Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

Kulbir Singh · 06 Jun 2005

Below is their version of attack on Darbar Sahib. It is disgusting to see how much they lie and how much hatred they have. Reading this account has really saddened me and has refreshed the wounds we incurred in 1984. To imagine that the pavitter, paavan (pure) parkarma of Siri Darbar Sahib had tanks in there sinks my heart. On the other hand we are proud that our Sant jee and other Singhs fought so valiantly. No matter what they say or what they claim about Sant jee; Sant jee will always be a hero of Sikh Panth. Sant jee's mentality was definitely of Singhs of 1700s. The Beparvaahee and the defiance that Sant jee had is not to be found in anyone today. If you listen to Sant jee's tapes you can see how much chardi kala Sant jee used to live in. The reality is that all the defiance Sant jee had, all the courage he had, all the power he had, the vaak-sidhee he had, the aan, shaan and maan he had, Maan and Taan he had, was all the result of his kamaayee of Gurbani. Where are we going to find a Gursikh like Sant jee at who's one ishaara (gesture) youth who met him used to transform? Hearing one lecture of Sant jee, hundreds used to stop cutting hair, stop taking drugs, stop drinking liquor. No doubt we are proud of Sant jee. What can these baahmans, the langoti wearing Baahmans, the tilak wearing baahmans know about the greatness of Sant jee. For them Sant jee was a terrorist but they don't know that it was Singhs just like Sant jee who freed thousands of Hindu women who had been taken away by Ahmend Shah Abdali and before him by Nadir Shah. While reading this article remember that this is a very biased account of the events. The facts they have provided should not be trusted. Kulbir Singh http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/articleshow/msid-1133674,curpg-1.cms Operation Blue Star: Fighting for Golden Temple The recent blasts in two Delhi Cinema halls have, once again, refreshed the public memory of a bloodily movement in Punjab that rocked the entire nation during the '80s. Delhi Police is now probing the role of Ranjeet Singh Neeta, leader of a defunct group called Khalistan Zindabad Force. The movement for a free Khalistan may seem very weak today, but twenty years ago, Punjab was the stage for mass killing by militants. By mid May 1984 the state was under the grip of terror for nearly three years. The terrorist movement seeking to carve an independent Punjab had acquired monstrous proportions. Terror attacks on politicians, law-enforcers, and the common man became almost an everyday affair. Heading this bloody movement was Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale, a preacher turned separatist who ran the terrorist campaign allegedly from the holiest shrine of the Sikhs, Golden Temple in Amritsar. Till 1983 thousands of people were killed all over Punjab by armed brigades of young motorcycle-born terrorists who would suddenly come and with one burst of machine gun kill innocent people. In 1982, Bhindrenwale was arrested but was released in two days. In later half of 1982 he moved to Golden temple complex and allegedly setup his headquarters in Guru Ram Das Sarai. In 1984 he moved to Akal Takht. As the death toll from militant activities rose, the Central government, in 1983, started holding frequent consultations with the Army. The Army was ordered to move into Punjab and decisively tackle the terrorists who reportedly received arms and aid from across the border. President's Rule was imposed in Punjab and 4 division of Army was deployed through out the state. In a desperate attempt to flush out Bhindrenwale and his accomplice from the Golden Temple complex, on June 5, 1984, the army launched what is possibly its most controversial action ever, Operation Blue Star, under the command of Major General Kuldip Singh Brar. But one last-minute attempt was made to avoid bloodshed. A senior civil administration member and a senior army officer through a public address system asked militants and devotees to come outside. From 4:30 pm to 7:00 pm the attempts continued. Only some 129 devotees many of them very sick were allowed to go. The other hapless ones were held as hostages inside the Temple complex, used as a deterrent to the Army action. At 7:00 pm troops started moving up to take their appointed positions. From the surrounding balconies, people watched the rumble of trucks and tanks, as night fell a darkness of gloom settled in the city. In order to prevent a violent backlash there was a total shutdown of the telecommunication and electric systems. Initial operations went through as planned with the both the Hotel Temple View and Brahm Boota Akara secured with little resistance. It was however not surprising as they were isolated and only existed to provide early warning of the army's approach. However the battlements on the top of the clock tower were proving harder to knock out and thus H-hour was postponed by half an hour. At 10:30 pm the first phase of Operation Blue Star commenced. By midnight the Guards had secured the eastern half of the North Wing but the Western side was only 75% secured. Due to the severe casualties suffered by the first two companies, the third company was pressed in. Rather than wait for the complete clearance of the ground floor they were asked to secure a foothold on the first and second floor. This was deemed necessary to provide some sort of fire to the bogged down Para Commandos and the SFF. By 2 am the 10th Guards after suffering heavy casualties, had more or less secured the northern wing. Sporadic militant activity from concealed chambers was still a problem. At this point Brigadier A.K. Dewan had reached their location. Brar placed Dewan in charge of 26 Madras, 15 Kumaon and the two companies of 9 Garhwal, and created an ad hoc task force. By 2:30 am, Brigadier Dewan took charge of the Garhwalis and Kumaonis while 26 Madras had still to join up. Meanwhile Maj. Gen. (retd.) Shahbeg Singh (advisior to Bhinderanwale) realising that the only way to win was to hold of the Indian Army