Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

Kulbir Singh · 25 Apr 2005

This brings me to the question; Should a devoted, amritdhari gursikh accept blood transfusion. As per this news, imagine having the blood of Narakdharis running in your veins. Second observation I have had reading this news is that Narakdharis are quite active in Punjab too. I know they have a very strong presence in Delhi but I did not know they could organise such an event in Punjab as well. Daas, Kulbir Singh 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood Our Correspondent Ludhiana, April 23 A blood donation camp, organised by the Sant Nirankari Mandal, was held at Satsang Bhavan here today to mark the “manav ekta divas”. At the second annual blood donation camp organised by the mandal more than 1,000 volunteers, including 350 women, donated blood. The blood collection was arranged jointly by the District Red Cross Society, Dayanand Medical College and Hospital and the Ludhiana Thalassemic Society. Inaugurating the camp, Mr Surinder Dawar, Parliamentary Secretary, Housing and Power, remarked that blood donation was one of the noblest deeds and a veritable proof of universal brotherhood. Mr H.S. Chawla, zonal in charge of the mandal, said the next blood donation camp would be organised on June 14.

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

etka · 25 Apr 2005

blood is physical and not menta/spirtual, but ankh would dictate do not accept.

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

too much ego for me · 25 Apr 2005

hmmm well parji - lets say ur in hospital nearly bout to die but u need a special type of blood, are u gonnah say "i rather die becuz that blood might be a narakdharis" or are u going to want to live on to do possible simran and gurbani. blood is blood, its about ur mind not blood.

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

G SINGH · 25 Apr 2005

if you are keeping strict sarbloh bibeki, than you clearly see the importance of making sure certain things don't getinto your body. For that reason, i am not sure that you should take blood, but this is very subjective

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

Sister · 25 Apr 2005

How about donating blood, is it okay accourding to Gurmat?

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

tera baap · 25 Apr 2005

my question is wud u want the blood of a smoker or drug addict in u?

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 25 Apr 2005

Vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa Vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!!!! guru pyareo, in my humble opinion KHANDE-KE-PAHUL / AMRIT is thicker than blood and it is also immortal, permanent, and stainless what if you were to meet an amritdhari, rehitdhari gursikh and you are so impressed with him, but you later find out that both his physical (worldly) mother and father are both radhasoamis, or narakdharis, or kookas, or anything like that ? of course their blood is in their son - but is their son contaminated? i don't think so. he is pure by his actions and thoughts, so what can somebody's blood do to him? kahai nanak sae pavith jinee gurmukh har har dheaaeiaa just my thoughts - please forgive my mistakes vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!!!!! [%sig%]

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

**** · 25 Apr 2005

When I was younger (age 3), I had a blood transfusion for a complex operation, where such a procedure was necessary. In my youth, I was also blessed with Amrit, and granted the invaluable opportunity to learn about Sikhi. I wasn't amritdhari at the time, but presumably I had Narakdharis (Does that mean people doomed for hell?) blood running through my veins. And if was in the position again today, I believe I would accept a transfusion. I would want to make the best of this life time to progress spiritually. [%sig%]

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

etka · 26 Apr 2005

i'd liek to see any one die a meaningless death in by not accpeting blood. a true death is on the battle field, such a death as stated above is meaningless.

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

hope this helps · 26 Apr 2005

this would be one big circle that would end up with no blood transfusions if everyone followed their religions. Muslims and rehiti christians would never accept blood transfusions from non believers, brahmins would not acceopt even from hindus, and sikhs would not accept blood from anyone else, buddhists blood would not beaccepted by anyone because they dont believe in god . So what hope would lie in transfusions then? but i gotto admit i wouldnt wanna get a transfusion from a nirankari.

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 26 Apr 2005

after spilling the priceless blood of 13 martyrs...these narakdharees now want to condone for their sins...no amount of their blood can wash off the stain of the martyrs of Vasakhi 1973..Bhai fauja Singh and Party....Zindabad. IF GOD decides to end your life of "simran and naam japna" except with a "donation" of narakdharee blood ?? who is getting blessed here..you the simranee gursikh or the narakdharee whose blood will flow in your veins and mix with you naam japaiyaa blood ?? Such "rhetorical questions" are really just that.... rhetorical. Someone once posed to me...should Bhai Taru Singh have "converted"..and thus EXTENDED his life to DO NAAM JAAPNA/SIMRAN ??..obviously we all know the answer to that one...so why would a GURSIKH naam rassiah..."accept" a narakdharee's tainted blood to "extend" his life to do some more naam jaapna when GOD ahs decided that his life must end NOW... Think well .....Whatever GOD does is for the GOOD..if it is time to say Goodbye..say it with grace..and go....dont fall from grace to save your life and then say it is for me to do some more naam jaapana...who you tryign to kid ??? kiddo..God is not kidded .

