Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

manj · 07 May 2005

whaeguru ji ka khalsa whaeguru ji ki fathe khalsa ji i know about a person who is amritdhari but he did BAJJAR KUERAHIT as he told us and idont think he get pesh to gururoop PUNJ SINGHS.what we should do. BHUL CHUK MUAAF KARNI JI whaeguru ji ka khalsa whaeguru ji ki fathe

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

cybersingh · 07 May 2005

someone else's sikhi is not in your hands... unless he is directly causing harm to someone you can't force him to do anything i would say just discuss it with him and tel him how he is not apart of the khalsa panth until he get's pesh and Punj accept him again... ...nothing more you can do..

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

Question Bhai · 07 May 2005

Forgive him/her.

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

! · 07 May 2005

it's not up to you to forgive, that is up to the Punj Pyaaray. When dealing with a bujjer kurehitee, you should explain to that person what he s/he did was wrong and that they should appear before the punj pyaaray and ask for forgiveness. If they agree to appear, then continue to support them and giving them encouragement. If they refuse to appear then it is best to leave them alone and not do their sangat any further until they accept their mistake.

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

hmm · 09 May 2005

It would be best to try to find out WHY the person has not appeared before the punj - is it that they do not believe that they have committed a kurehit, or is it that they do not feel ready to retake Amrit since their rehit is lacking? If the first case applies, then not doing their sangat is probably a wise idea; however if it the secnd case, then you should give them every encouragement to keep rehit and to do ardaas to Maharaaj for the strength to keep rehit. Bhul ckook maaf if i have said anything to offend

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

Singh · 09 May 2005

what did they do

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

Singh · 09 May 2005

If a Sikh breaches the four cardinal instructions (Bajjar Kurehats) of no hair cutting, no adultery, no use of intoxicants and no eating of meat, he is called Patit and stand excommunicated from GuruKhalsa Panth until the transgressor appear before the Panj Piareys to seek forgiveness, undergo the given punishment and get rebaptized. A Patit does not remain a member of the Sikh brotherhood and becomes a non-sikh. According to SRM, A Sikh must not have social or personal relations with a Patit which include sharing food and having marital relatioships. Traditionally a Patit is sent before the entire Sangat in the presence of Sri Guru Granth Sahib by Panj Piareys by painting his face with black ink or putting a garland of shoes on him before he is given other Tankhah(religious punishment) for a specific time period and then rebaptised to be inducted back to Guru Khalsa Panth. For your further information: * The Ardas of a Patit (apostate) is forbidden at the Akal Takhat in the Sikh Rehat Maryada **The SGPC has banned the ‘patit’ (apostate) Sikh singers from reciting ‘Gurbani’ in Sikh Gurdwars and also imposed a ban on telecast of the recording of Gurbani recited by Patit Sikhs. A Sikh has an obligation to abide by the command of Guru Sahib. What we should do: + We should follow the command of Guru Sahib ++ We should let the Patit know that he must have to get forgiveness and Amrit again from Panj Piareys +++ We should immidiately do complete Social boycott of Patit as soon as we came to know about his violation of any of the four injuctions. ++++ A Patit should never be allowed to have any involvement in Sikh Activities at any level. +++++ A Patit must be considered as human and must be forgiven completely once he surrendered before thePanj Piareys to realise his wrong doing and undergone the punishment and take the Amrit again. [%sig%]

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

g · 09 May 2005

im a bajja kurehitee but I will never go to the panj again if I want to ask for forgiveness ill ask Guru ji not 5 random "singhs"

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

-- · 09 May 2005

Can a bujjer kurehitee who has retaken Amrit and asked for forgiveness from the panjh ever do seva in the panjh if so asked to?

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

! · 09 May 2005

someone who committs a bujjer kurehit can be forgiven and given amrit again, but the privilge to do seva in an amrit sinchaar is lost. A person who does seva in an amrit sinchaar should have had an exceptional jeevan with no turning away from Guru Sahib. The example usually given is of a pot that has a hole in it. The hole can be filled, but the scar will never go away.