till dawn, poured in an even higher volume of fire. Brar now sought the permission to use tank fire to neutralise the Akal Takht's concrete defenses. In the meantime, in order to help the SFF and Paras, a tank was brought in and asked to switched on its search light. It was hoped that this would temporarily blind the defenders as well as allow the SFF and Paras locate some of the defences. But unfortunately this move failed as the Xenon lamps filament burned out in a couple of minutes. When this happened, another tank was moved in followed by a third. Thus all 3 tanks were in the Parikrama. At about 4 am, a Skot APC was moved in. Since it is a wheeled vehicle, the tank had to roll back and forth on the steps and crush the marble slabs. Only then could the APC be safely brought in. The APC was supposed to take a squad right up to the Akal Takht. The Guards were asked to fire a few 84mm Carl Gustaf rocket rounds at the Akhal Takht to precede the arrival of the APC. As the APC was approaching the Akal Takht, it was hit by an RPG-7 anti-tank rocket from the Akal Takht. This came as a complete shock as none had been expected. As the APC squad dismounted and retreated, the driver was shot by a sniper. By then dawn was approaching and soon the troops in the Parikrama would become sitting ducks. At 5:10 am the clearance to use tanks came from Delhi. The 3 tanks in the Parikrama, were asked to line up their machine guns on the Akhal Takht. Dewan had meanwhile readied for an assault, and the first Madrassis were trickling having cleared the southern wing. The first assault was led by 'A' Company of 15 Kumaon. Led by Major B.K. Mishra, a group of men reached the footsteps of Akal Takht, the first group to make contact. As they climbed the stairs, a machine gun opened up from the inside and all seven men were mowed down. More machine gun fire rained from the base and the buildings on both side and the Kumaonis were thrown back with heavy casualties. It was clear that the tank machine gun fire was not enough. The Kumaonis fell back to reorganise, having suffered 7 killed and 23 wounded. 2 companies of 26 Madras were now asked to pick up where the Kumaonis left. In the darkness there was confusion as Kumaonis and Madrassis got mixed up. It was realised that the 2 machine guns at the entrance had to be eliminated for any chance to move in on the Akal Takht. A section of troops were asked to volunteer for this dangerous task. The group was led by Lt. Jyoti Kumar Dang and was formed into two sub groups. One group led by Subedar K.P. Raman Ravi and 4 ORs was to destroy the bunker covering the stairs by hurling pole charges. Another led by the Lt and 4 ORs was to rush the first floor and silence the machine gun there. As the groups reached the Akal Takht, 8-9 fortified machine guns opened up. Valiantly the two groups moved forward. Subedar Ravi and his men reached the bunker and were about to launch their charges when they were cut down by machine gun fire. Lt. Dang and his men also managed to reach the first floor only to be cut down by machine gun fire. Two of the wounded men managed to crawl back. Lt. Dang, although wounded, tried to pull the wounded Subedar Ravi with him but had to give up due to the heavy fire. The barbarism of the terrorists now came through. Subedar Ravi was dragged back, attached with sticks of dynamite and blown up in full view of the other troops. In spite of this, discipline still held. 26 Madras had suffered 14 dead and 49 wounded. It was 7:30 am and daylight was well upon the troops. The temple complex marble was a sea of olive green and red as dead army personnel and terrorists lay sprawled all over. The Temple of God, was a full fledged fortress. With no other option the Generals authorised the tanks to use their 105mm main guns. The high explosive squash rounds smashed into the Akal Takht throwing up flames and masonry. This subdued the machine guns. Except for a few machine gun bursts it was now calm. All troops were asked to stay in the building they had secured and wait till dusk before launching an attack to clear the Akal Tkaht of any remaining militants. In response to reports of angry mobs approaching Amritsar, 15 Infantry Division moved in and sealed of the routes leading to Amritsar. At 11 am a large number of militants rushed out of the Akal Takht on to the Parikrama and fled towards the gates. Most were cut down. Seeing that the troops were not firing on the Harmandir Sahib some of them jumped in the Sarovar and tried to swim towards it. They too were killed. This led to a group of militants emerging from the Akal Takht, waving white flags. Then the Akal Takht suddenly went silent. To the army commanders it was an indication that the top leadership of Bhindranwale, Maj. Gen. (retd.) Shabegh and Amrik Singh had either escaped or had been killed. On June 7th, the Army started its mopping operation. At this stage the job of clearing the many rooms, concealed tunnels and basements began. A number of activists were captured and handed over to the Punjab Police and intelligence agencies. Other militants were asked to surrender. Their responses was to ask for the Head Priest Giani Sahib Singh. When he was brought the militants demanded that he be sent in. The scared Head Priest refused to go in and troops got ready to blast their way in. A demolition party crawled up and fixed explosives to the grill at the entrance. When it was blown up the SFF charged in and in the firefight, killed 7 militants inside only to find that the three soldiers had been executed in a inhumane manner. Their limbs had been chopped of. Search of various areas revealed cash, weapons and survival rations stashed away. The army suffered 83 dead and 248 wounded. A total of 492 terrorists and others were killed and 86 wounded. About 1500 people were captured, which included a number of Pakistanis who had taken shelter there. Thus ended the Indian Army's toughest operation. However a number of terrorists had fled to the countryside and the army had to launch "Operation Metal" to move around Punjab. These operations were relatively minor.

