Re: Question?
Balpreet Singh · 11 Aug 2003
What answer can we give about this? This is something only Guru Sahib and Vahiguru can know. Who knows what reasons there were that the female form was not chosen to house the Guru Jot?
This is for certain though, that women have a very special and completely equal spot in Sikhi. Bebe Nanakee jee was the first Sikh, Mata Khivee is mentioned specifically in Sree Guru Granth Sahib for her sevaa, Guru Amardaas appointed many Sikh women to head Manjees (missionary centres), etc.
But asking why a female body was not chosen would be equivalent to asking why did Vahiguru not give humans 4 arms? Or why did Vahiguru not let humans breath underwater or fly? The answer is known only to Vahiguru.
Re: Question?
domalla premee · 11 Aug 2003
Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh
Guru peeare,
Dass thinks though the intent may be sincere but the advice given above is misplaced and misguided. This is someone's opinion and should not be construed as fact. Dass thinks this perpetuates the subtle prejudice that is prevalent in North Indian society. On one hand there is talk of inability and lack of commitment then glowing references to the scripture regarding the nature of women.
Dass thinks Waheguru having created everything knows his reasons for chosing who He did when He did. All the processes for giving birth including menses, pregnacy and birth are part of His Hukam and are not inherent weakness or uncleanliness. Neither do they imply lack of resolve or lack of commitment. Dass thinks one needs to look at the world at large to see the immense contributions women
Women are roughly half of the adult population yet have been the victim of the world's worst brutalities, oppression and degrading living conditions perpetuated by who....some egotistical men. The sufferings and sacrifices borne by women in history have gone largely unrecorded and were borne mostly in silence.That the majority of leaders and thinkers of consequence are men does not guarantee fairness, justice and true vision for all. Whatever recorded history there is, as often skewed it may be, and according to living witnesses do attest to this.
No, Waheguru had different criteria not based on our narrow notions and biases. Being free of emnity (nirvair) and bias the infusion of Waheguru's Hukam occured on Waheguru's terms. Whatever seva is given will be given to whoever He sees fit....end of discussion. He can easily flip the whole universe on its head in one blink if He choses to do so. Gurbanee attests to His limitless capacity to create and destroy. He will give seva in the future to whoever He sees fit no matter how loudly we as a society may complain about the unsuitablility of the candidate..... and....it may not be a man.
dass
Re: Question?
TU GUR PITA TU HAI GUR MATA · 12 Aug 2003
Vaaheguroo Jee,
We cannot give the blame on women's body for this decision.
Firstly we must consider to what extent women did have a role in the development of Sikhi.
Firstly - all of the Sikh Gurus except Guru Har Krishan jee, were married.
And their wives were their souls.
What I mean is, husband and wife have one soul.
Therefore their wives - were not our Gurus but had the enlightened Jyot of the Guru within them.
This is why when Guru nanak left on his travels - the local sangat was taught by Guru Nanak Sahib's wife.
This is why when Guru Gobind Singh jee went to war, and when he passed on, Mata Sahib kaur and Mata Ajit Kaur gave hukamnamas to the panth.
Mata Sahib Kaur gave hukams with the SEAL of Guru Gobind Singh.
Mata Khivi Ji was the COMPLETE head of the entire Guru ka langar.
she was the cheif administrative authority of teh PANGAT.
She did not take breaks - she was the most dedicated sevadaar and her name is in the Guru Granth Sahib for this.
Mata Bhag kaur was more brave than many of her male counterparts and it is recorded in history that in fact - SHE WAS one of guru jee's CLOSEST BODYGUARDS.. yes.. she was one of his CHEIF generals.
Guru Amar Das jee appointed 42 manjees to women... these women were local preachers day in and day out - they did not step away from the challenges...
It was by Bibi Bhani jee's own grace that Guru Amar Das Jee began to follow Guru Angad Dev jee... YES, she inspired him to become a Sikh !
It was Mata Sahib Kaur who inserted the pathasas into the khande-ke-pahul... she was half of this ceremony. She was the degh in the Degh Tegh Fatheh of the Khalsa
Therefore it is OBVIOUS that women played a huge role in Sikhi...
and their contributions will never go unrecognized
In fact with the youth of this next generation this information will become more well known...
and people will recognize that women and men in human physical form are equal - and the soul has no gender... so these conflicts are of no good reason and we should work on our individual sikhi paths.
please forgive for the many many many errors and please fix wherever applicable
-das
Re: Question?