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

whoa · 09 May 2005

this is to 'g' I feel sorry for you. 5 random Singhs?...don't you know anything?...5 Singhs are Guru at the time of Amrit Sanchaar...you better read up...you think you can go out and drunk and then ask Guru Ji for forgivness in the morning? lemme ask you...do you see Guru Ji and talk with Him?...how do you know you are forgiven?...or do you just tell yourself you are?...to see Guru Ji you must first see Guru Ji in 5 Piaray.

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

ssingh · 09 May 2005

familiarize yourself with the events surrounding Akali Phula Singh and Maharajah Ranjit Singh. Then follow this example.

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

Amar Singh · 10 May 2005

Quote: "Traditionally a Patit is sent before the entire Sangat in the presence of Sri Guru Granth Sahib by Panj Piareys by painting his face with black ink or putting a garland of shoes on him before he is given other Tankhah" What is the source of this claim?

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

Question Bhai · 10 May 2005

Probably a mis-understanding of : koee vishhurr jaae sathiguroo paasahu this kaalaa muhu jam maariaa ||

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

kulmohan · 10 May 2005

Instead of familiarizing yourself with the events surrounding Akali Phula Singh and Maharajah Ranjit Singh. Then follow that example.---------- Remind yourselves of what Guru Nanak did to Kauda Rakshash Malik bhago Sajjan thag and then follow that example, I am sure you will be better off.

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

Harjinder Singh · 10 May 2005

[u]Patit[/u]: A defiled Sikh who has failed to live upto the vows of the Khalsa order and has commited one of the 4 cardinal injunctions (Karuhits) which are 1. Must not cut hair 2. Must not eat meat 3. Must not use intoxicants 4. Must not commit adultery If a Sikh breaches any of these vows taken at Amrit Sanchar, he/she ceases to be Sikh, he has to be rebaptised, after due pennance. The offender must publicly apologize to the congregation and perform whatever penances is suggested by Panj Pyares, the five chosen Gursikhs of the congregation. In this context, Rahitnama of Bhai Sahib Singh has recorded: "When a Sikh discards the hair My company he loses to share." Muktinama says: "Hair on head are Guru`s stamp. He who discards them be deemed bemukh (an apostate)." Rattan Singh Bhangu, in his Prachin Panth Prakash, makes an emphatic statement: "In Sikhism, the mental state of an apostate can never be in ascendancy because he does not appear to be the Guru`s Sikh. Our Gurus have forbade us to live a life of shame and pretence because this does not help us either in this world or in the other. Nobody trusts the degenerate, and more so his own conscience is ever in distress". Rahat-nama Bhai Daya Singh says: "A Sikh should not give his daughter in marriage to a Patit (apostate)" Rahat-nama Bhai Desa Singh says: "He should keep away from characterless men and women." "He should disassociate himself from Patits (apostates)." Rahat-nama of Bhai Chaupa Singh says: "A Sikh should marry Sikh" The current Panthic SIKH REHAT MARYADA says : Article XVI (Living in Consonance with Guru's Tenets) (p) He who regards another man's daughter as his own daughter, regards another man's wife as his mother, has coition with his own wife alone, he alone is a truly disciplined Sikh of the Guru. Living in Consonance with Guru's Tenets Article XVIII (Anand Sanskar) (b) A Sikh's daughter must be married to a Sikh. (q) A baptized Sikh ought to get his wife baptized. Article XXIII (Panth's Status of Guruhood) (p)The undermentioned four transgressions must be avoided: (1) Dishonouring the hair; (2) Eating the meat ; (3) Cohabiting with a person other than one's spouse; (4) Using tobacco or other intoxicants. In the event of the commission of any of these transgressions, the transgressor must get rebaptised. You must not associate with a Sikh who had uncut hair earlier and has cut it or a Sikh who smokes. You must remain fully aligned to the Khalsa brotherhood in accordance with the principles of the Khalsa faith. If you commit transgression of the Khalsa discipline, you must present yourself before the congregation and beg pardon, accepting whatever punishment is awarded. You must also resolve to remain watchful against defaults in the future. (q) The following individuals shall be liable to chastisement involving automatic boycott: (1) Anyone maintaining relations or communion with elements antagonistic to the Panth including the minas (reprobates), the masands (agents once accredited to local Sikh communities as Guru's representatives, sine discredited for their faults and aberrations), followers of Dhirmal or Ram Rai, et. al., or users of tobacco or killers of female infants; (2) One who eats/drinks left-overs of the unbaptised or the fallen Sikhs; (3) One who dyes his beard; (4) One who gives off son or daughter in matrimony for a price or reward; (5) Users of intoxicant (hemp, opium, liquor, narcotics, cocaine, etc.); (6) One holding, or being a party to, ceremonies or practices contrary to the Guru's way; (7) One who defaults in the maintenance of Sikh discipline. Article XXV (Method of Imposing Chastisement) (a) Any Sikh who has committed any default in the observance of the Sikh discipline should approach the nearby Sikh congregation and make a confession of his lapse standing before the congregation. (b) The congregation should then, in the holy presence of Guru Granth Sahib, elect from among themselves five beloved ones who should ponder over the suppliant's fault and propose the chastisement (punishment) for it. (c) The congregation should not take an obdurate stand in granting pardon. Nor should the defaulter argue about the chastisement. The punishment that is imposed should be some kind of service, especially some service that can be performed with hands. (d) And finally an Ardas for correction should be performed. The examples of Sikh character were set by the Gurus themselves and those prominent Sikh Saint Warriers who have moulded and cast the Sikh history. By their manliness and spirit of service, the Sikhs only strengthened their resolve to stand firm against tyranny and fanaticism even during their holocausts, . Those were the tru sons of Guru Sahib who have received compliments from their adversaries. Qazi Nur Mahommed, the Muslim historian who came in the retinue of Ahmed Shah Abdali to India in 1762, wrote about the Sikhs thus: “Do not call the Sikhs ‘dogs,’ because they are lions, and are brave like lions in the battle-field, they never kill a coward and do not obstruct one who flees from the field. They do not rob a woman of her gold or ornaments, be she a queen or a slave-girl. Adultery does not exist among these ‘dogs.’ None of them is a thief. . . the ‘dogs’ never resort to stealing and none of them is a thief. They donot keep company with any adulterer or thief.”

