Re: Sant Attar Singh ji Mastuana
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 18 May 2005
Even before we go into all that I want to say just one thing...
HAS anyone EVER...EVER..seen just ONE copy of a BOOK/Autobiography/Lifestory/Kautak/Bachans...etc of a SANT...WITHOUT HIS HOLINESS PHOTOGRAPH plastered across the COVER and also INSIDE pages... I HAVE NOT.
Has anyone Ever..ever..come across a Birr or Sroop of GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB... with a "photo"/Painting..of GURU NANAK JI SAHIB/GURU ARJUN JI SAHIB..or any other GURU JI SAHIB..on the Front Cover..inside Pages..
I HAVE NOT.
A really fantastic Book that i just heard about has been published in india..it is..
>
I also heard the author was attacked and assaulted..a sure sign of the "prem and Pyaar" of the sant chelas....Brahmgiani ju hoiyeh...
Sorry if i went into FAKE sant-bashing again.."kutteh dee poochh...he he he..and all that ..lols... and maybe off topic as well...Sorry.
Re: Sant Attar Singh ji Mastuana
Balpreet Singh · 18 May 2005
I have read the debates about Sant Attar Singh recently and am totally disgusted. The anti-Sant squad seems to have gone completely rabid. Sant Attar Singh was a Gursikh who spent his entire life spreading the message of Gurmat at a time when Sikhs were a very confused bunch and the message of Sikhi was not being heard.
I received an email in which Sant Attar Singh has been criticised with the most ludicrous points such as
>>>>
1. At 17 he joined British Army and left at 25. Thereafter,
he neither did any service nor farming - (Kirat Karo);
>>>>
Many Gursikhs have given up doing "work" and spent their lives doing meditation and parchaar. I don't think we should criticise him for this.
>>>>
2. He was still in the army when he took a vow not to marry.
(remained celibate without leading married life)-Vand Schako;
>>>>
Baba Deep Singh was celibate, should we condemn him as well? Sant Attar Singh did not preach against marriage. Singhs like Dr. Basant Singh and Dr. Surinder Singh in the Jatha also did not get married. Are they also to be condemned?
>>>>
3. Several prominent persons took Pahul from his hands.
(how a single person could give 'Pahul' to others?) Naam Japo;
>>>>
What a stupid point. Of course he didn't do this alone, he did so as a member of the Punj Pyaaray. This sort of "point" annoys me because it is purposely malicious when the author knows what the truth is.
>>>>
4. In 1902 he established Mastuana Dera (which led to Dera-
cult since spread all over Punjab and abroad);
>>>>
He set up a centre for parchaar. What's wrong with that? Deras were not invented by Sant Attar Singh, they have existed since the times of the Gurus. If some corrupt Babas have now used them for wrong purposes, we shouldn't blame Singhs like Sant Attar Singh. It's like blaming Guru Gobind Singh for giving Singhs BaNa because people like Poohla Nang wear it and do horrible things.
>>>>
5. He used to attend big functions on elephant/Saloon provided
by Jind/Nabha Maharajas (but his devotees often say that he
used to live in a grass-hut)
>>>>
Sant Attar Singh lived a VERY simple life. When he rode on chariots and elephants, it was while doing chaur of Guru Granth Sahib during processions. Christians and Muslims carried their scriptures under their arms and Sant Attar Singh showed the contrast between them and the way Sikhs revere Sri Guru Granth Sahib.
Sant Attar Singh was involved in many many important movements like Panch Khand Bhasaur (before it was corrupted). He sent Sant Teja Singh to the West to have the first amrit sinchaars in Canada. It is in his memory that the Academy at Baru Sahib continues to run today. The Singhnees in Sant jee's jatha all wear Dastaars even today.
Yes, I do not agree with dharna keertan, but one thing I don't agree with does not mean I can dismiss the person entirely. Even Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh had respect for Sant Attar Singh.