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

tera baap · 26 Apr 2005

dear ekta the real battlefield is inside you, its the battle with your mind.

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

can't think of a name.. · 26 Apr 2005

Its not like the blood will be labelled with the donors religion :p Its about how you live YOUR life, YOUR actions and kamai.. [%sig%]

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

gabroo · 26 Apr 2005

" Its about how you live YOUR life, YOUR actions and kamai.." this point proves the not taking the blood part. all these people who feel they hav low ego and propose to judge another gursikh's ego due to his chosen actions may even decide that guru nanak dev ji was wrong not to accept malik bhago's specially prepared food. guru sahib is beyond fault... so wat did he have to lose from eating from malik bhago's hands? someone could argue that guruji didnt need to refuse the food as it couldn't have affected him anyway. do u see where your 'logic' has lead you? too many 'logical' and 'modern' thinkers nowadays. i think these people who make claims like "its about your mind not blood" etc etc need to step back and live the life instead of trying to quote the life. " Its about how you live YOUR life, YOUR actions and kamai.." ...it IS. thats why guru sahib abd other gursikhs CHOOSE to help their kamai and thier actions by not accepting intake (food, blood) from false people. if you wanna get into the science behind exactly why and how this is,,, then u can maybe pen your letters of complaint to guru sahib. or perhaps just listen to him (baani) and answers (Guru) will reveal themelves. sory for condescending tones but daas gets upset at these 'modern' or 'logical' 'know it all' type answer givers. i shouldn't visit these forums anymore as they get me down.

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

Putt Sehmi da · 26 Apr 2005

ok here is a complicated one what if one brothersf family is amritdhari the other brothers family is nirankari?

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 27 Apr 2005

Not a nice thought, having the blood of a narkdharee in your veins, but what if me or you went to India and were involved in a car crash and needed blood?...surely we would not be told WHERE/WHOM the blood was coming from...I'm pretty sure the blood bags aren't labelled "Jatt Blood" "Gursikh Blood", "Baiyya Blood"...so we may have no choice... I do agree with Arshi ji however when he says go with grace...which is true, but on the other hand, if you were terminally ill, would you say "no" to that all important operation??? I think families will do anything to keep somebody alive, regardless of whose blood/body parts are used. Also, Arshi ji, wasn't that bloody Vaisakhi in 1978 not 1973 when the narkdharees wrote the death warrant of their naklee guru gurbachna?

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

atl_singh · 27 Apr 2005

thats equal to poising yourself. NarakDhari Murdabaad. Gursikhaan Zindabaad

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

Roopkaur · 27 Apr 2005

>I do agree with Arshi ji however when he says go with grace...which is true, but on the other hand, if you were terminally ill, would you say "no" to that all important operation???< If you have a firm faith in guru ji, gurbani and naam, you can say no to worldy measures. Sarb rog ka aukad, naam. What if some operation required you to shave your hair, would you do it? Likewise, would a naam abhyaasi Singh want the blood of a tabacco smoker or other such people running through their veins?

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 28 Apr 2005

Thank You veer Bilga ji, a typo error. My late dad refused to "shave" for an operation and also refused a blood transfusion.....he signed a letter of indemnity for the surgeon to proceed...all went well...but its a personal choice each of us have to make..IF GOD decides that your life is ended....no amount of blood transfusions, the best doctors in the world, the best facilities..NOTHING will save YOU....on the Other Hand IF GOD Has decided that YOU are NOT going to DIE....then even lying half dead in the dirtiest drain of Calcutta..YOU wiull come out alive..Rakkheh RAABB taan mareh Kaon....Jis ke sir upar tu swami so DUKH kaiseah pavah ???? ITS we who get all soft and mushy and TRY to "SAVE" our life....any which way we we can..IT is GOD who DECIDES.

