Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Should we listen to raag maala?

Should we listen to raag maala?

Tarrandeep Kaur · 17 May 2005

i've got a question for the anti raagmaala people (like myself) i think that if raag maala is being read we should walk out of the darbar sahib and not listen to it. Raag maala is kuchi bani, there fore we should not listen to it; khdy kcy suxdy kcy kcNØI AwiK vKwxI ] kehadhae kachae sunadhae kachae kacha(n)aee aakh vakhaanee || The speakers are false, and the listeners are false; those who speak and recite are false. (anand sahib) However i no of people who believe that raag maala is not bani, however they see nothinwrong in sitting there and listening to it. vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

Bundha · 17 May 2005

Raagmala is suchi bani and if you deliberately walk out of darbar sahib then the Guru will turn his back on you, for good! [%sig%]

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 17 May 2005

We have to "hear" a lot of other things as well...lists of donations, appeals for donations, building funds appeals next week's Programmes.... so a bit of raagmaala is actually just that much "noise" for me... My mind goes into auto switch off mode after Slok Mh 5vaan Tera Kita Jato nahin.. and i wait for anand sahib and ardass...and eagerly look forward to a huge gaffa of degh ( no swiayah for me Thank you...I Consume all the degh I want and Guru Ji will take care of the Cholestrol and Diabetes...and of course the MUST GET..Mouth ulcers/whatever people who dont like raagmaala are supposed to get...he he he...its all Ok in that department as well...

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

hello raagmaala · 17 May 2005

it dusnt matter, usually i walk out when they read raagmaala @ the end of an akhand path then come in for the ardaas....but it dunt really matter thaattt much

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

Premi · 17 May 2005

Get a life!! All you ones that get up disturb everybody else in the sangat just to show your opposition. You remind me of Badal. Can't concentrate and don't let anyone else concentrate. Sangat is Guru Roop don't try and be hot headed there you will run into serious trouble. If you don't agree sit outside the hall, then get up on your own. Don't disturb the sangat, there bad-asees will ruin you. According to SGPC, Bhog is done as per the traditions of that area. That is the final decision at present, don't go around thinking you know everything or that you are smarter than the sangat, and that "it is my Guru......", look inside yourself and see the hatred due to this topic, what have you gained? Nothing. You wrote Fateh in Laridaar , but not the Pakee Banee you are going on about, what sense does that make? You should not be using the font then if it can't be in lareedaar. Premi

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

Admin · 17 May 2005

Benti to sangat: This thread is a question for Gursikhs who don’t believe in Raagmala. Please don’t start a debate on Raagmala under this thread. Admin

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

Kulbir Singh · 17 May 2005

99% of times, at Akhand Paath Sahib, where Raagmala is read is done from Padd-chhed saroop and Khalsa does not attend Siri Akhand Paath Sahib done from Padd-chhed saroop. I personally have never been encountered with this problem because every time I have attended a Siri Akhand Paath Sahib from Laridaar Saroop, Raagmala was not read. It is sad that our pro-Raagmala veers who were once the biggest proponents of Laridaar Saroop have now given up this stand. Summing it up, I personally would avoid listening to Raagmala in the end of Siri Akhand Paath Sahib. It does not look good to get up when Raagmala is read. Therefore, it is best to avoid being around at the bhog time, when it is expected that they would read Raagmala. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

just me · 17 May 2005

I think it is abit petty getting up and walking of if you do not believe in raagmala. You will miss the ardas. I will never believe in raagmala, but have felt harmed by listening to the granthi singh reading it. I think it is important to be part of the ardas afterwards.

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

Tarrandeep Kaur · 17 May 2005

i agree with you bhai kulbir singh, but i was attending a kirtan programme, and the next thing i know raag maala is being read, so i didnt get a chance to 'avoid being there'.

