Re: Guru Granth Sahib ji on computer
Jarnail Singh "Arshi" · 25 Jul 2003
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Ji KI fateh.
IMHO...whats the difference ?? If ALL the GURBANI in the Sri Guru Granth sahib Jee is on on a DVD in your Cd-Rom Drive or on your HARD DRIVE...HOW is that DIFFERENT from the PAPER BOUND VERSION of SGGS ??
I dont think there is any difference. IMHO if GURU JI were here TODAY, Guru Arjun Sahib Jee would be having Bhai Gurdass Ji TYPING into his computer...better still Guru Ji could just VOICE COMMAND and the Computer could type itself.
In Guur Ji's TIME, GURU JI did not go backward but ADVANCED FORWARD - like USING the People's language and an entirely different Script GURMUKHI to convey the Divine Message of Gurbani. GURU JI also did away with letting their chelas record the bani later - THEY MADE SURE they wrote it down themselves ( UNLIKE the Vedas/Shastras/ Quaran - the known books of that time which were not written by their "authors" but much later put to paper by SCRIBES from HEAR SAY ONLY. Also the BOOKS werte NOT BOUND into one volume... they were on parchments and in piecemeal..GURU JI made sure the GURU GRANTH was BOUND in a Solid JILID. As such Bookbinding was NOT available locally, GURU JI SENT the Volume to be BOUND as LAHORE. If all this is NOT FORESIGHT by our Guru Sahibaans to PRESERVE their Divine Message from alterations and additions...????
We are BOUND by TRADITION if we stick to the Paper bound editions...soon there will be Multimedia HOLOGRAM Editions available on DVD...Projectors already Project Gurbani on screens in Gurdwaras and... there are bound to be better and better versions.
I "respect" some people's idea to go back......some want to just 'RETIRE" the padchaed Saroops now in practically every gurdwara and sikh home and replace them with LARIDAAR Saroops.....still others may want to GO BACK EVEN FURTHER and have Hand written Laridaar Saroops bound in the exact way the Karturpuri Bir is written and bound. I can only say with humility.. GURU JI was FORWARD LOOKING and ADVANCEMENT Oriented...otherwise we would have the Guru Granth sahib on parchments and leaves just like the Vedas
Re: Guru Granth Sahib ji on computer
Kulbir Singh · 25 Jul 2003
Becoming advance does not mean breaking the Gurmat traditions. If we go by the argument of being advance, we would end up supporting the replacement of kirpan as kakaar with a gun. Just as this is a wrong thing to do, there is nothing advance about breaking baani and having padd-chhed saroop. What is advance about it?
Writing Guru Granth Sahib jee is even better. I wish there was no printing press and only hand-written saroops were available. The Jewish Torah is only hand-written to this day and publishing it is prohibited. They have a whole department and hundreds of writers there are employed in writing the Jewish holybook day and night. We could have done the same thing.
In any case, Laridaar is a must.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Guru Granth Sahib ji on computer
everpresent devils · 26 Jul 2003
...dvd,cdrom,cassettetape, LCD projector, Toshiba laptop, Sony VCD, paper,handwritten, printed, parchments, leaves, larivaar printed by HP Laserjet,, padched printed by IBM Lexmark, jewish torahs hand written, flash memory by Samsung, human brains, wood palki form Canada, plastic palki from Korea, metal palki from Argentina.......these are juz mediums, MEDIA mediums to be exact. many have come n gone n many yet to come then go........
my respected khalsa ji,
"pay respect to the Everpresent Word n Shabad and not the medium."
(My respected MKhalsa, Be inspired by the Everpresent Word and not by whether it is handwritten bir by 50 sevadars or printed bir using the most pure or expensive ink!)
In fact, a medium is NOT even necessary if your objective is to meet...
Gauri Bairagan, 1st Mehla, (~ 749)
If I were to become a Deer, living in the forest, eating fruits and roots
By Guru's grace, if I were to obtain my Husband-Lord, O, unto him I would be a sacrifice again n again.||1||
I am a merchant of the Lord, Your Name is my merchandise and trade.||Pause||
If I were to be a Bird, living on a mango tree, reflecting peacefully on the Shabad, the Word.
With natural ease, I would meet my Husband-Lord, whose vision n beauty are incomparable.||2||
If I were to be a Fish, living in the water, I would remember the One who cares for all creatures n beings.
My Husband-Lord dwells on this side n other side, I would stretch out my arms to hug Him.||3||
If I were to be a Snake, living in the ground, the Lord's Shabad would still dwell within me, and my fear would depart.
O Nanak, they are the happy soul-brides, Whose light the Lord blends with His own light.||4||2||19||
everpresent devil no. 1 says: the deer, fish, bird, snake did not require dvd, vcd, paper, ink, computer, to achieve............
everpresent devil no.2 says: pay respect to the Word. not the medium, regardless if it's paper, dvd,vcd,lcd, abc, def, ghi, jkl, inkjet laserjet handjet, etc etc.
everpresent devil no.3 says: oops!!...he is missing....oops! he's gone to climb an apple tree!!
