Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Bhangra banned for Sikh women in Jamshedpur

Bhangra banned for Sikh women in Jamshedpur

searcher · 09 Apr 2003

http://www.hindustantimes.com/news/181_229214,000900030009.htm Bhangra banned for Sikh women in Jamshedpur Indo-Asian news Service Ranchi, April 7 A Sikh body in the steel city of Jamshedpur has taken to cultural policing, banning women from the community from dancing the vigorous Punjabi bhangra on the streets during celebrations. The Central Gurdwara Prabandhak Committee (CGPC) of Jamshedpur in Jharkhand said in a statement: "There will be a complete ban on women's participation in bhangra. Those found guilty of violating the directive will have pay Rs.2,100." The anti-bhangra stricture was one of several. The committee also banned the exchange of floral garlands by the bride and groom at their wedding, saying violations would invite a fine of Rs.1,100. It also decreed that girls attending weddings would have to be dressed in the traditional Punjabi salwar-kameez ensemble. The strictures invited sharp criticism from some Sikhs in Jharkhand's capital Ranchi. "The CGPC should not act like the Taliban. We oppose this move," said Santi Sardar of Ranchi. But members of the CGPC in Ranchi were not entirely in disagreement with their Jamshedpur counterparts. "We welcome the move to ban the bhangra (by women) on the streets. But we do not agree with the other bans," said Lakhbir Singh, a member of Ranchi CGPC.

Re: Bhangra banned for Sikh women in Jamshedpur

Harjinder Singh · 09 Apr 2003

what is this, who cares

Re: Bhangra banned for Sikh women in Jamshedpur

member · 10 Apr 2003

AHGAHAHAHAAH man, indians are sooo funnny, they can ban women and not men?????? yur gotta luv it, and if they gonna do it, let them do it, its only gonna be bad for them and no one else!

Re: Bhangra banned for Sikh women in Jamshedpur

kaur · 10 Apr 2003

What is this--- the 'Indian' version of Taliban!

Re: Bhangra banned for Sikh women in Jamshedpur

sawa lakh · 10 Apr 2003

i agree with the bibian wearing "decent" (modest) clothing to the gurdwara but the same should go for men. I think that if women want to they should be allowed to do bhangra or whatever else on the street. You can't make people behave like sikhs they've to choose do it. Also I think that banning bhangra will not solve the problem. People for the most part have no idea what sikhi is about what is so special about it. People think that it's just another religion like all other religions. They do not understand what is unique about it. i think if people had a better understanding of Sikhi they would themselves behave accordingly. I think this site also needs a section devoted to the basics of Sikhi. The content is very good but it does not speak much to somone who is just starting ont he path of Sikhi. No info about Gurus or even basic principles of Sikhism. I think admin should work towards changing this fast because that would provide context for why all the rehits are so important to keep.

Re: Bhangra banned for Sikh women in Jamshedpur

H Singh · 11 Apr 2003

fateh ji. i totally agree with this ban. isn't bhangra against sikhi? they are just banning sikhs from it. not non-sikhs. and what about banning non-sikhi bana? isn't that a good thing? finally, someone is taking good steps. first committee that is living upto its name and function. thank guruji for this.

Re: Bhangra banned for Sikh women in Jamshedpur

Kulbir Singh · 11 Apr 2003

Vaheguru jee kaa Khalsa Vaheguru jee kee fateh! I think what we need is parchaar and not decree of this kind. We all know that bhangra is not according to Sikhi but to ban bhangra will not work. How is the committee going to monitor this? What happens if some ladies are found to be doing bhangra? What are they going to do about it? Fine them? How will the enforce it? We don’t need Muslim kind of Fatwas but what we need is good solid parchaar done by Gurmukhs who have a practical Sikhi jeevan. I do agree that to some extent code of conduct should be enforced especially when it comes to the code of conduct to be followed at the Gurdwara Sahib. A few years ago, Delhi Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee, did a mataa (resolution or faislaa) to ask Sikh women not to wear skirts and pants when coming to the Gurdwara Sahibs in Delhi. This was not applicable on non-Sikh women. I fully agree with this decision of committee. In the eighties, when the Sikh freedom movement was at it’s zenith, some Sikh organizations burned the barber shops and meat shops in Punjab. Most of the youth at that time had long flowing beards but they did not change from heart. It was a terrible time because you would see a person, with a full beard and dastaara but acting like a manmukh i.e. going after girls and drinking etc. It had become hard to distinguish between an amritdhari person and an ordinary person. Then when the Sikh freedom movement was quelled by the military, all those persons who had kept kesh and beard out of fear, shaved and removed their turbans. In the light of the above stated facts, I believe that instead of issuing such meaningless decrees, solid parchaar should be done. Another flaw in this decree is that it only bans women from doing bhangra. What about men? I fully agree that Sikhs should not do bhangra but I don’t think this is the way we can stop it. It will not work. Something solid like changing one’s mind should be done. Daas,

Re: Bhangra banned for Sikh women in Jamshedpur

Singhnee · 11 Apr 2003

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!! I agree with kulbir singh jee. Bhangra is not gurmat but it should be banned for all sikhs not just for sikh women because we are not muslims who have different rules for men and women. There is a need for more sikhi parchaar to finish these kureets. Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!!