Gurpreet Kaur · 12 Aug 2003
>>>Guru sahib had to come in a mans form in the time and place so that people would listen instead of judging the book by its cover before guru sahib even said a single word.<<<<
I agree, the message the Gurus wanted to convey would not have been as well received if they were in female form. This is by no means justifiable, however this was due to the male dominance present in India at the time I believe.
What's so inspiring is that even with these views held by people of women in those times, Guru Ji gave equal rights to both sexes, something unheard of in those times.
Instead of worrying why they were not in female form, I am proud that I am from a religion in which women were given so much respect. This outweighs any other details.
Gurfateh
Re: Question?
<>.<>.<>.<>.<> · 12 Aug 2003
Everything reverts back to Hukam.
I suppose .... might Q why there were no Women in the Panj Piyare either.??
Guru Ji asked for a head, not according to gender, just a head!
As far as I know, there has never been any women in the 5 until recently.
How many Women Sant have u seen - not the fake ones...I'm referring to the period of S.Attar Singh/Teja Singh/Isher Singh etc?
Re: Question?
domalla premee · 12 Aug 2003
Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh
Guru peeareo,
I remember speaking to an elderly Gursikh about this years ago. Please forgive me, I am relying on my memory for this one. If anyone wishes to correct and add dates and fill in the gaps please feel free to add.
There was a period as stated before when women were very involved in Panthic seva at all levels.
There was also a dark period later. There was a period in our history when mahants were running our Gurdwaras as Sikhs were fighting to literally survive. They were corrupt and among other destructive changes brought in certain ladies who danced and performed lasciviously in our places of worship.
Due to this women in general were made to suffer for the activities of a few . Women were discouraged from participating in many sevas and were relegated to their families. It did not help that old attitudes in India attributed to the ambient Brahmanical culture were prevalent (see on the stautus of women in Hindu scripture). The Muslim influence was also prevalent and purdah was very much alive even among many Hindus. My mother-in-law (Hindu) was trained to follow that odious custom. She would hide her face when an unknown male came to the house. The Hindu elite had been working for years to undermine and dilute Sikh culture.Sikhs were also killed on sight. Women remained out of sight with their children. One must not forget that the British were also hand and glove with the Brahmins to erode the Sikh ethos. It was in the interests of the British Empire to do so. At some point later even the some British authorities woke up to the realization of the determined effort of the elite Brahmin culture to extinguish the Sikhs and again ,it being in their interest, offered some weak provisions as the independence movement picked up steam. So put all this together and it may give you an idea of what was going on at the time. There was much confusion and disarray and strong political and social leadership was severely lacking in the Khalsa Panth.
The Khalsa Panth is now slowly trying to undo the damage and women are gradually taking their rightful place at the side of their brothers. It is a painful process filled with much contention. The Brahmin elite continues its undaunted push in the form of the Hinduvta movement (Hindustan for Hindus). Other groups like Christians and Muslims are also in their sights. Undermining language, traditon, erasing and changing history and undermining basic beliefs, setting one community or community faction against the other and undermining family units ( ex. this is where sati came in (see sudra web sites), and underming the role of women in Sikhi fit in) are their tools. Major American corporation like Cisco, HP and Sun microsystems have stopped donations to an Indian society charity when it was brought to their attention that the monye was being funneled to support communal vilence. Change occurs gradually and especially given the pressures at work. That is reality. But with determination and the Gurus' grace change will happen for the betterment of all.
Dass thinks if all the members of the Khalsa Panth are fully engaged it means a strong community, stronger families that transmit BY EXAMPLE the values the Gurus have preached to their children (many kids have left to other faiths because they witnessed duplicity...values taught without practical example) and more convicing Parchar again based on example and not just words. All the Khalsa must be aware of these ploys and commit to the practice of the Gurus' teachings, not be blinded and steer clear those who would work to destroy Sikhi. It Truth and justice stand, all of humanity stands to benifit as well.
dass