karahi anand sachaa man so-i
sach khand vasai nirankaar
kar kar vaykhai nadar nihaal
tithai khand mandal varbhand
jay ko kathai taa ant naa ant
tithai lo-a lo-a aakaar
jiv jiv hukam tivai tiv kaar
vaykhai vigsai kar veechaar
naanak kathnaa karrhaa saar ||37||
vjkk vjkf
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 15 Mar 2005
------------
Kulbir Singh ji, you know what I believe and fully respect your understanding of Gurbani, so there is no need for us to keep on going at it. Now I don't want to start another debate :-) but we all recite Japji Sahib everyday and the pankaties you and "kar kirpaa" Bhai Sahib are referring to belong to KaramKhand, not SachKhand (in my "tusch" opinion).
------------
Your “tusch opinion” is very important. It is not tuschh at all.
I think Karam Khand and Sach Khand are almost the same and there is very little difference between them. Bhai Sahib writes that Karam Khand and Sach Khand have been written in one pauri for this reason. Bhai Sahib uses the analogy of a house and Verandah; Sach Khand being the house and Karam Khand being the Verandah.
In any case, Sach Khand has been described aptly in other shabads like “Beghampura” Shabad.
And you are so right. That pauri and whole of Siri Jap jee Sahib is mesmerising. Vaheguru!!!
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Jugroop Singh · 15 Mar 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Sadh Sangat Jio,
Just as a sidepoint, in Japji Sahib, within the 'Akheh..' verses, the Buddhas are also referred to alongside various Bhagats. However, they receive some extra attention.
Whereas other Bhagats are uniformly descibed as simply 'reciting/meditating your Name', Siree Guru Sahib Ji describes the Buddhas in the particular following terms:
'Various Buddhas, YOU HAVE CREATED, recite your Naam'.
(ps - forgive the dodgy translation)
So in a sense, perhaps Siree Guru Sahib Ji is teaching us, through this Pankti, that:
Even those who did not believe in The One Eternal Entity (VahiGuru), using the Buddhas in this case as an example, were trying to meditate upon Him without realising it; however, sadly, they did not realise the highest stages of spirituality - they may have arrived at the stage of Self-realisation (i.e. the nature of the mind) and Nothingness (which they see as Ultimate Reality) throught heir endeavours but through such mediatation they could not have arrived at the concept of Universal Self (ParAtma) and VahiGuru.
According to my limited understanding, Bhai Sahib puts this point across beautifully in either Unditthi Dunniya or Anhad Shabad Dasam Duar, where he states that the concept of a 'final destination' varies according to different faiths i.e. heaven, nothingness etc.
According to him, the Swan-Soul GurMukhs see the mergence with VahiGuru as their Final Destination and so GurMat is the Higher Path and is pukka compared to the others which are kachae.
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 16 Mar 2005
Veerjee Jugroop Singh jee,
vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa
vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!
is it not the case that
wherever it refers to "budhas" in gurbani,
it does not refer to Buddhists or Gautama Buddha
it refers to "bibek budhee vaalay" ??
i am confused on this
could you clarify how you can be sure that it refers to Buddhists ?
please forgive my mistakes
vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa
vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
avidya · 16 Mar 2005
Sorry, i mistakenly hit the post button;
Gurfateh Kulbir Singh ji,
I admire your reply, it is well thought out, and is your understanding, but I still maintain that my position is supported by gurbani also.
Now I agree with you 100% that the gursikh has no interest in mukti or swarg, only to remain ever in love with the charan kamal of Waheguru, but since waheguru is in it's purest form nirgun, that state of ever-residing bliss is also undifferentiated (in other words, there is no antish karan which arise from the traigun).
To my mind, your conception of sachkhand sounds a little bit like swarg. An actual place of swarg Guru ji rejects as having any importance, and instead states that the company of holy ones and singing kirtan is heaven for us. Therefore the goal is to die to ourselves to become nothing other than waheguru.
Guru ji states in Jaap Sahib;
'Ek moorat anek darsan deen roop anek
khel khel akhel khelan ant ko fir ek '
In other words, Waheguru's khel or leela is such that there seems to be differentiation when in actual fact at the end of it all there is only 'ek'.
Guru ji also states;
'Brahm disai brahm suniai ek eku vakhaniai
aatm pusaaraa krnhaaraa prabh binaa nahi jaaniai'
And most importantly on panna 294 Guru ji states;
'Sarab bhoot aapi vartaaraa
sarb nain aapi pekhanhaaraa'
If the aatm is in some way different containing 'us' then how can it be 'You' who sees through our eyes?
The means to reach this state is stated on panna 449 by Guru Ram Das ji as
'jivan mukt so aakhiai
mar jiwi maria'
The bhagat dies while alive, his individual identity cannot be taken with him for that would lead to seperation.
So how can there in the final stage there be the bhagat and God seperate? That is differentiated not undifferentiated.
Guru ji states;
'Sant Anthay antar nahi' panna 466
There is no difference between the saint and Waheguru
In Sri Akaal Ustat Guru ji states that Waheguru is 'Advai or undifferentiated.
So my questions;
1) How do you explain Guru ji describing this oneness as 'adavi' or undifferentiated?
2) There is a contradiction in terms that the aatma takes the mind with it and remains in some way seperate, as this is not oneness, this is duality.
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 16 Mar 2005
Avidya jee,
Good to hear from you. You are an intelligent person. It was fun debating with you and J. Singh.
----------
Now I agree with you 100% that the gursikh has no interest in mukti or swarg, only to remain ever in love with the charan kamal of Waheguru, but since waheguru is in it's purest form nirgun, that state of ever-residing bliss is also undifferentiated (in other words, there is no antish karan which arise from the traigun).
----------
You are right that there is no antashkaran in the sense of this world but don’t forget the following pankitis of Sharam Khand:
TITHAI GHAREEYE, SURAT, MATT, MANN, BUDDH||
In Sharam Khand, one’s Antakshkaran i.e. one’s mann, budhi, chit etc gets revamped. This is an important step in order to go to the higher khands of Karam Khand and Sach Khand. With this Antashkaran, one cannot comprehend anything in Sach Khand. Therefore, one’s antashkaran is tuned up in such way that it may comprehend and live in Sach Khand.
--------
To my mind, your conception of sachkhand sounds a little bit like swarg. An actual place of swarg Guru ji rejects as having any importance, and instead states that the company of holy ones and singing kirtan is heaven for us. Therefore the goal is to die to ourselves to become nothing other than waheguru.
----------
How can it be like Swarag when I mentioned nothing about Sharab-e-tahoor, Apsaras, Gandharabs. Sur Devtaas, Inder Devta, and other luxuries there. Sach Khand is purely a nirgun Khand, where there is only one kind of bliss and that is the bliss of Charan Kamal of Vaheguru.
-------------
Guru ji states in Jaap Sahib;
'Ek moorat anek darsan deen roop anek
khel khel akhel khelan ant ko fir ek '
In other words, Waheguru's khel or leela is such that there seems to be differentiation when in actual fact at the end of it all there is only 'ek'.
--------------
This pankiti strictly relates to this world of ours. This world is sargun world. Guru Sahib is saying that Vaheguru is sitting in everyone in this world and as such he has anek darshan.
----------------
Guru ji also states;
'Brahm disai brahm suniai ek eku vakhaniai
aatm pusaaraa krnhaaraa prabh binaa nahi jaaniai'
------------
This pankiti talks about that avastha of a Brahmgiyani that he or she attains while in this world in the human form. Bhagat in this stage see Brahm or Vaheguru everywhere and hear nothing but his Naam everywhere. He stays in extreme ecstasy. All over he sees only the pasaara of Vaheguru. This pankiti does not prove that Bhagats get decimated in the next world, rather this proves that the Bhagat sees only Vaheguru everywhere. This too proves that Bhagat does exist and only then he experiences this avastha of seeing and hearing only Vaheguru.
------
And most importantly on panna 294 Guru ji states;
'Sarab bhoot aapi vartaaraa
sarb nain aapi pekhanhaaraa'
If the aatm is in some way different containing 'us' then how can it be 'You' who sees through our eyes?
-------
Again this pankiti is about the Sargun world. Through all eyes he is the one who is looking. Because, he is in everyone and everything.
------
The means to reach this state is stated on panna 449 by Guru Ram Das ji as
'jivan mukt so aakhiai
mar jiwi maria'
The bhagat dies while alive, his individual identity cannot be taken with him for that would lead to seperation.
--------
This pankiti definitely goes in my favour. Guru Sahib is talking about dying once through Guru and then one never has to die again. There are several pankitis like this that prove that if we die through Gur-shabad, then one gets sadd-jeevan i..e everlasting life. How can it be everlasting life if one loses consciousness? One has to be alive to have bliss and everlasting life.
Marr-jeevai means marr ke jeeviya. Such person who dies through Guru and then becomes alive becomes jeevan-mukat. This death is the death of false-ego.
-----------
So how can there in the final stage there be the bhagat and God seperate? That is differentiated not undifferentiated.
-------------
In final stage, how can the Bhagat be in bliss if he does not exist? Being one means to be merged in Vaheguru and in this merger lies all the bliss but this merger does not mean the decimation of bhagat. Bhagats definitely stay alive in this merger because that is how they enjoy bliss. The question we need to address is who enjoys bliss? If one is not alive, how can one enjoy bliss? If I decimate in ocean, and cease to exist, then I cannot be in bliss. I don’t exist anymore.
I think to japp Naam to decimate oneself is a suicide. Why should I japp Naam in order to commit a suicide and suicide too of such level that is irreversible. If one commits suicide and destroys this body, then at least one’s aatma is alive but if one kills one’s aatma as you are suggesting, then there is no return from it. This is a suicide. Gurmat does not promote it. Gurmat promises us Sadd-jeevan.
--------------
Guru ji states;
'Sant Anthay antar nahi' panna 466
There is no difference between the saint and Waheguru
------------
The very fact that sant and Anant is mentioned here prove that there are two entities. There are two entities but they are totally merged with each other and sants stay in bliss in this merger. Their consciousness is in bliss. The fact that two are even mentioned prove that there are two entities.
---------
1) How do you explain Guru ji describing this oneness as 'adavi' or undifferentiated?
---------
Oneness over here is in the same sense as a Brahmgiyani in this world is one with Vaheguru yet maintains his separate identity too. You place an iron rod in hot fire and the iron rod becomes fire but still it is iron rod too. This iron rod takes on all qualities of fire but still stays iron rod as well. Same way bhagats stay merged in Vaheguru, take on all qualities of Vaheguru but maintain a separate entity. Well, this is just an analogy and is not a perfect analogy but nevertheless please accept it.
------------
2) There is a contradiction in terms that the aatma takes the mind with it and remains in some way seperate, as this is not oneness, this is duality.
-------------
What does it mean by “Mann tu jyot saroop hain” ? Does it not clearly prove that mann becomes atma-roop or jyot roop? So mann definitely goes up there but as I wrote above, it gets gharr i.e. carved so that it can stay there. This process takes place in Sharam Khand.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
jugroop singh · 16 Mar 2005
VahiGuruJiKakhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Veer/Bhain 'kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa' Ji wrote:
'is it not the case that wherever it refers to "budhas" in gurbani, it does not refer to Buddhists or Gautama Buddha it refers to "bibek budhee vaalay" ??
i am afraid i do not have the knowledge because i can't even read GurMukhi - nonetheless, this is a good point you have raised.
Perhaps others, including Veer Kulbir Singh Ji, could comment on the grammar employed and answer your question that way.
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
J Singh · 16 Mar 2005
I love it :-)! We have come back in full circle, almost to where we started this debate from. It's all about interpretation of the beautiful Ocean of Gurbani.
vjkk vjkf
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 16 Mar 2005
J. Singh jeeo,
Pray saanoo vee samjhaayo, how we are back to where we started.
Over the weekend, I talked to a bazurg Singh about this debate and told him what I was debating. He heard both sides and when I told him that one side is insisting that Bhagats decimate or get destroyed into the ocean of Vaheguru, he laughingly said, "Je agay jaa ke marna hee hai, phir aapaan ithay iss duniya vich hee changay haan. Ithay baar baar aayee jaavaangay. Zindaa tey rahaangay". (If we are going to get destroyed in the next world, then what is point of japping Naam and asking for his darshan. It is better to keep coming in this world again and again. At least we will be alive).
Survival instinct is in our being. Who wants to be decimated? At least I don't and know most entities don't want to be destroyed. Some really dukhee entity may want to just just get lost in the "ocean" but not any siyaana bhadur purash.
Naam japp ke taan sadd-jeevan hai. The word jeevan and getting lost in some merger is impossible. It is an oxymoron. You can't be in eternal bliss have sadd-jeevan and at the same time get merged and lost in the ocean of Vaheguru. Our veers who are in favour of this decimation have not given even single pankiti that specifically says that we will get decimated in the next world. I have given several pankitis that talk about life in the next world.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
J Singh · 16 Mar 2005
Kulbir Singh ji,
If you really think about how we got into this debate, you'll see that we are coming back to the same things.
You may not accept my position but here is how I had responded in some of my earlier posts:
"They look beautiful like "suhaagans" when they REACH in front of kant Vaheguru to be ONE with His Jyot. There is no difference between the two jyots once jeev-aatmas have merged into Vaheguru-jyot (after their "bandhans" are cut and they are freed from the circle of 84). How can jeev-aatma stay merged into Veheguru-jyot forever and ever (to eternity) and yet not loose it's own identity and consciousness? No, once jeev-atma goes back into Vaheguru, IT BECOMES HIM and is in Param-Anand forever. I don't think that there are millions and millions of jeev-aatmas residing in Vaheguru-jyot with their own distinct identities and consciousness."
"We can play with words all we want but the analogy of sugaagan and suhaag is just to prove that aatma finally reaches Vaheguru darbaar and merges into HIM to be in bliss forever and ever. To be ONE with the beloved Vaheguru is NOT destroying or decimating. On the contrary, it's the ultimate anand! Jeev-jyot goes back to the Param-Jyot where it originally came from". (Becomes part of Vaheguru who is the ultimate anand)
So, what you call decimation and destruction, I see it as atma really being ONE with Waheguru, going back to it's mool (Sach, one true being) where it originally came from. Being SEPARATE from Vahegur is really what brings pain and suffering to us.
I don't know the awasta of this bazurg gurmukh pyaara you mentioned (so forgive me) but all I can say is that atma isn't selfish (and it doesn't have any survival instinct!). Or is it? If it isn't, then how can it SELFISHLY think about staying as a distinct entity or consciousness while being one with Vaheguru. Khud naal aina pyaar kyon that you will choose to come back to the circle of 84 over and over again than to be ONE with Vaheguru-Jyot? “Mann tu jyot saroop hain” is talking to ourselves and advising
that we are jyot saroop and we need to recognize our mool. To me, there is only on sadeeve SACH and that is Vaheguru.
>>> Our veers who are in favour of this decimation have not given even single pankiti that specifically says that we will get decimated in the next world. I have given several pankitis that talk about life in the next world.>>>
It could be intentional on my part :-). And, I have already said that atma doesn't decimate, it merges into Vaheguru, and there is no difference between the two after that. I don't think that the pankities you have cited talk about life in the next world. If I did, we wouldn't still be debating. As I said, it comes down to how we interpret Gurbani.
vjkk vjkf
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 16 Mar 2005
J. Singh,
---------
It could be intentional on my part :-). And, I have already said that atma doesn't decimate, it merges into Vaheguru, and there is no difference between the two after that.
---------
Look at what you have written above. You yourself write that there is no difference between the two. This statement itself proves that you now agree that Aatma does not totally get finished. It does not get decimated.
Since you write in here that it does not get decimated, and only gets merged, could you tell us further if it has any consciousness? Is it sleeping? Is it in a dreamlike state? Is it in a dormant state? Is it a purgatary? What exactly is it doing?
Bhai Sahib told Bhagat Singh, "Tain marna nahi. Tain ithey hee muR ke aa jaana hai. Atma kadi marr nahi sakdi."
Even Krishna told Kunti-puttar Arjun that aatma never dies.
J. Singh jee, aapaan kadi nahi marr sakde. Ih gal taan pakki hai. Apnay andar jhaati maar ke dekho. Kee aapaan marr sakde haan? Hargiz nahi! Kadi nahi! Aapaan amar haan.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
RoopKaur · 16 Mar 2005
>I have already said that atma doesn't decimate, it merges into Vaheguru, and there is no difference between the two after that.<
Although the origin of the word decimate usually has a negative connotation, I think what is meant here is that the soul no longer exists as a seperate entity, thus is "decimated" out of existence, which is essentially what you are saying.
I was just wondering one thing from your posts, if once a brahmgyaani reaches Sachkhand, they merge with vaheguru and they no longer exist, how come many times lucky jeevs have had darshan of the jots of these singhs after they have passed on? Also, the shabad about Bey ghum pur i.e. Sachkhand, mentions that bhagats exist there in an ever blissfull state, how come this shabad does not say, the bhagats merge, or dissapear in Sachkhand, and instead outlines the type of existence they have there? Why would bani talk about their existence in Sachkhand if they no longer existed?
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
khalistani · 16 Mar 2005
kulbir singh jes right
man
we shud learn a bout sargun and nirgun saroop
bhula chuka maf
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 16 Mar 2005
J. Singh jeeo,
I am enjoying this debate with you so much. You are an intelligent man and your name probably stands for Jabarjang Singh.
--------
How can jeev-aatma stay merged into Veheguru-jyot forever and ever (to eternity) and yet not loose it's own identity and consciousness? No, once jeev-atma goes back into Vaheguru, IT BECOMES HIM and is in Param-Anand forever.
-------
J. Singh jeeo, I can't help writing this. Just read what you wrote, quoted above. You ask how can the jeev-aatma not lose consciousness after merging with Vaheguru. Then you write that after merging with Vaheguru, the jeev-aatma is in Param-Anand forever. If the jeev-aatma has lost its consciousness, how can it enjoy bliss? It is our consciousness that enjoys bliss. If there is no consciousness then whether there is bliss or Torturel, it is all the same.
If one is made to smell cholrophorm, then one loses consciousness. Now whether you show this unconscousness person a movie, or kirtan or whatever, what difference will it make to this corpse-like person?
Same way, if we are to lose consciousness, then what is the point in merging with Vaheguru? Apnay aap noo fanaah karan vaastay? Kadi nahi! Naa Mumkin. Kadachit nahi. Sau-jugg nahi. Kisay haalat vich nahi. nahi nahi nahi. kadee vee nahi.
Merging with Vaheguru means sadd-jeevan. Such a jeevan that one can experience, not a dormant state or a state of unconsciousness. If merging with Vaheguru is a dormant state or an unconcscious state, then why not smell the cholorphorm right here, and stay unconscoius till eternity? What is so great about getting unconscious in Vaheguru's saroop?
Merging in Vaheguru brings ba-hoshi (full consciousness) and not Be-hoshi (unconsciousness) as you are suggesting.
GHAAFAL NA SHAVAD YAKK-DAMM, AZZ YAAD-E-KHUDAA ||
DEEGHAR SUKHAN AZZ BULAND-O-PASTEE NA KUNAD ||
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
avidya · 17 Mar 2005
Gurfatehji,
Here goes again;
'Sarab bhool aapi vartaaraa
sarab nain aapi pekhanahaaraa'
Waheguru through all nain does pekhanhaaraa! How is this? Because the aatm is waheguru and it is his consciousness that is pekhanhaaraa.
Why is it 'you'? Firstly because there is NOTHING but YOU, not that there is nothing but ME! Secondly, because this is the satbachan of our Guru maharaj, who is giving us didactic teachings of bhakti marg. If he stated 'you are that, go figure' then the path would be jnaan/gyaan marg alone.
How can the finally merged aatm stay in bliss?
Because you are talking about the anandsaagar that is parbrahm. How is there complete conscious? Because Parbrahm is chitsaagar, the ocean of consciousness. It is also satsaagar, the ocean of truth. When Guru ji states 'hukami andar sabh ko, bahr hukam na koi' it is referring to Parbrahm's eternal consciousness.
Your translation of 'advai' is incorrect, and it is neither the meaning given in modern punjabi dictionaries! It means 'without differentiation' NOT 'oneness'
So
'Sarab nain aapi pekhanhaaraa' + 'advai' (undifferentiated) of Akaal Ustat
= At the truest level there is nothing but parbrahm.
= sagun qualities of antishkaran cannot continue to that saagar as these are the afflictions of maya
= describing sach khand as a plane of existence seperate from Parbrahm is duality (dvai) differentiation
= Not wishing to die to yourself, and wanting to hold to your own seperate independent identity as you posted is an affliction of antishkaran (haumai) and will hold you back from the highest state.
Consult Bhai Gurdas to find out where haumai, man, chit and budh arise from.
problem solved!
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
J Singh · 17 Mar 2005
>>> J. Singh jeeo,
I am enjoying this debate with you so much. You are an intelligent man and your name probably stands for Jabarjang Singh.>>>
I think you are just playing with me like a cat (in your case Sher) plays with a mice before decimating it with one panja :-) :-).
>>>> Look at what you have written above. You yourself write that there is no difference between the two. This statement itself proves that you now agree that Aatma does not totally get finished. It does not get decimated.
Since you write in here that it does not get decimated, and only gets merged, could you tell us further if it has any consciousness? Is it sleeping? Is it in a dreamlike state? Is it in a dormant state? Is it a purgatary? What exactly is it doing?>>>
>>>> J. Singh jeeo, I can't help writing this. Just read what you wrote, quoted above. You ask how can the jeev-aatma not lose consciousness after merging with Vaheguru. Then you write that after merging with Vaheguru, the jeev-aatma is in Param-Anand forever. If the jeev-aatma has lost its consciousness, how can it enjoy bliss? It is our consciousness that enjoys bliss. If there is no consciousness then whether there is bliss or Torturel, it is all the same. >>>
Pyaare Veer ji, I don't see anything wrong with what I have written above. Either you are just playing with me :-) or you still don't get what I meant in all my earlier posts. I have maintained this position from the time you mention destruction and decimation.
For info-tainment purpose, here is what I think these terms mean (and you may disagree):
To Decimate - to kill or to destroy
To Destroy - to kill or to demolish
To Merge - to unite or to engulf into something to become ONE
To summarize, here is what I understand your position is on the subject:
Vaheguru is biraajmaan (sitting) on His throne in SachKhand and ten Guru Sahibaan are sitting alongside Him in "nirgun" saroop (I am assuming they look like their Human form "roop"). You didn't say anything about whether Shri Guru Granth Sahib ji is parkaash there as well or not.
Bhagats very much alive and are sitting in KaramKhand (which is like a verandah infront of SachKhand) in their "nirgun" saroop doing bhagati of Vaheguru. They maintain their individuality and separate consciousness with feelings and memories, and they also have their own "will" to do whatever they want. Merging is eternal life and eternal bliss and not decimation of our self being. My comment: I don't quite understand how they are merged (jyoti jyot sammaye hoye) into Vaheguru though.
Our physical body cannot experience anything but it is the mann that experiences pain and suffering sitting in this physical body. Mann is the one that feels pain and it is mann that does bhagti and mann is what needs to be purified. When Mann gets purified, it becomes one with aatma and then the jeev-aatma becomes with Vaheguru. Our "jeev-aatma" takes on the astral body required for Dharam Khand. My comment: Yet jeev-atama is nirgun just like Vaheguru!
We start doing bhagati for Worldly (selfish) reasons, not for the selfless love of Vaheguru.
Now, here is a summary of my position on the subject (you don't have to agree with me at all):
Only Vaheguru is sadeeve Sach (paheli paurdi of Japji Sahib). HE runs the show, knows all, and can do anything and everything.
To be ONE with the beloved Vaheguru is not destruction or decimation of atma. On the contrary, it's the ultimate anand! Jeev-jyot goes back to merge into it's mool origion, the Param-Jyot where it originated from. At that point, it's not separate from Vaheguru at all. There is no difference between Guru Sahibaan and Vaheguru as they are ONE with Vaheguru. We infact love Vaheguru that resides in Guru sahib because their physical bodies (Worldly baana or clothes) are no more.
Bhagats do bhagati because they realized Him with Gurukirpa and now they long to merge in the param-anand of Vaheguru (just like fish without water). What more can they ask for then to be ONE with their beloved Vaheguru.
There is no difference between the two jyots once jeev-aatmas have merged into Vaheguru-jyot (after their "bandhans" get cut and they are freed from the circle of 84 with gur-kirpa). Jeev-atma and Parmatma are same, "nirgun". How can jeev-aatma stay merged into Veheguru-jyot forever and ever (to eternity) and yet not loose it's own identity and self consciousness?
Atma is beyond happiness and sorrow. All pain and suffering stems from being separated from Vaheguru, and merging into HIM is the ultimate bliss that can't be described. As long as jeev-aatma is in human form (still haven't finished 84), it has it's own identity like we all do. Brahmgiyani being in their physical form obviously are distinct from Vaheguru with their own aatma, until they "jyoti jyot samma" into Vaheguru. Once they jyoti jyot samma, there is no duality. It becomes part of the Param-Jyot, the
jyot that is forever in anand.
Kulbir Singh ji, this is just my meager understanding and I don't claim to know it all. "Tu dariya-o daana beena, main mashli kaise ant lavah". Guru Nanak Maharaj ji says, "kudrat kavan kahaa vichaar, vaari-aa naa jaavaa ayk vaar, jo tudh bhaavai saa-ee bhalee kaar, too sadaa salaamat nirankaar".
RoopKaur Bhainji wrote:
>>> I was just wondering one thing from your posts, if once a brahmgyaani reaches Sachkhand, they merge with Vaheguru and they no longer exist, how come many times lucky jeevs have had darshan of the jots of these singhs after they have passed on?
>>>
Because Veheguru is all merciful and grants whatever bhagats desire with shardah. He alone is "Sadaa salaamat Ningkaar". He can do anything and everything!
Again, galatian maaf karniya ji.
vjkk vjkf
[%sig%]
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 17 Mar 2005
----------
'Sarab bhool aapi vartaaraa
sarab nain aapi pekhanahaaraa'
Waheguru through all nain does pekhanhaaraa! How is this? Because the aatm is waheguru and it is his consciousness that is pekhanhaaraa.
------------
This is not true. Aatam is not Vaheguru. Aatma is Aatma and Parmatma is Parmatma as the name implies – Param-Atma. If atma is already Vaheguru, then what in your opinion is the point in merging this atma with Parmatma (as you say)?
----------
Why is it 'you'? Firstly because there is NOTHING but YOU, not that there is nothing but ME! Secondly, because this is the satbachan of our Guru maharaj, who is giving us didactic teachings of bhakti marg. If he stated 'you are that, go figure' then the path would be jnaan/gyaan marg alone.
-----------
The jnana maarag, or other maarags suggested by Bhagwad Geeta are not recognised by Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. Here only one maarag i.e. Prema-Bhagtee and that too through Sat-Naam is suggested. Jnana Maarag is flawed and so are other maarags suggested in Geeta because Gurbani does not sanction them.
----------
How can the finally merged aatm stay in bliss?
-------
Same way as Brahmgiyani stays merged in Vaheguru while living in this world. There is no difference after physical death.
------------
Your translation of 'advai' is incorrect, and it is neither the meaning given in modern punjabi dictionaries! It means 'without differentiation' NOT 'oneness'
-----------
First of all I don’t remember doing arth of “Advai”. Secondly, Advai actually means oneness. Dvai means two and Advai means one.
---------
'Sarab nain aapi pekhanhaaraa' + 'advai' (undifferentiated) of Akaal Ustat
----------
= sagun qualities of antishkaran cannot continue to that saagar as these are the afflictions of maya
= describin
----------
I already wrote before that in Sharam Khand one’s true Antashkaran is carved. Any comments on that?
Problem has not been solved still. You and J. Singh both talk about losing one’s consciousness and still talk about having Anand. This Gorakhdhanda is beyond me. Gurbani clearly says that Bhagats get Sadd-jeevan and have sadd-Anand. If they have consciousness, only then they have anand, right? How else?
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 17 Mar 2005
J. Singh jeeo,
-------------
Vaheguru is biraajmaan (sitting) on His throne in SachKhand and ten Guru Sahibaan are sitting alongside Him in "nirgun" saroop (I am assuming they look like their Human form "roop"). You didn't say anything about whether Shri Guru Granth Sahib ji is parkaash there as well or not.
Bhagats very much alive and are sitting in KaramKhand (which is like a verandah infront of SachKhand) in their "nirgun" saroop doing bhagati of Vaheguru. They maintain their individuality and separate consciousness with feelings and memories, and they also have their own "will" to do whatever they want. Merging is eternal life and eternal bliss and not decimation of our self being. My comment: I don't quite understand how they are merged (jyoti jyot sammaye hoye) into Vaheguru though.
--------------
You have misunderstood me. First of all, Vaheguru seated on the Takhat does not mean that he is just on that Takhat and not spread all over the universe, including whole of Sach Khand. It is very hard to explain and this is the reason why Siri Guru jee called Sach Khand description a Kathna Kardaa Saar. Vaheguru seated on the Takhat just means that this is where he is an accessible from. The whole of Sach Khand is his body. Since everything, including this Earth and other planets, are within Sach Khand, Vaheguru is in everything. Sach Khand engulf everything. It is just a different dimension; the real dimension.
And Bhagats are not in Karam Khand but in Sach Khand. Only those Bhagats who have not reached Sach Khand are in Karam Khand, depending on their spiritual state.
My position is this: Sach Khand and everything else is in Vaheguru and Vaheguru is also beyond all this. Vaheguru is too great for us to fathom. All aatmas in this world are made of the same material as Vaheguru and this material is indestructible. This material is beyond the 5 elements that we know of. In essence we just cannot comprehend what this material really is. I am using the word ‘Material’, just to explain.
Because of the Koorai-Paal, the aatmas are separated from Vaheguru. Once this dirt of false ego falls, through the True Naam, Bhagats go back to their dwelling. Yes they get absorbed in Vaheguru and stay absorbed in him there but still they have consciousness because in order to enjoy bliss, one needs it. If Bhagats choose to go anywhere out, or fly out to other lands, it does not affect their merger because where in this universe can you go and not have Vaheguru? He is everywhere and no matter where you go, you always have him and you always stay merged in him. So there is no question of losing the merger by going anywhere else, because you cannot go anywhere, where there is no Vaheguru. Vaheguru is everywhere.
For me, losing consciousness is losing life and it amounts to decimation.
Your position, as I understand, is that Bhagats get absorbed into Vaheguru and they get lost in there. They lose consciousness, the essence of life. What is life? Life is consciousness. Consciousness is the zenith of life. How losing consciousness can be classified as everlasting life?
Thanks for writing a summary of your position on this issue. Having read this couple of times, I can say that you and I am not too far apart.
You say, he runs the show, I agree.
You say, “To be ONE with the beloved Vaheguru is not destruction or decimation of atma”. I agree.
You say, “it's not separate from Vaheguru at all.”. I agree
You say, “There is no difference between the two jyots once jeev-aatmas have merged into Vaheguru-jyot”. I agree. There is no difference. “Koi na sakai pachhaanee”. Yes this is such a merger that is like flame to flame or water to water i.e. a very close merger, a union but not a consolidation whereby Jeev-aatma gets absorbed and totally ceases to exist.
------------
As long as jeev-aatma is in human form (still haven't finished 84), it has it's own identity like we all do. Brahmgiyani being in their physical form obviously are distinct from Vaheguru with their own aatma, until they "jyoti jyot samma" into Vaheguru. Once they jyoti jyot samma, there is no duality. It becomes part of the Param-Jyot, the
jyot that is forever in anand.
--------------
You have a slight misconception here. A Pooran Gursikh, who has attained the avastha of Brahmgyani is totally merged in Vaheguru, even while living. “Bhed na jaano mool, saayee jehiya” i..e Don’t consider any difference in them and Vaheguru. They are just like Saayeen Vaheguru. They are merged in Vaheguru but have consciousness because of which they can have anand.
The crux of my argument against you is that in order to have anand, we need consciousness. What would you say of Pankitis that say Bhagats have sadd-jeevan? If you say that they get consolidated in Vaheguru, then it is Vaheguru who is having Sadd-jeevan, not Bhagats.
Here is a new point, I would like to make. Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee has written the following in Akal Ustat:
“Na ghaat hai naa baadh, na ghaat baadh hot hai”
(O Vaheguru, you neither increase / grow nor decrease or shrink).
You suggest that the aatma gets absorbed in Vaheguru and loses identity and becomes part of Vaheguru. Technically, Vaheguru’s saroop has increased then? This is the violation of the above pankiti. So this explanation is flawed.
Here is my explanation now. Vaheguru is always in you and is always conscious about you. It is you who needs to develop his consciousness. Once this consciousness is developed, then one is free from these bandhans. One stays absorbed in Vaheguru. Remember, Vaheguru is already absorbed in us. It is now our turn to get absorbed in him. This absorbtion does not mean that our consciousness ceases to live. It is rather the opposite of that.
Think of this argument in terms of consciousness. You have not replied to my comments on Chloroform in the previous post. What is point of getting absorbed in him if we don’t have conscousness anymore?
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
J Singh · 17 Mar 2005
See how close we are veerji! Bass lafzaan da her-pher he hai. Being the aNhaa (spirituality blind) that I am :-), may be I am just unable to see the whole elephant and holding on to his leg and calling it a tree-truck :-). Only Vaheguru will reveal this mystery if we are blessed.
>>> “Na ghaat hai naa baadh, na ghaat baadh hot hai”
(O Vaheguru, you neither increase / grow nor decrease or shrink). >>>
Veer ji, how can Vaheguru be ghaat-baadh? He is beyond all our measures. How can He be measured (in my unworthy opinion)!! The pankati proves my point though as atma is indeed part of ParmAtma. Kiran is not separate from the Suraj. Afterall "Sabhe ghat Raam Bolle'.
>>> You suggest that the aatma gets absorbed in Vaheguru and loses identity and becomes part of Vaheguru. Technically, Vaheguru’s saroop has increased then? This is the violation of the above pankiti. So this explanation is flawed. >>>
I am really LOL (laughing out loud) now. We are going to get into "phambal-phussa" again if I went on to explain.
And, I have answered your comments on chloroform in many ways, par tusi mannde he nahee.
vjkk vjkf
[%sig%]
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulwinder Singh · 17 Mar 2005
I am genuinely not arguing with any of you, to me you are all saying right things from the point of view you are looking into.
I think ( I mean it is just my understanding I am not saying it is 100% right) answer lies not in the destination.
Answer is in the desire of the Bhagat.
If Bhagat spend their whole conscious life ( as someone can be bhagat even after living sinful life before they start the progressive life) in order to completly “Mil” with him, then do you think it is even possible that they will like to be even a 0.0000000001 micro mm away from HIM, and if you have met HIM as you want, your Desire to be with him is not on the law of diminishing returens, It actually increase as Guru Arjan Dev ji Say that my thirst is like fish’s thirst I can not live without YOU.
Wheather one is conscious or not after seeing HIM is not the question,
Question is do you want to be separated from HIM or would you be able to.
Guru Granth Sahib Ji tell us,
Even a fraction of second ‘s distance is like a big illness to me.
So the point is not how HIS setup is in Sachkhand, Point is how you want to be with HIM and what ever way you want, HE is not going to question your will or You are not going to question his will.
So answer is Bhagats do not want any distance between them and GOD and GOD love them so much that what ever they want he never say no.
And HE is so BIG what ever bhagats want he can make it real what ever ,who ever
where ever how ever his Dear Bhagats want.
Real is JUST him everything else is his Hukam and creation.
And remember you worship THE ONE in order to be with ONE, and in HIS world there are only two Numbers 0 and 1 if you have HIM then you are no 1 there is nobody who is no 2,3,……n. Just No 1. and , Zero keeping on going in circles to be 1.
Q: how will every Bhagat will be no 1 ?
Answer is simple by being 1.
But his ability is such that he can send his interface to others who he wish to talk with ,any interface they want.
His Interface are many as his Name are.
Just like Gurus have given darshan to their Bhagat in the interface of what Bhagats wanted.
If the above make sense then nice other wise ignore it .
Many thanks your Maha Moorakh
Kulwinder Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
>> · 18 Mar 2005
> I already wrote before that in Sharam Khand one’s true Antashkaran is
> carved. Any comments on that?
I know my question might sound kind of naive, but does Sharam Khand mean that you get embarassed easily, over little things that you wouldn't normally and that you might not even be concious about, ie- not even by viewing, but by sensing?
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Jugroop Singh · 18 Mar 2005
This Shabad is by Guru Arjan Dev Ji in Raag Bilaaval on Pannaa 827
raag bilaaval mehalaa 5 dhupadhae ghar 8
Raag Bilaaval, Fifth Mehl, Du-Padas, Eighth House:
ik oa(n)kaar sathigur prasaadh ||
One Universal Creator God. By The Grace Of The True Guru:
mai naahee prabh sabh kishh thaeraa ||
I am nothing, God; everything is Yours.
eeghai niragun ooghai saragun kael karath bich suaamee maeraa ||1|| rehaao ||
In this world, You are the absolute, formless Lord; in the world hereafter, You are the related Lord of form. You play it both ways, O my Lord and Master. ||1||Pause||
nagar mehi aap baahar fun aapan prabh maerae ko sagal basaeraa ||
You exist within the city, and beyond it as well; O my God, You are everywhere.
aapae hee raajan aapae hee raaeiaa keh keh t(h)aakur keh keh chaeraa ||1||
You Yourself are the King, and You Yourself are the subject. In one place, You are the Lord and Master, and in another place, You are the slave. ||1||
kaa ko dhuraao kaa sio balaba(n)chaa jeh jeh paekho theh theh naeraa
From whom should I hide? Whom should I try to deceive? Wherever I look, I see Him near at hand.
saadhh moorath gur bhaettiou naanak mil saagar boo(n)dh nehee an haeraa ||2||1||117||
I have met with Guru Nanak, the Embodiment of the Holy Saints. When the drop of water merges into the ocean, it cannot be distinguished as separate again. ||2||1||117||
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
thinking · 18 Mar 2005
hey guys if one of you make it up there when you gone from here do an ardas for me to make it to.
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 18 Mar 2005
---------
I know my question might sound kind of naive, but does Sharam Khand mean that you get embarassed easily, over little things that you wouldn't normally and that you might not even be concious about, ie- not even by viewing, but by sensing?
-----
LOL!
No veer / Bhain jeeo, Sharam Khand does not make you easily embarrased. The word Sharam here does not means that kind of sharam as you are thinking. Sharam means honour or izzat, just like in the following pankiti:
RAAKHO SHARAM ASAADEE JEEO||
OR
SHARAN PARAE KEE RAAKHO SHARMA ||
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 18 Mar 2005
My dear Jabarjang Singh jeeo (J. Singh),
No doubt our definition is very close.
I just want to approach this from another angle in order to make things more clear from my perspective.
You and I both agree that Vaheguru is everywhere. He is here in this world and in Sach Khand too and everywhere else too. The problem lies in the merger of bhagat and Vaheguru. You seem to be implying that this merger takes place after physical death and I think it happens before death. If it does not happen while living it ain’t gonna happen afterwards. Whatever spiritual progress is made while living in this physical body, that is where the Bhagat stands in the next world.
My point is that a Brahmgiyani Gursikh, while living in this world merges and becomes one with Vaheguru. There are several pankitis that prove this and here is just one of them:
Jina na visrai Naam, se kinehiya ||
Bhed na jano mool, sayee jehiya||
In the first pankiti a question is asked: Ones who never forget Naam, Oh keho jehe hunn i.e. what are they and what is their condition?
Siri Guru jee himself gives us the answer: Don’t see any difference between them and Vaheguru as they are one. They are like Vaheguru.
Wow!! What a great pankiti. It first tells us to “bhed na jaano mool” i.e. see no difference and then beautifully shows us the difference too. How? They are “Sayeen jehiya”. They are just like Sayeen Vaheguru. They are “like” him but not him. They are one with him but still as in this world, they are fully conscious of themselves.
What to talk about losing consciousness. Gurbani preaches us that such Gursikhs become super-conscious. They become Trai-Kaal Darshee i.e. they know Bhoot, Bhavikh and Bhavaan i.e. past, present and future. They know everything. Any knowledge they want, is at their fingertips.
Anyway, coming back to this question. A Gursikh merges with Vaheguru while living in this world. He stays in Sach Khand while living in this world, through surtee. Dasam Duaar is like a remote-access to Sach Khand. Bhai Sahib has written that Dasam Duaar is a remote-access within this body, a doorway within this body, a very gupt door, through which one enjoys the bliss of Sach Khand, while sitting in this world.
Since Vaheguru is everywhere, whether you are sitting here or in Sach Khand, a merged aatma has no difference. A merged aatma is merged in Vaheguru, no matter where it is.
------------------
>>> You suggest that the aatma gets absorbed in Vaheguru and loses identity and becomes part of Vaheguru. Technically, Vaheguru’s saroop has increased then? This is the violation of the above pankiti. So this explanation is flawed. >>>
I am really LOL (laughing out loud) now. We are going to get into "phambal-phussa" again if I went on to explain.
---------------
I had a good point though. You say that the aatma merges after death. If it merges after death and loses identity as you suggest, then surely Vaheguru’s saroop has increased causing violation of the above pankiti.
If you say agree that they are merged while living in the world, then what is the need to lose identity after death, when you can be merged without losing identity, as in this world?
Looking forward to your jawaab.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
J Singh · 18 Mar 2005
I like the name you gave me Veerji, but I am no Jabarjang Singh in front of great Jodha like yourself.
I guess this one difference of opinion will remain between us. Bhagat's surti is jurri hoi with Vaheguru through naam while being in human form but they still are in one of the 84 lakh juni. That's why they are reciting "Vaheguru-Vaheguru" (tuhi tuhi).
>>>> I had a good point though. You say that the aatma merges after death. If it merges after death and loses identity as you suggest, then surely Vaheguru’s saroop has increased causing violation of the above pankiti. >>>
Again, I answer this in two ways, one is with awe (how can we) and the other with logic. First, Vaheguru can not be ghaat-baadh. How can we ever imagine about measuring "the infinite" with our buddhi (brain). He is beyond all our mathematical measures. He is everywhere! “Na ghaat hai naa baadh, na ghaat baadh hot hai”. Secondly, There is no addition
or deletion of atma to ParmAtma. Atma is "nirgun" just as Parmatma. A ray has no real vajood without the Sun as it isn't separate from the Sun. After all "Sabhe ghat Raam Bolle".
>>>> If you say agree that they are merged while living in the world, then what is the need to lose identity after death, when you can be merged without losing identity, as in this world? >>>>
Like I said, as long as jeev-aatma is in human form it's still haven't finished with it's 84 lakh juni. It has it's own physical identity with an atma like we all do until "jyoti jyot samma". And stated in Gurbani, Bhagat's and brahmgiyani's surti is jurri hoi with Vaheguru while being on Earth thru Naam-jaap. They, being in their physical form, obviously still have their consciousness and own aatma until they "jyoti jyot samma" into Vaheguru after leaving human form with Vaheguru hukam. "Hukam-a andar sab
ko, bahir hukam na koi". Once they jyoti jyot samma, there is no duality in atma as their bandhans are cut. They are ONE-PARMJYOT. Their atma becomes part of the Param-Jyot, one Sachi-jyot that is forever in anand. We have already gone over the definition of a merger.
