Forum
Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
Gurcharan Singh Kulim, · 04 May 2005
Bibi Jagir Kaur,
President SGPC
Amritsar,
Punjab, India, & Sikhs world over
Panth di Mahan Satkaar Yog Pradhan, Bibi Jagir Kaur jio,
I have in the past been critical of some of the actions of the SGPC, and have written to your offices to that effect.
However, it does not remove the fact, that SGPC is still the premier organisation of Sikh authority in the world.I respect that, despite other "failures", as I have seen.
Therefore,today, I write to your offices to look into and investigate certain actions of a Sikh organisation in Malaysia, which brings into ill repute the principles of the Gurus, lowers the image of the Sikhs, as well as setting bad examples to the younger generation of Sikhs.
Let me give you a brief history of the organisation and the issues in question.The Sikh Naujawan Sabha Malaysia was set up in the mid sixties to meet the needs of the Sikh youth in Malaysia.It has done wonderful and unquestionably grand work and continued to do so,until this Vesakhi.This organisation was recognised as a great example of a Sikh body,for other sikh organisations to follow.
This Vesakhi this organisation who is presently under the Jathedari of Bhai Harvinder Singh ji, (son of a leading Giani and well respected sahibaans of Malaysia -the late Giani Inder Singh)organised a grand Vesakhi gathering, where the PM of Malaysia and many other leading Malaysian dignitaries were invited to.
However, also invited to this gathering was an ex Sikh,going by the name of DJ Dave(muslim name Irfan abdullah) ;son of a Sikh granthi,who has denounced his Sikh faith and converted to Islam.Over the years this person has emerged as a popular singer on the Malaysian scene in hindi and mixture of malay songs.
He was married to a Sikh women, left her with a son, then married a muslim stewardess, left her with a number of children and married another, and then another malay lady,leaving children behind.He is a known serial womaniser.His name can be seen on the SNSM website, along with the names of two other muslims, who we have no problems with as they are born muslims.We respect their religion.
He sang and did some dancing where a number of semi clothed women were involved , as part of the Vesakhi presentation to the large gathering, on the invitation of the Sikh Naujawan Sabha Malaysia.
As much as we recognise the sewa of any dastar dharri or mona Sikh or even a none Sikh , in this instance it cannot be tolerated and is an insult to the the Gurus and the Sikhs.He turned his back upon Guru Gobind Singh ji,that is his perogative;but now for the guardians of a SIKH organisation to invite him to perform for Vesakhi is nothing short of beizati of Gurbani and Guru sahibaan and the mahanta of Vesakhi.
In addition to this, during the last 400th Guru Granth Parkash deharra,held on a grand scale in malaysia by the Sant Attar Singh Ji Brahma Vidya Niketan Malaysia , a clean shaven Mona "sikh" was appointed as the MAIN Sikh speaker on the stage addressing thousands of Sikhs and non Sikhs,this can be witnessed in a CD(a copy of which I have).Surely, this cannot be accepted.No body again can stop any one doing sewa with sharda, BUT when some one aspires to be a leader of the SIKHS, surely he must look like a SIKH both in actions and appearance.
There are thousands of GURSIKH Sikhs in Malaysia,is it acceptable for a mona to be negotiating or representing for the rights of kesadhari SIKHS ? We do not have problem with his choice to be a mona, but we have to question when he presents himself as the leader of Sikhs, but does not accept or adopt the roop of Sikh.
This same MONA was again presented as the spokesman of Sikhs in the Vesakhi celeberations, while the Jathedar of SNSM,and many other gursikh roopi individuals were standing in the background.
This Mona called Jaspal Singh, spoke of Vesakhi as the great harvest festival of the Sikhs, etc, BUT NOT a SINGLE word was mentioned of the significance of the REAL VESAKHI- the Saajna of the Guru Khalsa.How could he?All he harped on about was the punjabi tattooing,gulab jamuns, and continually potrayed this as a harvest festival, Which is VERY FAR from the facts.
Many Malaysian dignitaries were present, NOT one of the so called Gursikhs stood to explain the real Vesakhi.Can one imagine what picture of vesakhi those present took home?
I believe this is not setting an acceptable trend to the young Sikhs and the new generation of Sikhs anywhere in the world.
I humbly request the supreme Body of the Sikhs, and the Sikhs world over to condemn these actions and offer the SNSM some advice to how it should conduct itself, and refrain from entertaining ex sikhs to conduct any Sikh RELIGIOUS events.
The next worrying issue is, the TATT Khalsa Gurduara sahib, which is now known by the name of Guru Nanak Darbar, Kuala Lumpur,is organisng a fund raising dinner, has again invited this ex Sikh turned muslim to attend as the guest of honour or main fuctionary at this event.Surely,this is against Gurmat.
What example are these parbandhaks trying to offer to the younger generation?That,it is all right to denounce sikhi and become whatever, but Sikh organsations will continue to honour such people?We can understand if it was someone born as a muslim, attending as a friend of the Sikhs, but in this case, this cannot be acceptable.
Both the Tatt Khalsa Gurduara and the SNSM was built by the pure hard work and dedication of Gursikhs who cared about the future generations.For the present managments of these organisations to be indulging in such unsikh activities is insulting and minisculing the sewa of our pioneer fore fathers and belittling the messages of the Gurus.The Sant Attar Singh Ji Brahma Vidya Niketan Malaysia is a relatively new commer to the scene.
Manyog bibi jagir kaur jio, and other esteemed members of the SGPC, I beg you to pay some attention to this issue, and help the silent majority of Sikhs who are NOT pleased with such anti Sikhi activity of some self declared "modern sikhs", and advice/issue matta or sandesh to stop such from happening in future, and condmen the beadbhi they are doing to the great Sikh history and Gurus.
I urge all concerned Sikhs to write against such manmat activities, so that such does not happen again.
A VERY CONCERNED HUMBLE SIKH of the PANTH
Gurcharan SINGH KULIM
Chaan [address removed]
Please write to the Sikh naujawan Sabha malaysia to register your protest:
[address removed]
Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
Guruvah · 05 May 2005
Wahegurooooooooo Je Khalsa,
Wahegurooooooooo Je Ke fateh!!
