talking before wedding
Question · 30 May 2005
If you are engaged to someone and you know you will be marrying them, are you allowed to talk to that person or is it a big NO-NO in terms of Sikhi?
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
Question · 30 May 2005
If you are engaged to someone and you know you will be marrying them, are you allowed to talk to that person or is it a big NO-NO in terms of Sikhi?indy · 30 May 2005
you can talk to the opposite sex wether your going to marry them or not, it just depends on what you talk to the person about. if you wouldnt do it infront of guru sahib to your sister, dont do it. engagement isnt marriage, and can still be broken off because you havnt said your vows infront of guru sahib. my views anyway.pk · 30 May 2005
we say vows?ekta · 31 May 2005
no u must marry a person u don't know.>><><< · 31 May 2005
ekta...why must we marry a person we don't know? what does that prove?kaur1 · 31 May 2005
marry a person u don't know? hmm... where exactly does it say that u MUST marry a person u don't know? I think its perfectly fine to talk to the person u r engaged to,why not? HOWEVER.... it depends also what you talk about, how are you meant to marry a person if you don't know him/her? thats an old tradition. marriage is a long life comittment right. so you are meant to be 100% sure if you want to marry a person or not. i don't think there nothing wrong talking 2 a person ur going 2 marry, after all its just like talkin 2 anyone else isn't it? hope that helps. Remember we are living in the 20th century! correct me if im wrong! wjkk wjkffgf · 31 May 2005
it should be like the old days when no one got divorced. you see the girl, dont talk. see the family then marry. that way tehres compromise in the relationship and its not so much emotionalRedwhiteandblue Kaur · 31 May 2005
I agree with what Indy says. Talking is fine as long as it's nothing untoward. Personally, I believe that a match should be based on values above all else. Corresponding or discussing with a person can be a very good way to understand a person's values for yourself.34 · 31 May 2005
COME ON NOT AGAIN, TALK OR DISCUSS SOMRTHING REASONABLE, OF COURSE YOU CAN TALK TO YOUR FIANCE, YOUR GONNA GET MARRIED, FORGET SIKHI, THIS IS COMMON SENSE!14 · 02 Jun 2005
erm kaur1 i think we are actually living in the 21st century lolllMr. Singh · 02 Jun 2005
Have faith in Guru sahib. Faith is all we have. Leave your maat behind and try to follow Guru's hukams. Do guru's sewa (paath) and things will work out for the best. Even if you end up with a horrible spouse, it's still for the best because its guru sahib's hukam. "hukamay andar sabh ko.." keep your amritvela and a strong nitnem. Why burden yourself with worries of marriage... let guru sahib take care of it, which will leave you to worry about your Sikhi. It's hard but keep your focus on meeting guru sahib. So, no need to converse with the person before marriage. Keep your mind focused and on Sikhi.kaur1 · 02 Jun 2005
lolllll....ye i meant 21st century!! hahahaha ok....i look very stupid now...dont matta !! hahahaha oooppppssssetka · 02 Jun 2005
guys i wuz being sarcastic.kawal · 02 Jun 2005
talking to anyone is not a big issue i guess .... but the thing matter what you are talking abt .... haina ???waheguruu · 02 Jun 2005
ahahahha i knew you were ekta - maybe you should have done "(!)" or something to make it more obvious [%sig%]Amritpal Singh · 02 Jun 2005
I think its totally wrong and distracting to talk to a bibi your going to get married to before marriage. Only anand karaj is pakha, nothing before that is paakha. We have been given hukam by Guru Sahib to treat the opposite sex as mothers, sisters or daughters, or vice versa fathers, brothers, sons. There is ONE and only ONE exception to this rule layed out by Guru Sahib, and that is the relationship of your SPOUSE. Your wife or husband. You only get a wife or husband after Anand Karaj!! Before anand Karaj that person should fall into one of the 3 categories above (sister, wife, daughter). Now which one would that person fall under? The point im trying to make is dont make the mistake of talking to the person your going to marry before anand karaj. In fact you should refrain yourself as much as you can. Cant we learn anything from our Older Generations and older gursikhs? Ask any Rehit vaan, tar-byar-tar khalsa about this and they will all give you the same answer. Every older singh and gursikh I can think of would NEVER give the advice to talk to a bibi your engaged too. Its just not good for your spiritually and avaasta to do so. You'll get unwanted kaam, and just lose out on the great things of gursikhi lifestyle. Have trust in Guru Sahib. Have trust in other gursikhs/parents who are arranging your ristha. dont follow the masses, follow gurmat.pk · 03 Jun 2005
