Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Dastaar vs. Hijaab

Dastaar vs. Hijaab

Roopkaur · 01 Jun 2005

Today, in one of my classes, we saw a presentation on the veil in Canada. During this presentation, one thing that came up was that the hijaab is seen by many as a way of oppressing women and keeping them in line. In both the quran and the bible, women are told to cover their head, and protect their modesty. But these same rules and regulations do not apply to the men of these religions. While I was sitting there, I thought to myself, it is only in the Sikh religion where both men and women have the same responsibilities to uphold. If a woman must be modest in her dress in Sikhi, so should a man. If a man must wear a turban, so should a woman. Everything a man can do, a woman can do in Sikhi. In comparision, while other religions end up giving more responsibilities to a woman, they give more rights to a man. But in Sikhi, not only do both genders have the same rights, they have the same responsibilities as well. Although I think it is better for women of other religions to cover their heads then go bareheaded, they are still inferior to their male counter parts. Only a Singhnee is equal to a Singh, there is no other dharm out there where a woman is equal. While it is a requirement for other religions to have head coverings, it is a RIGHT and a priveldge for a Sikh woman. I think it is high time all of my sisters out there accept their priveledge and rise to their true positions as princesses instead of acting as inferiors and submitting to the will of soceity. Dhan Gursikhi.

Re: Dastaar vs. Hijaab

kaur1 · 02 Jun 2005

wikid post! thanx for inspiration!

Re: Dastaar vs. Hijaab

Kulbir Singh · 02 Jun 2005

Excellent point Roop Kaur. I have seen many young Muslim women wearing hijab with pride, even though they don't have equality with men. But in Sikhi where there is equality and wearing of dastar is not a rehit only for men but for both men and women, still our bibiyaa are hesitating on wearing dastaars and becoming candidates of Guru Sahib's kirpa. Whether male or female, in Sikhi everyone is obligated to wear a dastaar. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Dastaar vs. Hijaab

? · 02 Jun 2005

i think times have changed and agreed jus like we have inequality issues pakistanis have too. But from what i see around me and believe me i live in a big muslim area they seem to have started adapting to change now, i think thats good their accomodatinhg religious requirements too and still have pride in their culture which we lack. The biggest thing hits me is apni kuriya not proud of the salwar kameez anymore and put on skirts instead. Im not saying tthat to single apniya out, but generally speaking apniya like to pretend they are goriyah and try to act and dress like them. Where is our pride gone? why are our gurls like that?

Re: Dastaar vs. Hijaab

ekta · 02 Jun 2005

Dastaar is not for modesty quite the opposite..its your crown...you are kings and queens of your domain.