I Totally agree with u singh jee.....This time SNSM did went to for and aren't giving a good example to the youth.......IT IS TIME FOR A CHANGE!!!
Wahegurooooooo Je Ka Khalsa ,
Wahegurooooooo Je Ke fateh!!!
Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
sarjitsingh khalsa · 05 May 2005
it is no use writing to sgpc the sgpc is olso under the control of the indian goverment look at www.khalistan.com
Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 07 May 2005
Waheguru ji ka kahsla waheguru ji ki fateh.
Veer GURUVAH Jio,
SNSM comitted a big blunder ( just this once)..I think we need ONLY to let them know that. The REST of their Work is OK and doesnt need any CHANGES.
The Other Youth Body...the Sant Attar Singh Niketan also Comitted the SAME BLUNDER..MUCH EARLIER..and even made it a PERMANENT one by recording and distributing a DVD/CD worldwide...They too need to be reminded not to commit such a blunder ever again...even if a huge donation is involved.
Bhullan ander sabh ko..ABHULL guur Kartaar.... lets forgive BUT not forget. ..THIS TIME.
Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
BS Dhaliwal · 07 May 2005
In a message dated 5/7/2005 2:47:15 PM GMT Standard Time, [address removed] writes:
Looks like Tatt Khalsa Diwan Malaysia has created a new and major milestone into its chequered history. At its fund raising dinner for its Gurdwara Building Fund, on May 06, 2005, it raised more than a million ringgit (1USD = 3.8 Ringgit). This dinner was held at the prestigious Putra World Trade Center.
However they did not heed our pleas. Their star performer was DJ Dave, a 57 year old, ex-Sikh who converted to Islam to marry a Malay-Muslim air stewardess. In the process, he dumped his Sikh wife and son.
To further add insult to injury, there was free flow of liquor! Bars were set-up and liquor prices were displayed on every table. Nothing was discreet.
In the great Malaysian tradition, non-halal meat was served. We Sikhs in Malaysia always apologetic about this by saying that our Muslim friends only eat halal food.
There have been several initiatives by panthic organisations in Malaysia, in conjunction with 400th Prakash Dihara Diwas, to stop serving liquor and halal meat at Sikh weddings. Looks like they were mere campaigns only. Zero results!!
There is no intention of starting another acrimonious debate. I am merely reporting. Please help us Malaysian Sikhs improve. Please.
Jetinderjeet Singh
Malaysia
It is obvious the Sikhs is Malaysia have lost their ANAKH, and turning their back on the Panth.A kaum without anakh will crawl to anyone and anything ...boneless and lost Sikhs havealways brought the kaum into disrepute ...
can anyone stand here and tell me they are not just a boneless and ANAKHless community of SIKHS in malaysia.
they are only Sikhs in appearance , not in words and karni .
.
Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 07 May 2005
Its all about "MONEY"....over in PUNJAB...we have the Kar sewa Babas/Sants/Derawallahs/mahapurashs...who go around COLLECTING DONATIONS for building GURDWARAS...at every meel pathhar !!
IN MALAYSIA we have the "ENTERTAINERS" like dj dave to do this SAME TASK..
Imho, the Sikhi da DHURA..the CENTRE of SIKHE ( IN AMRITSAR) is weakend...this is the Ripple Effect...a well known Punjabi proverb says..katte da zor killaeh te hundeh.... the "sikh" katta in malaysia is tied to a very much weakend killa in Punjab....so much so that the killa can be pulled any which way...
The DAYS are long gone where HONEST, HARDWORKING SIKHS earnign low wages by the sweat of theirbrow...used to give their DASWANDH freely and without asking by the Gurdawras....IT is with such HONEST DASWANDH that the ORIGINAL GURDWARAS and SCHOOLS are built...Now Siksh are High flying Lawyers, stock Players,, pyramid scheme Gold coin Merchants, ..on the High road to "quick prosperity..and principles of honesty be damned..who cares if i am honest..my shiny new merc/bmw will take care of that...these types will only "give" when "entertained/fed liqour and meat at fancy dinners etc....While the SAME TYPES will "give" to the BABAS/SADHUS to "buy" Spiritual Passes to Heaven..and legitimsie their ill gotten gains
Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 08 May 2005
This is indeed a very sad and repungent phase of Malaysian Sikh history.
Gurduaras and organisations are said to be pillars of any community's growth and development on all aspects and anchors to support the community to move forward while sustaining its unique identity and history, and success.
Sikhs in malaysia have had a very proud history since their arrival in this land.Sikh gurduaras abound the land from east to west , and north from thai border to south, near the causeway to Singapore.
Sikhs in Malaysia have had a history unparalelled to any of the others in diaspora.From humble beginings as policeman,cattle rearers to watchmen, Sikh parents worked hard to support the growth of their offspring,education, sport and economic development to ensuring facilities like Gurduaras, small Punjabi schools and organisations to unite and colllectivley develop further the community were erected and fuctioning.
That the community, achieved,not without the expense of losing some some of the young brains to other ways of life in this multi faithed and multi community country. some of these peopl have regreted their action at a young age ,and sought ways to return ...some have had no guts to do that because of legislation and law..others more because of embraasment struggled lonely ,and died, but certainly not before expressing their greatest mistake the one time in their lives...but Sikhism has flourished on ....
Habits have changed, commitment has changed to the faith, influences have lessened the resolve for a separte identity to continue.Others more feeling a sense of inferiority complexes because of own personal weaknesses... have continued to beleive in the Sikh principles but under the garb of modernisation.
What is modernisation?It is a very vast word, describes everything and yet nothing.Is it modernisation of clothes?or is it the thought or the appearance?many forget modernisation does not come in isolation..it the change as a whole....many opt for the outer appearance,but more than often under neath the mentality.mind and intelligence has not moved on .....it remains very backward, connected to outdated attitudes, destructive habits, narrow minded ness....etc ..I do not call that modernisation at all.
Comming back to the subject of Sikhs in Malaysia, Sikh pioneers in Malaysia have many firsts to their name...