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

Sehajvir Singh · 06 Jun 2005

This article makes me sick. I can't believe this author had guts to write such lies. It has relit the fire in me to spread the word of sikhi, to become a gursikh.I hope Guru ji blesses the panth with unity so we can stand together against such fanatical people. Sant ji was truly a sant-sipai. Truly MY HEREO. Thank you veer kulbir singh for your post, realy makes you think.

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

neutral sikh · 07 Jun 2005

yes bhindrenwala was a great gursikh, with courage and honour, he wanted the best for the sikh panth, his intentions were all pure. however his method was not wise, the account above is bias, but so is the admin on this site, who cannot accept the fact that bhindrenwala shouldnt have setup base in the darbar sahib complex.

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

suki singh · 07 Jun 2005

Can everyone write letters into the paper to protest against their biased reporting which has hurt the sentiments of Sikhs worldwide.

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

suki singh · 07 Jun 2005

This is the text of the letter I have sent to the editor- can others do the same (with different letters). email ad: [address removed] cc: [address removed] Dear Sir I would like to protest in the strongest terms against the misinformation and bigotry expressed in the article in your 6th June issue entitled Operation Blue Star: Fighting for Golden Temple. The fact is that the army of a country, purportedly to be the world’s biggest democracy mercilessly attacked its own people and massacred thousands of innocent civilians in an orgy of violence unprecedented in world history. Never before has an army attacked its own people in such a barbarous way. There is nothing heroic that Indian soldiers did- they only succeeded in making more Sikhs realise that their future lies with separation from Hindu dominated India. The 1984 attack on the Golden Temple and the subsequent anti-Sikh massacres in Delhi in November 1984 demonstrate that no minority is safe in India. The despicable abuses of human rights and the massacre of thousands of pilgrims (on what was one the most sacred religions festival days in June) was a calculated attempt at destroying the resolve of the Sikhs in seeking justice for their grievances against the state. You should be ashamed at your derisible, biased and ill-informed article which glorifies one of the most horrific and condemned acts of the 20th century. An apology and retraction must be made. Yours sincerely Suki Singh UK PS. I seriously doubt whether you will in fact publish this letter, for that reason I would like to escalate this to the Reader's Grievances department. If they fail to act, I will instruct the Minorities Commission to investigate your inflammatory and biased article.

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

'''''''''' · 07 Jun 2005

this is very very sad. the true history of the world is always suppressed. we are usually left with a "designer" made history before us taught in educational establishments. However this quam is unlike any other, am sure Maharj will always bless this panth with great men and women as before to eventually take this path towards the height the ten mehals of the divine had been ordained with. Rulers have every machinery at their disposal. The media tells us things so as to make us look like dreaded evil tyrants where even our own turn against us. They work at various levels, information is just one, the dhills affecting people now also change anbd affect energy grids where lust and ego increase.Just like the energy grids are different where bhagti happens. Sant Ji was a role model in his bhagti. No sikh will ever be happy once they turn their backs on the panth and believe sarkars. Thats why such are so dhilley in their sikhi. Time to time we have some sikhs blaming singhs and sant ji for 84 i wonder what such would do if somebody came to demolish their own house.