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

Gursach · 30 May 2005

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh, Dear sister jee, What's wrong in donating blood? I donate after ever 8 weeks. So far dass have given 72 units of blood to Red-cross. All my Naam kamai wala blood going for very good use. After giving blood dass, always ofers ardas to Guru jee, who so ever recieves your blood, pls be kind to him or her enlighten their innerself so they can one day come in ur feet. Giving a life to someone unconditonally is as precious as guru's presence in our life. Jagdish singh CA

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 31 May 2005

>> imagine having the blood of Narakdharis running in your veins << It wouldn't shatter my faith in the least.

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

P Singh · 31 May 2005

Kulbir singh please stop with your judgements and self righteous attitude.

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

14 · 01 Jun 2005

i dont see the big deal in all this ...if you were have been through all those million births and this is the only birth that could help you to reach sachkand...would you really refuse an offer like that? over what the kind of blood ur gonna have...

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

Mr. Singh · 01 Jun 2005

Life and Death are in guru's hands. Our getting to sach khand is also in guru's hands. Knowing this why would someone want the blood of a nirankari. The same people who martyred countless Singhs... you would take their blood to sustain this fickle body... a decaying vessel. I'm disgusted. How a Sikh can even consider this is beyond me. Would you take the blood of KPS Gill if you really needed it? Would you take money thrown at you by a Nirankari if it meant you could live longer? You people have no anakh.

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

P Singh · 01 Jun 2005

^^ Then be digusted. If you cannot see blood as blood then be disgusted, if you cannot see a man as a man but something lower then you then be disgusted.

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

Manjit Kaur Sidhu · 01 Jun 2005

dear P Singh jio, >>>>>>>>>Kulbir singh please stop with your judgements and self righteous attitude.<<<<<<<<<< why do you make judgements after advising kulbir singh ji to NOT do that ??

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

ello · 02 Jun 2005

i dont get it it i agree with p singh blood is blood

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

P Singh · 02 Jun 2005

Manjit Kaur sidhu you don't make any sense, if someone slaps someone and somebody else points that out to him how is that a judgement, please look up the word in the dictionary. You also might to look up "righteousness" "equality" "love" etc. OK some of you say you would reject the blood of a nirankari but what if you are dieing of thirst and the a Nirankari is bringing you a glass of water, would you reject it? I think not.

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

Mr. Singh · 02 Jun 2005

Ofcourse any rehitvaan Singh would reject that glass of water. Or would hope to and would do ardaas to guru sahib for shakti to not sway from bibeki rehit. >>> Then be digusted. If you cannot see blood as blood then be disgusted, if you cannot see a man as a man but something lower then you then be disgusted. >>> Blood is blood. Noone is saying otherwise. What we're discussing is wether it is accetable to take the blood of a Nirakari or someone like KPS Gill and if the blood is affected by a person's kamaiee and if it will have an adverse affect on the avastha of the person accepting the blood. I think taking anything from the hands of a someone who is a dhoki of the panth will have a negative affect on your avastha. Also, if food is affected in a negative way when a non-amritdhari prepares it, then how would their blood not be affected by their karams???? Anycase, You would drink a glass of water offered to you by a nirankari??? The same people who were created simply to destroy Sikhi. Who martyred countless Singhs... shabaaash. Those Singhs took bullets from Nirakari's and you take their samosas. good for you. Maybe you can marry off your daughter/sister to a nirakari since you claim that "a man is a man" and have indirectly implied that karams are of no consequence.

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 02 Jun 2005

Does it not surprise anyone to read that some people feel that a simple blood transfusion is enough to separate them from their Guru?

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

kulmohan · 02 Jun 2005

Despite fighting tooth and nail with the muslim forces and loosing every member of his family to them, Guru Gobind singh ji didn't treat all of them as outcasts or untouchables. Guru Gobind singh ji accepted the hospitality of two muslim brothers in his last times when he needed it. There will be numerous other such instances outlining the oneness of mankind from our guru ji's lives (e.g. bhai ghanaia - helping the muslims and sikhs alike incident) Guru sahib's judgement was based on merit, whilst he opposed the tryant amongst the muslims ,at the same time, he didn't fail to extend his love to the other just muslims. But in the times after our living gurus passed away, it has been indeed very foolish of us to who have lost our discretion. It is indeed the result of loosing our discretionary abilities that today we have instituted a hatred for each and every soul that is born into a nirankari/ram raia/dhirmalia family.