The first punjabi schools after India and afghanistan were built in Malaysia.The first Punjabi newspaper was published in 1900 from malaysia,and it continued in many forms to this day as The Malaysia Samachar .... it was the only voice of the Punjabis when all other punjabi newspapers were throtlled in India during the Punjabi Suba agitation.Malaysian sikh leaders led a deputation to india to impress upon the then PM nehru of the rightful demands of Sikhs.
It was 1953, Kushwant Singh had written three years earlier that by the end of the century,1999, the identity of the Sikhs would disappear fromm this earth.Many Indian Sikh organsiations, including SGPC admonished him but he was unrepentent.But that credit goes to malaysian Sikhs , ASP Pritam Singh, challenged him during a tea party given to him in TATT KHALSA Gurduara, where Kushwant singh lost his argument and fully apologised to the Sikh panth for his untasteful remarks.His predictions have ben proved futile.The Sikh identity is flourishing and blooming in the west particularly ...
Then the SNSM concept was another first by Malasian sikh leaders of the past ..who fully saw the need to maintain their identity , and sought to instill the same high principles in the new generations. Other countries followed this concept and have learnt a lot.
But after many succesful years , something seriously has gone wrong, with this vision in its own homeland.People blame the advent of so called modernisation, instead of looking to find what could have continued to instill the growth of Sikh identity among the children.
If Harbhajan Singh could come to the west and convince 250,000 americans of Sikh identity, why are we failing among our own??Is it because we are being apologistic to too much so called accomodatative attitude that has crept into our minds about our faith.We seem to bend over heels to acomodate others at the slightest whimp.We apologise for own identity ?We try quite wrongly, to appear "like them". We see some poor inadvertent practice, we than make our own mind and think, if Jack did that Jane could be justified to do it ?If we can get Jane to do it,then we can all do it as well.That then makes it 'our'evidence in the face of a challenge, no matter what the concrete laws of Sikhism say about it.
It is our law that matters as we belive that is the way we have seen it done , so it must be right.
Others more in garb of diversity , feel that shedding off their own culture and identity is the right approach or give and take is the right approach.
I wonder if someone would give and take parts of their own home ?Parts of their own car.I guess not.So why in in our religion?That is ok , baba ji is not watching.The strength of new societies lies in the diversity that can project the strongest colour of variety, and not of one sole entity.But many dont understand this.They are confused with cultural, religious and living in multi faceted society .
So down come the pillars of the community.Down come the great traditions and history, the language, identity and values...in exchange for a mish mesh of values that are neither our own nor we can own .It happens in communities that are weak.
The great history is rubbished by so called new enligtened individuals, who may never be able to give explanation to a single act of their own history,but are very vocal of the borrowed customs and values.
In their haste to justify their own lack of understanding and lack of knowledge of the great values of their fore fathers,, they knock their own pillars down.They compromise their own identity, culture, valued principles, and their own future!As they then pass on ....this repungent phase of their activities for their people to their new generation ....it withers out totally ...That is a very sad part of a very proud history of the unique Sikh kaum, of Malaysia.Would the pheonix ever rise .....?
Gurcharan SINGH Kulim
Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
((Gurcharan Singh Kulim)) · 10 May 2005
THIS MAIL WAS WRITTEN BY SARDAR JEETINDER SINGH JI OF KUALA LUMPUR,MALAYSIA IN RESPONSE TO AN ARTICLE I WROTE ABOUT THE DYING KALA OF SIKHS IN MALAYSIA>
Sardar Gurcharan Singh Kulim has delivered a substantive document on
the state of health of Sikhi in Malaysia.
His mail is a time capsule. He takes us from the very beginnings of
Sikhs in Malaysia, our glorious days when we were the standard
bearers of Punjabi education, gurmat principles, sports, education
civil service, soldiery, economic development and leadership. The
history of Sikhs in Malaysia was unparalled.
Reflecting on the present sad events, he asks, "Would the phoenix
ever rise .....?
Many parcharaks from India, UK and USA (eg. Karnail Singh California-
walle, Sant Singh Maskeen) have praised the Sikhi that is practised
in Malaysia. We all felt warm with pride when they repeatedly
announced from the stage that Sikhi would be thrust onto the world
stage and this would start from Malaysia!
Were they wrong? Or are these recent events an abberation?? I would
like to think that it is an abberation, a blip, a hiccup. I would
like to think that "THE PHOENIX WILL RISE".
What is required towards, "THE PHOENIX WILL RISE"?
Our hopes lie with 1. Sikh Naujawan Sabha Malaysia 2. Malaysian
Gurdwara Council and 3. Khalsa Diwan Malaysia. These three mainstream
national Sikh organisations would have to identify the issues
blighting the Sikhs in Malaysia and develop long term and short term
programs to address these issues.
In the days past, there was an active youth developmental program
developed by the SNSM under its wing, Akal Purkh Ki Fauj. The program
was touted to be holistic (all areas of development), cradle to grave
and it had a catchy catch phrase ""catch them young"". Apparently
this program has fizzled out.
This program needs to be revived. It must taken into account present
realities. Realities are:
1. Sikh Naujawan Sabha Malaysia has moved on to organising mega-
projects. They are no longer into child and youth development.
Granted that they organise Annual Gurmat Samelans and a smattering of
mini-samelans throughout the year. However the contact with these
impressionable youth is marginal.
2. Khalsa Diwan Malaysia manages Punjabi Education Centers
throughout the country and has the most sustained contact with Sikh
Youth. However KDM is small and does not have the depth in terms of
sewadars, the sewarders' zeal, and it lacks the appeal and standing that
SNSM enjoys.
These 2 organisations have to handle this first!
They must develop a national program. And this program should be
holistic, cradle to grave and must catch them young. Holistic would
means punjabi language, gurmat, leadership skills, organisational
skills, values, sports and other postive values development.
There should be parental involvement.
It should be continous with sustained contact throughout the year.
There should be seemless cooperation between these two organisations
in delivering these programs. No Prima donnas! No egos! Just plain
SEWA.
Only then "THE PHOENIX WILL RISE"?
More on this later.
Regards,
Jetinderjeet Singh
Malaysia
Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
Manjit kaur Sidhu · 10 May 2005
as i understand it...EGO is the downfall of most.