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

AMRIK SINGH · 17 May 2005

funny thing is i never have believed raagamala, and the programme Tarrandeep kaur was at i also was at, and in my mind i kept asking guru ji is raagmala really bani? lol i dont wat came over me... then all of a sudden the hukamnama came out vaho vaho bani nirankaar he tis jevad avar na koi... LOL i was like whaaaaaat!? but then i realised this hukamanama could mean alot of things... maybe guru ji is saying vaho vaho bani nirankaar heh (only siri guru granthi sahib up to mundavani mahala 5 and salok amhala 5) tis jevad avar na koi (raagmala). Or maybe guru ji is saying why u bother with raagmala when u can jaap naam... i took amrit and tell u the truth im no way at a spiritual level yet and to waste time debateing thinking about raagmala is useless. hopefully 1 day i will do a sehaj paath, maybe then ill ask guru ji agen shall i read raagmala... hope i never sed anythig bad wjkk wjkf

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

ss · 17 May 2005

i didn;t know raagmala would be so bad to listen to , looks like it's even worse than normal talk and chit chat. normal talk and chit chit is kachi bani, do kulbir singh and jarnail singh cover up their ears while listening to noraml people talking too? this is pure brahmnism, it's clear that from the akal takht it was decided within the panth that you can read if you want or don't read it, there is no need to make a big fuss. And what we do 50 years later nothing, we don't progress but just keep carrying with the same useless debate.

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

... · 17 May 2005

wjkk wjkf amrik singh, since you have taken amrit, shudn't the panj pyare have told you whether to read raag maala or not???

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

Singhstah · 17 May 2005

i dont walk out i just start doing simran, and try my best no to listen to any of it.

