Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

IHRO - Justice Denied to the Sikhs

IHRO - Justice Denied to the Sikhs

Kaur · 20 May 2005

Justice Denied to the Sikhs There is no justice for minorities in India Since the approval of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights 57 years ago, the international community established laws and procedures to help guarantee internationally recognised human rights. The International Human Rights Organisation (IHRO), therefore, was concerned over the near collapse of India’s political set-up. Democracy was under great strain in India as major organs of State that sustain democracy such as impartial and fearless judiciary, an independent press and conscientious legislature were on the retreat. The judicial system in India had virtually collapsed and there was no rule of law. Democracy was a thing of the past. State repression was the only voice one heard in the police state. A fair trial was not possible in Indian courts since the police were a law unto itself. There have been cases where the security forces not only flouted the orders of courts but also had actually shot at court officials, who were deputed to get the release of persons illegally detained by the police. This situation of lawlessness then was particularly disturbing in Punjab. Freedom, Rule of Law and Justice are the foundations of the Constitution of any democratic country and that of the international law and the United Nations charter and it covenants. Freedom and justice are indispensable but, unfortunately, at most places, they are in actual jeopardy and elsewhere they are in potential peril. According to Justice V. R. Krishna Iyer: 'The Rule of Law is a constitutional fundamental of India, and in theory, even amidst the clash of arms, the Law shall not be silent. Justice in Punjab had been crucified on the cross of law and if the country does not demand resurrection of the right to justice, constitutional guarantees may degenerate into rhetoric and human rights die a natural death. Unfortunately, not until long ago when judicial activism surfaced, the higher judiciary, too, was in the habit of looking the other way when even the fundamentals were under attack.' The history of India though brief, is extremely rich in the ignoble acts of terrorism by the executive, backed by tyrannical laws, purportedly enacted within the constitutional framework but totally destructive of the mandate of justice, liberty, equality and fraternity. The judiciary blissfully watched while the towers of democracy collapsed. Unfortunately, in India, because of the sinister political designs of the ruling classes, the Parliament was polarised against people who were fighting for their basic rights and greater autonomy. The Executive too toed the line of the Parliamentarians and flouted the Constitution and the Rule of Law with impunity due to the inaction of the Judiciary for better part of the recent decades. To crown it all even the Hon’ble Supreme Court had no time to take up cases involving Human Rights pertaining to minorities. The glaring example, quoted by many, of sleeping over by the higher judiciary, is that the hearing on the constitutional validity of the Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act (TADA) case was taken up after its virtual withdrawal by the Government of India. Hon’ble Mr. Justice J. M. L. Sinha of the Allahabad High Court had rightly observed: “It (judiciary) does not serve any particular section or community. It belongs to the common man. It is to this institution that the common man turns when his life and liberty are in jeopardy. If you do away with an independent judiciary, you sow the seeds of violence that may germinate slowly but surely.” “Whereas it is essential, if a man is not to be compelled to have recourse, as a last resort, to rebellion against tyranny and oppression, that human rights should be protected by rule of law,” also says the Preamble to the UN Declaration of Human Rights, December 10, 1948. Very aptly, Guru Gobind Singh, the Tenth Master (1704) proclaims: “When all other means of resistance against tyranny and oppression fail, it is legitimate, as a last resort, to turn to the sword.” All this apart and despite assurances given by both the Law Minister and the Home Minister, the Parliament session once again ended up without the Congress government tabling the report of the Nanawati Commission on the Sikh carnage of 1984. NDTV revisited those areas of the national capital, which witnessed the massacre, the worst ever in the history of independent India where nearly 3000 Sikhs lost their lives. Those who survived the massacre but lost their families see this delay by the Congress as just another mockery of the justice they have been waiting for in the last twenty years, according to Swati Maheshwari of the NDTV. In the past 20 years, hardly anyone has been held accountable while cases were recommended against Congress leaders HKL Bhagat, Sajjan Kumar and Jagdish Tytler, who were accused of instigating and organizing the genocide of the Sikhs. Former MP HKL Bhagat and Sajjan Kumar were let off by courts for lack of credible evidence even in cases based on the testimony of victims. The Kapoor and Mittal Committees recommended cases against 72 police officers for their connivance in and gross negligence during the carnage but this too was ignored. The Nanavati Commission report submitted in February has still not been tabled. The other report on Godhra was made public the same evening only because the perpetrators belonged to the other political turf. The jurisprudence dictum ‘Justice delayed is justice denied’ correctly applies to the Sikh Nation, despite what Mahatma Gandhi had reminded: “They (the Sikhs) well know how to safeguard their rights by exercise of arms, if it should ever come to that.” D S Gill

Re: IHRO - Justice Denied to the Sikhs

Singh · 20 May 2005

I agree with DS Gill specially the last pharagraph. http://5abi.com/vishesh/vishesh2005/200205_insaaf_ghuman.htm