"vjkk vjkf from the everpresent devils now back in campus."
[%sig%]
Re: Guru Granth Sahib ji on computer
Gursikhan to(n) balhaaree · 26 Jul 2003
Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh.
I completly agree with Bhai Kulbir singh, there should be handwritten birs in larridaar sroop and without raag mala. A few years ago bhai Ram Singh ji (Ex Sqd ldr. Amritsar Sahib, Jathedaar akj) did such sewa by doing hard labour,But some persons objected that. What happened afterwords I donot know . If someone knows please tell us , I am eager to know.
Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh.
[%sig%]
Re: Guru Granth Sahib ji on computer
Jarnail Singh "Arshi" · 27 Jul 2003
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
IMHO two persons who had the COMPLETE GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE in thier MEMORY come to mind. One was Bahi Randhir Singh Ji and the other was my own dad, the Late Gyani Darbara Singh Ji of Tallewal Bahtinda.
Neither Bahi Randhir Singh Ji or my dad wanted to be treated " equal" to Guru Granth.sahib jee. This is the MOST RIDICULOUS argument i have come across. The DVD of a Ragi contains the voice/picture of the Raagi --- that doesnt make the DVD EQUAL to the ragi. Only a real MOORAKH would equate a dvd with a ragi.
The message that made most sense is the MEDIUM one - paper, ink, jilid, tape,fourtrack,eight track,vcd, dvd, svcd, whatever is JUST THE MEDIUM. At that time GURU JI ONLY had the PAPER INK MEDIUM - NO OTHER OPTION .
Prpoer RESPECT - YES, when I have the computer on and its GURBANI, I cover my head and dont try to be eating somehting etc..... when I listen to the VCD of a Ragi I also cover my head......same as when I Parkash my copy of SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE ( which is LARIDDAR by the way)....... BUT POOJA.... NO WAY. I dont beleive in having a ghee lamp, arti in a thaal, etc etc. I beleive GURMAT is IN the WAY OF LIFE as shown by GURBANI......not in idle POOJA of the SAROOP as such. ( by this I mean just a clean set of rumallas, palki, chandoa,chaur sahib clean utensils for degh, etc changed as and when necessary .....and NO MUST BUY NEW Rumallas every week, ( guru ji needs to change clothes just like we do ??) wash the chaur, etc etc. IMHO that is not the DEH we mean is it. If that is DEH then we must brush the teeth,bathe,feed,etc etc - then the Saroop becomes just another idol which GURBANI CONDEMNS. I wonder if a man just brushes guru ji's teeth, washes, bathes, feeds the deh etc where does he have time to ACTUALLY READ the GURBANI and Follow the HUKM...anyway where are the teeth, feeding place etc of this "deh". Beleive me when I write this ... a SANT from NANAKSAR tried to convince me this is the way DEH of Guru Ji MUST be treated and was treated by Nand Singh/Ishar Singh to get DARSHAN of GURU NANAK.......
Not meant to hurt anyones feelings.
Dassan dass Jarnail Singh.
Re: Guru Granth Sahib ji on computer
Jarnail Singh "Arshi" · 28 Jul 2003
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Due to the Money making greediness of the Shopkeeprs, and booksellers we have many thousands of Guru Granth Sahib Jee Saroops with hundreds of MISTAKES.
This phenemonon was got rid off by the SGPC when they came up with PHOTOSTATIC PRINTS with No Mistakes.....all saroops were then printed from these plates...One or two mistakes still got through.
You know how difficult it is to WRITE GURBANI without making a mistake ?? Just try wriiting a few pauris of Japji sahib and compare what you wrote...You are bound to have many siharis and aunkars missing......
Then comes the Task of COPY PROOFING... who is going to COPY PROOF each and every handwritten copy of the saroop.... if anyone can just go ahead and write his own saroop arent there going to be some saroops with UNIQUE MISTAKES ( additions even maybe done intentionally......just like raagmala was added in ????) WHAT happens to these saroops when found out ?? WILL the AKAL TAKHAT be the vetting authority of each sroop...will there be enough vetters/copy proofers/ diligent enough to read every word properly.....HOW TO STOP someone from ADDING/DELETING after the copy is Vetted Approved ????
So many questions to consider???? Going back to handwritten laridaar sroops is just asking for trouble ???? IMHO. It is wishful thinking that we can set back the clock of Time.
A dear friend in malaysia has Handwritten a sroop and presented this to SGPC for Parkash at Harimandir sahib. It took him 10 years.......and each Page was sent to SCHOLARS to scrutinise word by word for mistakes...as one person couldnt be trusted to do a perfect job of it all The second copy he kept it for his sons as a momento.
Dassan daas jarnail Singh