Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

What is Bibek ?

What is Bibek ?

kulmohan · 17 May 2005

Bibek = Vibhin (Different) + Eik (Same or One) Bibek = All are One Bibek implies :- Same GOD in everyone. 'Ghat Ghat mein har joo basey' but unfortunately we have been lectured many a times on 'Bibek' and we take the term 'Bibek' to mean as a differentiator, as something that creates difference of Religious high-Religious low, Sarabloh-Otherwise, Jootha-Sucha, Amritdhari-Nigura, Superiority-Inferiority Bibek is emphasised by the gurbani as below "Na ko bairi nahin begana sagal sang hum ko ban aayi" "Bura bhala ko kis ko kahiyey , sagley jee tumhaarey" "Na ko mera dushman rehya, na hum kis tey bair aayi" My dear friends, if we people give up the old meanings of 'Bibek' - ones that create divides and accept the new and actual meanings of 'Bibek' - ones that unite, I can bet we would be better Off. Any secondees for this definition of Bibek ?

Re: What is Bibek ?

singh · 17 May 2005

if all are one.. then are we allowed to eat from a mona or nirguras hands? when shud 1 start doing bibek.. im already amritdhari i dont do it when in my lifetime shall i start?

Re: What is Bibek ?

Roopkaur · 17 May 2005

Very creative but this is not what bibek means. Bibek means to discriminate. A sikh must always discriminate and think about what he or she does. Mahaan Kosh also says that it means to drir the rules of SIkh dharm, of which dietary discrimination is one aspect. THere are many other bibeks as well, for example the bibek of wearing banaa all the time etc. It also means a religious decision. Nothing related to what you were trying to suggest.

Re: What is Bibek ?

Kulbir Singh · 17 May 2005

If all are one, then why become a Sikh. Stay what you are. Smoke, drink, eat meat and do other bad things. What difference does it make when all are one and are children of God? And Kulmohan jeeo, where did you get this meaning of Vibhin + Eik? The original word is Vivek and not Vibhek. Your etymology is all mixed up. I think you are confusing this word with some other word. Kulbir Singh

Re: What is Bibek ?

Sukhjit Singh · 17 May 2005

I agree that we must unite mankind from separating good qualities from bad qualities. If everyone follows gurbani than we can all unite under the kesri nishan sahib!

Re: What is Bibek ?

Singh · 17 May 2005

Babek does NOT mean 'all for one' or 'one for all'. The definition that you have given of Babek is in fact the motto of the ‘three musketeers’ (“all for one and one for all!”). ‘Vavek’ is the root word of the term ‘Babek’, and it means discrimination.

Re: What is Bibek ?

thought? · 18 May 2005

mmmmmm i was told bibek meant 'thought'

Re: What is Bibek ?

