Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

women in sikhi

women in sikhi

question · 01 Sep 2003

Ok I have q question, Please do not take this the wrong way and please do not judge me on this. I am not picking on specifics but giving examples. Assume that all the folowing are amrit dharis 1 Ok what is worse, a women who is married with children having an affair with another man. 2 A girl in love with a man, runs a way with a man and has to have an abortion so that she can get married to someone else as the parents do not like this guy she ran away with (even thought he was amrit dhari) 3 Girls sitting on the stage dpoing nindiya of veeryone else lying to their parents and behind their back going out listening to songs, and eating inrestaurants and going out with guys. 4 A guy trying to spilt up a perfectly happy couple cause he wants to marry a girl. Lying, cheating and making both of the parties look bad becuase he can't get his own way. 5 A women maintaining herself. Ie washes her face cleanses tones and looks good, bleaches using natural products 6 A women who bas been prisoned for fraud 7 A man who has raped a girl WHAT DO YOU THINK IS THE DIFFERENCE? SCROLL DOWN ONLY ONE OF THE ABOVE SCENARIOS IS NOT AS BAD AS THE OTHERS AS YOU WOULD NOT BE HARMING ANYBODY, JUST YOURSELF AND YOU WOULD PAY FOR THAT WHEN YOUR TIME CAME. SO WHY IS IT THAT PEOPLE CONCENTRATE ON THIS ONE SCENARIO THE MOST BUT FORGET THE BIGGER THINGS HERE PEOPLE ARE HARMING OTHERS. WE WILL ALL PAY FOR OUR ACTIONS SO WHY DO PEOPLE TRY TO ACT LIKE THEY ARE THE SAINTS BY TELLING PEOPLE WHAT TO DO. ESPECIALLY WHEN YOU DO NOT KNOW WHAT A PERSON MAYBE GOING THROUGH THINK ABOUT IT!

Re: women in sikhi

Kulbir Singh · 02 Sep 2003

>>>>> ONLY ONE OF THE ABOVE SCENARIOS IS NOT AS BAD AS THE OTHERS AS YOU WOULD NOT BE HARMING ANYBODY, JUST YOURSELF AND YOU WOULD PAY FOR THAT WHEN YOUR TIME CAME. >>>>>> This scenario may not be as harmful as other scenarios you have written but it is still harmful. A Sikh girl doing all that harms the image of Sikhi. A person doing that so called least harmful thing, will harm her kids because this is what she will teach her kids and that way they will forever stay away from Sikhi. Such lady may harm her husband, if her husband wants to amrit chhak and can't do so unless his wife gives up what she is doing. So don't think that the lady under supposedly harmless scenario, is not going to harm anyone. I do acknowledge that we should also condemn other ills as mentioned by you and not focus on this one alone. Thanks for bringing it up. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: women in sikhi

kaur · 02 Sep 2003

i agree with both of you but have also noticed a lot of people go round telling others what to do when they are not in a position to do so. i think its better to just be humble and if we feel we want to spread bani only with pyar.otherwise the wrong impression can be given which leaves behind negative vibes these can be so harmful they can totally put someone off sikh dharm. its easy to say but hard to comtemplate unless you have been in that situation. i myself have and know how it feels. i think the last point is vital, people dont realise what someone else is going through, and just say summit they wanna say. We are not all the same , we have different dealing capacities in life and every1 is on a diff level with different pressures in life and its just expected we are all one so if i can handle so can he or she. life is like a stream of thoughts we must be careful how we talk to fellow humans and conduct ourselves in a corporate sense. guru ji sed to heart a heart is a great sin, although people dont always do that intentionally, its no excuse we shud think twice and try to see more of the picture than just focus on the spot.

Re: women in sikhi

Mkhalsa · 02 Sep 2003

Just reading all those scenarios.. I know of situations where all of those are true.. and i just want to break out in tears.. how can guru khalsa panth have gotten this corrupt?! :'(

Re: women in sikhi

. · 03 Sep 2003

sau sakhis describe the nature of future sikhs right down to the exact symptons. everything happening is guru jis hukam.Guru sahib also mentions how the english were born in the homes of sikhs when adultry nasha backbiting and caste distinctions will be rife. How the gurus sikhs will come from all directions in different races in the future spread in each corner of the globe.