Re: Dastaar vs. Hijaab

You · 03 Jun 2005

We acknowledge that God has created each sex to carry out and fulfil a specific role, where the clear demarcation between the two roles is plainly evident from their different nature and physical makeup. Is there any doubt concerning this simple fact? If we differ in our physical constitution then it stands to reason that God intended us to fulfil these respective roles in the best possible way. Therefore, it would be impossible for one to say that both man and woman are equal without establishing this a priori difference. Any wise person who has sat down and reflected without jumping on the pseudo-bandwagon of equality will come to the inevitable conclusion that the restrictions and regulations of two different people from different back grounds, cultures and age must differ. No one would establish parameters for their 6 year old as they would their 17 year old since both differ in their mental and physical makeup. How is it possible for us to recognise, acknowledge and implement this for ourselves, and yet discard it for the one who is all-Wise and all-Knowledgeable? How is it possible for someone to affirm that God created each sex upon a completely different and distinct physical constitution and yet established laws, regulations, allowances and restrictions equally for both The phrase: "Men are are Mars and Women are from Venus", holds true. In Islaam, women have a clearly different role to fulfil, for which God has given them a specifically tailored physical makeup, which differs to that given to men. Alongside this, He, from His perfect Wisdom, has revealed laws that differ in specific ways in relation to these respective roles. However, alongside these differing laws, there are other laws that are the same for other actions for which God has made no distinction between the two sexes, e.g. worship and education where each sex is treated equally both by the Creator, when he rewards them, and by the Muslims. Hence, it is unfair my friends, not to mention a display of ignorance, to allude that women have greater roles to fulfil, but less rights. This is simply not true. Although this is not the occassion to demonstrate this fact (since it would take a whole book in order to delineate this), what I will do is leave the speech of one of the scholars in order to further clarify and elaborate upon this issue, which for the critically minded Muslim is clear. What I will say is that there is more to this than meets the eye: The scholar states: This word – equality – which many thinkers in both the east and the west advocate in various fields of life is a word which is based on deviation and a lack of understanding, especially when the speaker attributes this idea of equality to the Qur’aan and to Islam. One of the things that people misunderstand is when they say that “Islam is the religion of equality”. What they should say is that Islam is the religion of justice. Shaykh Ibn ‘Uthaymeen (may Allaah have mercy on him) said: “Here we should note that there are some people who speak of equality instead of justice, and this is a mistake. We should not say equality, because equality implies no differentiation between the two. Because of this unjust call for equality, they started to ask, what is the difference between male and female?’ So they made males and females the same, and then the communists said, ‘What difference is there between ruler and subject? No one has any authority over anyone else, not even fathers and sons; the father has no authority over his son,’ and so on. But if we say justice, which means giving each one that to which he or she is entitled, this misunderstanding no longer applies, and the word used is correct. Hence it does not say in the Qur’aan that Allaah enjoins equality, rather it says (interpretation of the meaning): “Verily, Allaah enjoins Al‑‘Adl (i.e. justice)” [al-Nahl 16:90] “and that when you judge between men, you judge with justice” [al-Nisa’ 4:58] Those who say that Islam is the religion of equality are lying against Islam. Rather Islam is the religion of justice which means treating equally those who are equal and differentiating between those who are different. No one who knows the religion of Islam would say that it is the religion of equality. Rather what shows you that this principle is false is the fact that most of what is mentioned in the Qur’aan denies equality, as in the following verses: ‘Say: Are those who know equal to those who know not?” [al-Zumar 39:9] ‘Say: Is the blind equal to the one who sees? Or darkness equal to light?’ [al-Ra’d 13:16] ‘Not equal among you are those who spent and fought before the conquering (of Makkah, with those among you who did so later’ [al-Hadeed 57:10] ‘Not equal are those of the believers who sit (at home), except those who are disabled (by injury or are blind or lame), and those who strive hard and fight in the Cause of Allaah with their wealth and their live’ [al-Nisa’ 4:95] Not one single letter in the Qur’aan enjoins equality, rather it enjoins justice. You will also find that the word justice is acceptable to people, for I feel that if I am better than this man in terms of knowledge, or wealth, or piety, or in doing good, I would not like for him to be equal to me. Every man knows that he find it unacceptable if we say that the male is equal to the female.” Sharh al-‘Aqeedah al-Waasitah, 1/180-181 Based on this, Islam does not regard men and women as equal in matters where regarding them as equal would result in injustice to one of them, because equality that is inappropriate is a severe form of injustice. The Qur’aan commands women to wear clothes that are different from those worn by men, because of the differences in the ways each sex is tempted by the other. The temptation posed by men is less than the temptation posed by women, so the clothes that women should wear are different than the clothes that men wear. It makes no sense to tell women to expose the parts of the body that men are allowed to expose, because of the differences in the temptation posed by a woman’s body and a man’s body – as we shall explain. May God guide us towards the Truth and away from the whims and desires of man-invented philosophies which on the face of it may sound good, but when deconstructed and examined, fall flat on their face because: "What is there after Truth, except falsehood." (Al-Qur'an)

Re: Dastaar vs. Hijaab

jugroop singh · 03 Jun 2005

Dear Veer/Bhain 'You' ji, before i came into Sikhi, Islam was something which deeply interested me and attracted me; but when i read parituclar verses of Al Qu'ran, i could not accept that this was the 'Complete Truth'... i respect Al Qu'ran very much due to the wisdom contained within it, but i do not think it is perfect...why do i feel this? because whether we use the term equality/justice, the fact is that i can never accept that a husband has the right to 'beat' his wife...whether quite forcefully or quite 'lightly', as translations have put it. also, as a sidenote, i understand that according to some Hadith, The Prophet said that the Dastaar (turban) is that which is best for men. Let's assume that Hijab is a definite requirement for women - well, then if one is to follow the example of The Prophet which is seen as the best example by Muslims, then certainly male Muslims should wear the Dastaar, and not just let a few of their brothers (i.e. Imaams) keep this tradition alive. pls forgive me if i have upset you - that was not the intention.