The Akal Purakh ki Fauj.....Movement started with very good vibes... a lot of good intentioned Gursikhs advised the "INTERNATIONAL COMMANDER IN CHIEF" of this "FAUJ" to drop the word FAUJ from it as GURU GOBIND SINGH JI had already FORMED the Akal Purakh Ki FAUJ - the KHALSA and it owuld be wrong to COPY CAT this name for a small Organsiation run by human beings...BUT no the EGO was too big....how could one be a International commander in CHIEF without a FAUJ ??..in the end what happened..The "FAUJ" itself DIED (While the Genuine FAUJ of GURU JI lives on till the end of TIME !!) IN MALAYSIA this apkf exists ONLY ON PAPER and in the minds of a few international commanders in chief..in INDIA it manages to survive on SGPC patronisation...
The SAME people are still involved in the Malaysian Youth Scene/Punjabi Boli/Gurmat samelans/Educational seminars/Schools etc etc....it would be worthy of them to DROP their EGO and do genuine sewa..I am sure the SIKHE in malaysia can advance...BUT if they attempt to "bottle" the same old "apkf" wine..... in a new bottle under any other name the sangats are wise...our children are NOT "Gharreh dian machhian" to be used as seminar attendees/gurmatt samelan participants..etc to line their pockets or extend their ego based organsiations for POLITICAL MILEAGE for personal advancement.
Mk
Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 12 May 2005
A post from another net By Veer Ajit singh Ji ....of malaysia
Dear Veer Ji's and Phen Ji's of GLZ,
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa,
Wahegure Ji Ki Fateh,
Adding on to Veer Jetinderjeet Ji message,
What is lacking now that was present in the 70's, 80's. What was it that made me (us)who we are today.
1) We had the naujawan satsangs in nearly every gurdwara in major towns. In Kuala Lumpur there were many of these pgms on every week. What happen. From being a naujawan satsang pgm it became a normal Gurdwara pgm. The organisers started getting "Professional / Imported" ragis to come and do kirtan during these satsangs.This pgms finally pushed the naujawan satsangs out and in came the normal evening programs. The children were left out from participating.Where is the Khalsa Naujawan Satsang of KL , the PJ Satsang grps, the Sg Besi Satsang. The list goes on and on.
We have become so pampered that we only want to hear these imported Ragis and not our children anymore.
2) What has happen to all the children / naujawans who were doing kirtan during these times. They grew up to adulthood. So what about the next generation. There was no avenue for them to learn and present the kirtan skills for the sangat. There is no kirtan training pgms , ie no school. Yes we have the SNSM, KDM, Gurdwara Council, Niketan etc etc. Are they preparing , teaching the youths today to do kirtan ?
3) We have Rahen Sebhais and guess who has the prime time. The imported ragis and handfull of local kirtan grps ( who learn from the satsang periods of the 70's, 80's). We forget that there are children and that too they are given the graveyard hrs. They do not get the oppurtunity to performed and this eventually kills their enthusiam for doing kirtan.
5) There are no more touring / visiting kirtans pgms between satsangs and local groups. Only imported Ragi's.
6) The number of dedicated teachers of kirtan have dropped as most of our teachers of the 70 n 80's have passed on but the children who have grown to adults dont have the time to teach the younger generation.
7) The leaders of todays organisations are the results of the all the above. Please sit down and re-look at what we have left out in the building process of our children. We need to start back the satsangs. This is the foundation of who we are today. I learn a lot during this time. Imagine the group synergy we had and how this energy build us.
8) Lets start a Kirtan school or academy and start creating our own Ragis.
9) Most of the committes members in SNSM, KDM , GC, Niketa are professionals who have learned to use their head to solve problems during thier working hrs. But when it comes to religion we become very emotional and the clear thinking disappears. Use the skills you have learned to pushed forward positively not negative actions.
10) Planning follow-up prgms after samelans is a must. We cannot let children idle for 51 weeks. Start e-grps use the current technology to pushed forward. Do not stagnate.
WILL THE PHOENIX RISE IN MALAYSIA. YES AND ONLY WE OURSELVES CAN PREVENT THIS FROM HAPPENING.
SEWADARS, ORGANISATIONS = OPEN YOUR EYES AND SEE THE FUTURE YOU ARE BUILDING. REMOVE THE "____" BTWEEN YUORSELVES AND THE NEXT ORG FOR THE SAKE OF OUR CHILDREN AND RELIGION.
Gur Fateh and my apologies for speaking out aloud and stepping on some toes in the process. Hope the pain can jolt you from your slumber. Please read the message from Veer Jetinderjeet Ji below. It is very crucial to our survival.
Being myself
Ajit
Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 12 May 2005
In a message dated 5/12/2005 7:02:13 AM GMT Standard Time, [address removed] writes:
Tatt Khalsa Dinner - DJ Dave, Alcohol and Halal Meat has been
changed to
Would the Phoenix Rise in Malaysia?
We can sit and read all this, but we dont get a response from SNSM.I understand that they have expressed on the ground via their secretary that they do not wish to get involved in any controversy.
What controversy?Who started this controversy?SNSM started this controversy themselves.The Sangats at least deserve some explanation.The SNSM owes them that accountability.We are not trying to put the SNSM in the dock,but it would help us understand what led to such a blunder, and how then it can be prevented in the future, and how this can also be than a yardstick for the other organisations to measure themselves and boost the image of the sikh positively, rather than "make do" attempts.
Silence only goes on to explain its criminal act ...against Sikh etheics,....it does not give a clean chit ...to .... innocence.....
Not being on the ground, I am not privy to some information.But I totally agree with Veer Ji Jiteenderjit Singh Ji,The SNSM has lost their original vision along the way, like I said in an earlier mail.
I think programmes like connecting during Rehraas, involving local sangats and children in quizs, opportunities for local talent to be on stage are the regular IN THINGS that should be revived at once.Use local children and sangat and their sikh talents.These parchars then need to be followed up ...
Presenting the SNSM on MEGA stages are one thing, BUT loosing the connection and REAL vision and moving away from the objectives is not healthy for the maintenence of Sikhi.
