Skirts
singhneeeeeee! · 29 Aug 2003
i am female amridhari sikh and i wnat to know if its ok to wear skirts, not the short ones but the long ones to my ankles. my dad says i cant but i dont see anythign wrong with them. is there?
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
singhneeeeeee! · 29 Aug 2003
i am female amridhari sikh and i wnat to know if its ok to wear skirts, not the short ones but the long ones to my ankles. my dad says i cant but i dont see anythign wrong with them. is there?Balpreet Singh · 29 Aug 2003
I'd say it's best not to argue with your father over such a trivial issue. A chola is a bit like a skirt and maybe that is something you should consider: looks good and lets you follow Gurmat BaaNaa at the same time.Knower · 29 Aug 2003
I think you should listen to your father on this one. In Punjabi society, skirts are not considered appropriate.Kulbir Singh · 29 Aug 2003
>> my dad says i cant but i dont see anythign wrong with them. is there? >>>> Her question is not whether she should listen to her father or not. I think her question is that, is ankle length skirt an inappropriate dress..... · 29 Aug 2003
If we think logically and compare wearing of ankle length skirt with wearning of pants, then I personally think that there is nothing wrong with ankle length skirt.mememe · 29 Aug 2003
We should try hard to embrace Gurmukhi dress, not Western styles. If a skirt-like type of garment is what you're looking for, go for a cholaa. It's way more comfortable and easier to move around in too. It'll keep your identity as a Singhnee intact while also allowing for better coverage. Moreover, we should dress in such a way that we'd be comfortable going to sangat dressed as we are at any time. I don't think a skirt would be too comfortable in sangat (hard to sit in, etc).SIngh · 29 Aug 2003
A singhni in a chola. lol. when i see that ive seen it all. I would not recommend you to wear a skirt NOT for reason that its bad or that against culture because guru ji has already put a stop to false practices. I've to my mates that are females, they asked me if it is ok to wear skirts, i said No, because if you are in a skirt you are more vunrable to an attack. You can run as fast, you can be raped easily. You are a sitting target. On the other hand, i didnt want to hurt their feeling to much so i continued to say. If you wish to wear a long skirt, get one with a slit. that way you can still run, if the need may be. Gursikhi, doesnt comment on what you need to wear to get to god. Dress appropriatly to where you feel confortable. You came to this world naked, you will leave naked. Wear what you heart desires, but remember that if you are a SIkh, what you wear will refelct on the whole of the Sikh Nation, Not just on you. Take your fathers choice into consideration, he is your father and has looked after you since you have been a little girl. He point is valid, even though you may not understand it. My final point it, If you wish to wear, be practical, if you dont, dont.Mkhalsa · 29 Aug 2003
uve never seen a singhnee in a chola?! :O are u living under a rock?? heheBalpreet Singh · 29 Aug 2003
>>>>>>>> "A singhni in a chola. lol. when i see that ive seen it all. >>>>>>>> Well, to "see it all" I suggest you come any day to Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib. There are many many bibis in cholas. Many among them stay in a chola at all times ie. to gurdwara and to school and at home. I have so much respect for all of them and I think they are setting an example for the Sikh women of the entire Panth to follow. But please do come and "see it all".Tejwant Singh · 30 Aug 2003
As Guru Sahib said " Rehat piyaree mujh koh, Sikh piyarah nahin". Lets Contemplate on the above for a for moments and find out how GURMAT wants us to conduct our lives as GURMUKHS. What it shows us that our deeds make our creed which is Sikhi, not vice versa. In other words Sikhi is based on the Bhavnah-sikh's true intentions - and Rehat is its fruit. So Sikhi is NOT whether one wears a punjabi dress or a western style one -as Sikhi is the only universal religion so way of dressing is irrelevant- as long as the skirt or the dress is comfortable and not enticing to the lustful eyes. On the other side the lustful eyes should also follow GURMAT and through GURBANI should train themsleves not get enticed with these small silly things. Nirbhau-Nirvair Tejwant SinghNO one · 31 Aug 2003