I know you don't agree with me but only Vaheguru can really reveal this mystery if we are blessed ( oh, what a thought).
vjkk vjkf
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 18 Mar 2005
J. Singh jeeo,
From this post and your earlier posts it seems that you some how think that being in this human body (84Lakh joons) somehow hinders merger with Vaheguru. There are just too many pankitis in Gurbani that show that Har and Harjan are ek i.e. they are merged even while living in this body. There is no pankiti that says that pooran Gursikhs or bhagats have anything less than a merger while in this dehi or sareer. You are a Sikh and I am a Sikh. Where we have a difference of opinion, we can refer to Gurbani. Please give me a Gurbani pankiti that says that union here of Bhagats is not pooran. If union here is pooran, then no other union is required after we leave body.
Deh taun ba-deh ho jaana means while living in this dehi, gursikhs become badeh i.e. free from bandhans of this deh. The constraints of this dehi no longer apply to them.
Second thing is that you see merger as end of bhagti, whereas this cannot be the case. The bliss can only be originating from Bhagti. "Seeto Seeta mehima maahe" etc are such states that are written in Gurbani and prove that Bhagats in that avastha continue to do bhagti because without Naam, nothing can be sustained in this world.
What do you think of this shabab here? This shabad defines state of jeev-atma in the topmost level. I have a feeling that you will call this avastha a metaphor, and I must that this is gross injustice with the shabad but even if you consider this shabad to be a metaphor, you cannot deny that this shabad talks about everlasting, blissful, sinless, sorrowless life.
baegam puraa sehar ko naao ||
Baygumpura, 'the city without sorrow', is the name of the town.
dhookh a(n)dhohu nehee thihi t(h)aao ||
There is no suffering or anxiety there.
naa(n) thasavees khiraaj n maal ||
There are no troubles or taxes on commodities there.
khouf n khathaa n tharas javaal ||1||
There is no fear, blemish or downfall there. ||1||
ab mohi khoob vathan geh paaee ||
Now, I have attained this most excellent city.
oohaa(n) khair sadhaa maerae bhaaee ||1|| rehaao ||
There is lasting peace and safety there, O Siblings of Destiny. ||1||Pause||
kaaeim dhaaeim sadhaa paathisaahee ||
God's Kingdom is steady, stable and eternal.
dhom n saem eaek so aahee ||
There is no second or third status; all are equal there.
aabaadhaan sadhaa masehoor ||
That city is populous and eternally famous.
oohaa(n) ganee basehi maamoor ||2||
Those who live there are wealthy and contented. ||2||
thio thio sail karehi jio bhaavai ||
They stroll about freely, just as they please.
meharam mehal n ko attakaavai ||
They know the Mansion of the Lord , and no one blocks their way when they go there.
kehi ravidhaas khalaas chamaaraa ||
Says Ravi Daas, the emancipated shoe-maker:
jo ham seharee s meeth hamaaraa ||3||2||
whoever is a citizen there, is a friend of mine. ||3||2||
You seem to have good grasp over Punjabi and therefore I don't see a real problem in your interpreting this shabad since it is simple Hindi language shabad. I think we can only get a closure on this topic by delving deep into Gurbani. While doing Sehaj Paath too, I always stay alert for any pankitis in my favour (hehe) and there were couple of pankitis and shabads I found, that I will share with you after your response.
It would be really wrong to close this topic saying that we agree to disagree. When we have Gurbani, then why not use Gurbani to solve this riddle for us? Gurbani is not in Sanskrit or Persian that we don't understand it. It is possible that my stand could be incorrect or incomplete and same holds true for you. Let us use Gurbani to solve this riddle for us. We can't wait for Vaheguru to reveal this to us because faida is only when he reveals it to both of us because if he reveals it to only me, then you may not believe what I say. In the interim, till that time of Vaheguru's revelation comes, let us understand Baani for the purpose of solving this riddle.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
J Singh · 18 Mar 2005
Kulbir Singh
Veer ji, I have a hunch that you just want to wear me down by bring these point back over and over again till I cry "I agree" :-) :-).
>>> We can't wait for Vaheguru to reveal this to us because faida is only when he reveals it to both of us because if he reveals it to only me, then you may not believe what I say. >>>>
LOL, come on now, if you say to me that HE has revealed this mystery to you, I will be begging to know!!. I have no doubt that Gurbani has all the answers but it's my misfortune that I fail to really see it all.
Tears come to my eyes when I hear this shabad of Bhagat Ravi Dass ji. Their bairaag and explanation of this blissful state is just too hard to bear. In my humble opinion, Bhagat ji is explaining what he experiences while his surti is jurri hoyi with Vaheguru with a metaphor, by comparing it to this World. How else can one describe what he experiences through naam simran! To me, this is one of the easiest way for a layman to understand and to relate to because this World is full of sorrow, suffering, anxiety,
troubles, taxes, all kinds of fears and much much more. There is no lasting peace and safety here in this mukaam-a-faani as it isn't eternal. Bhagats, being in the state of naam jaap, roam freely in this blissful state of anand without anyone blocking them. I know you will say that I am ignoring the later part of the shabad but I am really not. As I know from your other posts on this forum, you are fully aware that there are many shabads and pankaties that shouldn't be taken literally. We have to look at the essence of the shabads in it's full context, shabads such as "Raam Daas sarowar naahte, sabh oteray paap kamaate". Gurbani uses alangkaar all the time.
We only have limited word to describe, so we keep on getting entangled in these words. "Merger" is to unite to become ONE forever. Surti jurri hoyi with Vaheguru while being here in this World can't be really called a permanent merger with Vaheguru as bhagats are still here on Earth living like all of us.
I don't mean to be stubborn Veer ji but this is really how I see it. You are much more knowledgeable than I when it come to Gurbani, so please just ignore this moorakh :-).
Galtian maaf!
vjkk vjkk
[%sig%]
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 21 Mar 2005
J. Singh,
Hang in there. I will be responding to you either later today or tomorrow. I personally don't consider this a debate at all but Gurmat Vichaar. It is a must that we know what our destination is and this is exactly what we are doing by doing vichaar on this. I am learning and will continue to learn all my life. Who can claim to have learned everything?
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 22 Mar 2005
J. Singh,
Your interpretation of this shabad is what I expected it to be but there are few glitches in it. Look at the following pankiti in this shabad:
--------
dhom n saem eaek so aahee ||
There is no second or third status; all are equal there.
---------
If it were a spiritual avastha, then you know that all spiritual avasthas are different. But here Bhagat jee is talking about the shehrees or citizens of this city of Beghampura. There are no ranks in there. All are equal. This proves that this is talking about a place as opposed to an avastha.
--------
aabaadhaan sadhaa masehoor ||
That city is populous and eternally famous.
---------
Here it talks about the fame of this city or place. That this city always stays populated and is very famous. Aabadaan sada means always aabaad whereas Mashoor means famous. You tell me how this can be talked about an avastha that never stays the same. Avastha always keeps changing.
--------
oohaa(n) ganee basehi maamoor ||2||
Those who live there are wealthy and contented. ||2||
---------
Here Bhagat jee clearly mentions that in that mamoora i.e. city very remarkable and great citizens reside. Mamoor is a Persian word that has been used by shaayars very frequently. Ghalib has written as follows on this word Mamoor:
HAI AB ISS MAMOORE MEIN, KEHAR-E-GHAM-E-ULFAT, ASSAD;
HUM NE MAANA KE DELHI MEIN RAHEN, PAR KHAYENGAY KYA ||
(Okay I Agree that I should stay in this mamoora of Delhi but what will I eat since there is a famine of sorrow of love here)
Don’t know how you can interpret this straight pankiti that talks about wealthy and contented citizens of this mamoora of Beghampura.
---------
thio thio sail karehi jio bhaavai ||
They stroll about freely, just as they please.
---------
They can go anywhere they want freely. When you are in a spiritual state, you normally don’t go anywhere you want to because you are in a smaadhi. Here it clearly tells us that Bhagats can free go anywhere they want, at their will.
------
meharam mehal n ko attakaavai ||
They know the Mansion of the Lord , and no one blocks their way when they go there.
--------
They are meharam-Mehal i.e. knowers of mehal of Vaheguru. Meharam means ones who know inside out of the mehal. Clearly this is referring to the mehal of Vaheguru in Sach Khand. No one blocks them from going in there.
There are shabads that talk about pooran milaap of aatma and parmatma while living. If pooran milaap occurs while living, then what happens after death of this body? If you can be one with Vaheguru while living, and still exist and keep identity, what can stop you from losing identity after death? Please answer this.
As for Raamdaas Sarovar Naatay shabad, I have not an iota of doubt that indeed by taking ishnaan in Darbar Sahib, all your sins and dukhs are washed away, provided you fulfill other requirements in this shabad. Other requirement is clearly Naam japna.
How many examples do you want to prove to you that diseases and dukhs go away by just taking ishnaan in this sarovar? There are many examples that prove this.
Think about this. What else was the purpose of having this sarovar in the first place? Guru Sahib could have just dug up couple of wells there if the purpose had been only water. What was the need to build not one but five sarovars in Siri Amritsar Sahib and that huge sarovar of Siri Tarn Taran Sahib? And Sikhs from centuries have been doing ishnaan in these sarovars and reliving themselves of problems by doing so.
I don’t care what scholars and sceptics say because I myself have experienced the shakti of Gur-asthaans of Guru Sahib. How can I forget the ishnaan of Darbar Sahib that I recently had by great fortune? How can I forget the sweet water of Bauli Sahib of Ambala that Siri Guru Hargobind Sahib jee dug up? How can I forget the amrit water of Nanak Jheera Gurdwara Sahib of Bidar Karnataka and sarovar of Siri Dukh Nivaran Sahib of Patiala? Verily, these Gur-asthaans are loaded with spiritual power.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
J singh · 23 Mar 2005
>>>>> Your interpretation of this shabad is what I expected it to be but there are few glitches in it. >>>>>
Kulbir Singh ji, I interpret this shabad the same way our Shiromani Teekakaar (in my opinion) of Guru Granth Sahib ji and your favorite :-) Professor Sahib Singh has done. As I said in my last post, I am not ignoring any part of the shabad. I do understand the essence of what bhagat ji is saying. Begampura means (a state of being, a pura) without gham. You think that it's a actual physical place. There is a sheher called Beghampura. Now, do you think Begampura and Sachkhand are the same place? What is Begumpura to you and where is it? Is is a shehar or a khand? Does it reside within SachKhand because, by your own admission, bhagats reside in SachKhand?
>>>> Don’t know how you can interpret this straight pankati that talks about wealthy and contented citizens of this mamoora of Beghampura. >>>>
What does wealth really has to do with a "nirgun" jeev-atama?
>>>>> There are shabads that talk about pooran milaap of aatma and parmatma while living. If pooran milaap occurs while living, then what happens after death of this body? If you can be one with Vaheguru while living, and still exist and keep identity, what can stop you from losing identity after death? Please answer this.>>>>
Veer ji, I will answer this the same way I answered before. Bhagats are connected with Vaheguru through naam abiyaas. After their physical death, jeev-atma leaves human body to merge forever within the Vaheguru Jyot. As long as jeev-aatma is in human form (it still technically hasn't finished with 84 as it's still in a juni), it has it's own identity like we all do. Brahmgiyani and saints being in their physical form obviously are distinct from Vaheguru with their own aatma (yet they are completely jurre-hoye with Him through naam!), until they "jyoti jyot samma" into Vaheguru. Once they jyoti jyot samma, there is no duality. They becomes part of the Param-Jyot, the jyot that is forever in anand.
>>>> As for Raamdaas Sarovar Naatay shabad, I have not an iota of doubt that indeed by taking ishnaan in Darbar Sahib, all your sins and dukhs are washed away, provided you fulfill other requirements in this shabad. Other requirement is clearly Naam japna. >>>>
I request that you review your stance on this one. These specific pankaties don't talk about any requirement of naam japna! How can all of your sins or paaps be washed away with just taking a bath in the sarovar. To me it's misleading. Please forgive me for saying this but this is a very Hindu thought that Guru Sahibaan had stood firmly against. If you believe that the sarovar can wash away all of your sins, then is it okay for people to carry this "amrit water" (you know what amrit means) in bottles to wash away "sins"? It's baani not paani that washes the filth of our sins. There is no such thing as "Jab kaaBhe mein jaa-e(n)-ge, jamm-jamm se naha lei(n)-ge" :-) in sikhi.
When Bhatt Nal or other Bhatts are singing praises of Guru Sahibaan, do you think they are talking about Guru Sahib specifically or Vaheguru that is omnipresent in Guru Sahibs. You you think suns and moons can really singing Guru Sahibaan's or Vaheguru's naam? Do they have consciousness, literally speaking? What does Bhatt mean by "tu ta Janak raja Autaar"? Do
you think Guru Sahib was Janak's avtaar?
>>>> What else was the purpose of having this sarovar in the first place? >>>>
Purpose is obvious. Sarovars are simply there for millions of sardaloos to wash and clean themselves.
>>>> I don’t care what scholars and sceptics say because I myself have experienced the shakti of Gur-asthaans of Guru Sahib. >>>
Veer ji, I have seen a lot of your posts on this forum, you are the one who always quote scholars of Sikhi :-) to prove your point. I won't dare to question your personal spiritual experiences and I don't doubt your belief that your sins and/or kashts have been washed by taking a dip in the sarovars.
Veer ji, there is a lot of stuff you have written that wasn't necessary backed by Gurbani but I chose not to question it because I really respect your understanding. Here is some of what you have written in your earlier posts. I have paraphrased some of it but it's all been taken from your earlier posts:
>>>Vaheguru is sitting on His throne in SachKhand and ten Guru Sahibaan are sitting alongside Him in "nirgun" saroop (I am assuming Guru Sahibaan look like their Human form "roop" and you can tell me what Vaheguru looks like). >>>
>>> The whole of Sach Khand is Vaheguru's body. Since everything, including this Earth and other planets, are within Sach Khand, Vaheguru is in everything. Sach Khand engulf everything. It is just a different dimension; the real dimension.>>>
- Where does it say in Gurbani that Guru Sahibaan are sitting alongside Vaheguru in SachKhand? And where does it say that whole of Sach Khand is Vaheguru's body and Sach Khand engulfs everything? By that definition, we all are engulfed in Vaheguru's "body". If Vaheguru is sitting on a throne, does He have a "nirgun" form that looks like Guru Sahib? You say that Vaheguru in sitting on a throne in Sachkhand and is also everywhere but there is no explanation how.
>>>> Bhagats very much alive and are sitting in KaramKhand (which is like a verandah to SachKhand) in their "nirgun" saroop doing bhagati of Vaheguru. They maintain their individuality and separate consciousness with feelings and memories, and they also have their own "will" to do whatever they want. Merging is eternal life and eternal bliss and not decimation of our self being. >>>>
>>>> Bhagats are not in Karam Khand but in Sach Khand. Only those Bhagats who have not reached Sach Khand are in Karam Khand, depending on their spiritual state. >>>>
"jaa tis bhaavai taa sarisat upaa-ay, aapnai bhaanai la-ay samaa-ay, tum tay bhinn nahee kichh ho-ay". What happens to SachKhand vaasi bhagats eternal life ( i.e. who are doing bhagati of Vehaguru in SachKhand forever and ever while being merged in Him) when Vaheguru decides to "aapnai bhaanai la-ay samaa-ay"?
And, where does it say in Gurbani that Bhagats are not in Karam Khand but in Sach Khand. Where does it say that only those Bhagats who have not reached Sach Khand are in Karam Khand, depending on their spiritual state?
Veerji, we read Gurbani everyday and Gurbani advises and guides us how to reach Vaheguru. We do bhagati because we are separated from Vaheguru. We want to be free from this circle of 84 lakh juni and we want to realize our dream to be ONE with HIM. Human life is precious because this is the only juni out of 84 lakh that we get the chance to merge back to the infinite jyot of Vaheguru. You tell me what's the point of bhagats doing bhagati forever and ever when they are with Vaheguru in SachKhand (even by your definition)? Why are they reciting Vaheguru Vaheguru right in front his "nirgun" saroop? Does the same apply to Guru Sahibaan?
How can you say that we selflessly love Vaheguru while holding on to this completely selfish notion of having a self (individuality) and separate consciousness in Sachkhand to enjoy anand? Why so much pyaar with our vajood :-)?
You said in one of your earlier posts that I don't quote Gurbani and I said that this could be intentional :-). I am not asking or questioning anything but here are some pankatian to ponder upon:
- "barahm meh jan jan meh paarbarahm, aykeh aap nahee kachh bharam"
- "so antar so baahar anant, ghat ghat bi-aap rahi-aa bhagvant"
- "nirgun aap sargun bhee ohee"
- "agam agochar parabh nirbaanee"
- "khayl sankochai ta-o naanak aykai"
Again, garltian maaf veer ji. Gurbani is an infinite Ocean and we are mere masklies (fish). I have my own reasons to believe what I believe and I also fully respect you understanding of Gurbani and your stance on this. May be, in due time, Vaheguru will reveal this mystery to us if it's in our bhagg.
vjkk vjkf
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 23 Mar 2005
J. Singh,
Man, you are really trying to ambuscade me here. You have opened many topics at the same time. It is fine with me as long as we can keep track of all these topics here. Let us deal with the first topic i.e. the main topic first.
-----------
Kulbir Singh ji, I interpret this shabad the same way our Shiromani Teekakaar (in my opinion) of Guru Granth Sahib ji and your favorite :-) Professor Sahib Singh has done. As I said in my last post, I am not ignoring any part of the shabad. I do understand the essence of what bhagat ji is saying. Begampura means (a state of being, a pura) without gham. You think that it's a actual physical place. There is a sheher called Beghampura. Now, do you think Begampura and Sachkhand are the same place? What is Begumpura to you and where is it? Is is a shehar or a khand? Does it reside within SachKhand because, by your own admission, bhagats reside in SachKhand?
----------
I know Professor Sahib Singh has done the meanings of this as a state but there are many places where I don’t agree with him because he gives very dry interpretations. He was our Panini (great viyakran scholar) and that’s about it. I don’t rely on him for doing mystical interpretations. He himself was a great scholar but as written by himself in his autobiography, he never had any mystical experiences.
Now for your question whether Beghampura is a place in Sach Khand or is it another name for Sach Khand, I would say that it is another name for Sach Khand.
---------
What does wealth really has to do with a "nirgun" jeev-atama?
---------
Where did I say that I was talking about worldly wealth? I was talking about nirgun wealth of Naam.
NAAM MILAI, CHALAI MAIN NAAL ||
(May I get Naam that will with me in the end)
and
Satsangat lag Har dhiaaeeye, Har Har chalae terai naal ||
(In Satsangat do jaap of Hari. This Har Har Jaap will go with you).
This proves that Naam does go with you in the end. Many pankitis prove that Naam is that true Naam “Maayee, main Dhann paaiyo Har Naam||”
-------------
Veer ji, I will answer this the same way I answered before. Bhagats are connected with Vaheguru through naam abiyaas. After their physical death, jeev-atma leaves human body to merge forever within the Vaheguru Jyot. As long as jeev-aatma is in human form (it still technically hasn't finished with 84 as it's still in a juni), it has it's own identity like we all do. Brahmgiyani and saints being in their physical form obviously are distinct from Vaheguru with their own aatma (yet they are completely jurre-hoye with Him through naam!), until they "jyoti jyot samma" into Vaheguru. Once they jyoti jyot samma, there is no duality. They becomes part of the Param-Jyot, the jyot that is forever in anand.
-----------
Your stand is that Brahmgiyanis are totally jurre hoye with Parmaatma through Naam and are not one with him aatma-wise. My stand is that Brahmgiyanis get aatmik milaap with Vaheguru while living and as such they don’t need to go through another process (that you suggest) to merge in Vaheguru. They are already merged with Vaheguru while living. The pankiti that you yourself quoted proves this beyond doubt:
- "barahm meh jan jan meh paarbarahm, aykeh aap nahee kachh bharam"
You are the one who quoted this pankiti and perhaps you did it for my convenience. This famous pankiti is from the eighteenth ashtpadi of Siri Sukhmani Sahib. This pankiti makes it clear that “Vaheguru is in Jann and Jann is in Vaheguru. They are both totally one and there should be no doubt about it.“
Does this pankiti not refute your claim that the Bhagats are not one with Vaheguru while alive and are only “connected” through Naam? You believe that this merger takes place after physical death. Could you please substantiate your claim through baani?
If you claim that this pankiti relates to the merger that occurs in the next world, then I will humbly ask you to look at the preceding pankitis of this shabad. They clearly talk about this world and not next world. Just refer to the whole shabad yourself and if you have any doubt about it, we can discuss it.
-------------
Where does it say in Gurbani that Guru Sahibaan are sitting alongside Vaheguru in SachKhand?
----------
Gurbani has recorded the great event of departure of Siri Guru Raam Daas jee from this world to Sach Khand. When he reached Sach Khand, Vaheguru jee himself gave him a throne to be seated on. This has been recorded in Gurbani and your favourite teekakaar too has accepted this meaning. Here is the pankiti:
DEVPURI MEH GAIYO, AAP PARMESHAR BHAAIYO ||
HAR, SINGHAASAN DEEYO, SIRI GUR TIH BAITHAIYO ||
(By the will of Vaheguru himself, Siri Guru Raam Daas jee went to Sach Khand i.e. Devpuri. Hari himself gave Siri Guru jee a throne and had him seated there).
You can refer to Professor Sahib Singh’s pothi where he has interpreted this shabad just as I have above or as Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has done.
Regarding this throne of Vaheguru Bhai Sahib has written very beautifully, while doing translation of the above stated shabad:
“Phir, ikko singhaasan uttay Siri Vaheguru Nirankaar atay Guru Jyot Jaamay Biraajmaan hoye rehindey hunn, jo bhin bhin saroop vich vee nirkhay (dekhay) jaanday hunn atay abhed roop vich vee hoye rehindey hunn. Ik ikk adbhutt drishiya hai, jiss da amanna (yakeen) keval saakshaatkaar (when you actually behold it yourself) hoiyaan hee aa sakda hai”.
I will try to do a humble translation of this as follows:
“Then, on one throne Siri Vaheguru Nirankaar (whose form is beyond 5 elements of this world) and Guru Jyot Jaamay stay seated. They can be seen sometimes different from each other and at other times totally merged. This is an extremely wondrous scene and only after viewing it with your own eyes, one can believe and understand it.” (Sach Khand Darshan of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee).
----------
And where does it say that whole of Sach Khand is Vaheguru's body and Sach Khand engulfs everything? By that definition, we all are engulfed in Vaheguru's "body". If Vaheguru is sitting on a throne, does He have a "nirgun" form that looks like Guru Sahib? You say that Vaheguru in sitting on a throne in Sachkhand and is also everywhere but there is no explanation how.
--------
The whole of Gurbani says that Vaheguru resides everywhere. Sach Khand is no different in this respect. What is different about Sach Khand is that in this Khand, the jeev-aatma resides in its purest form and does not have any bodies as this body we have now. It is in its purest form and this is the Khand where Vaheguru is visible in his purest form as well. At other places such visibility of Vaheguru is not there as in Sach Khand, where everything including other bhagats of that level are visible and residing.
As for how he is in Sach Khand and in this world, Gurbani gives a beautiful example of this. I can’t remember the pankiti at this time but will find it if I can. It says that just as sun is far from this Earth but is present in this Earth through his rays, Vaheguru is in Sach Khand but also present in his whole creation.
-----------
"jaa tis bhaavai taa sarisat upaa-ay, aapnai bhaanai la-ay samaa-ay, tum tay bhinn nahee kichh ho-ay". What happens to SachKhand vaasi bhagats eternal life ( i.e. who are doing bhagati of Vehaguru in SachKhand forever and ever while being merged in Him) when Vaheguru decides to "aapnai bhaanai la-ay samaa-ay"?
----------
Sach Khand is not a creation as the name implies. Sach cannot be created because anything that is created has to die one day. Sach Khand is an abinaashi Khand i..e that cannot be destroyed. The name Sach Khand proves that. The pankitis that you have given above pertain to this world. This world that we live in can be created and destroyed but not Sach Khand.
No atma can be destroyed and every aatma in the end does get merged in Vaheguru. Here is a pankiti to prove this:
SABHNA SAHURAY VANJHNA, SABH MUKLAVANHAAR ||
------------
And, where does it say in Gurbani that Bhagats are not in Karam Khand but in Sach Khand. Where does it say that only those Bhagats who have not reached Sach Khand are in Karam Khand, depending on their spiritual state?
------------
The levels of Khands prove that. Guru Sahib has written about 5 Khands in Siri Japp jee Sahib. In Gyaan Khand Guru Sahib has written that many great souls reside and in same way all Khands have residents. What else is the purpose of Khands? Karam Khand clearly states the presence of Bhagats and Sach Khand too has stated Khand Mandal Varbhand. At other places like Beghampura shabad and many other shabads, talk about Bhagats residing in Sach Khand.
The shabad of Siri Guru Raamdaas jee residing in Sach Khand and on a throne should prove beyond doubt that aatmas don’t finish there and do reside there.
----------
Why are they reciting Vaheguru Vaheguru right in front his "nirgun" saroop? Does the same apply to Guru Sahibaan?
----------
No one needs to recite Vaheguru Vaheguru in Sach Khand as they have to in this world. We recite this Naam to connect to that consciousness but in Sach Khand everyone is already in that consciousness of spirituality and as such Naam-Naami is andar-baahar of everyone there. No effort is needed to do Naam abhyaas there. It is effortless there but it does go on there too.
----------
How can you say that we selflessly love Vaheguru while holding on to this completely selfish notion of having a self (individuality) and separate consciousness in Sachkhand to enjoy anand? Why so much pyaar with our vajood :-)?
---------
Where did I ever say that we should be totally selfless? “Aapnay suyayo ko keeno meeth” i.e. I have made Vaheguru my friend because of my personal needs, my manorath. I see nothing wrong in it. Bhagtee is initially done to deliver ourselves from this cycle of life and death and once this is accomplished, we lose all other needs and then is when we become truly selfless i..e we need nothing else and we have Vaheguru.
We can become selfless only when we need nothing and are fully fulfilled. If we have needs, and are suppressing them, than that too is not fair. Our wishes must come true and once our wishes are quenched through Naam, we become totally selfless, i.e. no need anymore.
The Gurbani pankitis you quoted go in my favour (hehe).
--------
Again, garltian maaf veer ji. Gurbani is an infinite Ocean and we are mere masklies (fish). I have my own reasons to believe what I believe and I also fully respect you understanding of Gurbani and your stance on this. May be, in due time, Vaheguru will reveal this mystery to us if it's in our bhagg.
---------
I respect your understandings too.
Now let us discuss other issues you raised in your post:
---------------
I request that you review your stance on this one. These specific pankaties don't talk about any requirement of naam japna!
---------
The rahao pankiti of this shabad clearly instructs us to “Gur ka shabad vicaarae”. Then the last pankitis of this shabad instruct us to do sangat and japp Naam.
-----------
How can all of your sins or paaps be washed away with just taking a bath in the sarovar. To me it's misleading. Please forgive me for saying this but this is a very Hindu thought that Guru Sahibaan had stood firmly against. If you believe that the sarovar can wash away all of your sins, then is it okay for people to carry this "amrit water" (you know what amrit means) in bottles to wash away "sins"? It's baani not paani that washes the filth of our sins.
-----------
I agree it is baani not paani and this is exactly what is working in Raamdas Sarovar. There is Baani paath done there all the time, for last 400 years. On top of this, our Guru Sahibaan have charan-chhoh to this place. Remember the following pankiti of Gurbani:
Jithay jaaye bahae mera Satguru, so thaan suhaava Raam Raajay ||
Gursikhee so thaan bhaaliya, lai dhoor mukh laavaa ||
Gursikhaan kee ghaal thaaye payee, jin Har Naam dhiyaava ||
Jin, Nanak Satguru poojiya, tinn Har Pooj Karaava ||
Where ever Satguru gets seated, that place gets suhaavee i.e. very beautiful and pavitter. Gursikhs go and find that place and place the dhoor of that place on their foreheads. This sewa of Gursikhs gets accepted, provided they also japp Naam. Ones who worship Guru Nanak, Vaheguru makes them worshipped by the world.
In this shabad too it is clearly stated that placing the dhoor of Guru Sahib’s Gur-asthaan is accepted by Vaheguru provided by japp Naam. Same way, ones who do ishnaan in Raam Daas Sarovar, get to wash away their sins and dukhs, provided they are good Gursikhs. This ishnaan works as a catalyst in purification process.
-----------
When Bhatt Nal or other Bhatts are singing praises of Guru Sahibaan, do you think they are talking about Guru Sahib specifically or Vaheguru that is omnipresent in Guru Sahibs.
-----------
At most places they are talking about Guru Sahibaan. This is why the saviye are named as Mahallay pehlay ke, Mahallay doojay ke and so on. In Mahalle pehlay ke saviyye, bhatts sing praises of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee and so on.
--------------
You you think suns and moons can really singing Guru Sahibaan's or Vaheguru's naam? Do they have consciousness, literally speaking?
------------
Please give a pankiti and we can discuss this then.
---------
What does Bhatt mean by "tu ta Janak raja Autaar"? Do
you think Guru Sahib was Janak's avtaar?
----------
This is saviyye mehlay doojay ke and all shabads in this baani pertain to Siri Guru Angad Dev jee Maharaaj.
Professor Sahib Singh thinks that this pankiti says that O Siri Guru Angad Dev jee, you are Raja Janak Avtaar when it comes to staying oblivious of maaiya. Raja Janak was known for being oblivious of maaiya.
Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has interpreted this pankiti as O Siri Guru Angad Dev jee, you are a great Raaj-Avtaar. The word Janik according the dictionary means great.
In any case, what is the big deal about this pankiti and what are you trying to say through this? Even if it means that Siri Guru Angad Dev jee was an avtaar of Raja Janak, what are the implications of that? Don’t we all know that Baba Lehna jee was a devotee of a Devi before meeting Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj? Only after Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee placed the jyot of Guru-form of Vaheguru in Baba Lehna jee, he became Siri Guru Angad Dev jee. So if he was Raja Janak in his previous life, and became Baba Lehna jee and then Siri Guru Angad Dev jee, it does not shake any foundation of Sikh Panth.
-------------
>>>> What else was the purpose of having this sarovar in the first place? >>>>
Purpose is obvious. Sarovars are simply there for millions of sardaloos to wash and clean themselves.
-----------
But to have 5 sarovars so close to each other makes no sense to me if the only purpose was for millions to wash and clean. And besides, it is clearly written on the sarovar that you are not allowed to clean our bodies there or use soap etc. People only used Darbar Sahib to do spiritual ishnaan and not that kind of ishnaan as you are talking about.
If you look at the Siri Tarn Taran Sahib ishnaan, there was no purpose of making that big sarovar. The sarovar is literally 10 times bigger than Siri Amritsar Sahib sarovar.
And why did Siri Guru Amardas jee dig up a bauli and made exactly 84 steps to it, not 83 or 82 or 85?
Don’t dismiss sarovars and other traditions of Sikhi because of your skepticism. We ask in our ardas every day "Siri Amritsar jee ke Darshan Ishnaan". Why do Sikhs worldwide ask for "ishnaan" of Darbar Sahib and this is the ardaas from hundred of years, not a new one. There must be some reason. If the purpose of sarovar is to just wash your body, then why do Gursikhs beg for ishnaan of Siri Amritsar Sahib in their ardaas everyday?
--------------------
>>>> I don’t care what scholars and sceptics say because I myself have experienced the shakti of Gur-asthaans of Guru Sahib. >>>
Veer ji, I have seen a lot of your posts on this forum, you are the one who always quote scholars of Sikhi :-) to prove your point. I won't dare to question your personal spiritual experiences and I don't doubt your belief that your sins and/or kashts have been washed by taking a dip in the sarovars.
------------
I am all for scholars but we must realise their limits. If a person is learned in one field, we must not consider that person learned in all fields of Gurmat. A person may be an expert of grammar but that does not make him suitable for interpreting the mystical pankitis of Gurbani that talk about stuff that ordinary persons cannot understand. Take for instance Sidh Gosth. The talk that took place in great Sidhas and Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj, is beyond the understanding of ordinary people. Scholars have interpreted the meanings but paR ke swaad nahi aunda.
I appreciate your knowledge and your keen interest in Sikhi. Guru Sahib aap jee uppar apni kirpa karan. Aap jee noo Gursikh dee daat bakshan.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
J singh · 23 Mar 2005
>>>>
- "barahm meh jan jan meh paarbarahm, aykeh aap nahee kachh bharam"
You are the one who quoted this pankiti and perhaps you did it for my convenience. This famous pankiti is from the eighteenth ashtpadi of Siri Sukhmani Sahib. This pankiti makes it clear that “Vaheguru is in Jann and Jann is in Vaheguru. They are both totally one and there should be no doubt about it.“
Does this pankiti not refute your claim that the Bhagats are not one with Vaheguru while alive and are only “connected” through Naam? You believe that this merger takes place after physical death. Could you please substantiate your claim through baani?
>>>>
No, it doesn't refute what I am saying! My intention was to show you that it's all Vaheguru (Param-Jyot and jeev-jyot are same). "aykeh aap nahee kachh bharam".
>>>> This proves that Naam does go with you in the end. Many pankities prove that Naam is that true Naam “Maayee, main Dhann paaiyo Har Naam||”>>>
I have never disputed the power of naam as it's naam that connects us to our beloved Vaheguru. But, in my opinion, you are taking the meanings of some of the pankaties too literally.
>>>>
-------------
Where does it say in Gurbani that Guru Sahibaan are sitting alongside Vaheguru in SachKhand?
----------
Gurbani has recorded the great event of departure of Siri Guru Raam Daas jee from this world to Sach Khand. When he reached Sach Khand, Vaheguru jee himself gave him a throne to be seated on. This has been recorded in Gurbani and your favourite teekakaar too has accepted this meaning. Here is the pankiti:
DEVPURI MEH GAIYO, AAP PARMESHAR BHAAIYO ||
HAR, SINGHAASAN DEEYO, SIRI GUR TIH BAITHAIYO ||
(By the will of Vaheguru himself, Siri Guru Raam Daas jee went to Sach Khand i.e. Devpuri. Hari himself gave Siri Guru jee a throne and had him seated there).
You can refer to Professor Sahib Singh’s pothi where he has interpreted this shabad just as I have above or as Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has done.
>>>>
Veerji, now Devpuri is also means Sachkhand! How convenient :-). And here you want to agree with Professor Sahib Singh because it goes in your favour!! I just read this shabad last night. How does this shabad prove that Guru Sahibaan are sitting alongside Vaheguru in SachKhand. Really, the difference between you and I is that I don't always take the meaning of Gurbani quite so literally.
>>>>>
----------
And where does it say that whole of Sach Khand is Vaheguru's body and Sach Khand engulfs everything? By that definition, we all are engulfed in Vaheguru's "body". If Vaheguru is sitting on a throne, does He have a "nirgun" form that looks like Guru Sahib? You say that Vaheguru in sitting on a throne in Sachkhand and is also everywhere but there is no explanation how.
--------
The whole of Gurbani says that Vaheguru resides everywhere. Sach Khand is no different in this respect. What is different about Sach Khand is that in this Khand, the jeev-aatma resides in its purest form and does not have any bodies as this body we have now. It is in its purest form and this is the Khand where Vaheguru is visible in his purest form as well. At other places
such visibility of Vaheguru is not there as in Sach Khand, where everything including other bhagats of that level are visible and residing.
>>>>>
Now you lost me here. We both agree that Vaheguru resides everywhere. I thought jeev-atma and Vaheguru are already pure. You said so yourself in your previous posts! How do they get to purest is beyond me. Is there a further purification process?
>>>>
-----------
"jaa tis bhaavai taa sarisat upaa-ay, aapnai bhaanai la-ay samaa-ay, tum tay bhinn nahee kichh ho-ay". What happens to SachKhand vaasi bhagats eternal life ( i.e. who are doing bhagati of Vehaguru in SachKhand forever and ever while being merged in Him) when Vaheguru decides to "aapnai bhaanai la-ay samaa-ay"?
----------
Sach Khand is not a creation as the name implies. Sach cannot be created because anything that is created has to die one day. Sach Khand is an abinaashi Khand i..e that cannot be destroyed. The name Sach Khand proves that. The pankities that you have given above pertain to this world. This world that we live in can be created and destroyed but not Sach Khand.
No atma can be destroyed and every aatma in the end does get merged in Vaheguru. Here is a pankiti to prove this:
SABHNA SAHURAY VANJHNA, SABH MUKLAVANHAAR ||
>>>>
You know I can't agree with you here. Only Vaheguru is Sach and only He who runs and controls everything. If he wills "aapnai bhaanai la-ay samaa-ay". And, above pankati doesn't prove anything you are implying. Our nij-ghar is Vaheguru-Jyot. You used the word destroy for atma again. I never said that atma gets destroyed!
>>>>
-----------
And, where does it say in Gurbani that Bhagats are not in Karam Khand but in Sach Khand. Where does it say that only those Bhagats who have not reached Sach Khand are in Karam Khand, depending on their spiritual state?
------------
The levels of Khands prove that. Guru Sahib has written about 5 Khands in Siri Japp jee Sahib. In Gyaan Khand Guru Sahib has written that many great souls reside and in same way all Khands have residents. What else is the purpose of Khands? Karam Khand clearly states the presence of Bhagats and Sach Khand too has stated Khand Mandal Varbhand. At other places like Beghampura shabad and many other shabads, talk about Bhagats residing in Sach Khand.
The shabad of Siri Guru Raamdaas jee residing in Sach Khand and on a throne should prove beyond doubt that aatmas don’t finish there and do reside there.
>>>>
No, it doesn't prove that. You yourself have agreed that Japji Sahib's pankaties (with Bhagats) belong to Karam Khand which, by your own admission, is like a verandah to Sachkhand. Then you said that some bhagats are in Sach Khand! Where does it say that only those Bhagats who have not reached Sach Khand are in Karam Khand, depending on their spiritual state?
>>>>
----------
Why are they reciting Vaheguru Vaheguru right in front his "nirgun" saroop? Does the same apply to Guru Sahibaan?
----------
No one needs to recite Vaheguru Vaheguru in Sach Khand as they have to in this world. We recite this Naam to connect to that consciousness but in Sach Khand everyone is already in that consciousness of spirituality and as such Naam-Naami is andar-baahar of everyone there. No effort is needed to do Naam abhyaas there. It is effortless there but it does go on there
too.
>>>>
I don't know how you came to all these conclusions and, as you can see from what I have posted so far, I don't know why bhagats would be doing bhagati of Vaheguru in SachKhand.
>>>>
We can become selfless only when we need nothing and are fully fulfilled. If we have needs, and are suppressing them, than that too is not fair. Our wishes must come true and once our wishes are quenched through Naam, we become totally
selfless, i.e. no need anymore.
>>>>>
Thanks for finally saying that in your opinion no one jaaps naam selflessly. It's done purely for selfish reasons. It other words, what you are saying is that we don't truly love Vaheguru because we have our needs and selfish motives to secure a place in SachKhand to enjoy anand forever. You do know what "selfless" means :-). I believe that it's a marag of pure prem (selfless love). Unless we truly loose ourselves in the love of Vaheguru, saying Vaheguru Vaheguru is just an empty dikhawa (show).
>>>> In this shabad too it is clearly stated that placing the dhoor of Guru Sahib’s Gur-asthaan is accepted by Vaheguru provided by japp Naam. Same way, ones who do ishnaan in Raam Daas Sarovar, get to wash away their sins and dukhs, provided they are good Gursikhs. This ishnaan works as a catalyst in purification process. >>>>
I agree with most of what you have written and the beautiful shabad you have quoted but, we were discussing the literal meaning of those first pankaties of the shabad. And, you had used the word "amrit water". I disagree. Our sins or paaps can not be washed away with taking a bath in the sarovar.
>>>> Please give a pankiti and we can discuss this then.>>>>
It's on Panna 1393 of Shri Guru Granth Sahib ji.
>>>
---------
What does Bhatt mean by "tu ta Janak raja Autaar"? Do you think Guru Sahib was Janak's avtaar?
----------
This is saviyye mehlay doojay ke and all shabads in this baani pertain to Siri Guru Angad Dev jee Maharaaj.
Professor Sahib Singh thinks that this pankiti says that O Siri Guru Angad Dev jee, you are Raja Janak Avtaar when it comes to staying oblivious of maaiya. Raja Janak was known for being oblivious of maaiya.
Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has interpreted this pankiti as O Siri Guru Angad Dev jee, you are a great Raaj-Avtaar. The word Janik according the dictionary means great.
In any case, what is the big deal about this pankiti and what are you trying to say through this? Even if it means that Siri Guru Angad Dev jee was an avtaar of Raja Janak, what are the implications of that? Don’t we all know that Baba Lehna jee was a devotee of a Devi before meeting Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj? Only after Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee placed the jyot of Guru-form of Vaheguru in Baba Lehna jee, he became Siri Guru Angad Dev jee. So if he was Raja Janak in his previous life, and became Baba Lehna jee and then Siri Guru Angad Dev jee, it does not shake any foundation of Sikh Panth.
>>>>>
You misunderstood my intention for asking the question. What I am saying is that we shouldn't take the meaning of Gurbani literally. We must understand Gurbani in the full context it's written. And, I don't know how can anyone say with a straight face that Bhatt ji doesn't mean Raja Janak in the pankati "tu ta Janak raja Autaar".
>>>> Don’t dismiss sarovars and other traditions of Sikhi because of your skepticism. We ask in our ardas every day "Siri Amritsar jee ke Darshan Ishnaan". Why do Sikhs worldwide ask for "ishnaan" of Darbar Sahib and this is the ardaas from hundred of years, not a new one. There must be some reason. If the purpose of sarovar is to just wash your body, then why
do Gursikhs beg for ishnaan of Siri Amritsar Sahib in their ardaas everyday? >>>>
Thank you for the nasihyt veer ji but who said I am dismissing sarovers and other traditions of Sikhi because of my skepticism. I am sure that you also disapprove a lot of karam kands. I thought we were talking about washing all sins with a dip in the sarover you call "amrit water". There are very simple answers to whatever you have written. Siri Amritsar Sahib is Guru ji de nagri and every sikh wants to have "Darshan Ishnaan" there, but it doesn't mean that all of your sins are going to be washed away with this ishnaan!!
>>>> I am all for scholars but we must realise their limits. If a person is learned in one field, we must not consider that person learned in all fields of Gurmat. A person may be an expert of grammar but that does not make him suitable for interpreting the mystical pankities of Gurbani that talk about stuff that ordinary persons cannot understand. Take for instance Sidh Gosth. The talk that took place in great Sidhas and Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj, is beyond the understanding of ordinary people. Scholars have interpreted the meanings but paR ke swaad nahi aunda.>>>>
It's all a matter of who we agree with and who really gets us inspired.
>>>>> I appreciate your knowledge and your keen interest in Sikhi. Guru Sahib aap jee uppar apni kirpa karan. Aap jee noo
Gursikh dee daat bakshan. >>>>
I am a gursikh and I will continue to "sikh" more and more with mere Guru Sahibaan de kirpa drishti. I do truly appreciate your kind words and asees. may Guru ji aap jee noo bhe Gursikh dee daat bakshan!
vjkk vjkf
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 23 Mar 2005
this is just a note that I am also monitoring this thread..it is just too fantastic for words...one of the best ( for me at least). Veers Kulbir Singh and J Singh ji are going along well.....I will jump in when i see soemthing i can comment on....
Jarnail Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 23 Mar 2005
J. Singh jeeo,
Dhan ho tussi! Why? Because debating with you prompted me into profound thinking.
----------
No, it doesn't refute what I am saying! My intention was to show you that it's all Vaheguru (Param-Jyot and jeev-jyot are same). "aykeh aap nahee kachh bharam".