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 17 May 2005

Vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa Vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!! Guru pyaaree saadh sangat jee, you have inspired this moorakh to post.. but I have no knowledge. Please forgive me if i am out of line, but here goes..... Although Sant Baba Jarnail Singh jee Khalsa Bhinderanwale believed in the authenticity of Raag Maala as Gurbani, he never forced anybody to read it - in fact (correct me if I am wrong), he discouraged his nephew from forceably having it recited at the places where it was not being read. That is the sign of a Gursikh. He was waiting for a resolution from the Panth. He did not see himself higher than the Panth. I think that a true Gursikh has nimarta first to his Guru, to follow his Guru's hukam, and second to his Guru's Khalsa. If a fellow Guru's Sikh is reading Raag Maala, and you believe that it's not authentic, then you should have enough respect and nimarta in your mind for that Gursikh, to forgive them (if you think they are wrong) because you have many many faults in your own mind. Getting up and leaving the sangat is a distraction, and it is against maryada to get up and leave from the program before the ardas. Getting up before ardas is also seen as disrespectful to Guru Sahib. A Gursikh who purposely avoids being "around" when Raag Maala will be read is missing the anand of the Mahala 9 Saloks and Mundavani. Furthermore, the anti-RaagMaalaa Gursikh who purposely stands outside of a darbar to avoid listening to Raag Maalaa is not getting Guru Sahib's khushee by making Guru Sahib's pro-RaagMaalaa gursikhs upset. If you believe Raag Maalaa is not authentic, you should have enough patience and self-control to write letters to all of the panthic sansthas and request that they organize a Sarbat Khalsa. This issue has become a Sarbat Khalsa issue, and our small, insignificant brains are not comparable to the Sarbat Khalsa. Re: Bhai Kulbir Singh jee's comment about Larivaar. There is a Singh in Vancouver who is a very chardee kalaa singh and he spent most of his youth learning at Dam Dami Taksal. He teaches santhiya only in Larivaar. He does Gurbani ucharan from Larivaar suroop, and same with Akhand Paath seva. There are Larivaar suroops read by Taksali Singhs and Raag Maalaa is read there too. If it is not Gurbani - that is something for Sarbat Khalsa Panth to decide. But please do not make a "blanket statement" that pro-RaagMaalaa veers are anti-Larivaar, as that is not true !!! There is also another very ChardeeKalaa Gurmukh in BC who has darshan of Guru Sahib and he is a total Naam-abhyaasee. He has seen with his own eyes, the darshan of sach khand and he said that Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh jee and Sant Baba Gurbachan Singh Jee, in the darbaar of Vaaheguroo, have so much pyaar amongst each other. Please stop this generation of vair-virod and eeirkha. Our whole generation has grown up with this tension and none of the past Gurmukhs advocated this "get up and leave because they are Manmukhs" type of attitude. Raag Maalaa is not a lustful song, nor does it contain anything against Gurmat. Even if you think it is not Gurbani, does not mean that you should get up and leave. If somebody is doing something strictly against Gurmat, especially violating somebody's rights, of course you should stand up and do something. But for the issue of Raag Maalaa, if it is Gurbani or not, you should allow the Guru Khalsa Panth to decide - whenever they do. You should not get up and leave while it is being recited. That is not the best way to show your respect to Guru Sahib. If you are so convinced that Raag Maala is not Gurbani, rather than disturbing the sangat by leaving, or missing Salok Mahala 9 and Mundavani by "not being around," you should sit quietly and listen intently to whatever you feel is Gurbani, and then do simran during whatever you think is not Gurbani, and in the ardas - do an ardas for forgiveness on behalf of the paathee Singh for any mistakes. Sometimes people in the jatha even leave the stage if a bibi without a keski comes and sits on the stage. I'm sorry Khalsa jee, I didn't know that bibi's who don't wear keskis have the ebola virus !!!! Even I believe that Keski is kakaar and even I have got pesh in the jatha, but sometimes this type of self-righteous behaviour is too much !!!! These type of actions don't show that you are strict or a good Sikh. Being a strict good Sikh shows in those dark morning hours, when people like me are hitting the "snooze" button and not waking up until 7:15am. I do not qualify as a Gursikh because I miss amrit vela. If I started to walk out during Raag Maalaa and get away from the stage when a non-keski bibi comes, that would make me a worse person, not a better Sikh. To be a better Sikh means following the fundamental hukams of Guru Sahib. Something that moorakhs like me are still learning. Khalsa jee, please forgive me for talking so much - but these "my side against your side" arguments are really hurtful. these are just my views and I think if we ever want ekta, we first need to accept that Sarbat Khalsa is wiser than us. A Taksali Singh has no right to get up and leave if there is a lecture about Keski as kakaar. That Singh should just be humble and listen, and have faith in Guru Sahib to bless him with bibek budhee. Same way, a Jatha Singh should not get up and leave during uchaaran of Raag Maalaa - instead should just sit and be humble and listen, and have faith in Guru Sahib to bless him with bibek budhee. please forgive my mistakes and forgive me for being a pakhandi loser. Vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa Vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!!!

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

.fg · 17 May 2005

what is the definition of kachi bani? are bhai gurdas ji deeaa vaaraan or bhai nand laal jee deeaa vaaraan kachi bani? should we walk out when theyre being read?-which they are....daily.., in darbar sahib.

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

kd · 17 May 2005

can u walk out when raagmala is being discussed..not because you bleev one way or another, jus to avoid having to listen to such discussions untill you are a gurmukh and able enough to judje for yourself? i agree 100% with amrik singh-why bother with raagmala when you can jap naam. once you have become a tru gursikh then you will know the answer for yourself and will not need to take part in such discussion.# not that i am anywhere near this stage. we should stop talkin...and start acting :). dayum i wish i could follow my own advice meanwhile if you want to read it then by all means do..and if you dont then dont. vjkk vjkf

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

ask the panj piyare · 18 May 2005

mmmm i agree with '...' amrik singh, if u have taken amrit the the panj piayre wud have told u wether to read it or not. if they didnt, ask them, they will give u the answer. the answer they give you, u shud jus accept it and leave it at that. then concentrate on naam and stuff.

