Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

40 muktas...BEDAWA

40 muktas...BEDAWA

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 13 May 2005

[gurbani]vwihgurU jI kw Kwlsw vwihgurU jI kI Piqh[/gurbani] We have all heard the famous sakhi of the 40 Muktas, thier BEDWAWA - TU sada GURU NAHIN ateh aseen tereh sikh NAHIN... Just pause for a moment and "look" at Sikh History.... Guru Hargobind Ji's FOUR HISTORIC BATTLES... the Siksh who were "amateur warriors" fought so bravely agaisnt the Fully trained and fully equipped seasoned troopers of the Moghal Emperor and defeated them..no record of any SIKH deserting the field or running away... saying I cant fight these trained warriors... Guur Gobind Singh ji's battles at BHNGAANI, with relativley untrained recruits and about 700 Murieeds of Budhu Shah....defeated the well traiend troops of the Hill rajas and the Moghul Emperor...not a single record of any traitors or "run away soldiers"...except the Mureeds of Budhu Shah who deserted Guru ji for better pay and maybe "islamic brotherhood" of the Moghuls side.. Then all the way fast forward to Anadpur Sahib...daily battles and tough fights..sikhs continue to be shaheed for tehri beloved GURU JI...no DESERTERS..except for one DUNI CHAND who was a free loader masand and not a SIKH of Guru Ji... The FOUR Children of GURU JI faced death fearlessly, against all odds...just like Guru ji's countless Sikhs.. NOTHING could shake the RESOLVE or SIKHI of the 5and 7 YEAR old sahibzadahs...or the 80 year old mata gujri Ji... On the Field outside Delhi, daily for 7 days CONTINUOUSLY, a line of 100 Sikhs was brought out and BEHEADED/TORTURED HORRIBLY in palin view of all present....NOT a SINGLE SIKH consented to DENY SIKHE and LIVE..out of the total 760 killed this way..NOT all were Profesional soldiers..many were just ORDINARY SIKHS arrested from villages and homes..and there were even young children..YET NOT a SINGLE ONE DENIED SIKHEE. EVERY SINGLE PAGE OF SIKH HISTORY is the SAME....NO DESERTORS, NO ONE DENYING HIS SIKHEE and wanting to trade his life for Sikhee..for WHATEVER REASON... in the Prisons of Mir manuu..even LADIES, sufferrred for days and months on little food, had their children murdered in front of their eyes...BUT DID NOT DENY their SIKHEE or save their lives or theri children... THEN WHY ?? WHY ?? does a LARGE GROUP OF 40 SIKHS, "DENY" their SIKHEE right in the FACE of GURU GOBIND SINGH JI...and 'write" GURU JI a LETTER OF DENIAL and WALK OFF !!! The Entire EVIDENCE of SIKH HISTORY before and after the event goes agaisnt all SIKHEE stands for. Could any SIKH, go up to HIS Beleoved GURU JI and tell Him to his face..Look here i have had enough, the "hunger" is too much, I cant take it any more..I am going off. GOOD BYE....and they go off. And IF they have indeed taken this Giant step..a mere "mehnna maarna" by their wives in the village sets them running BACK where they then BEHAVE LIKE ALL OTHER SIKHS IN HISTORY and MARTYR THEMSELVES...... OR have we just been "fooled" into beleivieng a tale.... could these 40 Singhs been SEPARATED from GURU JI during the Mad rish to the Cross the SIRSA RIVER ( Mata Gujri Ji and the two younger sahibzadahs also got separated this way and NEVER met GURU again.... also mata Sundari ji also got separated and went to Delhi...)..and all these LOST SIKHS made their way to their villages, and then got news that GURU JI was ALIVE and thus in FOUND their way BACK to GURU and also brought along their women in the leadership of Mata Bhag kaur Ji and Jatha..and FOUGHT in the TRUE TRADITION of SIKHS at MUKATSAR and became SHAHEED Gurdwara Sahib TUtee Gandhee stands in the place of thsi battle, where the 40 Muktas met their beloved GURU JI.."Tutti gandhee" signifies RE-UNION....after the "temporary separation" totally unintentional that happened during the time of the Sirsa Crossing..everything FITS in..EXCEPT the BEDAWA...LETTER OF DENIAL OF SIKHEE...this goes 180 DEGREES AGAINST everything that Sike stands for....NO SIKH ever DENIED his GURU JI..not for this World's riches, Princesses, Jewels, Thrones, whatever..certainly Not from HUNGER of the Body. This is based on a an article by Giani surjit Singh Missionary that I read. I am putting it here for feedback from the readers. What do you think...Is it really possible for a LARGE GROUP of 40 SIKHS to tell GURU JI to His FACE that we cannot stand the hunger and so we are going off...worse WRITE GURU JI a Letter of DENIAL of SIKHEE....when ALL a SIKH ever wants to do is be a SHAHEED for His GURU JI ?? Bedawaa and sikhee dont mix.... ??? [%sig%]