Re: Bhangra banned for Sikh women in Jamshedpur

Khalsa Soulja · 12 Apr 2003

yep, i agree, if u wanna teach people somethings wrong u dont just ban it, its just like prohibition in america - the problem will get worse.......all we need is more PREACHERS......guru arjun made enuf of em......look how big islam is now because of them.......sikhi has no preachers thats why we dont have a massive following, and even the people we do have, the majority are monneh who couldnt care less bout sikhi.

Re: Bhangra banned for Sikh women in Jamshedpur

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 12 Apr 2003

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!! sikhs are'nt allowed 2 have fun? Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!!

Re: Bhangra banned for Sikh women in Jamshedpur

member · 13 Apr 2003

i doint think bhangra is AGAINST sikhi, its just not right, as in we wasting our time with it. Same can be said about watching tv, or playing sport, anything thats not helping u remember god isn't right, but no ones banning tv now are they If ppl wanna be really good sikhs then they can make the decision to not do these things, if they dont wanna then its their own loss, but their shouldn't be a law about it

Re: Bhangra banned for Sikh women in Jamshedpur

Singhnee2 · 14 Apr 2003

I think its a good thing about this banning. Finally, a committee of gursikhs that are trying to enforce gurmat in the land of the guru! I think that its ok to ban singhnees from bhangra first since our modesty is different than the modesty of singhs. Also, our safety and security from being "touched" is a very big issue. This is a good first step, it also keeps the singhnees and singhs separated in that sexual atmosphere. Also I think that you know its kinda good that gurmat is being enforced. Look at what's happening in Punjab when its not enforced? Before we had the Guru's enforcing it. Then we had the Jatha's. Then we had the Nihangs. Now we have no one. That is why sikhi is dying there. You know everyone complains about the state of sikh youth in punjab. Finally a gursikh committee does something about it rather than just wasting all of our time talking and talking and no action and you guys say its too much? My phabhi is from panjab and when she heard about it she was very happy. She is a gursikh and she said this is the only way forward. I'm sorry this is so long but lots of people are glad we finally have a committee to turn too. We always complain that SGPC does nothing and DGPC does nothing. Well, someone finally did something. We should give them all a siropa.

Re: Bhangra banned for Sikh women in Jamshedpur

Guru's das · 19 Apr 2003

Vaheguru jee kaa Khalsa Vaheguru jee kee fateh! Kulbir Singh wrote: "In the eighties, when the Sikh freedom movement was at it’s zenith, some Sikh organizations burned the barber shops and meat shops in Punjab. Most of the youth at that time had long flowing beards but they did not change from heart. It was a terrible time because you would see a person, with a full beard and dastaara but acting like a manmukh i.e. going after girls and drinking etc. It had become hard to distinguish between an amritdhari person and an ordinary person. Then when the Sikh freedom movement was quelled by the military, all those persons who had kept kesh and beard out of fear, shaved and removed their turbans." I talked to a veer of mine that used to be in the movement. His response is that you should not criticize what the Singhs in the 80s did. Everything was done after much vichar. These decisions were made by mar-jeevaray gursikhs who laid down their lives, sacrificed their whole parivaars, and did more than just talk. He said that as long as these rules were enforced, most of the people were happy. They were living sikhi jivan. The populations supported the Singhs. He said where else did the singhs find refuge? There are no jungles or deserts or mountains in punjab. They found refuge in people's homes. The people sacrificed a lot. He said look at the Sikh youth now. Look at the situation they are in. Almost all of them are drug addicts and alcoholics. Is this better or the rules the Singhs were enforcing? He said that sometimes the fires of kaljug go to far in society and at that time Gursikhs have to make such rules. He said if parchar was so effective, why isn't it working in Punjab now? He said there are more parcharaks and parcharak organizations in punab now then in the 80s. He said he was surprised that such criticism is coming on a site like this since the decisions against the barbers and meat shops were first put forward by the Akhand Kirtani Jatha related Babbar Khalsa. Those were true Gursikhs who died for the Panth. They knew how to save the Panth. And for a couple of years in the 80s, it was like Khalsa Raj was already running in Punjab. He also said that why we talk about khalsa raj if we are not going to make it the raj of khalsa - pure? What type of raj will it be? Of punjabis? Are we just fighting for punjab, which is just another state or province, or we are fighting for sikhi? If we are fighting for sikhi and sikhs, then are we going to implement rules of sikhi or not? He said he completely supported this decision. So did his other friends from the movement which he still keeps in contact with. He also said its irresponsible for people who did nothing for the movement but write nice emails to criticize those who gave their lives. He said first pick up the gun and join your brothers. Watch as your bhai is killed in your arms. Hear the stories about how police raided your house to disrespect your mother. Sleep in the fields with one cyanide capsule, one revolver and 4 bullets. Then see if you can criticize. He said if you do this, then you will know why Singhs enforced sikhi. They were not going to die for just the land (mittee). Or just the water (paanee). They were dying for Sikhi. Their raj was sikhi raj. Or Khalsa Raj. He said people did change from the heart, otherwise why did those same people risk their lives to help the singhs? But, he said that a human's heart can change with sangat. When Singhs were not enforcing their rules anymore, then public shows like bhangra etc. came out. He said that had a negative effect and people's hearts changed. It is common fact he said that sangat or kusangat can change a person's heart. One last thing he asked me what are we fighting for? What are we dying for? Why did so many die? If not to have Sikha da raj? He said what when khalistan comes you don't think we will be enforcing sikhi rules then? Will we have the raj for just the money and the power? Not to make the sikhi rules? He sends his Fateh to all the Singhs and Singhneeaa who support the Khalistani Fighters.