---------
Whatever your intention was but this pankiti you quoted did in fact prove beyond doubt that Jann (bhagat) and Vaheguru do indeed merge while they are alive as this pankiti proves. Brahm meh Jann and Jann meh Parbrahm. What else does this prove? Does this not prove beyond doubt that both are merged while alive? What other merger takes place after death? Here are some shabads that I am going to quote hoping to prove that jeev and Vaheguru merge while living in this world:
Ang 633. Last shabad. Author – Mahalla 9
This shabad explains the great avastha of a Gursikh who has attained pooran avastha while living. Now just look at this whole shabad and then compare this shabad to the Beghampura Shabad. You will notice how much difference there is in Shabads explaining avastha and shabads explaining Sach Khand the dwelling of Bhagats:
JO NAR DUKH MEH DUKH NAHI MAANAE ||
SUKH SANEH AUR BHAE NAHI JAA KAE
KANCHAN MAATEE MAANAE || RAHAO|| 1||
(Such is the accomplished person, who does not feel dukh in dukh and who does not care about worldly happiness (such), moh and fear. Such person considers mittee (soil) and gold the same)
NEH USTAT NEH NINDIYA JAA KAI,
LOBH MOH ABHIMANA ||
HARKH SOG TEY RAHAI NIYARA,
NAHI MAAN APMAANA | 1 |||
(He does not indulge in worldly praises and also stays away from slandering anyone. Greediness, attachment and ego too are shed or eschewed by such person)
ASA MANSHA SAGAL TYAGAE
JAG TE RAHAE NIRAASA ||
KAAM KRODH JIH PARSAE NAHIN,
TIH GHAT BRAHM NIVASA || 2 ||
(He gives up all worldly aspirations and wishes; and stays oblivious of the jagat sansaar or world. Such person in whom Kaam and Krodh does not enter, Vaheguru has become pargat in him)
GUR KIRPA JIH NAR KO KEENI,
TIH IH JUGAT PACHHAANI ||
NANAK LEEN BHAIYO GOBIND SIYON,
JIYON PAANI SANG PAANI || 3 ||
(On whom Guru does kirpa, only that person gets to recognise and realise this kind of spiritual state. Siri Guru jee using his stamp “Nanak” concludes the shabad by saying that such person is merged in Vaheguru Gobind so deeply as water is merged in water).
J. Singh jeeo, just look at the last pankiti. It clearly talks about a complete merger and merger too that close that it is like the merger of water to water. Now you tell me what other merger takes place in Sach Khand? What is the need of any other merger after such great merger?
Also read the whole shabad and you will see that this is talking about the avastha and there is no mention of Sach Khand or other celestials planes here. In Beghampura shabad, you really have to stretch so much to get the meanings you wanted.
Please provide Gurbani reference to substantiate your theory that in this world the merger of Bhagat and Vaheguru is not complete and a second or real merger takes place after death.
------------
I have never disputed the power of naam as it's naam that connects us to our beloved Vaheguru. But, in my opinion, you are taking the meanings of some of the pankaties too literally.
------------
When the pankitis are written in a straightforward way, what is the need to use other interpretations? Why not take it literally? If Guru Sahib is asking us to japp Naam, then shouldn’t we just japp Naam , instead of wondering if we are taking this meaning literally?
If Guru Sahib is saying that there will be sadd-jeevan and that jeev-aatma will enjoy bliss forever and forever, what is the need to take some other interpretation, when the literal meaning is so straightforward?
Gurbani says that Naam Dhann goes with you in the next world. Why not believe it instead of deriving some meaning using our mann dee matt? Why should it not be taken just literally?
I agree that there are shabads where metaphors are used and in those cases only that ang of metaphor that is being enforced should be taken but where is the metaphor when Guru Sahib says that there is Beghampura? If there can be this world, why can’t there be Sach Khand, a place where we will reside forever, in happiness? Why is it not possible?
-----------
Veerji, now Devpuri is also means Sachkhand! How convenient :-). And here you want to agree with Professor Sahib Singh because it goes in your favour!! I just read this shabad last night. How does this shabad prove that Guru Sahibaan are sitting alongside Vaheguru in SachKhand. Really, the difference between you and I is that I don't always take the meaning of Gurbani quite so literally.
-----------
Why what is wrong with calling it Dev Puri. Dev means a deity and Devpuri means the land of Vaheguru. One word can have many meanings. In Gurbani Vaheguru has been called Dev. Here is an example of that:
Deva, Paahan taareealay || Raam kehat Jan kas na tharae||
(Deva Vaheguru has floated stones. Why would he not float me a paapi)
We write Gurdev and call our Guru Sahib a Dev.
You ask how this shabad proves that Guru Sahibaan is sitting alongside Vaheguru in Sach Khand. Don’t you see that this shabad clearly says that Vaheguru has seated Siri Guru Raam Daas jee on a throne in Sach Khand.
As for not taking it literally, this shabad is so obvious that even Professor Sahib Singh jee could not take any other meaning but the obvious meaning of this shabad. Please explain what else this shabad means.
And if Devpuri does not mean Sach Khand, then what else does it mean? What metaphor are you going to use here?
------------
Now you lost me here. We both agree that Vaheguru resides everywhere. I thought jeev-atma and Vaheguru are already pure. You said so yourself in your previous posts! How do they get to purest is beyond me. Is there a further purification process?
--------------
Jeev-aatma is pure but jeev is not. Jeev is not aatma alone. As we reside in this world, we are mann and Aatma and they both live in this physical body. There are further divisions of mann but that is beyond the scope of this debate. When our mann becomes jyot saroop by doing bhagti and purifying itself, then the jeev becomes pure and is ready to merge in Vaheguru.
In this world we have an astral body and a physical body. In the next world we go with our astral body that is still too asthool (thick) for Sach Khand but suitable for other planes like Dharam Khand where hisaab-kitaab of our deeds is done. For those khands, Astral body is needed and it is to us – the jeev – what physical body is to astral body.
In Sach Khand, we – the jeev – reside in our purest form i.e. our original form. I realise that my previous post was a little bit confusing but such was not my intention. By purest I mean the most original form i.e. without any bodies like physical body or astral body. In real sense haume too means to consider or realise oneself as physical or astral being. When one realises oneself to be beyond this and actually experiences it, one's haume is killed.
-------------
You know I can't agree with you here. Only Vaheguru is Sach and only He who runs and controls everything. If he wills "aapnai bhaanai la-ay samaa-ay". And, above pankati doesn't prove anything you are implying. Our nij-ghar is Vaheguru-Jyot. You used the word destroy for atma again. I never said that atma gets destroyed!
-----------
How can you not agree? The same Gurbani that told you that Vaheguru is Sach, also calls his Naam Sach and Sach Khand as Sach. Refer to the last Shabad on ang 868. The whole shabad is dedicated to Jeevatma. It starts with the following pankitis:
ACHARAJ KATHA MAHA ANOOP
PARATMA PARBRAHM KA ROOP ||
(listen to the wondrous and unrivalled story of Aatma that is the roop of Vaheguru).
The shabad tells many qualities of Jeev-atma and then declares:
NA ISS BAAP, NAHI ISS MAAIYA ||
IH APRAMPAR, HOTA AAIYA ||
(Jeevatma has no father and no mother. It is unreachable and not understandable by normal intelligence i.e. it is aprampar and has been there always (hota aiya).
Now you tell me how Aatma is not Sach? When Gurbani is saying that it is “Hota aaiya” and “Parbraham ka roop” how can you say that it is not Sach?
And you have it totally wrong about Nij Ghar. Nij Ghar is in our body and not outside of our body. Nij Ghar is the place within our body where first melaap of Vaheguru occurs. This again is a different topic from this thread.
-----------
No, it doesn't prove that. You yourself have agreed that Japji Sahib's pankaties (with Bhagats) belong to Karam Khand which, by your own admission, is like a verandah to Sachkhand. Then you said that some bhagats are in Sach Khand! Where does it say that only those Bhagats who have not reached Sach Khand are in Karam Khand, depending on their spiritual state?
------------
I have written before too that other shabads prove it beyond doubt that there are residents in Sach Khand. The Beghampura Shabad and another shabad that I will be translating soon prove it beyond doubt that there are bhagats in Sach Khand. In the meantime here are some shabads that show that Bhagats reside in the Darbar or Dargah of Vaheguru. For the most part, in Gurbani Vaheguru’s darbar has been referred to as “Dargah”. There is also a Dargah of “Dharam Rai” but it is beyond the scope of this debate.
SOOKH MEHAL, JA KE OOCH DUAARAY ||
TAA MEH VAASEH BHAGAT PYAARAY ||
(Comfortable and Sukhdaayee is the mehal of Vaheguru and lofty is his Duaara. In that Mehal of Vaheguru, the loving Bhagats reside).
I don’t understand what is the need for any other interpretation of this shabad when Guru Sahib is clearly telling us that there is a mehal of Vaheguru with ooch duaara and Bhagats resideing in there.
KOT DAAS JA KAE DARBARE ||
NIMAKH NIMAKH VASAE TIN NAALE ||
(Billions of Bhagats reside in his darbar. They reside with Vaheguru all the time and not even for a moment get away from him).
Just ponder upon the opening pankitis of the last shabad of Siri Sohila Sahib:
EEHAN KHAAT CHALO HAR LAAHA AGAE BASAN SUHELA ||
(Earn profit of Naam here and you shall always reside happily in the next world)
This shabad too proves that one gets to reside happily in the next world. If one is to merge in Vaheguru and then lose identity and consciousness, I don’t understand how he can stay happily. To be happy or to feel happiness, don’t you think the most fundamental thing is consciousness i.e. surtee? If there is no consciousness, who is going to enjoy happiness?
I asked you last time and I ask you again, that if you make a person inhale chloroform and gets unconscious, can such person enjoy or experience any dukh or such? The answer is no. When you talk about merger in Vaheguru, you for some reason also believe that one loses consciousness and identity. Who enjoys bliss then? What happens to Sadd-jeevan and anand that Guru Sahib promises us? Is your position not a violation of these promises of Guru Sahib. Please explain this.
------------
I don't know how you came to all these conclusions and, as you can see from what I have posted so far, I don't know why bhagats would be doing bhagati of Vaheguru in SachKhand.
----------
Bhagats continue to do bhagti because it is automatic there. Just as you breathe and your heart keeps beating while you live here in this world, bhagtee too is just natural there. Consciousness in Naam i.e. Naami Vaheguru is our base or default consciousness. When we are in Sach Khand, we naturally get to our base consciousness. You can call this bhagti or whatever else you want to call it.
-----------
Thanks for finally saying that in your opinion no one jaaps naam selflessly. It's done purely for selfish reasons. It other words, what you are saying is that we don't truly love Vaheguru because we have our needs and selfish motives to secure a place in SachKhand to enjoy anand forever. You do know what "selfless" means :-). I believe that it's a marag of pure prem (selfless love). Unless we truly loose ourselves in the love of Vaheguru, saying Vaheguru Vaheguru is just an empty dikhawa (show).
-----------
What dikhaawa are you talking about. If a person wants to japp Naam and do paath to get some worldly aspirations fulfilled, then it is not dikhaawa but I believe that such an act is commendable. Very soon, through Naam our worldly aspirations are quenched and then we have nothing but Vaheguru to love. Until we have our basic requirements fulfilled, we cannot do bhagti and it is perfectly fine to ask Vaheguru for basic wishes come true.
Yes, I agree with you that ultimately pure love for Vaheguru is ideal but I personally believe that with the exception of very few jeevs, such love is not possible. Love keeps growing and it takes time to reach that level of love that you are talking about.
And it is not a selfish motive to seek a spot in Sach Khand. To want to be near Vaheguru all the time cannot be selfish and even if it is selfish then it is an acceptable act of selfishness. What more would Kaiz want than being able to behold Laila till eternity and what more would Dheedo Ranjha want but just keep looking at Heer forever. Same way, what more do Bhagats want than being able to be with Vaheguru all the time in Sach Khand? How is it wrong to ask for this?
----------
I agree with most of what you have written and the beautiful shabad you have quoted but, we were discussing the literal meaning of those first pankaties of the shabad. And, you had used the word "amrit water". I disagree. Our sins or paaps can not be washed away with taking a bath in the sarovar.
-------------
It is a pure Gurmat Principle that water can absorb baani or become amrit because of baani. The whole initiation (Khanday baatay da amrit) ceremony of Khalsa is dependent on this. Punj Pyaray recite 5 baaniyan while stirring patasay in water with their khanda. This water after all 5 baniyaan is considered amrit and is administered to new Sikhs. This ceremony is not a pakhand. It is a true ceremony and this water does indeed become amrit i.e. such water that has accepted baani.
Same way, the sarovar of Ramdas Sarovar is amritmai. Just look at the name of this sarovar – Amritsar. Amrit da sar i.e. sarovar of Amrit.
I agree that just by taking dip in a sarovar, your paaps and sins cannot wash away but after following all hukams of this shabad, indeed your sins will be washed away and you can have full benefit of ishnaan of Amritsar Sahib then.
----------
You misunderstood my intention for asking the question. What I am saying is that we shouldn't take the meaning of Gurbani literally. We must understand Gurbani in the full context it's written. And, I don't know how can anyone say with a straight face that Bhatt ji doesn't mean Raja Janak in the pankati "tu ta Janak raja Autaar".
------------
I agree that we should understand Gurbani in full context but by the same token we should not avoid straightforward meanings of Gurbani just because they don’t fit in our pre-disposition or mindset. We have to follow Gurbani and have our intelligence go after Gurbani and not use Gurbani to prove our own notions and beliefs.
I have no qualms over accepting that Siri Guru Angad Dev jee was an avatar of Raja Janak. If we can accept that Siri Guru Angad Dev jee was a devotee of Devi before becoming a Sikh of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee then it is not a big deal to accept that Siri Guru jee was Raja Janak in his previous life. What matters to us is his life in this jaama, not his previous one.
I strongly disagree that we should not take the meaning of Gurbani literally. Where there is no metaphor used and where Guru Sahib is telling us something straightforward, we should accept it literally.
-----------
There are very simple answers to whatever you have written. Siri Amritsar Sahib is Guru ji de nagri and every sikh wants to have "Darshan Ishnaan" there, but it doesn't mean that all of your sins are going to be washed away with this ishnaan!!
----------
All your sins do get washed away if you fulfill other conditions of the shabad. Verily they do.
But pray tell me that if there is no spiritual benefit of doing ishnaan in Siri Harmandir Sahib sarovar, why is the whole Sikh Jagat begging before Guru Sahib everyday for Ishnaan of Amritsar Sahib? Darshan I can understand but why ishnaan? What is so important about it?
You may be aware that thousands of Gursikhs have given their life to just do ishnaan in Amritsar Sahib. There used to be permanent security outside Darbar Sahib in the 1700s and ishnaan there was prohibited. Many Gursikhs used to dash in there to do ishnaan and got killed as they came out. What was so great of doing ishnaan there?
I have felt that you have belittled the importance of Sarovars by your last couple of posts. These are not mere rituals as many modern thinking people believe. Ishnaan of sarovars related to Guru Sahib are all satt satt. No doubt about that. I personally never had the kind of belief I have today. All this happened because of my personal experiences at sarovars of Guru Sahib. Oh! What to write on the greatness of those places where Guru Sahib has placed his charan kamal.
----------
may Guru ji aap jee noo bhe Gursikh dee daat bakshan!
---------
Shukar hai tuhaadi asees da.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Nihaal Singh · 23 Mar 2005
j. Singh bhai sahib jee. my papa is right.
Nihaal Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
khalistani · 23 Mar 2005
hahahahahahahahahhaah
wat a safe kid
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
J Singh · 24 Mar 2005
Nihaal Singh ji, your papa is not only right, he is also a great Gursikh who is doing nishkaam sewa through Tapoban Sahib and I am sure through many other means. We are both proud of him :-).
>>>> Dhan ho tussi! Why? Because debating with you prompted me into profound thinking.>>>>
I thought we were just having a Gurbani Vichaar :-). I am glad to have prompted you into profound thinking.
>>>>
Whatever your intention was but this pankiti you quoted did in fact prove beyond doubt that Jann (bhagat) and Vaheguru do indeed merge while they are alive as this pankiti proves. Brahm meh Jann and Jann meh Parbrahm. What else does this prove? Does this not prove beyond doubt that both are merged while alive? What other merger takes place after death?
>>>>>
I thought I had answered this. No, it doesn't prove beyond any doubt what we are "debating" about. I am aware that it does for your with a doubt but not me. There are many shabads in Gurbani that state it's Vaheguru who speaks through and sees through us. What is atma other than an ansh of Parmatama! You read Sukhmani Sahib everyday. There are a number of shabads that go even beyond this. For example "Naanak saadh parabh bhayd na bhaa-ee".
>>>>>
NANAK LEEN BHAIYO GOBIND SIYON,
JIYON PAANI SANG PAANI || 3 ||
J. Singh jeeo, just look at the last pankiti. It clearly talks about a complete merger and merger too that close that it is like the merger of water to water. Now you tell me what other merger takes place in Sach Khand? What is the need of any other merger after such great merger?
>>>>>
Kulbir Veer ji, there are a lot more pankaties that say how gursikhs, sants, bhagats, brahmgianies are "leen" with Gobind. If you remember, it was I who had used the word "ik-mik" on this thread. There is no doubt about that. Our only difference of opinion has been our understanding of what happens when jeev-atma leaves this juni and "jyoti jyot samma". I have already told you what I mean by merger after a jeet atma leaves this juni to be one with Vaheguru. I know, with your explanation there is no need of any other "merger" after this merger. You are saying that jeev-atma stays alive, doesn't not loose it's own identity and "self" consciousness when it "jyoti jyot samma" in Veheguru-Jyot after leaving this juni. It stays in Vaheguru but separate from Param-Consciousness and yet stays in anand doing bhagati forever and ever (to eternity) in SachKhand. And, by my understanding (I am sure you know it by now!), jeev-atma goes back into it's mool origion PARAMATMA where it had originated from (after it's 84 is cut and it "jyoti jyot samma"). 'jis te opajiya tis mahi samanah". At that point, it's not separate from Vaheguru at all. It BECOMES HIM and is in Param-Anand forever. As long as jeev-aatma is in human form (still in one of the 84 lakh juni), it has it's own identity like we all do. At least to me , being ONE with the beloved Vaheguru is NOT destroying our "self", on the contrary, it's the ultimate anand!!
>>>> When the pankitis are written in a straightforward way, what is the need to use other interpretations? Why not take it literally? If Guru Sahib is asking us to japp Naam, then shouldn’t we just japp Naam , instead of wondering if we are taking this meaning literally?>>>>
You are playing with words here :-). All I am saying is that we should understand baani in the context it's written. We know Bhatts are praising Guru Sahibaan one by one, but when you read their baani closely, you get the feeling ( I do) that they aren't just talking about Guru Sahibaan in this human form, they are also praising Vaheguru that they "see" in Guru Sahibaan. How about "tithae jodh mahabal soor". It doesn't mean that all of the jodhey, mahabali and soormey are going to end up in Karam Khand.
Guru Sahib says, "paarbarahm saadh ridh basai" but it's it also true that "ghat ghat pooran barahm pargaas". How about "Saadh kai sang sabh kul uDhaarai, saadhsang saajan meet kutamb nistaarai". Don't get me wrong, I do understand what these pankatian mean but not by taking them literally. We can't just interpret that with the sangat of saadh, one's kul, saajan, meet and kutamb will all get uDhaar. There are numerous panakatian that we can just run with if we don't take them in the full
Gurbani context they are written it.
>>>>
You ask how this shabad proves that Guru Sahibaan is sitting alongside Vaheguru in Sach Khand. Don't you see that this shabad clearly says that Vaheguru has seated Siri Guru Raam Daas jee on a throne in Sach Khand.
As for not taking it literally, this shabad is so obvious that even Professor Sahib Singh jee could not take any other meaning but the obvious meaning of this shabad. Please explain what else this shabad means.
And if Devpuri does not mean Sach Khand, then what else does it mean? What metaphor are you going to use here?
>>>>>
Relax veer ji, I am not going to use any metaphor. The shabad talks about Guru ji's akaal-chalanah beautifully. I am not going to say what Devpuri means and what it doesn't mean either. We will just be spinning our heels. You are trying to prove with these panaktian that all ten Guru Sahibaan is sitting alongside Vaheguru in Sach Khand (for eternity, forever and ever) and I just don't agree with your here.
>>>>
In Sach Khand, we – the jeev – reside in our purest form i.e. our original form. I realize that my previous post was a little bit confusing but such was not my intention. By purest I mean the most original form i.e. without any bodies like physical body or astral body. In real sense haume too means to consider or realize oneself as physical or astral being. When one realises oneself to be beyond this and actually experiences it, one's haume is killed.
>>>>>
I believe atma and Paramatma are both "nirgun" (pure).
>>>>>
How can you not agree? The same Gurbani that told you that Vaheguru is Sach, also calls his Naam Sach and Sach Khand as Sach. Refer to the last Shabad on ang 868. The whole shabad is dedicated to Jeevatma. It starts with the following pankitis:
ACHARAJ KATHA MAHA ANOOP
PARATMA PARBRAHM KA ROOP ||
(listen to the wondrous and unrivalled story of Aatma that is the roop of Vaheguru).
The shabad tells many qualities of Jeev-atma and then declares:
NA ISS BAAP, NAHI ISS MAAIYA ||
IH APRAMPAR, HOTA AAIYA ||
(Jeevatma has no father and no mother. It is unreachable and not understandable by normal intelligence i.e. it is aprampar and
has been there always (hota aiya).
Now you tell me how Aatma is not Sach? When Gurbani is saying that it is “Hota aaiya” and “Parbraham ka roop” how can you say that it is not Sach?
>>>>
Haven't I been saying in all these posts that atma is indeed an ansh of Parmatma like a kiran is to suraj and like water is to ocean. You can chop it or twist it any which way you want but " paratma parbrahm ka roop". Atma is part of Parmatma, Parmatma who is SUCH and doer of this whole khel and more. "aapan khayl aap varteejaa, naanak karnaihaar na doojaa"
>>>>
And you have it totally wrong about Nij Ghar. Nij Ghar is in our body and not outside of our body. Nij Ghar is the place within our body where first melaap of Vaheguru occurs. This again is a different topic from this thread.
>>>>
NO, I don't have it totally wrong jeer ji. You, perhaps, didn't understand me. Atma's nij ghar is Parmatma. I also understand that everything is within us and not outside.
>>>>
-----------
No, it doesn't prove that. You yourself have agreed that Japji Sahib's pankaties (with Bhagats) belong to Karam Khand which, by your own admission, is like a verandah to Sachkhand. Then you said that some bhagats are in Sach Khand! Where does it say that only those Bhagats who have not reached Sach Khand are in Karam Khand, depending on their spiritual state?
------------
I have written before too that other shabads prove it beyond doubt that there are residents in Sach Khand. The Beghampura Shabad and another shabad that I will be translating soon prove it beyond doubt that there are bhagats in Sach Khand.
>>>>
I think we have already discussed this enough times. We can keep on cranking the towel but I don't expect to extract any more water out of it. "hukmay upjai hukam samaavai"
>>>>>>
This shabad too proves that one gets to reside happily in the next world. If one is to merge in Vaheguru and then lose identity and consciousness, I don’t understand how he can stay happily. To be happy or to feel happiness, don’t you think the most fundamental thing is consciousness i.e. surtee? If there is no consciousness, who is going to enjoy happiness?
>>>>>>
Don't you think Vaheguru has parm consciousness? Don't you know atma doesn't experience "happiness and sorrow"? You said so yourself in one of your earlier post! Gurbani is never ever in contradiction. It's our understanding "as a whole" that fails us. Once atma gets merged (samma) in Parmatma, it's in ultimate anand. Now, call it whatever you may.
>>>>
I asked you last time and I ask you again, that if you make a person inhale chloroform and gets unconscious, can such person enjoy or experience any dukh or such? The answer is no. When you talk about merger in Vaheguru, you for some reason also believe that one loses consciousness and identity. Who enjoys bliss then? What happens to Sadd-jeevan and anand that Guru Sahib promises us? Is your position not a violation of these promises of Guru Sahib. Please explain this.
>>>>>
There is no violation, just a difference of understanding. Atma has become part of Parmatma and stays in bliss. Sadd-jeevan is only with Vaheguru. In sunn-samadhi, He was the only one who contemplated everything. Didn't He? And, when a person inhale chloroform, the signal doesn't go to the brain. No communication to the nervous system, no feeling of pain! :-).
>>>>
Bhagats continue to do bhagti because it is automatic there. Just as you breathe and your heart keeps beating while you live here in this world, bhagtee too is just natural there. Consciousness in Naam i.e. Naami Vaheguru is our base or default consciousness. When we are in Sach Khand, we naturally get to our base consciousness. You can call this bhagti or whatever else you want to call it.
>>>>
You can see my understanding about this from the above responses. Besides, I think we have been through this already. In my mind, you are contradicting yourself. On one hand, you agree that rehit is an absolute MUST here in this World. No one is exempt from the rehit. Even Guru Gobind Singh ji took Amrit from Panj Pyaare. We must jaap naam, do panj baaniyan da paath at the minimum and follow full sikhi rehit. On the other hand, you are saying that bhagats continue to do bhagti because it is automatic there in Sach Khand. Just as you breathe and your heart keeps beating while you live here in this world, bhagtee too is just natural there. Don't you see the difference between the two.
>>>>
-----------
Thanks for finally saying that in your opinion no one jaaps naam selflessly. It's done purely for selfish reasons. It other words, what you are saying is that we don't truly love Vaheguru because we have our needs and selfish motives to secure a place in SachKhand to enjoy anand forever. You do know what "selfless" means :-). I believe that it's a marag of pure prem (selfless love). Unless we truly loose ourselves in the love of Vaheguru, saying Vaheguru Vaheguru is just an empty dikhawa (show).
-----------
What dikhaawa are you talking about. If a person wants to japp Naam and do paath to get some worldly aspirations fulfilled, then it is not dikhaawa but I believe that such an act is commendable. Very soon, through Naam our worldly aspirations are quenched and then we have nothing but Vaheguru to love. Until we have our basic requirements fulfilled, we cannot do bhagti and it is perfectly fine to ask Vaheguru for basic wishes come true.
Yes, I agree with you that ultimately pure love for Vaheguru is ideal but I personally believe that with the exception of very few jeevs, such love is not possible. Love keeps growing and it takes time to reach that level of love that you are talking about.
And it is not a selfish motive to seek a spot in Sach Khand. To want to be near Vaheguru all the time cannot be selfish and even if it is selfish then it is an acceptable act of selfishness. What more would Kaiz want than being able to behold Laila till eternity and what more would Dheedo Ranjha want but just keep looking at Heer forever. Same way, what more do Bhagats
want than being able to be with Vaheguru all the time in Sach Khand? How is it wrong to ask for this?
>>>>>>
Again, we both have our understanding on this issue. I respect your understanding and will not make any further comments here.
>>>>
It is a pure Gurmat Principle that water can absorb baani or become amrit because of baani. The whole initiation (Khanday baatay da amrit) ceremony of Khalsa is dependent on this. Punj Pyaray recite 5 baaniyan while stirring patasay in water with their khanda. This water after all 5 baniyaan is considered amrit and is administered to new Sikhs. This ceremony is not a
pakhand. It is a true ceremony and this water does indeed become amrit i.e. such water that has accepted baani.
Same way, the sarovar of Ramdas Sarovar is amritmai. Just look at the name of this sarovar – Amritsar. Amrit da sar i.e. sarovar of Amrit.
>>>>
Pressing a very emotional button here, aren't we :-). Being a singh, how can and why would I say that Khanday Baatay da Amrit is a pakhand? You are getting a little carried away here. Naam is supreme and Guru ji gave us the the bidhi (ceremony) to get this naam. Now, pls. answer this question: Is it accordance to Gurmatt to carry this "amrit water" (water that has become amrit by accepting baani for over 400 years) from Ramdas Sarovar in bottles to cure our dukhs, kashts and sins? Of course we need to naam jaap along with the amrit water. As you would agree, not everyone has access and the resources to get to the sarover.
>>>>> I have no qualms over accepting that Siri Guru Angad Dev jee was an avatar of Raja Janak. >>>>>
I have read your posts on some of the other topics. Don't you believe that Guru Sahibaan are the only true (sat) Gurus (one jyot) of all lok, parlok, khands and brehmands. They were sent directly by Vaheguru to do our udhaar. For example, didn't you say that it was "Guru Sahib" who save the laaj (honor) od Panchali in Raaj Sabha? I can find more if you like. Now your are saying, "I have no qualms over accepting that Siri Guru Angad Dev jee was an avatar of Raja Janak".
>>>>> I have felt that you have belittled the importance of Sarovars by your last couple of posts. >>>>>
I don't thing I have belittled the importance of sarovars. All I said was that Siri Amritsar Sahib is Guru ji de Nagri and every sikh wants to ave "Darshan Ishnaan" there, but it doesn't mean that all of your sins are going to be washed away with this ishnaan!!
>>>>>
You may be aware that thousands of Gursikhs have given their life to just do ishnaan in Amritsar Sahib. There used to be permanent security outside Darbar Sahib in the 1700s and ishnaan there was prohibited. Many Gursikhs used to dash in there to do ishnaan and got killed as they came out. What was so great of doing ishnaan there?
>>>>>
I am fully aware of the hard times our Qaum went through. In many ways, it's because of their qurbaniya that we are sitting here are discussing Gurbani. If someone prohibits us from seeing our guru de nagri, we will be flocking there to dare them. Singhs don't fear anyone but Vaheguru.
Veer ji, I am no scholor but just a nimmanah sikh. I wish I more time to write but i must leave now. Galtian maaf as some of it is written in haste.
vjkk vjkf
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulwinder Singh · 25 Mar 2005
Kulbir Singh Ji
You have written "Please provide Gurbani reference to substantiate your theory that in this world the merger of Bhagat and Vaheguru is not complete and a second or real merger takes place after death."
Remember vir Ji
Jis Marnea te Jag Derea
Merea Maren Anand Mernea te hi Pie'a Purna Paramanad.
Kindly explain the above vir Kulbir Singh Ji,
You have also written "If Guru Sahib is asking us to japp Naam, then
shouldn't we just japp Naam , instead of wondering if we are taking this meaning literally?"
The real meaning of Jap Nam is not purely reciting HIS NAME,
But rembering him in order to get guidance to see his Hukam in daily life and doing the right things. Remembering him is just a first step, do not just get stuck on the reciting bit. Other wise reciting and doing the sins is possible like
“ Banaras De Thug. “
You are also saying "Gurbani says that Naam Dhann goes with you in the next world. Why not believe it instead of deriving some meaning using our mann dee matt? Why should it not be taken just literally?"
Vir kulbir Singh Ji Gurubani is mainly for Vichar not just Ucharan . rather then Ucharan A Sikh must try to understand what Guru Ji Saying in the Shabad.
You are also saying “You ask how this shabad proves that Guru Sahibaan is sitting alongside Vaheguru in Sach Khand. Don’t you see that this shabad clearly says that Vaheguru has seated Siri Guru Raam Daas jee on a throne in Sach Khand.”
Seated on a Thorn or not is real point the real point is that Vaheguru is accepting the will of Shri Guru Raam Dass Jee as Guru Ji want.what else putting somebody on the thorn mean?
Vir Ji explain, Kabir Sahib Ji saying
Ab tu Jaie Charae Singhasan Milea hai Sarang Pani Ram Kabira………. Jo Pani Sang Pani.
Now KAbir Ji in his life time saying he has sat on the Thorne, and also merged, now consider your stand, either you can merge or sit with GOD you consider both be two diffrent things, Kabir Ji is saying that being both is perfectly OK and he has done that even in his lifetime on earth. If Kabir Ji was talking about some real physical Thorne or Darbar then how come he physical went their and sat on it, Vir Ji this Thorne is just acceptance of will of Kabir Ji in a totally free way by GOD so Kabir Sahib Ji are like on the Thorne as what ever Kabir Sahib Ji want GOD is doing it or there is no difference at all between the will of Kabir Sahib and GOD.
You are also saying “I asked you last time and I ask you again, that if you make a person inhale chloroform and gets unconscious, can such person enjoy or experience any dukh or such? The answer is no. When you talk about merger in Vaheguru, you for some reason also believe that one loses consciousness and identity. Who enjoys bliss then? What happens to Sadd-jeevan and anand that Guru Sahib promises us? Is your position not a violation of these promises of Guru Sahib. Please explain this.”
Vir Ji you are talking about losing worldly conscious, have you never heard of people who faint ( like inhaling chloroform) then they explain that they had amazing experience of seeing things which some claim to be experience of after life, I am not saying that their experience is of GOD or anything, but at least on thing is clear that even after becoming unconscious they carried on having experience of some sort, So it is a fact that even after being in medically unconscious state you can be having feelings, emotions and experiences.
Kulbir Singh Ji I am neither against your argument nor for it, For me the Bliss “ Anand “ is a state where GOD does not Question your will and you do not want anything but his will, HE is so BIG that every kind of imagination is possible, so what ever a bhagat want GOD just make it perfect, and mostly Bhagats do not want anything but being part of HIM in any case.
I give you example from a movie “A Space Odyssey” in which the main character when contact Aliens, Aliens send the interface to speak with this Girl as a father of that girl, and they chose this interface purely because it is easy for this girl to talk to her father ( which she lost in her early teens).Similarly GOD can have many interface with his Bhagats or anybody else he want, and all kind of imagination can come true but remember only HE is the real everything else is his creation and pleasure of game.
If somebody have a choice of just being equal to something big or becoming big I think they will chose to be JUST THAT BIG rather then equalent. Also why have different numbers of Bhagats as individuals rather then Just ONE HIM, it is also true that
“ Anek hai phir Eak hai “
HE is Many but then again he is ONE.
This Vichar thread is interesting in seeing how different people interpret different Shabads according to our own understanding, I believe you both are right in seeing what you see, I am impressed with Vir J Singh’s attempts and understanding and love his humbleness. I will say that the destination is not what GOD has made his setup in Sach Khand It also what Bhagat want and all in all Bhagats want to accept his will and Just want to be leen in him for ever, why because the Pain of being away from him even “Chin Mater” Microscopic far is very far for any True Bhagat.
That is my understanding. Vichar on all Gurubani is absolutely crucial, essential and compulsory requirement for a Sikh as a student we all must understand what our Guru Ji is saying and to see HIS Hukam. But in order to get closer to HIM LOVE is absolutely requirement, Gurubani show us the way to him, explain his Character, explain how we can enlighten yourself and all these things are attempt to make us see HIS Greatness so we fall in LOVE with only HIM, as Falling in love with somebody after understanding them is far more stronger and right way of falling in love rather then Just Love at first sight, which I do not think is impossible but in my eyes knowing and falling in love is better.
I also believe that understanding text is one thing, understanding the wishes of the Guru is another, To understand Gurubani there are many ways you can be enlighten, But the most simple way is to known the history, ambitions, projects and services of Guru Sahiban and if that make you fall in love with Guru Sahiban then read the Guru Granth Sahib ji( although reading Gurubani is good anyway) and seeing how Guru Ji giving us direction to make easy for us to be ONE with GOD. Otherwise just keep on learning text for the sake of it without Love does not bring the real fruit which a real Bhagat want.
Also J. Singh’s name to me is Jaspreet Singh Ji.
Sorry when I write Punjabi ( Shabads) in English most of the time it does look strange.
A big Hug to both of these Virs from me.
Kulbir Singh Ji I am siding with Vir J.Singh Ji as his explanation match my own understanding closely. Also I am bit cheeky and I do like putting bit extra hard question to you as you are very well read and that is a well deserved compliment to you.
Bul Chuk Maf.
Aap Ji da Murakh
Kulwinder Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 25 Mar 2005
One
----------
I thought I had answered this. No, it doesn't prove beyond any doubt what we are "debating" about. I am aware that it does for your with a doubt but not me. There are many shabads in Gurbani that state it's Vaheguru who speaks through and sees through us. What is atma other than an ansh of Parmatama! You read Sukhmani Sahib everyday. There are a number of shabads that go even beyond this. For example "Naanak saadh parabh bhayd na bhaa-ee".
----------
I think this is a very important part of our discussion and must be discussed more profoundly than this. Gurmat preaches that everything that one wants spiritually is attainable while living and such promises that something will happen after death are not acceptable. To whatever spiritual avastha a Gursikh reaches while living, that is where one gets after death. After death of this body, no spiritual elevation can take place. This is why Guru Sahib has written that to this human body even devtay beg for (Iss dehi to simraye dev). Because spiritual elevation is possible only in this human dehi.
“Brahm meh jan, jan meh Paarbraham” and “Nanak Leen bhaiyo Gobind sang, jiyon paani sang paani” prove beyond doubt that complete merger takes place while living. Bhagat Naamdev sensing this wailed out to Vaheguru:
Mooye hooye jo mukat dehogay, mukat na jaanae koila ||
(If you give me mukti after death, what is point of it. I need it while living).
What more merger can happen after death than “paani sang paani”? I feel that you have not addressed this point properly. You have repeated your previous position that [i]“As long as jeev-aatma is in human form (still in one of the 84 lakh juni), it has it's own identity like we all do.”[/i]
Your point is that because of the maanas dehi it cannot have complete merger but Gurbani says that don’t look at the maanas dehi and think that there is any difference between Bhagat and Vaheguru. From inside they are one. Here is the pankiti to prove that:
HAR KA SEWAK, SO HAR JEHA ||
BHED NA JAANO MAANAS DEHA ||
JIYON JAL TARANG UTHEY BAHU BHANTI
PHIR SALALE SALAL SMAINDA ||
In this above shabad Guru Sahib clearly says that the just like waves and ocean are one, same way Bhagat and Vaheguru are same. Don’t be mislead by the Maanas Deha and think that they are different. They are one.
This shabad shows me that while living bhagat and Vaheguru attain complete merger.
You say that the complete merger does not take place because of the maanas dehi but Gurbani says that they are merged like water to water (Paani sang paani). When our consciousness is entangled in the trai-gunni maaiya, then we are part of this world but once after Naam abhyaas one gets beyond trai-gunni maaiya and attains Vaheguru, maanas dehi is no hindrance in the merger.
So great is the merger between Bhagat and Vaheguru that Bhatts had to say, “Gur Arjun Partakh Har” i.e. Guru Arjun Dev jee is Saakshaat Vaheguru. They were able to view the merger of Guru Sahib and Vaheguru and had to say that there is no difference between Guru Sahib and Vaheguru. They were totally one.
Two
You write that “It BECOMES HIM and is in Param-Anand forever.” Think of it Veer J. Singh jeeo. Don’t you think that one needs to be have surtee to be in Parmanand (ultimate bliss)? This was my whole purpose of giving you the example of chloroform. If you inhale chloroform and then you are made view some entertainment, can you really enjoy it? You will not even have any recollection of it.
Same way, if you don’t have surtee or consciousness, how can you enjoy the Parmanand you are talking about?
I just take this simple logical approach that you cannot enjoy bliss if you are not conscious. And I don’t understand why you are insisting that bhagats lose consciousness after death. Why insist on it and where does it say in Gurbani that they lose consciousness?
You remind me of a shayer of Ghalib:
Ishrat-e-kathra hai Dariya me fanaah ho jaana ||
Darad ka hadd se guzarna hai davaa ho jaana ||
In the first line Ghalib is writing the famous Sufi khyaal that Ishrat-e-Kathra (top wish of a drop of water) is to get destroyed in the river. Where in Gurbani does it say that get Fanaah in the Dariya of Vaheguru?
Three
-----------
We know Bhatts are praising Guru Sahibaan one by one, but when you read their baani closely, you get the feeling ( I do) that they aren't just talking about Guru Sahibaan in this human form, they are also praising Vaheguru that they "see" in Guru Sahibaan.
------------
Of course. Greatness of our Guru Sahibaan is because Vaheguru gave them this greatness. When Vaheguru declared that the kingdom of Guru Nanak Dev jee is eternal, he gave great vadiaayee to Guru Sahib:
SIRI GURU RAAJ ABICHAL ATTAL, AAD PURAK FURMAAIYO ||
(The kingdom of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj is eternal and Attal; so said the Aad Purakh Vaheguru)’
----------
How about "tithae jodh mahabal soor". It doesn't mean that all of the jodhey, mahabali and soormey are going to end up in Karam Khand.
----------
This means exactly what it says. The Jodhay and Mahabalee Soormay who were able to wage war against 5 bikaars and maaiya and win this war, come to this Karam Khand. Guru Sahib in Gurbani has written at many places that real warriors are who fight their 5 bikaars and who are coloured in divine colours of Naam:
JA KO HAR RANG LAAGO ISS JUGG MEH, SO KAHIYAT HAI SOORA ||
----------
Guru Sahib says, "paarbarahm saadh ridh basai" but it's it also true that "ghat ghat pooran barahm pargaas".
----------
I don’t know what you are trying to make out of this. It looks like you are saying that there seems to be a contradiction in these two pankitis. But such is not the case.
In the case of former, it means that Vaheguru has become pargat in a Saadh and in latter case it means that in everyone, Vaheguru hee Vaheguru hai i.e. he alone pervades in everything.
Vaheguru is in KPS Gill and other tyrants but he is also in Mahapurakhs like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee. The difference is that in KPS’s case, Vaheguru is there but KPS has not realised him. Vaheguru is in dogs and cats too but they don’t realise it. On the other hand, Gurmukhs who realise him, have him pargat inside them.
The difference lies in the word “Hirda” and “Ghat”. Ghat means whole of body whereas Hirda is a particular place where Vaheguru becomes pargat.
----------
How about "Saadh kai sang sabh kul uDhaarai, saadhsang saajan meet kutamb nistaarai". Don't get me wrong, I do understand what these pankatian mean but not by taking them literally. We can't just interpret that with the sangat of saadh, one's kul, saajan, meet and kutamb will all get uDhaar. There are numerous panakatian that we can just run with if we don't take them in the full
Gurbani context they are written it.
---------
I have not one iota of doubt that this pankiti comes out true. The whole of kutamb and friends of Saadh get delivered, but not as they are today. In due time, Vaheguru does kirpa on them and they meet the true Guru – Guru Nanak Dev jee – and get delivered. But just by being the relative of a Saadh Jan, their process of deliverance starts.
----------
Relax veer ji, I am not going to use any metaphor. The shabad talks about Guru ji's akaal-chalanah beautifully. I am not going to say what Devpuri means and what it doesn't mean either. We will just be spinning our heels. You are trying to prove with these panaktian that all ten Guru Sahibaan is sitting alongside Vaheguru in Sach Khand (for eternity, forever and ever) and I just don't agree with your here.
----------
Since we are discussing this, it is not enough for you to say that you don’t agree. Please explain what else is the meaning of this pankiti. It is written clearly that Vaheguru jee gave the throne to Siri Guru Raamdaas jee Maharaaj in Devpuri. This proves that there is a throne in Devpuri.
---------
I believe atma and Paramatma are both "nirgun" (pure).
--------
Who are you? Aatma or Mann or Both. Who is this person debating with me? Aatma or Mann? Who is J. Singh? Do you believe J. Singh will get Fanaah one day?
----------
Haven't I been saying in all these posts that atma is indeed an ansh of Parmatma like a kiran is to suraj and like water is to ocean. You can chop it or twist it any which way you want but " paratma parbrahm ka roop". Atma is part of Parmatma, Parmatma who is SUCH and doer of this whole khel and more. "aapan khayl aap varteejaa, naanak karnaihaar na doojaa"
-----------
My point was that aatma never dies. If it did not die when it was separate from Vaheguru in this world, then how can it die when it is merged? Gurbani clearly says that aatma is “hota aaiya” i.e. has always been there. This clearly proves the independent haste of aatma.
