Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Honouring a Patit Sikh

Honouring a Patit Sikh

Kulbir Singh · 09 Sep 2003

I received the following email from a Singh in India: >>>>> Hope you all in Chardi Kala.Today itself, there was a news in a section of the press. SGPC is going to honour Jugraj Singh, a hockey player,who got injured in a car accident and is under treatment.Probablly, he was drunk when met with accident. He does not keep hair. Does SGPC furthers the cause of propagation of Sikh cause by honouring a Patit Sikh player. Kindly do highlight it and write to SGPC and your friends to drop the idea. >>>>>> Singh jee has made a very valid point. What is the point in honouring Jugraj Singh the hockey star of India? He is a monna and SGPC should not honour him and portray him as a Sikh hero. He may be a national hero but not a Sikh hero. We don't need heroes like him. He is an excellent hockey player and in the last world cup he out-performed everyone but still let hockey fans honour him. He has done nothing for Sikhi and there is no need for SGPC to honour him. I appeal SGPC to rethink it's decision to honour a patit Sikh. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Honouring a Patit Sikh

Knower · 09 Sep 2003

Yes, I agree by honouring Jugraj they are sending the wrong message... by honouring him, they are implying that you may become a Patit, and still be accepted by the Khalsa Panth as a "hero", considering that SGPC represents the Panth. They should only honour him if Jugraj makes a promise that he will from that day onwards be a Kesadhari. Now if he were to do that then he truly would be a hero as many young Sikh men in Punjab look up to him, would follow his example and keep kesh.

Re: Honouring a Patit Sikh

kps · 09 Sep 2003

Absolutely ! "gursikhaa no saabaas hai" "jis no bakhshay sifat salaah naanak paatshaahee paatshaahu" "naanak hor paathshaaheeaa(n) koorreeaa(n) naam rathae paatshaah" "paathshaahee bhagath janaa ko ditheean" "jab yae ga-ae bipran kee reeth, mai naa karoo(n) inn kee partheeth"

Re: Honouring a Patit Sikh

Singh101 · 10 Sep 2003

What is meant by patit Sikh? Meaning that the guy was baptised and broke his Amrit? Or that he is a mona who has never taken Amrit. In which case, how can he be a patit?

Re: Honouring a Patit Sikh

JB Singh · 14 Sep 2003

Better we send our comments on the subject to SGPC, so that it is not too late.

Re: Honouring a Patit Sikh

JB Singh · 14 Sep 2003

One who has not taken AMRIT, may be, he could not be technically termed as PATIT, if he is guilty of not keeping hair. Don’t know, what should we “term” them ? Sons or Daughters of Sikhs but without hair. But where is the SIKHI without tress knot on head? We do not expect very divine decisions from SGPC under the present scenario. But it is there that all of them, always utter big talks about propagation of SIKHI and crusade against menace of PATITISM. They also talk about using the print and electronic media for propagation of SIKHI. Honoring a PATIT sikh, gives wrong message to whole community, through the media, “Without hair, you achieve something worldly, you are welcome and proud for the community.” Does not that mean propagation of PATITISM ? I hold my head with disgust, when they think and decide to honour influential people like Ujal Dosanj, in front of young sikh students. DSPGC in Delhi did so and GNDU followed. They honored Him. Not a big gursikh or psychologist or philosopher is needed to understand, that what harm this “honor ceremony” does to the young minds. But after all, we are being led by foolish and third class leaders. We are strong, physically and economically, as a community .Can not we afford to prepare teams of players for different games, who are in SIKH SAROOP and play and win and merry in public view ? Where ever we see, we see sikh players, without hair generally. SGPC must think of honoring only the players or artists, who perform with SIKH SAROOP intact. JBSingh Amritsar