Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Khalistan?

Khalistan?

ASadana · 12 May 2005

Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Ki Fateh, Recently i have been asked by one or two people as to what i am, meaning for or against Khalistan. Can someone please explain what this is as i am not sure which i am. Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Ki Fateh, [%sig%]

Re: Khalistan?

Sikh · 12 May 2005

for khalistan means against Hindustans nasty treatments of sikhs....against khalistan means confused person.....very confused person....need to start thinking properly and become a proper sikh of the Guru...a Sikh who stands up against Injustice....

Re: Khalistan?

ekta · 12 May 2005

Khalistan, the huq and right of the Khalsa. Khalistan = land of the pure; originally called the sikh homeland. India has commited genocide upon the sikh ppl, and the only solution to this is the formation of Khalistan, an autonomous state run and directed by Sahib Siri AKaal Takht Sahib and edict of Siri Guru Granth Sahib ji Mahaaraaj.

Re: Khalistan?

A Singh · 13 May 2005

Dear Amrita Kaur Sadana, Gur Fateh! The Khalistan question is riddled with side-politics using a religious garb and sadly also Jat-specific issues that have risen to the forefront. In the process, many great institutions within the Sikh world such as the Damdami Taksal and the physical saroop of the Nihang Singh Khalsa have had their names tainted with terrorism owing to the actions of a few splinter groups during the 80s and early 90s and corrupt politicians. To assess the matter fully, I would suggest that you take your time looking at the events that occurred during this period, the individuals involved and compare and contrast these with similar occurences in our history and of course Gurbani from both Sri Guru Granth Sahib and Sri Dasam Granth Sahib to come to your conclusion. Hope this helps, A Singh.

Re: Khalistan?

stranger · 13 May 2005

if khalistan is the land of the pure - then how come Sri Desmesh Pita Guru Gobind Singh Ji did not create it???? To the admin chap - this is a genuine question - let it thru for an answer...!

Re: Khalistan?

Bijla Singh · 13 May 2005

jithhai jaae behai maeraa sathiguroo so thhaan suhaavaa raam raajae || Wherever my True Guru goes and sits, that place is beautiful, O Lord King. gurasikha(n)aee so thhaan bhaaliaa lai dhhoor mukh laavaa || The Guru's Sikhs seek out that place; they take the dust and apply it to their faces. gurasikhaa kee ghaal thhaae pee jin har naam dhhiaavaa || The works of the Guru's Sikhs, who meditate on the Lord's Name, are approved. jinh naanak sathigur poojiaa thin har pooj karaavaa ||2|| Those who worship the True Guru, O Nanak - the Lord causes them to be worshipped in turn. ||2||

Re: Khalistan?

kiran · 13 May 2005

''RAJJ BINA NAHIN DHARAM JALE HAIN DHARAM BINA SAB DALE MALE HAIN'' GURU GOBIND SINGH JI RELIGIONS CAN NOT PROGRESS WITHOUT SELF RULE (RAJJ) BABA BANDA SINGH BHADHAR WAS THE FIRST ONE TO ESTABLISH RAJJ (KHALISTAN) THEN JASSA SINGH ALHUWALIA AND THE MISLS AND THE LAST KHALSA RAJJ WAS OF MAHARAJA RANJIT SINGH. KHALISTAN MEANS SELF-DETERMINATION, SOVREIGN, INDEPENDENCE AND FREEDOM FOR THE SIKHS JUST LIKE THE KHALSA HAS DONE IN THE PAST ! [%sig%]

Re: Khalistan?

ASadana · 13 May 2005

Dear Amrita Kaur Sadana, Gur Fateh! ?? Who said anything about Amrita Kaur. The name is Aman Singh Sadana. Thank you all for your replies and helping me understand the whole Khalistan matter...btw i am For Khalistan :).

Re: Khalistan?