--------
NO, I don't have it totally wrong jeer ji. You, perhaps, didn't understand me. Atma's nij ghar is Parmatma. I also understand that everything is within us and not outside.
----------
Not at a single place in Gurbani (in my opinion) has Nij Ghar come in the meanings of Parmatma. Gurbani does not interpret Nij Ghar as Vaheguru. Please show a single pankiti that says that Nij Ghar means Vaheguru.
----------------------
>>>>>>
This shabad too proves that one gets to reside happily in the next world. If one is to merge in Vaheguru and then lose identity and consciousness, I don’t understand how he can stay happily. To be happy or to feel happiness, don’t you think the most fundamental thing is consciousness i.e. surtee? If there is no consciousness, who is going to enjoy happiness?
>>>>>>
Don't you think Vaheguru has parm consciousness? Don't you know atma doesn't experience "happiness and sorrow"? You said so yourself in one of your earlier post! Gurbani is never ever in contradiction. It's our understanding "as a whole" that fails us. Once atma gets merged (samma) in Parmatma, it's in ultimate anand. Now, call it whatever you may.
----------------------
Just read the last couple of sentences of your paragraph quoted above. You say that when aatma gets merged in Vaheguru it is ultimate anand. But anand for who? Vaheguru or Aatma? My position is that Vaheguru is already in Anand. Nothing special if after merger this anand continues for Vaheguru. Anand is also for jeev-aatma who gets merged in Vaheguru and this anand can only happen if Jeev-aatma has surtee.
You ask that aatma does not experience happiness and sorrow, then how is it experiencing Anand. My position is that it is our consciousness or our Mann, that becomes jyot saroop after merging with aatma, that gets anand. We are not just aatma. We are more than Aatma.
Yeh jo bol raha hai, kabhi nahi marta.
-------------------
>>>>
I asked you last time and I ask you again, that if you make a person inhale chloroform and gets unconscious, can such person enjoy or experience any dukh or such? The answer is no. When you talk about merger in Vaheguru, you for some reason also believe that one loses consciousness and identity. Who enjoys bliss then? What happens to Sadd-jeevan and anand that Guru Sahib promises us? Is your position not a violation of these promises of Guru Sahib. Please explain this.
>>>>>
There is no violation, just a difference of understanding. Atma has become part of Parmatma and stays in bliss. Sadd-jeevan is only with Vaheguru. In sunn-samadhi, He was the only one who contemplated everything. Didn't He? And, when a person inhale chloroform, the signal doesn't go to the brain. No communication to the nervous system, no feeling of pain! :-).
-------------------
I beg for maazrat but please read what you are writing. You write “[i]Atma has become part of Parmatma and stays in bliss. Sadd-jeevan is only with Vaheguru.” [/i]
First you were saying that aatma experiences no happiness or sorrow but now you say that it is in bliss. And then you say that sadd-jeevan is with Vaheguru only. The word “with” implies that aatma is still conscious and so does your assertion that it is in bliss.
I was saying that just as a person in chloroform cannot feel any dukh or such, same way a jeev-aatma that has lost consciousness cannot have any anand. Anand can only be felt by surtee or consciousness. So what do you mean here in the quote above?
-------------------
>>>>
Bhagats continue to do bhagti because it is automatic there. Just as you breathe and your heart keeps beating while you live here in this world, bhagtee too is just natural there. Consciousness in Naam i.e. Naami Vaheguru is our base or default consciousness. When we are in Sach Khand, we naturally get to our base consciousness. You can call this bhagti or whatever else you want to call it.
>>>>
You can see my understanding about this from the above responses. Besides, I think we have been through this already. In my mind, you are contradicting yourself. On one hand, you agree that rehit is an absolute MUST here in this World. No one is exempt from the rehit. Even Guru Gobind Singh ji took Amrit from Panj Pyaare. We must jaap naam, do panj baaniyan da paath at the minimum and follow full sikhi rehit. On the other hand, you are saying that bhagats continue to do bhagti because it is automatic there in Sach Khand. Just as you breathe and your heart keeps beating while you live here in this world, bhagtee too is just natural there. Don't you see the difference between the two.
------------------
I have not understood your analogy here. What are you trying to say? How have I made any contradiction above? What are you trying to come at?
How does insisting that we should follow rehit here contradict with my assertion that Bhagtee is automatic in Sach Khand. Mainu samajh nahi aahee. Talib-e-maazrat jeeo.
-----------------
>>>>
It is a pure Gurmat Principle that water can absorb baani or become amrit because of baani. The whole initiation (Khanday baatay da amrit) ceremony of Khalsa is dependent on this. Punj Pyaray recite 5 baaniyan while stirring patasay in water with their khanda. This water after all 5 baniyaan is considered amrit and is administered to new Sikhs. This ceremony is not a
pakhand. It is a true ceremony and this water does indeed become amrit i.e. such water that has accepted baani.
Same way, the sarovar of Ramdas Sarovar is amritmai. Just look at the name of this sarovar – Amritsar. Amrit da sar i.e. sarovar of Amrit.
>>>>
Pressing a very emotional button here, aren't we :-). Being a singh, how can and why would I say that Khanday Baatay da Amrit is a pakhand? You are getting a little carried away here. Naam is supreme and Guru ji gave us the the bidhi (ceremony) to get this naam. Now, pls. answer this question: Is it accordance to Gurmatt to carry this "amrit water" (water that has become amrit by accepting baani for over 400 years) from Ramdas Sarovar in bottles to cure our dukhs, kashts and sins? Of course we need to naam jaap along with the amrit water. As you would agree, not everyone has access and the resources to get to the sarover.
-----------------
Please don’t avoid this issue now. You started it and you should go all the way with it. My position is that water can retain the affect of Gurbani and Naam and this is how Amrit is prepared. The foundation of Sikhi is standing on it. The shabad of “Jithay jaaye bahae mera Satguru” proves that any place where our Guru Sahib sets his charan, becomes pure.
Jithay baaba payer dharai, pooja aasan thaapan soya ||
(Where ever Baba Nanak set his charan, that place becomes worthy of reverence)
If Khanda da amrit can retain baani, then Raamdaas Sarovar can too. And there is nothing wrong in filling this water in bottles. It is all Satt Satt. Only those on whom Guru Sahib does kirpa have faith on Guru Sahib’s words.
Raamdaas Sarovar’s water is pavitter because firstly Guru Sahib set his charan there and secondly because of Baani da Parvaah there. Verily, it is capable of curing diseases and ridding sins if other basic hukams are followed along with it. If other hukams are not followed then even Naam and Gurbani don’t do any effect. Raamdaas Sarovar’s paani is amrit. So in my opinion, it is perfectly in accordance to Gurmat to bring amritmai water of Raamdaas Sarovar in bottles.
----------------
>>>>> I have no qualms over accepting that Siri Guru Angad Dev jee was an avatar of Raja Janak. >>>>>
I have read your posts on some of the other topics. Don't you believe that Guru Sahibaan are the only true (sat) Gurus (one jyot) of all lok, parlok, khands and brehmands. They were sent directly by Vaheguru to do our udhaar. For example, didn't you say that it was "Guru Sahib" who save the laaj (honor) od Panchali in Raaj Sabha? I can find more if you like. Now your are saying, "I have no qualms over accepting that Siri Guru Angad Dev jee was an avatar of Raja Janak".
--------------
Here is what my understanding is of this issue. There is Vaheguru. Then there is Vaheguru’s own saroop that is there for udhaar purposes. This form of Vaheguru is called the Guru-form of Vaheguru and is totally merged in Vaheguru i.e. totally one with him but still distinguishable to Bhagats. This Guru-form is also called Guru-jyot and is also called Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj. The presence of this Guru-jyoti in our ten Gurus make them Guru Sahibaan. I could be wrong but Nij-aatma or the nijj-self of Guru Sahibaan got enhanced once the Guru jyot entered in all of them. Before they were aatma like us but with the presence of Gurjyoti, they became Satgurus. Before they were Brahmgiyanis but once Guru-jyoti was entered in them, they became Satgurus. Gurbani talks about the passing of this Guru jyoti from Guru to Guru, while staying in the first jaama too.
The Gurujyot alone did udhaar of Panchaali and of Prahlaad too. This Guru-jyot that was gupt before or worked through Raam, Krishna etc. became pargat in Kalyug and called itself Guru Nanak Dev jee and other ten Guru Sahibaan.
I strongly urge that you start a new thread to discuss this. Let us leave this thread to the topic of “condition of bhagats in Sach Khand”.
---------
I don't thing I have belittled the importance of sarovars. All I said was that Siri Amritsar Sahib is Guru ji de Nagri and every sikh wants to ave "Darshan Ishnaan" there, but it doesn't mean that all of your sins are going to be washed away with this ishnaan!!
-----------
By suggesting that Raamdaas Sarovar is just ordinary water, you have belittled the importance of Sarovars and hurt the feelings of millions of Sikhs who are dying to get ishnaan in these sarovars.
Here is the summary of the issues:
1) What more merger can you have than being merged like water to water as in the pankiti “paani sang paani?
2) After this merger as stated above, why is there any other merger necessary? Vaheguru becomes pargat in one’s ghat and one’s aatma becomes one with Vaheguru right in this Human Body. Why is there need for another merger after death?
3) If bhagats don’t lose consciousness of self while merging so close that they are paani sang paani, why would they lose it in the next world?
4) You seem to be suggesting that dehi is a hindrance in complete merger. What difference does it make whether the bhagat is in this body or anywhere in this universe as long as he is merged in Vaheguru?
5) Where does it say in Gurbani that Bhagats lose consciousness in the next world? Please quote a pankiti. I agree that they are ikk-mikk but why do they lose surtee? Where does it say in Gurbani that they lose surtee.
6) You have stated that Bhagats are in Parmanand (ultimate bliss) after merger. How can they be in bliss if they cannot feel it and don’t have surtee. You have never replied to this question. How can you enjoy bliss without surtee? Surtee is a must if you want to enjoy bliss.
7) Surtee is a must if you want Sadd-jeevan. If you don’t have surte or consciousness, you cannot have life or your life is like a purgatory.
8) If amrit of Khanda baata is prepared through baani and if that water can retain the affect of baani, why can’t Raamdaas Sarovar too retain the affect of Gurbani. The question here is whether water can retain the affect of Gurbani or not.
Looking forward to your response.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 25 Mar 2005
Veer Kulwinder Singh jeeo,
----------
Jis Marnea te Jag Derea
Merea Maren Anand Mernea te hi Pie'a Purna Paramanad.
Kindly explain the above vir Kulbir Singh Ji,
-----------
I think this marna is not the physical marna but the marna of haume and moh. Professor Sahib Singh thinks that this marna is of moh or attachment of this world. Also this shabad is not talking about any merger or losing consciousness of Bhagats but is calling about Parm-Anand i.e. ultimate bliss.
----------
The real meaning of Jap Nam is not purely reciting HIS NAME,
But rembering him in order to get guidance to see his Hukam in daily life and doing the right things. Remembering him is just a first step, do not just get stuck on the reciting bit. Other wise reciting and doing the sins is possible like
---------
The real meaning of Naam Japna is what Gurbani tells us i.e. “Barambaar Baar Prabh Japiye” i.e. keep repeating Naam Gurmantr like crazy, all the time. When tongue gets tired, do it in a subtle form but just keep on doing it. It generates great power. I think you should start a new thread to discuss this topic in detail. Let us do it.
--------
Vir kulbir Singh Ji Gurubani is mainly for Vichar not just Ucharan . rather then Ucharan A Sikh must try to understand what Guru Ji Saying in the Shabad.
--------
I think Gurbani is both Mantra roop i.e. for uchaaran and for teachings or updesh.
-------------
Now KAbir Ji in his life time saying he has sat on the Thorne, and also merged, now consider your stand, either you can merge or sit with GOD you consider both be two diffrent things, Kabir Ji is saying that being both is perfectly OK and he has done that even in his lifetime on earth. If Kabir Ji was talking about some real physical Thorne or Darbar then how come he physical went their and sat on it, Vir Ji this Thorne is just acceptance of will of Kabir Ji in a totally free way by GOD so Kabir Sahib Ji are like on the Thorne as what ever Kabir Sahib Ji want GOD is doing it or there is no difference at all between the will of Kabir Sahib and GOD.
------------
It is possible to sit on the throne while living too. At will, Bhagats can leave this body and go to Sach Khand and be seated on the throne there. If Bhagat Kabir jee is saying that he was seated on the singhaasan, who are we to question it and interpret the word throne to mean “will” or anything else. What other scholar has interpreted throne to mean “will” ? Even great scholars like Professor Sahib Singh could not do any other meaning of that shabad about Guru Raam Daas jee Maharaaj.
-------
Kulbir Singh Ji I am siding with Vir J.Singh Ji as his explanation match my own understanding closely. Also I am bit cheeky and I do like putting bit extra hard question to you as you are very well read and that is a well deserved compliment to you.
--------
You are welcome anytime Veer jeeo.
DAas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
J Singh · 29 Mar 2005
Kulbir Singh ji, I read your response and came to realize that we are just spinning our wheels. We can write chapter after chapter discussing this. We can even write books debating this but at the end of it, we will still have this difference of opinion.
>>>>
I think this is a very important part of our discussion and must be discussed more profoundly than this.
>>>>>
Doesn’t matter how many times you ask me Veer ji, my understanding will still be the same as before. By providing example of pannkiti "Naanak saadh parabh bhayd na bhaa-ee", I was trying to say that Gurbani says numerous times how saadh, sant, brahmgiani are same as Vaheguru as they are (able to get) “leen” in Vaheguru thru naam-jaap (Samadhi). If they don’t need to do naam abiyaas, then you tell me the need for naam jaap.
You have cited shabads from bhagats to prove your point. SAME BHAGATS who are literally begging and crying to Vaheguru to not “Visaar” (leave or ignore) them, do mehar on them, and give them mukti. You are saying “I know beyond any doubt that complete merger takes place while living”, then tell me Veer ji what are these Bhagats saying through their baani? IF you don’t believe me, please read baani. Here is what you said about Bhagat Kabir ji: “At will, Bhagats can leave this body and go to Sach Khand and be seated on the throne there. If Bhagat Kabir jee is saying that he was seated on the singhaasan, who are we to question it and interpret the word throne to mean “will” or anything else.” If you still say that Bhagats may not yet have attained enlightenment, then I suggest that you read ALL the Gurbani written by Guru Sahibaan as well to realize what it says. I will carry on this thought further later on in this post.
>>>>>
Gurmat preaches that everything that one wants spiritually is attainable while living and such promises that something will happen after death are not acceptable.
>>>>>
That’s what your understanding of Gurbani is, not mine. We both agree that we realize, meet or are able to see (or what we choose to call it) through human dehi only. And, I have explained what I believe in based on reading and reflecting on the same Gurbani that you do. You may want to stay in human form of 84 lakh juni but, for me, it’s the juni through which we get a chance to merge (I have already defined what merge means to me) in Vaheguru, to go back to our mool origin Vaheguru.
>>>>>
To whatever spiritual avastha a Gursikh reaches while living, that is where one gets after death. After death of this body, no spiritual elevation can take place. This is why Guru Sahib has written that to this human body even devtay beg for (Iss dehi to simraye dev). Because spiritual elevation is possible only in this human dehi.
>>>>
For starters, we get this janam to naam jaap so we can be one with Vaheguru; and we leave this dehi to be freed from janam-maran de bandhan. The same dehi that Devtay simar. I have already stated above that there are a lot of pankaties in Gurbani that say how gursikhs, sants, bhagats, brahmgianies are "leen" with Gobind through naam-simran. Gurbani even states that there is no difference between Gobind and saadh or brahmgiani. It’s nice to know that you don’t take the pankati “Iss dehi to simraye dev” literally as “simran” also means “worship” J. I have already clarified my position on this, “gobind Milan kea ho tere variya” but it doesn’t mean you get stuck in this human body and start calling in your “self”.
Do you think gursikhs and saadh, who are “COMLETELY MERGED WITH VAHEGURU WHILE LIVING”, stay “leen” with Him LIKE PAANI IS with PAANI through NAAM_JAAP (Simran, Samadhi) or THROUGH SOME OTHER MEANS? Do these same gursikhs or sant pursh eat sleep, talk, think, mingle with other humanoids, and perform numerous Worldly duties in their own GRISTI jeevans? IF they do, then are they still (during all these activities) “COMLETELY MERGED WITH VAHEGURU 24/7 “JIYON PAANI SANG PAANI”? If you still say YES they are, then what is the point of doing NAAM ABIYAAS for them? Think about it veer ji, they are already COMLETELY MERGED WITH VAHEGURU 24/7 and there is no bhayd (difference) between them and Vaheguru now, then why do they still keep rehit and follow prescribed jeevan like everyone else? WHAT FOR? Please don’t make up an answer or dismiss this. Do think about it. We will carry on this thought later on in this post.
>>>>>>
“Brahm meh jan, jan meh Paarbraham” and “Nanak Leen bhaiyo Gobind sang, jiyon paani sang paani” prove beyond doubt that complete merger takes place while living.
What more merger can happen after death than “paani sang paani”? I feel that you have not addressed this point properly.
>>>>>
From reading all of your posts, I have no doubt that, to YOU, the above shabads do prove (to you) beyond any doubt that the complete merger takes place while living but it’s not the case for me as I stated above. Please also read my last post where I had already clarified my position about these shabads.
Why is it so hard to believe that “Brahm meh jan, jan meh Paarbraham”. Gurbani says the same thing in numerous other shabads. And, if you read the whole shabad with pankaties “NANAK LEEN BHAIYO GOBIND SIYON, JIYON PAANI SANG PAANI”, you realize that it describes the attributes of a person (narr) who has taken the qualities of Vaheguru. This shabad further states that “KAAM KRODH JIH PARSAE NAHIN, TIH GHAT BRAHM NIVASA” and when Gur kirpa is on such person, he understand the “jugat”. And now, this person (through naam-jaap) is “leen” (jurriya hoya) with Gobind, like paani is in paani. If you don’t think this person is “leen” through “naam-jaap” (bhagati) then you tell me veer ji how is he “leen” with Vaheguru like “paani with paani”? We need to understand the essence of Gurmuki.
>>>>>>
Bhagat Naamdev sensing this wailed out to Vaheguru:
Mooye hooye jo mukat dehogay, mukat na jaanae koila ||
(If you give me mukti after death, what is point of it. I need it while living).
>>>>>
Please don’t be mislead Veer ji. I really urge you to read ALL of Bhagat Namdev ji’s baani and try to understand his baani in its “totality”. This shabad in fact goes in my favour. Bhagat ji is doing benati (plea, request) to Vaheguru to save his laaj. He is saying that if “You mukat me after I am dead, no one will know that I am freed (implying that he will be “mukat” after death when his 84 is finished) Here is the full shabad:
mo ka-o tooN na bisaar too na bisaar.
too na bisaaray raam-ee-aa. ||1|| rahaa-o.
Please do not forget me; please do not forget me. Please do not forget me, O Raamiya.
aalaavantee ih bharam jo hai mujh oopar sabh kopilaa. sood sood kar maar uthaa-i-o kahaa kara-o baap beethulaa.
The temple priests have doubts about this, and everyone is furious with me. They are calling me low-caste and untouchable, they beat me and drove me out; what should I do now, O Beloved Father beethul?
moo-ay hoo-ay ja-o mukat dayhugay mukat na jaanai ko-ilaa.
If I get mukati after I am dead, no one will know that I got mukati.
ay pandee-aa mo ka-o dhaydh kahat tayree paij pichhaNudee ho-ilaa. too jo da-i-aal kirpaal kahee-at haiN atibhuj bha-i-o apaarlaa.
These Pandits, these religious scholars, call me low-born; when they say this, they are tarnishing Your honor as well. You are called kind and compassionate; the power of Your Arm is absolutely unrivalled.
fayr dee-aa dayhuraa naamay ka-o pandee-an ka-o pichhvaarlaa.
The Lord turned the temple around to face Naam Dayv; He turned His back on the Brahmins.
Pls don’t go into the history of Bhagat ji as I am aware of it. Just stick to the point we are discussing here.
Since you mentioned Bhagat Namdev ji, here are some more pankaties by same Bhagat ji that you should ponder upon:
- “ajaimal kee-o baikuntheh thaan”.
Wondering why I cited this pankati J? You said that Devpuri means “SachKhand”, then what does “Baikunth” means here? I bet it doesn’t mean SachKhand to you here because how can ajaimal get to Sach Khand without the SATGURU, Guru Nanak Dev ji. What I am implying here is that we tend to side with the meaning that suits out understanding of gurbani.
- jahaa jahaa Dhoo-a naarad taykay naik tikaavahu mohi, tayray naam avilamb bahut jan udhray naamay kee nij mat ayh.
Please place me where You placed Dhroo and Naarad, (O my Beethal). With the Support of Your Name, so many have been saved; this is Naam Dayv's understanding.
Now, tell me if you think Bhagat ji is begging his “Beethal” (Vaheguru) to place him where Dhroo and Naarad are placed. If you say yes, then we will go further on this.
- mahaa maa-ee kee poojaa karai, nar sai naar ho-ay a-utarai.
One who worships the Great Goddess Maya, will be reincarnated as a woman, and not a man.
Literally speaking, do you think that it’s so bad to be born as a woman and not as a man? Do I need to write the famous words of Guru Nanak Dev ji here?
And, how would you interpret the following Shabad by bhagat ji? And, do let me know if you agree with Professor Sahib Singh’s interpretation here J:
Dhan Dhan o raam bayn baajai.
Blessed, blessed is that flute which the Lord plays.
maDhur maDhur Dhun anhat gaajai. ||1|| rahaa-o.
The sweet, sweet unstruck sound current sings forth. ||1||Pause||
Dhan Dhan mayghaa romaavalee.
Blessed, blessed is the wool of the sheep;
Dhan Dhan krisan odhai kaaNblee. ||1||
blessed, blessed is the blanket worn by Krishna. ||1||
Dhan Dhan too maataa dayvkee.
Blessed, blessed are you, O mother Dayvakee;
jih garih rama-ee-aa kavalaapatee. ||2||
into your home the Lord was born. ||2||
Dhan Dhan ban khand bindraabanaa.
Blessed, blessed are the forests of Brindaaban;
jah khaylai saree naaraa-inaa. ||3||
the Supreme Lord plays there. ||3||
bayn bajaavai goDhan charai.
He plays the flute, and herds the cows;
naamay kaa su-aamee aanad karai. ||4||1||
Naam Dayv's Lord and Master plays happily. ||4||1||
Literally speaking, what does narayan means in the shabad above? Who is Bhagat ji talking about here? “naamay kaa su-aamee aanad karai”
Here is some more by the same Bhagat ji:
dooDh katorai gadvai paanee. kapal gaa-ay naamai duhi aanee. ||1||
Naam Dayv milked the brown cow, and brought a cup of milk and a jug of water to his family god. ||1||
dooDh pee-o gobinday raa-ay.
"Please drink this milk, O my gobinday.
dooDh pee-o mayro man patee-aa-ay.
Drink this milk and my mind will be happy.
naahee ta ghar ko baap risaa-ay. ||1|| rahaa-o.
Otherwise, my father will be angry with me."||1||Pause||
so-in katoree amrit bharee.
Taking the golden cup, Naam Dayv filled it with the ambrosial milk,
lai naamai har aagai Dharee. ||2||
and placed it before Har||2||
ayk bhagat mayray hirday basai. naamay daykh naraa-in hasai. ||3||
narayin looked upon Naam Dayv and smiled. "This one devotee abides within my heart."||3||
dooDh pee-aa-ay bhagat ghar ga-i-aa.
HE drank the milk, and bhagat ji returned home.
naamay har kaa darsan bha-i-aa. ||4||3||
Thus did Naam Dayv come to receive the Blessed Vision of the Lord's Darshan. ||4||3
Literally speaking, what would you say about the shabad describing the vision of Hari by Bhagat ji? Don’t ask me what I think as I am not question anything here. If bhagat ji was completely merged in Vaheguru like paani sang paani, then what does this shabad mean? He is feeding milk to his Narayan Here. And, please don’t ignore or dismiss my comments as we are doing Gurbani Vichaar here.
Here is one more:
paakhantan baaj bajaa-ilaa, garurh charhHay gobind aa-ilaa.
Playing on the instrument of the feathered wings, the Lord of the Universe came, mounted on the eagle garura.
apnay bhagat par kee partipaal, garurh charhHay aa-ay gopaal.
He cherished His devotee, and the Lord came, mounted on the eagle garura.
kaheh ta Dharan ikodee kara-o, kaheh ta lay kar oopar Dhara-o.
The Lord said to him, "If you wish, I shall turn the earth sideways. If you wish, I shall turn it upside down.”
Again literally speaking, who does savari of garurh? I know that you are very well read veer ji, so I just hope you don’t dismiss these lines by giving me the history of the whole incident of this shabad. Stick to the point of discussion which is “TAKING OR NOT GURBANI LITERALLY”. You have already stated: “When the pankitis are written in a straightforward way, what is the need to use other interpretations? Why not take it literally?” YOU CAN’T HAVE IT BOTH WAYS J.
There are innumerable shabads of Gurbani that should not be taken literally as taking them out of context can be really misleading.
>>>>>>
You have repeated your previous position that “As long as jeev-aatma is in human form (still in one of the 84 lakh juni), it has it's own identity like we all do.”
>>>>>>
I repeated my previous position because my position hasn’t changed. It’s still the same J.
>>>>>>
Your point is that because of the maanas dehi it cannot have complete merger but Gurbani says that don’t look at the maanas dehi and think that there is any difference between Bhagat and Vaheguru. From inside they are one. Here is the pankiti to prove that:
HAR KA SEWAK, SO HAR JEHA ||
BHED NA JAANO MAANAS DEHA ||
JIYON JAL TARANG UTHEY BAHU BHANTI
PHIR SALALE SALAL SMAINDA ||
In this above shabad Guru Sahib clearly says that the just like waves and ocean are one, same way Bhagat and Vaheguru are same. Don’t be mislead by the Maanas Deha and think that they are different. They are one.
This shabad shows me that while living bhagat and Vaheguru attain complete merger.
>>>>>>
If after all this discussion, you still don’t know what I mean by “jyoti jyot sammauna” after leaving this “manukh-juni” which is part of 84 lakh juni, I don’t expect to convince you. Next time when someone says “Guru Sahib “jyoti Jyot Sammaye”, please be sure to tell that they were always “jyoti jyot sammaye hoye” (and by that logic they didn’t have their own jyot in this World!).
Again, in your own words: “Bhagat and Vaheguru are same just like just waves and ocean are one(I also agree with this shabad by not the way you describe it). ..while living bhagat and Vaheguru attain complete merger”.
Do you agree that rehit is an absolute MUST here in this World and no one is exempt from it? Even Guru Gobind Singh ji took Amrit from Panj Pyaare. We must jaap naam, do panj baaniyan da paath at the minimum and follow full sikhi rehit. Now, if “Bhagat and Vaheguru are same just like waves and ocean are” and they are MEREGD into VAHEGRU 24/7 FOREVER AND EVER AND EVER TO ETERNIY WHILE BEING HERE ON EARTH, then why are they following all this rehit here in this World as all of us. AREN’T THEY ALREADY “MERGED INTO” VAHEGURU AND ARE SITTING IN SACHKHAND (by your own admission)? PLEASE TRY TO UNDERSTAND WHAT I MA SAYING AND REPLY ACCORDING TO YOUR OWN LOGIN AND WITH GURBANI.
You have also stated: “Bhagats continue to do bhagti in SachKhnad because it is automatic there. Just as you breathe and your heart keeps beating while you live here in this world, bhagtee too is just natural there.”
Don't you see the difference between the two states, one being here in human form in Grist Jeevan and the other being there in Sach Khand in Jyot-Saroop (in your own words)?
>>>>
When our consciousness is entangled in the trai-gunni maaiya, then we are part of this world but once after Naam abhyaas one gets beyond trai-gunni maaiya and attains Vaheguru, maanas dehi is no hindrance in the merger.
>>>>>>
I don’t know what you are talking about. I am talib-e-mazrat too here.
>>>>>
So great is the merger between Bhagat and Vaheguru that Bhatts had to say, “Gur Arjun Partakh Har” i.e. Guru Arjun Dev jee is Saakshaat Vaheguru.
>>>>>
I have already commented on Bhatt Baani and said that Bhatts were able to “see” Vaheguru in Guru Sahib.
>>>>>
You write that “It BECOMES HIM and is in Param-Anand forever.” Think of it Veer J. Singh jeeo. Don’t you think that one needs to be have surtee to be in Parmanand (ultimate bliss)?
>>>>>
I will say what I have said many times on this thread, once jeev-atma samma in ParmAtma, they are EK JYOT. Atma has merged into the Parm-Consciousness and are out of all bandhans of Worldly aspirations. You keep on thinking in “selfish” manner. What would happen to “ME”? You are stuck with surtee or consciousness of your “SELF”? Who is this “YOU” but JYOT SAROOP, just an ansh of Vaheguru Jyot. What is Kulbir Singh? Not your Dehi that Devs simar. I don’t think you will comprehend what I am saying with the logic you are applying here.
>>>>>>
Ishrat-e-kathra hai Dariya me fanaah ho jaana ||
Darad ka hadd se guzarna hai davaa ho jaana ||
>>>>>
Although a sharabi, juaari, and a muffat-khor J, but indeed one of the greatest Urdu poet. I too love his syeri.
>>>>>>>
----------
How about "tithae jodh mahabal soor". It doesn't mean that all of the jodhey, mahabali and soormey are going to end up in Karam Khand.
----------
This means exactly what it says. The Jodhay and Mahabalee Soormay who were able to wage war against 5 bikaars and maaiya and win this war, come to this Karam Khand.
>>>>>>>
This is a good example of taking something out of its context. You conveniently added “Jodhay and Mahabalee Soormay who were able to wage war against 5 bikaars and maaiya and win this war”. You ever gave a pankati from Giurbani but where is it written in the pankiti I cited from Jap Ji Sahib? THE PURPOSE OF MY WHOLE PARAGRAPH WAS TO PROVE THAT GURBANI SHOULDN’T “ALWAYS” BE TAKEN “LITERALLY”.
This is what I had written. Please read it. I have added additional comments to make it clearer:
You are playing with words here :-). All I am saying is that we should understand baani in the context it's written. We know Bhatts are praising Guru Sahibaan one by one, but when you read their baani closely, you get the feeling ( I do) that they aren't just talking about Guru Sahibaan in this human form, they are also praising Vaheguru that they "see" in Guru Sahibaan.
How about "tithae jodh mahabal soor". It doesn't mean that ALL of the jodhey, mahabali and soormey are going to end up in Karam Khand.
Guru Sahib says, "paarbarahm saadh ridh basai" but it's it also true that "ghat ghat pooran barahm pargaas". If one takes the first pankati “literally”, one would believe that Parbrahm only resides in Saadh ridh but the second pankati it’s also clear that "ghat ghat pooran barahm pargaas". He indeed resides in ghat-ghat, whether jeevs recognize it or not. i.e. we shouldn’t always take Gurbani literally! We should learn it in totality, in its full context.
How about "Saadh kai sang sabh kul uDhaarai, saadhsang saajan meet kutamb nistaarai". Don't get me wrong, I do understand what these pankatian mean but not by taking them literally. We can't just interpret that with doing the sangat of a saadh, one's kul, saajan, meet and kutamb will all get uDhaar. i.e. they “ALL” must jaap-naam INDIVIDUALLY as one's kul, saajan, meet and kutamb WILL NOT get uDhaar because one does sangat of saadh.
>>>>>>
----------
Guru Sahib says, "paarbarahm saadh ridh basai" but it's it also true that "ghat ghat pooran barahm pargaas".
----------
I don’t know what you are trying to make out of this. It looks like you are saying that there seems to be a contradiction in these two pankitis. But such is not the case.
In the case of former, it means that Vaheguru has become pargat in a Saadh and in latter case it means that in everyone, Vaheguru hee Vaheguru hai i.e. he alone pervades in everything.
>>>>>>
Please read my response above. As you know from not taking these pankities literally, there is indeed no contradiction. How would you have known this by taking the pankities literally. Ridh and ghat means the same. It’s a very convenient (in my meager opinion) to say that they don’t mean the same but Devpuri and SachKhand do mean the same as it fits your understanding.
>>>>>>
----------
How about "Saadh kai sang sabh kul uDhaarai, saadhsang saajan meet kutamb nistaarai". Don't get me wrong, I do understand what these pankatian mean but not by taking them literally. We can't just interpret that with the sangat of saadh, one's kul, saajan, meet and kutamb will all get uDhaar. There are numerous panakatian that we can just run with if we don't take them in the full
Gurbani context they are written it.
---------
I have not one iota of doubt that this pankiti comes out true. The whole of kutamb and friends of Saadh get delivered, but not as they are today. In due time, Vaheguru does kirpa on them and they meet the true Guru – Guru Nanak Dev jee – and get delivered. But just by being the relative of a Saadh Jan, their process of deliverance starts.
>>>>>>
You have added a lot of condition that these shabad don’t mention AT ALL. Since you don’t have one iota of doubt, I respect you understanding. I personally don’t believe that, by just doing sangat of saadh, one's kul, saajan, meet and kutamb will all get uDhaar automatically. i.e. we ALL must do our part including naam abiyaas INDIVIDUALLY as our kul, saajan, meet and kutamb will not get our uDhaar.
>>>>>>>>
----------
Relax veer ji, I am not going to use any metaphor. The shabad talks about Guru ji's akaal-chalanah beautifully. I am not going to say what Devpuri means and what it doesn't mean either. We will just be spinning our heels. You are trying to prove with these panaktian that all ten Guru Sahibaan is sitting alongside Vaheguru in Sach Khand (for eternity, forever and ever) and I just don't agree with your here.
----------
Since we are discussing this, it is not enough for you to say that you don’t agree. Please explain what else is the meaning of this pankiti. It is written clearly that Vaheguru jee gave the throne to Siri Guru Raamdaas jee Maharaaj in Devpuri. This proves that there is a throne in Devpuri.
>>>>>>
I was responding to your claim that all ten Guru Sahibaan are sitting alongside Vaheguru on a Throne in Sach Khand for Eternity. This shabad doesn’t say that at all. On one side you are saying that COMPLETE MERGER happens here on Earth. On the other hand, you are saying that this shabad literally means That Veheguru himself came to receive Guru Sahib and gave him throne to sit on in DEVPURI (which means SachKhand to you). Wasn’t Guru Sahib FULLY COMPLETE MERGED with Vaheguru like “PAANI Sang PAANI”? Weren’t they already sitting in Sach Khand alongside Vaheguru forever and ever while being here on Earth at the same time? These are your own words! I think you are siding with me here indirectly by saying that this merger is happening after “Jyoti Jyot Samma”. I am confused! There is lot more I can say here but WILL NOT.
>>>>>
----------
Haven't I been saying in all these posts that atma is indeed an ansh of Parmatma like a kiran is to suraj and like water is to ocean. You can chop it or twist it any which way you want but " paratma parbrahm ka roop". Atma is part of Parmatma, Parmatma who is SUCH and doer of this whole khel and more. "aapan khayl aap varteejaa, naanak karnaihaar na doojaa"
-----------
My point was that aatma never dies. If it did not die when it was separate from Vaheguru in this world, then how can it die when it is merged? Gurbani clearly says that aatma is “hota aaiya” i.e. has always been there. This clearly proves the independent haste of aatma.
>>>>>>
Veer ji, just read what I have written above. Where did I ever say that atma dies. It’s a ansh, a part, of parmatma. Just read I wrote above.
>>>>>>
--------
NO, I don't have it totally wrong jeer ji. You, perhaps, didn't understand me. Atma's nij ghar is Parmatma. I also understand that everything is within us and not outside.
----------
Not at a single place in Gurbani (in my opinion) has Nij Ghar come in the meanings of Parmatma. Gurbani does not interpret Nij Ghar as Vaheguru. Please show a single pankiti that says that Nij Ghar means Vaheguru.
>>>>>>
Don’t try to twist what I wrote by playing with words veer ji. Where did I say Nij Ghar = Vaheguru. Nij means kudh (apna, mine) and Ghar means home. Simple! So, Atma's real final destination, its mool origin (nij ghar) is INDEED Parmatma.
>>>>>>
Just read the last couple of sentences of your paragraph quoted above. You say that when aatma gets merged in Vaheguru it is ultimate anand. But anand for who? Vaheguru or Aatma? My position is that Vaheguru is already in Anand. Nothing special if after merger this anand continues for Vaheguru. Anand is also for jeev-aatma who gets merged in Vaheguru and this anand can only happen if Jeev-aatma has surtee.
>>>>>>
What more special treatment do you want then to be ONE with Vaheguru Jyot? Once atma gets merged (samma) in Parmatma, there is no duality. Parmjyot is in ultimate anand. You can’t understand what I am saying if you keep on thinking in the same selfish manner. Who is Kulbir Singh, Mann, Atma, or something else.
>>>>>>>
You ask that aatma does not experience happiness and sorrow, then how is it experiencing Anand.
>>>>>>
I AM NOT SAYING THIS VEER Ji, SHRI GURU ARJAN DEV JI SAYS THIS. You wrote yourself that atma is beyond HAPPINESS AND SORROW. Now you are saying: “To be happy or to feel HAPPINESS, don’t you think the most fundamental thing is consciousness i.e. surtee? If there is no consciousness, who is going to enjoy happiness?” I urge you to stick with one mode of thinking veer ji.
>>>>>
I beg for maazrat but please read what you are writing. You write “Atma has become part of Parmatma and stays in bliss. Sadd-jeevan is only with Vaheguru.”
First you were saying that aatma experiences no happiness or sorrow but now you say that it is in bliss. And then you say that sadd-jeevan is with Vaheguru only. The word “with” implies that aatma is still conscious and so does your assertion that it is in bliss.
I was saying that just as a person in chloroform cannot feel any dukh or such, same way a jeev-aatma that has lost consciousness cannot have any anand. Anand can only be felt by surtee or consciousness. So what do you mean here in the quote above?
>>>>>>>
Problem isn’t with what I wrote. It lies in what you want to read. Please read again. What do I mean by “Atma has become part of Parmatma”? The word “with” doesn’t imply anything. You can create this “phambal-phoosa” but I will not get entangled in it J.
Again, I do understand and respect what you saying, but I don’t agree with you. I don’t agree that atma will stay separate from Vaheguru while merged in Vaheguru and it will have its own separate SELF with surtee or consciousness to enjoy bliss. It will sit in Sachkhand doing Bhagati to eternity. What happened to the selfless love of Vaheguru? You still crying SELF, SELF not Vaheguru, Vaheguru or Tuhi, tuhi. What about “ME”? Vaheguru is self-created. He is the ONE and ONLY who contemplated this whole Srishti, this Khel, which includes everything.
>>>>
It is a pure Gurmat Principle that water can absorb baani or become amrit because of baani. The whole initiation (Khanday baatay da amrit) ceremony of Khalsa is dependent on this. Punj Pyaray recite 5 baaniyan while stirring patasay in water with their khanda. This water after all 5 baniyaan is considered amrit and is administered to new Sikhs. This ceremony is not a
pakhand. It is a true ceremony and this water does indeed become amrit i.e. such water that has accepted baani.
Same way, the sarovar of Ramdas Sarovar is amritmai. Just look at the name of this sarovar – Amritsar. Amrit da sar i.e. sarovar of Amrit.
>>>>
Pressing a very emotional button here, aren't we :-). Being a singh, how can and why would I say that Khanday Baatay da Amrit is a pakhand? You are getting a little carried away here. Naam is supreme and Guru ji gave us the the bidhi (ceremony) to get this naam. Now, pls. answer this question: Is it accordance to Gurmatt to carry this "amrit water" (water that has become amrit by accepting baani for over 400 years) from Ramdas Sarovar in bottles to cure our dukhs, kashts and sins? Of course we need to naam jaap along with the amrit water. As you would agree, not everyone has access and the resources to get to the sarover.
-----------------
Please don’t avoid this issue now. You started it and you should go all the way with it. My position is that water can retain the affect of Gurbani and Naam and this is how Amrit is prepared. The foundation of Sikhi is standing on it. The shabad of “Jithay jaaye bahae mera Satguru” proves that any place where our Guru Sahib sets his charan, becomes pure.
>>>>>>
I didn’t avoid the “issue” as I told you what I thought about it. Being a singh, I have full faith in Khanday Baatay da Amrit” ceremony but my understanding doesn’t necessarily have to match yours. First you agreed with me that “it’s baani not paani” that cures dukhs, kashts and sins. Now you are saying that it is perfectly in accordance to Gurmat to bring amritmai water of Raamdaas Sarovar in bottles to cure dukhs, kashts and sins. Power is not in the Paani, it’s in Gurbani. You are welcome to carry Khanda da amrit (that retains baani) in bottles to do whatever pleases you but, to me, it’s the Panj Pyaare (Parmesher, Vaheguru) who give NAAM and the shakti through baani.
>>>>>>>>>>>>
----------------
>>>>> I have no qualms over accepting that Siri Guru Angad Dev jee was an avatar of Raja Janak. >>>>>
I have read your posts on some of the other topics. Don't you believe that Guru Sahibaan are the only true (sat) Gurus (one jyot) of all lok, parlok, khands and brehmands. They were sent directly by Vaheguru to do our udhaar. For example, didn't you say that it was "Guru Sahib" who save the laaj (honor) od Panchali in Raaj Sabha? I can find more if you like. Now your are saying, "I have no qualms over accepting that Siri Guru Angad Dev jee was an avatar of Raja Janak".
--------------
Here is what my understanding is of this issue. There is Vaheguru. Then there is Vaheguru’s own saroop that is there for udhaar purposes. This form of Vaheguru is called the Guru-form of Vaheguru and is totally merged in Vaheguru i.e. totally one with him but still distinguishable to Bhagats. This Guru-form is also called Guru-jyot and is also called Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj. The presence of this Guru-jyoti in our ten Gurus make them Guru Sahibaan. I could be wrong but Nij-aatma or the nijj-self of Guru Sahibaan got enhanced once the Guru jyot entered in all of them. Before they were aatma like us but with the presence of Gurjyoti, they became Satgurus. Before they were Brahmgiyanis but once Guru-jyoti was entered in them, they became Satgurus. Gurbani talks about the passing of this Guru jyoti from Guru to Guru, while staying in the first jaama too.
>>>>>>>
There is a lot I like to say here but I will stay quite at the moment. First you say that Guru Angad Dev jee were an avatar of Raja Janak and a bhagat of a devi. Now you are saying, “they were Brahmgiyanis before but once Guru-jyoti was entered in them, they became Satgurus.” You may go the convenient way and say that they become Brahmgiani after meeting Guru Nanak Dev ji! (I say it was the “will” of the Almightly Vaheguru). If Guru-jyoti entered in them when they becaome guru, then what was in Guru Nanank Dev ji, as they were still in human form? Now you would say there were more than one Satguru jyoties. Do you believe that there can be more than one Satguru? Don’t get me wrong, I am just asking. By the way, what do you think happen to Sache Patshah Guru Nanak Dev Ji after they “Jyoti Jyot Samma”. Does the same logic apply here that applies to Guru Raam Daas Ji’s Akaal Chalanah?
Please read Raamkalee kee Vaar by Satta Doom And Raa-ai Balwand carefully.
>>>>>>>
The Gurujyot alone did udhaar of Panchaali and of Prahlaad too. This Guru-jyot that was gupt before or worked through Raam, Krishna etc. became pargat in Kalyug and called itself Guru Nanak Dev jee and other ten Guru Sahibaan.
>>>>>>>
What can I say here other than that I respect your understanding of Gurbani while disagreeing with you completely.
