Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Frescos of Hindu gods whitewashed

Frescos of Hindu gods whitewashed

Kulbir Singh · 26 Jul 2003

Frescos of Hindu gods whitewashed Tribune News Service Tarn Taran, July 26 Wall paintings of Hindu gods including Lord Rama and Lord Krishna, which were unique specimens of Sikh school of art, have disappeared from the upper storey of Sri Darbar Sahib here founded by fifth Sikh Guru, Guru Arjan Dev in 1597 A.D. It is learnt that the frescos of Hindu gods were erased during the ‘kar seva’ being carried out by Baba Jagtar Singh at the behest of the Shiromani Gurdwara Prabandhak Committee. The frescos were unique specimens of Sikh school of art, completed in the year1824, during the regime of Maharaja Ranjit Singh. According to Sikh history, Maharaja Ranjit Singh got the gold-plating and interior decoration of the Darbar Sahib completed by taking personal interest. However, Baba Amrik Singh, in charge of the ‘kar seva’ feigned ignorance about the existence of the wall paintings of Hindu gods, he claimed there was not even a single painting of Hindu Gods when the SGPC had handed over the ‘kar seva’ to Baba Jagtar Singh in 2000. He said the interior decoration of the upper storey including the wall paintings were badly damaged due to seepage. However, rest of the paintings which were visible at the time of ‘kar seva’ could be preserved after taking lot of painstaking efforts. When asked that the history had record of the paintings of Hindu Lords in the upper storey of Darbar Sahib, Baba Amrik Singh hastened to add that, “it was practically difficult to revive those paintings which were beyond recognition”. Now all the 16 paintings which were revived by using the similar style and colours that of the time of Maharaja Ranjit Singh, belong to Sikh Guru, Sikh warriors and religious leaders including Baba Deep Singh, Bhai Mani Singh, Bhai Ghanaiya, Baba Budhaji. The first head granthi of the Golden Temple (Amritsar) and four ‘Sahibzadas’ (sons of Guru Gobind Singh) and Bhai Gurdass. Some of the paintings depict Guru Nanak Devji flanked by Bhai Bala and Bhai Mardana. Though the ‘kar seva’ of the paintings has been completed yet the upper storey has not been open to the devotees. Mr Jaswant Singh, an artist of ‘Dera Baba Jagtar Singh, Kar Seva’ claimed that the specified colours were used to complete the art work. He claimed that the paintings would last long as efforts had been made to stop seepage of the upper storey.

Re: Frescos of Hindu gods whitewashed

Jarnail Singh "Arshi" · 28 Jul 2003

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa waheguru Ji Ki fateh. IMHO what's the FUSS about ? What are Hindu devtas paintings doing on a gurdwara wall anyway. This must be a throwback to the days BEFORE SINGH SABHA MOVEMENT when the Darbar Sahib parkarima had DEVTA STATUES lined up all over the place. The Singh sabha REMOVED the statues but the wall frescoes must have escaped attention. Are we not supposed to HAVE NO PAINTINGS of even our GURU jI's on Gurdwara walls ? So if GURU JI paintings are not allowed why the big fuss about paintings about Hindu Gods?? IMHO SHABAD is GURU...all paintings are human imagination. The famous artist Sobha Singh whose famous painting of Guru nanak with raised handPalm is in the millions...was once asked How he imagined aGuru nanak. He said everything was EASY...BUT to Paint the PALM of Guru Ji I had to ask a BRAHMIN ASTROLOGER as to WHAT LINES a PALM of SUCH A HOLY PERSON should have...and I then PAINTED the PALM according to that barhmin astrologer's instructiuons. CAN ANYONE TELL ME ANYHTING MORE RIDICULOUS /??? When will SIKHS learn to Follow the SHABAD only and leave all this uselss luggage behind

Re: Frescos of Hindu gods whitewashed

daas · 29 Jul 2003

No I think the frescos should have remained there. Those hindu Gods are SLAVES of Waheguru ... and drawing them was: 1) an expose of the TALENT of Sikh artists 2) a piece of HISTORY 3) just a visual representation of the SLAVES of God -- even Guru jee says that these god's EXIST but none of them are "poojan-jogay" or worth praying too.. only Akaal Purkh is worth praying too - the God of all Gods - MAHAA AKAAL, SAT SRI AKAAL