I think the Baba-Bashing people should know their limits. Yes, there are many many fake Sants out there and Dera-culture is not healthy. But that doesn't mean that anyone who has been labelled a "Sant" is bad. The Jatha had Singhs like Sant Juaalaa Singh, etc. And a "dera" is not necessarily bad either if it is used for the propogation of Sikhi.
Sant Attar Singh is a Sikh hero and to condemn him is in my opinion, plainly anti-Sikh and works into the hands of the RSS and other enemies of the Panth.
Re: Sant Attar Singh ji Mastuana
Sardar Gurbir Singh Waraich · 18 May 2005
SSINGH, before I begin to answer your questions please let me give you a brief history of my family. My great Grand Father spent a lot of time with Maharaj and to this present day all my family immediate and far respect and follow the teachings of Sant Maharaj. For this reason I will offer you a ‘personal’ viewpoint to your questions.
SSingh yes you are correct in your statement that the title Sant was first attributed to Sant Maharaj Baba Attar Singh Ji Mastuana Wale.
But why ordain Baba Attar Singh Mastuana Wale as the first Sant in the Khalsa Panth?
Maharaj was born into a period described by many as a golden era in Sikhi - after Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji passed the Guruship to Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji many acclaimed Sikhs in one special era from the period 1870 – 1930 gave and received the darshan of the Sadha Sangat of Punjab.
The most notable Sikhs during this epoch were Baba Sundar Singh, Baba Sham Singh, Baba Nand Singh, Baba Ram Singh, Baba Attar Singh Reru Sahib Wale, Baba Karam Singh Hoti Mardan and Baba Juwala Singh.
But why pick why pick out one particular individual amongst all these celebrated Sikhs for special preference?
Firstly Maharaj never asked for this title of Sant or ever pushed for it – Maharaj’s life was spent severing the Khalsa Panth and it was the Panth that gave the title to Maharaj.
But one must debate SSINGH’s query with more scope to give a justified and conclusive answer.
Maharaj built well over 400 Gurdwara, not forgetting the first Gurdwara outside India
(Shepards Bush Gurdwara London opened by Sant Teja Singh who was a disciple of Maharaj Ji.)
Was it possibly this reason that the title Sant was given to Maharaj, given that before Maharaj’s time – Gurdwara’s were very scarce?
Or could it be that Maharaj was asked to laid the foundation to first purpose built Hindu Unversity in Hardawar and that a large but significant minority of the congregation that used to descend on to Baba Ji dera were Muslims. Could it be that Maharaj possessed the complete qualities that Guru Nanak laid down some 400 years earlier – as not merely being the saviour for Sikhs, but for Hindu’s and Muslims alike.
Another viable motive could be that Maharaj brought back the Spartan image the Khalsa, through baptising 1.7 Million Sikhs? (A act not repeated by any body since) in addition one should not forget that Sant Maharaj introduced a new but effective method of preaching to the Sikh masses through Sidia Tarna Kirtan. This method is often criticised, but let me make something very clear.
As told by my elders, when Baba Ji used to present their divaans, their used to be congregations in excess of 50,000 to 80,000. Baba Ji’s Kirtan and Parchaar would travel over many Miles during a period when loudspeakers were not common. If this was Kachee Bani how could the individual performing the Kachee Bani perform such a feat – more so how could it inspire individuals in their thousands to accept Amrit? Even the prized Sant Giani Sundar Singh said that if any one wanted to see God in Human form, go to Pind Bradrukhan district Sangrur and fall at the feet of Sant Attar Singh Mastuana Wale.
However this is another debate and we must stick to the question in hand.
The statements above offer just a few reasons why Baba Ji is known as the first Sikh Sant of the Khalsa Panth. If any readers want a detailed account of the events discussed above or other inspiring diaries during Baba Ji life please refer to Sant Gulab Singh’s Janam Sakhi of Baba Ji.