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

AAA · 10 May 2005

WAT IS A BAJJAR KUERAHIT?????

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

Singh · 10 May 2005

Kulmohan, A manmukh is in my eyes 100 times better than a bemukh. Sajjan Thugh, Kauda Raksh and others were all manmukhs who met Guru Nanak and then became his Sikhs. A Bemukh like Duni Chand who ran from Anandpur Sahib suffered. If someone becomes bemukh from Guru Sahib, you can try to explain to them what they have done is wrong, but doing sangat with them after that if they insist on staying bemukh is harmful. btw. a Bujjer Kurehit means Major Violation of Rehit and results in a person no longer being a Sikh. The four are listed above.

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

Akaal · 10 May 2005

Halal meat not meat. Don't try to change Akal Takht maryada.

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

Harjinder Singh · 17 May 2005

[gurbani]<>[/gurbani] [gurbani]nwnk kciVAw isau qoiV FUiF sjx sMq pikAw[/gurbani] Naanak Kacharriaa Sio Torr Dhoondh Sajan Sant Pakiaa O Nanak, abandon The False And Join The True Ones (sggs 1102) The Gurbani has shown a very clear way for all of us that how one can transform his life from that of a Manmukh (a Material being who follows his mind) to a Gurmukh (a Spiritual Being who follows the hukum of Guru Sahib). As outlined above, the process involves external association (i.e. joining the company of Gurmukhs), and Inner association (i.e. association of Naam-Simran, Truth, the real Self or Sat Guru). Birds of same feather flock together. Like attracts like. Therefore, the association make very strong and direct influence. We become just like the one we associate. With Satsang (True Association), one becomes God-faced or Gurmukh. On the contrary, with false or bad association ( Saakat Sang or Kusang), one becomes mind-faced or Manmukh. Choice is ours. One has to abandon the False Association or Kusang in order to join the Satsang. Truth and the falsehood can not dwell in the same place. The company of faithless cynics (bad association) will bring us nothing but ruin. On the other hand, by joining the Satsang, one becomes qualified to be elevated to God-Consciousness. [gurbani]kbIr swkq sMgu n kIjIAY dUrih jweIAY Bwig[/gurbani] [gurbani]bwsnu kwro prsIAY qau kCu lwgY dwgu[/gurbani] Kabeer Saakat Sang N Keejeeai Doorei Jaaeeai Bhaag Baasan Kaaro Paraseeai To Kachh Laagai Dhaag Do not associate with the faithless cynics and run far away from them. If you touch a vessel stained with soot, some of the soot will stick to you (sggs 1371) [gurbani]swkq sMgu n kIjeI ipAwry jy kw pwir vswie[/gurbani] [gurbani]ijsu imilAY hir ivsrY ipAwry suo muih kwlY auiT jwie[/gurbani] Saakat Sang Na Keejayee Piyaare Je Kaa Paari Vasaayi Jis Miliyai Hari Visrai Piyaare Su Muhi Kaalai Uthi Jaayi As far as possible, do not associate with the faithless cynics Meeting with them, the Lord is forgotten and you rise and depart with a blackened face (sggs 640) Coming to main point of the discussion, A Bemukh (the Patit or an apostate Sikh) is worst person in the category of people not to be associated by a Sikh and all the above hukums of Guru Sahib applies to a bemukh. So sangat of a bemukh