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

khalistani · 14 May 2005

O MY VAHEGURU now ure sayig this is false too? man, everythng in history is just false for osme people this ssakhee shows that even after leaving ure guru je, guru e will still bless u after andt ake u back they have no vair, not hate, no grudges they are PERFECT so wat if the singhs made a mistake? they made up for it with their lives its all about the end that matters even if i commit paap my whole life, do the worst things, but then go vaheguru at the end and remeber him with pure ik chit, i can be crossed over too this is messed up man every historical souces says the did do this, and now this missonary guy comes how many years after, more than 300 YEARS after and thinks he knows wat happened who the heck is he to say thas wat happened? this sakhee is one of the best sakhee to show even if u do something bad, guru je can always forgive u one of the most tocuhing sakhees and now this guy is trying to mess our history up and hes suddenly popping out after 300 years and starts claiming he knows wat happens, no other chardi kala singh ages ago wud know and say soomthing about this eh? bhula chuka maf

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

ssingh · 14 May 2005

"NO SIKH ever DENIED his GURU JI..not for this World's riches, ... Jewels," who was left with Guru Nanak dev ji up to the end? even baba budha ji was not. This also may be a tale though.

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

Singhstah · 14 May 2005

yes i think its possible. It all runs by his hukam and maybe Vaheguroos hukam was for them to abandon guroo ji and then be forgiven later on. That would show how guroo ji forgives anyone know matter what. however im a moorakh so i cud just be talking rubbish...

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

Akaal · 14 May 2005

How did the 40 Singhs get out from the fort? How come mughals and hindu raajas didn't attack them? Mughals and hindu raajas attacked even the garbage that was taken out to show Sikhs how eveil they were. How come no attack on 40 Singhs by Mughals and hill raajs? These are also some questions that rise. Arshi Ji that article and analytical report does make sence. http://www.sikhmarg.com/2005/0508-bedava-vishora.html This is where the article is. Please take a look.

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

Bijla Singh · 15 May 2005

Greatness of Guru Ji just amazes my mind. Whenever any question came to my mind, Guru Ji gave me the answer within days. Just last week I was just thinking about this and after two days I came across the original article and my question was answered. it is a fact that Anandpur Sahib was surrounded by mughal army for nine months. Gursikhs ate wood and leaves but never left Guru Ji. Those Gursikhs were true gursikhs. Even if I assume they left Guru Ji, just how exactly did they manage to get through the army and escaped without anyone noticing them? If they did then everybody else including Guru Ji could too. Some historians try to make the sakhis more beautiful by putting make-up on them but it actually back fires and they end up insulting our glorious history. many famous sakhis such as getting pothis from Baba Mohan Ji, sending Kartarpuri Bir Sahib to Lahore and Mangat are false. not only that there was no one named Bhai Bala Ji who accompanied Guru Nanak Dev Ji. "Ik Baba Akaal Roop Dooja Rababi Mardana" no mention of Bhai Bala Ji. just my personal opinion. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 15 May 2005

