Sikhism in the 21st Century
Indy · 15 Aug 2003
Dr Sangat Singh An Excellent Read. In the contemporary phase, Sikhism is found in Punjab in a devastated form. Parkash Singh Badal’s coming into power there in February 1997, with all the fanfare and expectations, has proved an episode. Earlier in February 1996, Shiromani Akali Dal had ceased to be a Sikh party, but one could hardly think that he will drop the issue of human rights, or finding out the truth in the form of a Truth Commission from the promised agenda of his party. He had joined Congress in 1956 when Akalis themselves had wound up Akali Dal as a political instrument. Later, he had joined Sant Fateh Singh Akali Dal. He had expounded the Sikh issues during the hey days of state militancy but one did not think that he would jettison the main issues as a hot potato. So was the case with the issue of suicides by Sikh farmers in post 1994 era, a new phenomenon in Sikhism. The question of police atrocities, though on a lower scale, and Badal’s siding with the atrocious police under the influence of his ally, Punjab’s Bharatiya Janta Party (BJP) was another point. BJP leaderhip has continued to espouse pre-1984 philosophy, without much change in its outlook. Badal has not found satisfaction on any issue agitating the Sikhs or Punjabis, but has chosen to jettison the main issues to keep himself in power. The people who were held under TADA, many of them on trumped-up charges, continue to languish in jails; some of them have died or committed suicides. The only notable feature was his falling out with Tohra, whose alignment with leftist Harkishan Singh Surjeet, his political guru, is well known. Badal’s current administration too casts its shadow over his Panthic credentials. Escapism: The spread of apostasy among the Sikh youth, to distance itself from militancy since 1994, associated in official parlance with Bhindranwale, under police and para-military atrocities, has found new proliferation since then. This is notwithstanding the medium of ardas which encapsulates Sikh history and recollects the heroic role of the common man. As of now, one finds Sikh Keshadhari parents, even holding high offices in SGPC or Akali Dal or state legislatures, with their children clean shaven. This shedding up of Keshas in Malwa is estimated at 80 per cent, except in central pockets like Bathinda, where the efforts of Giani Kewal Singh, Jathedar Damdama Sahib, have reportedly shown their results. The women there have become active agents in telling their menfolk to shed drugs and come within the Sikh principles. The apostasy in Daoba and Majha is equally bad. The urban areas too are getting adversely affected. The apostasy which was represented at 50 per cent in the college going Sikh youth in 1999 is now reported to be over 60 per cent. The position about diaspora, especially U.K., Canada and USA too is not inspiring. Fake Saints & Pretenders: Another issue that agitates the Sikh mind is spread of Sants or Sant-Babas apart from Namdharis, Radha Soamis, Sant Nirankaris. Then there are Ramgarhias who despite their orientation to Sikhism continue to owe fealty to Vishwa Karma. There were Sants in Malwa, a couple of them in Doaba and one or two in Majha, all of them aligned to Congress. Since 1994, with the spread of apostasy in Punjab their number has proliferated and shown a mushroom growth. According to one estimate there are now 250 hard core sants or sant-babas in Punjab alone, and members of Sant Samaj, who are operating all over the Punjab villages. They are doing so as agents of Congress, with few exceptions. According to another estimate, their number is far larger, as new deradars do not owe fealty to their earlier mentors. One thing is clear. They do not preach Sikhism of Guru Nanak-Guru Gobind Singh, viz, Sabad or gur-sabad - Word. Unlike Sant Attar Singh, who marshalled the Sikh people in 19th and early 20th centuries in tune with the teachings of Sikh Gurus, and administered them amrit, the present lot, firstly, constitutes a half way house towards Hinduism; secondly, they have no faith in Guru Nanak-Guru Gobind Singh, or Sikh Rehat-Maryada, code of conduct, and have their own individual rigmarole rituals which attach a person to themselves; and, thirdly, they are interested in visiting foreign countries from where they collect a lot of funds which they use to increase their clout among the Sikhs in Punjab, and mislead the people there. In terms of 17th century scenario of Sikhism, the position of Sant-Babas now is no better than that of Minas, Dhirmalias, Ram Raiyas or Handalis, etc. These days a lot Sant Samagams, in the names of known and not so well-known Sant-Babas take place in Punjab. All sorts of jathas, some of whom have