Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

REPLY FROM BBFC About Kanjarwood movie.

REPLY FROM BBFC About Kanjarwood movie.

MS · 12 May 2005

Dear ****** Singh Thank you for your email in which you expressed concern regarding the classification of the film 'Jo Bole So Nihaal'. I would like to explain the BBFC's decision to pass this film at the '12A' category and respond to the issue of potential offence to the Sikh community. The film was classified '12A' primarily for its 'moderate violence', in line with our published classification Guidelines. These Guidelines are the result of an extensive consultation with a large cross-section of the public. The Guidelines are available on our website - www.bbfc.co.uk. With regard to the issue of potential offence to the Sikh community, I would like to reassure you that the BBFC is committed to addressing the concerns and needs of the community at large, in particular the sensitivities of ethnic and religious minorities. It is partly for this reason that we have a broad mix of South Asian examiners (of Muslim, Hindu and Sikh origin) who remain well attuned to any issues in films that may offend or upset particular communities. 'Jo Bole So Nihaal' is a light but also impassioned film about a Punjabi Sikh policeman called Nihaal (played by Sunny Deol) who chases a terrorist from India to New York and brings him back to India, to serve the cause of justice. As he is a proud Sikh character, his reference to the revered Sikh war cry and greeting 'Jo Bole So Nihaal, Sat Sri Akal!' is conveyed with the kind of glory and respect that is part of the overall positive message of the film. It is important to clarify, from our point of view, that the film does not carry any politically sensitive or sacrilegious elements. It is also worth noting, as most South Asian film lovers will be well aware, the Bollywood actor Sunny Deol is a proud Punjabi Sikh himself. He has often played strong Sikh characters much to the delight of Punjabi Sikh cinema audiences across the world. 'Jo Bole So Nihaal' is a continuation of that trend and I suspect that had the film carried any intentions to offend Sikhs audiences, Mr Deol would not have agreed to play the lead. If you decide to watch the film after its release, or receive feedback from viewers who have seen the film, we believe you will be reassured that its intention is not to offend Sikhs. Rather, it depicts a strong Sikh hero figure, in a straightforward thriller, who cherishes and hails the Sikh greeting that is an important part of the Sikh tradition. May I thank you for your email, as your feedback is important to us. I hope that this response satisfies your concerns. If you have any further questions, please do not hesitate to get in touch. Yours faithfully Hammad Khan Film & Video Examiner

Re: REPLY FROM BBFC About Kanjarwood movie.

Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 12 May 2005

I would have expected that Film examner to be a Sikh who responds in line with the claims made in the mail. It is important that we have the name of the Sikh examiner of this film, and his views not a mulsim trying to tell us about our sensitivities. If indeed the have a Sikh examiner??

Re: REPLY FROM BBFC About Kanjarwood movie.

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 12 May 2005

The DEOL Family are ARYA SAMAJISTS...who says they are SIKHS ?? The Lame explanation above is a classic example of Maakhi te makhee maarnee.....since SIKHS "didnt protest" about his earlier films....this means he is a "good sikh"....blah blah blah....and so this must be a good sikh film..blah blah blah.... foour or five WRONGS dont make a "right" even if SIKHS didnt protest the first Five WRONGS..

Re: REPLY FROM BBFC About Kanjarwood movie.

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 13 May 2005

So Hammad Khan would be fine if the tables were turned and the offence was directed at Islam????

Re: REPLY FROM BBFC About Kanjarwood movie.

MS · 13 May 2005

So any ideas on a reasoned reply back to this reply plz? I was thinking along the lines of Giani Jee said - i.e. Deol not being a Sikh, however then Mr Khan could say most the ppl who claim to be Sikh have not follwed the first Rehat and are not Sikh also?

Re: REPLY FROM BBFC About Kanjarwood movie.