This is HOW our Glorous HISTORY is being DEFACED and ADULTERATED. We have been "sleeping ' for 300 years....MORE and MORE "fake sakhis" are being created even NOW...just look at the History Books and articles, movies etc being created..History is being changed right under our noses. BEDAWAA is such a crude term....people who Give BEDAWAA right to the FACE of their BELOVED GURU....dont return so fast. THEY were just "SEPARATED" from GURU JI on that TERRIBLE NIGHT...if Guur Ji's own PARIVAAR can be separated and enver see him again...why not these 40...LOST and wandering in the jungles the enxt morning they found their way home and upon hearing that GURU JI was alive and well, they imm eduately set out again to MEET up with GURU JI and martyred themlseves at Mukatsar....this goes PERFECTLY well with our GLORIOUS HISTORY. The ONLY person to RUN AWAY from Anandpur sahib was DUNI CHAND..and the ONLY TRAITOR at SIRHIND was GANGGU...NO AMRITDHAREE SINGH who ahd already given his HEAD to GURU JI would dare to BEDAWAA HIM under any circumstances....if they were DYING of HUNGER, they would DIE of HUNGER at the CHARAN of GURU JI and not run away..like cowards. This whole episodfe of BEDAWAA is an insult to AMRIT of KHANDA BATTA. How to answer the other queries put up by Akaal... WHY did the Mughals let 40 AMRITDHAREE SINGHS ESCAPE ?? when they even looted the GARBAGE Guru ji sent out in broad daylight ?? In my Younger days this sakhi was even "used" by my "malwaii friends" to PUT DOWN the MAJHA SINGHS....hey you majhails..your ancestors "deserted" Guru Ji in His time of need..how can you be good Singhs ??? THIS MUST have been another of those famous divide and rule tricks of the Bipars..because even the "granthis and raagis" made fun of these majhails who ran away..and wrote a bedawaa...since then I have been "seriosuly doubting" this bedawaa story...a GURU JI ka AMRITDHAREE simply wouldnt do such an act..NO WAY. Khalistani veer says: 300 years//300 years... what is so great about 300 years..CANT a LIE be 300 years old ?? Cant the TRUTH come out after 400 YEARS ?? even 500 years ?? The TRUTH of 1984 STILL HAS NOT COME OUT AFTER 20 YEARS ?? We are being asked to JUST WAIT AND SEE ???

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

kaur · 15 May 2005

only waheguru knows his creation. logic is just a manmade christianised concept limited ONLY to what we percieve as right wrong. Outside our "box" there is a lot more but we have been conditioned by temporary limited maya type logic thinking due to our mundane environments and education we recieve at the hands of christian semitic value based educational institutions. Similar thing happened on Guru Nanak Jis visit to mecca debate some people would not believe mecca rotated doubting the powers of Guru Ji based on the law of logic. God is above logic he can do what he wants with the matter of 5 elements created by himself. Logic is only what a scientist has discovered a few decades back and now we become governed by a goras laws. Baba deep singhs head coming off and fighting headless may also seem illogical to some, but some research scientists in russia have found that councious energy flows through the body as opposed to just the brain functioning everything. The foreparent of the chahals or sandhus clans is also reported to have fought the turks headless after his head was chopped, when the moghuls invaded in punjab a few hundred years before sikhi came. read gurbani and dasam patshahs sacred writings such as Akal Ustat to gain a deeper understanding of creation and how Gods grand plans are, and the rahim dhyaal element of the great Guru unless we also want to start doubting dasam patshah jis writings too because it does not happen to agree with our "logic". God does not care about ritualisti empty daily lip service. But it sure does not mean desert your Guru either just as bhai gurdas ji gave examples of the reformed people does not mean we can go and do the same. may waheguru do kirpa on our blessed educated brothers and sisters doubts. [%sig%]

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

Tera jann · 15 May 2005

wow i am really glad this topic has been brough up here. i heard this version of the saakhi as well and what i was told was... us being the students of Guru Ji, our TEacher, it doesn't make sense that such a superb, wonderful, perfect, great, amazing, unique, ..and the list goes on... teacher could have students (the 40 Sikhs) that failed a 'test' given by their Teacher. that would only show the incompetence of the teacher, and by no means is Guru Ji anything less than perfecT!!! so, it doesn't make sense that a group of Sikhs gave their 'bedava' to their Guru ji... well, im just spitting out what i have heard :) can others shed some light on this please?