Re: Dastaar vs. Hijaab

You · 04 Jun 2005

That would be veer 'You' I'm sad to see that Islam attracted you but wasn't enough to convince you of the Truth. Perhaps you didn't study its foundations of Tawheed (singling Allaah for all forms of worship), Shirk (forbiddance of associating partners in His worship), including the fact it calls mankind back to the correct of worship of God. Its mentioning of mankind originally being upon a singular guidance and worship before they differed and divided. The authenticity and preservation of the Qur'an (including its inimitability) and the Prophetic Sunnah. Its all-encompassing comprehensive law covering every aspect of life: "And We have sent down to you the Book (Qur'an) as an EXPOSITION of EVERYTHING. A guidance, a mercy and glad-tidings for those who have submitted themselves (to Allaah as Muslims [those who submit their will to the will and commandments of Allaah]). Verily Allaah commands al-'Adl (all that is just), and al-Ihsaan (all permissible things) and giving (help) to kith and kin. And He forbids al-Fahsha (all types of evil) and al-Munkar (all prohibited matters) and al-Baghy (all types of oppression). And He admonishes you that you may take heed." (an-Nahl 16:89-90) I will simply say: Keep your options open, be sincere towards the Truth, seek it with vigour and determination and: "Whomsoever Allaah Wills to guide He expands his breast towards Islaam..." (al-Qur'an) Further to your reasons, although much can be said about the correct interpretation of the oft-quoted and misunderstood verse concerning the so-called "beating" of the wife (nushooz), which would include an appeal of not reaching premature conclusions based upon a cursory overview of this verse, what I will say is: Were you acquianted with what the Truth was before you went on your discovery of it (in which case, your pursuit of it would be meaningless since you already what to look for and expect)? Or were you searching for a Truth that would conform to your own needs and expectations? If the answer to the above two questions is no, then you should submit to the Truth whether you like it or not. The Truth we speak of is singular and asbolute by definition. It may not be completely digestable to us initially, but the Truth is not so much at fault here as we are ourselves. Too often, especially in this day and age, we find people choosing "truth" like one chooses icecream - the tastiest flavour. Rather, Truth from our Lord should be seen as a medicine - even if the medicine is bitter one will take it knowing it will cure and restore his health. Perhaps you've forsaken the Truth from your Lord based upon this wrong idea that truth should be like icecream rather than medicine. As the Prophet Muhammad said: "Truth tastes bitter", which it does for many. An Islamic proverb states: Follow the Qur'an and do not let it be that the Qur'an should follow you. Your sidenote is interesting. I do not know of any authentic hadeeth which states that the best thing for a man is a turban. I have come across a hadeeth on some sites, although no source reference was given. Hence, the credibility of the hadeeth would be brought to question. Whatever the case, the Prophet wore many types of clothing from various parts of the Arab world. As long as the attire does not contravene the Islamic dress code, it can readily be adopted. The Prophet Muhammad's (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) wearing of the turban makes it at most permissible (mubah), but not obligatory (waajib). Hence, if one wishes, one can wear it. If not, then there is no harm in that. And Allaah knows best

Re: Dastaar vs. Hijaab

i dont wear a dastaar · 04 Jun 2005

while i agree its good to wear a dastaar, i still don't wear it.. i keep my head covered at all times.. its just that i dont know how to tie one.. i am challenged when it comes to such areas..and plus its very easy tying a ramaal..its only a matter of seconds..but i dont think people shold discriminate and theres many types of different rehats out there ie the taksaali rehit and the akj rehit..i have seen many stereotypes that if a sikh bibi wears a dastaar she is given more value..which is totally wrong because we should see everyone in the same light regardless of keski or not..i have seen many ramaal bibian that know their paath, have taken santhia and are parpak in their rehit..their also very suchet.. and then i have also seen some bibian that wear the keski for a fashion statement or just because they wear it.. wearing a keski does not make one superior...so im just saying that people shouldnt be too quick to judge.. i may have said something wrong in the process, and im not trying to justify me not wearing a keski, i just wanted to point some real misconceptions that we have today within the sikh society. bhul chuk maaf [%sig%]

truth and ice-cream

jugroop singh · 06 Jun 2005

Dear Veer 'You' Ji, thanks for your response... re: the bedrock PRINCIPLES regarding Islam; that's the very reason why Sikhi attracted me even more! my Siree Guru Sahib Ji tells me that a breath that does not get used to meditate and remember Tauhid (The One) is a breath wasted...my Siree Guru Sahib Ji also tells me not to associate anyone with The One regarding worship; to do so would be the surest spiritual death...and my Siree Guru Sahib Ji tells me about the most pristine form of worship...the Truest Submission - complete immersion into the Love of The One at all times...via thought, word and action. verily, to me Sikhi represents the most straight and unwavering path. re: AUTHENTICITY; that is another issue altogether and there are, as you may be aware, many viewpoints...however, it would be safe to say that we both believe that The Word, which is central to my faith, is unchanged within our respective faiths. re: keeping an OPEN MIND; i would say the same to you dear veer ji. to be Sikh is to be 'a student/disciple'...literally. re: the OFT QUOTED VERSE; please, if you do not mind, provide your interpretation...i would be very interested to hear it. re: being ACQUAINTED WITH MY 'TRUTH' PREVIOUS TO SEARCHING; there are many things that i have changed as a result of trying to understand and comprehend what my Siree Guru Sahib Ji teaches...i must eventually surrender my intellect...however, the rationale you have used is not sound; for instance perish the thought that someone found a scripture somewhere that said 'go out and rape women' i.e. physically/emotionally/spiritually hurt women... i certainly would tell them to take the 'tastier icecream'! i agree with you - Truth does often taste bitter...however, i would say that it may taste bitter in terms of us having to accept things about ourselves - not regarding hurting others. you wrote: 'Perhaps you've forsaken the Truth from your Lord based upon this wrong idea that truth should be like icecream rather than medicine'. i would say i don't think i have; it is up to you to ask this question of yourself...if you choose. also, i would be obliged if you respond to the following question: - do you accept Al Qu'ran in its entirety as a complete, unchanging set of Truths that are not time-specific i.e. whatever a Muslim is enjoined to do within any Surah (verse), s/he should do so forevermore? if you do not believe this, please tell me why by referring to specific Surahs and why you think they are time-specific as opposed to eternally relevant. thanks very much dear Veer Ji.

