Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sikh teen's hair cut off in beating

Sikh teen's hair cut off in beating

Vancouver Sun · 01 Jun 2005

People please arm your children with self defense lessons....so this does not happen to them....:( http://www.canada.com/vancouver/vancouversun/news/westcoastnews/story.html?id=a20a4ddf-fac7-494c-b5ae-475101cad64c

Re: Sikh teen's hair cut off in beating

Roopkaur · 01 Jun 2005

This is really distressing news, especially because it happened in a so called multicultural country such as Canada, and also in a diverse area such as Vancouver. What the guys did was totally disgusting. I truly hope that they are caught and punished justly, even though nothing can make up for what they have done to the victim.

Re: Sikh teen's hair cut off in beating

KHALISTANI · 01 Jun 2005

learn shaster vidyia ppl. and carry shasters. that doesnt mean jsut ure kirpan

Re: Sikh teen's hair cut off in beating

just a comment · 01 Jun 2005

this has happend but we need to make sure that it never happens again THAT IT NEVER HAPPENS AGAIN all and any means necessary

Re: Sikh teen's hair cut off in beating

just a comment · 01 Jun 2005

does anyone know who this person is please reply and what are of richmond was he in

Re: Sikh teen's hair cut off in beating

Excuse · 02 Jun 2005

I think we should get more information before being so distressed. The same exact story came out of Queens w/ a ragi's son 3 years ago and last year in New Jersey. The fictional "thugs" somehow always went for the Kesh. Sounds like an excuse to cut his own kesh. Read the discussion on Sikhnet. The cops are already doubting the story. Don't be so alarmed & distressed people. The truth will be out today.

Re: Sikh teen's hair cut off in beating

Mm Singh · 02 Jun 2005

I remember a similar story a few years ago in Vancouver. The 'Thugs' again went for the kesh. Later on, it turned out that the boy made up the whole story in order to have his kesh cut. Apparently he had his friends punch him up a bit so he would look like he was jumped by 'thugs' and with a scissor he cut up his own kesh. He acted traumatized and told his father that he does not want to keep kesh as he has still not gotten over the incident. Later on, his fake beating and plan was exposed some how to the shame of this family. Not that I'm saying this new particular story is also fake because I know that Vancouver does have a racism problem. But we should first investigate this incident. [%sig%]

Re: Sikh teen's hair cut off in beating

oneandonlyme · 02 Jun 2005

i can't belive someone could do something so disgusting. What did there parents teach them?

Re: Sikh teen's hair cut off in beating

no one · 02 Jun 2005

Now I'm really distressed, ohhhhh that would be sooooo embarassing for everyone.....I wouldn't know whether to hope for the genuinity of this story or thank God for it being a lie

Re: Sikh teen's hair cut off in beating

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 02 Jun 2005

I am also suspicious. This is a consistent lie done by malcontents that seek to toy with other people's emotions...while they defame their swaroop. I want to see more documentation before falling in to lockstep with the believe that this was a genuine hate crime. Liar...................................... http://abclocal.go.com/wpvi/news/71103-sikhhoax.html Sikh Admits Robbery Hoax HACKENSACK, N.J. July 11, 2003 A Sikh man who claimed his arm was slashed, his turban removed and his hair chopped off during a robbery at the drug store where he worked has admitted that the robbery was a hoax. Harminder Singh, 21, of Teaneck, was charged Thursday with theft and filing a false police report. Authorities said Singh, a manager at the North Arlington store, staged the June 30 robbery as a ruse to steal $5,600 from the cash register. Singh initially told police that two men armed with a knife and a gun had burst into the store, led him to the rear and cut off his hair before fleeing with the cash. Sikhs are forbidden by their religion to cut their hair, believing it is a gift from God, and community leaders and national Sikhs groups quickly denounced the attack. However, Singh later confessed to cutting his own hair and slashing himself after investigators told him that the store's video surveillance tape contradicted his story, and the $5,600 was found under the back seat of his car. He has been released on his own recognizance pending a court hearing that will be held later this year. More Liars.................................... http://www.sikhcoalition.org/NewsletterW03262004.asp Case Update: Lodi Youths Fabricate Bias Crime Attack Lodi, NJ - Two young Sikhs, who alleged that their hair was cut off by assailants motivated by anti-Muslim hate, concocted the story according to police in Lodi, New Jersey. Police in Lodi initially reported that they believed the incident to be a bias crime. On March 10, police reported that the teens confessed to making up the incident in order to provide an acceptable excuse for cutting their hair. The Coalition would like to thank the Lodi Police for their prompt investigation of the matter, and for their willingness to work with the Sikh community. The Coalition regrets that the resources of the Sikh community were used to support a tale that was ultimately a fabrication.