Sardar Jiteenderjit Singh , who has a better and detailed picture on the ground,quite rightly has pointed to the wastege of monies and the resources channelled into the wrong directions.How many 'Sikhs' did indeed adopt the roop of a Sikh as a result of all these efforts.
From what I heard on this net, apart from "great songs,great food,great crowds, and the assumption , that non- sikhs "learnt" a lot about the Sikhs, I repeat an assumption,"because they have indeed seen that Sikhs can drink,{{Malacca running out of alcohol during barsi celeberations has hit international headlines a number of times}} dance to semi naked women,have great food, ...did they find out why Sikhs gave their heads to the call of the Guru, did they go back and say to a Sikh friend...'hey singh,you must respect that turban, I know about the great scarifices of your community ........ and lastly,how many did indeed returned to the dentity of their faith, at this smagam ...?
Let me share just one episode, a few years back, as I drove into Perlis from Kedah,at the border Police checkpoint, my car which was about forty cars from the front car, in the que being checked....was singled out by a passing Malay Field Force Officer, who greeted me with a loud ...SAT SRI Akal..... Singh ji, apa macam ........raising his hand in a semi-salute wave.I replied, Sat Sri Akal, bagus, ...pergi mana enche Singh......I reply Kangar , ....Enche keluar kereta dari sini ...asking me to pull my car out of that line, and whistling to his colleague ahead to let my car ...carry on ...by passing all the traffic there.....Khalsa ji, can we reach this levels with the reputation that our fore fathers built in this society?Believe me, this was not an isolated incident I had.I have a number that I can share.Can the Sikh phoenix arise to this levels?
We need to empower our local sangats to do the parchar and become the eyes and ears of the SNSM ,the CKD and the GC.The organisations can provide the resources, the expertise and the process and efforts can be tapped from the local sangats.Get them involved, connect them as part of the national effort.There are thousands out there who will respond, if we involve them from young.
The Vidyala in Malacca was supposed to provide for the training of local talents ,but from my understanding after over thirty years only one has so far utilsed the vidyala or the Vidyala has only produced one.
The scene is the future,how do we revive that zeal,how do we get to work on the ground in Malaysia, rather than extending to places like Australia, and Indonesia or Thailand?I know, it helps Sikh in these other countries, but our priority should be Malaysia, and until and when we have achieved that success, that some efforts should be concentrated to support elsewhere to raise their own SNSM type organisations /parchaaraks.
Going around simply doing some kirtan ...haan ji...han ji ...theek hai ...theek ji ...and packing up all the wajje, dholkian tabla and returning is not the sort of parchar that should done.Neither it is effective.The kirtan should be the culmination of a history class, sikh quiz and discussions....gurmat Sikh movies/Cds etc.....there is so much thayt can be revived among tne sangats .....reviving and teaching the locals even an introduction to tabla and harmonium.Changing the local sangats knowledge and understanding, can become effective foundation for the greater programmes.
I recall a two week programme in Kulim by Master Malkit Singh ji, changed the future and knowledge base of many sikh youth, in the late 60s.
These three organsiations need to work together.In my humble view,the SNSM should be re- connecting to the growing youth,the CKD should continue to develop the teaching of Punjabi and build upon it.It is unfortunate the PM never turned up, and others had their vested interests and ego...beyond pure sewa to boost.
The CKD can link in at SNSM samelans to continue to also promote the language.The survival of sikhi depends very much upon the promotion of the Punjabi language.
The GC should concentrate on harnessing all the gurduaras together and implementing ONE Maryada, supporting in the parchar and teaching of the langugae and promoting Sikh image at the national and international level.They can also effectively contribute to setting standards to the tyope of rgais that we should import, not just any simpleton who is not connected to the ground...
There is so much these three organisations can do and have to do earnestly, if they truly have the interest of the Sikh community at heart.They cant all do all the things that need doing, all alone by themselves.
I think the SNSM needs to pay particular attention towards this.They need to reconnect back to the ground level with the growing youth and revitalise the zeal that they produced up to about ten years ago....sports etc can be their brief, with the GC supporting in this area.
The CHK divan could expand its working remit and re-evaluate its objectives and pay more attention to the tasks it should be doing ahead.
There are many out there who do feel very concerned at the state of affairs of the Sikh panth.We can do somethings ourselves and do not need to depend upon others to do this for us.
In the old days, the Malaysian and Singaporean Sikhs held national level Sikh conferances and jointly planned for issues.
I cannot recall when the last national Sikh conference took place in this land.twenty two years ago, in Cameron Highlands?
If I may suggest, it is time perhaps for us to have one such 2 day conference and launch a Natioanal strategic plan for the community by next Vesakhi ?All the Sikhs should attend this and come on one platform.It is time to shade our differences and COME ON ONE PLATFORM.The issues facing the community concern every and each Sikh, family and gurduara- let us get together and address this issues.
Sikhs have done it in the past, we can and Sikhs will- be our motto.Love your kaum, then get on one platform.
I have no interest in picking nits, but I do care for my people and we need to put words into action.Can we all ?
Interesting is it not , that the so called sikh organisations, that OWE their existence to the SIKhs..should HIDE under the shroud of SILENCE..an erri silence ...Singho ...a thief caught red handed .....often displays such silence ..in the face of embarasment ...
Gurcharan SINGH Kulim
Clarification on Tatt Khalsa Dinner(personal comments)
SIKH · 29 May 2005
Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh,
After reading the various messages, I was equally hurt by the practices of the various Sikh organization recently and proceeded to seek clarification from the organizers of the Tatt Khalsa Fund Raising Dinner held recently which I also attended.
Firstly, as informed the main purpose of organizing the Dinner was to raise funds to lower the bank loans taken by the Gurdwara. It was not a religious function but purely a dinner organized by professionals Sikhs from the private sector (non committee member of Tatt Khalsa) to raise funds for the said purpose above.
Secondly, as informed by the organizers of the dinner, they did not at any time associated themselves in the sales and distribution of any hard/soft drinks. There were some who brought in liquor bottles on their own accord and paid a corkage of RM20/- to PWTC management directly. The beer was also sold by PWTC for RM10/- per mug. Under no circumstances, were the organizers involved with the sales distribution or received any profit or commission for the sale of hard/soft drinks. Furthermore, there was no beer booth set up. Your have to place your order through the PWTC staff.