I think you should do wateva you feel like, so long as yur intentions are correct..... not all ppl are capable of wearing bana/chola 24/7, and just becuase yur dad is stuck in the past with his indian culture doesn't mean that you have to be as well........ most skirts are less revealing/tight than pants nowadays..... let yur heart guide you, if its pure, you will make the right decision.Looking Good · 31 Aug 2003
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh My wife wears an ankle-length skirt (togather with a pyjama) - even to semagams in India. So far noone has any complains about that.... · 31 Aug 2003
i was once told to dress ur self in the way that u would dress to meet the guru.. so ask ur self the question .. would it b aaceptable to wear woteva in front of guru sahib?.. if not then u shuldnt... · 31 Aug 2003
Waheguru jee ka Khalsa, Waheguru jee ke Fateh!! You can not stop lustfull eyes, even if you are in chola lustful eyes will be there. The only thing we can do is that we should at least dress appropiately so that we don't give more chance to lustful eyes. I am sure that a Singh/Singhni in sikhi dress from outside and inside has an "KAAR" around and there is nothing to worry about an attack. It is very important that instead of focussing only on external rehat, we should focus much on internal rehat and doing so Guru sahib jee will give you 'SOOJIE' about good and bad choices. Personally, if you can wear a pant at work then there is nothing wrong in wearing an ankle-length skirt. The only thing i will agree is that you should not make ourselves a target of attack. Concentrate more on internal rehat and Guru sahib jee will guide you.MSK · 31 Aug 2003
Although I usually have pretty strict ideas on Sikhi i really dont see whats wrong with a skirt......it wouldnt suit my mom or sister but if its down to ur feet if you want to then wear it......but trousers are better obviously.someone · 03 Sep 2003
make sure legs are covered and skirt is not tight fittingSardaro.. · 03 Sep 2003
I dont think singhnees should wear normal jeans/pants that girls out there wear.. clothes made for girls these days are WAY too revealing and tight!! I see too many singhnees these days wearing jeans that just show everything (without skin showing, they are just so tight) or they wear these tops where the sleeves are very short or the bottom of the top is so short there may be a gap between shirt and pants.. personally i find it disgusting and dont think singhnees should wear any clothes made for girls in the west.. i do know of some singhnees who wear tshirts from mens section or baggier jeans than normal.. and those look ok and less revealing.. but i think we should stay away from a lot of western clothes that are only made to be revealing and "sexy"..yeah · 04 Sep 2003
i also think singhs should follow the same rules... i personally think it looks pretty dumb to see a singh wearing a muscle shirt or whatever else... if girls should dress respectfully and not show skin, or anything revealing, as "sardaro" says, shouldnt it be the same for men? hmmm.......Balwinder Kaur · 04 Sep 2003
VAAHEGUROO JEE KA KHALSAA VAAHEGUROO JEE KI FATEH!!!!! Hmm very interesting topic put forth by bhainjee. Personally I feel its okay to wear a skirt so long as its ankle-length and is conservative. It's sad to see that clothes made for ladies nowadays dont serve their proper functions nowadays. I personally have resorted to getting tops and jeans/pants from the men's section as they are long and baggy unlike the types sewn for ladies which are simply HORRID and way too tight. :s However nothing beats wearing a bana. :) Guruji didn't give us a bana for no reason...so as far as possible...IF U CAN...try to wear a bana. I think if you're living in Canada you're quite lucky as there should be no problem as whites are fairly open minded and there are soooo many other singhs/singhnees who wear bana all the time. So you don't feel alone or out of place. :) Unlike here in Asia,where u get stared at even if you're wearing a keski(i've gotten weird stares from passers-by on the street but ultimately it doesn't matter as i dress for myself and Guruji)....much less wear a chola with all your shasters out. [%sig%]SIngh · 04 Sep 2003