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 13 May 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki Fateh. Dear MS jio, The DEOLS are Kuttarr ARYA SAMAJISTS from Dharmendar's father onwards...( not "sikhs" who dont follow rehit ) The leader of teh Arya Samajists was Swami Dyanand who wrote very disparaging language about GURU SAHIBAANS in his Granths. The Arya samajists are the CHIEF ANTI-SIKH Force all along in the Punjab hindu...they are the ones who do all the anti sikh propoganda, who actively promoted writing HINDI as the Mother Tongue of all Punjabi hidnus in the Census to stop Punjabi Suba.....and their onslaught agaisnt Sikhi was so strong that BHAI KAHN SINGH NABHA had to write his "Hum Hindu nahin" booklet, aginst which false reports were sent to the British to get it banned. ALL the MAHASHA PRESS in jalandhar that spewed out Anti-Sikh filth in the name of "journalism" like Partap, Hind Samachar, Milap etc are Arya Samajist Hindi language/Urdu language Papers. They are always in the forefront to bring out Anti-Sikh, RACIALIST comments and editorials promoting anti sikh violence and bloodshed. One of their Editors was killed by the Kharkoos in the 1980's (Lala Jagat narain of Hind Samachar) This long time anti sikh stance of the Arya Samajists is a far cry from anyone who claims he is a "sikh" and doesnt follwo the rehit or is even a Patit/mona etc. This is an ORGANISATION that does active Anti-Sikh parchaar. Hope this helps.

Re: REPLY FROM BBFC About Kanjarwood movie.

MS · 15 May 2005

Thanks, stay tuned for next reply, assuming Mr Khan does

Re: REPLY FROM BBFC About Kanjarwood movie.

singh is king · 15 May 2005

anyone wants to know about what arya samaj means click on http://www.jatland.com/aryasamaj.htm

Re: REPLY FROM BBFC About Kanjarwood movie.

MS · 19 May 2005

Dear Mr Khan, Thanks for the prompt reply. I would like to further address some of the issues you have raised in your reply to my initial email. Firstly with regards to the mix of examiners that you say are of Sikh origin, certainly does not even suggest that they have the pulse of not only the Sikh community but also how this movie addresses Sikh believes on an ideological level. Can I ask for some more information with regards to what makes the Sikh origin examiners qualified to deliberate the Sikh perspective of such a movie? Secondly I have some serious concerns with the BBFC's own information and understanding of the actors surrounding this movie, in particular you have said Sunny Deol is a Sikh. The DEOLS are Kuttarr ARYA SAMAJISTS from Dharmendar's father onwards...( not "sikhs" because they don't believe in the basic fundamentals of Sikhism). The leader of the Arya Samajists was Swami Dyanand who wrote very disparaging language about Sikh Gurus in his books. This long time anti-Sikh stance of the Arya Samajists is a far cry from anyone who claims he is a "Sikh" and doesn't follow the Sikhism or is even a Patit/mona etc. You have also made reference to the 'Proud Sikh character' of this hero figure, yet in reality the behaviour of the character let alone appearance, is misrepresentative of not only Sikhism but true Sikh heroes who have throughout history given their lives in gruelling torture rather than for example convert to another religion, or cut their hair. Yet correct me if im wrong Suny Deol is singing a Sikh salutation while dancing with half naked girls on the beach, trimming his beard, is not reflective of true Sikh heros but offensive to suggest that this character is a hero to Sikhs. So I hope you can appreciate the clear contradiction that this is i.e. having Sikh scriptures being used in a way that is contradictory to what they represent; thus re-evaluate the serious offence that is being caused to Sikhs. Kind Regards ******* Singh

Re: REPLY FROM BBFC About Kanjarwood movie.

amorphous_singh · 21 May 2005

[snip] > It is also worth noting, as most South Asian film lovers will > be well aware, the Bollywood actor Sunny Deol is a proud > Punjabi Sikh himself. He has often played strong Sikh > characters much to the delight of Punjabi Sikh cinema audiences > across the world. 'Jo Bole So Nihaal' is a continuation of > that trend and I suspect that had the film carried any > intentions to offend Sikhs audiences, Mr Deol would not have > agreed to play the lead. If you decide to watch the film after [snip] > Hammad Khan > Film & Video Examiner Strange. Hammad Khan writes on behalf of the supposedly independent BBFC but seems to sound like the agent for Sunny Deol. Hmmm .... "The creatures outside looked from pig to man, and from man to pig, and from pig to man again; but already it was impossible to say which was which." [Animal Farm, George Orwell] [%sig%]