2) someone posted that Sant Attar singh ji went around on an elephant like modern "sants" go around in mercedes/hummer's etc. Was this an example of the "patronage" of the 'rajas' such as Maharajah Patiala (?) How did this relationship go?
SSINGH, I believe you are referring to the following event – please read on:
In the early 20th Century India was under the occupation of its British Invaders, a time known as the British Raj. The then highest-ranking governor in India wanted all the major religions of Hindustan to bring their religious texts to New Dehli and portray them to the governor.
As a portrayed in Baba Ji’s Janam Sakhi, the Iman presented his Koran solely to the governor with his shoes on and the Hindu mahant presented their Gita head uncovered.
Sant Maharaj presented Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji on a gloriously decorated elephant, with the Panj Pira on horse back from the then finest Arabian Horses.
The governor of India was so impressed by the Sikh’s that he was quoted as saying that if Sant Maharaj was a Christian, we could convert the whole world to Christianity.
SSINGH contrary to your earlier claim one must also mention that Sant Attar Singh walked bear footed to Sachkand Sri Hazoor Sahib from Sangrur – this again doesn’t give you a picture of a person who would want to elevate himself by portraying himself as some sort of raja on a elephant.
Finally Sant Attar Singh was not educated by Nirmalas!
Maharaj was born in pind Cheema, district Sangrur, I don’t know where this claim came from given that there is not or has been one recognised Nilmala Sant from Baba Ji’s childhood residence in Cheema. More so we should note that the great Nirmila Sant of present time, Sant Daler Singh Ji Maarkandee Wale was a firm follower of Sant Maharaj.
I hope this answers all your questions SSINGH.
GurFateh
Sardar Gurbir Singh Waraich
Re: Sant Attar Singh ji Mastuana
Guldeep Singh · 18 May 2005
Thank you S. Balpreet Singh Ji and S. Gurbir Singh Ji for posting a fitting answer to all the ridiculous bashing of Baba Attar Singh Ji Maharaj (going on on many other boards). May Waheguru Bless you and this forum for the few sensible Gursikhs left.
Our Ego comes in the way of possibly accepting that some Gursikhs ever did have higher spirtual levels than ourselves.
Re: Sant Attar Singh ji Mastuana
Charanjeev Singh · 18 May 2005
For those who do not know the greatness of Sant Baba Attar Singh Jee mastuanwale please read his life biographies, and you will definately adorn your heart with virtues of a true Gursikh and jewel of Guru Nanak.
Re: Sant Attar Singh ji Mastuana
chima pind lagey pyara · 18 May 2005
baba attar singh was a very good bro of bhai randhir singh ji.
i want to ask ssingh what the problem is list each problem you have with this great sikh.
There is a mountain of difference between a s chardi kala singh like baba attar singh and a fake sant.
Re: Sant Attar Singh ji Mastuana
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 20 May 2005
waheguru ji ka kahlsa waheguru ji ki Fateh.
Dear Jss Jio,
Thanks for the correction. I had thought that by now people would have realised that my MAILS are GENERAL.."warnings" about such actions by certain FAKES... people ALWAYS come up with MAILS like YOURS that list the "OK" ones...I am trying to Throw away the CHAFF and people always point out the WHEAT....IF I meant WHEAT I would SAY WHEAT..and I would back it up with Facts...BUT I will NOT let the CHAFF get away as WHEAT..NO SIREE.
I DONT "Name" the CHAFF also becasue it is up to EACH ones; own avastha to get through..I make my choice and you make yours. Read GURBANI.... There are NO NAMES attached to all the BENARES KE THUGGHS mentioned....no names attached to Sadhs as well..BUt it doesnt mean that ALL are therefore.."not thuggs".
Just for the record there are only two things that I dont agree w ith about Sant Attar Singh mastuana..One Dhaarna Kirtna of Kachi bani...and the other Celibacy which is AGAINST all that GURU JI taught us..Householder gRishttee jiwan etc.