Sardaro, from your suggestion, it seem to be the fact the you want singhnees to wear Burkas. (muslim veil) They cover up their women so no other man can see them in a lustful way. I.e They have given into Kaam. Remember, they let Kaam control them and therefore made their women wear bukas. We as sikhs, dont let kaam control us, We CONTROL it. I.e we dont need to make Singhnees walk around Until WE feel confortable.Sardaro.. · 04 Sep 2003
SIngh i agree with you.. BUT we do need modesty.. and I agree that men should also have this modesty, i was just pointing out problems with western clothes.. i dont think singhnees need to "cover themselves up".. but i think singhs AND singhnees should have modesty in the clothes they wear.. therefore tight jeans/top or muscle shirt for guys etc is just not acceptable.. we are showing off our bodies in these.. why?SIngh · 04 Sep 2003
point taken. I get where you comming from. all the people in the tank tops, go to your local charity.NO one · 05 Sep 2003
FATEh i think ppl need to chill wid the girls enticing kaam wid their clothing, i dont think ANY sikh girl dresses to be sexy...... to look good maybe, but thats about it..... and men are the same, wear suits and all sorts to look good, if a girl likes jeans let them wear it and i seriously think ppl worry too much about kaam!, if u get kaam looking at a singhnee then fix yurself, doint ask them to change for yur inadequacies.... and im a guy , and i normally only wear a pair of board shorts and i get around like that, i go to the beach , drive around, even gone to shops..... now u may think this is odd, but i live in a weston society where no thinks anything of it! no one cares, no one has kaami thoughts, but yet if a singhnee sees me, yur saying she might??? maybe some sikhs have more kaam than white ppl!! who knows....warrior*princess · 05 Sep 2003
Sikhi is the only unique religion around. Our every moment should be a potrayal of that as possible. LOL - veer ji said 'all the people in the tank tops, go to your local charity.' Tight and revealing clothing shouldnt be worn - this applies for both genders. It does look very bad and gives Sikhi bad name. Attracts wrong attension from perverts. One can still wear the clothes they like but with a sensible and sophisticated look without being revealing! e.g. a real life situation, there was a report of a rape by a female...but when they showed her pic, that day she was wearing a mini-skirt. And she was out after 10pm on her mission to a club. What we sow is what we reap. Guru Nanak Dev ji says so. So we should take caution and be responsible. Anyway what looks more pure and within Sikhi. How can tight n revealin clothes be okay???? Do we gain any virtues as per Sikhi by wearing tight clothes? However you dress, you will attract those kind of people and attention only. It is not possible to walk around in a chola in this society so we can at least dress appropriately and always keep in bana/rehit. Guru Nanak Dev ji said we must dress simple. I doubt tight fitting clothes comes under this category! Otherwise our Sikhi is not better of than other peoples lifestyle. Guru ji's ways are amazing and they totally & automatically mould ones ways into the Right way. So point being lets take amrit, abide by rehit, be gurmat, do more swas gras, more banee/paht, wake at amrit velaa and Guru ji will guide us!G · 05 Sep 2003
singhs shouldnt wear muscle shirts? thats one of the funniest things i have heard... i tell you ones who are fat ***admin cut*** should not wear them no one wants to see there fat hanging outSomeone · 06 Sep 2003
who cares if she wants to wear a skirts, i know some people that wear them, at first i was like wth, but now its just like who cares... let them wear them, i wouldnt wera them though.......but yeahhh anyways do whatever u want oh and yea, muscle shirts are gay and skirts are okay hahahmodern singh · 27 Apr 2005
i think we should think beyond the cloths n rules of religion. Honesty truthfulness , n be ur self r more important than dress issue . baki baba jee bhi keh gaiee aa JAISA DESH WAISA BESH"DUKKI TEEKI · 27 Apr 2005
I think skirts are worn by girls who are allowed by parents in sikh families as the above line shows such behaviour is common to the whole family.I mean you can see the whole family and then look at your self.As for the size i have seen girls doing kirtan in a gurdwara and trying to show a different self and then going to a bank dressed in skirt i should say a mini that was so tight and high i could not believe the hypocracy.I knew her answer that they were a western family ( modern) but then i looked at the whole family and came to the conclusion of her dress. I think the question itsilf is typical and the answer is witihin yourself.MKaur · 27 Apr 2005