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

AMRIK SINGH · 18 May 2005

u dont take amrit to find out wether raagmala is bani. why dont i ask guru granth sahib when i start doing sehaj paath. i rather ask the panj piyare how they reach there dusam duars and stuff, there more to life then raagmala

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

ask the panj piyare · 18 May 2005

mmmmm yes but u wer sayin that at the kirtan u wer thinkin about wether raag maala is bani or not. therefore ur mind was distracted bcos of raag maala. u shud ask guru gobind singh jee (panj piayre) for the answer, wether it is bani or not, then u can accept ther ansa. and let ur mind concentarte on naam and stuff. yes there are more important things in life than raag maala. but gurbani is very important in sikhi, its important to know what is and wat isnot gurbani. u shudnt listen to kuchi bani as quoted above; '' [gurbani]khdy kcy suxdy kcy kcNØI AwiK vKwxI ][/gurbani] kehadhae kachae sunadhae kachae kacha(n)aee aakh vakhaanee || The speakers are false, and the listeners are false; those who speak and recite are false.''

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 18 May 2005

Kachi bani.....is NOT BANI....it is the typical two liners that the snat types always use in their Diwans ( reasons best known only to themselves) Examples of kachi bani... Raab milda ghreebee daveh.... Oiyeh raab milda greebeeh daveh... SIngh baithe jee guraan de charnee, guraan de charnee....Singh baithee jee..... Wataan lamiahn..kandha raet dian..oiyeh kharach palleh na baniyah...Bandiaya.... kharach palleh na baniaaah... The entire Diwan will Keep on REPEATING these two liners for a full Hour or even MORE, interspaced with some Kachi Sakhi, miracle performed by the Sant's Waddeh baba Ji...Maharaj ji deKAUTAK..whatever..and some more repetitions of the two liners... Boloh Ji...Guraan de charnee guraan de charnee..Singh Baithe jee ..etc Blah blah blah. This is DIRECTLY RELATED to these people's INABILITY to LEARN GURBANI/GURMAT SANGEET or "waste time" learnig all thsi when just TWO LINERS will do just as well..WHY BOTHER spending time learnign Gurbani and Gurmatt sangeet ?? Attached is a missive from another net regarding this PRACTISE which I beleive began with SANT ATTAR SINGH MASTUANA.. the author writes: Gur fateh, It is right that the introduction of Kachian Dhaarnas was done by Sant Attar Singh Ji as he himself was not conversant with Gurmat Kirtan system .Therefore the mushrooming of Sants using kachian Dhaarnas was a real set back to the parchar of Gurbani Kirtan .The Gurbani sys as "Gun Gobind gavahu sabh har jan ; rag ratan alaap , kot janam ki trisna nivarian rasayen aatam dhraap I (Bilaval M:5 P821).`, Then again "Paanch bajitra karai santokha saat sura lai chaalai " (Ramkali M:5 P885), "Dhan soa raag sulakhnai , alaapat sabh tikh jaey " (Var Ramkali M:5 P958),"Rag naad sabh sach hai kimat kahai na jaey,raagai naadai bahra eni hukam na bujhiaa jaey ( Slok M:4 P815) "Bilaval tad hi keejiai jab mukh (guru) hovai naal , Raag naad sabad sohnai ja lagai sejh dhiaan " Therefore the bani very forcefully and emphytically says that the gurbani leaves its real impact only if sung in the specific raag of the time . For example if the doctor prescibe to take a medicine with juice , it must be taken with juice and it may not give the right effect if taken by goat milk .The Lot of these Sants was an illiterate lot and could not endeaver to learn Gurbani sangeet .The gurbani sangeet is not a very dificult system to learn but only the singing of sabad should be within the set sur notes of the particular raag .The kirtan may not have real alaap and taans of that rag in it as usually famous ragis do , to the depth of a raaga .I remember a Kiratn by Baba Ishar singh Rarewale at Ludhiana Rakhbagh when he was singing a Dhaarna " Rab milda gribi daavey " and the Bibis at the end of pandal was singing ; " Rab mircha khareebi javai " I have no constraints in saying that the Dholki chimta and harmonium system of Kirtans using kachian Dhaarna have just created a Cobra BEEN taste instead of sabad leaning . adsmangat .[..END OF QUOTE.] Jarnail Singh