>>>>>
By suggesting that Raamdaas Sarovar is just ordinary water, you have belittled the importance of Sarovars and hurt the feelings of millions of Sikhs who are dying to get ishnaan in these sarovars.
>>>>>>
You are welcome to accuse me but I am not one for “sensationalism”. I don’t think that I didn’t hurt the feelings of millions of Sikhs Worldwide. I have explained what I think already.
>>>>>>>>
Here is the summary of the issues:
1) What more merger can you have than being merged like water to water as in the pankiti “paani sang paani?
>>>>>
I have already made my stand clear on this. I ask you again to review earlier replies.
>>>>>
2) After this merger as stated above, why is there any other merger necessary? Vaheguru becomes pargat in one’s ghat and one’s aatma becomes one with Vaheguru right in this Human Body. Why is there need for another merger after death?
>>>>>
I can’t agree with you more that it’s through this human dehi that we get a chance to realize (see, meet) our pyaara Vaheguru by naam-abiyas but this body is naash-vaan. Jeev-atma leaves this human dehi (this dehi which IS part of the 84 lakh juni) and “JYOTI JYOT SAMMA” in Parm-Jyot. Atma doesn’t get destroyed, decimated or fanah as it becomes part of its mool origin (its real ghar, since you didn’t like the word “nij”).
>>>>>>
3) If bhagats don’t lose consciousness of self while merging so close that they are paani sang paani, why would they lose it in the next world?
>>>>>>
As long as they are here in this world, they are still a part of 84 lakh juni and have their ATMA. Read Bhagat Namdev ji’s baani and see how desperately converses with Vaheguru. I urge you to read and understand all of Gurbani in its full context to get the essence.
>>>>>>
4) You seem to be suggesting that dehi is a hindrance in complete merger. What difference does it make whether the bhagat is in this body or anywhere in this universe as long as he is merged in Vaheguru?
>>>>>>
I have explained the difference earlier in this post.
>>>>>>
5) Where does it say in Gurbani that Bhagats lose consciousness in the next world? Please quote a pankiti. I agree that they are ikk-mikk but why do they lose surtee? Where does it say in Gurbani that they lose surtee.
>>>>>>
In my humble opinion, your fixation with SELF is blinding you from seeing what is obvious. Atma is nirgun and pure and it’s a part of ParmAtma. Atma’s surti and consciousness is same as Vaheguru. There is no difference between the two after they “jyoti jyot samma”. I can give you the same pankities you are using to prove that bhagats are sitting in front of Vaheguru in Sachkhand doing His bhagati with their individual consciousness and surti intact while being merged in Vaheguru. They have free to whatever they “will”, go wherever they want in the brehmand while being completely merged in Vaheguru in sachkhand. Doesn’t matter how many pankities I provide, I don’t think they will change your opinion. But that’s fine.
>>>>>>>
6) You have stated that Bhagats are in Parmanand (ultimate bliss) after merger. How can they be in bliss if they cannot feel it and don’t have surtee. You have never replied to this question. How can you enjoy bliss without surtee? Surtee is a must if you want to enjoy bliss.
>>>>>
Don’t put words in my mouth Veer ji. I have answered your question not once but few times on this thread but the answer is not of your liking. I suggest that you read my posts more carefully. I have clearly maintained that jeev-atma goes back to Parmatma and becomes ONE. You are thinking too much in human terms. ATMA IS PART OF PARMATMA. ITS REAL DESTINATION IS PARMATMA. PARMATMA IS IN ULTIMATE ANAND. AFTER IT’S 84 GETS CUT WITH GUR-KIRPA AND IT GOES BACK TO IT’S REAL MOOL GHAR (origin) PARMATMA. IT WAS ONLY PARMATMA WHEN HE CREATED EVERYTHING AND IT WILL ONLY BE PARMATMA WHEN HE DECIDES TO FOLD THIS DREAM WORLD (SUPNA JAISA SANSAAR).
>>>>>>
7) Surtee is a must if you want Sadd-jeevan. If you don’t have surte or consciousness, you cannot have life or your life is like a purgatory.
>>>>>>
You are still stuck with SELF PRESERVATION. UNLESS YOU GET OUT OF THIS MODE OF SELF AND SEE “TUHI TUHI” THERE IS NO WAY THAT YOU WILL EVER SEE WHAT I AM TALKING ABOUT. YOU NEED TO UNDERSTAND WHAT WE REALLY ARE. WE ARE JYOT SAROOP. ONLY VAHEGURU IS SACH AND, LOGICALLY, ONLY HE HAS SADD-JEEVAN.
8) If amrit of Khanda baata is prepared through baani and if that water can retain the affect of baani, why can’t Raamdaas Sarovar too retain the affect of Gurbani. The question here is whether water can retain the affect of Gurbani or not.
You, yourself said that “it’s not paani but baani that does everything”. Now you are saying otherwise. “Amrit Baani har har teri, parh parh hoi parmghat meri”. I have full faith in khande baate da amrit as Desmesh Pita prescribed this initiation for us. You are free to carry “Amrit in Bottles” to cure people and relieve their “sins” with it but don’t ask me to follow this ritual.
Veer ji, I say again that let’s just agree to disagree on this one issue. Gurbani is infinite (aseem) Ocean and we are mere Masklies. Let Vaheguru reveal this mystery to us (if we have the good fortune :–) Wishful thinking indeed).
I am a nimmana sikh, so please forgive me for my mistakes as there are tons in my post above.
Vjkk vjkf
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 29 Mar 2005
J. Singh jeeo,
----
Doesn’t matter how many times you ask me Veer ji, my understanding will still be the same as before. By providing example of pannkiti "Naanak saadh parabh bhayd na bhaa-ee", I was trying to say that Gurbani says numerous times how saadh, sant, brahmgiani are same as Vaheguru as they are (able to get) “leen” in Vaheguru thru naam-jaap (Samadhi). If they don’t need to do naam abiyaas, then you tell me the need for naam jaap.
----
I have repeatedly told you before also that even in the next world Naam Abhyaas and Keerat gauni i.e. Sifat-salaah does not stop. Ponder upon the following shabad of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee from the 9th pauri of Siri Asa kee Vaar that Gursikhs do everyday:
BHAGAT TERE MANN BHAAVDE, DAR SOHAN KEERAT GAAVDE ||
NANAK KARMA BAAHREY, DAR DHOH NA LEHNEE, DHAANVDE ||
(Bhagat who are pleasing to Vaheguru look beautiful at the Dar of Vaheguru i.e. Dargah of Vaheguru i.e. Sachkhand because they sing the keerat of Vaheguru. The unfortunate ones don’t get accepted in the Dargah of Vaheguru and as such they wander around (dhaanvde).
This pankiti proves to me that firstly there are bhagats at the Dargah of Vaheguru and secondly that they sing the keerat of Vaheguru there too. Seeto-seeta mehima maahi and other such shabad prove that in the top most avastha too, Naam does not stop. Naam is everything here and in the next world too.
-----------------
You have cited shabads from bhagats to prove your point. SAME BHAGATS who are literally begging and crying to Vaheguru to not “Visaar” (leave or ignore) them, do mehar on them, and give them mukti. You are saying “I know beyond any doubt that complete merger takes place while living”, then tell me Veer ji what are these Bhagats saying through their baani?
-------------
Our Guru Sahibaan and Bhagat Sahibaan wrote this baani but it was also meant for us as well. These shabads of “not to visaar” and other such shabads are mostly meant for us. These bhagats and Guru Sahibaan were totally one with Vaheguru. Their imploring and supplications are for our sake, so that we worldly people may benefit from them.
----------------
For starters, we get this janam to naam jaap so we can be one with Vaheguru; and we leave this dehi to be freed from janam-maran de bandhan. The same dehi that Devtay simar. I have already stated above that there are a lot of pankaties in Gurbani that say how gursikhs, sants, bhagats, brahmgianies are "leen" with Gobind through naam-simran. Gurbani even states that there is no difference between Gobind and saadh or brahmgiani.
----------------
So far I totally agree with you. No difference at all.
-------------
It’s nice to know that you don’t take the pankati “Iss dehi to simraye dev” literally as “simran” also means “worship” J. I have already clarified my position on this, “gobind Milan kea ho tere variya” but it doesn’t mean you get stuck in this human body and start calling in your “self”.
--------------
I am not against interpreting as you seem to have misunderstood. I was just commenting on your earlier lecture to me that we should not take things too literally. I had responded to you saying that where literal meaning is clear, there is no need to derive any other meaning contrary to the literal meaning.
Having said that, the word “simar” means “yaad karna” and not worship as you have interpreted. Japna means Jaap karna i.e. recite karna but simran is from the Sanskrit word “samaraN” and it means yaad karna. Yaad karna in a way means lochna i.e. to want something. So Devtay do “lochna” i.e. simran of this dehi.
----------------
Do you think gursikhs and saadh, who are “COMLETELY MERGED WITH VAHEGURU WHILE LIVING”, stay “leen” with Him LIKE PAANI IS with PAANI through NAAM_JAAP (Simran, Samadhi) or THROUGH SOME OTHER MEANS? Do these same gursikhs or sant pursh eat sleep, talk, think, mingle with other humanoids, and perform numerous Worldly duties in their own GRISTI jeevans? IF they do, then are they still (during all these activities) “COMLETELY MERGED WITH VAHEGURU 24/7 “JIYON PAANI SANG PAANI”?
-------------
Yes they always stay one with Vaheguru through Naam simran and this Naam simran does not stop in the next world either. It goes on for ever. They get samaayee in naam i.e. they stay merged in Naam forever and forever. Naam and Naami is same. No difference. Naam though source, it is such source that merges with the destination.
----------------
If you still say YES they are, then what is the point of doing NAAM ABIYAAS for them? Think about it veer ji, they are already COMLETELY MERGED WITH VAHEGURU 24/7 and there is no bhayd (difference) between them and Vaheguru now, then why do they still keep rehit and follow prescribed jeevan like everyone else? WHAT FOR? Please don’t make up an answer or dismiss this. Do think about it. We will carry on this thought later on in this post.
-----------------
Baba Budda jee stopped keeping rehit after he reached the param-padd. I don’t remember which Guru it was but he was summoned to Guru Sahib and ordered to keep rehit so that other gursikhs don’t get misled. Mata Bhaag Kaur also called Maayee Bhago reached the top level of Brahmgiyani and became so absorbed in Naam that she stopped caring about anything around her. At one point she started living totally naked. Singhs noticed this and told Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj. Siri Guru jee summoned Mata jee and told her to keep full rehit and have at least two articles of cloth on her body – Kachhera and Dastaar. This is written in Sooraj Parkash Granth and other old granths of that time.
Rehit has to be kept for above stated reasons i.e. for the sake of other Gursikhs and because Guru Sahib has ordained that so far so this body is there, rehit has to be there.
-----------------------------------
>>>>>>
“Brahm meh jan, jan meh Paarbraham” and “Nanak Leen bhaiyo Gobind sang, jiyon paani sang paani” prove beyond doubt that complete merger takes place while living.
What more merger can happen after death than “paani sang paani”? I feel that you have not addressed this point properly.
>>>>>
From reading all of your posts, I have no doubt that, to YOU, the above shabads do prove (to you) beyond any doubt that the complete merger takes place while living but it’s not the case for me as I stated above. Please also read my last post where I had already clarified my position about these shabads.
Why is it so hard to believe that “Brahm meh jan, jan meh Paarbraham”. Gurbani says the same thing in numerous other shabads. And, if you read the whole shabad with pankaties “NANAK LEEN BHAIYO GOBIND SIYON, JIYON PAANI SANG PAANI”, you realize that it describes the attributes of a person (narr) who has taken the qualities of Vaheguru. This shabad further states that “KAAM KRODH JIH PARSAE NAHIN, TIH GHAT BRAHM NIVASA” and when Gur kirpa is on such person, he understand the “jugat”. And now, this person (through naam-jaap) is “leen” (jurriya hoya) with Gobind, like paani is in paani. If you don’t think this person is “leen” through “naam-jaap” (bhagati) then you tell me veer ji how is he “leen” with Vaheguru like “paani with paani”? We need to understand the essence of Gurmuki.
----------------------------------------
I don’t know what you are talking about. Correct me if I am wrong but you seem to be insisting that this merger we have with Vaheguru is temporary because it is only sustained through Naam and that the real merger takes place after death. far you have never provided any shabad to substantiate your philosophy. ]
------------------
Please don’t be mislead Veer ji. I really urge you to read ALL of Bhagat Namdev ji’s baani and try to understand his baani in its “totality”. This shabad in fact goes in my favour. Bhagat ji is doing benati (plea, request) to Vaheguru to save his laaj. He is saying that if “You mukat me after I am dead, no one will know that I am freed (implying that he will be “mukat” after death when his 84 is finished)
-----------------
Hehe! It is not going in your favour and it is not implying that mukati does happen after death. Bhagat jee is clearly saying that he does not want the mukati after death as promised by other religions. Sikhi believes in having the thing in your muthi as opposed to some promise of Sharab-e-tahoor or some hoor or apsara. We want it while living, not after death. Hath uppar saron jamauni hai.
---------------------
Here is the full shabad:
mo ka-o tooN na bisaar too na bisaar.
too na bisaaray raam-ee-aa. ||1|| rahaa-o.
Please do not forget me; please do not forget me. Please do not forget me, O Raamiya.
aalaavantee ih bharam jo hai mujh oopar sabh kopilaa. sood sood kar maar uthaa-i-o kahaa kara-o baap beethulaa.
The temple priests have doubts about this, and everyone is furious with me. They are calling me low-caste and untouchable, they beat me and drove me out; what should I do now, O Beloved Father beethul?
moo-ay hoo-ay ja-o mukat dayhugay mukat na jaanai ko-ilaa.
If I get mukati after I am dead, no one will know that I got mukati.
ay pandee-aa mo ka-o dhaydh kahat tayree paij pichhaNudee ho-ilaa. too jo da-i-aal kirpaal kahee-at haiN atibhuj bha-i-o apaarlaa.
These Pandits, these religious scholars, call me low-born; when they say this, they are tarnishing Your honor as well. You are called kind and compassionate; the power of Your Arm is absolutely unrivalled.
fayr dee-aa dayhuraa naamay ka-o pandee-an ka-o pichhvaarlaa.
The Lord turned the temple around to face Naam Dayv; He turned His back on the Brahmins.
Pls don’t go into the history of Bhagat ji as I am aware of it. Just stick to the point we are discussing here.
--------------------------
Nice translation! It is an amazing shabad and records an important even of Bhagat jee’s life. Thanks for the translation.
-------------------
Since you mentioned Bhagat Namdev ji, here are some more pankaties by same Bhagat ji that you should ponder upon:
- “ajaimal kee-o baikuntheh thaan”.
Wondering why I cited this pankati J? You said that Devpuri means “SachKhand”, then what does “Baikunth” means here? I bet it doesn’t mean SachKhand to you here because how can ajaimal get to Sach Khand without the SATGURU, Guru Nanak Dev ji. What I am implying here is that we tend to side with the meaning that suits out understanding of gurbani.
---------------
Yes it does not mean Sach Khand here. Baikunth is another realm where bhagats of aanmat go. Nice place to be but I rather go to Sach Khand.
------------------------
-- jahaa jahaa Dhoo-a naarad taykay naik tikaavahu mohi, tayray naam avilamb bahut jan udhray naamay kee nij mat ayh.
Please place me where You placed Dhroo and Naarad, (O my Beethal). With the Support of Your Name, so many have been saved; this is Naam Dayv's understanding.
Now, tell me if you think Bhagat ji is begging his “Beethal” (Vaheguru) to place him where Dhroo and Naarad are placed. If you say yes, then we will go further on this.
------------------
Naik means don’t. This is the translation that Bhai Sahib did of this pankiti. Bhagat jee is saying that don’t just leave me at the point where Dhru and Narad are placed i.e. in the middle. Take me all the way to Sach Khand.
--------------
-- mahaa maa-ee kee poojaa karai, nar sai naar ho-ay a-utarai.
One who worships the Great Goddess Maya, will be reincarnated as a woman, and not a man.
Literally speaking, do you think that it’s so bad to be born as a woman and not as a man? Do I need to write the famous words of Guru Nanak Dev ji here?
---------------
There is nothing wrong in this shabad. According to Gurmat, you become the roop of whom you worship. If you worship Vaheguru, you become like him and if you worship this woman Devi, then you will have to become a woman. It is not saying that woman is a bad janam or that man’s janam is a good janam. It is just telling the truth.
---------------------
And, how would you interpret the following Shabad by bhagat ji? And, do let me know if you agree with Professor Sahib Singh’s interpretation here J:
Dhan Dhan o raam bayn baajai.
Blessed, blessed is that flute which the Lord plays.
maDhur maDhur Dhun anhat gaajai. ||1|| rahaa-o.
The sweet, sweet unstruck sound current sings forth. ||1||Pause||
Dhan Dhan mayghaa romaavalee.
Blessed, blessed is the wool of the sheep;
Dhan Dhan krisan odhai kaaNblee. ||1||
blessed, blessed is the blanket worn by Krishna. ||1||
Dhan Dhan too maataa dayvkee.
Blessed, blessed are you, O mother Dayvakee;
jih garih rama-ee-aa kavalaapatee. ||2||
into your home the Lord was born. ||2||
Dhan Dhan ban khand bindraabanaa.
Blessed, blessed are the forests of Brindaaban;
jah khaylai saree naaraa-inaa. ||3||
the Supreme Lord plays there. ||3||
bayn bajaavai goDhan charai.
He plays the flute, and herds the cows;
naamay kaa su-aamee aanad karai. ||4||1||
Naam Dayv's Lord and Master plays happily. ||4||1||
Literally speaking, what does narayan means in the shabad above? Who is Bhagat ji talking about here? “naamay kaa su-aamee aanad karai”
-------------------------
I have no idea what you are trying to show here but we will discuss this shabad if you want. In my humble opinion this is an amazing shabad that I love to sing and hear. Balwinder Singh Rangila sang this shabad in an amazing way. I just love this shabad. And Siri Krishna was a great avatar but whatever his power was or beauty was, it was that of Vaheguru. You must note one great point in this shabad though. Bhagat jee is not saying that “Krishan Beyn Baaje” but deliberatly said “Raam Beyn baaje”. Raam and Krishna are two different avatars and ones who worship Krishna can never worship Raam and vice-versa. Over here, Bhagat jee is talking about Vaheguru jee’s khel.
And Krishna was a very blessed soul and a great avtaar. Gurbani in this shabad clearly says that even his Mata was Dhan and so was everything around him. But Bhagat jee is saying that it is because of Narayan in him.
I have only good things to say about Siri Krishna and don’t say bad about him. Gurbani too has praised his good works and chided his mistakes.
-----------------
Here is some more by the same Bhagat ji:
dooDh katorai gadvai paanee. kapal gaa-ay naamai duhi aanee. ||1||
Naam Dayv milked the brown cow, and brought a cup of milk and a jug of water to his family god. ||1||
dooDh pee-o gobinday raa-ay.
"Please drink this milk, O my gobinday.
dooDh pee-o mayro man patee-aa-ay.
Drink this milk and my mind will be happy.
naahee ta ghar ko baap risaa-ay. ||1|| rahaa-o.
Otherwise, my father will be angry with me."||1||Pause||
so-in katoree amrit bharee.
Taking the golden cup, Naam Dayv filled it with the ambrosial milk,
lai naamai har aagai Dharee. ||2||
and placed it before Har||2||
ayk bhagat mayray hirday basai. naamay daykh naraa-in hasai. ||3||
narayin looked upon Naam Dayv and smiled. "This one devotee abides within my heart."||3||
dooDh pee-aa-ay bhagat ghar ga-i-aa.
HE drank the milk, and bhagat ji returned home.
naamay har kaa darsan bha-i-aa. ||4||3||
Thus did Naam Dayv come to receive the Blessed Vision of the Lord's Darshan. ||4||3
Literally speaking, what would you say about the shabad describing the vision of Hari by Bhagat ji? Don’t ask me what I think as I am not question anything here. If bhagat ji was completely merged in Vaheguru like paani sang paani, then what does this shabad mean? He is feeding milk to his Narayan Here. And, please don’t ignore or dismiss my comments as we are doing Gurbani Vichaar here.
---------------------------
This shabad is an example of an event of life of Bhagat jee. At the time these bhagats wrote this baani or said this baani, they were pooran and one as “paani sang paani” but they are describing an event of their life. You cannot draw the conclusion from this, that they were not one as Paani sang paani. There surely were and that’s how they were able to write Baani.
----------------------
Here is one more:
paakhantan baaj bajaa-ilaa, garurh charhHay gobind aa-ilaa.
Playing on the instrument of the feathered wings, the Lord of the Universe came, mounted on the eagle garura.
apnay bhagat par kee partipaal, garurh charhHay aa-ay gopaal.
He cherished His devotee, and the Lord came, mounted on the eagle garura.
kaheh ta Dharan ikodee kara-o, kaheh ta lay kar oopar Dhara-o.
The Lord said to him, "If you wish, I shall turn the earth sideways. If you wish, I shall turn it upside down.”
Again literally speaking, who does savari of garurh? I know that you are very well read veer ji, so I just hope you don’t dismiss these lines by giving me the history of the whole incident of this shabad. Stick to the point of discussion which is “TAKING OR NOT GURBANI LITERALLY”. You have already stated: “When the pankitis are written in a straightforward way, what is the need to use other interpretations? Why not take it literally?” YOU CAN’T HAVE IT BOTH WAYS J.
-------------------
Again this shabad tells of an event of Bhagat jee’s life when he may have been doing sargun bhagti. At the time he wrote this shabad, he was a pooran bhagat after meeting the true Guru and he could now see that it was Vaheguru who had saved his honour at that time. Even though at the time of the incident, he may have sought the help of Chaturbhuji GaruR mounting Lord but it was Vaheguru who helped him in that form. I don’t see anything wrong in taking this in literal sense.
Bhagat jee has described this event in an honest way and we should accept his honest account. Whatever happened, he told us.
------------------
There are innumerable shabads of Gurbani that should not be taken literally as taking them out of context can be really misleading.
-----------------
I think none of the shabads that you have stated would be misleading if taken literally. However, I should repeat that I am not an advocate of taking everything literally. When something is so clearly black and white, then we must take it literally. I bet you don’t believe in Dharam Rai and Jammdoots either and probably will dismiss it because you don’t like to take things literally. It seems like you like to take things not as written in Gurbani but as you think they should be and then you seem to be interpreting things as you believe them to be.
Those who are proponents of not taking literally say that there is no need to japp Naam and that Gurbani should not be taken literally. They say that japping Naam is like chewing like bakree. They say that jammdoots and Dharam Rai are just daraavay used by our Guru Sahib. So if you are in that category, we cannot preach you. Only Guru Sahib can.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
>>>>>>
Your point is that because of the maanas dehi it cannot have complete merger but Gurbani says that don’t look at the maanas dehi and think that there is any difference between Bhagat and Vaheguru. From inside they are one. Here is the pankiti to prove that:
HAR KA SEWAK, SO HAR JEHA ||
BHED NA JAANO MAANAS DEHA ||
JIYON JAL TARANG UTHEY BAHU BHANTI
PHIR SALALE SALAL SMAINDA ||
In this above shabad Guru Sahib clearly says that the just like waves and ocean are one, same way Bhagat and Vaheguru are same. Don’t be mislead by the Maanas Deha and think that they are different. They are one.
This shabad shows me that while living bhagat and Vaheguru attain complete merger.
>>>>>>
If after all this discussion, you still don’t know what I mean by “jyoti jyot sammauna” after leaving this “manukh-juni” which is part of 84 lakh juni, I don’t expect to convince you. Next time when someone says “Guru Sahib “jyoti Jyot Sammaye”, please be sure to tell that they were always “jyoti jyot sammaye hoye” (and by that logic they didn’t have their own jyot in this World!).
Again, in your own words: “Bhagat and Vaheguru are same just like just waves and ocean are one(I also agree with this shabad by not the way you describe it). ..while living bhagat and Vaheguru attain complete merger”.
Do you agree that rehit is an absolute MUST here in this World and no one is exempt from it? Even Guru Gobind Singh ji took Amrit from Panj Pyaare. We must jaap naam, do panj baaniyan da paath at the minimum and follow full sikhi rehit. Now, if “Bhagat and Vaheguru are same just like waves and ocean are” and they are MEREGD into VAHEGRU 24/7 FOREVER AND EVER AND EVER TO ETERNIY WHILE BEING HERE ON EARTH, then why are they following all this rehit here in this World as all of us. AREN’T THEY ALREADY “MERGED INTO” VAHEGURU AND ARE SITTING IN SACHKHAND (by your own admission)? PLEASE TRY TO UNDERSTAND WHAT I MA SAYING AND REPLY ACCORDING TO YOUR OWN LOGIN AND WITH GURBANI.
------------------------------------------
Merging in Vaheguru does not mean that one should ignore what Guru Sahib’s hukam is. You are saying that your matlab with Guru is only till the time you merge in Vaheguru and after that you don’t need to follow Guru Sahib’s hukam. So long as they live in this world, they have to keep maryada of this world but this does not mean that they are not one with Vaheguru. If they do their worldly duties, they are still one with Vaheguru.
You are saying that whoever is in this human body cannot be one with Vaheguru. Looks like you don’t have any concept of milaap inside this human form. Our Guru Sahibaan are a perfect example of this. They were in human body but they were totally one with Vaheguru. Are you tellling me that after leaving this body, they had a second merger with Vaheguru? I think you need to think about this issue again and then make a decision. By your account it seems that you are saying that our Guru Sahibaan were not one with Vaheguru but only connected to Vaheguru through Naam? In your opinion they were not one aatmak-wise but only connected to Vaheguru.
I am sorry but you have not provided any claim from Gurbani that a second merger takes place as well. As for the term “Jyoti Jyot samauna” it does not appear anywhere in Gurbani. Gurbani does not believe in extinction of us after death.
--------------
Don't you see the difference between the two states, one being here in human form in Grist Jeevan and the other being there in Sach Khand in Jyot-Saroop (in your own words)?
-------------
The difference is there but this does not mean that a merger does not occur in the human body. Vaheguru appears right in this human body and merges with aatma forever and ever. Bhagats are totally ikk mikk with Vaheguru while living.
-----------------
>>>>>
So great is the merger between Bhagat and Vaheguru that Bhatts had to say, “Gur Arjun Partakh Har” i.e. Guru Arjun Dev jee is Saakshaat Vaheguru.
>>>>>
I have already commented on Bhatt Baani and said that Bhatts were able to “see” Vaheguru in Guru Sahib.
----------------------
To me this pankiti shows clearly the great merger of our Guru Sahibaan and Vaheguru while living. You are saying that this is not a merger but a connection through Naam and that second merger will take place after death. You however don’t quote baani anywhere to backup your claim. Where does it say in baani that a second merger takes place after death.
------------------------------
>>>>>
You write that “It BECOMES HIM and is in Param-Anand forever.” Think of it Veer J. Singh jeeo. Don’t you think that one needs to be have surtee to be in Parmanand (ultimate bliss)?
>>>>>
I will say what I have said many times on this thread, once jeev-atma samma in ParmAtma, they are EK JYOT. Atma has merged into the Parm-Consciousness and are out of all bandhans of Worldly aspirations. You keep on thinking in “selfish” manner. What would happen to “ME”? You are stuck with surtee or consciousness of your “SELF”? Who is this “YOU” but JYOT SAROOP, just an ansh of Vaheguru Jyot. What is Kulbir Singh? Not your Dehi that Devs simar. I don’t think you will comprehend what I am saying with the logic you are applying here.
----------------------------
Don’t worry about what I am stuck in. Answer the question I raised. How does one stay in bliss or enjoy bliss without surtee? You have failed to answer this question even after writing thousands of words. This is the crux of our argument. You say that they become one jyot. In essence, one of the ceases to live. That’s how you become one jyot. You yourself stated last post that the jyot is in Paramand but you don’t want to admit that it has surtee. How can you be in Parmanand without having consciousness about it? You please answer this.
I am not stuck with surtee but the main question is that you cannot be in anand if you don’t have surtee. Where does it say in Gurbani that we lose surtee? Please provide reference. I have given you pankitis that you have dismissed as metaphors. Now let us see pankitis from you that favour the loss of surtee in the ultimate merger.
-------------------------
>>>>>>
Ishrat-e-kathra hai Dariya me fanaah ho jaana ||
Darad ka hadd se guzarna hai davaa ho jaana ||
>>>>>
Although a sharabi, juaari, and a muffat-khor J, but indeed one of the greatest Urdu poet. I too love his syeri.
-----------------------
Haanji Miyaan Ghali kaan “Andaaz-e-biyaan aur” hee thaa.
------------------------------------------
>>>>>>>
----------
How about "tithae jodh mahabal soor". It doesn't mean that all of the jodhey, mahabali and soormey are going to end up in Karam Khand.
----------
This means exactly what it says. The Jodhay and Mahabalee Soormay who were able to wage war against 5 bikaars and maaiya and win this war, come to this Karam Khand.
>>>>>>>
This is a good example of taking something out of its context. You conveniently added “Jodhay and Mahabalee Soormay who were able to wage war against 5 bikaars and maaiya and win this war”. You ever gave a pankati from Giurbani but where is it written in the pankiti I cited from Jap Ji Sahib? THE PURPOSE OF MY WHOLE PARAGRAPH WAS TO PROVE THAT GURBANI SHOULDN’T “ALWAYS” BE TAKEN “LITERALLY”.
-----------------------
I provided you with a pankiti that had a defination of soora (warrior, jodha) in Gurbani but you conveniently ignored it. Please refer to my previous post for the same and you will realise that jodh mahabal soor are the ones who have Har Rang.
---------------------------
This is what I had written. Please read it. I have added additional comments to make it clearer:
You are playing with words here :-). All I am saying is that we should understand baani in the context it's written. We know Bhatts are praising Guru Sahibaan one by one, but when you read their baani closely, you get the feeling ( I do) that they aren't just talking about Guru Sahibaan in this human form, they are also praising Vaheguru that they "see" in Guru Sahibaan.
-----------------------
I agree with this paragraph.
-----------------------
How about "tithae jodh mahabal soor". It doesn't mean that ALL of the jodhey, mahabali and soormey are going to end up in Karam Khand.
------------
All Jodhay that are sooray according to Gurbani definition will go to Karam Khand.
---------------
Guru Sahib says, "paarbarahm saadh ridh basai" but it's it also true that "ghat ghat pooran barahm pargaas". If one takes the first pankati “literally”, one would believe that Parbrahm only resides in Saadh ridh but the second pankati it’s also clear that "ghat ghat pooran barahm pargaas". He indeed resides in ghat-ghat, whether jeevs recognize it or not. i.e. we shouldn’t always take Gurbani literally! We should learn it in totality, in its full context.
-------------------
I repeat my earlier assertion that ghat and rida are two different things. Ghat literally means a ghaRA the clay pot and in Gurbani the body has been called a ghat. Rida on the other hand is dil. Gurbani will never say that Parbraham is in the mann of a Saakat or a ridai of a manmukh. It would however say that it is in the ghat of everyone. So realise the difference between the two terms.
-------------------
How about "Saadh kai sang sabh kul uDhaarai, saadhsang saajan meet kutamb nistaarai". Don't get me wrong, I do understand what these pankatian mean but not by taking them literally. We can't just interpret that with doing the sangat of a saadh, one's kul, saajan, meet and kutamb will all get uDhaar. i.e. they “ALL” must jaap-naam INDIVIDUALLY as one's kul, saajan, meet and kutamb WILL NOT get uDhaar because one does sangat of saadh.
-------------------
As I said before that if one person gets his udhaar, his 21 kuls too get udhaar. How? The process starts. Vaheguru does kirpa on them and they meet the true Guru and start leading their life according to Sikhi and eventually they do their udhaar.
------------------------------
>>>>>>
----------
Guru Sahib says, "paarbarahm saadh ridh basai" but it's it also true that "ghat ghat pooran barahm pargaas".
----------
I don’t know what you are trying to make out of this. It looks like you are saying that there seems to be a contradiction in these two pankitis. But such is not the case.
In the case of former, it means that Vaheguru has become pargat in a Saadh and in latter case it means that in everyone, Vaheguru hee Vaheguru hai i.e. he alone pervades in everything.
>>>>>>
Please read my response above. As you know from not taking these pankities literally, there is indeed no contradiction. How would you have known this by taking the pankities literally. Ridh and ghat means the same. It’s a very convenient (in my meager opinion) to say that they don’t mean the same but Devpuri and SachKhand do mean the same as it fits your understanding.
------------------------
Show me how ghat and ridai means the same. It is my opinion that they mean different things. I would stand corrected if you prove otherwise.
--------------------------------
>>>>>>
I was responding to your claim that all ten Guru Sahibaan are sitting alongside Vaheguru on a Throne in Sach Khand for Eternity. This shabad doesn’t say that at all. On one side you are saying that COMPLETE MERGER happens here on Earth. On the other hand, you are saying that this shabad literally means That Veheguru himself came to receive Guru Sahib and gave him throne to sit on in DEVPURI (which means SachKhand to you). Wasn’t Guru Sahib FULLY COMPLETE MERGED with Vaheguru like “PAANI Sang PAANI”? Weren’t they already sitting in Sach Khand alongside Vaheguru forever and ever while being here on Earth at the same time? These are your own words! I think you are siding with me here indirectly by saying that this merger is happening after “Jyoti Jyot Samma”. I am confused! There is lot more I can say here but WILL NOT.
>>>>>
---------------------------
You claimed that there is no throne in Devpuri. I showed you the pankiti that shows clearly that there is a throne in Sach Khand. After Guru Sahib left his human body, though he was still merged with Vaheguru, he was brought out of this realm of maat-lok and taken to Sach Khand. There no merger too place but he was seated on the royal throne by Vaheguru himself. It just proves my point that you stay merged but you retain consciousness and surtee here and in Sach Khand.
-------------------------------
>>>>>>
--------
NO, I don't have it totally wrong jeer ji. You, perhaps, didn't understand me. Atma's nij ghar is Parmatma. I also understand that everything is within us and not outside.
----------
Not at a single place in Gurbani (in my opinion) has Nij Ghar come in the meanings of Parmatma. Gurbani does not interpret Nij Ghar as Vaheguru. Please show a single pankiti that says that Nij Ghar means Vaheguru.
>>>>>>
Don’t try to twist what I wrote by playing with words veer ji. Where did I say Nij Ghar = Vaheguru. Nij means kudh (apna, mine) and Ghar means home. Simple! So, Atma's real final destination, its mool origin (nij ghar) is INDEED Parmatma.
------------------------
No you said that Aatma’s nij ghar is Vaheguru and I objected to the use of word Nij Ghar because Nij Ghar means totally something else. Nij ghar is the place in this human Body where Vaheguru and Aatma get their merger. After that merger, no other merger is required as you claim.
----------------------------------------
>>>>>>
Just read the last couple of sentences of your paragraph quoted above. You say that when aatma gets merged in Vaheguru it is ultimate anand. But anand for who? Vaheguru or Aatma? My position is that Vaheguru is already in Anand. Nothing special if after merger this anand continues for Vaheguru. Anand is also for jeev-aatma who gets merged in Vaheguru and this anand can only happen if Jeev-aatma has surtee.
>>>>>>
What more special treatment do you want then to be ONE with Vaheguru Jyot? Once atma gets merged (samma) in Parmatma, there is no duality. Parmjyot is in ultimate anand. You can’t understand what I am saying if you keep on thinking in the same selfish manner. Who is Kulbir Singh, Mann, Atma, or something else.
------------------------------
You have not answered my question above. I asked you clearly how can you have anand if you don’t exist? You keep repeating your mantra that I am selfish for refusing to merge in Vaheguru. I am not being selfish or anything but I am just stating the facts. It is nice to know that Vaheguru does not destroy us after this life. That’s all. You claim to the contrary. You are imagining Vaheguru to be some vaccum machine that sucks up the soul inside him and merging you totally.
Imagine the feeling you would have just before the merger that is another name of your destruction. There would be cheek-chihaaRa in Sach Khand as you define it. Your thought of mukti is as scary thought man and thankfully Gurbani does not support your assertion.
---------------------------
>>>>>>>
You ask that aatma does not experience happiness and sorrow, then how is it experiencing Anand.
>>>>>>
I AM NOT SAYING THIS VEER Ji, SHRI GURU ARJAN DEV JI SAYS THIS. You wrote yourself that atma is beyond HAPPINESS AND SORROW. Now you are saying: “To be happy or to feel HAPPINESS, don’t you think the most fundamental thing is consciousness i.e. surtee? If there is no consciousness, who is going to enjoy happiness?” I urge you to stick with one mode of thinking veer ji.
---------------------
I am sticking to my original version but it is you who is picking up fragments of my writings and holding me to it. I wrote clearly that I am not only aatma but also mann and surtee. Gurbani says so. Aatma is there too but not only aatma. Tithai ghareeye surat matt mann budh proves that before entering Sach Khand we get carved out surat, matt, mann and budh. We maintain all this.
--------------------------------
>>>>>
I beg for maazrat but please read what you are writing. You write “Atma has become part of Parmatma and stays in bliss. Sadd-jeevan is only with Vaheguru.”
First you were saying that aatma experiences no happiness or sorrow but now you say that it is in bliss. And then you say that sadd-jeevan is with Vaheguru only. The word “with” implies that aatma is still conscious and so does your assertion that it is in bliss.
I was saying that just as a person in chloroform cannot feel any dukh or such, same way a jeev-aatma that has lost consciousness cannot have any anand. Anand can only be felt by surtee or consciousness. So what do you mean here in the quote above?
>>>>>>>
Problem isn’t with what I wrote. It lies in what you want to read. Please read again. What do I mean by “Atma has become part of Parmatma”? The word “with” doesn’t imply anything. You can create this “phambal-phoosa” but I will not get entangled in it J.
Again, I do understand and respect what you saying, but I don’t agree with you. I don’t agree that atma will stay separate from Vaheguru while merged in Vaheguru and it will have its own separate SELF with surtee or consciousness to enjoy bliss. It will sit in Sachkhand doing Bhagati to eternity. What happened to the selfless love of Vaheguru? You still crying SELF, SELF not Vaheguru, Vaheguru or Tuhi, tuhi. What about “ME”? Vaheguru is self-created. He is the ONE and ONLY who contemplated this whole Srishti, this Khel, which includes everything.
-----------------------------------------------
I too respect what you write but I am saying this with maazrat that you have not substantiated your beliefs through Gurbani. You wrote a lot of Gurbani but not relevant to this subject. I mean you brought a lot of other topics in this topic but did not produce one pankiti that says that a second merger takes place in Sach Khand and you did not produce single pankiti that says that you lose surtee after merger with Vaheguru.
----------------------------------------
>>>>
It is a pure Gurmat Principle that water can absorb baani or become amrit because of baani. The whole initiation (Khanday baatay da amrit) ceremony of Khalsa is dependent on this. Punj Pyaray recite 5 baaniyan while stirring patasay in water with their khanda. This water after all 5 baniyaan is considered amrit and is administered to new Sikhs. This ceremony is not a
pakhand. It is a true ceremony and this water does indeed become amrit i.e. such water that has accepted baani.
Same way, the sarovar of Ramdas Sarovar is amritmai. Just look at the name of this sarovar – Amritsar. Amrit da sar i.e. sarovar of Amrit.
>>>>
Pressing a very emotional button here, aren't we :-). Being a singh, how can and why would I say that Khanday Baatay da Amrit is a pakhand? You are getting a little carried away here. Naam is supreme and Guru ji gave us the the bidhi (ceremony) to get this naam. Now, pls. answer this question: Is it accordance to Gurmatt to carry this "amrit water" (water that has become amrit by accepting baani for over 400 years) from Ramdas Sarovar in bottles to cure our dukhs, kashts and sins? Of course we need to naam jaap along with the amrit water. As you would agree, not everyone has access and the resources to get to the sarover.
-----------------
Please don’t avoid this issue now. You started it and you should go all the way with it. My position is that water can retain the affect of Gurbani and Naam and this is how Amrit is prepared. The foundation of Sikhi is standing on it. The shabad of “Jithay jaaye bahae mera Satguru” proves that any place where our Guru Sahib sets his charan, becomes pure.
>>>>>>
I didn’t avoid the “issue” as I told you what I thought about it. Being a singh, I have full faith in Khanday Baatay da Amrit” ceremony but my understanding doesn’t necessarily have to match yours. First you agreed with me that “it’s baani not paani” that cures dukhs, kashts and sins. Now you are saying that it is perfectly in accordance to Gurmat to bring amritmai water of Raamdaas Sarovar in bottles to cure dukhs, kashts and sins. Power is not in the Paani, it’s in Gurbani. You are welcome to carry Khanda da amrit (that retains baani) in bottles to do whatever pleases you but, to me, it’s the Panj Pyaare (Parmesher, Vaheguru) who give NAAM and the shakti through baani.
--------------------------------------------
It is baani and not paani but this paani has become sacred because of baani in it. Khanday da amrit is not allowed out of the amrit samagam room, so I cannot take your advice of taking it with me in bottles.
And mark my word that you will one day beg for this Raamdaas sarovar amrit paani, when you need it. No other way you will understand it.
-------------------------------------------
>>>>>>>>>>>>
----------------
>>>>> I have no qualms over accepting that Siri Guru Angad Dev jee was an avatar of Raja Janak. >>>>>
I have read your posts on some of the other topics. Don't you believe that Guru Sahibaan are the only true (sat) Gurus (one jyot) of all lok, parlok, khands and brehmands. They were sent directly by Vaheguru to do our udhaar. For example, didn't you say that it was "Guru Sahib" who save the laaj (honor) od Panchali in Raaj Sabha? I can find more if you like. Now your are saying, "I have no qualms over accepting that Siri Guru Angad Dev jee was an avatar of Raja Janak".
--------------
Here is what my understanding is of this issue. There is Vaheguru. Then there is Vaheguru’s own saroop that is there for udhaar purposes. This form of Vaheguru is called the Guru-form of Vaheguru and is totally merged in Vaheguru i.e. totally one with him but still distinguishable to Bhagats. This Guru-form is also called Guru-jyot and is also called Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj. The presence of this Guru-jyoti in our ten Gurus make them Guru Sahibaan. I could be wrong but Nij-aatma or the nijj-self of Guru Sahibaan got enhanced once the Guru jyot entered in all of them. Before they were aatma like us but with the presence of Gurjyoti, they became Satgurus. Before they were Brahmgiyanis but once Guru-jyoti was entered in them, they became Satgurus. Gurbani talks about the passing of this Guru jyoti from Guru to Guru, while staying in the first jaama too.
>>>>>>>
There is a lot I like to say here but I will stay quite at the moment. First you say that Guru Angad Dev jee were an avatar of Raja Janak and a bhagat of a devi. Now you are saying, “they were Brahmgiyanis before but once Guru-jyoti was entered in them, they became Satgurus.” You may go the convenient way and say that they become Brahmgiani after meeting Guru Nanak Dev ji! (I say it was the “will” of the Almightly Vaheguru). If Guru-jyoti entered in them when they becaome guru, then what was in Guru Nanank Dev ji, as they were still in human form? Now you would say there were more than one Satguru jyoties. Do you believe that there can be more than one Satguru? Don’t get me wrong, I am just asking. By the way, what do you think happen to Sache Patshah Guru Nanak Dev Ji after they “Jyoti Jyot Samma”. Does the same logic apply here that applies to Guru Raam Daas Ji’s Akaal Chalanah?