Re: women in sikhi

Khalsa Soulja · 03 Sep 2003

penji im assuming you do number 5 and bleach your facial hair yes the other things are bad but if you are amritdhari then you are only destroying your self by breaking your rehat and no offence, but dishonouring your own self and the image of the khalsa. i know this sounds harsh and its probably hard for you, but in the end when you stand before dharam raj there wont be people there who give you browny points for appearing in a different way to how the guru made you, there will just be dharam raj who tells you that you have committed a kurehit (removal or mutilation of bodily hair) and teh golden chance of mukti will be gone......just because of one tiny thing dont take this the wrong way....but get ur strength from guruji and act like a true singhnee! dont b afraid!

Re: women in sikhi

Sardaro.. · 03 Sep 2003

Many times you will hear "Just cause someone doesnt bleach facial hair, doesnt mean they automatically go to sachkhand" or "I know lots of bibis that dont bleach but do such and such" and other things of that nature... yeah just cause you dont do it doesnt mean you go to sachkhand.. BUT that doesnt mean if u do bleach u WILL go to sachkhand.. little things could ruin everything you have done! who knows?

Re: women in sikhi

? · 05 Sep 2003

lets praise those few khalsa women who r left on this earth !

Re: women in sikhi

uk sikh · 05 Sep 2003

what if a Bibi suffered from hormonal changes and ended up being too hairy. does this mean she can shave her hair as it is seen as a medical condition. she might have too much facial hair. not a problem for us men, but can be a disaster for bibis when it comes to marrying someone. some might say that we should look past external roop and be strong

Re: women in sikhi

seeker · 05 Sep 2003

i went through that as a guy in my hormone changes i ended up with hairs growing under my eyes my beard line covers my whole face and i have hairs on my ears eventhough im still a teenager, i too am worried about marriage as my beard isnt the average kind you will see. but what can i do? people think its only women us men have the pangah too, maybe its just me being too worried.

Re: women in sikhi

uk sikh · 05 Sep 2003

Do we exept this as the will of Waheguru or do we change it? the only similar example I can think of is where Plastic Surgery, eye laser treatment and so on are reqd to treat disfigurements and problems with eyes. what is considered a medical condition, where treating it does not fall in the boaundary of religion but as a necessity.

Re: women in sikhi

. · 05 Sep 2003

uk sikh thats easier sed than done. if ur beard looks fine or within the norms its easy for u to say. if its covering the whole of ur face spreading up to ur eyes with hairs all over ur ears try putting yourself in their shoes then say its gods will?

Re: women in sikhi

warrior*princess · 05 Sep 2003

vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh I dont think we should judge/assume what someone has done, what they should do etc.... Of course we are to strictly obey Guru jis hukum for us...theres no doubt about that! But we should not criticize others for what they do 'especially' if you are not the same gender nor know what they may be going through. Everyone is different. We cannot understand others sufferings. Only Vaheguru ji can. Its Vaheguru ji's will whatever one does and beyond human control. Vaheguru ji can very easily do something to us within seconds that someone else maybe suffering of or going through that we once critisized. Never say never! Instead we should be thankful that we are not in the position of that person. In an above post, a veer ji said to bhainji that she is dishonouring Khalsa etc and that she should behave like a true singhnee BUT maybe she does more paht and swas gras than any of us...maybe she has more faith in vaheguru ji than us! Maybe vaheguru has more faith in her than us, so lets not assume what Dharam Raj will say to her either. I am not saying that she is doing the right thing by the bleaching if its true but we shouldnt ever assume about others if u havent been in their shoes. Vaheguru ji can show us otherwise. By being able to point out someone elses faults we must have ego to be able to do that. We should explain with pyaar through gurmat. I was suprised that an assumption was made without proof of her actions. Also we should not hurt other peoples feelings. Vaheguru ji listens to all and understands every individuals dukh n sukh. Lets not forget that guru ji even says no one is bad and no one is good! Alot of males very easily are ready to put down Singhnees...but sometimes occurences or sakhis make me think that Singhnees have twice the spiritual stength than Singhs out there. But thats just a personal opinion about some Singhnees!

Re: women in sikhi

warrior*princess · 05 Sep 2003

i agree with Kaur ji

Re: women in sikhi

G · 05 Sep 2003

Mkhalsa.... its allways been this currupt, people just hide wut they do.... then when you find out how everyone is its very sad and then you learn you can trust your non Gursikh friends more than your gursikh friends, everyone has their own motivations things they want and they dont care if they are going to ruin the other persons life or hurt them by doing it... its just how life is... no one is innocent anymore