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

anonsingh · 18 May 2005

amrik singh said - why dont i ask guru granth sahib when i start doing sehaj paath who do you think you are, are you trying to test guru granth sahib by asking whether ragmala is bani? what makes you think you have enough gyiaan to understand what guru granth sahib says?

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

AK SANTALEE · 18 May 2005

This is my view of Sitting in or out of Raag Malaa. Basically check this out! Raag malaa should be listened to. Dhur Ki Bani! On this thartee right now, only Brahm Giannis know everything! They know the knowledge of Waheguru; Hence Brahm da Gian Now even our 5th Guru has given them a staggering level in Sikhi by devoting 1 whole astpadi in the Sukhmani Sahib to them. This Proves how high we should class them in terms of inspiration and guidance. ALL BRAHM GIANNIS AND TAKSALI JATHA's ACCEPTED RAAG MALAA AS BANI. The Late Sant Baba Thakur Singh Ji and Sant Baba Jarnail Singh Ji all read and sung all verses of our Guru. Not only are you questioning your DHARAM but you are also questioning the Brahm Gianni knowledge by not reciting and accepting the Raag Malaa! Boleh So Nihaal!! SAT SRI AKAAL IK O ANKAR! >>>> ATHARAA DAS BEES! Waheguru ji ka Khalsa!!! Waheguru ji ki Fateh!

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

LOL · 18 May 2005

AND WHO ARE YOU TO SAY WHO IS BRAHM GYANI AND WHO IS NOT? WHAT MAKES THE PEOPLE YOU NAMED AUTOMATIC BRAHMGYANI? THEY DONT HAVE A LINEAGE BACK TO GURU JI IT STARTED WITH SANT SUNDAR SINGH EVERY SCHOLAR KNOWS THAT! A BRAHMGYANI IS GUPT THEY DO NOT ADVERTISE THIS FACT TO THE WORLD! STOP MAKING A MOCKERY OF THIS CONCEPT OF BRAHMGYANI!

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

ddd · 18 May 2005

lol.anon singh.u msut be amazing...u dont have any questions that u mite want to ask guruji...or any gaps in your understanding of sikhi..or more generally life. when one reads a sehaj paath hana, these questions which are in your thoughts already, are answered.i mean, in terms of raagmaalaa which is not half the massive deal that everyone makes it out to be in comparison to ther things and devlopments we must undergo, if that is a question you have, then you will find the answer through guruji.Its very insiginifcant but made very significant. in fact you probably wont veen need to know the answer-it prob wont matter to you.i dno wow.anon singh if you dont have any questions to ask then...you must know everything already.vaah plus-"what makes you think you have enough gyiaan to understand what guru granth sahib says?"- quite harsh dont you think?-isn't it an aspect of sikhi to control haumai and krodh?not that i dont have truck loads of them myself. what i mean is who really in this world has enoguh gyaan to know what mahraj jeeo is saying.if we did then we wouldnt even b bothering with these discussions..and if i rele understood i prob wouldnt b sitting here infront of this computer screen or reading through forums to find answers which dont matter, i'd be looking in gurugranthsahibji to find answers to questions which do. sorry if i dont know what i'm talking about.and i wish i practised what i preach.vaheguru ji ps. ak santalee are you taksali by any chance lol. [%sig%]