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

khalistani · 15 May 2005

so sudeenly after 300 yars after suddenly WE ARE SMARTER THAN AAAAAALLLLL THE GURSIKH BEFORE WHO DID BELIVE IN THIS SAKHEE??? amazing how the youth NOW knows the purtaaan maryada and sakhees better than the purtaaan singhs vaah je vaaah bhula chuka maf

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

Kulbir Singh · 15 May 2005

It is not fair to assume that all Sikhs before 1708 were perfect. At that time too just like today, Sikhs made mistakes and Sikhs faltered. I am rather surprised to hear that Giani Surjit Singh Missionary has questioned this very important event of Sikh history. What a beautiful Saakhi this is. Sikhs lost faith in bad times but Guru Sahib did not forget them. Siri Guru jee lost everything, even his four Sahibzaaday, but did not lose the Bedaawa, a piece of paper, that he saved for that great moment when Bhai Maha Singh jee begged before Guru Sahib to tear it off. When the Mughal army had a siege at Siri Anandpur Sahib, most of the town fled. Only tyaar bar tyaar Khalsa was left to fight off the enemy. As the time went by, some Sikhs inside the fort got impatient. They wanted Guru Sahib to accept the generous offers (which were false offers) by Mughals to vacate the fort. Hunger and bad times can do a lot of bad to a person. Apparently Bhai Maha Singh and about 39 more Sikhs made a strong resolution to leave the fort. Before leaving Guru Sahib told them that if they were not going to listen to him, then they should write to him that they are shedding Sikhi from this day. “Asee tere Sikh nahi tey tu Saada Guru nahi” (We are not your Sikhs and you are not our Guru anymore) is what they have said to have written. Incidentally all these Sikhs belonged to the Majha region of Punjab. We should not forget that even though these 40 Sikhs from Majha left, this does not mean that no Majha Sikhs were left inside. Reality is that from Siri Guru Hargobind Sahib’s time, most warriors have come from the Majha region of Punjab. This saakhi does not show the weakness or Majha but proves its strongness and faithfulness to Guru Sahib. When Bhai Maha Singh and others reached their villages in Majha, they faced unprecedented scorn and hatred from all people of Majha. Men, women and bazurg of Majha region had meetings with these Singhs and upon hearing that they had left Guru Sahib, they severely chided and scolded them. Mayee Bhago got so upset that she asked them to wear glass bangles. By now, Bhai Maha Singh and other Singhs themselves too realised that they had made a mistake. Even when they committed this mistake they were feeling the burden of this sin on their shoulders. Everyone can make a mistake. So what is wrong if Bhai Maha Singh made a mistake? Anyway, Bhai Maha Singh jee and other Singhs decided to go back to Guru Sahib. They marched towards Malwa region, where Siri Guru jee was at that time. We all know how valiantly they fought the Mughal army and defeated the army. All Singhs got shaheed. Siri Guru jee came to the battlefield. He went through dead bodies to find his Gursikhs. Satguru jee kneeled down by each of his son Gursikh and placed their head in his lap. He lovingly cleaned their faces with cloth and gave them pyaar. Finally he reached Bhai Maha Singh jee. Bhai Sahib was still alive. It was as if he was just waiting for Guru Sahib’s arrival. Upon Guru Sahib’s arrival, his face lightened up and when Guru Sahib placed his head in his lap, his eyes won’t stop shedding tears. Guru Sahib gave him immeasurable pyaar. Guru Sahib came into the house of full kirpa i.e. became very pleased and asked Bhai Maha Singh to ask for anything he wanted. Guru Sahib asked to ask for kingdom or anything he wanted. Bhai Maha Singh did not ask for mukti or anything else. He entreated and begged before Guru Sahib to forgive his and his companions’ mistakes. Guru Sahib said that he had already forgiven them but Bhai Maha Singh again requested Guru Sahib and asked him to tear off the Bedawa they had written. It is amazing that Guru Sahib still had the bedawa in his Kamarkassa. Siri Guru jee knew that his Sikhs would come back. He lost so many material possessions but did not lose this bedawa. Siri Guru jee took out the bedawa and in front of Bhai Maha Singh jee teared it off. The joy that Bhai Maha Singh experienced witnessing this, cannot be described. At this time Guru Sahib called them “Muktay”. Now let us ponder upon one thing. So many other Singhs got shaheed. Why did not Guru Sahib gave the title of “Muktay” to anyone else? The reality is that this event holds a very special place in Sikh history. A Sikh can always falter. Guru Sahib is the one who protects us. We must try our best but we should never get proud of our Sikhi and claim that we cannot falter. Guru Sahib kirpa rakhan. Someone here asked the question, how Bhai Maha Singh and other Singhs escaped Siri Anandpur Sahib. Well, how did Baba Binod Singh escape Gurdas Nangal? It was common for Singhs to come out and raid the Mughal forces. At night, in those days it was not hard to escape. Did not Singhs afterwards escape from the fort? So this is a lame argument that 40 Muktas could not have escaped the fort. I don’t see anything anti-Gurmat in this saakhi. This saakhi is a great saakhi and what eye can stay tearless when hearing or imagining the scene when Bhai Maha Singh jee begged for forgiveness? Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 15 May 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Veer Kulbir Singh Ji has rasied a very pertinent question...WHY "MUKTAY" ?? Yes why call these 40 Shaheeds MUKTAY.....when many more were shaheed outside Anandpur Sahib, and at Chamkaur sahib - not forgetting the elder sahibzadahs...why no one was called Mukta at the battle of Bhangani... I am writign to Giani surjit Singh ji on this point to get his viewpoint..but meantime...any others have anything to say on this. This is the way we LEARN....Guru Ji NEVER asked us or expect us to be MIttee de madho and just swallow hook line and sinker whatever we hear..or read as TRUTH...the lamest argument is flanni sakhi is so many centuries old..so it must be true....not every time. Bhenji kaur brought up some other points about baba Deep Singh ji/Vasakhi 1699 etc. Those are not in the same league as this bedawaa. Logic is not involved here..it is just history.