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 07 Jun 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. What these cowards wont tell the world is that Sant jarnail Singh Bhin derawaalah had only about 65-70 Singhs INSIDE..and this small group of Marjeewrrey Singhs made CHamkaur 1705 COME ALIVE. The "oh so MIGHTY Indian Armed Forces...Sixth largest in the World..." MAULED so badly by just 65 Singhs...in 1984...just like the 10 Lkah Armed Forces of Aurengzeb were MAULED by the 40 Singhs in Chamkaur in 1705.. Proved to the entire World that Sikh History is NOT a tall Tale.. The words speak for themsleves.... Read the THIRD LINE from the Bottom... "THUS ENDED the Indian Army's TOUGHEST OPERATION"... toughest opearation..agaisnt a TEMPLE OF GOD.... agaisnt a FEW THOUSAND INNOCENT PILGRIMS...old men, old women, and children..AGAINST just 65 SINGHS of GURU GOBIND SINGH JI..armed with conventional arms...with fighter aircraft, bazookas, tanks, thousands of Armed Forces, 24/7 Clamp on Media blackout, armed Helicopters...in short EVERYTHING the Indians had (short of using NUCLEAR BOMBS)..this was the MOTHER OF WARS the Indian Army fought ( isnt it a shame that it was agaisnt its OWN CITIZENS) THIS is why Sant Jee and his marjeewrrey Singhs like Amrik Singh, Subegh Singh and all others, will be in OUR DAILY ARDASS..as long as the Guru Khalsa panth is around. They FELL in battle..BUT they PUT our FALLEN DASTAAR back on our HEADS....how can we forget ?? All these LIES only make our TRUE HISTORY alive/ REJUVENATED..as we RESOLVE to RETAKE our MOTHERLAND and FREE it of the Occupying Forces. KHALISTAN ZINDABAD. Sant-Sipahi jarnail Singh ji Zindabad.

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

JARNAIL SINGH GYANI "ARSHI" · 07 Jun 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. I just came across this mail on another Forum. Waheguru in his excellency has proven that the Martyrs of June 3-June 5 1984 were true on their path. Check out the Hukamnama's for these three dates that just passed. Talking about martyrdom on June 3 hukamnama, talking about the selfless act of martyrdom on June 4 and pride of today's leaders, to talking about the blindness of these politicians on June 5th...Waheguru has shown again that we must not forget the sacrifice of the martyrs and what the leaders are of today. Bole So Nihaal Sat Sri Akal http://www.sgpc.net/hukumnama/oldhukumnama.asp Our Ever Living GURU JI is always with us...it is we who falter and despair. jarnail Singh.

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

Bhopinder singh · 07 Jun 2005

A article written by Lt. general rt. Sk sinha GOC western command which is the command under which punjab falls. Here are his main points 1) In any war it is the principal and logic that dictates that the strength of the opposing army be compared and in the given situation the disparity is so much that they are virtually unarmed. 2) They fought to the last bullet and man. 3) They were right and very well with in their god given right to defend their place of worship and they did that true to their history and legends.This from the general of the opposing army now isnt that a tribute.Dont we all talk about the agents of abdali talking about the sikhs in similar words in 17th centuary. NEUTRAL SIKH WHERE ARE YOUR SENSES 4) According to general sinha the operation was planed and conducted as an exercise in 1981 near dehradoon a replica of golden temple was made and commondo operation planed but it was leaked and was known to have reached jarnail singh which logically makes him the deffender . 5)General sinha further goes on to say that paramillitary forces fired 10000 ronds a year before the 1984 operation forcing the sikhs to make two bunkers in defence which general sinha says they demolished as he told them that no body is going to attack the temple which he tells shows that they were not gung ho or looking for the fight. WE SHOULD NEVER SAY IT OPERATION BLUESTAR AS IT IS AN INSULTING WORD DELIBRATELY CHOSEN

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

neutral sikh · 07 Jun 2005

how can you say bhindrenwala was protecting golden temple complex when he was standing behind its walls? the walls were protecting him if he never took cover in the complex it would not have been blown to pieces. of course he knew they were going to attack the goldentemple, because he was in there and he knew the government wanted him dead. not only did he risk desicration of darbar sahib, he also put hundreds of innocents at risk by setting up base among them. bhindrenwala was a gursikh, he would sacrifice everything for the sikhs to have their own homeland, in his despiration i feel he made an error of judgment. bhindrenwala said - attack on golden temple/ my martyrdom will set foundation stone for khalistan in a way i think he wanted them to attack, as he thought it would be a final push which would cause a sikh up-roar..........resulting in khalistan intentions were pure and honourable, however i do not agree with his method.

