1,000 Nirankaris donate blood
Kulbir Singh · 25 Apr 2005
This brings me to the question; Should a devoted, amritdhari gursikh accept blood transfusion. As per this news, imagine having the blood of Narakdharis running in your veins.
Second observation I have had reading this news is that Narakdharis are quite active in Punjab too. I know they have a very strong presence in Delhi but I did not know they could organise such an event in Punjab as well.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
1,000 Nirankaris donate blood
Our Correspondent
Ludhiana, April 23
A blood donation camp, organised by the Sant Nirankari Mandal, was held at Satsang Bhavan here today to mark the “manav ekta divas”. At the second annual blood donation camp organised by the mandal more than 1,000 volunteers, including 350 women, donated blood. The blood collection was arranged jointly by the District Red Cross Society, Dayanand Medical College and Hospital and the Ludhiana Thalassemic Society.
Inaugurating the camp, Mr Surinder Dawar, Parliamentary Secretary, Housing and Power, remarked that blood donation was one of the noblest deeds and a veritable proof of universal brotherhood.
Mr H.S. Chawla, zonal in charge of the mandal, said the next blood donation camp would be organised on June 14.
Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood
too much ego for me · 25 Apr 2005
hmmm well parji - lets say ur in hospital nearly bout to die but u need a special type of blood, are u gonnah say "i rather die becuz that blood might be a narakdharis" or are u going to want to live on to do possible simran and gurbani. blood is blood, its about ur mind not blood.
Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 25 Apr 2005
Vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa
Vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!!!!
guru pyareo,
in my humble opinion KHANDE-KE-PAHUL / AMRIT is thicker than blood
and it is also immortal, permanent, and stainless
what if you were to meet an amritdhari, rehitdhari gursikh and you are so impressed with him, but you later find out that both his physical (worldly) mother and father are both radhasoamis, or narakdharis, or kookas, or anything like that ? of course their blood is in their son - but is their son contaminated? i don't think so. he is pure by his actions and thoughts, so what can somebody's blood do to him?
kahai nanak sae pavith jinee gurmukh har har dheaaeiaa
just my thoughts - please forgive my mistakes
vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa
vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!!!!!
[%sig%]
Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood
hope this helps · 26 Apr 2005
this would be one big circle that would end up with no blood transfusions if everyone followed their religions. Muslims and rehiti christians would never accept blood transfusions from non believers, brahmins would not acceopt even from hindus, and sikhs would not accept blood from anyone else, buddhists blood would not beaccepted by anyone because they dont believe in god . So what hope would lie in transfusions then?
but i gotto admit i wouldnt wanna get a transfusion from a nirankari.
Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood
Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 26 Apr 2005
after spilling the priceless blood of 13 martyrs...these narakdharees now want to condone for their sins...no amount of their blood can wash off the stain of the martyrs of Vasakhi 1973..Bhai fauja Singh and Party....Zindabad.
IF GOD decides to end your life of "simran and naam japna" except with a "donation" of narakdharee blood ?? who is getting blessed here..you the simranee gursikh or the narakdharee whose blood will flow in your veins and mix with you naam japaiyaa blood ?? Such "rhetorical questions" are really just that.... rhetorical. Someone once posed to me...should Bhai Taru Singh have "converted"..and thus EXTENDED his life to DO NAAM JAAPNA/SIMRAN ??..obviously we all know the answer to that one...so why would a GURSIKH naam rassiah..."accept" a narakdharee's tainted blood to "extend" his life to do some more naam jaapna when GOD ahs decided that his life must end NOW...
Think well .....Whatever GOD does is for the GOOD..if it is time to say Goodbye..say it with grace..and go....dont fall from grace to save your life and then say it is for me to do some more naam jaapana...who you tryign to kid ??? kiddo..God is not kidded .
Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood
can't think of a name.. · 26 Apr 2005
Its not like the blood will be labelled with the donors religion :p
Its about how you live YOUR life, YOUR actions and kamai..
[%sig%]
Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood
Putt Sehmi da · 26 Apr 2005
ok here is a complicated one what if one brothersf family is amritdhari the other brothers family is nirankari?
Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 27 Apr 2005
Not a nice thought, having the blood of a narkdharee in your veins, but what if me or you went to India and were involved in a car crash and needed blood?...surely we would not be told WHERE/WHOM the blood was coming from...I'm pretty sure the blood bags aren't labelled "Jatt Blood" "Gursikh Blood", "Baiyya Blood"...so we may have no choice...
I do agree with Arshi ji however when he says go with grace...which is true, but on the other hand, if you were terminally ill, would you say "no" to that all important operation??? I think families will do anything to keep somebody alive, regardless of whose blood/body parts are used. Also, Arshi ji, wasn't that bloody Vaisakhi in 1978 not 1973 when the narkdharees wrote the death warrant of their naklee guru gurbachna?
Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood
Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 28 Apr 2005
Thank You veer Bilga ji, a typo error.
My late dad refused to "shave" for an operation and also refused a blood transfusion.....he signed a letter of indemnity for the surgeon to proceed...all went well...but its a personal choice each of us have to make..IF GOD decides that your life is ended....no amount of blood transfusions, the best doctors in the world, the best facilities..NOTHING will save YOU....on the Other Hand IF GOD Has decided that YOU are NOT going to DIE....then even lying half dead in the dirtiest drain of Calcutta..YOU wiull come out alive..Rakkheh RAABB taan mareh Kaon....Jis ke sir upar tu swami so DUKH kaiseah pavah ???? ITS we who get all soft and mushy and TRY to "SAVE" our life....any which way we we can..IT is GOD who DECIDES.
Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood
Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 31 May 2005
>> imagine having the blood of Narakdharis running in your veins <<
It wouldn't shatter my faith in the least.
Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood
Manjit Kaur Sidhu · 01 Jun 2005
dear P Singh jio,
>>>>>>>>>Kulbir singh please stop with your judgements and self righteous attitude.<<<<<<<<<<
why do you make judgements after advising kulbir singh ji to NOT do that ??
Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood
Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 02 Jun 2005
Does it not surprise anyone to read that some people feel that a simple blood transfusion is enough to separate them from their Guru?
Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood
K S Dhillon Uk Wala · 04 May 2006
Too caught up in ridiculous rituals which we profess to be sikhi...
We as Sikhs should be above these issues? If Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji clearly stated that mankind is one, then why condemn a people who choose to interpret our faith an alternative way? Yes protest it, but lets not get silly.
A lot of hatred for the wrong things. Our faith needs a major clean up. Our establishment is in ruins. Our leaders are corrupt, lets not show our true colours by adding to the mess that’s already out there, blood is blood.
Makes me question if all that simran is doing anything positive or just adding to ones ego....
IMHO