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

Akaal · 15 May 2005

I have been ever confused about this. How did the Singhs get out? Either way, it is fine. This is nothing much to worry about. Not a big issue.

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 16 May 2005

This whole sakhi reminds me of this shabad: bilaaval mehalaa 5 || bhoolae maarag jinehi bathaaeiaa || aisaa gur vaddabhaagee paaeiaa ||1|| simar manaa raam naam chithaarae || bas rehae hiradhai gur charan piaarae ||1|| rehaao || kaam krodhh lobh mohi man leenaa || ba(n)dhhan kaatt mukath gur keenaa ||2|| dhukh sukh karath janam fun mooaa || charan kamal gur aasram dheeaa ||3|| agan saagar booddath sa(n)saaraa || naanak baah pakar sathigur nisathaaraa ||4||3||8|| Bilaaval, Fifth Mehl: He places the one who strays back on the Path; such a Guru is found by great good fortune. ||1|| Meditate, contemplate the Name of the Lord, O mind. The Beloved Feet of the Guru abide within my heart. ||1||Pause|| The mind is engrossed in sexual desire, anger, greed and emotional attachment. Breaking my bonds, the Guru has liberated me. ||2|| Experiencing pain and pleasure, one is born, only to die again. The Lotus Feet of the Guru bring peace and shelter. ||3|| The world is drowning in the ocean of fire. O Nanak, holding me by the arm, the True Guru has saved me. ||4||3||8|| vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa vaaheguroojeekeefatheh!!!!!!!!!!!!!! [%sig%]