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

AK SANTALEE · 18 May 2005

IM just trying to be a sikh people! OK OK OK! MR LOL!: are you QUESTIONING that BABA THAKUR SINGH JI WASNT A BRAHMGIANNI?!?!?! LOL! my loord! 1st your saying that RAAG MALAA ISNT BANI. and now your SAYING; "BABA THAKUR WASNT A BRAHM GIANNI". firstly; baba thakur singh ji never said they themselves they are a brahm gianni sant jarnail bhindrawale acknowledged this fact that baba thakur singh ji had supreme powers. INFACT!: baba thakur singh ji told sant jarnail singh ji that they did not have enough bhagti under their belt to carry forward the sikhs through 84! dayum lol no point arguing. i guess we'll find out who's right when we die :D if you dont wanna believe the brahm gianni's....i guess the jam doots will teach u :P lol..joke.

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

Singh · 19 May 2005

for goodness sake, ''so and so was a bhram gianni so he must be rite'' why not use the facts and u'll get the ansa. raag maala is not bani, just accept it. (i dnt wanna start a raag maala debate). and yes i agree with 'ask the panj piayre', amrik singh u say raag maala doesnt mata- u r rong. raag maala is kuchi bani, by it bein in the guru granth sahib jee, it is beadbi of guru jee, therefore it is an important matta. if guru grath sahib jee, doesnt matta to you.............

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

anonsingh · 19 May 2005

ddd-when one reads a sehaj paath hana, these questions which are in your thoughts already, are answered ppl hav done sehaj paaths and taken hukamnamas which i interpret as saying ragmala is not bani, but others have interpreted as it saying ragmala is bani.

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

anonsingh · 19 May 2005

a bram gyiani would not respond to people calling them 'sant' or 'santji' as they see themselves as quite the opposite

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

NEUTRAL SIKH · 19 May 2005

FORGET about who you THINK is/isnt a bramgyiani. FORGET about JATHABANDHE, AK SANTALEE you clearly are TAKSALI as you are only mentioning taksali sikhs who you think are bramgyiaanis, FORGET ABOUT taksal is right akj is wrong (vise versa) mentality. LOOK AT THE FACTS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! FACTS = TRUTH = SIKHI

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

AK Santalee JR · 23 May 2005

WJKKWJKF!! Well said by my older bro... AK SANTALEE totally ripped it up with his posts! To the Anti-SREE RAAGMAALAA ppls out there, answer these questions... IS GURU SAHIB THE KING OF KINGS? ARE THEY ALL KNOWING AND ALL PREVADING? If your Answer is YES to both questions then do you really believe that the KING OF KINGS the ALL KNOWING and ALL PREVADING SATGURU will allow KACHI "PORNOGRAPHY" to be inserted and read within their Divaan?? DO U HAVE NO FAITH IN YOUR GURU WHATSOEVER?? Get real and start to imbue the Lords Simran and Bani within your hearts you will then understand and realise that Nimrata comes first. Humbly accept SREE RAAGMAALAA and then the World can start to live in peace! WJKKWJKF!! Dhan Dhan Satguru Sahib Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj!! Ik Oankar - Atharah Das Bees 4 LYFEEEE!!! :D Bhul chuk maaf, dun mean to offend...plz do Ardas for the World... NANAK NAAM CHARDIKALA TERE BHANE SARBAT DA BHALA!!!!!

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

NEUTRAL SIKH · 23 May 2005

ragmala is not found in all birs many birs without ragmala in were burnt most puratan birs with ragmala in also contain many other miscelaneous scriptures such as ratanmala if you accept ragmala, do you also accept ratanmala? I have faith that my GURU IS PERFECT , RAGMALA has IMPERFECTIONS - to start with the NUMBERING SYSTEM is completly WRONG. If you had faith that your guru is perfect you cannot accept ragmala.