There is a Hukamnama from Akal Takaht BANNING such Pictures etc from ebing published on GUTKAS/STEEKS. Can you "imagine" a SANT/BRAHMGIANI so and so...just merely paying for the PRINTING of a Sunder Gutka/Sukhmani Sahib Gutka or Nitnem Gutka ( from Sangat's GOLAK ) PUTTING his own PICTURE on the said GUTKAS...This hsa happened and thsu the Akal takhat ahd to issue a HUKMNAMA tot he effect. ( This was specific to NANAKSARI SANTS/BRAHMGIANIS)..who also DISTORTED GURBANI, added Kachi bani dhaarna and manmatt sakhis. forwards, appendixes etc tot eh Gutkas..
Re: Sant Attar Singh ji Mastuana
Abhiyaas.Blogspot.Com · 21 May 2005
Premi Ji is correct.
Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji, your second point about Celibacy is true that Guru Sahib says we should live a Gristhee Jeevan. However, you must accept that there are certain souls sent down to this earth that are here to preach nothing but Japping Naam, Daas believes Sant Attar Singh Ji was one of these. There are many many examples of Naami Gurmukhs who have stayed celibate, it is not that they were against this teaching of Gurmat; it is because they were sent for a special mission on this earth and they had little Karam to suffice.
Also, if you read Rangley Sajjan by Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Ji, you will also note that some Gurmukhs in their also stayed celibate, i.e. Did not get married and stayed chaste and pure all their life. Namely, Bhai Prabhakar Singh Ji, Mahant Sunder Singh Ji, Dr. Basant Singh Ji and Sriman Sant Arjan Singh Ji. Daas is certain that there are more.
Re: Sant Attar Singh ji Mastuana
Jarnail Singh "Gyani "Arshi" · 22 May 2005
[gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani]
Gurbani Says...Bhaag Hoa GUR_SANT MILAYAEAH....and this Panktee by Guru Arjun Ji Sahib refers to GURU RAMDASS JI..clearly and unequivocally clear 1000%...and any ordinary human being NO MATTER HOW HOLY, LIVING or DEAD..who is PUT on the SAME PEDESTAL as GURU RAMDASS JI by being compared/addressed as SANT...is NOT ACCEPTABLE TO ME.
The "SANTIST LOBBY" does KIRTAN and SINGS so LOUDLY Panktees such as "Mahima kaho SADHU_SANG KI".....and in their mind's eye the "mahima" they think GURBANI refers to is the MAHIMA of their OWN PATRON BABAJI/SANT JI dead or living..... They are sadly and GROSSLY MISTAKEN..this is MAHIMA of SAADH SANGAT..the One and Only way to SALVATION ..
SO all of you "sant lobbyists" out there who want to Get across the Ocean of Maya holding on to the Cholas of such humans....I am desirous of getting across Holding ONLY the CHOLA of GURU HARGOBIND JI..BANDEE CHHORR.
In their ZEAL, these Chelas also get so excited that they begin to CLAIM in writing and in Print as well as Vocally.... so and so SANT JI Amrit Chhkaaed to so many Billions.... when they should KNOW that even GURU GOBIND SINGH JI Chhakeed AMRIT to ONLY FIVE ( Panj Piyaras) INITIALLY...and After that NO ONE Chhakkaed Amrit to anyone EXCEPT...PANJ PIYARAE JIs. Their ZEAL to PROMOTE SHAKSHI POOJA of their sant..even fails to show them the PRINCIPLE of AMRIT is being wrongly propogated by associating ONE NAME with it. How many millions have chhaked AMRIT at Akal Takhat/other Takhats/Gurdwaras World Wide....ONLY PANJ PIYARAS...no one sant or fake sant or kusant mentioned at all and NO NEED TO do so.
GURU KA SINGH.....NO SANTS FOR ME...THANK YOU.