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

Manvir Singh · 16 May 2005

Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji, thanks for posting the Saakhi of Mukatsar Sahib. Very inspiring and moving Saakhi. Can someone please tell us more about Mata Bhaag Kaur Ji (Mai Bhago). Did she travel with Bhai Maha Singh Ji and the 40 Mukte to Mukatsar Sahib? What was her role and how does her role relate to the Chaalee Mukte. Dhan Guru - Dhan Guru Ke Piare All Shaheed Singhs and Singhnian are inspiration. Penji/Paaji thanks for posting the Shabad... very fitting shabad.

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 May 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. We had a discussion on this topic in my Gurbani Class and one of the students came up with... They are called MUKTAY....because they "were the FALLEN ONES" ( they had become BEMUKH and went away from Guru Ji)..and when they came back..GURU JI was OVERJOYED to see them Back. Just like a Father will be definitley more worried about his son who has left house in anger, and if he then returns and begs forgiveness, Father is more likley to "favour" him more or "fuss over him" than the OBEDIENT son who stayed home all this while...Uss nu Bhulla na akhiyeeah jo shammee ghar murr aiyeh.... Food for thought. Thsi is just what may have happened..Guru Ji would have been overjoyed to see the RETURN of the WAYWARD SINGHS....they were thus MUKAT ( free ) of their GREAT SIN of deserting Guru Ji...while those hundreds who NEVER deserted Guru ji in the First Place..need not be treated this way. Makes perfect sense.....eh ?? By the way this student is just 9 years old and learning Panj Granthi

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

... · 16 May 2005

For those that are against this sakhi, need to open your eyes. Kulbir Singh has nicely told the story. It makes sense that the badawa event did occur. It is amazing to see how guru ji can forgive his gursikhs.....

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

Roopkaur · 16 May 2005

I think this sakhi is one of the most heart moving and emotional sakhees in our history, and cannot imagine why anyone would question it. THe argument that how could gursikhs from that time abandon guru ji is lame. Were not the masands that guru ji burnt baagis? Duni Chand was another famous baagi. Guru Raam Das Ji's oldest son started his own guru dom because he would not accept Guru Arjun Dev Ji as his guru. The people that ran away from Vasaikhi of 1699 and called guru ji crazy, were they not baagi? When guru Nanak Dev Ji tested his SIkhs to see who would become the next guru, Only GUru Angad Dev Ji passed, many SIkhs abandoned guru ji on the way, were they not baagis? You also said how could they fail guru jis test, well all the people who did not stand up to get their head cut when guru ji asked for it failed the test. Baba Budha ji himself could not eat the dead carcass Guru Nanak Dev Ji asked them to eat. What ever happens happens for a reason in hukam, and all of our sakhis give us a lesson. One lesson we learn from this saakhi is that we all make mistakes, only guru ji/akaal purkh are abhul. But guru ji is all forgiving, deen dhyaal, gareeb niwaaz, the only one that can forgive us of our mistakes if we ask truly from our heart. Another lesson we learn is that any Sikh can falter, no matter how chardi kalaa they are, and it is only with guru jis kirpa that we have the Sikhi that we do. Instead of having maan that oh I am so chardi kalaa, one should always beg guru ji for kirpa and aseesaa because all of ones Sikhi and avastha is in the hands of guru ji. Another important part of this saakhi is the role of Mata Bhaag Kaur Ji. She led the chalee muktey back to guru ji by shaming them and making them realise their mistake. SHe fought in the battle. COmpare this mahaan SIkh to todays bibiaa, who are scared to break even a nail. Also, it is only in SIkh history that women played a role like this. How can a saakhi that offers so much sikhiaa be fake?