-------------------------------------
Before meeting Guru Sahib they were devi worshippers. Then after meeting Guru Sahib they became a Brahmgyani. Finally after Guru Sahib passed on the jyot to them (Read Ramkali kee Vaar, first and second pauri), they became Siri Guru Angad Dev jee. As they became Satguru, Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee who too had the Guru-jyot in him did matha tek to Siri Guru Angad Dev jee. Our Guru Sahibaan, all ten of them, have their own aatmas and then they all are also Satgurus because of the presence of Guru-jyot in them.
----------------
Please read Raamkalee kee Vaar by Satta Doom And Raa-ai Balwand carefully.
-------------
Sat Bachan jee.
---------------------------------
>>>>>>>
The Gurujyot alone did udhaar of Panchaali and of Prahlaad too. This Guru-jyot that was gupt before or worked through Raam, Krishna etc. became pargat in Kalyug and called itself Guru Nanak Dev jee and other ten Guru Sahibaan.
>>>>>>>
What can I say here other than that I respect your understanding of Gurbani while disagreeing with you completely.
---------------------------
Theek hai jee.
---------------------------
>>>>>
By suggesting that Raamdaas Sarovar is just ordinary water, you have belittled the importance of Sarovars and hurt the feelings of millions of Sikhs who are dying to get ishnaan in these sarovars.
>>>>>>
You are welcome to accuse me but I am not one for “sensationalism”. I don’t think that I didn’t hurt the feelings of millions of Sikhs Worldwide. I have explained what I think already.
--------------------------
Theek hai jee.
----------------------------
>>>>>>>>
Here is the summary of the issues:
1) What more merger can you have than being merged like water to water as in the pankiti “paani sang paani?
>>>>>
I have already made my stand clear on this. I ask you again to review earlier replies.
---------------------
You have failed to prove anything because you could not provide relevant Gurbani reference.
-------------------------------
>>>>>
2) After this merger as stated above, why is there any other merger necessary? Vaheguru becomes pargat in one’s ghat and one’s aatma becomes one with Vaheguru right in this Human Body. Why is there need for another merger after death?
>>>>>
I can’t agree with you more that it’s through this human dehi that we get a chance to realize (see, meet) our pyaara Vaheguru by naam-abiyas but this body is naash-vaan. Jeev-atma leaves this human dehi (this dehi which IS part of the 84 lakh juni) and “JYOTI JYOT SAMMA” in Parm-Jyot. Atma doesn’t get destroyed, decimated or fanah as it becomes part of its mool origin (its real ghar, since you didn’t like the word “nij”).
-------------------------
On one hand you say that the aatma does not get fanaah or decimated and on the other hand you say that it loses surtee. I don’t understand this Gorakh dhanda.
Then you say that it goes to real ghar but what kind of ghar would decimate you. Why don’t you call it its “graveyard”. Graveyard seems like a more appropriate word for it. Hehe!
-------------------------
>>>>>>
3) If bhagats don’t lose consciousness of self while merging so close that they are paani sang paani, why would they lose it in the next world?
>>>>>>
As long as they are here in this world, they are still a part of 84 lakh juni and have their ATMA. Read Bhagat Namdev ji’s baani and see how desperately converses with Vaheguru. I urge you to read and understand all of Gurbani in its full context to get the essence.
----------------------
I will take your advice and try to understand baani more closely.
--------------------------------
>>>>>>
4) You seem to be suggesting that dehi is a hindrance in complete merger. What difference does it make whether the bhagat is in this body or anywhere in this universe as long as he is merged in Vaheguru?
>>>>>>
I have explained the difference earlier in this post.
>>>>>>
---------------------------
It is my humble opinion that you talked a lot but did not prove anything. You could not provide a single pankiti that shows that this aatma gets decimated in Sach Khand and that it loses surtee after merger.
--------------------------------------
5) Where does it say in Gurbani that Bhagats lose consciousness in the next world? Please quote a pankiti. I agree that they are ikk-mikk but why do they lose surtee? Where does it say in Gurbani that they lose surtee.
>>>>>>
In my humble opinion, your fixation with SELF is blinding you from seeing what is obvious. Atma is nirgun and pure and it’s a part of ParmAtma. Atma’s surti and consciousness is same as Vaheguru. There is no difference between the two after they “jyoti jyot samma”. I can give you the same pankities you are using to prove that bhagats are sitting in front of Vaheguru in Sachkhand doing His bhagati with their individual consciousness and surti intact while being merged in Vaheguru. They have free to whatever they “will”, go wherever they want in the brehmand while being completely merged in Vaheguru in sachkhand. Doesn’t matter how many pankities I provide, I don’t think they will change your opinion. But that’s fine.
-----------------------------------
Please provide pankitis to show me that one loses surtee in Sach Khand. Don’t talk your manmatt. Talk about Gurmat (Gurbani). I can talk my manmatt and you don’t have to listen to it and viceversa but we all listen to Gurbani. Let’s see a pankiti that proves your point.
-------------------------------
>>>>>>>
6) You have stated that Bhagats are in Parmanand (ultimate bliss) after merger. How can they be in bliss if they cannot feel it and don’t have surtee. You have never replied to this question. How can you enjoy bliss without surtee? Surtee is a must if you want to enjoy bliss.
>>>>>
Don’t put words in my mouth Veer ji. I have answered your question not once but few times on this thread but the answer is not of your liking. I suggest that you read my posts more carefully. I have clearly maintained that jeev-atma goes back to Parmatma and becomes ONE. You are thinking too much in human terms. ATMA IS PART OF PARMATMA. ITS REAL DESTINATION IS PARMATMA. PARMATMA IS IN ULTIMATE ANAND. AFTER IT’S 84 GETS CUT WITH GUR-KIRPA AND IT GOES BACK TO IT’S REAL MOOL GHAR (origin) PARMATMA. IT WAS ONLY PARMATMA WHEN HE CREATED EVERYTHING AND IT WILL ONLY BE PARMATMA WHEN HE DECIDES TO FOLD THIS DREAM WORLD (SUPNA JAISA SANSAAR).
-----------------------------------------
Please provide a single pankiti that shows that Bhagats lose surtee after merger and that a second merger takes place. You have provided a lot of irrelevant pankitis but none of them touched the main issue here. Let us talk about the issue on hand.
---------------------------------
>>>>>>
7) Surtee is a must if you want Sadd-jeevan. If you don’t have surte or consciousness, you cannot have life or your life is like a purgatory.
>>>>>>
You are still stuck with SELF PRESERVATION. UNLESS YOU GET OUT OF THIS MODE OF SELF AND SEE “TUHI TUHI” THERE IS NO WAY THAT YOU WILL EVER SEE WHAT I AM TALKING ABOUT. YOU NEED TO UNDERSTAND WHAT WE REALLY ARE. WE ARE JYOT SAROOP. ONLY VAHEGURU IS SACH AND, LOGICALLY, ONLY HE HAS SADD-JEEVAN.
---------------------------------
Just in case you did not know, capitals stand for “yelling”. Why are you yelling at me?
I am not stuck in anything but Gurbani. When you say tuhi tuhi, that too proves two entities – one that is saying tuhi tuhi and Vaheguru. So please prove to me that we get destroyed after merger with Vaheguru and that a second merger takes place.
--------------------------------
8) If amrit of Khanda baata is prepared through baani and if that water can retain the affect of baani, why can’t Raamdaas Sarovar too retain the affect of Gurbani. The question here is whether water can retain the affect of Gurbani or not.
You, yourself said that “it’s not paani but baani that does everything”. Now you are saying otherwise. “Amrit Baani har har teri, parh parh hoi parmghat meri”. I have full faith in khande baate da amrit as Desmesh Pita prescribed this initiation for us. You are free to carry “Amrit in Bottles” to cure people and relieve their “sins” with it but don’t ask me to follow this ritual.
-----------------------
I am not asking you to follow this ritual but I have a feeling that you will beg for the water of Raamdaas Sarovar. The day will come when Guru Sahib does kirpa on you and you realise the importance of this great teerath. Till then, let us agree to disagree.
----------------------
Veer ji, I say again that let’s just agree to disagree on this one issue. Gurbani is infinite (aseem) Ocean and we are mere Masklies. Let Vaheguru reveal this mystery to us (if we have the good fortune :–) Wishful thinking indeed).
--------------------
Nothing wishful here. You are a good man and will one day meet your Lord. But hopefully we both will have good time in Sach Khand. Then I will tease you on this silly merger thing you have been talking about. We will all tease you then.
----------------
I am a nimmana sikh, so please forgive me for my mistakes as there are tons in my post above.
----------------
Nimaanay taan tussi bahut hee ziyaada ho.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
P Singh · 30 Mar 2005
Very interesting topic indeed. The Universe is expanding and will continue to expand as beings send out thoughts (as we know thoughts create), basically the expanding of the universe is the exhale of Vahiguru and the contracting is an inhale, based on this who knows when we truly decimate? Before creation there was only God, only bliss, how can bliss know bliss without expereincing non-bliss?
I don't not believe Sikhs are in anyway superior and have access to these high realms more then anyone else, God does not play favorites to anyone. This whole "my method is superior then yours" is the thing that wages wars and takes us away from advancing. There is a huge batch of literature that talks about higher realms and many people are coming out in the open and telling others about there near death expereinces, pieces of the puzzle are coming together quite fast. Seek and you shall find.
Out beyond the ideas of right doing
and wrong doing is a field --
I'll meet you there.
~Rumi
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
P Singh · 30 Mar 2005
What is the purpose of decimating when most of beings aren't even close to doing so? Saints come again and again to help us.
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 30 Mar 2005
I write this to retract my earlier translation of the following pankiti:
Tu ta Raja Janak Autaar ||
I read Bhai Sahib's translation again yesterday night, and I have to agree with the translation that Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has done i.e. Janak here means Vadda and not Raja Janak. The definition of "Janak" has been done in Gurbani as follows:
"Janak soye, jin janiya, unman rath bhariya |"
(So is Janak, who knows Vaheguru and is one with him)
Guru Angad Dev jee was a Vadda Avtaar and Raaj Avtaar. Bhai Sahib has done these meanings and I agree with Bhai Sahib. I retract my agreement in earlier posts that Raja Janak da avtaar. My apologies.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
J Singh · 30 Mar 2005
Kulbir Singh ji,
There is so much to say but let me just address the following first.
>>>>
Just in case you did not know, capitals stand for “yelling”. Why are you yelling at me?
>>>>>
LOL, I am no yelling at you Veer ji. I don't know how to use BOLD here on this forum. So I used capitals. Take my capitals as bold letters from now on. You almost always write baani in CAPITALS, I never said you were yelling baani. Please take your own advice and don't yell baani :-). First you said I hurt the feelings of millions of Sikhs Worldwide. Now you say that I
am yelling :-) at you. Since you know that I hurt millions of Sikhs, I request to you to let them all know that we are just doing some vichaar here.
You didn't answer half of what I wrote. I can only hope you really read what I wrote before responding to it.
Before getting lost in the quagmire of detail, let me just say a few things.
You conveniently dismiss Professor Sahib Singh's interpretation when it doesn't suit your cause on sabads such as "Begampra", "jahaa jahaa Dhoo-a naarad taykay" and many other shabads. You call his interpretation dry and un-spiritual when it doesn't suit your matt but you gladly point out to his direction when it suit your purpose. Go ahead and call him dry and un-spiritual or whatever you want but I do believe this great Gursikh who devoted himself to such great sewa and spent so much time on the
athiyaan of Guru Granth Sahib ji. Show me any of his contemporary or predecessor who single-handedly did such deep teeka of SGGS ji. Everyone who followed him, basically just used him as a source to do their teekas including Bhai Veer Singh.
You keep on asking me to provide pankities but you haven't been able to prove any of your own tall claims AT ALL. You gave pankities but they don't mean what you say they mean.
You claim that all ten Guru Sahibaan are sitting alongside Vaheguru on a Throne in Sach Khand for Eternity (forever and ever). The only shabad you could come up with was the shabad that describes Siri Guru Raamdaas ji's akaal-chalanah. Don't you see it goes against your whole concept! First you say that all ten Guru Sahibaan are sitting alongside Vaheguru on a throne in Sach Khand for Eternity. Then you turn around and say this shabad literally means that Veheguru Himself came to receive Guru Sahib and gave him throne to sit on in DEVPURI (which conveniently means Sach Khand to you) after their akaal-chalanah. If Guru Sahib is already sitting with Vaheguru on a throne then which "nirgun" atma did Vaheguru came to
receive!! Make up your mind. Aren't they already sitting in Sach Khand alongside Vaheguru forever and ever? Aren't Guru Sahib FULLY COMPLETE MERGED with Vaheguru in Sach Khand according your own logic? It's just your own matt.
You make atma look and sound just like humans. It sits, it's happy, it's conscious, it has surti, it does bhagati of Vaheguru while
being there completely merged in Him. What is this Gorakh-dhandha you talking about :-)?
Who created Vaheguru? Vaheguru Himself. Who created this universe including atma? Vaheguru Himself. Who can do anything and everything? Vaheguru. Who alone can end this whole khel and fold ("samma") his own ansh back into Him? Vaheguru and Vaheguru alone.
You wrote chapter after chapters and I obliged you by answering to everything.
Where exactly does it say in Grubani that bhagats are sitting in front of Vaheguru in Sachkhand doing His bhagati with their individual consciousness and surti intact while being MERGED in Vaheguru. They have their personal free "will" to do whatever, go wherever they want while being completely merged in Vaheguru in sachkhand. It's just your own matt.
Say what you may but "bhagat tere mann bhaavde" doesn't mean what you make it out to mean. Do you think Vaheguru is a person who has a "mann"? Bhagats have physical bodies that they look beautiful?
Gurbani teachings are for all of us mortals here on Earth. So logically, there are tons of examples throughout Gurbani that use everyday stuff we see here to make us understand our mool origin. Guru Sahibaan and bhagats use duniyavi things to simplify and to demonstrate their points to us. Gurbani also uses names and incidents from other religions of that time to clarify to us who we really are. How else would we understand? Gurbani tells us how we can realize Him in this janam through NAAM, but this juni is also part of the 84 lakh juni and this dehi will disappear one day. Akaal Purakh isn't a person.
You stated, "why shouldn't we take Gurbani shabads literally?" I gave you numerous pankites to prove that we just can't. You had to add a lot of explanation and conditions to prove what those same pankities really meant! Yet you don't or don't want to get my point. Wasn't the whole point of this exercise to prove that you can't just take a shabad or a pankiti literally? Come on, be real now. What makes your matt Gurmat and mine manmat?
You just change interpretation of gurbani to fit your own arguments.
- - “ajaimal kee-o baikuntheh thaan”. "Devpuri" means “SachKhand” but “Baikunth” does not. It means something lower.
- Straight pankiti "jahaa jahaa Dhoo-a naarad taykay naik tikaavahu mohi, tayray naam avilamb bahut jan udhray naamay kee nij mat ayh" doesn't mean what Pro Sahib Singh says. Where does bhagat ji say that don't leave me in the middle?
- You ignored the real meaning of the next shabad I mentioned by just saying, "Nice translation". You are the one who had cited the pankiti from the same shabad to prove your point.
- "mahaa maa-ee kee poojaa karai, nar sai naar ho-ay a-utarai." We were talking about your "why not take Gurbani literally" point? What does "nar sai naar ho-ay a-utarai" means? Will be born as a woman, not as a man? Both can realize Vaheguru. Literally speaking, what wrong to be born as a woman, not as a man?
- In the next shabad I cited, if you take it LITERALLY, it CLEARLY means that Bhagat ji is calling Krishna his "Narayan" and his suaamee. “naamay kaa su-aamee aanad karai”. You HAD to explain that Siri Krishna was a great avatar but whatever his power was or beauty was, it was that of Vaheguru. I have been saying all along that we shouldn't just interpret Gurbani literally. Of course it's Vaheguru, who else? THE WHOLE POINT WAS NOT TO TAKE GURBANI LITERALLY.
You say that Krishna was a very blessed soul and a great avtaar. You also said that Guru Angad Dev ji were avtaar of Raja Janak.
- Bhagat ji is literally feeding milk to his Narayan in the next shabad I cited. You conveniently said, "At the time these bhagats wrote this baani or said this baani, they were pooran and one as “paani sang paani” but they are describing an event of their life." It's completed beyond me how did you come this conclusion by reading this shabad. Read the shabad again!
- In the next shanbad, I asked you, "who does savari of garurh?"
You responded, "Again this shabad tells of an event of Bhagat jee’s life when he may have been doing SARGUN BHAGATI. At the time he wrote this shabad, he was a pooran bhagat after meeting the true Guru and he could now see that it was Vaheguru who had saved his honour at that time. Even though at the time of the incident, he may have sought the help of
Chaturbhuji GaruR mounting Lord but it was Vaheguru who helped him in that form. I don’t see anything wrong in taking this in literal sense."
Come on, where did you come up with the above interpretation. Why would Guru Sahib add the shabad in Gurbani? Don't add your own matt, GURBANI IS always SAT SAT.
>>>>>>>
Our Guru Sahibaan and Bhagat Sahibaan wrote this baani but it was also meant for us as well. These shabads of “not to visaar” and other such shabads are mostly meant for us.
>>>>>>
Where did you get this idea that all these shabads are mostly meant for us? Bhagats are spilling their heart out in pyaar and bairaag and you are saying that isn't meant for them! What are they pleading and begging for?
>>>>>>
----------------
Do you think gursikhs and saadh, who are “COMPLETELY MERGED WITH VAHEGURU WHILE LIVING”, stay “leen” with Him LIKE PAANI IS with PAANI through NAAM_JAAP (Simran, Samadhi) or THROUGH SOME OTHER MEANS? Do these same gursikhs or sant pursh eat sleep, talk, think, mingle with other humanoids, and perform numerous Worldly duties in their own GRISTI jeevans? IF they do, then are they still (during all these activities) “COMPLETELY MERGED WITH VAHEGURU 24/7 “JIYON PAANI SANG PAANI”?
-------------
Yes they always stay one with Vaheguru through Naam simran and this Naam simran does not stop in the next world either. It goes on for ever. They get samaayee in naam i.e. they stay merged in Naam forever and forever. Naam and Naami is same. No difference. Naam though source, it is such source that merges with the destination.
>>>>>>
What's the point of Naam Abiyaas (Simran or Samadhi) if they stay "COMPLETELY MERGED WITH VAHEGURU WHILE LIVING"? You have your own definitions of samaayee and merged. One gets "leen" with Vaheguru through Naam. Use Gurbani not your own matt to answer what I asked above.
>>>>>
Baba Budda jee stopped keeping rehit after he reached the param-padd. I don't remember which Guru it was but he was summoned to Guru Sahib and ordered to keep rehit so that other gursikhs don't get misled. Mata Bhaag Kaur also called Maayee Bhago reached the top level of Brahmgiyani and became so absorbed in Naam that she stopped caring about anything
around her. At one point she started living totally naked. Singhs noticed this and told Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj. Siri Guru jee summoned Mata jee and told her to keep full rehit and have at least two articles of cloth on her body – Kachhera and Dastaar. This is written in Sooraj Parkash Granth and other old granths of that time.
>>>>>
Do you believe everything that is written in Sooraj Parkash Granth? Are you saying they were brahmgianies but also wrong for not following hukam as Guru Sahib corrected them. Read Sukhmani Sahib and see if fits your understanding.
>>>>>
Rehit has to be kept for above stated reasons i.e. for the sake of other Gursikhs and because Guru Sahib has ordained that so far so this body is there, rehit has to be there.
>>>>
Are you stating here that rehit isn't important when you get realize Vaheguru through Naam Jaap? It's only kept for the sake of other Gursikhs. What else are you going to resort to? You can't just side step the very basis of Khande Bate de Pahut. Or can you? Pick one or the other
>>>>>
I don't know what you are talking about. Correct me if I am wrong but you seem to be insisting that this merger we have with Vaheguru is temporary because it is only sustained through Naam and that the real merger takes place after death. far you have never provided any shabad to substantiate your philosophy.
>>>>
I have corrected you many times and also explained to you what my understanding of Gurbani is. Gurbani says countless tiems that we can see, realize get leen with Vaheguru by Naam Jaap. It's not a permanent state as we are here on this Earth in our grist jeevan. Your definition of permanent Merger is different from yours. You haven't substantiated any of your claims through Gurbani. In the light of how you have responded so bar to the shabads I provided far, there is no need for me to go through this exercise. I ask you to listen to you own advice first and substantiate your own philosophies first.
>>>>>>
Merging in Vaheguru does not mean that one should ignore what Guru Sahib’s hukam is. You are saying that your matlab with Guru is only till the time you merge in Vaheguru and after that you don't need to follow Guru Sahib’s hukam.
>>>>>>
What are you talking about? Now the "nirgun" atma have to follow same rehit that we follow here on Earth! Would this Kulbir Singh look the same Kulbir Singh in "nirgun" form as well while "sitting" in front of Vaheguru doing His Bhagati? You are the one who is stuck with self interest (matlab) not me. I am saying that once you merge after getting freed from the circle of birth and death, what remains is Parm Jyot. Isn't atma beyond all these dukh, sukh, happiness, sorrow now? It is Vaheguru now, not me or my atma. Your atma belongs to Vaheguru not to you! He is the creator, remember!
>>>>>>
You are saying that whoever is in this human body cannot be one with Vaheguru. Looks like you don't have any concept of milaap inside this human form.
>>>>>
I do but, as I have been saying through all these posts, it's not the same concept as you. "sabh kish ghar mein, bahir nahi", to me, doesn't mean that Sach Khand is in J Singh's Dehi and Vaheguru and Guru Sahibaan are sitting on a throne in my dehi (not to mention that crores of Bhagats are sitting there too doing Bhagati of Vaheguru while being sammaye hoye in HIM).
>>>>>
Our Guru Sahibaan are a perfect example of this. They were in human body but they were totally one with Vaheguru. Are you telling me that after leaving this body, they had a second merger with Vaheguru? I think you need to think about this issue again and then make a decision. By your account it seems that you are saying that our Guru Sahibaan were not one with Vaheguru but only connected to Vaheguru through Naam? In your opinion they were not one aatmak-wise but only connected to Vaheguru.
>>>>>
Go back and read you own posts. It's you who said they were avtaars and Vaheguru came to receive them after they left human dehi!! I maintain that they undoubtedly were part of Vaheguru What does "main hoo Parm Purkh ko daata" means? Vaheguru indeed send them to liberate us, his own jeev-atmas that are stuck here in the circle of maaya.
>>>>>
I am sorry but you have not provided any claim from Gurbani that a second merger takes place as well. As for the term “Jyoti Jyot samauna” it does not appear anywhere in Gurbani.
>>>>>
You are the one implying second merger above through your explanation. Guru Sahib are sitting with Vaheguru forever and ever and then Vaheguru came to receive Guru Sahib (their nirgun jyot) in Devpuri (Devpuri means SachKhand). You used samauna yourself in your post above. Aren't you a Jyot and isn't Vaheguru the Parm-Jyot? The whole Sikh Jagat uses "Jyoti
Jyot samauna” for Guru sahibaans akaal chalanah except may be for you!
>>>>>Gurbani does not believe in extinction of us after death.>>>>
It was destruction, decimation, fannah, and now it's extinction. How many more words are you going to use? None of that happens to apma as it merges into Parm atma. The ocean of blissful Vaheguru. read the definition of a "merger".
>>>>>>
--------------
Don't you see the difference between the two states, one being here in human form in Grist Jeevan and the other being there in Sach Khand in Jyot-Saroop (in your own words)?
-------------
The difference is there but this does not mean that a merger does not occur in the human body. Vaheguru appears right in this human body and merges with aatma forever and ever. Bhagats are totally ikk mikk with Vaheguru while living.
>>>>>>>
"Vaheguru appears right in this human body and merges with aatma forever and ever" What is this "phambal-phoosa" you are getting me into here? First you say that jeev-atma goes to Sach Khand (an actual place
where Vaheguru resides) now you are saying "Vaheguru comes to the human body and merges with aatma forever and ever." MAKE UP YOUR MIND VEER JI! Who merges in who and how?
>>>>> Bhagats are totally ikk mikk with Vaheguru while living. >>>>
Agree. They are through Naam Simran.
>>>>>
To me this pankiti shows clearly the great merger of our Guru Sahibaan and Vaheguru while living. You are saying that this is not a merger but a connection through Naam and that second merger will take place after death. You however don't quote baani anywhere to backup your claim. Where does it say in baani that a second merger takes place after death.
>>>>>
This is your self creted issue. What does the shabad your quoted about Guru Sahib's Akaal chalanah says. According to you they are completely merged with Vaheguru (in fact they are sitting in Sachkhand alongside Vaheguru forever). But the shabad states otherwise. You keep on making up stuff such as "Second Merger" and keep on asking me for pankities to support your words. I am not going to get tricked with these twists.
>>>>>
I will say what I have said many times on this thread, once jeev-atma samma in ParmAtma, they are EK JYOT. Atma has merged into the Parm Consciousness and are out of all bandhans of Worldly aspirations. You keep on thinking in “selfish” manner. What would happen to “ME”? You are stuck with surtee or consciousness of your “SELF”? Who is this “YOU” but JYOT SAROOP, just an ansh of Vaheguru Jyot. What is Kulbir Singh? Not your Dehi that Devs simar. I don't think you will comprehend what I am saying with the logic you are applying here.
----------------------------
Don't worry about what I am stuck in. Answer the question I raised. How does one stay in bliss or enjoy bliss without surtee? You have failed to answer this question even after writing thousands of words. This is the crux of our argument. You say that they become one jyot. In essence, one of the ceases to live. That's how you become one jyot. You yourself stated last post that the jyot is in Paramand but you don't want to admit that it has surtee. How can you be in Parmanand without having consciousness about it? You please answer this.
>>>>>>
If by answering you mean agreeing with you then it's not going to happen. What is this "one of the ceases to live" means? You need to read what I wrote. When a drop of water merges in Ocean, it becomes Ocean. Once jeev-atma samma in Parm Atma, they are EK JYOT. Atma came out of Parmatma and it finally goes back (samma) into Parmatma once it gets freed from the circle of 84 lakh juni. It's not my fault if you don't (want to) understand it. I am not trying to change you. I have already said that I may not agree with you on everything, but I respect your understanding.
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>
What more special treatment do you want then to be ONE with Vaheguru Jyot? Once atma gets merged (samma) in Parmatma, there is no duality. Parmjyot is in ultimate anand. You cant understand what I am saying if you keep on thinking in the same selfish manner. Who is Kulbir Singh, Mann, Atma, or something else.
------------------------------
>>>>>>
You have not answered my question above. I asked you clearly how can you have anand if you don't exist? You keep repeating your mantra that I am selfish for refusing to merge in Vaheguru. I am not being selfish or anything but I am just stating the facts. It is nice to know that Vaheguru does not destroy us after this life. That's all. You claim to the contrary. You are imagining Vaheguru to be some vaccum machine that sucks up the soul inside him and merging you totally.
>>>>>>
I have answered this question many times. What can I do if you don't want to understand it. For me, there is nothing more special then to merge into , to be ONE with Vaheguru Jyot? Parmjyot is in ultimate anand. You can keep on calling Vaheguru a vaccum machine that sucks up the soul or whatever you may want. Keep on putting Vaheguru in some physical form with your dimaag.
>>>>>>>
Imagine the feeling you would have just before the merger that is another name of your destruction. There would be cheek-chihaaRa in Sach Khand as you define it. Your thought of mukti is as scary thought man and thankfully Gurbani does not support your assertion.
>>>>>>
Good luck, keep on holding on to your "SELF" Veer ji. Keep on thinking that you will be sitting inside Vaheguru or in front of Vaheguru or in the verandah in front of Sach Khand doing Bhagti forever. These scare tactic you mentioned above aren't going to work on me. I know who created the atma that resides in my naashvan dehi and who will samma, merge it back into Him. that's all I need to know. Like it or not, this is not your khel, it's all Vaheguru's creation. Don't think for a second that he can't fold it all back.
>>>>>
You Said: "You ask that aatma does not experience happiness and sorrow, then how is it experiencing Anand."
I replied: "I AM NOT SAYING THIS VEER Ji, SHRI GURU ARJAN DEV JI SAYS THIS. You wrote yourself that atma is beyond HAPPINESS AND SORROW. Now you are saying: “To be happy or to feel HAPPINESS, don't you think the most fundamental thing is consciousness i.e. surtee? If there is no consciousness, who is going to enjoy happiness?” I urge you to stick with one mode of thinking veer ji."
NOW YOU SAID: "I am sticking to my original version but it is you who is picking up fragments of my writings and holding me to it. I wrote clearly that I am not only aatma but also mann and surtee. Gurbani says so. Aatma is there too but not only aatma. Tithai ghareeye surat matt mann budh proves that before entering Sach Khand we get carved out surat, matt, mann and budh. We maintain all this."
You wrote it about atma Veer ji. Read it yourself. Now this new revalation from Kulbir Singh that nirgun atma ("we") will get carved out into four pieces: surat, matt, mann and budh.
>>>>>
And mark my word that you will one day beg for this Raamdaas sarovar amrit paani, when you need it. No other way you will understand it.
>>>>>>
Now we have come down to making claims! Wonderful. We already have vaheguru Veer ji, don't try to play one yourself :-).
>>>>>>>
You wrote a lot of Gurbani but not relevant to this subject. I mean you brought a lot of other topics in this topic but did not produce one pankiti that says that a second merger takes place in Sach Khand and you did not produce single pankiti that says that you lose surtee after merger with Vaheguru.
>>>>>>>
I would ask you to review this whole thread. I didn't bring other topic to this topic. You are the one who asked questions and made claims that required me to demonstrate how wrong you were. In my opinion you take Gurbani literally when it suits your cause and you try to drive meanings from one shabad to the other to justify your claims.
>>>>>>
You have failed to prove anything because you could not provide relevant Gurbani reference.
>>>>>>
The feeling is mutual here regardless of what you may think you have provided me.
>>>>>
4) You seem to be suggesting that dehi is a hindrance in complete merger. What difference does it make whether the bhagat is in this body or anywhere in this universe as long as he is merged in Vaheguru?
>>>>>>
I have explained the difference earlier in this post.
>>>>>>
---------------------------
It is my humble opinion that you talked a lot but did not prove anything. You could not provide a single pankiti that shows that this aatma gets decimated in Sach Khand and that it loses surtee after merger.
>>>>>
As much as you like to believe your own interpretation to be Gurmat, the feeling is mutual here as well.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>
Don't put words in my mouth Veer ji. I have answered your question not once but few times on this thread but the answer is not of your liking. I suggest that you read my posts more carefully. I have clearly maintained that jeev-atma goes back to Parmatma and becomes ONE. You are thinking too much in human terms. ATMA IS PART OF PARMATMA. ITS REAL DESTINATION IS PARMATMA. PARMATMA IS IN ULTIMATE ANAND. AFTER IT’S 84 GETS CUT WITH GUR-KIRPA AND IT GOES BACK TO IT’S REAL MOOL GHAR (origin) PARMATMA. IT WAS ONLY PARMATMA WHEN HE CREATED EVERYTHING AND IT WILL ONLY BE PARMATMA WHEN HE DECIDES TO FOLD THIS DREAM WORLD (SUPNA JAISA SANSAAR).
-----------------------------------------
Please provide a single pankiti that shows that Bhagats lose surtee after merger and that a second merger takes place. You have provided a lot of irrelevant pankitis but none of them touched the main issue here. Let us talk about the issue on hand.
---------------------------------
>>>>>>
What's the point Really. You haven't provided any pankiti to prove your claims. We can both keep on singing this tune. You know very well that I disagree with your claims. In my opinion you are just using your manmatt and are stuck at the same place. Gurbani says that IT WAS ONLY PARMATMA WHEN HE CREATED EVERYTHING AND IT WILL ONLY BE PARMATMA WHEN HE DECIDES TO FOLD THIS DREAM WORLD (SUPNA JAISA SANSAAR) BACK.
>>>>>>
I am not stuck in anything but Gurbani. When you say tuhi tuhi, that too proves two entities – one that is saying tuhi tuhi and
Vaheguru.
>>>>>>
Just in case you didn't actually know Veer ji, we jaap Vaheguru Vaheguru (Him i.e. tuhi tuhi) while being here in this human dehi not there in Sach Khand in front of Vaheguru as you like to believe.
>>>>>>>
I am not asking you to follow this ritual but I have a feeling that you will beg for the water of Raamdaas Sarovar. The day will come when Guru Sahib does kirpa on you and you realize the importance of this great teerath. Till then, let us agree to disagree.
>>>>>>>
What's up with this self righteousness! Are you giving me a "shraap" (curse) that I will get some decease and I will beg for the water of Raamdaas Sarovar? Please be little more forthcoming.
----------------------
Veer ji, I say again that lets just agree to disagree on this one issue. Gurbani is infinite (aseem) Ocean and we are mere Masklies. Let Vaheguru reveal this mystery to us (if we have the good fortune :–) Wishful thinking indeed).
--------------------
>>>>>>
Nothing wishful here. You are a good man and will one day meet your Lord. But hopefully we both will have good time in Sach Khand. Then I will tease you on this silly merger thing you have been talking about. We will all tease you then.
>>>>>>
Now I will take the "you will one day meet your Lord" as a blessing but there is no "we" as there is only "HIM".
>>>>
Nimaanay taan tussi bahut hee ziyaada ho.
>>>>>
Sukar hai aap da.
Veer ji, this is a never ending discussion. I took it as far I could but I don't have the time to go on and on with this. I have a hectic work schedule that doesn't allow me much free time to do this. I also want to spend whatever time I get doing naam simran and understanding baani. I don't really see any point in keep on debating this any further. I don't know how much time you have and I don't know what you do for living. I don't even know if you work at all (you could be a millionaire!). So forgive me if I don't respond to your detailed questions. I believe what I believe based on my understanding of Gurbani and you are welcome to think whatever about my understanding.
vjkk vjkf
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 30 Mar 2005
Saadae Vidvaan Veer - J. Singh jeeo,
I say with afsos that despite bentis and requests, you still have not provided a single Gurbani Pankiti to substantiate your two claims:
Firstly that bhagats lose Surthee after merger and secondly that a second merger takes place after death. This is the crux of your argument and you should be able to give some pankitis in your support. This is such an important process as per your understanding, then Gurbani should say something along the lines that while living you only stay connected through Naam and your merger will take place after death.
Also there would be cheek-chihaara in Sach Khand, when aatmaas would be sucked up in kabristaan (as opposed to Nij Ghar). If we go by your definition or notion of mukti, it makes more sense calling Vaheguru a Kabristaan as opposed to Nij Ghar, because in a Kabristaan the body stays in a dormant and dead position but in a house the body plays and goes merry around. You tell me what is Vaheguru according to your definition - Nij ghar or a kabristaan for this aatma?
I will continue on the reply to your post soon but I could not help writing this little bit.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
J Singh · 30 Mar 2005
>>>>>
I say with afsos that despite bentis and requests, you still have not provided a single Gurbani Pankiti to substantiate your two claims
>>>>>
Read my reply first kulbir Singh ji. As much as you like to admire your own understanding of Gurbani, you haven't substantiated any of your own tall claims. Kulbir Singh ji's matt doesn't equal Gurmatt, not to me :-).
>>>>
Also there would be cheek-chihaara in Sach Khand, when aatmaas would be sucked up in kabristaan (as opposed to Nij Ghar). If we go by your definition or notion of mukti, it makes more sense calling Vaheguru a Kabristaan as opposed to Nij Ghar, because in a Kabristaan the body stays in a dormant and dead position but in a house the body plays and goes merry around. You tell me what is Vaheguru according to your definition - Nij ghar or a kabristaan for this aatma?
>>>>
What is this? Keep on saying whatever you wish, keep on making tall claims; and keep on calling Vaheguru a Kabristaan (how sad is that!). These are your words not mine.
It doesn't apply to you anymore but I do request forum sangat not to fall for what Great Kulbir Singh claims I wrote. If you like to know, just read my posts instead and make up your mind.
You seems to forget that I was the one who said that jeev-atma's Nij Ghar (mool origin, final destination) is Vaheguru, Parmatma. You are the one who opposed my meaning and I ended up explaining word for word. Now Vaheguru means Nij Ghar to you as well! What's the point really. I don't even know why I am explaining myself here.
You tried your best to pin destruction, decimation, fannah, and extinction of atma on me. Now there is this new word Kabristaan for Vaheguru!! Calling Vaheguru a Kabirstaan of dead bodies! Truely shows your immense love of Akaal Purkh Vaheguru! Well done.
I told you that I respect your undestanding but I don't agree with you but it wasn't enough.
With all humility I say again that I don't have time for all this. I rather spend my time doing paath and understanding baani. Say what you want.
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 30 Mar 2005
J. Singh jeeo,
--------------
Read my reply first kulbir Singh ji. As much as you like to admire your own understanding of Gurbani, you haven't substantiated any of your own tall claims. Kulbir Singh ji's matt doesn't equal Gurmatt, not to me :-).
-------------
This is quite odd of you to have said this. I did provide many pankitis to prove the condition of the bhagats in Sach Khand. This whole thread with my post on the condition of Bhagats and my understanding on this subject matter is same as that of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee and pretty much all translaters of Gurbani. Then I gave you so many pankitis to show that Bhagats stay merged in Sach Khand but don't lose surthee.
You did dismiss all the pankitis I gave. Okay fair enough. But when I requested you to give a single pankiti that can subtantiate your claim, which in my opinion is based on your nijmatt, you reply back with whole lot of Gurbani pankitis but of totally irrelevant subject matter. I enjoyed going through all those subjects and am not complaining but I think you deviated from the point to hide your weakness of not having a single Gurbani pankiti to support your claims that firstly Bhagats lose surthee in Sach Khand and secondly that there is a process of merger-ism in which Bhagat have a second merger in Sach Khand.
------------
What is this? Keep on saying whatever you wish, keep on making tall claims; and keep on calling Vaheguru a Kabristaan (how sad is that!). These are your words not mine.
-----------
I am not calling Vaheguru Kabristaan but you are, by your definition of muktee. You called Vaheguru a nij-ghar of aatma (Gurbani does not support this) and going by your analogy I said that since Bhagats lose identity after merging with Vaheguru, it seems like your concept of Vaheguru is more of a Kabristaan as opposed to a Nij ghar. My word Kabristaan came against Nijghar. Nothing else. Otherwise, main kee Vaheguru noo Kabrishtan keh ke marna hai.
-------------
It doesn't apply to you anymore but I do request forum sangat not to fall for what Great Kulbir Singh claims I wrote. If you like to know, just read my posts instead and make up your mind.
-------------
Hahahahaha! this is a funny plea.
-----------
You seems to forget that I was the one who said that jeev-atma's Nij Ghar (mool origin, final destination) is Vaheguru, Parmatma. You are the one who opposed my meaning and I ended up explaining word for word. Now Vaheguru means Nij Ghar to you as well! What's the point really. I don't even know why I am explaining myself here.
-------------
I coined the word Kabristhaan sensing your definition of aatma. You were calling Vaheguru, Aatma's nijghar and then also claiming it to lose identity after merger. I could not fathom why you would call it a Nijghar then. Kabristhaan would be a more appropriate word as per your definition. That's all.
-----------
You tried your best to pin destruction, decimation, fannah, and extinction of atma on me. Now there is this new word Kabristaan for Vaheguru!! Calling Vaheguru a Kabirstaan of dead bodies! Truely shows your immense love of Akaal Purkh Vaheguru! Well done.
----------
Hahahaha!
Well, it is well done to you, for coming up with such a unique notion of mukthi, that no one in Sikh Panth ever thought of. As per your definition of mukhtee, Vaheguru surely seems like a kabrishtaan of dead aatmaas and if not dead aatmaas, then surthee-less dormant, unconscious, Zombie aatmas for sure.
--------
With all humility I say again that I don't have time for all this. I rather spend my time doing paath and understanding baani. Say what you want.
-----------
Like you, I am no big-time paathee of Gurbani or an abhyaas of Naam. So I have no time-problem on discussing such issues. So expect to hear more from me. I will reply to your big post soon.
Tuhaada Charan sevak,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
J Singh · 30 Mar 2005
>>>>
This is quite odd of you to have said this. I did provide many pankitis to prove the condition of the bhagats in Sach Khand.
>>>>>
Dont' hide behind words Veer ji. You haven't proven a thing to me. You do like to believe that you have though. I too believe that I have proven you wrong many time during this discussion but you just create your own interpretation to suit your needs.
>>>>>
I enjoyed going through all those subjects and am not complaining but I think you deviated from the point to hide your weakness of not having a single Gurbani pankiti to support your claims that firstly Bhagats lose surthee in Sach Khand and secondly that there is a process of merger-ism in which Bhagat have a second merger in Sach Khand.
>>>>>
These are just your imaginations Veer ji. I didn't deviate from any point to hide any weakness. I responded to every thing you asked. In Stead of making up stuff to hide your own weaknesses, why don't you listen to your own advice. You haven't supported any of your tall claims.
>>>>
I am not calling Vaheguru Kabristaan but you are, by your definition of muktee.
>>>>
You are most welcome to make up your own imaginary meanings to slander me but you can't show me a single place were I called Vaheguru Kabristaan. It's nothing more than just a white lie. I know what I wrote. I can say the same for your dream world But I have been respectful to your understanding so far.
>>>>
Well, it is well done to you, for coming up with such a unique notion of mukthi, that no one in Sikh Panth ever thought of.
>>>>
What are you talking about Veer ji. Does the Great Kulbir Singh have his own panth? Even on this forum, people agree with my understanding. I am not going to become your blind follower.
>>>>>
As per your definition of mukhtee, Vaheguru surely seems like a kabrishtaan of dead aatmaas and if not dead aatmaas, then surthee-less dormant, unconscious, Zombie aatmas for sure.
>>>>>
You have desperately tried to put words in my mouth. Atma can be dead and Parmatma can be Kabristaan FOR YOU, but not for me. I love my Guru Sahibaan and I love my Vaheguru. You are not saying anything new here. Keep on living in your imaginary world Veer ji.
>>>>>
Like you, I am no big-time paathee of Gurbani or an abhyaas of Naam. So I have no time-problem on discussing such issues. So expect to hear more from me.
>>>>
Keep on looking down on this nimmana and keep on implying what you want. It doesn't bother me. Say what pleases you as you are behaving like a true gursikh :-)
vjkk vjkf
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 30 Mar 2005
Veer J. Singh jeeo,
It seems that you have got very upset. Take it easy Dost. It is only one issue on Sikhi that we differ. There are probably hundred issues where we have similar views.
I don't know why but I just can't stop laughing today, while writing on the board. Our board is poora garam today.
--------------
Dont' hide behind words Veer ji. You haven't proven a thing to me. You do like to believe that you have though. I too believe that I have proven you wrong many time during this discussion but you just create your own interpretation to suit your needs.
---------------
You asked me if I provided any pankitis and I said that I did provide pankitis and even Bhai Sahib agreed with me. You on the other hand have not provided a single pankiti to prove your point.
------------
These are just your imaginations Veer ji. I didn't deviate from any point to hide any weakness. I responded to every thing you asked. In Stead of making up stuff to hide your own weaknesses, why don't you listen to your own advice. You haven't supported any of your tall claims.
------------
Then where did all those shabads of Bhagat Naamdev come and where did the issue of Raamdaas Sarovar come in and not to mention the Raja Janak issue? Please don't misunderstand me. I loved all these subjects and enjoyed debating with you on all of these subjects. I am just saying that you provided a lot of Gurbani panktiyaan but none relevant to the subject matter.
--------------------------
>>>>
I am not calling Vaheguru Kabristaan but you are, by your definition of muktee.
>>>>
You are most welcome to make up your own imaginary meanings to slander me but you can't show me a single place were I called Vaheguru Kabristaan. It's nothing more than just a white lie. I know what I wrote. I can say the same for your dream world But I have been respectful to your understanding so far.