Re: Sant Attar Singh ji Mastuana
arashi singh easy there · 22 May 2005
Gurfateh Arashi Ji,
Please take it easy...take deep breath in and out and say- Wahe Guruuuuuuuuuuuuu
I can just feel your frustrations halath right now..after all your anti-sant parchar is not really working well.
may be it's time for you to retire from these forums and live rest of your life in shanti place near the river or something.
Beauty play of akaal is it can make prostitues, theifs, murders, thugs an Sant and make so called religious leaders - irkhalo, insecure individuals.
Re: Sant Attar Singh ji Mastuana
Jarnail Singh "Gyani "Arshi" · 23 May 2005
[gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani]
dear arashi singh easy there jio,
wouldnt you and your easy there brothers just LOVE to see "me " go somewhere and drown in a river or some thing..it sure would make your day wouldnt it...like read in the newspaper.." Arashi found dead...floating up side down in a fish pond..!!!"
so sorry to disappoint you..my GURU JI takes too much care of me...i have not even visited a "doctor" for fever even..and my HALATH is well..too good to be true...
I am taking it easy... so easy that i have 24/7 time to be on the FORUMS WORLDWIDE....and when i am by the "riverside" i have my LAPTOP/WI-FI Access...i have a sneaky feeling you wont be "rid" of me even when I go " up that place in the sky...because i have trained so many descendants..who i assure you are even more "dedicated" than me to dispell this "sant dhund".. blocking GYAN SOORAJ of GURBANI .
What you said is true..100%..AKAAL makes prostitutes, thieves, murderes.."SANTS"... that is OK by me....BUT not "SANTS" who turn murderers, thieves and prostitutes/rapists etc
So veer it is your turn to "take a deep breath...say WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHEEEEEEEEEEEEEEGUUUUUUUUUUUUUUURUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU...and keep your fingers crossed for that "arshi dead" news....who knows WAHEGURU may just hear your ARDASS..... by the way i am NO "leader" of anybody.
[gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani]
Re: Sant Attar Singh ji Mastuana
arashi singh easy there · 23 May 2005
Ravan also did bhagti and was also scholar(maha gyani) of his yug but he couldn't stand erect when his time came.
Torondo of kaal took him with it's power. I can draw tables between you and him but I am not going down that level.
As Siri Sahib Guru Tegh Bahudar Ji Maharaj says:
Naam Rahio Sadhu Rahio Rahio Gur-Gobind, Kaho Nanak Eh Jagat Mein Kin Japeyeo Gurmant ||
You can use your curses and tactics to bring down holy saints but nothing will happen.
As I am sure you heard this saying-
When you spit's on moon, spit comes down to your own face.
When I come across with nidaks of sants/mahatama's/bhramgyanis/arif/fakirs, I don't feel mad at them but crack a lil smile and move on since reflection of true saints spread automatically in his hakum..no negative force can change that after their thousand attempts nothing happened because positive energy(truth) always win after all.
Re: Sant Attar Singh ji Mastuana
Khalsa_Force · 24 May 2005
Author: Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi"
Date: 05-20-05 05:55
waheguru ji ka kahlsa waheguru ji ki Fateh.
Dear Jss Jio,
Thanks for the correction. I had thought that by now people would have realised that my MAILS are GENERAL.."warnings" about such actions by certain FAKES... people ALWAYS come up with MAILS like YOURS that list the "OK" ones...I am trying to Throw away the CHAFF and people always point out the WHEAT....IF I meant WHEAT I would SAY WHEAT..and I would back it up with Facts...BUT I will NOT let the CHAFF get away as WHEAT..NO SIREE.
I DONT "Name" the CHAFF also becasue it is up to EACH ones; own avastha to get through..I make my choice and you make yours. Read GURBANI.... There are NO NAMES attached to all the BENARES KE THUGGHS mentioned....no names attached to Sadhs as well..BUt it doesnt mean that ALL are therefore.."not thuggs".