khalistani · 13 May 2005

veer je guru gobind singh je cud also have done a lot of things for us y didnt they just kill all the dushts of the pannth right then and now, the forfathers of people like indiara y didnt guru nanak dev je just come and make khandai da amrit? we can make a billion questions like this but they are pointless guru je is letting things happen as THEY SHUD let time takes its course let things happen properly khalsitan MUST BE MADE after an attack on harimander sahiub, u can still live under that same gov.? who still supports rss, nakli nirankari, radhaswamis, and pakhandee babai? how can a true khalsi see his guru granth sahibs sarropps burned by a country and then still love it? guru granth sahib je was BURNED that is the mist heartbreaking thing for his sikh to see a sikh of guru je can never see that when even haring nindya of guru je we take our kirpan and kill them, or we never talk to them and wat r we doing when our guru je is being BURNED, when oour maryada is being changed daily, when purtaan gurughars are being destoryed, when pakhandee babai overfolow the land of punjab the most supported by gov., when our harimander sahiubd and akal takht have been attacked, not only do we not go against this same gov, this same country, but some of us actually SUPPORT IT akaal takht was attacked on a day that soooo much sangat attends guru arjun dev jes shaheedi purab and they attack ON THAT DAY is it a coincendence that many pakhandee babai have extreme connections to india gov.? is it a coincidence that it was indira that gave nakli nirankaris visas to go to uk and oopen up dehrai? sant jarnail singh je bhindran wale clealy said i do not ask for khalistani give to us and we will take it BUT ATTACK HARIMANDER SAHIB AND YOU WILL LAY THE FOUNDATION BRICK OF KHALSTAN nanak daas mukh thay jo bolai ehhaaa ohaaa sach hovai it is inevitable now this raj will not be handed over to us we must take as guru gobind singh je says in banee without raj religion cannot survive, as guru mahraj je says in banee and people say guru gobind singh je didnt have raj they might not have made a country but they held a revolution agains ttheir tyranical gov. guru je made akaal takht higher than dehli takht y? to show the moghuals they are nothing, vaheguuru je is always greater khalistan will be made whoever opposes it even if they arent gov. is blind blind to wat is happening to sikhi right now sikhi has NEVER been like this we have neever had guru je being burnt, our relgion being attacked vicisoly bu hindu extremist groups liket he rss by changing our history, when our youth do not know punjabee, when hindi in even punjab is taught more than punjabee, when nso many thing r happening, when punjab is being pumped full of drugst o take chldren away from sikhi and to prevent them from leading a good life, punjab is being destroyed slowly it s beeing killed if people agree or not, we need punjab all our athiaas happened there it is the motherland of sikhi it will always be connected to any sikh, white, black, punjabee, anyone thas where our athiiasic gurughars r we cannot let our relgion be changed, we cannot let oru banee be hurt, we cannot let attacks on our guru maharaj happened the saddest thing is even in athiaas when ever somone wud even SAY SOMETHING STUPId singhs wud go crazy and take badla NOW we just sit there when people ARE DOING HORRIBLE THINGS, NOT SAYING when pakhandees r just sitting there, no0 one stopping them khalistan is needed for sikhis survivial we need our raj bhula chuka maf

Re: Khalistan?

truthseeker · 14 May 2005

kiran said - ''RAJJ BINA NAHIN DHARAM JALE HAIN DHARAM BINA SAB DALE MALE HAIN'' GURU GOBIND SINGH JI Theres no proof dasm patsah said this, it is not in gurbani. Source is not reliable. However in general as sikhs we do not seek kingdom or rulership, we only seek justice. Just as dasm patsah did justice against the moghuls.

Re: Khalistan?

truthseeker · 14 May 2005

sant jarnail singh je bhindran wale clealy said i do not ask for khalistani give to us and we will take it BUT ATTACK HARIMANDER SAHIB AND YOU WILL LAY THE FOUNDATION BRICK OF KHALSTAN he wanted them to attack, and in a way provoked the attack

Re: Khalistan?

..... · 14 May 2005

Aim in sikhism = to find god Is khalistan going to make it easier for you to find god? Answer is NO its not. Yes i know we are being oppressed in india,but as worldy suffering is increased spiritual bliss increases. Is fighting for justice for all people including atrocites against muslims in gujjarat going to improve your jeevan? answer is YES fighting for truth is part of sikhi and will help naam devotion. You cant blame hindu rule for sikhs cutting their hair, drinking ,smoking etc thats just kaljug. In Guru Gobind Singhs time under muslim oppression sikhism was still running strong. Khalistan will not make sikhs. Making more sikhs is not the goal in sikhi.

Re: Khalistan?

? · 15 May 2005

if sikhs want khalistan then why are so many sikhs leaving punjab to be replaced with bhaiyas from bihar. this does not make sense

Re: Khalistan?

Bhopindersingh · 15 May 2005

..... Khalistan will not make sikhs. Making more sikhs is not the goal in sikhi. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Slavery will SGPC controlled by DC and GOI will -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Is fighting for justice for all people including atrocites against muslims in gujjarat going to improve ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- you cannot give justice to your own women raped and paraded naked in 1984 in delhi riots forget about punishing those who murederd 10000 sikhs you cannot even get one hindu executed .I think you are a day dreamer

Re: Khalistan?