Re: Dastaar vs. Hijaab

Roopkaur · 06 Jun 2005

For "you". Even if we are to accept and agree that biologically men and women are built differently, that is just a physical difference, what basis do you have to differentiate between them spiritually? The aatmaa changes genders many times going through the cycle of life and death, but it itself stays the same, so spiritually both men and women should have the same rights and responsibilities. If Quran enjoins justice, then please tell me what is the justice in giving only one half (at most) of the property to a girl of what her brothers are given? What has that got to do with biology? How about the fact that while a man can get a divorce whenever he wants, a women has to have permission before the marriage to ask for divorce? If the aim here was justice, wouldnt women have been given more leeway here since they are the ones more likely to be mistreated because of societal pressures? And why are men able to marry 4 wives, where is the justice in that? Women in Arab societies were already treated badly, but wouldnt the fact that they had other counterparts fighting for their husbands attention ruin their situation instead of better it? How about slavery? Why is slavery permitted according to the Quran? There is nothing just in slavery. There is no doubt that all religions, except for Sikhi, keep women at a lower level. Also, you say that men and women are tempted by different things. I assume that is why a woman can never stand infront of a man while praying, because supposedly this would arouse a man when she bends down. But then why can a man stand infront of a woman? Why is it okay for a woman to be in a dangerous position? Does her spiritual state not matter? This is a pretty obtuse reason behind why the women in Islam are kept down so badly. It makes it seem as if women are kaamless things or objects, and the only people that matter are the men, so women must be controlled in order for the betterment of men. You also say we should submit to truth, whether we like it or not. But Truth is somehting unquestionable, it should take away our doubts, not create more in our minds. This type of truth is only found in the house of Sri GUru Nanak Dev Ji. And it is not bitter, but like bani tells us, there is no sweetness like it in this world. Truth, whether we find it bitter or sweet, should be infallible and complete. Yet there are so many problems in the koran and the Hadiths that need to be covered up through different analysis's because if we take them literally, we will realise that there is somwthing wrong there. The only perfect Truth is In Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, where there is nothing said that can be disputed because it is all pure Truth. How can it be truth to work piously for ones whole life just for the promise of sexual gratification in the next one? The problem with many doctrines we find is that although they may have a lot of spiritual goodness in them, they are all this worldy, based on tregunn. But we are aiming to realise the fourth gunn, which is not of this world. In order to achieve this, we need tools or materials to get us there that are also not of this world, but of the fourth gunn, and it is only through the apaar bakshis of satguru, who is the boat through which we can get to this fourth gunn, and bani and Naam, that we can get there. A doctrine of the world can only get us so far, and I think it is high time we all come into the sharn of the Satguru, the only person who is the Truth, and partake in the atut bhandar of Truth instead of wasting our life entangled in this world of only tregunns.

Re: Dastaar vs. Hijaab

hm · 06 Jun 2005

kiddah putt "you" so what is the truth dear brother? and how do you know it is the truth?