Re: Sikh teen's hair cut off in beating

suki singh · 03 Jun 2005

This has happened in Slough, UK twice in the past few years- a very sad phenomenon demonstrating the lack of confidence amongest some of our youth when it comes to Kesh.

Re: Sikh teen's hair cut off in beating

Guldeep Singh · 03 Jun 2005

Sikh teen may have lied about attack, police told By PETTI FONG Thursday, June 2, 2005 Page S3 VANCOUVER -- With no suspects and no witnesses in an alleged racial assault against an Indo-Canadian teenager who said he had his turban and hair hacked off by five attackers, Richmond RCMP say one possibility they're investigating is whether the boy cut his own hair. Richmond RCMP Corporal Peter Thiessen said investigators have heard from members in the Sikh community that the teenager may have lied about the assault in order to defy his parents' expectations that his hair should remain uncut as a symbol of his faith. "They feel the potential is there that this may be fabricated on the part of the young man," said Cpl. Thiessen yesterday "It hasn't been completely ruled out." But Cpl. Thiessen said the likelihood is greater that the boy was attacked, as he told police, by five Caucasian men in their early 20s in a field at Grauer Elementary School. The teenager said one of the attackers called out a racial slur Thursday afternoon as he was walking home. When the boy then tried to run away, the five older men punched him. One of the attackers held a utility blade to his throat, then tore off his turban and cut off the teenager's hair, police were told, before the youth managed to escape and go home. The possibility that the victim lied to the police about the incident has been raised with the family, Cpl. Thiessen said, but both the teenager and his family members deny that is the case. The boy's cut hair has been recovered, but police have not said where it was found. Although the teenager wore a turban and had not cut his hair in his 17 years, he was not a baptized Sikh, said one immediate family member who asked not to be identified. The mother of the victim released a statement saying it was a difficult time for the family. "As Indo-Canadians we understand that the community must band together at a time like this, however, we ask all of you not to act hastily or in a rash manner," the mother wrote in a note, which included a plea for witnesses to step forward. Radio Punjab news director and host Harinder Thind said hundreds of callers yesterday morning phoned in to voice their opinion about the attack, with only a handful advocating retaliation. Some callers said a devout Sikh would have been carrying a dagger to defend against an attack, but the victim was not carrying any ceremonial weapons. "There was a lot of anger and frustration that the police were not doing enough, but there was a consensus that this is not a country where people should use weapons to defend themselves," Mr. Thind said. "If five Indo-Canadians beat up a white man and took off his cross or whatever, things would be different, some callers said." Some parents have put pressure on their children, especially young males, to adhere to the traditions of the devout in keeping their hair uncut and wearing turbans, said Balwant Sanghera, an Indo-Canadian youth worker. "It would be really tragic if it is the case that the boy is responsible," said Mr. Sanghera, a spokesman with the Sikh Societies of the Lower Mainland. "There was a previous case where that was the circumstance and the whole community felt embarrassed by the situation." Mr. Sanghera said community groups are making efforts to bridge generational gaps between more tradition-bound parents and their increasingly secular children.

Re: Sikh teen's hair cut off in beating

not sure · 03 Jun 2005

yeh its possible he cut his hair off but i still think its unfair to say that so early. the truth will lie in the boy himself time will tell if he vows to keep his kes in future.

Re: Sikh teen's hair cut off in beating

Excuse · 03 Jun 2005

Last year the New Jersey boy also vowed to keep his kes after he was caught. I just saw him 2 weeks ago. Hair is still cut.

Re: Sikh teen's hair cut off in beating

not sure · 03 Jun 2005

easy tiger i mean as in vow to keep his kes right now as they are letting them grow rather than 2 years later.

Re: Sikh teen's hair cut off in beating

just a comment · 03 Jun 2005

dont assume he is lieing right now we have to believe what is infront of us this was not attack on a single person but a attack on us all

Re: Sikh teen's hair cut off in beating

singh · 04 Jun 2005

jagtesvar hain || parmesvar hain || O Lord! Thou art the Master of the universe. O Lord! Thou art the supreme Lord King. kal kaaran hain || sarb ubaaraN hain || O Lord! Thou art the cause of strife and evil. O Lord! Thou art the Saviour of all. 172.