;;;;; · 15 May 2005

yesterday i saw many fresh immigrant punjabis on the way to my nana house and i wondered so many punjabi men have left their families wives sisters daughters sons back in punjab with no father figure to guide the family. So what is going to happen to society out there now? The same thing is happening now gujar farmers who are entirely muslim and bihari hindus come in with single men in big loads into punjab to settle, buy land and move in. A few years back an innocent gujar kuri was raped by some bad punjabis at a village school which united the still small number gujars luckily they did not do the same in retaliation. We can get carried away with equal rights and political correctness the day will not be far when gujars and biharis build up a good number to do the same back. The base of sikhi in punjab is under threat. It is not racist to mention immigration we have to think about punjabs interests. We have to wake up and help our people understand being two pennies off less is far better than loosing our families to wondering migrants. I would suggest we produce a written notofication to Jagir kaur and Akal Takhat Jathedar ji to start a relocation programe of sikhs from south india to punjab. This way sikhs stay politically safe and the foreign cultural impact is lessened. I dont understand why farmers are ready to pay bihari hindus a wage for daily chores but not a fellow sikh from the south indian bc camps who live in mud huts. I think the task in fronmt of all sikh is to first preserve the base of punjab to the best of our ability by serving the interests of punjab so it can grow strong again. then whatever waheguru wishes will take place. A lot of it is to do with changing our brain waves so we do not think about ourselves but for our land. But its very hard when people want for themself only. [%sig%]

Re: Khalistan?

..... · 16 May 2005

your daydreaming about khalistan, its not gonna happen. The very fact that you say SGPC is controlled by DC and GOI shows that we are not strong enough for our our country. Khalistan now would have a khalsa minority not majority. And would be as corrupt as india is now. Doing justice is possible its not a daydream, its within our control. Getting khalistan is not.

Re: Khalistan?

Bhopindersingh · 16 May 2005

..... Khalistan now would have a khalsa minority not majority. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Hindustan has a brahmin majority ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Doing justice is possible its not a daydream, its within our control. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- you cannot give justice to your own women raped and paraded naked in 1984 in delhi riots forget about punishing those who murederd 10000 sikhs you cannot even get one hindu executed .I think you are a day --___________________________________________________________ Getting khalistan is not WHY ISNT it the same or lets say as hard as the other _______________________________________________________ Gremans had 1700 subs under the sea sunk by the British India has 6 working subs .If india was still a colony it could never get freedom even from the England of 1945 Think how and why they got

Re: Khalistan?

bhopsi · 16 May 2005

bhhopinder singh if u think india is free your naive. read up on the deflation of property immediatly after 1947 and the reasons behind it. India is a bacha of colonisation. Nations will slowly cease to exist, Right now the global movement of people is paving way for a one big entity, globalisation started as a policy after nationhood experimenting. This is why the sulley are up in arms they know whats going to happen peera mohmed likheyah si. The time will come when even the weather is engineered. Read up on scaler technology.

Re: Khalistan?

bhopsi · 16 May 2005

by weather i mean storms, quakes,etc.

Re: Khalistan?

bhopsi · 16 May 2005

apologies should read "scalar"

Re: Khalistan?

... · 16 May 2005

khalistan would have a brahmin majority. what u gnna do to all the hindus in punjab wen u get khalistan kill them? kick them out of their own homes? war shud be against those who commit atrocites, not innocent people.

Re: Khalistan?

anon · 16 May 2005

bhopinder said - 'you cannot give justice to your own women raped and paraded naked in 1984 in delhi riots forget about punishing those who murederd 10000 sikhs you cannot even get one hindu executed' exactly the point, if we cant fight for justice, how are we gonna run a just country? Bhopinder thinks its easier to get khalistan then to do justice. Babbars have been able to put many people to justice but still havnt won khalistan.