Princess · 18 May 2005

Veer Kulmohan Singh jeeo, here are full shabads from which you chose punkties to derive the new meaning of bibek. After reading whole shabad, anyone can tell that it does not talk about bibek at all. These shabads are explaining different states of spirituality. Bibek and enmity are two totally irrelavant topics. By quoting these punkities you (innocentaly or knowingly) try to mislead not only bibeki Gursikhs but also disregarded and belittled Guru jee's hukam of bibek. Please read these shabads before jumping to conclusion: [gurbani]kwnVw mhlw 5 ] ibsir geI sB qwiq prweI ] jb qy swDsMgiq moih pweI ]1] rhwau ] nw ko bYrI nhI ibgwnw sgl sMig hm kau bin AweI ]1] jo pRB kIno so Bl mwinE eyh sumiq swDU qy pweI ]2] sB mih riv rihAw pRBu eykY pyiK pyiK nwnk ibgsweI ]3]8] Awsw mhlw 5 ] qUM ivsrih qW sBu ko lwgU cIiq Awvih qW syvw ] Avru n koaU dUjw sUJY swcy AlK AByvw ]1] cIiq AwvY qW sdw dieAwlw logn ikAw vycwry ] burw Blw khu iks no khIAY sgly jIA qum@wry ]1] rhwau ] qyrI tyk qyrw AwDwrw hwQ dyie qUM rwKih ] ijsu jn aUpir qyrI ikrpw iqs kau ibpu n koaU BwKY ]2] Eho suKu Ehw vifAweI jo pRB jI min BwxI ] qUM dwnw qUM sd imhrvwnw nwmu imlY rMgu mwxI ]3] quDu AwgY Ardwis hmwrI jIau ipMfu sBu qyrw ] khu nwnk sB qyrI vifAweI koeI nwau n jwxY myrw ]4]10]49] DnwsrI mÚ 5 ] kir ikrpw dIE moih nwmw bMDn qy Cutkwey ] mn qy ibsirE sglo DMDw gur kI crxI lwey ]1] swDsMig icMq ibrwnI CwfI ] AhMbuiD moh mn bwsn dy kir gfhw gwfI ]1] rhwau ] nw ko myrw dusmnu rihAw nw hm iks ky bYrweI ] bRhmu pswru pswirE BIqir siqgur qy soJI pweI ]2] sBu ko mIqu hm Awpn kInw hm sBnw ky swjn ] dUir prwieE mn kw ibrhw qw mylu kIE myrY rwjn ]3] ibnisE FITw AMimRqu vUTw sbdu lgo gur mITw ] jil Qil mhIAil srb invwsI nwnk rmeIAw fITw ]4]3][/gurbani] Now here are shabads through which Guru Sahib jee orders us to be bibeki and these shabads explain the correct meaning of bibek. Veer jeeo, Gursikhs are trying to follow the hukam of Guru jee, why do we need to do nindya if we don't have enough knowledge about Gurbani? The following shabads is straight-forward. No one can interpret it another way. [gurbani] iblwvlu mhlw 5 ] pwxI pKw pIsu dws kY qb hoih inhwlu ] rwj imlK iskdwrIAw AgnI mih jwlu ]1] sMq jnw kw Cohrw iqsu crxI lwig ] mwieAwDwrI CqRpiq iqn@ Cofau iqAwig ]1] rhwau ] sMqn kw dwnw rUKw so srb inDwn ] igRih swkq CqIh pRkwr qy ibKU smwn ]2] Bgq jnw kw lUgrw EiF ngn n hoeI ] swkq isrpwau rysmI pihrq piq KoeI ]3] swkq isau muiK joirAY AD vIchu tUtY ] hir jn kI syvw jo kry ieq aUqih CUtY ]4] sB ikCu qum@ hI qy hoAw Awip bxq bxweI ] drsnu Bytq swD kw nwnk gux gweI ]5]14]44] pauVI ] Bgqw qY sYswrIAw joVu kdy n AwieAw ] krqw Awip ABulu hY n BulY iksY dw BulwieAw ] Bgq Awpy myilAnu ijnI sco scu kmwieAw ] sYswrI Awip KuAwieAnu ijnI kUVu boil boil ibKu KwieAw ] clx swr n jwxnI kwmu kroDu ivsu vDwieAw ] Bgq krin hir cwkrI ijnI Anidnu nwmu iDAwieAw ] dwsin dws hoie kY ijnI ivchu Awpu gvwieAw ] Enw KsmY kY dir muK aujly scY sbid suhwieAw ]16] "siqgur bwJhu guru nhI koeI ingury kw hY nwau burw " "swkq sMgu n kIjeI ipAwry jy kw pwir vswie ]" "kbIr sMgiq krIAY swD kI AMiq krY inrbwhu ] swkq sMgu n kIjIAY jw qy hoie ibnwhu ]93]" "kbIr swkq sMgu n kIjIAY dUrih jweIAY Bwig ] bwsnu kwro prsIAY qau kCu lwgY dwgu ]131]"[/gurbani] So, veer jee, should we listen to you or our Guru Sahib jee? [%sig%]

Re: What is Bibek ?

kulmohan · 19 May 2005

Ok, I accept that people forever will continue the 'Bahmanwaad' or 'Bipran ki reet' of creating a divisive society. Earlier ours was a society divided on caste etc now we shall live with some more divisions of religous high-religious low on account of the term 'Bibek'. I have seen people conducting themselves with arrogance and considering themselves as righteous to reject the Karah Prasad and many more such instances, while they uphold their BIBEK nevertheless sorry for wasting yours and my time

Re: What is Bibek ?

RoopKaur · 19 May 2005

Sikhi bibek is often been labelled bahmanvaad by the dokhis of the panth, but this statement is not true, infact, bibek is the exact opposite of what bahmans did: 1. bahmanvaad is based on birth and caste, while Sikhi bibek is based on following guru jis teachings and keeping rehit. In Sikhi, any person of any birth can become amritdharee while in bahmandvaad you are stuck where you are born. 2. In Sikhi a person is judged by their kamaee, or how much rehit they keep, both inside and outside rehit, while in bahmanvaad a person is judged by thier caste 3. In bahmanvaad the "lower castes" are discourage, condemned, persecuted against, while in Sikhi there is no caste or persectution, but non amritdharees are encouraged to tiaag manmat and come into the sharn of guru ji instead of following the illusions of this world. 4. In bahmanvad there are different rules for all different groups, while in Sikhi, all Sikhs have to follow the same rules i.e. get amritshuck, keep rehit (which includes dietary bibek), jap naam. 5. In bahmanvaad, the bahmans themselves give themself the fake honour that they enjoy in this world, but in Sikhi, a GOd fearing rehit loving gursikh gets honour from guru ji, in this world and the next. It is a misconception that keeping bibek is creating differences within the panth. Infact, not keeping bibek is. If all Sikhs were amritdharees and kept bibek, there would be no differences or difficulties, it is because of these dhils that problems arise. Kulmohan Singh mentioned not taking karah parshad, this is not true, a bibeki Singh always takes karah parshad after a divaan, but you should note that simply doing ardaas over karah does not make it parshad, if it is made with full maryada only then is it parshaad. It is shamefull that those who oppose guru jis rehit call those keeping rehit arrogant. I think it is out of haumai that these enemies of rehit want to lower the rehit of bibekis to their level. Also, there are no different levels of Sikhi. FOr example there is no such thing as a moderate Sikh, a fundamentalist, a modern Sikh. Since there is only one path, there can be only one SIkh, so infact those who are actually making these splits in SIkhi are those who cannot accept rehit in its entirety. They want to be called SIkhs, but do not want to actually become Sikhs. [%sig%]