is very detrimental to any Sikh. If someone in our association becomes a bemukh from the Guru Sahib, you must clearly convey the hukum of Guru Sahib to him and dissociate ourself from him until he publicly apologize to the congregation in the presence of Gurur Granth Sahib Jee and return to the fold of Sikhi by rebaptising after due pennance as ordained by Panj Pyareys. Unfortunately, Bemukhs are leading the Sikhs at many places today. We have not been able to check most of these people in spite of even their repeating the strictly prohibited injuctions again and again. We just keep ourselves silent or unable to bring them in the court of Gurur Khalsa Panth in order to stop the continous degradation of Sikh character which is very detrimental to our future. May Guru Sahib give the strength to us, to take strong decisions to make right choices as per the hukum of Guru Sahib to regain the lost character for which once Every Sikh was well known all over and it was shown by Great Sikh General Sardar Hari Singh Nalwa and almost all the Sikhs of those golden days in the history of Guru Khalsa Panth for whom people said [gurbani]moVI bwbw fWg vwilAw CeI[/gurbani] [gurbani]moVI bwbw kC vwilAw CeI[/gurbani] Morieen Baba Kacchh Waliya, Shayee! Morieen Baba Daang Waliya, Shayee! And Bhai Gurdas Singh Jee describes very well as follows: [gurbani]auhu guru goibMd hoie pRgitE dsvW Avqwrw[/gurbani] Ouhu Gur Gobind Hoe Pragattiou Dhasavaan Avataaraa [gurbani]ijn AlK Aper inrMjnw jipE krqwrw[/gurbani] Jin Alakh Apear Niranjanaa Japiou Karataaraa [gurbani]inj pMQ clwieE Kwlsw Dir qyj krwrw[/gurbani] Nij Panthh Chalaaeiou Khaalasaa Dhhar Tej Karaaraa [gurbani]isr kys Dwir gih KVg ko sB dust pCwrw[/gurbani] Sir Kaes Dhhaar Gehi Kharrag Ko Sabh Dhusatt Pashhaaraa [gurbani]sIl jq kI kC phir pkVo hiQAwrw[/gurbani] Seel Jat Kee Kashh Pehar Pakarro Hathhiaaraa [gurbani]sc Pqy bulweI gurU kI jIiqE rx Bwrw[/gurbani] Sach Fateh Bulaaee Guroo Kee Jeethiou Ran Bhaaraa [gurbani]sB dYq Airin ko Gyr kir kIcY pRhwrw[/gurbani] Sabh Dhait Arin Ko Ghaer Kar Keechai Prehaaraa [gurbani]qb sihjy pRgitE jgq mY guru jwp Apwrw[/gurbani] Tab Sehijae Pragattiou Jagat Mai Gur Jaap Apaaraa [gurbani]ieauN aupjy isMG BujMgIey nIl AMbr Dwrw[/gurbani] Eioun Oupajae Singh Bhujangeeeae Neel Anmbar Dhhaaraa [gurbani]qurk dust siB CY kIey hir nwm aucwrw[/gurbani] Turak Dhusatt Sabh Shhai Keeeae Har Naam Ouchaaraa [gurbani]iqn Awgy koie n TihirE Bwgy isrdwrw[/gurbani] Thin Aagae Koe Na Thehiriou Bhaagae Siradhaaraa [gurbani]jh rwjy swh AmIrVy hoey sB Cwrw[/gurbani] Jeh Raajae Saah Ameerarrae Hoeae Sabh Shhaaraa [gurbani]iPr sun kir AYsI Dmk kau kWpY igir Bwrw[/gurbani] Fir Sun Kar Aisee Dhhamak Ko Kaanpai Gir Bhaaraa [gurbani]qb sB DrqI hlcl BeI Cwfy Gr bwrw[/gurbani] Thab Sabh Dhharatee Halachal Bhee Shhaaddae Ghar Baaraa [gurbani]ieauN AYsy duMd klys mih KipE sMswrw[/gurbani] Eioun Aisae Dhundh Kalaes Mehi Khapiou SanSaaraa [gurbani]iqih ibnu siqgur koeI hY nhI BY kwtn hwrw[/gurbani] Thihi Bin Sathigur Koee Hai Nehee Bhai Kaattan Haaraa [gurbani]gih AYsy KVg idKweIAY ko skY n Jylw[/gurbani] Gehi Aisae Kharrag Dhikhaaeeai Ko Sakai N Jhaelaa [gurbani]vwh vwh goibMd isMG Awpy guru cylw[/gurbani] Vaah Vaah Gobind Singh Aapae Gur Chaelaa [%sig%]