Re: Khalistan?

kiran · 16 May 2005

TO TRUTHSEEKER IF KHALSA RAJJ IS SUCH A BAD THING WHY DID BABA BANDA SINGH BAHADUR, SIKH MISLS, MAHARAJA RANJIT SINGH ESTABLISHED IT ? I THINK IT IS THE MOST STUPID THING TO EVER SAY THAT RELGIONS DO NOT NEED SELF-RULE !!!!! WHERE WOULD THE JEWS BE WITHOUT ISREAL [%sig%]

Re: Khalistan?

manjh payara guru ko · 16 May 2005

khalistan zindabad

Re: Khalistan?

ggggg · 16 May 2005

i actually agree that sikhi should have its stan home for its well deserved growth but jews are not your ordinary smiths and johns. They have grown from their experiences. Although i see some positive signs with sikhs now but overall we are still way to disunited and power crazy to come together for a power share. I have not seen any other komb that has faced so many ghaluukaras one after the next than sikhs and i wnder why sikhs dont seem to shape up like the jews. Jews have functioned with and without israel to their credit, they are a very powerful people, owning most big companies,banking systems, financial houses, media, and political power. They are divided into three groups zionists and ordinary and orthodox jews, the zions have a lot of say in what goes on around the world, the zions are not based in israel but in the west. The secret of jewish success is their dedication, growth from experience, and unity. The ordinary and orthodox have no connections with and do not support the zions whos only aim is to dominate political power. But they are masters at that with or without israel. Jews both orthodox and ordinary, used to live in europe and russia, after the world war was surprisingly entineered by jewish contacts close to hitler ie the rothchilds Israel was created to establish a domain central to a greater one world plan by the rothchilds key player zion. This central presence is vital for new world even at the cost of 6 million. Zionism is not linked to the intesrests of jewish religion but to political doctrine. The land of israel used to belong to arab peasants but has been slowly taken away by force which is why arabs resorted to desperate measures which the world could not understand. Israel will become the central point for the new world order of the zion only as a political hold nothing to do with religion hence many wars are now taking place across the arab world and america is taking each one down like domino effect. All arab countries are going to slowly fall in the end, the process of global agenda has already taken ground in india. This is why media never reports anything that is truthful, things revolve around certain plans to make people think in a certain way. The beazati play was suddenly on a new avenue with the religious law. sikhs are probably more in number than jews let alone zions but we have problems ego chaudhar and blaming each other. It is hard to get 10 sikhs into one room and agree with each other on politicial matters. Jews do not need israel to be jews because they are a very mentally strong race and have come out on top of world scene they have bigger things under their belt that affect global policy making. Sikhs would need their own stan because we are not as smart as jews yet. [%sig%]

Re: Khalistan?

ggggg · 16 May 2005

read up on kabbala (the black majic art ) and how it has been used in political nature.

Re: Khalistan?

A Singh · 17 May 2005

What exactly has Isreal accomplished for the Jews -please assess this carefully. Also what has Northern Ireland and the crisis achieved for the Irish Catholics -assess this situation carefully as well. I am not pro-or-anti self-determination in terms of a Khalsa Raj, however Khalistan as it has been preached to date leaves a lot to be desired, and is heavily overidden by corrupt politicians, pseudo-sikh interests disguising the underlying Jat-specific themes and extreme amounts of emotion. Sikhs often like to compare themselves to the Jews and Irish, however these Groups have not achieved any amazing success in terms of political independence, have a look at your newpapers on a daily basis to see why, chaos runs amok through these areas. The quote cited above is indeed not as reliable as Gurbani itself which clears states "Raj na chao..." If we are to look at history, Banda Singh Bahadur, Jassa Singh Ahluwalia and others established Kingdoms which were a far cry away from the hate-emotion-filled demands by "some" of today's Khalistanis, also, Maharaja Ranjit Singh, didn't establish the Sikh Kingdom in a land of 5 rivers consisting only of 2, he did justice to the name and expanded the borders significantly. 1984 is a very painful episode, I personally had family involved in the crisis in Punjab and Delhi. Even looking at this issue from a historical point of view raises interesting comparisons, no one prior to the events of the 1980's ever made the Akal Thakt into their permanent residence or even a fortress, not even the Gurus or the fanatical Nihangs or the sometimes questionable Maharaja Ranjit Singh, a man otherwise known for his excesses. Similarly, the Khalsa has faced much in the way of similar Government sponsored programs in the past as well, however never has this turned into a wide-spread hatred of any particular religious or racial group, be they Mohammedan or Hindu as we see today. The Khalsa panth is 'ucha' -high and esteemed and conduct themselves as such no matter what the obstacles and are always in Chardi Kala, not crying to the world about their wounds or allowing them to get their spirits down. What is needed is for the Khalsa to return to Chardi Kala and be shasterdhari. "Har Joo Harmandir Aavagey!"