Thirdly, the organizer informed me that the price list was a standard list displayed at any function held at PWTC and they have nothing to do with the sale, consumption, distribution or profits of hard drinks/ soft drink.
Fourthly, in respect of halal food (chicken), vegetarian food was cooked in the temple and the chicken was cooked by a Punjabi chef especially paid to do so in PWTC.
Fifthly, on DJ Dave issue, after reading the various messages, the organizer informed me that they did in fact terminated the services of DJ Dave a day before the dinner. Nevertheless, he still showed up on the dinner day and insist on performing based on a contract executed in early January 2005. The organized did not want a scene, paid RM10K and told him to perform as an entertainer for 15 minutes for the non sikhs and not to seek any donation from the audience. I was also told he was not the star attraction for the night but an ordinary performer. If you have attended, you may have noticed that there were many real stars like Reshmonu, Comedy Court and Gunjit Singh of UK.
It is my personal view, the writers are ignorant and rely on hearsay news to write messages without actually inquiring the actual facts from the organizing committee of the said dinner.
My apologies if my clarification annoys anybody but it is strictly from my observation and clarification from the organizing committee of the said dinner.
Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
Me · 30 May 2005
Jarnail Singh, the original post was about SNSM and another organisation, do you have to bring sant bashing into every thread? Why are you so bitter?
Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
Manjit kaur Sidhu · 30 May 2005
[gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani]
imho...after all this dust settles...everything will be back to square one..because the "differences" between the "Organsiations" are in actual fact differences between PRSONALITIES controlling these Organsiations..and none of these will ever "give up" his control to the other. I am on the ground...and am painfully aware of why so many Organisations keep struglling along..when by self admission they say ..we dont have this and we dont have that..and to let soemone who "has this and has that" to come in...will mean their own organsiation/pardhangee/jathedari will be "diluted" or even in danger.
The Holla mahalla Games began some years ago...the Commanders in Chiefs prepared so many "rules and regulations" and had "uniforms" , "compulsory memebership" etc of their own pet organisation BEFORE the Youth could take part....THE SNSM , dispensed with all the "rules and regualtions/cum compulsory membership", opened the Games to ALL GURDWARAS....and the mini organsiation that pioneered the Games disappeared in the "dust" of following Years successive games..... This is a personality difference...just like in Punajb where we have multiple Akali dals.. even the Akal takhat FAILED to dissolve the various Dals...
The SNSM has rvial organisation just because of MARYADA differences.. money of sangat being spent on duplicating many Youth Programmes..Gurmat samelans etc and "differences" being perpetauted instaed of beign removed
The SNSM has a very active and Registered SWAT...Sikh Women's Awareness Team to deal effectively with LADY ISSUES and liase with the Govt on these...another SIMILAR Organsiation sprang up to deal with the SAME issues..another duplication...
The SNSM also had ongoing Mother Language programmes and such...
The LIST is endless..personalities clash and failure to get along lead to new organsiations or old ones take on new issues ..whatever... IF you "absolutely have to have " your own SWAT to "swat" the established swat....then how can you reasonably expect that "cooperation" will be forthcoming in other areas..in which you claim you have the "expertise", the students, teachers etc etc..COPERATION is a TWO WAY STREET. It is the HUMAN FACTOR that ultimately FAILS us all the time.
[gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani]
Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
S Singh · 30 May 2005
>>However, it does not remove the fact, that SGPC is still the premier organisation of Sikh authority in the world.I respect that, despite other "failures", as I have seen.
Should this letter not be going to the Akal Takht which is the premier organisation of Sikh authority ?
The SGPC is a management committee and nothing more. They are headed by Jagiro who has been excommunicated from the Sikh faith and has been charged with murdering her daughter. SGPC members also organise mass alcohol distribution at the time of SGPC elections so I doubt they will find anything wrong with what veer Gurcharan Singh Kulim has written to them about.
Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 30 May 2005
Dear Me Jio,
Looks like its you who are Bitter and uncomfortable. IS YOUR SANT or BRAHMGIANI named by me as Bad ?? SO why do you "see" your sant/babaji as being bashed ..when in fact ONLy the WRONG DOERS are being taken to task ??
On one hand you people tell me..Jarnail Singh Ji..we HAVE STOPPED reading your posts because they are always sant bashing..blah blah blha....but then you still pick up "one sentence out of a hundred" and point it out..Either YOU saw ONLY that one sentence...OR what ??
Those AGAINST the SNSM maryada here ARE "SANT SAMAJ FOLLOWERS". That is a fact even they wont DENY. SNSM follows Akal takhat maryada..they DONT. It is also a fact that these sant samaj followers spread unsubstantiated 'sakhis", maryadas such as ghee jyots, coconuts, and red cloths and water in bottles under Guru Ji , extra readings of Japji sahib along with Akhand Paath, NO WOMEN PAATHIS, read Raagmaala...etc etc. I will not support such maryadas that are NOT in line with AKAL TAKHAT ( which they "support" ?? because they very well KNOW the POWR of Akal takaht")
I have no axe to grind "against" any particualr sant babaji..BUT I will support only Akal Takhat. In fact I have many "sants/babajis? as friends....and their followers as close friends....and i certianly dont hate anyone.
Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 30 May 2005
ref: SIKH's Personal comments on Tatt Khalsa Fund Raising Dinner.
I find the personal comments of SIKH quite reasonable. Its true that this was a Fund raising dinner, held outside Gurdwara Premises.
Secondly the Organsiers did try to remove the Patit DJdave, but due to legal contract, they could only minimise his exposure...and that is perfectly acceptable under the difficult circumstances. Others hould learn from this experience and avoid such messes.
We all make msitakes but the wise learn from them. I am pretty sure in the future No SIKH Organsiation will commit these same mistakes. Much water has flowed under this particular bridge...time to let go...and MOVE ON.
Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 30 May 2005
A Sikh writes:
'It is my personal view,"" the writers are ignorant and rely on hearsay news"" to write messages without actually inquiring the actual facts from the organizing committee of the said dinner.
My apologies if my clarification annoys anybody but it is strictly from my observation and clarification from the organizing committee of the said dinner.'