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

Dogma · 17 May 2005

Harjinder Singh, I'm loving your posts brother. I don't even read them all, I just love the way you make points and back them up with Gurbani...maybe I should go back and read them, eh? :) Fateh!

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

Unknown Singhni · 17 May 2005

guroo roop khaalsa sangat jeo i would like to kno what is punisment if an amritdari Sing forced himself on a bibi. I know an amritdari singh did this with two bibis. He suceeded with one of them who is actually also amritdari while the other one ( not amritdhari) was strong and resisted and put a slap on his mouth. I would like to kno what kind of punisment such a person deserve specially if he still portray among sangat as he has done nothing. Is the punisment gonna be same whether someone surrendered himself before the sangat OR he is forced by the Sangat to do so. I beleive that he is rapist. I know in Islam, the punishment is death. I recently heard that a court in India gave death penalty to a rapist. I want to what kind of action is appropriate as per gurmat so that nakab of such people is removed and they are taught a lesson knowing which no should dare to point a finger at somone's daughter, sister and mother. I heard from someone eighteenth century Khalsa was well known to protect the ijjat of all women and punish such people very severely. I would really appreciate feed back from every knowlegible gursikh who can help in this specially veer kulbir singh ji, veer balpreet singh ji and veer jarnail singh ji because this is very important and concerning issue. I do not want to disclose any identity at this point unless I find it really needed to take some concrete step. Please ............ [%sig%]

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

Balpreet Singh · 17 May 2005

Someone who forces himself on other women and does so repeatedly is worse than an animal. I don't know how forgiveness can be given for this. I suppose that would be up to the Punj Pyaaray. I think such a person, to be forgiven by Guru Sahib, would have to first be forgiven by his victims. I'm not sure someone can be forced to pesh if he doesn't want to confess his mistakes. I was asked a few years ago what I thought would be the appropriate punishment in such a case. I decided to cite something I read about puraatan Singhs: CA Bayly wrote a paper "The Pre-History of Communalism". He writes, "The Sikh attacks of 1764.....A large Sikh band attacked village Jalalabad, for instance, because its Muslim coparceners were alleged to have mistreated a Hindu girl; the headman was burnt alive and the village sacked"

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

Unknown Singhni · 17 May 2005

I highly appreciate the views of veer balpreet singh jee and I highly commend specialy veer harjinder singh jee for showing so much concern about this issue and explaining the Gurmat stand in this matter. you both have really expressed what my heart feeling at this moment that i could not actually put in words. I expect more viwes as i would like to kno more how in present days it is feasible to take such a class action. Any more viewes on how can we mobalize the sangat to stand strongly against such fakes having nakab of amritdari sings so that they are forced to surrender before the sangat to correct themselves or they are forced to sack from the community. should we take this matter to law enforcement in the first place or we can have our own enough measures to handle such doosts. [%sig%]