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

G · 23 May 2005

Dear AK Santalee JR, You are probably a young Singh full of lots of energy and excitement for Sikhi. It makes us happy to see youth with so much passion for Sikhi. You clearly have a very strong belief on the Raagmala issue amongst many. However, since you have done no research, you are wrong. If you look at old Birs of Guru Granth Sahib Ji, you will find that in many of them, possibly even the majority of them, there is Kachi Bani at the end - even after Raagmala. eg/ Rag Ramkali Ratanmala. Such a composition was unanimously removed by the Sikh Panth in the early to mid 20th century, along with many others. Raagmala is not Pornography but rather is part of an erotic story. Please re read Kulbir Singhs post and answer his question. You claim if we all accept Raagmala we will live in peace. To the contrary, Sikhism has been on a slippery slope downwards ever since Jasbir Singh Rode forced the reading of Raagmala at the Akal Takht. So your argument is invalid. Daas, GSD

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

Search For TAT · 23 May 2005

Ak SANTALee has only demonstrated his fundmaentalist taksali views. As soon as you start having a sensible conversation, someone comes up with this rubbish. Firstly your whole argument is false. There was kacchi bani considered part of the Guru granth Sahib, and it came before raagmala. It was called rattan mala and other compositions. Even the Taksalee leaders and sants accepted it should be removed and it was! Did they not have faith in Guru ji? So your own so called brahmgianis accept people have tried to manipulate the Guru Granth Sahib. The number system does not allow this, but anyone can add somethinga t the end. The fact that it was before raagmala also questions the validity of raagmala. lastly your arguments about baba Thakur Singh. When people have lost the debate they bring personalities into it. How shameful? Many people do not accept Baba tahkur Singh as a brahmgiani, if they did taksal itself would not be fighting over whether Sant jarnail Singh should be called shaheed or not? So before pointing fingers in outrage about people questioning your brahmgianis views, look inside your own house!

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

raag maala is not bani · 23 May 2005

xcuse me but wat about rattan mal and recipies for ink, they wer put into the guru grath sahib jee, but they were taken out. so kuchi bani was put into guru granth sahib jee, but THEN IT WAS REMOVED. raag maala is NOT bani. it is beadbi of guru granth sahib jee, to alloe kuchi bani to say in the guru grath sahib jee.

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

AK Santalee JR · 23 May 2005

WJKKWJKF!! Do you think that we are going to go the rest of our lives with a Guroo that is "KACHI" I dont think so! Wake up! As for your views on Sant Baba Thakur Singh ji thats up to you...no one can change your opinion but EVERY JATHA ACCEPTED THEM AS A SANT all except the "MAN MADE ONES!" WJKKWJKF!!

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

G · 23 May 2005

Conversely, Mr Santali, how do you think Singhs of the 18th, 19th and early 20th centuries coped with Maharaj's Saroops containing material that even you do not consider as Bani? Please think intellectually for a moment. Rise above the group politics, and use your Guru-given intellect. Daas, GSD

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

NY Singh · 23 May 2005

AK Santalee jr, Taksal and other groups that claim to have a lineage to Guru Gobind Singh Jee are also man made as SGPC, AKJ, Missionary, and akalis are. Although many groups claim to have lineage dating back to Guru Jee, but none of those lineages are have any hard evidence to be factual enough to be supported by Sikh scholars. They are more fairy tale then fact. [%sig%]

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

indy · 23 May 2005

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa best comment came from this singh/singhni. We have no eekta or humility as a panth, how are we going to be strong when we need to be, when we are fighting over petty things like this. However strongly someone feels about Raagmala, the next person will think just as strongly against it. Wait for a decision from the Panth (Sarbat Khalsa) until then we should be more humble and be ready to pick up a Gutka Sahib not a Kirpan. Apologies for any offence to anyone.

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

Bijla Singh · 23 May 2005

Stop fighting like two cats while a monkey (GOI) is eating up our roots, history, language and culture. If you really care about GuruBani then do something about bhanoo moortee and dehdhari pakhandees. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

Admin · 23 May 2005

topic closed.