Just for the record there are only two things that I dont agree w ith about Sant Attar Singh mastuana..One Dhaarna Kirtna of Kachi bani...and the other Celibacy which is AGAINST all that GURU JI taught us..Householder gRishttee jiwan etc.
There is a Hukamnama from Akal Takaht BANNING such Pictures etc from ebing published on GUTKAS/STEEKS. Can you "imagine" a SANT/BRAHMGIANI so and so...just merely paying for the PRINTING of a Sunder Gutka/Sukhmani Sahib Gutka or Nitnem Gutka ( from Sangat's GOLAK ) PUTTING his own PICTURE on the said GUTKAS...This hsa happened and thsu the Akal takhat ahd to issue a HUKMNAMA tot he effect. ( This was specific to NANAKSARI SANTS/BRAHMGIANIS)..who also DISTORTED GURBANI, added Kachi bani dhaarna and manmatt sakhis. forwards, appendixes etc tot eh Gutkas..
great post !!!!
Re: Sant Attar Singh ji Mastuana
Liten to my Veer, Gyani Arshi · 24 May 2005
Wahegurujikakhalsa,wahegurujikifateh.
In support of my Veer Jarnail Singh Arshi, please read the following comments:
No doubt that sant Attar Singh Mastuana did sewa for sikhisim, but what we have as evidence, is only the fables written by his closest chela's, which we will all have to agree, are going to be one-sided, right?
Yes they started the dheraism, they stayed unmarried, and sang in local dialect, chachi-bani. If they were so great, so much of a bhramgaini, then would they not have seen how they were laying the path, for so- many fake sants to follow?
Overzealous chela's is what i was myself, until i realised the truth about a certain 'large' sant, who now feels thankful to do parchar in harayana/punjab alone. No more world tours, why, because the truth will look him in the face, and boy the truth is over-powering!
Lets not read the fables of chela's about how great there sant was, and by that i include all so-called sants, whether they use the title or not. Look at the state of sikhi, look at our attitudes towards one another, our bani talks about the path of love, yet love has not even crossed our paths!
Shiri Guru Nanak Dev Ji came to earth to deliver many messages. They spoke out against Brahmins, and there 'controlling' ways, they tried to educate the public that no middle-man is required. That was not to say that all brahmins were bad/wrong, but we as sikhs, now find them all inferior, right?
In the same way, sants have soured the nectur of sikhi, and we need to end this chapter, we need to remove the middle-man nonsense, and again focus on Shiri Guru Granth Sahib Jeeo, without the middle man, otherwise the bad sant element will continue to thrive in out religion!
Gurfateh,
guru ka lal.
Re: Sant Attar Singh ji Mastuana
Harjinder Singh · 24 May 2005
[gurbani]<>[/gurbani]
[gurbani]vwihgurU jI kI Piqh[/gurbani]
Dear Veer NaamRas Ji
I respect your devotion to respect the Gurmukh personalities who spent their entire life with extra-ordinary Kamayee of Gursikhi. But Can you answer one simple question WHY(or On what basis you make this distinction) you put or accept the prefix of Bhai with Bhai Randhir Singh Ji (or and all other great Gurmukhs without the prefix Sant) and put or accept the prefix of Sant with Baba Isher Singh Ji (or and all other great Gurmukhs with the prefix Sant)?
From what I understand, Gyani Jarnail Singh "Arshi" want that when we have Guru Sahib who is Sun as compared to a Candle or any other great Gurmukh (which you also have confirmed in this post that Guru Sahib is the biggest Sant) then we have no need to feel/call a Candle as the Sun.
I repeat again what I posted in another post that Guru Sahib says
[gurbani]gurmuK sau kir dosqI siqgur sau lwie icqu[/gurbani]
guramukh so kar dhosathee sathigur so laae chith ||
Make friends with the Gurmukhs, but focus your consciousness on the True Guru Only.