formed organisations who are influenced by lucre, take part in these. The Jatha gets paid for the number of times the main kirtaniya mentions of some Sant-Baba, for instance, Sant Nand Singh ji Maharaj Kaleranwale, etc. That has become a standard practise. Though SGPC has now, after Supreme Court’s Judgement of March 2000 declaring Guru Nanak-Guru Gobind Singh’s Sikhism with Guru-ship conferred on Guru Granth Sahib as the only legitimate Sikhism, got powers to curb these Sant-Babas, it has so far not shown the will to move in the matter. The political leaders do either participate in these Sant Samagams or extend their patronage; they seek to please everybody as they have to fight political elections in Punjab! I would like to appeal to the Sikh community in the diaspora not to fall in their trap, or get out of the embrace of these Sant-Babas, shorn of spiritual content. They serve as agents to lead you elsewhere than pristine Sikhism. The role of Sikh Jathedars, whether of Akal Takht or the other two Takhts in Punjab, or of numerous granthis, pracharks or of President and numerous members of SGPC too has not been wholesome. The CONSTANTacrimony over office of President of World Sikhs Council, the organisation enmeshed in questionable funds from the diaspora, calls for dire action, at least sacking of some of the Jathedars themselves. The Sikhs had enought of such dubious characters. Aggressive Hindutva: Another notable feature of this period was blossoming of the forces of Hindutva - BJP (earlier Jan Sangh), Rashtriya Swymsewak Sangh, Vishva Hindu Parishad, etc. who aim to take Sikhism within its closer embrace. The alignment of Akalis with such forces, and their decision to change the character of Akali party into a ‘Punjabi’ party (which could be understood in certain circumstances) and completely shedding of Sikh character, could firstly, be compared to Tara Singh’s alignment with such forces like Ram Rajya Parishad in post-1947 era, and, secondly, reflected a sign of desperation at absence of an alternative. Their only hope lies in the continued weakness of such forces, but Akalis have shown a lack of awareness and intellectual dialecticism to safeguard the vital interests. The Congress, as earlier, seems to continue to pursue its Gangu Brahmin heritage, despite the presence therein of some thoughtless Sikhs. Hypocrisy: Duplicity is writ large in the existing Sikh character in Punjab - whether in political, social, cultural, or economic fields. Frankly speaking, one need not look into such characters to do any good to Panth. The religious hierarchy is very much in the hands of political elements having clout in SGPC. The leftists - communists, naxalites, even agnostics and others - who had hey day in SGPC, and infiltrated their partisans both in the religious and administrative hierarchy too, are in look out to ditch Sikhism of Guru Nanak-Guru Gobind Singh. There is degeneration all around. The scenario in the diaspora, especially U.K., Canada and USA is full of pitfalls. The spread of apostasy among the Sikhs in UK in 1960s was a matter of concern, except in certain sections, especially those coming from East Africa in 1970s. They reflected a new spirit of a middle or higher class, which had earlier mastered the English language on an equal footing. The second generation in UK or North America is seeking to meet the onslaught of modernism heroically. There is a section of leftists, Marxists and some wayward people, who are causing great harm to Sikhism by discarding their keshas, hair. There is also a section of society where both husband and wife are working, and have no time to do the plaits, or do the hair and teach how to tie their turbans. Such children when they grow up will not know much about Sikhism or Sikh maryada, code of conduct, and will be a dead loss. These sections will hang in the balance. The saving grace is that a section of Sikh youth in the diaspora is participating in the summer camps and learning about the principles of Sikhism. Also, the medium of ardas ties them to pristine Sikhism, and to Darbar Sahib/Akal Takht - a universal presence and outlook. Their parents earlier during their presence abroad broadly did the same. The Sikh community is more in need of special schools or weekend schools in Gurdwaras to imbibe Sikh principles as part of their character. There is an urgent need for placement for right type of persons both in SGPC and the so-called clergy, including Jathedars. That is not in sight. Also, the quality of Sikh leadership has deteriorated from about 1950 to its nadir in 1996-97 - elections to SGPC and Punjab assembly. These gravely hurt Sikhism. A Ray of Hope: The position in other parts of India where the community is confined to