Re: women in sikhi

domalla premee · 05 Sep 2003

Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh Guru peeareo, One cannot base the following of the rehet on uncommon worst case scenarios. That is not realistic and affords loopholes for too many to make excuses for not following the Guru's Hukam. A lot of women especially as they cross into middle age will develop facial hair and this is normal. A few happen to have some or lots when younger and it is still not a problem. Why is it even an issue for anyone anyway?? What is the problem is we convince ourselves into thinking it is because deep inside we are looking for a way out so we may comfirm with the ambients societal norms. We lose faith that the Guru is the original eternal provider and look to the world to provide our needs. This comes at a dear price. Why heed to the voice of wordly criticism??....it can easily be gone in a twinkle of Waheguru's eye.Doors mysteriously open to those who walk towards the Guru with full surrender and devotion. When will we ever learn?? If we are to follow the Guru's path who do we follow the Guru's standard or the world's fickle fashion statement of the day. Eternity vs. transient and fickle? Which one do you want?? dass

Re: women in sikhi

bola · 06 Sep 2003

It is easy to say follow Gods will in almost anything, when you are placed in a situation then you will realise, whatever that situation will be.

Re: women in sikhi

gupt singh · 06 Sep 2003

Sabh te neech aatam kari maanahu mann amhi ih sukh dhaarahu: I judge myself to be the lowest of all; in this way, I instill peace within my mind (sggs 532). Ham nahee change buraa nahee koyi: I am not good; no one is bad (sggs 728). Kabeer sabh te ham bure ham taji bhalo sabh koi. Jin aisaa kari boojhiaa meet hamaaraa soi: Kabeer, I am the worst of all. Everyone else is good. Whoever understands this is a friend of mine (sggs 1364). Antar kee gati tum hee jaanee tujh hee paahi nibero...: Only You know the state of my innermost self; You alone can judge me. Please forgive me, O Lord; I have committed thousands of sins and mistakes (sggs 618). Nanak parkhe aap kayu ta paarakh jaan: O Nanak, if someone judges himself, only then is he known as a real judge (sggs 148 vaheguruvaheguruvaheguruvaheguruuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu

Re: women in sikhi

Kulbir Singh · 06 Sep 2003

If a bibi or a singh is doing be-adbee (desecration) of the sacred hair, then it is safe to say that such person is committing a paap according to Gurmat. It is quite true that there are normally many circumstances that can lead a person to do so, but it still remains a paap. A Singh cannot compromise on the basic principles of Gurmat. The fundamentals of Gurmat that define Sikhi cannot be ignored. It may be true that ninda, or stealing or other karams may be worse than bleaching or doing other forms of be-adbee like tying beard in case of singhs, but to justify your act of doing be-adbee of kesh and then saying that you don’t do bigger paaps like ninda or stealing is deceiving yourself. As for such person who is violating the most basic and vital principles of Gurmat but is doing lot of paath to compensate, I personally believe that again such person is not fully informed about Gurmat. Such person is unaware of the following pankiti of Guru Sahib: VIN GUNN KEETAY, BHAGAT NAA HOYE || (Without creating Gurmat gunns of rehit, one cannot do bhagtee) This pankiti proves that apart from bhagtee one needs to have other qualities as well. These qualities range from living truthful life, not stealing or embezzling, not doing ninda, keeping sabar-santokh i.e. contentment, to keeping Khalsa rehit like 5 kakaars, daswandh, abstaining from 4 kurahits, keeping bibek etc. If one tries to ignore these gunns (qualities) then paath done by that person, does not yield much spiritual benefit. They will do paath but it gets wasted trying to compensate for basic violations like be-adbee of hair. It is a fact that was stated by Sant Jarnail Singh jee Bhindranwaale once to a Hindu Swami that one who violates kesh, can never be a holy person. A goraa guy narrated this to me. I met a Goraa in Downtown Toronto once and he told me some things about Sikhi. I was surprised at this knowledge and asked him how he found out all that. He told me that he was a disciple of a famous Hindu Swami with whom he had accompanied to India many times. One one of his visits to India, the swami and the Gora, along with other disciples went to get darshan of Darbaar Sahib. There they met Sant Jarnail Singh jee on the top of Siri Guru Ramdass Langar building. While discussing, Sant jee told this Hindu Swami, who had a shaven head, that it was not possible for person who cuts hair, to meet God. The swami got upset but kept quiet in front of Sant jee. Who had the guts or courage to talk back to Sant jee? Sant jee was in his full prominence in those days of early eighties. The swami kept quiet there even though he was humiliated in front of his disciples but later when he reached his ashram, he burst out, bad-mouthing Sant jee. The goraa guy I met, too had a bad opinion about Sant jee. I tried in vain to correct his opinion but all in vain. The gist of this posting is that one should not expect any kirpa if one does not keep basic rehit including be-adbee of kesh. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: women in sikhi

domalla premee · 06 Sep 2003

Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh The maintaining of kesh is one very fundamental hukams of the Guru. Does anyone think they can rise to the level of the Guru to question this? Putting ego ahead of Guru can there be full blessing? The Guru is the dispeller of ego which impedes progress. He saves us from the ravages of ourselves. Dass won't even attempt to question his wisdom. The Guru will test one's devotion and faith. I pray that he keep dass attached to His feet no matter what happens. He is dass's support and salvation and His Hukam is the salve for dass's aching soul. dass

Re: women in sikhi

.. · 06 Sep 2003

still none of you are in a position to judge anyone else.