But i think most of us today believe and act in fact otherway around in the event of responding to Guru Khalsa Panth Jee and Guru Granth Sahib Jee as compared to a Gursikh we associate with.
Just think what is status of any Gurmukh as compared to Guru Sahib in the situation when Guru Sahib is available or present to you all the time. A Gurmukh is our dedicated partner or Humsafar whose company/or friendship we need to move along with him(Gurmukh) towards Gurur Sahib not Move towards him(Gurmukh) in stead of Guru Sahib. To give title of a Sant to any Human is not our right/capability and we should just let it to Guru Sahib to know/decide who has become his most beloved Gursikh or let it be between a Gurmukh and Guru Sahib. We should just love all our Gursikh mates as our Bhai/Bhahen/our Sakhi Saheylees all trying to seek happiness of the same common Kant. we all are deficient in one way or the other and can fall down at any time. Only Guru Sahib is Pooran and eternal.
[gurbani]vwihgurU jI kI Piqh[/gurbani]
[%sig%]
Re: Sant Attar Singh ji Mastuana
Harjinder Singh · 24 May 2005
[gurbani]<>[/gurbani]
[gurbani]vwihgurU jI kI Piqh[/gurbani]
One more thing, I would like to mention that calling a great Gursikh as Bhai/Bhahen is making him/her feel that he is on going on the Gurmat path and calling a Gursikh as Sant make him/her feel that he has reached perfection which is a final roadblock on his/her continuity in moving further advance in Gurmat. So not calling Sant is a big help/favour we can do to a fellow Gursikh.
Furthermore, By avoiding to give title or prefix of SANT to any of our Gursikh fellow, we can prevent the damage and embarrassment that we face for the entire Sikh nation when we see scandals of those well known as our great Sants.
Sant is perfect and let this title remain only to Guru Sahib who is perfect for ever.
Bhai Randhir Singh Ji gave the title of Rangaley Sajjan not the title SANT to his fellow great Gursikhs that also only after their death because he did not felt right to take gurantee of any other Gurmukhs (of same or even more Kamayee) who were still alive.
Regarding Dharna Keertan,
By not promoting the Keertan of Dharna is not going against Baba Attar Singh Ji or Baba Isher Singh Ji rather it is step of improvement from the own methods used by these Gursikhs to preech Sikhi to obey the actual Hukum of Guru Sahib.
I think Singing in Dharna can be Approaching Sikhi in our way ( which can be right/wrong or may keep us stuck in between or take us to wrong destination if we put/sing wrong words in dharna as we make the dharna not the Guru Sahib)
and on the other side
Singing Gurbani is Doing ( or practicing or implementing) Sikhi.
[gurbani]vwihgurU jI kI Piqh[/gurbani]
[%sig%]
Re: Sant Attar Singh ji Mastuana
Harjinder Singh · 24 May 2005
[gurbani]<>[/gurbani]
[gurbani]vwihgurU jI kI Piqh[/gurbani]
One more thing:
I just want make it crystal clear that my intent
is not bashing the title Sant
rather my sole intent is
to keep the utmost significance/sanctity of status of title Sant or BrahamGyani.
I can see this same feeling in the posts of Gursikh veers/bahans like Gyani Jarnail Singh Ji.
So it is not about hating Sants, it is about whom we can (or have the right to) call a Sant
There is no Gursikh so far in the Sikh history to whom all sikhs agree one hundred percent. Sant should be the one who is Pooran or Brahamgyani, to whom’s actions or sayings, no one can disagree which is no other than Guru Sahib himself . And Guru Sahib(Husband) only is capable or has right to measure the level of Kamayee/sincerity of any of his Gursikh (wife). We should always do ardas for all so that we all can live to the expectations of Guru Sahib.
Bhul Chuk Maaf Karna Ji.
[%sig%]