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

stranger · 19 May 2005

Wow - you guys really do live in another world - u all know more Gurbani then me - thats a fact!! In the court of Dharm Raj each soul is judged according to Chit and Gupt and there no one has any witnesses to back them up on why they did bad deeds. If a person changes there views about the so-called 4 bad deeds thats their God given right. To stop talking to that person or excommunicating them is not YOUR right. Besides for me the big question is: Who the heck are you to excommunicate them from Sikhi????? Have you looked in your closet to see what you are hiding before ruffling through someone elses to disgrace them.....? As said above by someone else: don;t change the Akal Takhat Rehit - we are NOT allowed to eat Halal or spiritually prepared meat - its does not say: Sikhs are NOT allowed to eat meat. THATS a FACT. So eating meat is not a bad deed according to the Akal Takhat and thats good enuf for me. Unless of course you discount the rehit for the general Sikh populous? Which suggests you think you are higher and more knowledgeable them the philosophers who put together the rehit?

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

outfit · 19 May 2005

Ftahe!! Bhai Balpreet Singh Ji, your tone was very strong and you shose to pinpoint on one 'kurehat'. Also, for some reason, you are picking a certain hypothetical scenario. Anyhow, das would just like to point out that if we are adept enough in our Sikhi, we are never 'VICTIMS'. What doesn't kill me can only make me stronger. Society is cruel but there are ways to fight back. Ultimately, our tool is Gurmantar, and Gurbani is our aasra to move FORWARD. Why do post-mortems of other people's situations. Why not focus on your own life? We don't need to take stuff from anybody else, i.e. mistake making HUMAN beings. Nowadays, it seems that a lot of 'bigged-up' names are very quick to jump the gun without UNDERSTANDING an individual's situation, setting or mood of the TIME. Forgive me, but you ppl can be SO dry and complascent sticking your noses into other people's business/affairs. That is not what 'sangat' is there for UNLESS your help is called for by the ppl concerned. These internet boards especially seem to be an ever-increasing breeding ground for NINDHAKS and CHUGAL KORS. It may be subtley put, but is definitely there. Any outsider to your little group reading this is not likely to take a POSITIVE message with them. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh1!

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

Roopkaur · 19 May 2005

>If a person changes there views about the so-called 4 bad deeds thats their God given right. To stop talking to that person or excommunicating them is not YOUR right. Besides for me the big question is: Who the heck are you to excommunicate them from Sikhi????? < The panth did not excommincate them, they themselves choose to excommincate themselves from Guru Ji and the panth. They can change their views, but they do so on the condition of no longer being SIkhs, since it is clear as day, from the posts above, that after becoming a patit, you are no longer a SIkh of guru ji, you have become a sikh of mayaa. It is the duty of a Sikh to follow rehitnamaas, not their rights. Rights can be chosen, which right we want and which we dont, but duties are mandatory, as SIkhi is a game of love, not a game of our minds whims. >As said above by someone else: don;t change the Akal Takhat Rehit - we are NOT allowed to eat Halal or spiritually prepared meat - its does not say: Sikhs are NOT allowed to eat meat. THATS a FACT. So eating meat is not a bad deed according to the Akal Takhat and thats good enuf for me.< THere is nowhere where it says we can only eat non halal meat. It says we are to avoid kutthaa meat. Kutthaa means anything murdered. Yes we always eat meat, through the bacteria in our food or in air, but we are not allowed to murder and eat. Gurbani stresses this many times that we are not to take a life of another being for the sake of our tongue, your mans mat is not higher than gurbani, so I suggest if you want to call yourself a Guru Ka Sikh, start actually listening to guru ji. >Why do post-mortems of other people's situations. Why not focus on your own life? We don't need to take stuff from anybody else, i.e. mistake making HUMAN beings.< The Sikh panth is a family, and if a bibi has been mistreated, and forced upon, how can you sit there and say that we should mind our own business? If your sister or mother was treated badly, would you just sit there with your mouth shut and say, I have to mind my own business, because whatever happened to them, they are still alive, so they will only be stronger. THat is pure crap. When a supposed amritdharee acts like an animal, and abuses guru jis roop, he makes it the whole panths business. >These internet boards especially seem to be an ever-increasing breeding ground for NINDHAKS and CHUGAL KORS. It may be subtley put, but is definitely there. Any outsider to your little group reading this is not likely to take a POSITIVE message with them.< Nindya and chugli is not critisising something, it is the act of lying and trying to defame someone through untruth statements. To expose injustice and manmatt is not nindya. I think it is the duty of Sikhs to deal with this when imposters try to act as SIkhs and defame the whole panth, and when our sisters are being mistreated, instead of sitting there and being kayers, and saying, oh we all must mind our own business now, whatever doesnt kill them will only make them stronger. Let me see you go say that to the mothers of the victims of the Delhi riots, or the famililes of those Singhs still rotting in jails under the TADA laws, or to the girls and women who were mistreated by police and now are screwed for life because people like you just want to mind their own business. [%sig%]