Re: Bhangra banned for Sikh women in Jamshedpur

Sarbloh Badman · 19 Apr 2003

u just need people to PREACH. forget bans and stuff. back in 82 to 84, alcohol consumption in punjab was virtually non existant. people like bhindrenwale made people forget vice and sikhi flourished to an extent. now alcohol is rampant, even if it was banned u think people would stop? bhangra is wrong but banning it isnt the way to stop it.

Re: Bhangra banned for Sikh women in Jamshedpur

devinesanative · 18 Jan 2006

Is ban the only way out ? People ban what they see , what about which is not seen . Is your Belief and Faith so Weak that You people get distracted by women wearing jeans . Is this your sikhi ? Are you so weak that whenever you go to gurudwara you always look for what women are wearing . Oh , Dear dharam ke thekedars Try to spread the message of GuruNank Dev ji .... instead of banning anything .

Re: Bhangra banned for Sikh women in Jamshedpur

curious · 18 Jan 2006

exactly....just more Brahmanism creepin in ...lets get it all outta Sikhi, stop this Bipran ki Reet

Re: Bhangra banned for Sikh women in Jamshedpur

DDT · 18 Jan 2006

u shouldnt ban ppl from doing so thats like trying to force ppl to make the rite decision if a person doesnt see the problems with wat there doing themselves then theres no point. U cant force someone to get involved with sikhi they have to themselves this is the same thing. it would be better if we would tell ppl wats wrong with wat there doing forcing ppl to stop stuff like this is oppressing them, even if we know what there doing is wrong. if u tell a kid he cant eat candy he'd just want to eat it more, but if u explain to the child that eating candy isnt good because of health reasons and dental hygene then they mite stop themselves. either way if there going to ban women from doing so banning men would be the just thing to do... no one should be doing bhangra we should all be doing pentra

Re: Bhangra banned for Sikh women in Jamshedpur

Truth · 18 Jan 2006

Guru's das.......you're damn lucky to know a living shaheed like that. Reading your post gave me goosebumps. Sometimes living in this liberal society we become too soft. I too support Khalsa ideals being promoted, and anti-khalsa habits being either banned or atleast officially admonished in our khalistan. To hell with anyone who says "you guys are acting like the taliban". If you don't like, then move along, this world is a big place. we'll have our khalistan and we'll keep it strict, just the way we like it.

Re: Bhangra banned for Sikh women in Jamshedpur

DDT · 19 Jan 2006

"Truth" what ure saying is wrong and against sikhi. WE can't go around and make strict rules that everyone must follow no matter what. ONly when the person feels it is rite to follow these rules can they follow them. What ure saying is a tyranny. If we get Khalistan as the sate of Punjab are we gonna force all hindu;s to convert? i think not thats going against what our Guru's told us.

Re: Bhangra banned for Sikh women in Jamshedpur

LionKing (LK) · 19 Jan 2006

Author: H Singh Date: 04-11-03 01:15 fateh ji. i totally agree with this ban. isn't bhangra against sikhi? they are just banning sikhs from it. not non-sikhs. and what about banning non-sikhi bana? isn't that a good thing? finally, someone is taking good steps. first committee that is living upto its name and function. thank guruji for this. ******** Agree with DDT. If you're a Sikh and like to have a dance at songs like - "sadi rail gadi ay" or whatever - that's entirely up to them. As some have already states no it is not enocuraged by Gurmat - it will not help you in your Gursikhi jeevan - but NO-ONE has the right to enforce something upon you. If you want to go and move your legs back and forth with your hands in the air - who cares? Are we talibanis? Fine I'm not saying encourage - but no-one can BANN someone from doing it. Seriously. No matter if Bhangra is or isn't against Sikhi is completly irrelevant. Let's say it is - no-one still has the right to IMPOSE theri view on you and BANN you from dancing. If you wanna go and dance - go and Dance. Gosh. Where are we getting? T