Re: What is Bibek ?

Singh · 19 May 2005

An Inspiring post by RoopKaur. I didn't think of it that way before.

Re: What is Bibek ?

Mr · 19 May 2005

very nice post by Bhen Jee Roop Kaur.

Re: What is Bibek ?

Question Bhai · 19 May 2005

When did "keeping Bibek" actually start ? Also, I would like to honestly know how I can keep Bibek when most of the food I eat has already been handled [ farmed, treated, cut, packed, labelled and put on shelves ] by monays ?

Re: What is Bibek ?

RoopKaur · 19 May 2005

>When did "keeping Bibek" actually start ?< Bibek has been around from the moment we g\have had bibek budhi. Guru Nanak Dev Ji offers us an example of bibek when he refused to eat from Malik Bhago. Dietary bibek, as has been mentioned many times before, is that the raw materials should be cooked by amritdharees. It is the process of cooking and doinf paath and abhyaas while cooking that puts the mohr of the Khalsa on the food.

Re: What is Bibek ?

kulmohan · 20 May 2005

Does the upkeep of somebody's rehit mean calling others 1. Dokhis of the panth 2. Enemies of rehit The Guru I know tells me "Farida jo teh marein mukiyaan, tina na maarey ghum" Roop Kaur Bhenji, which guru did you learn your rehit from ?

Re: What is Bibek ?

Princess · 20 May 2005

Kulmohan jee, all Gursikhs learn rehit from Guru Sahib jee. I have quoted so many punkities in my previous post. Do you have any other explanation of those punkities according to your views? Why are your trying to mislead sangat by giving totally irrelevant punkities from Gurbani. Show us any punkiti where Gurbani teaches to eat from manmukhs. I have given those punkities which desist us doing it. 'Bipran kee reet' is when sikhs after chukking amrit don't listen to Guru sahib jee and don't keep rehat(bibek). Guru Sahib jee asked us to be distinct: is that bramanvaad? "Jab lag khalsa rahay nyaara, tab lag tej deeo(n) mai(n) saara".

Re: What is Bibek ?

* · 22 May 2005

jIau pwie qnu swijAw mUMh A`KIN nk kMn svwry] jeeo paae than saajiaa moo(n)h aakhee(n) nak ka(n)n savaarae|| Creating the jiva (self) He made his body and gave good shape to his mouth, nose, eyes and ears. hQ pYr dy dwq kr Sbd suriq suB idSt duAwry] hathh pair dhae dhaath kar shabadh surath subh dhishatt dhuaarae|| Gracefully He bestowed hands and feet, ears and consciousness for listening to the Word and eye for beholding goodness. ikrq ivrq prikrq bhu sws igrws invws sMjwry] kirath virath parakirath bahu saas giraas nivaas sa(n)jaarae|| For earning of the livelihood and other works, he infused life into body. rwg rMg rs prs dy gMD sugMD sMD prkwry] raag ra(n)g ras paras dhae ga(n)dhh suga(n)dhh sa(n)dhh parakaarae|| He bestowed various techniques of assimilation of music, colours, smells and fragrances. Cwdn Bojn buiD bl tyk ibbyk vIcwr vIcwry] shhaadhan bhojan budhh bal ttaek bibaek veechaar veechaarae|| Clothing and eating He gave wisdom, power, devotion, and discriminatory wisdom and thought process. dwqY kImiq nw pvY bySumwr dwqwr ipAwry] dhaathai keemath naa pavai baeshumaar dhaathaar piaarae|| The mysteries of that Bestower cannot be understood; that loving Donor keeps with Him myriad's of virtues. lyK AlyK AsMK Apwr ]ó] laekh alaekh asa(n)kh apaar ||a|| Beyond all accounts, He is infinite and unfathomable. Bhaaee Gurdaas Jee (Var 18)

Re: What is Bibek ?

kulmohan · 23 May 2005

Princess ji Here are the relevant punkties from Gurbani Boojhey deikhey Karey Bibek, Aapey eik, Aapey Aneik (Discover and see Bibek, He Himself is in One, He himself is in All)