Re: Frescos of Hindu gods whitewashed

Kulbir Singh · 29 Jul 2003

daas wrote: > No I think the frescos should have remained there. > > Those hindu Gods are SLAVES of Waheguru ... and drawing them > was: > > 1) an expose of the TALENT of Sikh artists > > 2) a piece of HISTORY > > 3) just a visual representation of the SLAVES of God -- even > Guru jee says that these god's EXIST but none of them are > "poojan-jogay" or worth praying too.. only Akaal Purkh is worth > praying too - the God of all Gods - MAHAA AKAAL, SAT SRI AKAAL I don't think this logic stands. The real daas or slaves of Vaheguru are his bhagats i.e. Gursikhs. The naqli devtaas who do not go beyond Giyaan Khand have no place in Harmandir Sahib (Sachkhand). If devtaas are not allowed in SachKhand, why allow them in the Sachkhand on Earth. Besides, Arshee jee has already made it clear and no kind of pictures are allowed in a room where Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee is parkaashed. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Frescos of Hindu gods whitewashed

daas · 30 Jul 2003

If the frescos were in Guru jee's room I can understand But "Sach khand vasai nirankar" "ghutt ghutt rav rahiaa banvaaree" Put the two together There is no sach khand on earth Any building / room is not Sach Khand Why would Guru Har Gobind turn his BACK to Sach khand ? please think along the lines of GURMAT not traditional PENDU punjabi ideology

Re: Frescos of Hindu gods whitewashed

daas · 30 Jul 2003

Shabad is the Guru we do not FOLLOW artwork nor do we BOW to it we just ... admire it, view it why would Guru jee have all of the artisans and craftsmen work on Harimandir Sahib ?!?!! ?!?! If Guru jee was so against artwork ? Guru jee loved the arts - all keertan is in raag, we do martial arts - our bani is written in different languages we are Warrior Poets, Sant Sipahis, sons and daughters of Badshah Darvesh We do not hide from certain respectable disciplines artwork is a respectable discipline sure sobha singh's logic of guru nanaks painting and the palm is twisted - but artwork in general is not bad and neither are frescos

Re: Frescos of Hindu gods whitewashed

singh singhneea da charandhoor · 04 Aug 2003

reminds me of taliban and bamian statues. had these paintings been put there , im sure the likes of great mahapurkhs like sant jarnail singh, bhai randhir singh, sant kartar singh, sant attar singh, and even modern day gursikhs who lead the panth such as shaheed sukhdev singh babbar, gurjant singh budhsinghvala, anok singh, etc etc would have either have said somthing about this or done something directly. great men who led the panth, had the concious to distinguish, gathered warriors, did parchar as per gurmat, fought off enemies, and most of all meditated a large part of their lives would know what is what and as per their lives portrayed tyaar pur tyaar in all instances would never have let these paintings remain if they were impanted there for suspicious reasons.

Re: Frescos of Hindu gods whitewashed

singh singhneea da charandhoor · 04 Aug 2003

so for these paintings to have lasted to this time shows the mentioned gursikhs in my last post have not led a movement to get them removed which means by their standards there was nothing wrong with them being there. Had there been they would have been the first up in arms about it.

Re: Frescos of Hindu gods whitewashed

Anonymous · 04 Aug 2003

So how do those of you who support think of the Taliban's destuction of the Budha statues which were against their religion? Was that right too?

Re: Frescos of Hindu gods whitewashed

Ranjit Singh · 04 Aug 2003

'Anonymous', it seems like you're trying just a little too hard here to paint the sikhs as extremists. You should take a deep breath to clear your head and re-examine the situation. Some points for you to consider: -The Budha statues weren't inside a mosque. -The Hindu paintings in the Gurdvara weren't exactly considered to be of any great historic or cultural significance. -The Buddhist statue comparison would only be suitable if Sikhs were to destroy an ancient Hindu Mandir or statue at some Hindu site (sort of like the way Hindus destroyed the Akhal Takht and the Babri Masjid)

Re: Frescos of Hindu gods whitewashed

anon2 · 05 Aug 2003

it is against some religions to tolerate other religions but is that a license excuse to go round doing whatever in the name of religion?