------------------------------
You are taking it too seriously Mitr-pyaaray. Respect taan main vee hazoor dee bahut karda haan. You did not show Vaheguru a Kabristhaan but the definition that you gave of Vaheguru was very much like Kabristhaan. Just like dead bodies go to graveyard, same way according to you, aatmas get sucked up in Vaheguru and they lose all identity and surthee. Loss of consciousness is death. Simple as that. In case of such definition of Vaheguru, tell me what else is Vaheguru according to your definition, if not Kabristhaan?
----------------
>>>>
Well, it is well done to you, for coming up with such a unique notion of mukthi, that no one in Sikh Panth ever thought of.
>>>>
What are you talking about Veer ji. Does the Great Kulbir Singh have his own panth? Even on this forum, people agree with my understanding. I am not going to become your blind follower.
--------------------
MitrPyaaray, I am not in the business of making followers. But indeed this notion is unique not only to Sikh Panth but to the whole world. First Bhagats get connected to Vaheguru through Naam, and then after death, they go in front of Vaheguru and at that point they look very beautiful (your earlier post, one of the first ones). Then finally they get sucked up in Vaheguru and this you call the second and final merger. This philosophy of two mergers, one while living, that you consider incomplete merger and then the second merger, is indeed new to the spiritual world. Please show me who else in this world has shown this unique philosophy?
---------------------
>>>>>
As per your definition of mukhtee, Vaheguru surely seems like a kabrishtaan of dead aatmaas and if not dead aatmaas, then surthee-less dormant, unconscious, Zombie aatmas for sure.
>>>>>
You have desperately tried to put words in my mouth. Atma can be dead and Parmatma can be Kabristaan FOR YOU, but not for me. I love my Guru Sahibaan and I love my Vaheguru. You are not saying anything new here. Keep on living in your imaginary world Veer ji.
-------------------
Pray Mithr-pyaray jeeo, what else are atmaas who have no surthee, no mann, no budhee, no matt? Are they not dead, dormant, unconscious and Zombie aatmaas? What is the use of such muktee that is going to take away surthee from you?
--------------------
>>>>>
Like you, I am no big-time paathee of Gurbani or an abhyaas of Naam. So I have no time-problem on discussing such issues. So expect to hear more from me.
>>>>
Keep on looking down on this nimmana and keep on implying what you want. It doesn't bother me. Say what pleases you as you are behaving like a true gursikh :-)
-------------------------------
Come on Muthr-pyaaray, everyone knows how much nimrata I have. I am not known anywhere for having nimratha. If you don't know about my nimratha, then just read the article I will be posting soon on the encounter I had this Sunday.
Talabgaar-e-bossa of Kadam-e-Mubarik aap jee de,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
J Singh · 31 Mar 2005
Veer ji, call it being upset but I just responded to your allegations. That's all.
"If you prick us, shall we not cry :-("
Yes, I do agree with you on lots of issues. We both are sikhs of Guru Sahib. I have said many times on this thread that I may disagree with you at times but I respect your understanding of Gurbani. I admire your knowledge on numerous subjects.
>>>>>>
Then where did all those shabads of Bhagat Naamdev come and where did the issue of Raamdaas Sarovar come in and not to mention the Raja Janak issue? Please don't misunderstand me. I loved all these subjects and enjoyed debating with you on all of these subjects. I am just saying that you provided a lot of Gurbani panktiyaan but none relevant to the subject matter.
>>>>>>
Go read it yourself Veer ji as to why these issues came up. You are the one for taking Gurbani meanings "literally". Now you are retract back to agree that the pankiti "Tu ta Raja Janak Autaar" shouldn't be taken literally. Who literal you want to be. It says "RAJA JANAK" not "Janak".
>>>>>
You are taking it too seriously Mitr-pyaaray. Respect taan main vee hazoor dee bahut karda haan. You did not show Vaheguru a Kabristhaan but the definition that you gave of Vaheguru was very much like Kabristhaan. Just like dead bodies go to graveyard, same way according to you, aatmas get sucked up in Vaheguru and they lose all identity and surthee. Loss of consciousness is death. Simple as that. In case of such definition of Vaheguru, tell me what else is Vaheguru according to your definition, if not Kabristhaan?
>>>>>
Veer ji, this is your own definition, not mine. As I said, go call Vaheguru Kabristhaan. You want to know what Vaheguru is, start with the very first line (mool mantra) of JapJi Sahib.
>>>>>
Please show me who else in this world has shown this unique philosophy?
>>>>>
I total sharda is in Gurbani. You are most welcome to go out in the World to find unique philosophy. You said you have plenty of spare time.
>>>>>>
Pray Mithr-pyaray jeeo, what else are atmaas who have no surthee, no mann, no budhee, no matt?
>>>>>>
Atma is jyot saroop, an ansh of Vaheguru! You know the one we "JAAP" because we (jeev-atma) are separated from Him; and in your case because we are selfish and want to reserve a seat for ourselves in sach Khand :-). Keep on creating what I believe and what I don't believe Veer ji.
>>>>>
If you don't know about my nimratha, then just read the article I will be posting soon on the encounter I had this Sunday.
>>>>>
You had an incounter Veer ji. Was it with a Bhagat who is sitting in front of Vaheguru in the verandah to Sachkhand doing His Bhagati :-) :-). Mazrat ji, just couldn't help myself.
vjkk vjkf
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 31 Mar 2005
I will tell you honestly that I kept laughing while responding to you yesterday and to "Singh" under the "Shahrukh" post. Both of you were really upset at me yesterday and both of you looked more haseen to me in gussa.
-----------
Veer ji, call it being upset but I just responded to your allegations. That's all.
"If you prick us, shall we not cry :-("
--------------
I don't know where and when I pricked you. You responded to my arguments but in the mode of being upset.
-----------
Yes, I do agree with you on lots of issues. We both are sikhs of Guru Sahib. I have said many times on this thread that I may disagree with you at times but I respect your understanding of Gurbani. I admire your knowledge on numerous subjects.
------------
The feeling is mutual. You are a dimaaghi person. A person I really enjoy debating.
-----------
Now you are retract back to agree that the pankiti "Tu ta Raja Janak Autaar" shouldn't be taken literally. Who literal you want to be. It says "RAJA JANAK" not "Janak".
-----------
It is still being taken literally. I originally did give the version of Bhai Sahib's translation on this. Raja Janak Avtaar means Raaj Avtaar and Janak Avtaar -two adjectives to one noun Avtaar.
I read Bhai Sahib's translation again and could not go against it. Bhai Sahib taun vaddae taan nahi ho jaana aseen.
-------------------------------------------
>>>>>
You are taking it too seriously Mitr-pyaaray. Respect taan main vee hazoor dee bahut karda haan. You did not show Vaheguru a Kabristhaan but the definition that you gave of Vaheguru was very much like Kabristhaan. Just like dead bodies go to graveyard, same way according to you, aatmas get sucked up in Vaheguru and they lose all identity and surthee. Loss of consciousness is death. Simple as that. In case of such definition of Vaheguru, tell me what else is Vaheguru according to your definition, if not Kabristhaan?
>>>>>
Veer ji, this is your own definition, not mine. As I said, go call Vaheguru Kabristhaan. You want to know what Vaheguru is, start with the very first line (mool mantra) of JapJi Sahib.
--------------------------------------------
Please tell me how according to your definition Vaheguru is not a Kabristhaan and why is it a Nij-ghar. Do you know the difference between ghar and kabristhaan? If Vaheguru according to you is a Ghar for aatma, then aatma cannot be a dead aatma as you imply by saying that it loses surthee. If you think that aatma does lose surthee and consciousness, and got dormat, then surely Vaheguru according to your definition is a Kabristhaan. Imagine the moment before the horrifying merger that according to you brings death of surthee of jeev. There would be cheek-chihaara there man.
-------------------------
>>>>>
Please show me who else in this world has shown this unique philosophy?
>>>>>
I total sharda is in Gurbani. You are most welcome to go out in the World to find unique philosophy. You said you have plenty of spare time.
---------------------------
Well you got it right. Time is not a problem for me. hehe!
But I have to accept that you did give this world a unique philosophy of mukti and a new meaning to Vaheguru - Kabristhaan.
-----------------------------
>>>>>>
Pray Mithr-pyaray jeeo, what else are atmaas who have no surthee, no mann, no budhee, no matt?
>>>>>>
Atma is jyot saroop, an ansh of Vaheguru! You know the one we "JAAP" because we (jeev-atma) are separated from Him; and in your case because we are selfish and want to reserve a seat for ourselves in sach Khand :-). Keep on creating what I believe and what I don't believe Veer ji.
---------------------------
I agree with you that aatma is an ansh of Vaheguru. That's why it cannot be destroyed or go dormant. It will stay just as Vaheguru is - Fully conscious. You yourself said it is Vaheguru's ansh. Then it must have same qualities as Vaheguru (hota aaiya). So it will have consciousness too as opposed to what you are saying aatma to be i.e. zombies without surthee or perhaps robots.
----------------
>>>>>
If you don't know about my nimratha, then just read the article I will be posting soon on the encounter I had this Sunday.
>>>>>
You had an incounter Veer ji. Was it with a Bhagat who is sitting in front of Vaheguru in the verandah to Sachkhand doing His Bhagati :-) :-). Mazrat ji, just couldn't help myself.
------------------
We attended a conference last Sunday and there was some hulla-gulla there. I am in the process of writing the complete report and will post it on Friday.
Khush raho Jigree Dost,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Neutral · 31 Mar 2005
Having being undecided, reading both sides of the argument I can now say whilst I did not originally agree, I now agree with Kulbir Singh. And J Singh it is not hard to see the spite in your posts. Please cut down on the mocking and mean ness, it does not enhance the quality of your points. But I still respect your view.
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
J Singh · 31 Mar 2005
>>>>>
Do you know the difference between ghar and kabristhaan? If Vaheguru according to you is a Ghar for aatma, then aatma cannot be a dead aatma as you imply by saying that it loses surthee.
>>>>>
Veer ji, it's you who need to understand the differance not me. You come up with these words, so you sort them out yourself!!
>>>>>>>
If you think that aatma does lose surthee and consciousness, and got dormat, then surely Vaheguru according to your definition is a Kabristhaan. Imagine the moment before the horrifying merger that according to you brings death of surthee of jeev. There would be cheek-chihaara there man.
>>>>>>
Now I am completely amused at your tries Veer ji :-). Quit using destruction, decimation, fannah, death for atma. You have used all these words. Don't you see they all mean the same here!
Who is ever conscious or has Parm consciousness? Parmatma, Vaheguru. Where does atma go back to after getting freed, in Whom does atma MERGE or samma into? It's origin, Vaheguru and Vaheguru only. Remember atma is jyot saroop.
>>>>>
Khush raho Jigree Dost
>>>>>>
Lakh lakn sukar aap ji daa.
vjkk vjkf
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
princess · 31 Mar 2005
J.Singh jee and Kulbir singh jee you both did a lot of hardwork and khoj to prove your points. Both of you made good points. It was fun to read this friendly discussion. From your posts sometimes it seems as you both are best friends. Are you?
J. singh jee your points are good but only problem with your point of merge of aatma in Vaheguru lacks Gurbani support. In Japji Sahib Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee explains scene of Sachkhand. He says, "Tithe khand mandal bharbhand, je ko kathe ta(n) ant naa ant" If aatmaas which go to sachkhand, don't have any existance after meeting Vaheguru jee then what those khands, mandals and barbhands are for? If aatmaas go right into Vaheguru and finish their identities then those aatmaas don't need any extra space to live. Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh jee has witnessed that even Ten Guru Sahibaan have their own identities in sachkhand then how bhagats can't?
"Gurmukh aaye jaaye nisang" If gurmukhs loose their identities how can they aa jaa nisang anywhere?
So, according to Gurbani your point is wrong. And there is other gurmat principle of meeting Vaheguru which does not support your point is: One can't meet Vaheguru after death if one does not meet HIM in his life time. Gursikhs get one with Vaheguru while living in this world then how their jyot gets destroyed? One gets uchi avasthaa while living in deh roop not after death.
Bhul chuk dee muaafi jee!
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
J Singh · 31 Mar 2005
>>>>>
J. singh jee your points are good but only problem with your point of merge of aatma in Vaheguru lacks Gurbani support.
>>>>>
No it doesn't. Kulbir Singh hasn't provided any support to the key point of our discussion. I am not a scholor by any means. I am just a nimmana sikh who doesn't agree with Kurbir Singh on this point.
>>>>>
"Tithe khand mandal bharbhand, je ko kathe ta(n) ant naa ant"
>>>>>
Please read and understand japji Sahib again. Sach Khand shabad applies to Nirangkaar. Karm Khand part covers bhagats, jodh, mahabal and soorey. Sort through this post and you will see that even Kulbir Singh agree with this.
>>>>>
One can't meet Vaheguru after death if one does not meet HIM in his life time.
>>>>>
I never said that one can't realize, meet or see Vaheguru in this life. The whole purpose of this life is to jaap naam to be one with Vaheguru. Gurbani is full of shabads that states bhagats get leen with Vaheguru. It even says that there is no differance between the two and much much more. The issue here is that how we both interpret Gurbani.
>>>>>
Gursikhs get one with Vaheguru while living in this world then how their jyot gets destroyed?
>>>>
Never said their jyot gets destroyed. We are jyot saroop, so is Vaheguru who is Parm-Jyot, the origin of all of us.
>>>>>
One gets uchi avasthaa while living in deh roop not after death.
>>>>>
Agree that One gets uchi avasthaa while living in deh roop.
>>>>
So, according to Gurbani your point is wrong.
>>>>
Don't assume anything. I read the same Gurbani you do and I don't think my understanding is wrong.
>>>>
Ten Guru Sahibaan have their own identities in sachkhand then how bhagats can't?
>>>>
By having "their own identities", do you mean that they have the same saroop that they had here while being in human form? Kulbir Singh believes Guru Sahibaan are sitting in Sach Khand on a throne alongside Vaheguru from eternity. The only shabad he could come up was the one with Guru Sahib's akaal chalanah. He claims "Devpuri" means "sach Khand but "Baikunth" doesn't. I completely disagree with him on that point. I humbly suggest you read this thread more carefully.
Being part of AKJ, I respect your and Kulbir Singh's admiration for Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh ji. I love their writings too.
Galtian maaf princess ji. This is just my meager understanding and you don't have to agree with me. Gurbani is an endless ocean and we are all "sikhs" who trying to learn it in our own ways.
Neutral, I am sorry if you feel that I have mocked anyone or I am mean to anyone. I don't think I have done that. It's Kulbir Singh who used the word "kabristhan" for Vaheguru not me as I love my Pritam Pyaara. I only responded to the specific alligations.
vjkk vjkf
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 31 Mar 2005
J. Singh jeeo,
Zahe-Naseeb naal tuhaade behas-mubahisa hoiya ,
Vichaaran da aadaan-pradaan achha khaasa hoiya |
Tu apna hee koi mehram lagda hain mere veer,
Tera gussa vee saano, mehsoos pyaar jaisa hoiya |
Aatma majzoob hai Rabb naal, asee sehmat haan ji,
par oh surthee gavaundi hai, ih tu dass ke kaisa hoiya |
Jadd milaap atma parmaatam da hoiya iss jahan vich,
Phir agay hove dooja milaap, tu dass kyoon aisa hoiya |
Apne haqq vich tussi bahut Gurbani pesh-o-quote keeti,
Par kissay vee gal da tuhaathon nahi koi khulasa hoiya |
Vaheguru Kabristhaan hai, ih tussi navee kaadh jo kadhee,
Iss navae falsafay daa aaghaaz vaang ikk tamasha hoiya |
Bhai Sahib jee jaise uchay suchay Sikh bahut thoray ne,
Tu samjhe ohna da kahiya, jiyon mazaak tay haasa hoiya |
Tu mera mehram koi, vichudiya hoiya mithar hain pakka,
Tere naal charcha karkay sakoon achha tey khaasa hoiya |
Jiyon khoj baani dee, tu keeti dil-o-jaan laa kae
Lagga raheen ivay hee, dukh ziyada chahe maasa hoiya |
Dimaagh tere jaise maujood ne Sikh Panth vich
Ih jaan ke saano bahut santokh tey dharvaasa hoiya |
I was not planning this at all but while writing response to this post, the effusion of my emotions in the form of this poem occurred just swiftly. Please accept this as is and I know that it is not pooran according to behar (meter) of the ghazal of nazam but accept it.
-----------------
>>>>>
[i]Do you know the difference between ghar and kabristhaan? If Vaheguru according to you is a Ghar for aatma, then aatma cannot be a dead aatma as you imply by saying that it loses surthee.
>>>>>
Veer ji, it's you who need to understand the differance not me. You come up with these words, so you sort them out yourself!![/i]
-----------------
The intricating thing here is that you insist that the aatma is in bliss but don't accept that it has surthee. It is consciousness that enables us to experience Anand or bliss. If we don't have consciousness, how can we feel bliss?
The definition of muktee that you offered clearly comes with the package that jeevs get ridden or removed of their consciousness and then merged into Vaheguru. The removal of consciousness essentially means a death-like state, whereby the jeev cannot experience anything. This only means that Vaheguru is a Kabristhaan then, as opposed to Nij Ghar that you insist it is.
I entreat and supplicate before you again to explain how Vaheguru is not a Kabristhaan as per your definition of Mukti. Either change your description of mukti or accept that Vaheguru is a Kabristhaan according to your description.
[i]
>>>>>>>
If you think that aatma does lose surthee and consciousness, and got dormat, then surely Vaheguru according to your definition is a Kabristhaan. Imagine the moment before the horrifying merger that according to you brings death of surthee of jeev. There would be cheek-chihaara there man.
>>>>>>
Now I am completely amused at your tries Veer ji :-). Quit using destruction, decimation, fannah, death for atma. You have used all these words. Don't you see they all mean the same here!
-------------------------[/i]
You yourself have been insisting on the destruction of the jeev by insisting that it does not have any identity and consciousness. The only difference is that you just don't use the word "destruction" but you mean nothing but destruction of jeev's surthee and consciousness which in essence means death of the jeev.
-------------------
Who is ever conscious or has Parm consciousness? Parmatma, Vaheguru. Where does atma go back to after getting freed, in Whom does atma MERGE or samma into? It's origin, Vaheguru and Vaheguru only. Remember atma is jyot saroop.
----------------------
But, pray tell me why do you insist that the jeev loses consciousness? Where in Gurbani does it say that it loses surthee?
[i]--------------------------
>>>>>
Khush raho Jigree Dost
>>>>>>
Lakh lakn sukar aap ji daa.
---------------------------
[/i]
Aseen taan tuhaadi sada hee khair mangde haan.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 31 Mar 2005
J. Singh jeeo,
--------------
Being part of AKJ, I respect your and Kulbir Singh's admiration for Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh ji. I love their writings too.
-------------------
I just want to comment on this comment of yours. The description of Sach Khand that Bhai Sahib has given is not unique to AKJ. Sant Gurbachan Singh of Damdami Taksal (Read Gurbani Paath Darshan) and Bhai Sahib Doctor Vir Singh (Read Rana Soorat Singh) too have the same description of Sach Khand. Sant Ishar Singh Rarewalay (listen to his diwans and cassettes of Jathedar Baba jee)too believed in the same description of Sach Khand i.e. where Bhagats are not sucked up into extinction but stay merged in Vaheguru and in full anand.
Your philosophy of two mergers (one in this world and one in the next world) and Bhagats losing consciousness and going extinct is a unique philosophy.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Princess · 01 Apr 2005
"Tithe khand mandal bharbhand, je ko kathe ta(n) ant naa ant"
>>>>>
Please read and understand japji Sahib again. Sach Khand shabad applies to Nirangkaar. Karm Khand part covers bhagats, jodh, mahabal and soorey. Sort through this post and you will see that even Kulbir Singh agree with this.
((((((((((
Veeray jee, please read these punkities again. Guru sahib has described all khands and then he comes to sachkhand and that's how he describes sachkhand:
"Sachkhand vasai nirankaar, kar kar vekhai nadar nihaal II Tethai khand mandal varbhand, je ko kathe ta(n) ant na ant ll Tithe low low akaar, jiv jiv hukam tevai(n) tiv kaar ll Vekhai vigsai kar vichaar, nanak, kathanaa karaRaa saar ll"
I did not talked about karam khand in my previous post. I think veer J. Singh got tired by writing so much and now mixing up karam khand and sachkhand.
))))))))))))))
>>>>>
One can't meet Vaheguru after death if one does not meet HIM in his life time.
>>>>>
I never said that one can't realize, meet or see Vaheguru in this life. The whole purpose of this life is to jaap naam to be one with Vaheguru. Gurbani is full of shabads that states bhagats get leen with Vaheguru. It even says that there is no differance between the two and much much more. The issue here is that how we both interpret Gurbani.
Ten Guru Sahibaan have their own identities in sachkhand then how bhagats can't?
>>>>
By having "their own identities", do you mean that they have the same saroop that they had here while being in human form? Kulbir Singh believes Guru Sahibaan are sitting in Sach Khand on a throne alongside Vaheguru from eternity. The only shabad he could come up was the one with Guru Sahib's akaal chalanah. He claims "Devpuri" means "sach Khand but "Baikunth" doesn't. I completely disagree with him on that point. I humbly suggest you read this thread more carefully
(((((((((
veer, so, you agree that bhagats have their own identities, atleast. We all know this human body does not go with us after we do kooch from this jahaan but our aatma goes. According to your willingness of accepting Guru Sahibaan's and bhagats' own allagg identities, what do you think where they sit then? It is obious they have some kind of seats to get biraajmaan on or you think they fly in air there? Here's a shabad which tells us what bakunth is.
gur kee saakhee a(n)mrith baanee peevath hee paravaan bhaeiaa ||
dhar dharasan kaa preetham hovai mukath baiku(n)t(h)ai karai kiaa ||3||
sifathee rathaa sadh bairaagee jooai janam n haarai ||
kahu naanak sun bharathhar jogee kheevaa a(n)mrith dhhaarai ||4||4||38||
The Teachings of the Guru, the Ambrosial Bani - drinking them in, one becomes acceptable and renowned.
Unto the one who loves the Lord's Court, and the Blessed Vision of His Darshan, of what use is liberation or paradise? ||3||
Imbued with the Lord's Praises, one is forever a Bairaagee, a renunciate, and one's life is not lost in the gamble.
Says Nanak, listen, O Bharthari Yogi: drink in the intoxicating nectar of the Lord. ||4||4||38||"
Does not above shabad punkiti clears that bakunth is not sachkhand?
bhul chuk dee muaafi jee!
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
J Singh · 01 Apr 2005
Parm Pyaare Veer ji,
>>>>>>
Zahe-Naseeb naal tuhaade behas-mubahisa hoiya ,
Vichaaran da aadaan-pradaan achha khaasa hoiya |
.......
.......
Dimaagh tere jaise maujood ne Sikh Panth vich
Ih jaan ke saano bahut santokh tey dharvaasa hoiya |
>>>>>
Sadhke Veer ji, main qurbaan haan aap ji de. I didn't know you were a shaayr as well. Just great. Now I can proudly say that the great Tapoban Singh Kulbir Singh wrote a poem just for me.
Our vichaar was going good, till you got frustrated and started mocking my understanding of Gurbani :-). I am terrible at typing and it takes me a long time to respond to these elaborate questions, but instead of reading and responding to my post, you just started ridiculing my understanding. I don't remember nearly as much Gurbani by heart as you do, so I really had to do some research to refute your points. I am not trying to blow my own trumpet but I am more of a thinker. I read Gurbani and then I 'try" to understand it by putting it the the full context of Shri Guru Grant Sahib ji. Sometimes I don't even agree with myself (translation: when I can't decide, just leave it open :-) ).
I think we both are in agreement that Gurbani advises us that this is our only chance to meet Vaheguru. It's through Naam Simran that we are able to attain His darshan while being here in human dehi. Our disagreement has been about what happens to jeev-atma when it's liberated from the circle of 84 lakh juni and goes back to it's origin Vaheguru. I just can't digest your explanation.
I could have asked you to answer the questions from my detailed post, but here I am, giving it a one final try to make you understand my position. You are welcome to laugh at me, ridicule me or call me a totally lost case mitr pyaare ji:
1. We came to this Jagg (World) when Vaheguru put his jyot in our sareer (dehi).
2. We are here stuck in this world of maaya and the only way to get out of this is through Naam, Naam that come with Gur Kirpa. We must jaap naam to be one with our beloved Vaheguru.
3. Vaheguru and Vaheguru alone does kirpa (bless) on us. "nadar kare ta simariya jaayi". He awaken the selfless love within us and we start to tarp (in bairaag) to be one with him. Afterall He is "Sargun nirgun nirankaar sunn samaaDhee aap, aapan kee-aa naankaa aapay hee fir jaap". We may think it's "me, me, me" but it's Him, Him and Him alone who puts this bairaag in
our heart.
4.When through SatGuru we are able to see what our real purpose here on Earth is, we start to jaap naam and get rangg-a in His rang. (Our) atma indeed is an ansh Parmatma and that's what we realize. We realize that "sabh kish ghar mein, bahar nahi, bahar tolle so bharam bhullahi". We realise that he resides in our ghat or ridh.
You say RIDH and GHAT are two difference things. Please ponder upon this pankati and decide for yourself: "jih GHAT simran raam ko so nar muktaa jaan, tihi nar har antar nahee naanak saachee maan". Gurbani tells us again and again how there is no difference between Vaheguru and Saadh, Brahmgyani, Sant, Gursikh, or bhagat. So, (liberated) atma is really roop of
Parmatma.
5. Now through naam simran (samathi), we are able to connect with him, see him, meet him, realize him, experience him, or call it whatever makes you understand this state. Grubani say, "kaho kabeer goonge gurr khaya, puche te kya kahee-ay". We can't describe it in words.
6. Although we have realized Vaheguru (our bandhans of 84 lakh juni are cut with Guru kirpa and we are freed from jamm dandey :-) ) while being in Human dehi and we stay leen in Him through Naam Samadhi, we still (literally) ARE in one of the 84 lakh juni. Aren't we.
7. Once we leave this dehi (after our bandhan of 84 lakh juni got cut with Guru kirpa and we got freed while still being in this dehi), we get merged in the infinite jyot of Vaheguru.
8. Vaheguru is INDEED infinite. I don't have to tell you what Gurbani says about Vaheguru but here are just a few pankities out of hundreds in SGGS ji:
"janam maran teh rehit narayan"
"tudh roop na rakhaya, jaat tu varana bahera"
"oh aggam agocher ek-onkaar"
"Prabrahm ka ant na parr"
"ta ka ant na jan-ne koi"
"be-shumaar beant su-aami, tero ant na kin-he lah-ye-a"
"roop na rekh na rang kish, trih gun theh prabh bhinn"
"tu aa-thaa mo thaa nahi"
"agam agochar be-ant, ant na pa-e-aye"
"oh beant ant kin lahe-aye"
He is "aape karta, aape bhugtaa", "aap opaa-ay, aap kha-paa-ay", "aap he pujaari, aap he deva", "prabh ek tuhi ek tuhi" and "aape purakh aape he naari". Bhagat says, "paani mein dekh mukh jaisa, naamey kaa Beethal aisa".
9. Once atma is freed and out of jamman-marran, it becomes (part of) Parmatma. Atma is "tuj te opjay, tuj mahe samaave". Vaheguru IS atma's mool origin ("mann tu jot saroop hai, apna mool pachaan", "Atma pratma eko karre"). I believe that a liberated atma is same as Parmatma (i.e. it becomes parmatma once freed after lekha jokha :-) ), "acharajh katha maha anoor, pratma parbrahm ka roop", "atma parmatma eko karreh, anter ke dubedha anter marreh".
How could atma have any other saroop than parmatma?? It is the same Jyot Saroop. Gurbani says that Vaheguru is, "jyot saroop sadha sukh daata" so is atma.
10. In my humble opinion, baani also says that we must let go of this "Self". "aap tiyaag hoy-aye sabh rianaah, jeevtea-n ao-n
marreyeh", "rasna japte tuhi tuhi". I think we are too attached to ourselves. You even said jokingly that you will tease me their in Sach Khand.
11. Guru Sahibaan has recited dhur ke baani for us humans here on earth. It advises, "jal-tarang geo-n jalayeh samaaya, teo-n jyoti sang jyot milaaya".
Veer ji, you say that Guru Angad dev ji was an avtaar but Gurbani says, "Avtaar na janne ant, parmesher parbrahm be-ant".
Gurbani talks about mukti yet bhagats say in pyaar, "raj na chaahoo, mukt na chaahoo" and asks for just place close to their Satguru.
Bhagat says in complete devotion and love of Vaheguru that I don't want any "baikunth" but gurbani also says:
"baikunth nagar jahaa sant vaasaa,
parabh charan kamal rid maahi nivaasaa"
Baikunth is a realm where the saints live, they enshrine the lotus feet of Parabh within their hearts
Guru Sahibaan are addressing their sikhs here on Earth. So understandably the tools they use to make us understand why we are here also the same that we can see and understand. Gurbani gives us references and references by calling Vaheguru friend, husband, father, mother, and countless other names. Ghar, darbaar, dargah and other such names are used so we can relate to and imagine. It will take forever to understand what Gurbani says and how we can put this all in prospective.
I have already admitted that like a blind man. I could be holding on to the leg of the Elephant and calling it a tree trunk. Unless Vaheguru makes me see again, how can I realize the whole elephant. I must agree that you know a lot more Gurbani than I, but I also say that we both could be like frogs in a well. If you ask that frog, "You have no idea that you are stuck in this well. There is an infinite world out there to experience." He will stubbornly dismiss your claim by saying, "what rubbish are you talking fool?" He will proceed to take coupe of big hops to hit the wall and would say, "Here, this is the end?" Now you can talk all you want, spend days beating your head against the walls of that same well but it will be all in vein. All you have to do is just pick him up, take him out the well and drop him anywhere. You wouldn't have to say a word! Please do this to me Veer ji as I am that frog in your opinion :-)
I say it again Veer ji. Let me understand baani more in light of what we have learned here. At this time, I just can't agree with your explanation of the scene after death where Guru Sahibaan are sitting on a throne alongside Vaheguru in Sach Khnad and they also came here to liberate us while sitting alongside Veheguru. Same way, Bhagats doing bhagati of Vaheguru in Sachkhand while sitting right in front of Veheguru (and they are also MERGED into Vaheguru and are able to come to Earth as they desire). I just can't agree with this at all. There are just too many loose ends and way too many holes in your theory.
>>>>>>>
I just want to comment on this comment of yours. The description of Sach Khand that Bhai Sahib has given is not unique to AKJ. Sant Gurbachan Singh of Damdami Taksal (Read Gurbani Paath Darshan) and Bhai Sahib Doctor Vir Singh (Read Rana Soorat Singh) too have the same description of Sach Khand. Sant Ishar Singh Rarewalay (listen to his diwans and cassettes of Jathedar Baba jee)too believed in the same description of Sach Khand i.e. where Bhagats are not sucked up into extinction but stay merged in Vaheguru and in full anand.
>>>>>>>
I disagree with you but I don't have the heart to disagree with all these great departed souls that did soo much great sewa for the Panth. I say with folded hands (as many others who don't believe the exact same thing) to sangat that I could be completely wrong but this is my understanding at the moment. So please, baksh laina ji.
I also suggest to you to listen to your own advice Veev ji and whenever someone cites writings, diwans, recordings, or any other material from SANT Gurbachan Singh Damdami Taksal, BHAI SAHIB Doctor Vir Singh or SANT Ishar Singh Rarewalay just say SAT BACHAN JI, I AGREE. Let's see if that can be accomplished. You are a very good poet Veer ji. Do you sing your own baani as SANT Ishar Singh Rarewalay use to do?
Vaheguru di apaar kirpa hai aap ji opper. You are a great Gursikh Veer ji and you are doing a great sewa through Tapoban Sahib, no doubt about it. I do love your posts, no doubt about that either.
vjkk vjkf
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
kaur · 01 Apr 2005
I have followed this VERY lengthy, yet quite engaging debate, but I have found that despite the numourous exchanges of ideas, discussions on pankitees and their meanings, sidetracks to other topics and other things, the fundamental question that was originally asked still has not been answered by J.Singh bhaji.
If bhagats no longer exist in Sachkhand because they merge with Vaheguru, WHO enjoys the bliss, WHO is going through anand, and HOW can they feel anything if they no longer exist?
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 01 Apr 2005
J. Singh jeeo,
[i]-----------------------------
Sadhke Veer ji, main qurbaan haan aap ji de. I didn't know you were a shaayr as well. Just great. Now I can proudly say that the great Tapoban Singh Kulbir Singh wrote a poem just for me.
----------------[/i]
I am no poet. Sitting there while writing that response to you, the effusion of emotions turned into poem. It was not planned.
[i]-----------
Our vichaar was going good, till you got frustrated and started mocking my understanding of Gurbani :-).
---------[/i]
Ih Sach nahi. This is not true. I did not mock your understanding of Gurbani not even once but I did however ask you to review your understanding of the notion of Mukti.
[i]
-----------------------
I am terrible at typing and it takes me a long time to respond to these elaborate questions, but instead of reading and responding to my post, you just started ridiculing my understanding. I don't remember nearly as much Gurbani by heart as you do, so I really had to do some research to refute your points. I am not trying to blow my own trumpet but I am more of a thinker. I read Gurbani and then I 'try" to understand it by putting it the the full context of Shri Guru Grant Sahib ji. Sometimes I don't even agree with myself (translation: when I can't decide, just leave it open :-) ).
-------------[/i]
I was not mocking you or disrespecting you but your post was written in a little bit of gussa and I found it very amusing. In haasa-makhaul-mazaak, I did write some lines but not to mock you, but to pacify you and make things lighten up. That’s all.
[i]---------
Our disagreement has been about what happens to jeev-atma when it's liberated from the circle of 84 lakh juni and goes back to it's origin Vaheguru. I just can't digest your explanation.
----------[/i]
Similarly, I could not agree to your concept of death-like Mukti, where aatmas lose consciousness and surthee. And to the second merger theory and to the fact that you believe that full merger is not possible while living and that only a connection occurs while living in this world.
[i]-------
1. We came to this Jagg (World) when Vaheguru put his jyot in our sareer (dehi).
-----------[/i]
Okay
[i]---------------
2. We are here stuck in this world of maaya and the only way to get out of this is through Naam, Naam that come with Gur Kirpa. We must jaap naam to be one with our beloved Vaheguru.
------------[/i]
Okay
[i]-----------
3. Vaheguru and Vaheguru alone does kirpa (bless) on us. "nadar kare ta simariya jaayi". He awaken the selfless love within us and we start to tarp (in bairaag) to be one with him. Afterall He is "Sargun nirgun nirankaar sunn samaaDhee aap, aapan kee-aa naankaa aapay hee fir jaap". We may think it's "me, me, me" but it's Him, Him and Him alone who puts this bairaag in
our heart.
------------[/i]
Okay. The only thing I want to add here is that when he does kirpa, he does not do it directly but does it through the True Guru. He is after all “Gurprasaad”. He lets us meet the true Guru, through whom we learn how to meet Vaheguru.
[i]-----------
4.When through SatGuru we are able to see what our real purpose here on Earth is, we start to jaap naam and get rangg-a in His rang. (Our) atma indeed is an ansh Parmatma and that's what we realize. We realize that "sabh kish ghar mein, bahar nahi, bahar tolle so bharam bhullahi". We realise that he resides in our ghat or ridh.
-------------[/i]
Just do inform, who realises here? Aatma? Or someone else? Aatma is already an ansh of Vaheguru. So need for aatma to realise anything. Then who is it that gets “Rang” in his rang?
[i]-----------
You say RIDH and GHAT are two difference things. Please ponder upon this pankati and decide for yourself: "jih GHAT simran raam ko so nar muktaa jaan, tihi nar har antar nahee naanak saachee maan". Gurbani tells us again and again how there is no difference between Vaheguru and Saadh, Brahmgyani, Sant, Gursikh, or bhagat. So, (liberated) atma is really roop of
Parmatma.
--------------[/i]
In your earlier example you had mentioned that Gurbani is saying something contradictory and I believe there is no contradiction in Gurbani. You stated two pankitis “Parbraham Saadh Rid Basae” and “Ghat Ghat Pooran Brahm Pragaash”. By stating this you implied that there is nothing special in Parbraham residing in the heart of a Saadh because he is “ghat Ghat” andar “Pragaash”.
In response to this I had written that the word Ghat in the pankiti you have given means a body. The word Ghat actually means a clay pot and this body is also referred to as a ghat i.e. a clay pot that will break anytime.
You cannot say that Parbraham resides in a Saadh in the same way as in a Manmukh. Parbraham is in everything but he is pargat in jyot form, in an accessible form, only in a Pooran Gursikh Saadh Mahapurakh, who through Naam gets him Pargat inside him. This is all.
I would say that we leave this topic because this will deviate us from the main topic – Condition of Bhagats in Sach Khand.
[i]-------------
5. Now through naam simran (samathi), we are able to connect with him, see him, meet him, realize him, experience him, or call it whatever makes you understand this state. Grubani say, "kaho kabeer goonge gurr khaya, puche te kya kahee-ay". We can't describe it in words.
-------------[/i]
What do you mean by connection? Does he not come to the seyj of your hirda and have milaap with your aatma, while living in this body?
If this milaap of Vaheguru and us occurs while living, then there is no need for another one after death of the physical body.
[i]----------
6. Although we have realized Vaheguru (our bandhans of 84 lakh juni are cut with Guru kirpa and we are freed from jamm dandey :-) ) while being in Human dehi and we stay leen in Him through Naam Samadhi, we still (literally) ARE in one of the 84 lakh juni. Aren't we.
-------------[/i]
Gursikhs do get deh taun Videh i.e. free of this body while still living in this body. This is why they are called Jeevan-mukat. Their body is still in 84 Lakh joonis but they are not, because they have now realised Vaheguru and Vaheguru has become one with their aatma.
[i]-----------
7. Once we leave this dehi (after our bandhan of 84 lakh juni got cut with Guru kirpa and we got freed while still being in this dehi), we get merged in the infinite jyot of Vaheguru.
------------[/i]
This is where again I differ. I provided shabads that clearly prove that gursikh and Vaheguru become one like “paani sang paani” i.e like water mergers in water, while living. It is not a connection but a merger of aatma with Parmatma, while living. I have never heard anywhere that while living only a connection occurs and after death a merger occurs. Please provide Gurbani pankiti to backup this claim of yours.
You had questioned why they still stay in this dehi then and why they still continue to keep rehit. Well they stay in dehi as per hukam of Vaheguru and they keep rehit because they have to keep the maryada of this human body and for the sake of other gursikhs and because it is hukam of Guru Sahib. Gursikh never becomes greater than Guru Sahib, whether he is merged or not.
[i]--------------
8. Vaheguru is INDEED infinite. I don't have to tell you what Gurbani says about Vaheguru but here are just a few pankities out of hundreds in SGGS ji:
mein dekh mukh jaisa, naamey kaa Beethal aisa".
-----------[/i]
Thanks for some great pankitis. I have no disagreement on this.
[i]------------
9. Once atma is freed and out of jamman-marran, it becomes (part of) Parmatma. Atma is "tuj te opjay, tuj mahe samaave". Vaheguru IS atma's mool origin ("mann tu jot saroop hai, apna mool pachaan", "Atma pratma eko karre"). I believe that a liberated atma is same as Parmatma (i.e. it becomes parmatma once freed after lekha jokha :-) ), "acharajh katha maha anoor, pratma parbrahm ka roop", "atma parmatma eko karreh, anter ke dubedha anter marreh".
-------------[/i]
I am glad that you accept that aatma’s roop is same as Parmatma. This simply means that like Parmatma, Aatma too is abinaashi i.e. eternal. Good. I agree with you here. So far you have not said that it loses consciousness, so I have no qualms over it.
Remember that above there, you have written that “mann tu Jyot saroop hain”. This proves that our mann too does not die and stays with us. Even Vaheguru has as a Mann – Bhagat, terai Mann bhanvde”. The only difference is that Mann now becomes jyot-roop after becoming roop of aatma.
[i]----------
How could atma have any other saroop than parmatma?? It is the same Jyot Saroop. Gurbani says that Vaheguru is, "jyot saroop sadha sukh daata" so is atma.
---------[/i]
Agreed. Aatma never dies and is Vaheguru’s roop, his ansh. This is why I cannot fathom why you were insisting on it losing surthee.
If Vaheguru does not lose surthe, why should aatma lose it?
After all, Aatma and Parmatma have similar qualities. If Parmatma is conscious, so will Atma be, that is one with Vaheguru. Aatma is abinaashi just as Vaheguru. “hota aaiya” i.e. it is eternal.
[i]----------
10. In my humble opinion, baani also says that we must let go of this "Self". "aap tiyaag hoy-aye sabh rianaah, jeevtea-n ao-n
marreyeh", "rasna japte tuhi tuhi".
-----------[/i]
I have no qualms over this. Agreed.
[i]-----------
11. Guru Sahibaan has recited dhur ke baani for us humans here on earth. It advises, "jal-tarang geo-n jalayeh samaaya, teo-n jyoti sang jyot milaaya".
-----------[/i]
If you read this whole shabad you will realise that this shabad is a very famous shabad of Siri Guru Panchmesh Pita jee. It has been beautifully sung by Bhai Gopal Singh Raagi of Darbar Sahib.
With respect to our vichaar going on, you will realise that these pankitis “Jal-Tarang jiyon, Jaleh samaaiya || Tiyon Joti sang jyot milaaiya |” describe the avastha of a Bhagat while living in this human body and not after physical death.
Sabh Kichh Ghar mein, baahar naahi || is also from this shabad. Guru Sahib is saying that everything is attained right in this body. Pooran Milaap occurs right here as stated above i.e. just as a wave of water merges in Water, same way Vaheguru and jeev merge.
[i]-------
Veer ji, you say that Guru Angad dev ji was an avtaar but Gurbani says, "Avtaar na janne ant, parmesher parbrahm be-ant".
---------[/i]
It will take us off-topic. I called him an avatar because Guru Sahib’s baani said so – Tu taan Janik Raja Avtaar.
As for that pankiti you gave, that is being referred to the 24 Avtaars of Vishnu.
[i]-----------
Gurbani talks about mukti yet bhagats say in pyaar, "raj na chaahoo, mukt na chaahoo" and asks for just place close to their Satguru.
----------[/i]
Here too it is clear that the utmost destination of a Gursikh is “Man Preet Charan Kamala re”. How can this avastha occur in a dormant deathlike state, where aatma has no consciousness, that you propagate? Preet of Charan Kamal can happen only if one is conscious.
[i]--------
"baikunth nagar jahaa sant vaasaa,
parabh charan kamal rid maahi nivaasaa"
Baikunth is a realm where the saints live, they enshrine the lotus feet of Parabh within their hearts
---------[/i]
This pankiti should be viewed in the same manner as you would view “Gur Ishar, Gur Gorakh Brahma, Gur Parbati Mayee”. For a Gursikh guru alone is Brahma, Bishan, Mahesh and Parbati. Same way, for Gursikhs, Sant Mandal is a Baikunth place.
[i]-------------------------
I say it again Veer ji. Let me understand baani more in light of what we have learned here. At this time, I just can't agree with your explanation of the scene after death where Guru Sahibaan are sitting on a throne alongside Vaheguru in Sach Khnad and they also came here to liberate us while sitting alongside Veheguru. Same way, Bhagats doing bhagati of Vaheguru in Sachkhand while sitting right in front of Veheguru (and they are also MERGED into Vaheguru and are able to come to Earth as they desire). I just can't agree with this at all. There are just too many loose ends and way too many holes in your theory.