Re: women in sikhi

darshan kaur · 06 Sep 2003

Sant Jarnail Singh also said in audio tape "gurmat parchar translation ninth canto" those of our brothers who do not believe in raaag maala to be bani and will go back into charasi lakh joon".

Re: women in sikhi

Kulbir Singh · 06 Sep 2003

Bhain Darshan Kaur jeeo, It is pretty naive of you to bring up Raagmala issue in this totally different thread. May I remind you that the topic being discussed here is desecration of sacred hair. It seems like some people who are obsessed with controversey, cannot come out of the Raagmala issue. In a way you are telling me that I am not allowed to use Sant jee's reference, because I am not in agreement with 100% of his views. You are implying that if I agree with one of his principles, then I have to agree with all of his principles. This does not seem fair to me. I can give you example of Sant Kartar Singh jee Bhindranwaale, who in one of his cassettes goes to great lengths in praising Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee. He has only good words to say about him. No once he mentions that Bhai Sahib did not read Raagmala. If we go by your logic, then we would have to tell Sant Kartar Singh jee to agree with Bhai Sahib's Raagmala views also, or stop praising him. Does this sound fair to you? Bhain jeeo, it is not good to be stuck in Raagmala issue alone. This issue has done great damage to panth. True, you can hold to your ground and do Raagmala paath but by the same token, let others who don't believe Raagmala to be baani, not read it. Don't force everyone to read Raagmala. There is a strong segment in panth who does not read Raagmala and same goes for the ones who read Raagmala. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: women in sikhi

Waheguroo! Network · 06 Sep 2003

Kulbir Singh Veer jee, We would like a copy of that tape. Please email me at [address removed] :) --Daas

Re: women in sikhi

-kookar- · 07 Sep 2003

A GurSikh gets hurt when they see Sikhs cutting their hair, trimming their beirds, taking the turban of Guru Gobind Singh ji into un- gursikh places like pubs and clubs. A GurSikh gets hurt when they see Sikhs wearing a Kara and raising a pint of beer in the same hand. A GurSikh gets hurt when they see a Sikh raising a cigarrette to the same mouth that was eating Guru's langar just a few days before. These things rightly hurt the Gursikh because those Sikhs have turned their back on the Shabd Guru's teachings. The Trap the GurSikh falls into is Hate. Hate consumes the GurSikh because all the those people have insulted what s/he holds closest to their heart. Maya's friend Hate was invisible, unsmellable and undetectable...hate sneaked into the gursikh's mind and body temple like a trained Ninja Warrior. O GurSikh pyari-o jee, dont let hate enter your temple for any reason whether it's personal hurt or religious insults. O GurSikh pyari-o, Guru jee has taught us that Waheguru ji resides in every heart...so we are only hating Waheguru ji if we hate anyone at all. O gurSikh pyari-o, Guru ji has taught us the mortal will be judged by actions alone. Criticise their actions, call the actions bad, deal with actions...but dont hate the person. There is a Sakhi (historic event) about a great Sant-Sipahee...he truly had attained one-ness with Waheguru ji and had mastered weaponary too. In the battlefield he fought for justice. His opponent had been overpowered and lay on his back on the floor. The Sant-sipahee was about to destroy the sinner by plunging the sword of Akal into his chest, when the opponent spat in the Sant-Sipahee's face. The Sant-Sipahee's blood boiled, rage and fury burned him for a moment, he raised his sword with new fervour.but stopped the sword in mid-swing!. The enemy was shocked, expecting to be dead, he grunted 'Kill Me Sikh, you have beaten me'. The Sant-Sipahee replied, 'Before I was fighting for justice, against the evil actions of your army, and destroying you was destroying injustice. When you spat in my face I wanted to kill you because you insulted ME. I was going to kill you out of ANGER AND HATE. I would have to have been reborn because of that, so I have spared you'. The enemy soldier was so incredibly amazed at the Khalsa soldier, that within a few months he left his troops and joined the Khalsa. path - finer than a hair and sharper than a sword.