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

Bhopinder singh · 07 Jun 2005

Why even after knowing the 1981 incident you are not understanding the logic.He was defender in the eyes of the General of the invading army and this he himself has written in his book .He is not a sikh hope guru ji will do bakshish on you

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

Kulbir Singh · 07 Jun 2005

Excellent point by Bhopinder Singh. Neutral Sikh, think of it. Sant jee had found out about the army action to take place as the government was planning it since 1981, when there was not much problem in Punjab. The information of the planned attack leaked out to Sant jee who then resolved to defend Siri Harmandir Sahib. If you are a Sikh (as you have mentioned) you will side with Guru Sahib Sikhs i.e. Sant Bhindranwale and not with baahmans. Kulbir Singh

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

RoopKaur · 07 Jun 2005

I agree. What would you do if you found out the Indian gov't was planning an attack agaisnt Harmander Sahib? Sit there and wait for it to happen in your safe little pind somewhere? THat is the work of kayers, and Sant Bhinderwaley were no kayer. THey were bahadur, and there is no way the bir ras in them would have let them let the gov't attack Darbar Sahib while they sat outside. It is very naive of you to think that it is because of Sant Bhinderwaley that the gov't attacked. THis is what they want you to believe, and it is sad when people who call themselves guru ke Sikh start believing the propaganda of the bahmans. Open your eyes to reality bhaji, and remember it is because of the shaheediaa of these mahaan yodhrey, abd all the others that have given their life for Sikhi, that we can walk tall and proud with our dastaaraa on our heads today.

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

Prabhdeep Singh · 07 Jun 2005

Guroooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

neutral sikh · 07 Jun 2005

i cant see the indian govenment blowing the golden temple complex to pieces and shooting hundreds of sikhs without giving the rest of the world a reason. to me bhindrenwala gave them an excuse to attack, if theres evidence the indian government were plannig on randomly attacking darbar sahib with tanks and killing hundreds of pilgrims i would like to see the evidence even if they were plannig an attack are you telling me there would be more damage and more sikhs killed if bhindrenwala were not there? how can you defend a structure if you are inside it? how can you defend people if you are among them? bhindrenwala used the complex as a forte, complex took the brunt of the bombardment and he was inside - you call this protecting the structure? im not siding with the bahmans, i just think people should look at the possibilty that maybe bhindrenwala shouldnt have hidden out inside the complex instead taken up positions outside the complex to stop them entering and also draw fire away frfom sanghat inside

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

RoopKaur · 07 Jun 2005

The Indian gov'ts aim was to kill of the SIkhs, whether Sant Ji were on the scene or not. If they only attacked because of Sant Ji, then why did they have a model built in 1981 of the complex? How can you say that Sant Ji should not have been there, its his fathers house, now we need special permission to stay in our fathers house? There are many instances where GOI attacked SIkhs, even when Sant Ji was not there, ex. THe Vasakhi Massacre of 1978. If Sant Ji had not been there to defend Darbar Sahib, there would have been much more damage, and the job would have been much more easier for the GOI because they would have had no competition. Wake up and smell the roses bhaji, GOI does not give a crap about justifying what they did to the world, these people are besharms, they did not justify why they raped, murdered, brutally tortured the SIkhs for the whole kharku movement, what makes you think they cared about justifying this ghallughara? Sant Ji was not a terrorist, and the GOI called them one. If they were not there, the GOI would take someone else and call them terrorists.

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

Bhopinder singh · 07 Jun 2005

neutral sikh what is neutral yyou either oppose or side lets agree with your side of sant ji choose the venue how many tanks=0 enemy=4000 artillery=0 " =8000 planes=0 " =700 standing army=65 " =130000 navy=0 " =400000 now let us think of a senario of two people in a room one is 27 years old healthy young man and the other is 5 year old something happens they both blame the other now whome do you think is responsible like you the 27 year old blames the 5 year old you know whome the law would find responsible IT LIES WITH THE STRONG They were no threat to anybody it was that they wanted to hummiliate the sikhs even venue was of their choice singhs and sant ji merely defended themselves

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

Mehtab Singh · 07 Jun 2005

If they wanted Sant jee, they could have arrested/captured him before June 1984. Why then on that day? Plus the attack on Sri Darbar Sahib (as sangata have mentioned) was well-planned well in advance. Why did they need such a large number of soldiers, ammunition, artillery, helicopters, planes and other loads of equipment for JUST ONE MAN! And how did they assemble all this in Amritsar in alot less days than normally it takes?

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

ssingh · 07 Jun 2005

"neutral" - it's a bahman mindset that has to focus solely on a "structure" (your own words, not mine) and keep belating over that while ignoring the actions/singhs/shaheeds/righteousness/beliefs of the kaum. THe akhal takhat IS the center of miri-piri. Our sikh kaum was in the process of a Dharam Yudh morcha, declaring the objectives in the anandpur sahib resolution, asserting the declaration of amritsar. These were the miri-piri issues at the forefront of every khalsa's mind at the time - the very reason the akal takhat was raised was to take an ARMED by-necessary-means stand for such issues. The center of the issues of the kaum naturally belong therefore at akal takhat. No wonder it ended up being there. That sant jarnail singh ji was there, that large numbers of Sikhs were there, that the babbar khalsa was there, that general shahbeg singh was there, that Sikhs fighting for the current miri-piri objective were, fulfills the situation. That thousands of such sikhs gave Everything - became shaheeds- to fight for the stand of the khalsa at the akal takhat, that "neutral sikhs" today will fault them for taking a stand at the spot where if there is no stand there is no issue, there is no khalsa - that one should take a stand somewhere else only goes to say that you believe the dharam yudh morcha and everything else they stood was out of line and did not fit what the Akal takhat was made to stand for. That the enemies deemed it necessary to attack the akal takhat in their objective to silencing the stand of such khalsay further validates this. Your viewpoint is that of the injust butchers': Why are they at the spot their Guru's also spoke against injustice? Can't they find somewhere else, This place was not designed for fighting. this is a place of worship. There's nothing similar about that so they have no reason, if they chose elsewhere so that we don't have to put up with this big structure they have here, and this complex that's so complex we have to make an actual replica.