Re: Dastaar vs. Hijaab

Roopkaur · 06 Jun 2005

>i keep my head covered at all times.. its just that i dont know how to tie one..< if you live in Toronto, you should come to Tapoban Sahib where someone will happily teach you how to sajaa one. >but i dont think people shold discriminate and theres many types of different rehats out there ie the taksaali rehit and the akj rehit..< No one is discriminating. But whether you think keski is a kakaar or not, there is no doubt that a bibi is supposed to wear a dastaar. This is not discrimination bhenji, but fact. You raise a very good point that rehit really important, and wearing a dastaar in itself will not do much good without following the rest of rehit. But that goes for anything. Wearing a kirpan on its own will not do much good if you never do paath or you never go to the gurdvaraa etc. Same with wearing a karaa, many people who smoke, drink, go clubbing, think that by wearing that "magic" karaa around their wrist automatically makes them a Sikh, and they dont need to keep any other rehit, but we know that is not true. You are right that a just because a person is wearing a keski does not mean they are the best Sikh in the world. But, taking santhya and knowing their paath should also be accompanied with keeping rehit, and there is not doubt that the dastaar is part of the Sikh rehit, whether that Sikh is a bibi or a Singh. This is not discrimination. In fact, I would argue that the people who say that the dastaar is not necessary for a bibi are the ones that are discriminating. I mean, why should Singhs have the right and priviledge of always wearing a dastaar, and not a bibi? Isn't this taking away the right of Guru jis princesses to wear their crown? Why are we discriminating against our sisters, isntead of encouraging them to accept this crown?

Re: Dastaar vs. Hijaab

Mkhalsa · 06 Jun 2005

In reply to Roop Bhenjis original post, Dastar is not a right or priveledge (well it is) but morover, it is a RESPONSIBILITY!

Re: Dastaar vs. Hijaab

Hari Singh · 06 Jun 2005

Everytime I hear the name Tapoban I feel a longing to do darshan of the gurdwara sahib. I've heard so many stories about Tapoban and I'm humbled by the dedication that bibi's from Tapoban have. I personally wore pant and kameez to University but it must be an amazing sight to see young Khalsa's who attend universities, keep sarbloh rehit and are always dressed in Khalsa bana. I would suggest that all parents send their young ones to do sangat of these brilliant daughters and sons of Dashmesh Pita. They are an asset to the Sikh nation and are the ladlay of Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaj and it is our duty to do everything we can to support them. Well Done. May the Kalgianwalay keep his hand on your heads. Because it truly must be ... Truly I wish for nothing more then to see such young Sikhs everywhere.

Re: Dastaar vs. Hijaab

RoopKaur · 07 Jun 2005

To “you”, by spirituality I mean the aatmaa, loosely related to what you would called the ruh or life force. Although biologically we are different, the aatmaa or the life force within us is the same. Are you saying that muslim men are more prone to kaam or lust then women, that is why you have different rules? That is B.S. and deep down inside you know this too. Reincarnation is not just a Hindu concept, but fact that has been accepted by many groups and religions. The idea of the last judgement does not make sense. What would then happen to children that are born and immediately die? They did not have a chance to practice any religion, so who would judge them? The explanation that we all have karms that we have to pay off, and that there are many lives that we acquire to do so and that human life is the only life where we can advance, this reasoning makes absolute sense and has no loopholes, which is the way Truth should be, infallible. A doctrine of Truth should be able to adjust to any times, it should not be time specific. Yet the reasoning you give for more inheritance for men is based on a times specific model of the family. What if it is the wife that is bringing in the income? Why cannot she then get more inheritance? Why must the inheritance only be dispensed equally if there are no males? This is dumb reasoning, because even though men traditionally were the breadwinners, the money is the family’s, not just the man of the family’s, and a woman getting inheritance would use that family for her family as well. Why can a male in the family get inheritance for his family, but a female in the family cannot get inheritance for her family. And what if they are not married? What is the reasoning then? If you say women turn men on, that is why they should be covered, then men should be covered as well, since they can turn women on. A female has to have a solid reason for filing divorce if she wants to, and this reason must be approved by a Qazi, who are male. But a man does not have to have a good reason, if he even suspects (or pretends to suspect) that there is something wrong with his wife, he is able to get a divorce. There is no justice in this, and you cannot deny that fact. A women is already treating lowly in most cultures, when Islam allows three other women to come into the household as wives of the same husband, this is injustice not only to the wives, but the children of these wives who must compete for attention. Not to mention the concubines that are permitted by Sharia law for a man. That is totally disgusting, the fact that Muslim men are allowed concubines to gratify their sexual pleasure within their religious doctrine. In Sikhi, marriage is not just a contract, like Islam, it is an enjoining of two souls. Sikhi is not a religion that promotes lust and sexual gratification like Islam does. We as Sikhs are to fight against this evil, not allow it through religious doctrine. As for situations like the ones you mention, in Islam it is only the men that fight, while in Sikhi both men and women fight in wars. Even if a woman stays at home during war, the main aim in a Sikhs life again is not sexual gratification, it is to meet Akaal Purkh. Although masturbation is not allowed in Sikhi, I am not surprised that it is not allowed in Islam either, where would you find the need for it after your four wives, and concubines, not to mention all that dirt and filth promised to you in your afterlife. In Sikhi, sex is not the main focus, like it seems to appear in Islam from your description. Your description of why a women must never lead prayers or always stands in the back reinforces my assertion that Islam thinks of women as asexual objects. What if a women is distracted from her prayers while staring at the males in front of her? Of course that does not matter, because it is the males who must not waiver, who gives a crap about whether the women can concetrate or not. You claim that eastern religions have lost in touch with reality. I cannot vouch for other religions, but from Sikhi, I think your biggest mistake is that you think this world in fact is reality. That is the problem with your doctrine, it is so focused on worldy pleasures, even your afterlife consists of worldy pleasures, which are nothing compared to the spiritual anand a Sikh enjoys when they have reached those stages. As for slavery, there are other alternatives that could be given to them, instead of this excuse of slow eradication. When any of the Satguru Ji’s saw any wrong being done, they did not say, we will stop this slowly, they stopped it right then. For example, the practice of sati, they did not say, ok first give them more choice, they can choose the clothes they want to wear while they jump into the pyre, and they can choose which side of the pyre they want to jump on. They condemned this practice whole heartedly without any exception. That does not mean that sati stopped immediately, but it does stand that Sikhs condemn this practice and do not practice it. We do not use sorry excuses like you who says that Mohummed wanted to eradicate this problem slowly. And why must a slave earn their freedom? Instead of us paying the worker for doing work for us, this process turns this around and the worked has to pay the ‘workee’ so to speak. The issue here is not the treatment of the slaves, but they should not have been allowed in the first place. Instead of marrying them, why could not the captivator accept them as daughters and secure a house for them? It is because this idea that foreign women are daughters, not sex objects, is not an idea familiar to your people.