urban areas is much better. But the impact of events of 1984 and aftermath, is visible all around. The situation in Madhya Pradesh, where Sri Guru Singh Sabha movement is strong, is much better. So is the situation in Tamil Nadu, Karnataka or Maharashtra, except Nander or Hazur Sahib where the local administration has had a hand in Gurdwara administration, and where some of the Brahminical practises are prevalant. These need a rectification. So probably is the case with Patna Sahib. In Calcutta, Sikh Federation has done a good job, with emphasis on student culture. It must be understood that Sikhism, confined mainly to Punjab-Delhi before 1947, spread to other parts of India after decolonisation. This was so except in Northeast India where Sikh community has continued to exist for the last two centuries, reprehensibly without much interaction with the SGPC. Now-a-days, Gurbani is being telecast, thanks to mushroom growth of TV stations, from Darbar Sahib, Hazur Sahib (Maharashtra), Gurdwara Bangla Sahib and Sis Ganj in Delhi, apart from some other gurdwaras like those in Mumbai. There is also some times telecasts through Sant-Baba elements. A common complaint heard from youth is lack of knowledge about Gursikhi and Gurmat among parents, and their failure to impart it through short stories during their childhood. The religious hierarchy, similarly, is concerned simply with performing of their duties, with emphasis on collection of funds. There is general absence of pre-1947 type of dharmik, religious education, or dedication of teachers and granthis. The practise of youth camps, prevalent in Madhya Pradesh or West Bengal in India, has got discontinued especially in Punjab and this has played havoc. The All India Sikh Students Federation, as nursery of Sikhism, has ceased to exist. There is no sign of a movement for religious revival. Only some institutions are there to look after Sikhism, and these, though welcome, are not sufficient. Cultural Identity: In urban and semi-urban areas, the Sikh youth is indulging in inter-religious marriages. There is likely to be further decrease in Khatri and Arora segments. The caste has taken Brahminical roots among Jats, who look down upon Mazhabis. There is a state of hiss between these two sections, both ruralites. This has got accentuated. The Mazhbis are also likely targets of Bahujan Samaj Party, and schedule caste partisans who, however, have a negative approach in misrepresenting Sikhism. Already, the forces of Hindutva have gained sizeably in the Punjab countryside among the gentry. They represent that the people have passed through an atrocious phase since 1984 and the only way left out now for them was to merge their children among the ruling Hindu fold. That would make them indistict from the general body of Hinduism and serve as a saving grace. The failure of all sections of Akalis to face, much less meet, the challenge is glaring and casts its shadow. The successful blackmailing of Akalis by BJP for another Rajya Sabha seat in May-June 2001 is glaring. The Sikh population is likely to indicate a sharp fall in the Punjab. The forces of Hindutva are on the rise. The forces of pristine Sikhism lack consciousness or alertness to countermand the situation. In the words of Prof. Noel Q. King of California University, there are no barriers against such type of forces destroying Sikhism from within. That is what is happening in Punjab. My estimate of the apostate Sikhs in UK, Canada and USA is about 40 per cent of the population. Of course, there are second and subsequent generations of Sikh in Britain and North America. USA and Canada too, at the moment, have first generation Sikhs. Already, the institution of gurmat camps during summer has had a strong impact. The Sikh orientation of present day youth is many a times attributed by their parents, who originally migrated to these countries in 1960s and after, to the impact of these camps. Such camps are playing useful role in keeping the youth in harness. Such elements also have developed a strong intimacy with white Sikhs of 3HO in USA. One of the direct impact of this gurmat education or training is dropping of caste or village names by some of these young men. The main cause of apostasy have been the failure of parents to keep Sikh insignia of their children where both parents have been working; the impact of communists and pseudo-leftists who migrated from India and their alignment with the Indian National Congress and later with Indian intelligence agencies; the inability of parents to find suitable matches for their children; the designs of some extraneous elements; and the impact of modernism, to look different and loose their identity. Some times the role of bobbed women of the