Re: Frescos of Hindu gods whitewashed

gtroadster · 05 Aug 2003

how comes bhai randhir singh , kulwant singh nagokey, babbar shaheeds down from the 1950s to the 1990s not protested at these paintings if they were so bad? and if they didnt have significance these are the great gursikhs who would fight to get them removed tooth and nail not the sgpc. correction hindus alone didnt destroy the akhal takhat some sikhs like ****admin-cut*** phoned up the indian army to come in, sikhs like general brar led the temple assault.

Re: Frescos of Hindu gods whitewashed

gtroadster · 05 Aug 2003

since when does a national army in todays world represent any religion?

Re: Frescos of Hindu gods whitewashed

Kulbir Singh · 05 Aug 2003

>>>>>> However, Baba Amrik Singh, in charge of the ‘kar seva’ feigned ignorance about the existence of the wall paintings of Hindu gods, he claimed there was not even a single painting of Hindu Gods when the SGPC had handed over the ‘kar seva’ to Baba Jagtar Singh in 2000. >>>>>>> I think we should believe Baba Amrik Singh jee’s word that there were no paintings with Hindus Gods, within Darbar Sahib. Even if there were, these were probably done during the period of Raja Ranjit Singh and not during Guru Sahib’s times. The Sikhs today have no obligation to keep such paintings that don’t tie in with our faith. In the early 1900s, there used to be idols of Siri Raam jee, Siri Krishna jee and other Hindu gods. These were subsequently removed and at that time too, many Hindu-minded Sikhs protested. I am glad that these were removed, otherwise the Hindus would have moved to set their claim in Darbar Sahib also, just like they have on many mosques like Babri Masjid. It is very strange to hear many supposedly Sikhs protesting the removal of the paintings of Hindu gods from Darbar Sahib. Why do they forget that this is Harmandir Sahib and not Jagan Nath Puri (Holy temple for Hindus), from where the paintings have been allegedly removed. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Frescos of Hindu gods whitewashed

harminder kaur · 06 Aug 2003

save ALL the children, by whichever way, through whichever door, but to save them from the BURNING WORLD 'jagat jalanda rakh lay , apanee kirpaa dhaar jit duaaraay ubaray tithay lehu ubaar'

Re: Frescos of Hindu gods whitewashed

Kulbir Singh · 06 Aug 2003

>>>>>>> Author: harminder kaur Date: 08-06-03 03:38 save ALL the children, by whichever way, through whichever door, but to save them from the BURNING WORLD 'jagat jalanda rakh lay , apanee kirpaa dhaar jit duaaraay ubaray tithay lehu ubaar' >>>>>>>>>>> Just want to clarify something. The misinterpretation of this Gurbani Pankiti is rife in Panth. The meanings of this pankiti should be as follows: Vaheguru, Protect the burning world through your divine grace. Whichever way they can be delivered, through whichever special one doorway they can be delivered, deliver them. The ones who are interpret this to mean that there are many doors of deliverance are wrong. This pankiti actually makes it clear that there is only one doorway and that of course is the doorway of Gurmat. According to Gurbani Viyakaran, the word “duaarai” is a singular noun of “Karan Kaarak” kind. The dulaavaan in the end of this word prove that this word is a singular. Then the kirya i.e. verb – Ubrai too is a singular verb. Guru Sahib is saying in the pankiti to deliver the world no matter what it takes. Whichever that doorway is through which this world can be saved, deliver this world through that single doorway. These above stated meanings have been done based on the meanings done by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee was of very strong opinion that only Gurmat Dharam i.e. the Faith of Guru Nanak Dev jee alone offers full salvation or full deliverance from this world into Sach Khand. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Frescos of Hindu gods whitewashed

Dilbagh Puri · 07 Aug 2003

WGJKK, WGJKF, I feel pity on our hardliners who are doing more harm to sikhi than helping it. After all we are not Taliban like organization. Who break Lord Budha statue. Scriptures of hindu gods at Golden temple does not mean that we bow to them. It is just an art work. You must realizt that those who have tolerance power, at they only survive at the end. Those who do not have it get faded with time. Bhool Chook Muaf WGJKK, WGJKF,