----------------[/i]
We are not discussing what you can agree or what I can agree to or believe but we are discussing what the Gurmat viewpoint is on the ultimate condition of the Bhagats.
You cannot believe that Bhagats in the Dargah of Vaheguru can do Naam abhyaas but Gurbani clearly says so:
‘Bhagat Tere Mann Bhanvade, Dar sohan Keerat Gaanvade”.
Guru Sahib here clearly says that Bhagats at the Dar of Vaheguru are looking beautiful and are singing the praises of Vaheguru.
In the next pankiti Guru Sahib clearly says that Manmukhs cannot reach this Dar and are thrown out of there and they they wander around – Nanak, Karma baahrey, Dar dhoyee na lehnee, dhaanvde”.
I gave other pankitis too and I gave references of Singhs like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee who clearly mention that there are Bhagats at the Dargah of Vaheguru who are singing Keerat of Vaheguru.
I don’t know how it is agreeable to you that Bhagats lose consciousness and stay in a dormant deathlike state in the next world. Why do you like this definition of Mukti and where in Gurbani can you find support for this?
[i]----------
I also suggest to you to listen to your own advice Veev ji and whenever someone cites writings, diwans, recordings, or any other material from SANT Gurbachan Singh Damdami Taksal, BHAI SAHIB Doctor Vir Singh or SANT Ishar Singh Rarewalay just say SAT BACHAN JI, I AGREE. Let's see if that can be accomplished. You are a very good poet Veer ji. Do you sing your own baani as SANT Ishar Singh Rarewalay use to do?
------------[/i]
The only reason why I gave you reference of other Mahapurakhs along with Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee was because you had made a comment that this philosophy was that of AKJ and Bhai Sahib. I wanted to let you know that all Gursikhs I have read about believe in the everlasting life of Bhagats and don’t believe in Bhagats losing surthee.
Dost, there are two things still missing from your post. Please show some Gurbani proof that a second merger or the real merger takes place in the next world. Also please prove that Bhagats lose surthee and consciousness in the next world after merger.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulwinder Singh · 01 Apr 2005
This is clear, strong and above all humble appeal to Both Vir J.Singh Ji and Vir Kulbir Singh Ji to stop this topic for any further discussion.
You both have elaborated very well your own opinions and I love you both, to me you both are right as you are looking from your own point of view, None of you claim yet to have reached the Sachkhand ( which is good not to claim), so both parties are investing time and efforts to convince the other.
when you have never reached the destination yourself then it is wise not to commit too much efforts in describing the destination, you guys are going one step ahead then that saying for sure that you know what exactly it is in the destination although I do like the debating bit but on this topic it is time to call this debate off.
You can stop this topic by agreeing to disagree or you can just take this stupid brother of yours advise and accept my appeal and stop this debate. I strongly suggest that at least when somebody even moorakh like me appeal and it does not have anything against Gurmat or the interests of community then we should listen to that and try to accept it.
Please Viro Just stop this debate now. Both of you can just say 20 words maximum after this post, and try to be extra nice in 20 words, Please.
Your Moorakh Brother
Kulwinder Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
J Singh · 02 Apr 2005
Veer Kulbir Singh ji, I will listen to Veer Kulwinder Singh’s advise and try not go into too much detail.
You claim that all ten Guru Sahibaan are sitting alongside Vaheguru on a Throne in Sach Khand for Eternity (forever and ever).
Prove your claim through Gurbani. The only shabad you come up with so far is “dayv puree meh ga-ya-o aap parmaysvar bhaa-ya-o. har singhaasan dee-a-o siree gur tah bathaa-ya-o”. This shabad goes against your whole concept.
First you say that Guru Sahibaan are sitting alongside Vaheguru on a throne in Sach Khand forever and ever. Now, through this shabad, you prove that Veheguru Himself came to receive Guru Sahib and gave him throne to sit on in Devpuri (which means Sach Khand to you) after they left human dehi. If Guru Sahib is already sitting with Vaheguru on a throne in Sach Khand from eternity then which atma did He came to receive Veer Ji?? Haven't they already been sitting in Sach Khand alongside Vaheguru FULLY COMPLETE MERGED in Pooran Milaap with Him.
Same goes for your explanation of the state of bhagats.
If Devpuri means Sach Khand to you, then I assume Shivpuri or Shiv Nagri also means Such Khand to you (literally speaking). Please don’t tell me to whom these pankities are being addressed as I already know. Just to clarify, to me, Shiv Puri is a realm (not a place of Shiv ji) that you realize while naam jaap, not a place where Vaheguru is physically sitting as He is a infinite consciousness, sarab biyaapak.
shiv nagree meh aasan a-oDhoo alakh agamm apaaree
The true hermit obtains a seat in Shiv Nagri (City of God), the invisible, inaccessible, infinite.
shiv nagree meh aasan baisai gur sabdee jog paa-ee
Sitting in aasan postures in Shiv Nagri (city of God), through the Word of the Guru's Shabad, you shall find Yog.
shiv nagree meh aasan baisa-o kalap ti-aagee baadaN.
In Shiv Nagri, he sits in his aasan posture, and he forsakes his desires and conflicts.
shiv kee puree basai buDh saar.
In the City of God, sublime understanding prevails.
Princess ji, I have read the interpretation of Dharam Khnad, Gyan Khand, Saram Khand, Karam Khand and Sach Khnad by few writers; and I agree with the explanation Professor Sahib Singh gives. Even in it's literal meaning, there is no mention of bhagats, sants or anybody in Sach Khand part of the shabad. Only Vaheguru is SACH. It’s a realm that is experienced through naam simran.
>>>>>>
Sabh Kichh Ghar mein, baahar naahi || is also from this shabad. Guru Sahib is saying that everything is attained right in this body. Pooran Milaap occurs right here as stated above i.e. just as a wave of water merges in Water, same way Vaheguru and jeev merge.
>>>>>
Pyaare Veer ji, your explanations are nothing but a quagmire for me :-). First you say Vaheguru and Guru Sahibaan are sitting on a throne in Sach Khand and bhagats are doing bhagati there in anand. Now you say that they are doing all that in YOUR BODY! Translation: you merge in your own BODY where Sach Khand is and in that Sach Khand Guru Sahibaan are sitting on a throne and bhagats are doing bhagati!
>>>>>>
"Bhagat Tere Mann Bhanvade, Dar sohan Keerat Gaanvade”
>>>>>>
I don’t agree with your explanation. Bhagats are merged (Pooran Milaap) into vaheguru as a wave of water merges in Water while being here, so far so good. But then you say that at this Pooran Milaap (complete merger), they are sitting in front of Vaheguru in Sach Khnad doing bhagati forever and ever. How many atmas, surties, consciousness do they have?
>>>>>
Remember that above there, you have written that “mann tu Jyot saroop hain”. This proves that our mann too does not die and stays with us.
>>>>>
Disagree. We are talking to ourself by saying, bandiya tu jyot, atma hai.(“mann tu Jyot saroop hain”).
>>>>
If Vaheguru does not lose surthe, why should aatma lose it?
>>>>
I said atma and parmatma are same now. i.e. atma isn’t sitting in front of parmatma doing bhagati.
Veer ji, khima da jaachak haan. You are a wonderful Singh and you stuck with me through all these posts. I could be completely wrong, and I agree to disagree if it's ok with you :-).
And Sorry Kulwinder Singh, I couldn't quite stick to your 20 word max request.
vjkk vjkf
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 02 Apr 2005
J. Singh jeeo,
[i]--------
Veer Kulbir Singh ji, I will listen to Veer Kulwinder Singh’s advise and try not go into too much detail.
-----------[/i]
Well, you really did not listen to Veer Kulwinder Singh and did not limit your response to words he asked you to. I will thereby follow lead that you set and respond to your post.
[i]---------------
You claim that all ten Guru Sahibaan are sitting alongside Vaheguru on a Throne in Sach Khand for Eternity (forever and ever).
Prove your claim through Gurbani. The only shabad you come up with so far is “dayv puree meh ga-ya-o aap parmaysvar bhaa-ya-o. har singhaasan dee-a-o siree gur tah bathaa-ya-o”. This shabad goes against your whole concept.
-------------[/i]
There is no doubt that I say that our Guru Sahibaan are totally ikk-mikk with Vaheguru like taana-petta and Vaheguru is seated on the divine Singhaasan. All Bhagats are seated around him and this nazaara is so huge. "Vadda Tera Darbar, Sach Tudh Takhat". Your Darbar is Vadda and your Takhat is Sacha i.e. eternal.
When I quoted from Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee’s books that Vaheguru has a Darbar and a Takhat, you questioned mockingly how can there be a singhaasan or throne in Sach Khand. In response to that query from you, I gave you this pankiti of Guru Raamdas Sahib seated on a Takhat in Sach Khand. Even Professor Sahib Singh had to agree that this Takhat is in Sach Khand on which Siri Guru Raamdaas Sahib jee was placed after he left this human body. Don't know why you find it so hard to believe that Vaheguru can be seated on the throne in Sach Khand.
[i]----------------
First you say that Guru Sahibaan are sitting alongside Vaheguru on a throne in Sach Khand forever and ever. Now, through this shabad, you prove that Veheguru Himself came to receive Guru Sahib and gave him throne to sit on in Devpuri (which means Sach Khand to you) after they left human dehi.
--------------[/i]
I never wrote that Vaheguru came to receive Siri Guru Raam Daas Sahib jee. I did write that once he reached Sach Khand, “Har Singhaasan diyo, Siri Guru theh baithaaiyo” i.e. Vaheguru jee gave Siri Guru jee a throne and seated him on that throne. What can you or I say when Gurbani is saying that this event occurred and all Mystical saints like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee have said this and even scholars like Professor Sahib Singh agree to this?
[i]--------------
If Guru Sahib is already sitting with Vaheguru on a throne in Sach Khand from eternity then which atma did He came to receive Veer Ji?? Haven't they already been sitting in Sach Khand alongside Vaheguru FULLY COMPLETE MERGED in Pooran Milaap with Him.
-----------[/i]
I know you are not a saada-dimaagh (simpleton) as you are portraying yourself to be. I did not say that our ten Guru Sahibaan are seated on the throne from eternity anywhere. Now however, after the Guru-jyot or the Guru form of Vaheguru merged and became one with the Aatmas of our Guru Sahibaan, they are seated on the throne in Sach Khand. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has written this and he writes that he himself has witnessed this vision of Sach Khand. If you have witnessed something else, then you are welcome to believe whatever you want. But if you yourself have not witnessed anything, then I don't know why you are so adamant in your assumptions
[i]--------------
Same goes for your explanation of the state of bhagats.
If Devpuri means Sach Khand to you, then I assume Shivpuri or Shiv Nagri also means Such Khand to you (literally speaking). Please don’t tell me to whom these pankities are being addressed as I already know. Just to clarify, to me, Shiv Puri is a realm (not a place of Shiv ji) that you realize while naam jaap, not a place where Vaheguru is physically sitting as He is a infinite consciousness, sarab biyaapak.
----------------[/i]
One word can have many meanings. Just take the word “Raam”. In Gurbani most of the times this word means Vaheguru i.e. Ramiyaa hoiya Vaheguru i.e. all pervading Vaheguru. Raam also means Raghuvanshi Raam Chander the famous king of Treta Jug and the avatar of that yug. Gurbani has reference to this Raam as well e.g. Raam gaiyo, Raavan gaiyo; jaa ko bahu parivaar”.
Same holds true for the word “Gurmukh” that means Vaheguru, Guru Nanak Dev jee, Sikh, and “through Gurmat”.
Similarly the words Baikunth, Shivpuri, Dev, Krishna, Muraari, etc have different meanings and just like Hans bird that splits milk from water, Gursikhs discern the meanings of these words depending on the context they are used in.
I think you are deviating from the real issue again. The crux of my argument is that Bhagats get an everlasting life in Dargah of Vaheguru and as you claim, they don’t get everleasging life and die in the vajood of Vaheguru.
Earlier I asked you to prove to me how Vaheguru is not a Kabristhaan according to your interpretation of mukti and I asked you to either prove that he is not a Kabristhaan according to your interpretation or change your concept of Mukti. You totally ignored this benti from me.
[i]-----------------------------
>>>>>>
Sabh Kichh Ghar mein, baahar naahi || is also from this shabad. Guru Sahib is saying that everything is attained right in this body. Pooran Milaap occurs right here as stated above i.e. just as a wave of water merges in Water, same way Vaheguru and jeev merge.
>>>>>
Pyaare Veer ji, your explanations are nothing but a quagmire for me :-). First you say Vaheguru and Guru Sahibaan are sitting on a throne in Sach Khand and bhagats are doing bhagati there in anand. Now you say that they are doing all that in YOUR BODY! Translation: you merge in your own BODY where Sach Khand is and in that Sach Khand Guru Sahibaan are sitting on a throne and bhagats are doing bhagati!
-----------------------[/i]
You are totally confused and have failed to grasp a very simple concept that is known to bacha bacha of Sikh Panth. In this body you attain the pooran aatmak milaap of Vaheguru and after you leave this body, you go to Sach Khand, still merged in Vaheguru, and get an everlasting life there. You stay in Sach Khand, beholding Vaheguru inside and outside of yourself there too. Exactly same milaap as here but the only difference now is that you get free from maaiya and this body and can now reside in pargat roop in Sach Khand.
This shabad that you quoted proved it beyond doubt that in this human body the aatmik milaap of Vaheguru and Sikh occurs like jyot into jyot. This pankiti destroyed your imaginative notion that the aatmik milaap occurs only after death.
[i]--------------------
>>>>>>
"Bhagat Tere Mann Bhanvade, Dar sohan Keerat Gaanvade”
>>>>>>
I don’t agree with your explanation. Bhagats are merged (Pooran Milaap) into vaheguru as a wave of water merges in Water while being here, so far so good. But then you say that at this Pooran Milaap (complete merger), they are sitting in front of Vaheguru in Sach Khnad doing bhagati forever and ever. How many atmas, surties, consciousness do they have?
---------------------[/i]
Why are you using your own matt when Gurbani is clearly saying in this pankiti that Bhagat at the Dargah of Vaheguru are looking beautiful and are singing keerat of Vaheguru?
Why can’t you be merged in Vaheguru and be seated in front of Vaheguru at the same time? What is the problem with this? Vaheguru is so big that in his body the whole creation is there. While he is pargat inside you, you also behold him in Sach Khand. What is the hard part to understand here?
Here is a prime example of how you are ignoring Gurbani furmaan here. Is not Gurbani clearly saying that the Bhagats are sitting in Dargah of Vaheguru and doing keerat? Does not the next pankiti clearly say that Manmukhs don’t get dhoyee at this dar and have to wander around? Just you saying that you don't agree does not solve the problem. Tell us what else this pankiti means then.
[i]----------------------
>>>>>
Remember that above there, you have written that “mann tu Jyot saroop hain”. This proves that our mann too does not die and stays with us.
>>>>>
Disagree. We are talking to ourself by saying, bandiya tu jyot, atma hai.(“mann tu Jyot saroop hain”).
------------------[/i]
J. Singh jeeo, Guru Sahib is not saying Bandiya or anything else. Guru Sahib is clearly referring to Mann as jyot saroop. Mann is Jyot Saroop and is abinaashi just as the jeev is. If Gurbani is saying that mann is jyot saroop, you can’t ignore it like you are.
[i]-----------------
>>>>
If Vaheguru does not lose surthe, why should aatma lose it?
>>>>
I said atma and parmatma are same now. i.e. atma isn’t sitting in front of parmatma doing bhagati.
------------------[/i]
No, you are now shying away from your theory that aatma loses identity when it merges with Vaheguru to become one. To you oneness means losing one’s surthee and then on top of that you also claim that the aatma is in bliss. Here you totally fail me with your unique philosophy.
Guru Sahib has clearly asked for neither mukati nor Raaj but only Charan Kamal kee Preet. In order to have this preet of Charan Kamal for ever and ever, you have to have surthee or consciousness. A dead aatma as you prefer it, cannot do preet. If it is an alive aatma with surthee, and if it is to do preet, then it would be doing ustat as well.
[i]----------------
Veer ji, khima da jaachak haan. You are a wonderful Singh and you stuck with me through all these posts. I could be completely wrong, and I agree to disagree if it's ok with you :-).
-------------------[/i]
I am not stuck with you at all. I enjoyed doing this discussion with you and don’t mind continuing it as long as we resolve this. So it is up to you if you want to respond to this or not but I will summarise your and my beliefs in this post for others to understand:
Your Beliefs are very different. Your claims too are very different from others and are not supported by Sikh Mahapurakhs and mystics. You claim that in this world one cannot have pooran milaap with Vaheguru. You claim that in this world only a connection occurs with Vaheguru and not a milaap. The real milaap or merger happens in the next world. Your concept of milaap is very cruel and gruesome. You believe in removing all surthee, budhee, matt, i.e. stripping the aatma of all its consciousness and thrusting it in Vaheguru. I then questioned to you if this is milaap, then Vaheguru is a Kabristhaan of dead dormant, conscious-less aatmas. On top of everything, I appealed to you, again and again, to provide a single pankiti for your support, but to no avail.
My beliefs are same as those of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh and other great mystics of Sikh Panth. Bhagats get pooran aamtak milaap right in this body and after death the only thing that changes is that physical location of the Bhagats. From this dehi they move to Sach Khand, where they can behold Vaheguru all the time and they get everlasting life in Sach Khand. They stay totally merged in the Anand Roop Vaheguru. They stay one with Vaheguru and have an eternal life.
The ball is in your court. It is up to you to think of Vaheguru as a Kabristhaan or an ocean of Bliss that he is. He is a Kabristhaan if you claim that aatmas are cruelly stripped of their surthee and consciousness; and he is Anand Roop if Aatmas retain their surthee and can enjoy his Anand
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulwinder Singh · 03 Apr 2005
I feel odd that my request has been over looked, never mind, but I feel this discussion need to be end now I am going to try one more time for now.
I am not angry with either of you Just want this discussion to close now,
As brother of both Virs , although I did side with J.Singh ‘s view as it is similar to my own view, But I said that for me it is not the how GOD has his setup of Sachkahnd , He is so big that he can make any number of enviournment with any kind of setups for a Bhagat, if that is what He/She want it to be in the sachkhand. As the wish of Bhagat is prime for GOD and Bhagats normally do not want anything else but the wish of GOD.
Now to me the difference you two are having is simply this:
I use a small example, Assume there is a big flame of Fire with Diameter of 20 meter and it is constant and it give light to the whole small city, then there are lot of children playing extremely safely around that flame, and they light their sticks and candles and play with little flame extremely safely ( 100% safe). Once these sticks and candles reach their end these children throw these candles and sticks right in the flame sometime they throw them in at random anyway just for fun, but flame neither decrease nor increase.
Your difference is does these little flames lose their identity in the big flame or not.
I think you can say either, they exist and keep on lighting with the big flame , or you can say they are now just part of the big flame.
You may think the merge take place after the candles /sticks are thrown back in the big flame, I think it was always part of the bigger flame anyway to say it right as true fact but there is an incident which can be described as final milap or merge as well. So you are both right.
Now the Question of conscious, a little flame enjoyed the enviourment where it was lighting up the small area, given the chance does this flame want to carry on the enjoyment of this small area of which this flame made lit, or would this little flame want to enjoy even more consciousness and though become part of bigger flame and even get far more bigger conscious then before to accelerate the enjoyment. Both possibilities are true for sure. But there is no death of conscious merging in both cases is perfectly with the conscious.
You may also like to think that we humans have only five senses, but GOD probably have many many many more senses to enjoy and experience, so merging with him will be far far more enjoyable, think if a blind person get eye sight and after getting the eye sight he /she is assure of only the Anad sights for ever, would that person like to gain eye sight or not ? Same with final merge with GOD, if that is what a Bhagat want, will only gain there is no chance of any loss at all.
It is perfectly true that many people who attain the prime level of closeness to GOD can find what ever vision they want of this final destination as true as their desire be cause GOD is sarb samrath. So people who have described their visions of final Destination should be take as true, as in GOD’s blessing everything is possible.
Now please Stop this debate for now, your comments are lacking sweetness in them and this topic should be just sweet and nothing else, so close your pens for now for this topic.
If would be kind for both of you to say the final Sat Shri Akal on this topic now.
I declare that you both agree to disagree. Have different way of looking at things but good news is you both looking at the same direction.
No more then 20 words after this post, and please as I said before be extra kind in those words.
Your Moorakh Brother.
Kulwinder Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 03 Apr 2005
Veer Kulwinder Singh jeeo,
With the due respect to you, please allow me to say something. I am enjoying this debate very much and am not in favour of closing this debate with "Mann kee mann kee maahe rahee" i.e. without satisfying either side. Closing this debating without bringing appropriate closure on this debate would not be fair to the debaters.
We are learning a lot from this debate and we are not at all fighting as you seem to think. J. Singh will confirm this that we are having a very friendly debate and probably one of the most intelligent debates that we ever had on this forum. Why stop it until one of us exits out?
It is just my opinion.
However I think we should concentrate only on the subject matter and not deviate from the topic as we have been doing. The topic on hand is:
1) What happens to the Bhagats in the ultimate condition of merger with Vaheguru? Do they cease to exist without conscousness or surthee? Does a second merger take place as J. Singh claims?
To go out of these topics is wrong and let us stick to the topic. Just my humble opinion. Tudh bhaavae taan aavae raas.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kaur · 03 Apr 2005
I too think this debate should keep going. It is only through debating and discussing Sikhi that we can find what is the truth according to Sikhi. And besides, I have learned a lot, as I am sure many others have, while following this thread. It would be weird to cut this debate off right at the climax, sort of like ending a story right when we are about to get to the conclusion. So, please, keep the topic going so we can all add to our knowledge on this issue.
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
J Singh · 04 Apr 2005
Kulbir Singh ji,
How I wish that you could stand by the very words you wrote yourself. We have gone over 100 posts discussing this issue. You have tried again and again and again to put words into my mouth. I asked you to support the very specific claims you made but you haven’t been able to prove any of these specific claims through Gurbani, the very reasons for why I got involved in this discussion.
I am not trying to mock you or anything. I truly don’t agree with what you wrote happens after death. I request you to read your own responses to my specific questions. There are no pankities in Gurbani that can support your specific claims.
>>>>>
But if you yourself have not witnessed anything, then I don't know why you are so adamant in your assumptions.
>>>>>>
You asked me a direct question and the answer is NO. NOW, I WILL DROP THIS DEBATE IN YOUR FAVOUR IF YOU TELL ME THAT YOU HAVE WITNESSED THE SPECIFIC SCENE YOU DESCRIBE IN SACHKHAND. Come on, we are not in elementary school anymore. The main reason I got involved in this discussion is because I didn’t agree with what you said happens after death. Gurbani doesn’t support it.
>>>>>> One word can have many meanings. >>>>>>
I agree 100% that one word can have many meanings. Gurbani should never be taken literally.
>>>>>>>
I think you are deviating from the real issue again.
>>>>>>
Crux of my argument is that you can’t support your claims, though you have softened your stance in this last post in the hope to get more support from Gurbani.
I don’t claim to know all the answer but I do have my understanding of Gurbani. I have asked you to let it be my understanding and let me learn more from Gurbani. You try to put words into my mouth over and over again. You called Vaheguru a Kabristhaan, which to me is very contemptuous word in shaan of our beloved Pritam Pyaara Vaheguru. What for?
>>>>>>
You are totally confused and have failed to grasp a very simple concept that is known to bacha bacha of Sikh Panth.
>>>>>
Now, you are making me laugh again. First it’s the whole Panth and now it is bacha bacha of Sikh Panth. Sikh Mahapurakhs and mystics are with you too. I know yoy don’t agree with a number of things these mahapurakhs have stated or condoned. Is it the same Kulbir Singh who opened says on this forum that everyone who doesn’t follow strict sarbloh is a Dhilla (WEAK IN REHIT) Sikh :-)? LOL.
>>>>>>
This shabad that you quoted proved it beyond doubt that in this human body the aatmik milaap of Vaheguru and Sikh occurs like jyot into jyot. This pankiti destroyed your imaginative notion that the aatmik milaap occurs only after death.
>>>>>>
Still trying to put words in my mouth. I am not going to repeat myself. I do fully understand that Gurbani says we realize, meet, see, get leen with (or whatever you want to call this Milan) Vaheguru in this Human Dehi through Naam Jaap.
>>>>>>
Here is a prime example of how you are ignoring Gurbani furmaan here. Is not Gurbani clearly saying that the Bhagats are sitting in Dargah of Vaheguru and doing keerat? Does not the next pankiti clearly say that Manmukhs don’t get dhoyee at this dar and have to wander around? Just you saying that you don't agree does not solve the problem. Tell us what else this pankiti means then.
>>>>>>>
As I said before, it’s your understanding not mine and you seem to believe that only you know the truth (SACH). I have already explained myself.
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>
I said atma and parmatma are same now. i.e. atma isn’t sitting in front of parmatma doing bhagati.
------------------
>>>>>>
No, you are now shying away from your theory that aatma loses identity when it merges with Vaheguru to become one.
>>>>
Go read any of my earlier posts. You can interpret them any which way you like but I have maintained the same stance throughout our discussion.
I have already said that this keera (insect) has very high respect for Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh and other great Mahapurkhs. I don’t think by discussing my understanding with you diminishes that respect at all.
>>>>>>
1) What happens to the Bhagats in the ultimate condition of merger with Vaheguru? Do they cease to exist without consciousness or surthee? Does a second merger take place as J. Singh claims?
>>>>>>
One more time, atma merges back into its moor origin Parmatma, the origin it came from. Vaheguru Created “dehi” by putting His jyot in it. His jyot goes back into HIM, into Vaheguru who is the Supreme Consciousness. To me, Vaheguru isn’t some form that looks like a human. He is self-created, He is infinite and He alone runs the whole show. Please read my other posts for more details.
Veer Kulbir Singh ji, I could be completely wrong but this is what my current understanding is. I read the same Gurbani as you do. We can keep on going at it but I personally don’t thing we are getting anywhere at all. Besides, I don’t have that much time either. I have also gained and learned a lot from this forum and will continue.
Kulwinder Singh, I have no zidd here. I just don’t agree with Kulbir Singh. I will try to end it here and will refrain from responding (unless of course my views are completely ridiculed or misquoted).
Khush raheo, mitr pyaareo.
Vjkk vjkf
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 04 Apr 2005
J. Singh jeeo,
I will ignore everything else you wrote here and just stick to the main issue on hand here.
1) Please prove that a complete merger does not take place in this dehi or body, while living. Tell us where did you get your concept that in this dehi, only a connection with Vaheguru occurs and not a milaap.
2) Please let us know what is the basis of your assertion that a second merger takes place after death? What is the basis of your two merger theory?
3) Lastly tell us know why do you insist that aatmas lose consciousness in the next world. Where does it say in Gurbani that they lose consciousness? And tell us that if aatmas lose consciousness, how do they enjoy bliss that you have been claiming that they enjoy?
The last point is particularly important. The descriptions of Sach Khand and how it looks and what Bhagats do there, we can forget for the moment, as long as we can agree that aatmas do not lose consciousness or surthee.
I am really surprised to know that for you a pooran milaap means losing means losing consciousness of Bhagats when there is not a single pankiti that says that the bhagats lose identity but there are several pankitis that clearly say that Bhagats have an everlasting life and bliss in the Dargah of Vaheguru.
Let us just concentrate on these subjects. I just want to know why you think that aatmas lose surthee or consciousness in the next world. If you could kindly let us know this, we will appreciate.
You wrote:
[i]One more time, atma merges back into its moor origin Parmatma, the origin it came from. Vaheguru Created “dehi” by putting His jyot in it. His jyot goes back into HIM, into Vaheguru who is the Supreme Consciousness. To me, Vaheguru isn’t some form that looks like a human. He is self-created, He is infinite and He alone runs the whole show. Please read my other posts for more details.[/i]
Well it is nice to see that you have not mentioned that they are stripped of their surthee or consciousness. Surely they are merged in Vaheguru and surely it is true that Vaheguru is not like the human body (remember that human body is of 5 elements and Vaheguru is beyond the 5 elements) but still the Gurmat point of view on the topmost avastha is that Bhagats don't cease to exist. They stay merged in Vaheguru and become one with him but they don't cease to exist. They have an everlasting life and stay in Total Anand forever and ever.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
J Singh · 05 Apr 2005
Pyaare Veer ji, although I did say that I will stop responding but I will oblige you one last time.
I assume that we have taken back your claims in question now because there is no specific support in Gurbani.
>>>>>
1) Please prove that a complete merger does not take place in this dehi or body, while living. Tell us where did you get your concept that in this dehi, only a connection with Vaheguru occurs and not a milaap.
>>>>>
We both agree that Gurbani says we realize, meet, see, get leen with (or whatever you want to call this Milaap) Vaheguru in this Human Dehi through Naam Jaap. You are welcome to read my earlier posts.
Your second merger is that, after death, bhagats sit infront of Vaheguru in Sach Khand or in Karam Khand doing Bhagati and having their individual will, atma, surti, consciousness intact to go whatever and be wherever they want. I say that jeev-atma goes back into (merges, sammaudi hai) Parmatma after its freed from the circle of birth and death. This is where it originated from. Atma is an ansh of Vaheguru Jyot. Vaheguru created it and sent it here; and Vaheguru alone calls it back. HE alone is SAT.
>>>>>
2) Please let us know what is the basis of your assertion that a second merger takes place after death? What is the basis of your two merger theory?
>>>>>
In my opinion, your theory states the second merger because you say that jeev-atma is completely merged into Vageguru 24/7 here on Earth and then this same Jeev-atma is sitting in front of Vaheguru in Sach Khand or in Karam Khand again completely merged into Vaheguru doing Bhagati forever and ever and ever. Doesn't bhagat's atma leave Dehi after death or do you have some other formula to get these two parts of the same jeev atma together in Sachkhand or Karam khand? You even quoted the shabad about what happens after death.
I have explained my position already.
>>>>>
3) Lastly tell us know why do you insist that aatmas lose consciousness in the next world. Where does it say in Gurbani that they lose consciousness? And tell us that if aatmas lose consciousness, how do they enjoy bliss that you have been claiming that they enjoy?
>>>>>
I have explained my meager understanding to you many times during this discussion. We already know that Gurbani says we realize, meet, see, get leen with with Vaheguru in this Human Dehi through Naam Jaap. After we die (get out of this dehi which IS part of the circle of 84 lakh juni), liberated atma goes back into it's mool origin Parmatma. At this point atma is same as Parmatma. Parmatma that is the Supreme consciousness and is forever in bliss. Gurbani says they are both jyot saroop. The difference to me is that one is the aseem (infinite) jyot, the supreme consciousness and other is an ansh of that same infinite jyot. Once this ansh goes back into it's mool infinite jyot, it becomes Him. Infinite Parm-Jyot that is forever in bliss.
I don't get it but you are free to sort out the difference between all these consciousness and atmas that you say are merged into Vaheguru like a wave is in Ocean.
Once again, please don't call Vaheguru a Kabristhan (a graveyard). It's very disrespectful. And, Once again, atma is beyond death, decimation, fannah or whatever. It's jyot saroop!, not a human being that if you hit it, it will lose consciousness.
>>>>>
They have an everlasting life and stay in Total Anand forever and ever.
>>>>>
Pyaare Veer ji, Our little difference lies in the interpretation and only Vaheguru can reveal this mystery to us. It's just my understanding and I don't claim to know the truth. This keera hasn't been blessed with the darshan of my Pritam Pyaara Vaheguru. Call me stubborn and move on :-).
Galtian maaf jeo.
vjkk vjkf
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Kulbir Singh · 05 Apr 2005
Your post has just repeated what you have written earlier. I will respond to you message later on but here is something else I want to talk to you about.
J. Singh jeeo, today while doing sehaj paath, I came across an amazing shabad on Ang 237. It is an ashtpadi of Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee and begins with "Prathmay Garbh Vaas tey Tariya".
You understand Punjabi and Gurmukhi pretty well. You don't need any translations. This shabad describes all other realms like Shiv Puri, Brahma Puri and other places including this world and in the end it makes startling revelations. It says that all other places will be destroyed except for the Anbhau Nagar (another name for Sach Khand). I think you should have a look at this shabad objectively and tell me if you think this shabad is talking about some avastha or an actual dwelling where Bhagats reside after this world.
Let us forget everything else and just do vichaar of this shabad. Guru Sahib has clearly written that Bhagats reside in this nagar and there are kirtan akhaaray there.
Please review that shabad and let me know your views on it. Professor Sahib Singh tried doing the arth of Avastha in the Padd-arths but fumbled while doing the actual translation and had to call it a place or a dwelling. All other translaters have done the meanings of Sach Khand here.
gourree mehalaa 5 ||
prathhamae garabh vaas thae ttariaa ||
First, they come forth from the womb.
puthr kalathr kutta(n)b sa(n)g juriaa ||
They become attached to their children, spouses and families.
bhojan anik prakaar bahu kaparae || sarapar gavan karehigae bapurae ||1||
The foods of various sorts and appearances will surely pass away, O wretched mortal! ||1||
kavan asathhaan jo kabahu n ttarai ||
What is that place which never perishes?
(This the central idea of this shabad - the rahao pankiti. What place is that which never perishes? Guru Sahib is going to answer this question in this shabad.
kavan sabadh jith dhuramath harai ||1|| rehaao ||
What is that Word by which the dirt of the mind is removed? ||1||Pause||
ei(n)dhr puree mehi sarapar maranaa ||
In the Realm of Indra, death is sure and certain.
breham puree nihachal nehee rehanaa ||
The Realm of Brahma shall not remain permanent.
siv puree kaa hoeigaa kaalaa ||
The Realm of Shiva shall also perish.
thrai gun maaeiaa binas bithaalaa ||2||
The three dispositions, Maya and the demons shall vanish. ||2||
gir thar dhharan gagan ar thaarae ||
The mountains, the trees, the earth, the sky and the stars;
rav sas pavan paavak neeraarae ||
the sun, the moon, the wind, water and fire;
dhinas rain barath ar bhaedhaa ||
day and night, fasting days and their determination;
saasath si(n)mrith binasehigae baedhaa ||3||
the Shaastras, the Simritees and the Vedas shall pass away. ||3||
theerathh dhaev dhaehuraa pothhee ||
The sacred shrines of pilgrimage, gods, temples and holy books;
maalaa thilak soch paak hothee ||
rosaries, ceremonial tilak marks on the forehead, meditative people, the pure, and the performers of burnt offerings;
dhhothee dda(n)ddouth parasaadhan bhogaa ||
wearing loin cloths, bowing in reverence and the enjoyment of sacred foods
gavan karaigo sagalo logaa ||4||
- all these, and all people, shall pass away. ||4||
jaath varan thurak ar hi(n)dhoo ||
Social classes, races, Muslims and Hindus;
pas pa(n)khee anik jon ji(n)dhoo ||
beasts, birds and the many varieties of beings and creatures;
sagal paasaar dheesai paasaaraa ||
the entire world and the visible universe
Binas jaaeigo sagal aakaaraa ||5||
- all forms of existence shall pass away. ||5||
Now here onwards the description of the dwelling of Bhagats start
sehaj sifath bhagath thath giaanaa ||
Through the Praises of the Lord, devotional worship, spiritual wisdom is attained.
sadhaa ana(n)dh nihachal sach thhaanaa ||
That eternal place (nihchal thaan) where there is eternal anand, is obtained if we do as ordained in the previous pankiti.
thehaa sa(n)gath saadhh gun rasai ||
There (in the next world in nihchal thaan), in the Saadh Sangat, the Company of the Holy, the Lord's Glorious Praises are sung with love.
anabho nagar thehaa sadh vasai ||6||
There, in the city of fearlessness, He dwells forever. ||6||
Here above, Guru Sahib calls this place Anbhau Nagar. Clearly Guru Sahib says that Bhagats reside in this Anbhau Nagar forever.
theh bho bharamaa sog n chi(n)thaa ||
There is no fear, doubt, suffering or anxiety there;
aavan jaavan mirath n hothaa ||
there is no coming or going, and no death there.
If his is talking about an avastha, then we know that an avastha does not stay the same. Definitely this is the talk of next world.
theh sadhaa ana(n)dh anehath aakhaarae ||
There is eternal bliss, and the unstruck celestial music there.
bhagath vasehi keerathan aadhhaarae ||7||
The devotees dwell there, with the Kirtan of the Lord's Praises as their support. ||7||
This above pankiti leaves no doubt at all. There bhagats reside on support of Kirtan (kirtan aadhaar).
paarabreham kaa a(n)th n paar ||
There is no end or limitation to the Supreme Lord God.
koun karai thaa kaa beechaar ||
Who can embrace His contemplation?
kahu naanak jis kirapaa karai ||
Says Nanak, when the Lord showers His Mercy,
nihachal thhaan saadhhasa(n)g tharai ||8||4||
the imperishable home is obtained through Saadh Sangat, and you shall be saved. ||8||4||
Let us do vichaar of this shabad. Perhaps we will get somewhere or reach some conclusion through this shabad. Let us hear your views on this shabad and if possible your interpretation of this shabad. Before throwing anything else in this debate, let us first finish doing this shabad. Then we can proceed to other shabads if you want.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
N30 S!NGH · 06 Aug 2006
This is probably the best thread I ever read on tapoban in the past, just finished re-reading this whole thread, some really great posts by Jsingh and Kulbir Singh:
Argument/Focus of this debate:
When soul gets merge with Nirankar after leaving the phsyical body. It's not destroyed. It still has consciousness because there are gurbani tuks in siri guroo granth sahib mentioning terms like- begumpura sehar, paramand, anand which proves that soul has consciousness of it's own existence.. so naturally even though soul gets merge with nirankar..soul has it own indentity. Soul does not get destroyed.
Point raised to counter that argument:
Soul merges with Nirankar and become one with Nirankar. No diffference between nirankar and soul...just like drop merges with the ocean and no one can tell difference. Soul loses it's consciousness (antish karam/man chit budd) and surat and after merging with nirankar...reason why there is mention of terms "parmanand" "anand" in the gurbani is because nirankar itself is in parmanand, anand ..once soul merges with nirankar (according to different interperation used in argument) ..it's ok to say - it's is anand and parmanand and this does not mean soul have consciousness because nirankar itself parmanand, anand...soul does not get destroyed but get merged with Nirankar..ray belongs to sun..source and destination of that ray is sun after all !!!!!!!!!!!! also example used from gurbani- Soraj Kiran Milli Jal ka Jaal hoya Raam Joti Jot Rali Sampuran thiya Raam ||
==
Here are the some of responses members of Sikhawareness had to add to this discussion after reading this great vichar:
====
One is a modified non-dualism; akin to the toenail and the person - the toenail is a part of you, but not your entirety...but then this leads to the suggestion that there are lesser essential parts of Brhman. The toenail on being reunited to the foot abides at the feet in bliss..this is a dualistic-non-dualism.
The other is that nothing gets destroyed because the concept of an individual soul is illusory in the first place! That sat chit anand is you, therefore you are ever abiding in bliss, ever conscious, ever truth (brahmgyani aap nirankar). This would make gurbani at times as didactic as 'tat tvam asi' (you are that) - as it is virtually impossible to discuss non-dualism without using dualist language.
These are simply positions to be held by people. For example, most Nirmalay such as Baba Isher Singh Rarewale, Kavi Santokh Singh hold firmly to the latter view. Yet others hold to the first.
I would argue that the strictest advait of Adi Sankaracharya is not akin to gurmat, and if anything it is the modified forms such as Ramanuj's and Vallabacharya which show the closest similarity. Vallabhacharya holds that Adi Sankaracharya has misunderstood and created a further dualism between vidya (truth) and maya (although he is not thought to have used the words in the texts most likely written by him), as maya although being unreal in its nature, exists in one level of understanding (ours). Therefore, Vallabhacharya states that actually everything is brham and if brham wills it (akin to nadari) then we shall be awoken to our true nature, hence accepting both bhagti marg and jnanmarg.
It is at the end of the day a useless debate to a degree as they are positions to be held by individuals based on their own understanding. I have heard and accepted arguments with quotes for the Advait view, and heard and accepted arguement for the qualified view.One is a modified non-dualism; akin to the toenail and the person - the toenail is a part of you, but not your entirety...but then this leads to the suggestion that there are lesser essential parts of Brhman. The toenail on being reunited to the foot abides at the feet in bliss..this is a dualistic-non-dualism.
The other is that nothing gets destroyed because the concept of an individual soul is illusory in the first place! That sat chit anand is you, therefore you are ever abiding in bliss, ever conscious, ever truth (brahmgyani aap nirankar). This would make gurbani at times as didactic as 'tat tvam asi' (you are that) - as it is virtually impossible to discuss non-dualism without using dualist language.
These are simply positions to be held by people. For example, most Nirmalay such as Baba Isher Singh Rarewale, Kavi Santokh Singh hold firmly to the latter view. Yet others hold to the first.
I would argue that the strictest advait of Adi Sankaracharya is not akin to gurmat, and if anything it is the modified forms such as Ramanuj's and Vallabacharya which show the closest similarity. Vallabhacharya holds that Adi Sankaracharya has misunderstood and created a further dualism between vidya (truth) and maya (although he is not thought to have used the words in the texts most likely written by him), as maya although being unreal in its nature, exists in one level of understanding (ours). Therefore, Vallabhacharya states that actually everything is brham and if brham wills it (akin to nadari) then we shall be awoken to our true nature, hence accepting both bhagti marg and jnanmarg.
It is at the end of the day a useless debate to a degree as they are positions to be held by individuals based on their own understanding. I have heard and accepted arguments with quotes for the Advait view, and heard and accepted arguement for the qualified view.
===================
==================.
This illusionary identity of being dualistic is necessary for the only purpose of expressing in word the non-dualistic truth. Words are a hinderence in themselves in knowing the Truth.
example: I cannot come to you and say I am God without you raising and eyebrow and condeming me to being an egoist. Yet at the same time There is no greater truth than that. To know that I am God and yet at the same time speaking about God as something not me. I am God, yet i speak about God as if he is not me, an oxymoron?
The purpose of thinking of God as not yourself wihtout this realization that you are him has much to do with our ego. There has to be someone for us to surrender this ego to before this realization can come to exist that we ourselves are god. That is the role of the God in the form of a Guru. He accepts the burdon of your ego.
Whos identity is being saved when being merged with God? So the Identity of God realized soul is being saved by god himself. God is saving his own identity...if all is he then so is this saved identity...for the memories of this god-soul being merged with god are none but the memories of God himself. For is it not he himself who is a Brahmgiani?Aside from the enlightening explanation veer tsingh has provided.
===============
[%sig%]
Re: Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru
Singh · 06 Aug 2006
Regarding Sant Rarewale's view on this, look at this respond by kulbir singh:
Author: Kulbir Singh
Date: 03-31-05 20:12
J. Singh jeeo,
--------------
Being part of AKJ, I respect your and Kulbir Singh's admiration for Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh ji. I love their writings too.
-------------------
I just want to comment on this comment of yours. The description of Sach Khand that Bhai Sahib has given is not unique to AKJ. Sant Gurbachan Singh of Damdami Taksal (Read Gurbani Paath Darshan) and Bhai Sahib Doctor Vir Singh (Read Rana Soorat Singh) too have the same description of Sach Khand. Sant Ishar Singh Rarewalay (listen to his diwans and cassettes of Jathedar Baba jee)too believed in the same description of Sach Khand i.e. where Bhagats are not sucked up into extinction but stay merged in Vaheguru and in full anand.
Your philosophy of two mergers (one in this world and one in the next world) and Bhagats losing consciousness and going extinct is a unique philosophy.