household has been a factor. Those children who right from their childhood fail to learn how to tie their knots and the turbans or do their plaits, are not likely to do so at the young age or later. That is also true for India. The continued merger of some of such elements in the general body of population, or losing their identity, is on the cards. There have been some cases of coming back to the mainfold of Sikhism. This is a welcome development, but this has been confined to elder Sikhs, with few exceptions. As the 21st century advances, we shall see upcoming of new generation of Sikhs in UK or North America who have little interaction, unlike their elders, with back home. They are likely to act independently. They shall have no emotional links with Punjab. Jathedar Akal Takht or President SGPC shall need to be men of a wider vision for which there seems a little chance at the moment, because of continued subservience of Sikh leadership of all hues, the activity of forces of Hindutva, and of the Indian intelligence agencies who have gained a new control in UK and Canada, though not to that extent in USA. Sikhism is under attack at the hands of Brahminical juggernaught, and history has shown that no where including the case of once powerful Buddhism, has it been unsuccessful. The juggernaut came into violent conflict with the followers of Kabir, a bitter critic of Brahminism, and a powerful factor at one time, in post-Kabir period: it forced them to fall within its framework. The Brahmins were not bothered about Kabir’s teachings or philosophy. It is such a humpty dumpty rigmarole consisting of so many hotch potch of contradictory doctrines, including agnosticism and nihilism; it did not mind about existence of another digressive sect. Now, for the first time it has come to grips with another minority, the Sikhs, and has full support of all sections of Hindu society. The commitment written by some advocates of Hindutva in the presence of Tarlochan Singh, Vice Chairman, Minority Commission, in January 2001 about independent character of Sikhism, is not worth the paper written on: Hindus can change their option at any time when they feel the need to launch next operations. People have spoken of evil designs of Hindutva forces towards Sikhism, which to them is no longer a material factor. Some signal from India, from various type of forces of Hindu resurgence with state support, which is part of life, putting Sikhism on the defensive, would prompt the Sikhs in the diaspora to assert their individuality and independence, and emerge as the dominant sector in the mainstream Sikhism. One would like some revivalist organisation, like Singh Sabha Internaitonal at Roseville, CA, and the institution of gurmat camps during summer for Sikh youth in the diaspora especially UK, Canada and USA, to get strengthened. One would like such organisations to have a closer look at the Sikh principles and imbibe the Sikh spirit. The hardcore in India shall remain there to lend them credence. To say it succinctly, the present day Sikh leadership in Punjab, in the words of Giani Sant Singh Maskeen, is arrogant, oriented towards self (haumain), and politically oriented, using religions only as a tool to achieve the objectives which stands free. The rise of spurious state-inspired militancy did the maximum, from 1986, to destroy the religious or ecclestastical order which was already dysfunctional. The Sikhs paid that much price to remove one Mahant Narain Das from Nankana Sahib. Now there is all round proliferation of those Mahants. Who will come forward to remove them? The common man is not oriented towards that; the state of apostasy makes one prone to confusion and misdirection. The rise of communist influence, and now Hindutva or Hindu resurgence, glaringly completes the cycle. Let people pay more attention to it, debate it fully, its pros and cons, and find out what is Sikhism and where it is going. The intellectuals or educated ones take part in seminars and read papers, but the impact is nil. Life circle goes on as it were, on a downhill journey for Sikhism in Punjab. There is absence of Parcharaks in the field. Renewal: I am glad to learn that some Western scholars, like Professor Arthur W. Helweg, Karen Leonard and Noel Q. King in the North America, have spoken of renewal of Sikh faith in the new world. So has been the case with England. Let us hope that the Sikh faith shall show an added energy in the new world, when there are signs of its dwindling in Punjab, unless some unforseen but dramatic activity takes place there. However, one shall need to look into the state of Sikhism in the West - North America and UK - once it declines in Punjab and to the extent it digresses from the mainstream.