Its funny because my brother asked me this question one day. "Do you think its ok for SInghnia to wear long skirts?" I thought about it and I really couldn't think of why it would be WRONG. Think about it, a long skirt would be waaaay more modest than pants. I even know of some religion where the women are only allowed to wear skirts because they are modest. At the same time I think we Singhnia should wear something underneath so the legs aren't showing. Knee high boots perhaps or like a pajamee thingi especially if theres a slit. I don't think anything is wrong with it. They are not excepted in our society because skirts are just viewed to be straight up for BAD GIRLS. Thats ridiculous though. Also, everyone always says that you shouldn't follow western ideas n blah blah blah. But what if you were born and raised in a Western society! Thats all you know. Like myself, I would probably be considered more western than I don't know Punjabi? because I'm more open minded about things. Thats just how we're raised? Especially my father he's been living in Canada for soo long he's become MORE "OPEN MINDED" THAN I AM or westernized whatever you want to call it. Enough said, the dressing issue, IMHO dress however you like as long as its modest and you have no bad intentions. Keep your head focussed in gurmat and you'll never dress inappropriate no matter what you wear. BUT I have to say a Singhni won't look as beautiful as she will in Bana. I went to Tapoban and also dressed in a chola for the first time and it felt sooo goood. Every Singhni should strive to wear bana all the time. Or atleast at home and stuff. Its so comfortable anyway. I know I will:)majboor · 27 Apr 2005
How about redesigning the chola to look more like a dress, without shoulder straps, pockets, big patti in the front?......how about fabric...can we use any material or does it have to be cotton............how about wearing this dress like chola with long boots so your legs are completely covered?khalistani · 27 Apr 2005
bibis in chollaii??? wat???? thas just wrong matha bhagos chola is with a pyajama, still here and people might say guru je had pyajama too, howevber, they also have only chola of guru jes no only chola of any matha this is new thing wearin a pyjamai and bein a bibi... thas wrong bhula chuka mafDUKKI TEEKI · 27 Apr 2005
modern singh JAISA DESH WAISA BESH" Which baba ji said that is he your baaba i mean some sant. ___________________________________________________________ As for the seeker I would suggest you look at your father ad try and see what he has done all his life please try and see as a nutral person do you see the hypocracy, any honesty of staying in one marriage does he believe in rehat is he bare face or a trimmer.What about you mother does she believe in rehat or is she a fake with double standards look at the brothers of your mother are they cheaters if the answer is possitive then skirt wont matter any size is good for you.DUKKI TEEKI · 27 Apr 2005
Mostly the ***Admin Cut**** or mixed kids like such dress as they are double faced hypocrates for them gurduwara and disco party go hand in handSingh · 27 Apr 2005
khalistani, think before you post. Just take a few brief minutes to reflect on what you are writing and saying. What did Sikh bibis wear if not cholas? Salwar Kameez like the Muslim women? Guru Sahib gave Sikh men a dress but not the women then? Giani Gian Singh described the clothes Sikh women wore and many of them wore the same thing as the Singhs. Sikh women wearing cholas is no new phenomenon. As for no cholas being found of Mata ji: how many of their clothes have been found and are genuine? Is there a wardrobe that you know of somewhere?khalistani · 27 Apr 2005
i never said guru je never gave singhnies a bana too pajee a chola with a pyjaaamee this is the bana matha bhag kaur je used to wear, which is preserved but no, since some people wont agree, let me hear it ITS FAKE ITS FAKE its a lie, its not real, etc etc etc well, u can live in ure dillusioned world if u want and there is a set of matha jes chola and pyjama thas the bana or singhness chola and PYAJAMAAEE bhula chuka maf