My amritdhari cousin was introduced to a keshadhari boy in India. The familes agreed on the match and the two were engaged. Shortly before she was to return to Canada, the boy told her that when he got to Canada he would cut his hair (in an attempt to sound cool,I guess?). She broke of the engagement, and married someone else. She's happily married now, lucky for her that she talked to that first guy.SK · 09 Jun 2005
i dont know what u ppl will think about this, but i am going to marry this singh and we have been talking a lot. we have got so close that we have done much physical stuff and almost had sex as well. but we know that we are going to get married to each other in the end no matter what, so we justify our actions as not being wrong. even though i know in my heart that we ARE wrong. and i have never done this stuff with another person before. so should we approach the punj piaray before we get married? please advise me. ps. i know that getting close to the person efbroe marriage shifts your spiritual state. i learned the hard way..... · 10 Jun 2005
SK, I think you and the person you are marrying should definitely go to the punj pyaray about this. Sometimes mistakes like this made before marriage end up even negatively effecting the marriage itself.Roopkaur · 10 Jun 2005
>She broke of the engagement, and married someone else. She's happily married now, lucky for her that she talked to that first guy.< The problem here was not that your cousing talked or did not talk to the guy, but it was that she was engaged to a keshadari. An amritdharee can only marry another amritdharee person. Even if the person is keshadharee when engaged, they should be peshed and amritdharee before the wedding happens. In a Sikh marriage two bodies share one soul but how can an amridharee share a soul with a non amritdharee? THis is impossible. If this marriage was done in the traditional SIkh way, the couple would both be amridharee or about to be amritdharee, and would not talk to eachother before the marriage.Premi · 10 Jun 2005
A possible thing to do which I have heard from a very old gursikh was. They were presented with many rishtaa's they wrote everybody's name down on seperate papers did ardaas in front of Guru Granth Sahib and "said please guide me on this path of grastee as you have guided me in all other paths of my life, I am your child please keep me following your will. I humbly request you Guru jee to tell me where I should get married out of the rishtaas from the families you have sent for me. So he put them all in a bowl and took a hukumamaa whatever was the first name to come out, he got married there. My point being is his faith in the Guru ferried him through his life. In regards to talking before the marriage I think you should if possible meet at least once to see if your natures match each other, and if so confirm with Guru jee if it is acceptable however you feel comfortable, either using the above method or any other method. In this day and age there are very few that can just trust the people doing the rishtaa, I mean if you need to speak with the potential partner then you should and clear your doubts. Not everybody is at the same avasthaa of trust in family and Guru jee. Don't worry be happy, trust in the Lord, he does not always send everybody on the 401, some need to take the side streets first then get on the ramp then get on the 401. It is a big decision marriage. The above mentioned Gursikh had many, many ups and downs in his marriage life, but it was his faith in the GURU than ferried him through. I really don't think you should worry to much about it, I have known many gursikhs who have been engaged for a year or so, some broke it off and were happy to do so, some got married. Personnally my marriage rishta talk is on the front burner right now. I would like to meet the potential partner first at least once to see if I could live with this person or not, to see what there views are on Sikhi, then ask Guru jee for the final OK. Premipk · 10 Jun 2005
Yes Roop Kaur, What you have explained is correct and would be ideal, but her family searched for a match for a couple of years and couldn't find an Amritdhari boy. Also, her parents are not Amritdhari themselves, which makes it a bit more difficult, i think.Haprpreet singh · 13 Jun 2005
I really like your views Roop Kaur