Re: Sikh teen's hair cut off in beating

singh · 04 Jun 2005

it's official he lied Youth says story made up Broadcast News Saturday, June 04, 2005 Click here to find out more! VANCOUVER -- A B.C. Indo-Canadian youth who claimed he was assaulted by a group of white men has admitted he made the story up. The 17-year-old Sikh from the Vancouver suburb of Richmond confessed to police he fabricated the tale that his turban was removed and his long hair cut off with a utility knife. RCMP Corporal Peter Thiessen says the incident has upset the Sikh community but no decision has been made whether to lay charges. Thiessen says the boy is shamed and realizes the the lie has caused pain to his family. Police suspected a hoax when no tips came in concerning the incident that was said to have taken place during the daytime. The teen told officers he was jumped by five white men in their 20's last Thursday when he was walking home from high school.

Re: Sikh teen's hair cut off in beating

singh. · 05 Jun 2005

He's lying. He admitted it and apologised for it. Personally, I'm sick of people acting in such a selfish way that it hurts their community image. IF they don't want to follow Sikhi, that's their business, but they have no right to commit such public actions that tarnish our image. Completely selfish...

Re: Sikh teen's hair cut off in beating

---- · 05 Jun 2005

i just wanted to let everyone know that i heard last night that he in fact as telling a lie. its sad that it has had to come to this....

Re: Sikh teen's hair cut off in beating

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 05 Jun 2005

It is a terrible shame. It is a shame that someone is selling our faith out to such indulgence. And it is a shame that as individuals, we are not making more of an effort to reach out to one another and to keep each other strong, in frendship and in faith. http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/1117935462964_24/?hub=Canada --------------------- Sun. Jun. 5 2005 8:01 AM ET Sikh youth hair attack 'victim' admits hoax CTV.ca News Staff A Sikh youth in B.C. has apologized for inventing a story of being set upon by a group of white men who cut his hair. The 17-year-old from Richmond, a Vancouver suburb, admitted to police he made up the story. Police had already been suspicious, because the attack, which had been alleged to have occurred in broad daylight on May 26, had generated no tips from the public. "He had fabricated the entire incident," RCMP Cpl. Peter Thiessen told reporters Saturday. "The injuries that we observed on him that required medical attention were self-inflicted," he said. The youth had claimed the five men stopped their basketball game, pulled off his turban and cut his long hair with a utility knife. Hair is considered sacred by Sikhs. But the youth merely wanted to cut his hair but was afraid to deal with his parents. "... His hair was hanging out, so it looked like he was attacked," said Sheldon D'Cruz, a friend of the youth who came upon him minutes after the hoax. Sikh leaders denounced the attack, but when the hoax was revealed, were largely silent. Some Sikhs expressed annoyance with the youth, saying it cast their faith in a bad light. In a statement released Friday night, the boy said he didn't realize this incident would blow up the way it did: "My sincere apologies to my family, friends, the RCMP and overall community -- whose feelings I have hurt in this whole ordeal. I have to work very hard to rebuild the trust I lost." Thiessen said the case is being reviewed to decide if a criminal charge should be laid against the youth.

Re: Sikh teen's hair cut off in beating

Sister · 06 Jun 2005

Disgusting........slap the kid!

Re: Sikh teen's hair cut off in beating

Kulbir Singh · 06 Jun 2005

This is a sad day. We need to do something very fast to do parchaar of Sikhi. It seems that our kids have become so desparate to cut their hair that they are coming up with excuses as this one to cut hair. It tells you a lot about our parchaar of Sikhi. Each one of us should lead a life of parcharak to do parchaar of Gurmat. Kulbir Singh

Re: Sikh teen's hair cut off in beating

gondal baar · 06 Jun 2005

perhaps the kid never really felt sikhi or practiced it to feel why kes was important component in his meditation. Probably applies to those who keep kes only for identity or told to by their parents. Education would be a start and also helping the person to understand how keeping kes reading bani, and doing rehat all fall together in line. I see it as plant the seed into our monai brothers by just getting them to read bani and then the time will manifest itself when the call to keep their kes come. However when someone has kes all their life only for identity they are used to their ways functioning as an outer garb sikh but not internally. It is here we need to show them the beauty of gurmat path.

Re: Sikh teen's hair cut off in beating

s.singh · 07 Jun 2005

fateh everyone, i think this incident shows us that firstly we shudnt force our kids to keep their kesh cus no point in making them if they dont want to. the thing we have to do is educate them on why we keep our hair and tel them why hair is so important and then keeping their hair will have a meaning to them rather tehn just keeping it because their parents say. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Sikh teen's hair cut off in beating

Singh · 05 Jul 2006

This happened in langley aswell. A kid made up a story. It came in press, then he admitted it was all lies.