-------------------
A Sikh has to hide behind a pseudo name to write here first and foremost explains all.
I think ignorance starts here, with him.
The fact TATT Khalsa Divan tried to back out of was NOT out of the IGNORANCE they had before: but the education by the exposure of the UNSIKH activities by individuals.
ONE DAY BEFORE THE EVENT THEY TRIED TO PULL OUT ...explains ..all.. and for your information clever sikh .... THE ISSUES started long before that ONE day.
Had the dust NOT flown and kicked up TATT khalsa would have not bothered cancelling the event even three days after the date.
This is VERY SMART move now to take the heat off, after many weeks.
So please do NOT turn up weeks after the event, and having thought about it all, to limit their damage.A Good try.
So who did the organising committee clarify to?To you?Who are you ?Someone hiding behind a pen name?
Just who are you that has all the education and not ignorance of other's intelligence?
The fact is the dirt has now reached the malaya samachar newspaper..Issues are being discussed on the ground.I have had a phone call from Penang that tell me another story.
Now these guys are trying to clarify and try to justify THEIR OWN IGNORANCE , thinking their stupidity is cleverer off the ignorance they percieve in others.
Sangat ji, this """billi Sikh""..expects us to think as ignorantly and stupidly as them ......how clever or ignorantly stupid these people were...having organised and invited this adulterer dave for their function....then when the dust kicked up after the vesakhi , they sat on it for many days...at the last minute when the heat really turned on...they tried to cancel him...but whatever their internal arranged lies,that Irfan abdullah caught them out still ..with their pants down ...and got RM10,000 so they tell us....and it is out side the gurduara premises ...so it makes it all alright ...tomorrow a granthi will come say ..I smoked ..but outside the gurduara ..so all is well and fine within the gurduara....
This sikh looks like a real ignorant, and beleives the whole world is ignorant as him.
There is more to come ....the issue is not dead and gone.
Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 30 May 2005
My original issue about tatt Khalsa was as follows in the first post :-
The next worrying issue is, the TATT Khalsa Gurduara sahib, which is now known by the name of Guru Nanak Darbar, Kuala Lumpur,is organisng a fund raising dinner, has again invited this ex Sikh turned muslim to attend as the guest of honour or main fuctionary at this event.Surely,this is against Gurmat.
What example are these parbandhaks trying to offer to the younger generation?That,it is all right to denounce sikhi and become whatever, but Sikh organsations will continue to honour such people?We can understand if it was someone born as a muslim, attending as a friend of the Sikhs, but in this case, this cannot be acceptable.
------------------------------------
The FACT THAT TATT KHALSA (ACCORDING TO THIS SIKH) tried to pull out shows, had the FUSS NOT been kicked up, they would have gone ahead.They had arranged to invite this lesser than perfect adulterer.
Clever Sikh tell the sangat what is based on heresay in my above realting to tatt Khalsa post ?Or are you trying pull wool over others eyes?
The rest of the excuses given by this Sikh are just excuses...of no consequences....like saying I did not pee in the church , but on the christian cross outside on the road....wow ....these people...can really buy and sell the Gurbani on the share market ...if given half the chance!
Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
BS Dhaliwal · 30 May 2005
hahaha,
I have followed this thread and all related to it very closely, the thread was raised by veer Dr Gurcharan Singh Kulim of UK.
I am amused by the so called defence put up by Sikh.veer Dr Gurcharan Singh only raised the issue of a patit turned muslim,but this Sikh then goes on to explain, about alcohol etc, halal foods etc .The fact remains it does not matter who brought the alcochol, there was alcohol...there was halal food, there was the Dj whatever,there was an organised attempt to abuse, but given the stint kicked up by Dr sahib and Giani ji, these organising committe walahs have really cheek in tongue to ask some chicken hiding under a pen name of SIKH to wash their dirty linen clean.Sorry mate we no suckers to buy your story.
Amazing the guy had TWO contracts with which he caught out these tatt khalsa tattoos, with ignorant brains.
So he was after all only interested in MONEY, and what happened to the chap that said he sings good kirtan and comes to gurduara????see how one lie leads to another these organisers are such tattoos
The fact as said by Veer Dr Gurcharan Singh ji,remains that these organisers have waited long enough thinking a way out to explain,and then explained what they think people will buy, hoping that will settle off things.
Funny how like Dr sahib GS KULIM said these pople have been caught red handed with their kahcerra or is it pants down and now will use a straw to hide their little wrinklly bits that have been burnt badly.
I think the point remains it will be a long long time before anyone will ever thinks again of organising with such stupidity.I wonder how stupid must be those that put these morons into place and then also stupid ones like SIKH who buy their story to tell us all!!!
Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
Manjit Kaur Sidhu · 30 May 2005
I have to go with Veer Gurcharan Singh Ji Kulim on this one....Veer Ji Gyani jarnail Singh Jio..this issue is NOT DEAD....its Ramifications will last for YEARS.
IF the vasakhi Fiasco had not taken palce earlier...and heated up by the write ups on this issue of a patit convert taking centre stage and another political tattoo Mona Sikh trying to Project His own Sikh leaderee on to the Sikhs..i dont think the tatt khalsa people would even have thought twice about removing djdev. As it is he ended up having the LAST LAUGH...he got the 10,000 fee ( for 15 minutes of dancing on stage), got his act on stage too..IF they had already PAID HIM 10,000 WHY on earth ALLOW him 15 minutes on STAGE ??
As far as I know the Tatt Khalsa OWNS Malaya Samachar lock stock and barrel...and it will carry thier side of the story...and the FACT that from the INTERNET BOARDS this ISSUE has flared up in the PUNJABI PRESS..is something we are PROUD OF as our views are NOTICED.
I call upon Veers GS Kulim, Jarnail singh Gyani Arshi, BS Dhaliwaal and other WELL WISHERS of the GURU KHALSA PANTH to not let this issue DIE..but reach a stage whereby NO ONE will wever dare to call a convert/patit/adulteror/mona wanna be leader to LEAD the SIKHS at such Mega Events in future.