but there are too many worms...

jugroop singh · 07 Jun 2005

Dear Veer 'You' ji, thanks for the many translations which presumably have ben cut-and pasted from various sources - i wanted to read your interpretation of the verse though... however that said, none of the verses seem to contradict the notion that it is ok to beat your wife, in some circumstances, while being a good muslim - i wonder what the Islamic angle is regarding a woman beating her husband within certain circumstances ofcourse...this is a question of 'mutual justice' and not 'equality' in case you were wondering... - re: my question about an 'unchanging eternal truth'; at one point, verses spoken by Satan were accepted by Muslims as part of the Revelation; what did those Muslims do when they were eventually told by The Prophet that these verses were from the Devil, via new verses? i ask this because my faith would be seriously shaken if my Siree Guru Sahib Ji became subject to the 'whims' of the devil...if The Prophet became a believer in idol worship AFTER being raised to the pedestal of The Seal of The Prophets - The Final Messenger, then that raises serious questions in my mind...and please don't mention 'tasty ice-cream' (i'm vegan). and additionally, - are women allowed to say Talaaq three times, during a 'temporary marriage', as men are allowed to in order to nullify the marriage...again, i ask for purposes of assessing the 'justice' and not 'equality' aspect. - another thing that surprised me about Islam is that within Al Qu'Ran it is written in a particular Surah (2:256): "There is no compulsion in religion". This is to me is an Eternal Truth, and something i totally agree with. However, what is your position, given the fact that Sha'riah, which you seem to accept, encourages the stoning to death of those who leave the religion of Islam? -and it would be interesting to get your perspective regarding a Perfect Revelation and how it does not condemn slavery... i would appreciate it if your response is a little bit more concise than your latest postings, and qualifies YOUR opinion and not the opinion of another scholar, via another scholar, via another scholar/witness etc. thanks in advance Dear Veer Ji.

Re: Dastaar vs. Hijaab

Admin · 07 Jun 2005

"You", please respond with concise and brief responses as opposed to copying pasting from Islamic sites. We had to take out your posts as they were too long and no one has time to read 10,000 words of Islamic literature. We have taken out the derogatory reference to Hazrat Mohammad written by "Search for Tat". Please refrain from using derogatory terms for founders of other religions. Admin.

Re: Dastaar vs. Hijaab

You · 07 Jun 2005

I'm afraid I cannot carry on this discussion without giving detailed explanations in order to provide a full picture of what the correct understanding, and thus, the Truth is. In doing so, I will be able to dispel the doubts and misunderstandings many people have about Islaam and, likewise, expose the shortcomings of the religions of falsehood. Khayr insha'Allaah. I pray Roopkaur and Jugroop Singh (who did read my long explanations) understood that there is more to Islaam than meets the eye. Perhaps they will look into it further and reflect over what they are following before the angel of death comes to take their souls. Thereafter, there will be no second chances. Apologies if I caused any offense. None was intended. I simply wanted a delve into a dispassionate dialogue in an attempt to shed light on many lies and half truths spread around the many websites concerning this religion of the Prophets and Messengers, al-Islaam Wasalaam

Re: Dastaar vs. Hijaab

Punjab Singh · 07 Jun 2005

FATEH SADH SANGAT JEO..... Just wanted to ask a quick question that a lady at work asked me and it somewhat relates to this topic.. She asked me if my dastar is a must and i must keep my hair covered at all times..... why do i not cover my beard and leave it open and exposed?? Please advise?

Re: Dastaar vs. Hijaab

heera panna · 07 Jun 2005

although i believe in sikhi 100% and our faith will never be shaken in guru ji i welcome "you" to this website and his or her trying to explain their religion better it helps break misunderstandings. I do wish the posts were smaller, found them interesting and hope "you" can just cut down the words a bit and carry on the talk. where i think you had a point in regds to women being different physically at all times i believe women were as you described mentally different with different emotional patterns, but that is time and culture conditioned . But that changes in the society they live in. Women are much more confident now. I have female managers and work colleagues and believe me most of them are mentally tough like guys, one threatened to knock my block off after i pissed her off lol and believe me shes twice the size of me. However i have seen guys with real weedy mentalities, strange as it might seem sometimes it feels like women are getting more mentally stronger and brauny like "geezer gurls" and guys are becoming more in touch with their feelings and emotional side. Seeing what i have i do not believe your point that women are in any way weaker or less than a man but have seen society change where once women felt inferior, low and helpless in the society around them because thats how things were then. Ok brother here is a question for you. Perhaps back in Peer Sahib Mohammed Jis days women were homely dependant on mans labour. But today in uk at least the labour market is significantly reduced and replaced with the service industry and cheap labour imports from abroad. Women have entered the same service industry as men and are just as successful now so they can support themselves if their husband either divorced them, died early, or was killed in a battle. So under such changing situation now would it be vital for a woman to marry again? Slavery is bondage brother, in other aspects of anything not in agreement with islam, islam speaks out in clear words i am sure if it was enjoined slavery was wrong then islam would totally forbid it. [%sig%]

Re: Dastaar vs. Hijaab

heera panna · 08 Jun 2005

dear brother you ji i have another question for you out of curiosuity. I understand circumcision is part of many cultures, however i am interested in finding out why it is vital in islam? i have heard the word purity being mentioned but need more clarity if you could help. is it for spiritual reasons? or matters related to the body? I myself am aware that cousin marriages appear to be cultural more so in pakistan than say turkish immigrants, could you just clear up the confusion whether it is a cultural or religious practice?

Re: Dastaar vs. Hijaab

jugroop singh · 08 Jun 2005

Dear Veer 'You' Ji, you wrote: '..I will be able to dispel the doubts and misunderstandings many people have about Islaam and, likewise, expose the shortcomings of the religions of falsehood'. > even though i do not believe in many things Islam teaches, i still have a level of respect for it and would never call it, generally speaking, a 'religion of falsehood'. that is very offensive and in my humble opinion shows the the very low level of spirituality you have attained. insh'allaah, you will be blessed with a higher level of spirituality, whereby you wil not feel the need to utilise fee your nafs/ego by dismissing other people's beliefs so ignorantly... however, i am still interested in any response you may want to provide regarding the questions i have posed. namely: - re: about an 'unchanging eternal truth'; at one point, verses spoken by Satan were accepted by Muslims as part of the Revelation; what did those Muslims do when they were eventually told by The Prophet that these verses were from the Devil, via new verses? i ask this because my faith would be seriously shaken if my Siree Guru Sahib Ji became subject to the 'whims' of the devil...if The Prophet became a believer in idol worship AFTER being raised to the pedestal of The Seal of The Prophets - The Final Messenger, then that raises serious questions in my mind...and please don't mention 'tasty ice-cream' (i'm vegan). - are women allowed to say Talaaq three times, during a 'temporary marriage', as men are allowed to in order to nullify the marriage...again, i ask for purposes of assessing the 'justice' and not 'equality' aspect. - another thing that surprised me about Islam is that within Al Qu'Ran it is written in a particular Surah (2:256): "There is no compulsion in religion". This is to me is an Eternal Truth, and something i totally agree with. However, what is your position, given the fact that Sha'riah, which you seem to accept, encourages the stoning to death of those who leave the religion of Islam? -and it would be interesting to get your perspective regarding a Perfect Revelation and how it does not outrightly condemn slavery... ps - can people act more maturely and not make immature relarks about The Prophet; if you are genuinely interested in or want to discuss Islam, please communicate with Veer 'You' ji maturely...by not taking cheap shots.

Re: Dastaar vs. Hijaab

Rabh De Lokh Sareh · 09 Jun 2005

peace "you" pravah we welcome our veer here. I am sorry on behalf of the sikhs that some idiot called Prophet Mohammed Ji a bad name earlier, this is not at all reflective of practicing sikhs however some ignorant people always surface up here and there on all sides. In fact Sant (saint) harnam Singh an old sikh dedicated to the service of sikhism and part revolutionary in the sikh struggle just before 1984 had darshan of Prophet Mohammed Ji. Book Se kineyah pages 253 " One day Babaji was in deep concentration of highly elevated conciousness The Great Christ, Mohammed Sahib and Brigh Rishi gave their glimpses. They had spiritually radiant faces having auras around their heads". This shows us that sikhs at higher levels had regard for other prophets, contrary to what ignorant people say. Illumined glow in sikh terms means someone with kamai. Sant Harnam singh was a product of daily prayers nitnem and derived everything he had through meditation and truthful living upon the sikh path and still had darshan of Prophet Ji. i would like to ask you however you interpret truth? have you ever read any passages of Guru Granth sahib ji? I would like to understand if you consider sikhism as false and if so on what basis? is that basis based on research upon sikhism? or simply reading the Quran sharif and then stating all others are false? This morning i switched on to islam channel on sky for morning prayers to understand a little bit more about what the Quran says. I came across a mesmerising passionate voice. The voice was reciting passages from the Quran mentioning the praises and qualities of the Creator but more so about believers and infidels. How would you define an infidel? Islam teaches a person to remember God as formless and his qualities right? waking up at 4am and doing prayers right? If a sikh does all of that, in addition to being told to remember God as much as they can with minimum 2.5 hours a day of meditation towards God how would they qualify to be infidel? The name Allah is a name of God. We all come from different pieces of land where the language is different. If i say Waheguru you say Allah an englishman says God is our Creator not the same entity? when all three of us will pray to a formless God and believe in living truthful lives and helping others trying to focus our lives the right way. surely the errior belongs to a person and how he she interprets a divine message. On the karma belief versus one life belief. I would like to ask brother where does a soul come from where does it go? If we had only one life then these souls must be coming from somewhere right? why do they continue coming if the result was from adam and eve? why are some people better off while others are not? how would you then interpret kismet? is that not similar to karma? how then is everything ordained in such a way? God is justice right? so why would God have a different test for one person and different for another especially if they only get one life? what did they do to deserve a bad life? that then means humans are not born equal. I was in a bus yesterday a thought came to me when the bus went past a pub. the person who owns it is probably loaded earning huge money, selling forbidden things , owning a large chunk of land and doing something he she enjoys. Then theres me doing night shifts day shifts, waking up all hours, earning probably a tenth of what he earns knowing that life ahead will be a struggle not worrying just reflecting. That person has quality time to spend with his her kids while i will be out working. How can this be seperate "fates" for each human? why would God bless someone who does wrong with resources ( distributing forbidden intoxicant) over another if this is just one life? The perfect answer came to me that this was his or her karm they only benefitted from it from somewhere. When their karm runs out they will depart and not be in that position again. On the topic of booze i recall you said there are pleasures on earth summit like why not enjoy them up there in paradise? so then why is alcohol forbidden here but not up in paradise then? alcohol effects in large consumption leades to decay in families, increased ego, and usually voilence. anyhow i hope you come back i would like to talk to you.

Re: Dastaar vs. Hijaab

Princess · 09 Jun 2005

////// She asked me if my dastar is a must and i must keep my hair covered at all times..... why do i not cover my beard and leave it open and exposed?? ///// Punjab singh veer jeeo, tell her that our father Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee is The King of kings(universe) and we, his children are princes and princesses. Dastaar is our crown and crown is to wear on head not under the chin.

Re: Dastaar vs. Hijaab

Princess · 09 Jun 2005

//// If we differ in our physical constitution then it stands to reason that God intended us to fulfil these respective roles in the best possible way. Therefore, it would be impossible for one to say that both man and woman are equal without establishing this a priori difference. //// Need clearification from "you" on following issues. 1) What about covering head and face of women and not of men when they both have same kind of head with hair, forehead, two eyebrows, two eyes, one nose and one mouth. Is that because of the difference of beard? 2) Why a muslim male can marry four women and a woman can't? Both have different bodies but equal physical ability to have four or more partners. Dropdi had five husbands and they all were happy with her. 3) Why women's vote is counted half than men? How it's related to physical differences? 4) What a muslim gets at the end by following Islam? Is not that beautiful ladies? Did we get this precious life to do this kind of besharmi or to meet God? Any one who wants beautiful women, can have anytime while living in this world and by not following any religion then why one needs to follow Islam? Come on "you", search for truth, don't waste your amol life in [gurbani]kUV ][/gurbani] [%sig%]