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

stranger · 19 May 2005

If I may respond to the Kuttaa meat point - your definition of Kuttaa is wrong Bibi Roop Kaur Ji Read this please: The Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib, the Supreme Authority of the Sikhs, and the (Panth Parvaan) Sikh Rehat Maryada (which has been passed and approved by the Akaal Takhat Sahib) states that the four kurehats (prohibitions) are: 1) Dishonouring the hair 2) Sexual relationship with another man or woman other than one's husband and wife (i.e. adultery) 3) Tabacco 4) Kuttaa (in a foot note in the Maryada it states - "kuttaa = meat prepared in accordance to Muslim rites) These are the four Kurehats because in no consciousness or situation you can unwillingly commit these acts. 1) You cannot unwillingly or unknowingly dishonour your hair 2) You cannot unwillingly or unknowingly have sexual contact with another person other than one's wife or husband. 3) You cannot unwillingly or unknowingly smoke or take tabacco 4) You cannot unwillingly or unknowingly eat Halaal Meat (Kuttaa) If you follow the thought that in the situation where a Gursikh is in a jungle and there is totally nothing to eat - no vegetables, plants or leaves - then it is permissible for a Sikh to eat meat... then eating meat cannot be a "kurehat" - for a kurehat is something which cannot be committed in any circumstance or possible situation. Therefore the Kurehat is "Kuttaa"/Halaal Meat. (Halaal meat is slaughtered in a way which causes unnecessary suffering to the animal as well as it is a sign of slavery to eat it because during the times of Gurus, the Mughals had made it a law that the only permissible meat for any person to eat was Halaal... therefore the Sikh Gurus said we are not under the Mughals and therefore refuse to eat Halaal meat)

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

Roopkaur · 19 May 2005

the halal meaning of kutthaa is just one meaning that has been accepted by those who wish to gratify their tongues at the cost of animals lives. If you look up the word in the mahaan kosh, you will see that the first meaning given is the one I offer. It is also the one that agrees with what Gurbani says, and gurbani and rehit cannot ever contradict each other. Your definitiion of kutthaa on the other hand clearly contradicts with bani. I do not follow the thought that Sikhs can eat meat when there totally nothing to eat. If Bhai Taru Singh Ji could give his life for the SIkh of his hair, than a Sikh should be able to give up their for the sake of their dietary bibek. Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Ji was kept without food or water in hellish conditions for 40 days. If he did not even waiver on breaking his bibek, which would not have been a kurehit, how can a Sikh be allowed to make a huge compromise in their rehit such as eating meat? >Therefore the Kurehat is "Kuttaa"/Halaal Meat. (Halaal meat is slaughtered in a way which causes unnecessary suffering to the animal as well as it is a sign of slavery to eat it because during the times of Gurus, the Mughals had made it a law that the only permissible meat for any person to eat was Halaal... therefore the Sikh Gurus said we are not under the Mughals and therefore refuse to eat Halaal meat)< Are you saying that the meat you eat was made from animals that were smiling when they were murdered? Is not the suffering cows endure when they are stunned and hung upside down, and when their throats are slashed so the blook can pour out, is that not unneccary suffering? What about the little chicks that have their beaks cut off, or the pigs who have their ears cut off. That must not be unneccary suffering right? These animals must have died happily at thought of becoming food for a stomach for a person such as yourself.