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

Sister · 16 May 2005

Roop Kaur bhenji is absolutely right, this sakhi makes a lot of sense and should not be considered a fake, we have too much to learn from it.

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 May 2005

Bhen Roop kaur's points: 1. Baggi....all the people mentioned..are in a different state as they were NOT AMRITDHAREE SINGHS....who received AMRIT AFTER giving their head. These 40 were AMRITDHAREE SINGHS. Prithee Chand was NOT even a SIKH....he had pretensions to being the GURU HIMSELF. Dunni Chand was NOT a SIKH/SINGH at all..he was just a TYPICAL DERAWADDI FREE LOADER ( the Deras of snats are full of such even today) at Anandpur to enjoy the great food and all that and probably got trapped by the seige. The Masands burnt by Guru Ji....not Singhs at all but FRAUDS in the guise of Sikhs. When GURU NANAK JI put up the EXAMINATION....only one passed..when GURU GOBIND SINGH JI put up the Exam..ONLY FIVE passed. The Sakhi refers to the PASSED ones....who then FAILED. The 40 had already taken Amrit and Given their HEADS...to compare them to the Masands duni chands etc is comparing oranges to grapes. The MOST IMPORTANT POINT is that 1708....and AFTER....it is RECORDED FACT wittnessed by European Visitors even that NOT A SINGLE SINGH..from age 5 - 100 FELL from his sikhi/shortchanged GURU JI by converting to Islam. Had ANY ONE...even ONE fallen in this manner to Hunger/Torture/suffering/lalach/offers of great riches/princesses/kingdoms/nawabis.... HE would have been GREAT PROPOGANDA MATERIAL for the Rulers....BUT they FAILED to get even one SINGH/SIKH/Man/Woman/CHILD to CONVERT. NOW THAT is a Totally unchallenged historical FACT that we have a LOT..LOT...LOT to LEARN FROM. Note: WE DO have a LOT to LEARN from this sakhi. NO doubts about that...but we cannot "drag" in the likes of dunni chand to prove our points.

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

hardave singh · 17 May 2005

i think i know one thing for sure that.... Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" ji love creating doubts in sikhs. How did he ever think of changing the truth and Who does he thinks he is?

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

Mr Singh · 17 May 2005

hardave singh jee why not attack the argument instead of attacking the person who made it? it ruins the debate and discussion if we start attacking each other instead of the argument made.

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

Jugraj Singh · 17 May 2005

Jarnail Singh, The author of the article is merely speculating and frankly, I'm beginning to have doubts as to your self-proclaimed status of being a Gyani since you found it even necessary to discuss this "article". EACH INDIVIDUAL has his or her own KARAMS that they must deal with. The 40 muktay also had their karams and tests that they had to go through. Surjit Singh is saying that no Singh ever faltered and the Chali Muktay were the first. This is such a stupid claim that I don't even know where to begin. Its like someone keeps claiming that the color of blood is green. How can a blind person be convinced? The crux of Surjit Singh's argument is totally false and no historical data can back-up the claim that none before the chali muktay ever abandoned guru sahib. This is foolish and nonsensical. Is there a written account of ALL Sikhs and their relationship with Guru Sahib that we should know about? The author's reasoning ability leaves a lot to be desired. >>>> signifies RE-UNION....after the "temporary separation" totally unintentional that happened during the time of the Sirsa Crossing >>>> How does tuTee ganDee imply that act has to be totally unintentional? "karmeee apno apnee, kay nairay kay door" "Gur tutee lai joreee..." I personally think this is a beautiful and moving sakhi.

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

Roopkaur · 17 May 2005

Although they were not amrit shuck from khandey dee pahul, the pre-1699 Sikhs still had naam from guru ji. Are you suggesting that Baba Budha Ji was not a total Sikh because he had not shucked khandey dee pahul? You make excuses for the other examples like the masands and Duni CHand, but the point is at some point they did fail to be guru jis Sikhs, while you suggest that NO ONE failed guru ji before the chalee muktey. This sakhi is also about passing. THe chalee Sikhs realised their huge mistake and came back into the sharn of guru ji. THey got MUKT. Is that not a pass for you? I do not see how that is a failure. Just imagine the amount of aseesaa and pyaar guru ji would have given to Bhai Mhaa Singh Ji when they tore up the vedaavaa. Becoming a bemukh and then realising your mistake and coming back into guru jis sharn is a defininate pass.