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

14 · 02 Jun 2005

Its funny how the guru's never showed any hatred of this kind to any 'group' but we ...who seem to think we know better than every body else know the truth ...we know everything...we are right...we should not touch or communicate with anybody that does not share the same beliefs as us EVEN THOUGH the guru's did....please stop all this let people believe what they want..try show them towards the right direction 4 sure but dont forcw any 1 our mission isnt 2 convert nirankaari's but 2 gain sakvation

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

15 · 02 Jun 2005

14, Guru Sahib told his Sikhs to boycott heretic groups. Guru Sahib himself told his Sikhs not to associate with Masands, Rami Raiyas, Dhirmalias, Kurimaar, Narimaar, Sir Gumm. Nirankaris are a new cult and they have been boycotted by the Panth. We cannot deal with them. This lovey dovey stuff sounds good but its not Gurmat nor is it even practical.

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

Mr. Singh · 02 Jun 2005

The panj pyare tell you not to associate with nirkari's, ram raia, dhirmalis etc. etc. All panj pyare... regardlesss of jatha give this hukam. You're wiser then the panj pyare? Because your openly advocating for a lift of this hukam. Besides, the muslims weren't created for the purpsoe of destroying sikhs like the nirankari's were. And as far as using discretion... I hope that we're all intelligent enought to use our budhi to listen to hukam of panj pyare. >>> Does it not surprise anyone to read that some people feel that a simple blood transfusion is enough to separate them from their Guru? >>> Nobody said it would separate you from guru sahib. It's not a bajjar kurehit to get a blood transfusion. However, in my understanding, it is wrong and all the mistakes we make will have an effect on our spiritual jeeven.

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

P Singh · 02 Jun 2005

Guru Gobind Singh Ji said he does see difference in a man regardless of caste, color, religon, race. Everybody knows deep within them what is true and everyone can see when other's egos are talking.

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

14 · 03 Jun 2005

sounds good but its not Gurmat nor is it even practical. it so much easier 2 take a route thats simpler isn't it... if u cant DEAL wit em den dere always gnna b there probally donating more blood for people n we cant av dat can we now...their bloods dangerous init

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

** · 10 Apr 2006

Those who are against blood transfussion because of non gursikh blood you are full of hatred. Sikhi is Love, Love and more Love. There is no place for hatred in sikhi. But to understand love you must love and love is blind. It does not ask cast colour or religion. In love you see one not two. Two creates "dubidha, dubeikh".

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

nvtaij · 10 Apr 2006

Author: tera baap Date: 04-25-05 16:04 my question is wud u want the blood of a smoker or drug addict in u? -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- it would be highly unlikely that a smoker or a drug addict would donate blood since they usually screen each donors blood.

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

Death · 10 Apr 2006

So i f you guys need blood thank god you wont be aloud blood transfusion as the person giving blood is not amrithdhari. So all you sikhs will die and it will be the end of sikh religion. Hopefully after that there will just peace and people who are true belivers of Guru Nanak. Thankyou.

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

LK · 10 Apr 2006

Where are we going... Pathetic. Very Pathetic.

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

Gandalf · 10 Apr 2006

Again with this nonsense??....a focus on the physical aspects of sikhi and using that to justify the spiritual....(i.e. the spiritual is defined by the outward)... "I can't share the blood of such and such becasue it makes me weaker.....I can't eat with such and such because they are not as strong in their sikhi as me....I cant spend time with these people because they don't follow a certain Rehit....I can't eat the food of someone who doesn't do such and such because the food is tainted...." who are you to judge anyone......only Waheguru can judge someone else's Sikhi....people need to become humble....instead of being on a power trip and thinking that their Sikhi is better than everyone elses.....what happened to becoming the lowest of the low....(that doesn't just apply to your relationship with guru....it should apply to your relationships with people as well....) What is blood...nothing....How does it's composition affect your mann....it doesn't....it can't....it only allows our physical body to survive...thats it....your blood doesn't make you any worse or less of a person....YOUR ACTIONS DO......how is this any better than a rich person judging someone who is poor because he is a "blue-blood" and the other person isn't.... Kulbir Singh, why do you create gaps, when you should be bridging them......fine, you hate nirankaris, and I can understand that...its human instinct to hate those who hurt you do you shake the hands of people who do not believe the same thing as you?? By your beliefs, that is jootha...and you would be sinning at a molecular level.... you breathe the same air as Nirankaris.......that is jootha.... I have never seen one post from you that I could construe as building bridges...it is all "don't associate with these people", "you are not a gursikh if you do this"....blah blah blah... (I think this one paragraph will prevent this from being posted).....hate is a strong word to use, but I don't get much love from your posts.... but why not try and love your enemy (very hard thing to do) or try and become closer with those who are different from you.....you can learn a lot from these people that you push away.....and it will make you a stronger Sikh....(and I am not saying I am perfect, but I do try to live to this ideal).....I know that I could learn soooooo much from you if I were to sit down and talk with you about life, the world, etc...., but you know what, knowing your feelings would bias my opinion of what you would have to say....... This whole "don't have anything to do with people who don't follow the same rehit as you" is what is breaking Sikhi apart.....this is why there is no ekta..