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

anon · 07 Jun 2005

so you sayin government was plannig an attack before bhindrenwala started takin up residence in the golden temple? cause i kno he was in there quite aong time, they prly were plannig an attack, but only cause they knew he was livin there, its the perfect excuse

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

singh · 07 Jun 2005

"they prly were plannig an attack, but only cause they knew he was livin there, " So why did they attack several dozen other gurdvaray? Was Sant Bindherawalay in all of them? What's the obsession here with the structure? The point wasn't to just defent the structure. It's the principles behind the structure. Sri Akal Takht Sahib isn't just a pile of bricks. It stands for something. If the sikhs were to run away and leave it for fear of damaging the structure, then what would be the point of having it? Is the Akal Takht Sahib just some historic relic for you? If so, that's pretty sad. If the Americans were under attack, would they leave and let the White House fall to their enemies, in order to save it from being damaged? I doubt it. No self respecting nation would. Your seat of power is YOUR seat of power. If you have to ask other's persmission to use it, then it's just an empty symbol. Of course, Sri Akal Takht Sahib is much higher than any other takht and I'm not trying to put it in the same category as the White House. By the way, the GOI never issued any legal warrant for the arrest of Sant Jee before the attack. If their goal was simply to remove Sant Jee, they could have just asked him to leave. If this failed, the second step would be to attempt some legal proceedings. They did none of this. Their aim was to crush the sikh nation and it's spirit. To humiliate us. Thank Guru Sahib that some self respecting gursikhs were there to fight back.

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

KHALISTANI · 07 Jun 2005

Why do people say that it was Sant Ji;s fault and why do they say he should have gave himself up. They releasesed him from prison after he was arrested at Mehta Chowk were the indian police fired and innocent sikh's. If they wanted to arrest him they should have put out a warrnet Sant Ji would have came peacefully like they had done before... WJKK WJKF

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

Fact Singh · 07 Jun 2005

I believe the matter of the fact is as follows: 1. Indira Gandhi wanted to take revenge from Sikhs for their leading role in the agitation against 1977 Emergency under the leadership of Sant Harchand Singh Longowal, the head of Akali Dal, the party representing the majority of Sikhs at that time. 2. Indira Gandhi made a plan to finish the Akali Dal, the political stronghold of Sikhs. For this, she chose Sant Jarnail Singh Jee to establish a parallel and stronger leader than Sant Harchand Singh Longowal among Sikhs. She promoted him to sky in a very short span with the very prominent help of Giani Jail Singh, one of her main confidant throughout his life. (I want to make it crystal clear that Sant Jarnail Singh Jee was utmost honest and sincere Gursikh Saint Soldier and he was not having a clue of this game plan of Indira Gandhi) 3. The anger of Indira Gandhi continued to increase with the stunning success of Dharam Yud Morcha going on under the leadership of Sant Longowal. Even though she was somewhat successful in creating a rift between two great leaders but she was not able to throw away Sant Longowal. 4. Indira Gandhi created the situation very intelligently through her intelligence agencies that she made Sant Jarnail Singh to become her case for her final game to finish the political stronghold of Sikhs in Punjab to take revenge of 1977 emergency. So my conclusion is that Sant Jarnail Singh Jee was not the actual reason for the attack. The actual reason was to finish the power base of Sikhs, the Akali Dal. Unfortunately Sant Jarnail Singh was made just the mohra, the planned cooked reason to invade Sri Harmandir Sahib. Sant Jarnail Singh Jee was very clean heart straight forward and was not crook to understand this game . The result was that we lost Sant Jarnail Singh Jee and our many other great warriors and Indira Gandhi was finally successful when she also got Sant Harchand Singh Longowal killed with the hands of Sikhs. In my humble opinion that the death of Sant Harchand Singh Longowal was one of the most invaluable dream fulfilled for Mrs Indira Gandhi. We are now dreaming for a leader for last 20 years who can successfully lead Sikh masses once again in a non-violent overwhelming mass-struggle. We must never forget 1978, 1984 and all what happened for 27 years and is still continuing to happen in one way or the other against Guru Panth Khalsa I pay tribute to both great leaders Sant Jarnail Singh Jee and Sant Harchand Singh Jee whom we have not been able to replace so far. I further salute all those who laid down their lives in last 27 years since Baisakhi 1978 for the glory of Sikh Nation. May Guru Jee do kirpa on his Khalsa Panth to learn from the mistakes of the past and build the future with strong GURMAT base and joining all hands together so that we can pay real tribute to all our lost heros in last over 2.5 decades by making a place in this world where Khlasa can flourish freely. Raj Karega Khalsa Khalsa Parnaam Shaheedaaan Noo *Please forgive me for any unintentional mistake and I do not anticipate everyone to agree with me. I just honestly presented what I have learnt with my own eyes and ears in last 30 years. I also have same pain in my heart as all the other Panth dardi Sikhs [%sig%]