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

RoopKaur · 19 May 2005

correction, breaking bibek would have been a kurehit, but not a bujjar kurehit

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

Harjinder Singh · 19 May 2005

I highly appreciate your reply Roop Kaur Bhainjeo. Thanks you bhain ji for this befitting reply. You actually covered everything that I was also writing in response to the post written by “stranger” and “outfit” as result of the Sangat or the learning environment they have gone through (I do not blame them for their views). I have nothing much left to say after reading your posts. I can again say that, in my opinion based on learining of Gurmat so far, sexually mistreating (or forcing upon) is the most heinous act and is worst scenario of “Adultery”, which is one of the four forbidden injunctions because it makes one human a cruel animal towards your other human. This kind of act can not be ignored as it hurts others ( the effected ones) much more than the person who is actually committing it and hence such a person can not be a Sikh and a Sikh must boycott that person until he is forgiven after taking due punishment as ordained by Panj. I believe that all of the Sikhs believe in this Hukum of Gurur Sahib The another injunction is not to use Tobacco/Intoxicants Consuming intoxicants cause life threatening diseases and can result in the disputes & criminal acts. I believe that all of the Sikhs also believe in this Hukum of Guru Sahib The first injunction is not to cut hair. Cutting hair is interfering in God’s will. Keeping hair asserts faith in God's creation & wisdom. Guru Sahib gave highest importance to the Kesh and named the Khalsa’s creation place as Sri KeshGrah Sahib. I believe that all of the Sikhs believe in this Hukum of Guru Sahib. The only injuction which has unfortunately become controversial these days is “Not to eat Meat”. As far as I have learnt Gurmat, I believe that eating meat is also another intentional merciless act towards another living animals just like intentional sexual mistreatment towards another human fellow. Any kind of meat is prepared by intentional murdering of another living creature. One has to be merciless to do so. Guru Sahib says [gurbani]DOlu Drmu dieAw kw pUqu[/gurbani] Dhoul Dharam Daiya Ka Poot Dharam is son of Mercy Eating meat is violation of the someone’s right to live and Not eating meat is a gesture of kindness which is the seed of Dharam as taught by Guru Sahib Sikhs. I can guarantee, most of the Sikhs who eat meat do not do so called acceptable chatka by their hands or they have not seen with their own eyes how the animal was killed before they consume meat. It is just an unreasonable excuse. Meat is a meat. Meat prepared in a Muslim way is no different than prepared in any other way as far as act of a human being intentionally murdering another living being to fulfill the taste of tongue. I do not know how can we save many Sikh (who are otherwise so Good Sikhs) from this desease of eating meat which is a major roadblock in the path of sipirtual growth as per Gurmat. I understand it is not the fault of those Sikhs who eat meat. It is the unintentional drawback in the wording of SRM that it gave the opportunity for the meat-eater Parcharaks/Scholars to mis-interpret it so much that today we have a significant group (although still in far minority) established among the Sikh masses in the favour of meat. Guru Sahib Aap hee Kirpa Karan otherwise a day of a big split will definitely come when we will have Gurdwaras with meat langar and non-meat langar. Gyani Jarnail Singh Ji, Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji and Bhai Balpreet Singh Ji have more knowledge/understanding of Gurmat and they can add more valuable input. [%sig%]

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

stranger · 20 May 2005

If the meat issue was so clear as you make it 'Roop Kaur' then why is it not so clearly labelled in the Sri Akal Takhat Rehit - Sikhs are not allowed to eat meat. So many references are being made to Kan Singh Nabha's Mahan Kosh - could you also look up the meaning of 'Chatka Meat' - clearly its describes the way an animal should be killed - say sat sri akal and with one swipe perform the killing. (No exact wording but please do read it). About someone raping another person - they deserve to be punished.

Re: what we should do to a bajjar kurehitee

taksaal 4eva · 20 May 2005

jus cos akaal takht says tht u can meat doesnt mean u can! ur not supposed to eat any kind of meat full stop. akaal takht also say kes is the 5th k but any knowledgeable peron will tell u tht this is a load of raagmala