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 18 May 2005

Bhen Roop kaur jio, Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji Ki Fateh. Exactly my sentiments....as i wrote earlier about one of my studnets coming up with an explanation of WHY only these 40 Singhs were called MUKTAY...while all the others shaheeds didnt....it is Solely because they Faltered, Failed and subsequently Passed...and this explanation was sure yes with all in the class... I beleive in LEARNING..through VICHAAR... I NEVER advocate "swalloing" anything without vichaar. The silliest thing is to get an answer..Why do YOU beleive in this fallani sakhi....OH, mY FATHER told me to... or MY SANT JI said so... The ONLT thing i BELIEVE without QUESTION is what MY SATGURU...GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB SAYS...and I can proudly say that to anyone regardeless of what they think of me. I frmly beleive AFTER this solid discussion on this sakhi....me and my students are MORE IN PYAAR with this sakhi..and will be able to stand up to any questioning about it. I notice people have called me names like "self styled Gyani...etc just because i dared to raise a discussion on it... but i dont mind..thats their Karam as they have sadi it themsleves..I will NEVER raise a group of children who will BLINDLY BELIEVE in every word I teach them..and neither will i let them beleive others EXCEPT GURU JI.

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

Jarnail Singh "Gyani "Arshi" · 26 May 2005

[gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani] Those of you who can read Punjabi in Gurmukhi script....please visit Badhni.com for a good write up on this subject by Bhai Waryam Singh Ji.. What is Bedawa and what is its Objective..and Why guru Ji "allowed" this. [gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani]

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

kulmohan · 26 May 2005

One has to be kept hungry for days at a strech to know the power of HUNGER. Hunger, in the past has made shipwrecked men, lost in the sea, eat their own colleagues in turns, at times......What to talk that 40 Sikhs couldn't have given a bedawaa to the Guruji in the face of hunger. Friends let us live in Reality and let us try not to negate the known facts of History. Lets us try to come out of the illusions of glory attached around the sikh history and let us remember one thing - All that happened in the History, happened only because God ordained it that way.

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

jss · 26 May 2005

Arshi ji, i can't concur with your statement that no other singhs faltered or disobeyed guru ji in that time. i believe there's a sakhi in kalgidhar chamatkar written by bhai vir singh ji in it, Guru gobind singh ji and singhs were being attacked by opposing faujaan..and guru ji gave the singhs instructions to not leave their position, but also not to advance on the enemy if the enemy falls back... however, while fighting, the enemy started losing and the singhs didn't pay heed to guru ji's instructions of not moving forward and started chasing the enemy... by doing this, they ran into territory where there were more faujaan...then all the singhs started yelling for guru ji to help them out...but guru ji turned his horse around and started to leave the field becasue the sikhs had disobeyed him.. finally they made him stop... i believe they convinced guru ji's horse to stop and they apologized for not listening to his hukam... i know this sakhi isn't of people leaving the battlefield...but is about singhs disobeying the hukam of their guru...there are quite a few sakhis about singhs who didn't follow hukam...not every singh was perfect in guru ji's time..they were human, they faltered here and there...but with the guidance of guru ji they always got back on track....

Re: 40 muktas...BEDAWA

Bijla Singh · 26 May 2005

"It is not fair to assume that all Sikhs before 1708 were perfect. At that time too just like today, Sikhs made mistakes and Sikhs faltered." Just like today? I would like you to prove it. Give me some accounts of history. They were nothing like today's Sikhs. Your comments are very insulting. They made mistakes and faltered but it was nothing like today unless you can prove it. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh