Re: Who Killed Chamkila???
sunny hounslow ealing uk · 02 Jun 2005
i think chamkilla was killed at a village mesampur district jalandher by the kcf
Re: Who Killed Chamkila???
dusta da dust · 03 Jun 2005
kuldeep manak and lal chand yamla jatt sang much better songs. Chamkila could have been good if his songs related more to sikhi with the vulgra crap out. Its a shame because he was talented but we cant have ganth being spread which is a soft way to describe those songs. Some of chamkilas songs were like soft porn they had to stop.
i love manaks voice it would have been wicked if he stuck to dharmic songs my best ones were "ooj de jajaru khalsey", " " jhaga jhaga jhandhai kesari " from manak and "meeri peeri dah malik" and slow motion " din basakhi da lokho" by yamla.
If these two guys were singhs in a rensbhai it would be a dream come true to listen to these do shabads cos they sang from the heart man they would electrify it.
(manaks dharmic songs got me into sikhi).
[%sig%]
Re: Who Killed Chamkila???
sunny hounslow ealing uk · 03 Jun 2005
chamkilla and his female artist i think her name was amarjit kaur were killed while geting ot of there car at a wedding at village mesumpur district jalandher by some top hitmen of kcf panjwar
Re: Who Killed Chamkila???
Kulbir Singh · 03 Jun 2005
Before getting killed Chamkila came to Toronto and sang religious songs in Malton Gurdwara Sahib and I think Dixie Gurdwara Sahib too. I was there to listen to him. He was very humble and promised to give up singing bad songs and promised to sing more religious songs.
The religious songs that he sang were just great. His song "Saatho Baba kho liya tera Nanakana" was a really well written and well sung song. He used to write his own lyrics. Another one of his song which too was written by him is an imaginative conversation between the wall that buried younger Sahibzaadey and the poet. Amazing song it was.
Chamkila was not the only one who used to sing bad songs. Which singer did not sing bad songs? Even Surinder Kaur, the nightingale of Punjab could not stay away from singing bad songs ( duets with Didar Sandhu). There is no doubt that these bad songs were destrying our culture but the way to stop these songs was not to kill the singers. Militants had numerous options on hand and they should have exhausted other means before resorting to this final mean.
I think Chamkila would have reformed if he had been given a chance. I am not sure if militants killed him but if they did, it was their shortsightedness. Some militants (there were only a minority of such militants) determined death to be the punishment of every offense. I don't think his little falterings warranted a death sentence and it is such actions as this one that took away from militants the sympathy of the common person.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Who Killed Chamkila???
jugroop singh · 04 Jun 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Sadh Sangat Jio,
if it was 'Sikh militants' that killed him, then that was obviously out-of-order and blatantly anti-GurMat. it would also raise another issue...
a Singh and myself were discussing the other day that to become a genuine Khalsa Jujharoo, one would have to have an excellent and pretty immaculate Jeevan; strict Naam Abhiyaas, Nitnem, Paath, Seva etc.
if 'Sikh Jujharoos' did kill Chamkila, then it shows that atleast some involved in the Panthic struggle did not have such a GurSikhi Jeevan...that is why i respect the original BKI philosophy; 'if you haven't managed to get your basic Jeevan in order, please do not consider becoming a Jujharoo'.
Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh once said to a rich person who followed their cart, as it left a village, that they should come back and feel free to use his money to do more Kirtan, Parchaar etc. Bhai Sahib asked him 'did you do your Nitnem this morning'. he had not done so...imho, i think Bhai Sahib was getting this person to explore a root issue...
Seva cannot become Sufal (frutiful/meaningful) when it has not been given the chance to become Sufal...when the Jeevan is lacking, their is no water to noursih the field of Seva and so it either does not grow, or its growth is stunted or (in the case of Chamkila's murderers, assuming they were 'Jujharoos'), it comes out all twisted, gnarled and perverse. such Seva can only be described as Seva of the Mun...not Seva of Siree Guru Sahib Ji.
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: Who Killed Chamkila???
Manjit Kaur Sidhu · 04 Jun 2005
I KILLED CHAMKILA.... the day i threw all his tapes in the GUTTER behind my house.
Re: Who Killed Chamkila???
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 04 Jun 2005
[gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani]
veer jugroop singh jio,
i couldnt agree more with your views. a genuine jhujaroo/kharrkoo would have the JEEWAN first. This is the reason we DONT HEAR any such tales about the KHALSA JI of 1708...and after.. They had JEEWAN and were Naam bahiyasees with Bhau and Bhaeh [gurbani] Bwau - BY [/gurbani]
The trouble thsi time was that the GOI/RAW etc infiltrated the Kharrkoo Movement and these peopel committed these anti social criems to blacken the name of the lehr and defeat it from within. Once the POPULACE withdrew support...the genuine khaarrkoos also had no life line...whcih was what the GOI planned all along..ISOLATE and ELIMINATE.
[gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani]
[%sig%]
Re: Who Killed Chamkila???
interesting · 06 Jun 2005
someone wrote
I KILLED CHAMKILA.... the day i threw all his tapes in the GUTTER behind my house.
what were u doing with those tapes in the first place
Re: Who Killed Chamkila???
JARNAIL SINGH GYANI "ARSHI" · 11 Jun 2005
a lot of "personal scores" were settled during those turbulent times..THis is a FACT. Brothers killed Brothers over Land divisions and blamed it on Kharrkoos....Sons killed off Fathers over Land sales..and blamed it on kharrkoos.... so it is very plausible that this chamkila guy was bumped off by his salleh for doing the thigns he did...and they got away in the dust of kharrkoo kharrkoo margey margey...or by the ever ready police to malign the kharrkoos..
Anyway thats all old history...always happens in such times.. Thousands of GENUINE SIKH YOUTHS disappeard without trace.... what about them ??