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

... · 10 Apr 2006

Gandalf, It's attitudes like yours that are hurting the community. Don't judge! We're all the same! Unite with everyone! It sounds great and very P.C. but at its core it's utter manmat. We aren't to have roti-beti di sanjh with Nirankaris. They are cut off. Oh no! We're judging them! Of course we are!! They have drenched themeselves in the blood of our shahids. If some "Sikh" still wants to deal with them and have "unity" they can only be called "baegairat". What do you think bibek budhi is? It's the ability to judge and discern. All Gursikhs have it. Ask yourself why you don't.

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

LK · 10 Apr 2006

So '...' jee You are completly up to boycotting blood from a Nirankari ?[which has nothing to do with Nirankaris, since the blood was not invented by the Nirankari, but Nirankar himseld =) ]

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

Gandalf · 10 Apr 2006

Listen, I know what the Nirankaris have done...and I agree they should be cut off...I am speaking in general...if we were to paint everyone in a certain group with the same brush, then we would cut off the rest of the world...its very simple to judge someone based on a few attributes (be they physical or beliefs)....but why not take the time to really get to know the person..... there is a bad apple in every bunch....not all hindus are bad...not all muslims are bad....not all brown people are bad... you are supposed to see the light of god in everyone.....i feel that people only see the light of god in those who believe in the same thing that they do.... you should talk to people who are different than you so that we can expand on what we believe (i.e. have a deeper understanding of what we believe)...what I see nowadays is "group-think"....a certain group of people all think the same way...follow the leader.....this has one problem...no dialogue, means not seeing if what you do has flaws.... And this attitude is just sad....: "What do you think bibek budhi is? It's the ability to judge and discern. All Gursikhs have it. Ask yourself why you don't."

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

waheguru · 11 Apr 2006

Im sorry to say this but this above statement is very much a egoistic statement....guru ji says " HUM NAHEE CHANGAY, BURA NAHEE KOI, PRANVATH NANAK THARE SOYE".....how much of this pankthi have we sunk within ourselves?....Im sorry but this topic is all about being VERY JUDGEMENTAL!.......

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

K S Dhillon Uk Wala · 04 May 2006

Too caught up in ridiculous rituals which we profess to be sikhi... We as Sikhs should be above these issues? If Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji clearly stated that mankind is one, then why condemn a people who choose to interpret our faith an alternative way? Yes protest it, but lets not get silly. A lot of hatred for the wrong things. Our faith needs a major clean up. Our establishment is in ruins. Our leaders are corrupt, lets not show our true colours by adding to the mess that’s already out there, blood is blood. Makes me question if all that simran is doing anything positive or just adding to ones ego.... IMHO

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

B Singh · 04 May 2006

I would have to agree with that. Not accepting blood?? Doesn't that make us Jehova's Witnesses? [%sig%]

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

Gandalf · 09 May 2006

And I note that Kulbir Singh chose not to respond to my comments....

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

Sardar · 14 May 2006

Why does it bother us Sikhs if 1,00 narakdharis donated their blood? Does it matter what "race" did it or does it matter what good deed they did?

Re: 1,000 Nirankaris donate blood

Khalsa · 22 May 2006

blood is blood its physical; it does not carry any spiritual significance to your soul. blood can be broken down into atoms, and molecule and those may well have belonged to anyone. what if your grandpa's hitler and you have his blood in your body what do you do than.