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

bad man gettin good · 07 Jun 2005

NCM slams hard-liners as Badal drops Bluestar memorial plans UNI New Delhi June 7: The National Commission for Minorities (NCM) chief, Mr Tarlochan Singh has slammed what he called a rat race among Sikh leaders to capitalise on Operation Bluestar as hard-liners hijacked Shiromani Akali Dal (SAD)’s plans to dedicate a memorial to the 1984 army action on the Golden Temple. Mr Singh said he had written to SGPC chief, Ms Jagir Kaur that no such structure should be allowed on the sacred compound to undercut the sanctity of the holiest of the Sikh shrines. Hard-line Sikh groupings commemorating the 21st anniversary of Bluestar yesterday dedicated a gallery near the Akal Takht, Sikhism’s highest seat that was damaged in the Army Operation, to slain militant leader Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale, prompting former Punjab chief minister, Mr Parkash Singh Badal’s SAD to drop its memorial plans during the ceremony. Leaders of the Damdami Taksal, the Dal Khalsa, the Khalra Mission Committee, the Shiromani Akali Dal (MANN), the Punjab Human Rights Organisation, and the Sikh Students’ Federation declared the gallery a Bhindaranwale Memorial by placing a board in front of it. “I have never seen any other religion has ever raised memorials over its SAD historical events at its very centre,” the NCM chief said. The Golden Temple, he said, was a spiritual attraction for the entire humanity. “No tower or gallery should be allowed on its compound to violate its sanctity.” The NCM chief suggested the SGPC should rather build a Bluestar library or a museum outside the sacred premises. “Such a hall should house films, publications and all other material relating to the most unfortunate event in modern Sikh history,” Mr Singh said. Yesterday, Mr Badal, when asked about his views over such memorial following the radical actions, said the structure he planned did not aim at glorifying militants.

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

JARNAIL SINGH GYANI "ARSHI" · 08 Jun 2005

Two Facts prove the GOI "fact-sheet" a FAKE. 1. The 1980's Planned attack and training in the Mountains far away from Punjab. 2. The SIMULTANEOUS ATTACK on over 52 Historical Gurdawaras in PUN JAB on 3rd June, 1984. Bhinderawalah and his militant group of 65 was ONLY in Darbar Sahib Amrtisar...WHY were the other 52 Histroical Shrines attacked on the same day and same time -as obviously they too would be full of sikh pilgrims celebrating the Gurpurab. Obviously this attack on all sikh shrines was to destroy at one stroke the entire Sikh Kaum with an ALL OUT attack on the Akal Takhat/Centre of sikhe...and simultaneously destroy the 52 Centres of Sikhe at the same time. ( Punjab was under 100% BLACKOUT so who would worry !!) Bhinderawalh or NO bhinderawalh... the ATTACK was ON and it would have led to EVEN more destruction as there would be NO 65 Sant Sipahis to BLOCK the Indian Armed Forces and fail their mission. Those that beleive the GOI propoganda and "blame" Bhiderawalh for the "destruction" of Akal Takhat should THANK GURU JI that these 65 Sikhs were there to STOP the TOTAL ANNIHILATION of the entire Akal takhat Darbar Sahib complex. IF the 65 Singhs had not been there the entire Complex would be RUBBLE. Notice the SUDDEN influx of NEW ITEMS....about Militancy in Punjab, Bluestar memeorials, sant Ji declared Shaheed, chohan and croonies making statements....hardliners etc shouting slogans and storming Darbar sahib etc etc...is VERBAL/WRITTEN DIARRHOREA by the GOI controlled indian media to begin another operation/deal another blow to Punjab by saying the militants are abck..back..back..etc.

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

ekta · 08 Jun 2005

sant mahapurkh sant giani jarnail singh ji khalsa is flawless....he stayed in the complex in aim only 2 defend. If indian army wanted 2 capture just him why choose sahib siri guru arjun dev ji maharaaj's shaheedi divaaas as the date 2 do the action?