Re: Khalistan?

truthseeker · 17 May 2005

khalsa raj does not = khalistan. If you want to know how sikhs should live under tyranny read about the bhai sukhdev singh and the rest of the babbars, try an tell me that they were not chardi kala. Those singhs were sant-sipahi, fighting tyranny with the only aim was to do justice strengthened their spiritual life. If they won khalistan it would not have increased their chardi kala. (Khalistan is not going to make more chardi kala sikhs)

Re: Khalistan?

Bhopinder singh · 17 May 2005

What is chardi kala it is your imagination

Re: Khalistan?

truthseeker · 17 May 2005

daily spiritual progress

Re: Khalistan?

KHALISTANI STUDENT · 19 May 2005

KHALISTAN JINDABAD

Re: Khalistan?

? · 19 May 2005

VJK VJKF Just one question, is there neone willing to move back Punjab to help the movement???? Because it is easy for us to talk about it when we live in free societies. I knw there are goin to be responses like, one doesnt have to move back to make a change. However, how can you make a change without moving to Punjab. No matter what u do in North America, UK or anywhere else, people in Punjab will not listen to you because your not goin through what they are goin through. VJKK VJKF

Re: Khalistan?

kiran · 19 May 2005

we can support the panthic groups and the ppl in panjab !!!!!11 [%sig%]

Re: Khalistan?

khokars behead ghauri · 19 May 2005

i was reading on another forum where some guy was anti khalistani but some of the points made a bit of sense. I think we first need to tackle major problems in punjab like illiteracy, feoticide, farmers situation, water shortages, electricity and migration. i do not know what panthic groups have on their plans? but they first need to help sort out the big mess and tackle major problems there right now. we want to see educated doctors, nurses, accountants, proffesionals coming from punjab, we want feotocide to stop, we want our farmers to have a better life, water must first b distributed in punjab then into other states only if punjab is fully ok. Electricty is needed in pinds not power cuts. I kind of feel dazed when i hear avbout khalistanis talking although some of their points usually grievances religion based make sense, then go off onto a tangent, because it forgets abouty all the problems that are in punjab right now, and even to get to the point where khalistanis want to go the punjab needs to be sorted out in terms of economy, resources, people, structure, and literacy first otherwise punjab would be a huge mess. Punjabis by nature have a strong distaste for headmen, i dont think they want to sit around waiting for any sant, or special set of chosen people to arrive its like a go and get on with it attitude. But that is beinbg exploited the wrong way by some people who want to make money. If most punjabis were educated to degree levels india would depend on us it would be the other way round. We certai9nly cannot maintain current or previous lifestyles to support our future needs in a place that will need new development. Our brothers are only dissapearing from punjab because they are illiterate, then upon coming to the west they have to work as cheap labour exploited labour hands. To stop this in one go a huge education drive is needed in punjab. If the gov is failing then rich affluent settled sikhs uniting from canada america and uk to raise money for schools and colleges? how do you get someone to want to become a pilot auttronaut, leader, accountant, putting the drive and confidence into their hearts. It is people with education that will have the power qand capability to lead punjab into a strong country if thats how they wished to go. This world has something called money that most used to go after but now is a nessessacity. People need more money because demands increase, so there is a gap between the most ideal place sikhs want and human demands that need to be met inbetween. I think first sikhs should unite to face their common problems.

Re: Khalistan?

gondal baar · 21 May 2005

Under Indian agrarian policies, ridiculous land ceilings of 18 acres/household were set and agricultural prices have been historically set at 50% lower than prevailing world pricesBrahmanists are traditionally non-landowners and non-agriculturalists, so this move served to maintain the agricultural masses in perpetual poverty. Meanwhile, no such controls or ceilings were ever imposed on ownership of urban property and industries (requiring government permits/licenses for entry) and the industrial price index in India has been above the international industrial price index, thereby enriching the Brahmin-controlled State-Owned Public Sector Units (PSU's) and Industries. Over the past 50 years, such neo-colonialist policies have precipitated a massive transfer of wealth from the highly productive "Saka region" in the west (comprising Rajasthan, Punjab, Haryana and western UP ) into the hands of Brahmanists monopolizing the upper level bureaucratic machinery, the agro-industries and the wider industrial-manufacturing sector with which the agrarian sector exchanges production. The tremendous wealth generated by the "Green revolution" in the northwest has been siphoned-off through the state-run banking system and these savings diverted to fund the massive, inefficient, stagnant and corrupted state-run industrial sector.