I have read elsewhere that in the USA there are attempts being made by MONAS and PATITS to AMEND GURDWARA CONSTITTIONS to allow Monas in Gurdwara Comittees and excos....next they will DEMAND MONA GRANTHIS, MONA RAAGIS and MONA PANJ PIYARAS as well. We must all co-operate and DRAW the LINE HERE and NOW....one is either a SIKH or a MONA..no one can be BOTH.
Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
Sher Singh · 31 May 2005
Well done Singho...this 'Sikh' is another tatoo that is carrying information around from his masters.fact is a Sikh writer like Kulim ji and Arshi ji stood out against all these tatoos from and made the scene, the heat go too hot for them to handle ...they decied to drop that musslah but they are such stupid bumkins- these tatt khalsa fellows that he stung them for 10000.
SIKH be the son of a father and tell your name instead being another tatoo like the the tatt khalsa fellow nerds.
Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
Manjit kaur Sidhu · 02 Jun 2005
i am amused. All along some people have been saying...."dont bother..this is just some "internet kharrkoo" writing on a message Board in far away Canada..who in malaysia reads it anyway ( THAT is if the Message tells the TRUTH about them, their so called maryada, gurbani classes, school, brahmgiani, or vidya etc..)...then these same people go ahead and BASH the poster ( which they have already claimed NO ONE READS)..
The Tatt Khalsa Diwan has been REBUILT from the Ground up..and will be the MONEY EARNER in years to come...and these "Maryada vidyaks" are eagerly awaiting in the wings to take over..ONCE the DEBTS are settled and the Gurdwar is FREE of any encumbrances..but ready to earn for them..Same story as in Australia and elsewhere. Fisrt they will try and bring in Panj piayaras/Maryada..etc to take over the Gurdwara and once they have full control...the maryada etc will take back stage while they run the gurdwara by keeping all opponents out.
I am releived that even messages on Tapoban..in far away canada have an EFFECT on MALAYSIAN Parbhandaks .... proves my point.
Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
Guru Ka Sikh · 02 Jun 2005
Manjit Kaur Sidhu,
What nonsense you talking about...wat is that to do with maryada, gurbani classes, school, brahmgiani, or vidya...You said they will try to bring Panj Piayaras/Maryada....hey... you must know that Panj Piayaras do sewa based on Guruji's hukam and it is Guru's Panj Piayaras & Maryada, so please respect!!!
Panj Piayaras sewa is the greatest sewa....you must know that
Mind your language........
Phul Chuk Maf..
Guru Ka Sikh
Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
Hurchatran Singh Kulim · 02 Jun 2005
Dear bibi Bhen manjit kaur jio,
Please read MALAYA SAMACHAR under the heading ...Kalam Kulim di...London Ton .....these activities are being exposed....already two parts to a four part article have been published.....
I have not minced my words in that articles.The second two parts are another hot stove for such mona and aspiring Sikh leaders, and djdave supporters,....and the poor suckers who landed up paying RM10,000 to him .....We are also calling strongly for an all malaysia national sikh conference ...we MUST have that ....
To turn the events against the opportuinities and non Sikh looking individuals asspiring to distort the Sikh identity.
One aspiring to be a leader of the Sikhs must look like a basic SIKH>
Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
Manjit kaur Sidhu · 03 Jun 2005
Dear Guru ka Sikh ( who else's Sikhs are on this board ??,
What i am trying to put across is the "mere presence" of or just using the Panj Piayars sroop doesnt STOP what GSKulim is talking about. Watch the DVD/Video Cd in question.... the "Panj Piayars" are in FULL STRENGTH..and so is the MONA "sikh" trying to PROJECT HIS LEADEREE. This was a function organsied and controlled by the so callled POOREE DAMDAMI MARYADA WALEH GROUP...blah blah blah. Famous Raagis from India and Gyani Dhianiyees from malaysia are also there in full force...all KEPT QUIET. WHY ??
In Australia....a "group" pretending to be led by panj Piyaras/maryada shudh group.... captured the Gurdawra sahib from the ordinary sikhs group...and then set about altering and changing the memebership lists etc to KEEP CONTROL...then the Gurdawra lost the Sangat ( and GOLUK)..so this maryada group also went away....and when the Gurdawrta began running successfully again..YOU GUESSED IT..the "panj Piayara/Shudh maryada" group was BACK....for the GOLUK !!! This whole sordid story si not fiction but fact being put up on intenret boards.
BOTH these are BAD NEWS. Gurdawra SEWADAARS MUST be GENUINE NISHKAAM SEWAKS..not goluk capturers...just being in full banna cannot fool people all the time.
Thats all in my message. Panj Piayaras is indeed GREAT SEWA...if genuine.
LIONS in DONKEYS CLOTHING were exposed bY none other than GURU GOBIND SINGH JI...
Bhul Chuk maaf if i was not clear the first time.
Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
Harvinder Singh · 03 Jun 2005
lol......Don't you people have anything *better* to do??........
Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
Manjit kaur Sidhu · 03 Jun 2005
lol...harvinder singh jio...what *better* do you suggest..i am sure many will do it...tell us your experiences at this *better* thing....its not nice to be secretive ..lol..
Re: Please support in protesting agains UNSIKH activities of the SNSM
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 05 Jun 2005
I wonder where these people have gone:-
SANT ATTER SINGH VIDYALA MALAYSIA-after trying to gain political milage they disappeared, and have not answered questions asked about the MONA spokesman , who cant even speak proper Engl;ish
Sikh Naujawan Sabha Malaysia-they preffered silence after their fork tongued Gurmat parchar and Mona projection, with DJ dave semi naked dances on Sikh stage to celeberate Vesakhi.
The Tatt Khalsa sent a Sikh to EXPLAIN-and still got stung for RM10,000 on their hung buttocks...by the COMMITTED "SIKH KIRTANIYA" DJDAVE!!!
Err, someone told some granthi committed rape outside the gurduara ..shh , that is okay it is outside the Gurduara!"!!
While the sangat still patiently sits and awaits to hear from them all......err.hey hello???we are here!!!waiting FOR YOU!!!
Or is it may be they all like their MONA "sikh" leader..do not speak English well enough to answer.....???If that is the problem ....tell me ,I will anwser for you all ....