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

... · 08 Jun 2005

there were other militants in them other gurdwara which were attacked

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

neutral sikh · 08 Jun 2005

singh sed - If the Americans were under attack, would they leave and let the White House fall to their enemies, in order to save it from being damaged? I doubt it if the white house was under attack, would the american soldiers hide inside it? i think not, they would setup postions outside it to prevent enemies attacking it. if bhindrenwala really wanted to protect darbar sahib and the sanghat inside, he would have setup bunkers outside the complex to try an stop the army/tanks getting in waiting inside darbar sahib makes no sense. fighting should have been taken outside not inside.

Re: Attack on Darbar Sahib - Their biased version

Sikhi · 08 Jun 2005

Sat Sri Akaal, I recommend everyone to read the book "Gallant Defender" written by a Punjabi HINDU. I dont understand why people like "neutral Sikh" can be so simple minded. Are they blind? India is well known about the fact that if Sikhs stick together they can beat any country or regime. When they heard stories about our great history they couldnt believed it but scared they were! They were scared that with Bhindranwale as a leader, we the Sikhs would dominate India. That’s why they planned just a huge attack on the Golden Temple. To finish us for good. It almost worked out! Look to the Sikhs today! Their fighting even with each other in Gurduwaras! Bhindranwale wasn’t a Sant only or a Holy man. NO! He was a SANT-SIPAHI!!! He didn’t preached for peace but for JUSTICE! How can you get peace if you dont got JUSTICE?! Sikhs today should ask themselves this question. Bhindranwala vision was that the Sikhs first must get their JUSTICE from the Indian government. If we got that (like the AnandPur resalution) then we can talk about peace. He never fought for a Khalistan, he was fighting for justice. He was fighting for the Panth. But the Panth was almost dead. He first wanted to awake the Panth again. And this is what he did, because he gave his life for the Khalsa Panth for our Pita Guru Gobind Singh Ji. Sikhs who blame Bhindranwale should ask themselves why the Indian Army put a "baatcheet" out to every military bout the Sikhs telling that every Amritdhari is a terrorist? That they should be arrested and locked behind bars. ITS BECAUSE THE GOVERMENT WANTED TO FINISH OF THE SIKHS! Just look at the facts. 150 true Sikhs of Guru Gobind Singh Ji fighting against an army of thousands. Mr. Darshi wrote in his book the following thing: "It was an utterly unequal battle fought between a handful of Sikh defenders led by Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale assisted by Major General Shabeg Singh and Bhai Amrik Singh on one side and the massive Indian Army headed by Lt. General Krishnaswamy Sunderjit besides Lt. General Ranjit Singh Dyal and Kuldeep Singh Brar. The Sikh fighters were armed with ordinary weapons in comparison to the ones possessed by the Indian Army. The former had no superior weapon than Light Machine Guns. Other arms they possessed were sten-guns etc. On the other hand the Indian Army was equipped with all kinds of heavy and sophisticated weapons which included Main Battle tanks "Vijayanta" howitzer, heavy guns and canons using twenty-pounder shell ect. The army used Russian made helicopters too. Numerical strenght of the Sikh militants was also miserably insignificant in comparison to that of the Indian army. The Sikh fighters were not more than two hundred whereas the Army's numerical strength fighting them in the complex was at least seven thousandth Sikh fighters had no line of communication and source of supply. They were totally cut of from the state, the country and the world. They were completely besieged in the Golden temple complex, particularly inside the Akal Takht. Supply of electricity and water was cut of. They had no reserves to reinforce their positions. They nothing to eat but roasted grains, nothing to drink but their own sweat oozed from their bodies due the scorching heat. They had no place to answer the call of nature. They could not sleep for seven days and seven nights. They were exhausted and weared out under these horrible conditions. On the other hand Indian Army had all sorts of provisions, facilities, reserves and what not. Yet the Sikhs fought gallantly and demonstrated their remarkable valour, courage and fighting skill. Yet they held the well equipped Indian Army at bay for five days and gave it bloody reply, the reply which the Army would remember for ever. Had the militant Sikhs been equally armed, had their numerical strength been even one-tenths of the Indian army, they would have pushed the Army up to Delhi or even beyond Jamuna. The unequal battle, that a handful supporters of Sant Bhindranwale fought, would be recorded in golden letters in the history of the Sikhs. The entire credit for this exemplary valour goes to Sant Bhindranwale who had enthused and inspired the Sikhs to fight for their rights and defend their faith. It would not be an exaggeration to say that after Guru Gobind Singh Ji it was Sant jarnail Singh Bhindranwale who has taught the Khalsa to live with dignity and die with honour" And still we blame him for everything!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!