Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

Balpreet Singh · 04 Jul 2005

Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History Based on “Tabai Roas Jagio” by Dr. Sukhpreet Singh Udokay Last week’s announcement by the VHP of putting portraits of Guru Gobind Singh and Sree Guru Granth Sahib in Hindu Mandirs has shocked Sikhs worldwide. The fact is that attacks on the Sikh faith and history have been ongoing for years in order to show Sikhs to be a part of Hinduism. How Did This Begin? Brahminism has always feared the Sikh faith. The Sikh Gurus proclaimed the equality of all humanity and rejected practices like caste, holy threads and worship of the cow. The exploitation of simple people by the Brahmin was eliminated. Although Hindu fundamentalists have taken a keen interest in destroying Sikhism for centuries, this latest cycle of Hindu attacks on Sikhism can be traced to 1993. The Sikh Liberation Movement had been brutally crushed in Punjab and was on its final breaths. Sikh villagers were afraid of being identified as being practicing Sikhs and roves of young Sikh men were cutting their hair so that they would not be harassed or killed by the police. It was at this point that a new “Sikh” organization, the Rashtri Sikh Sangat began to enter Sikh villages. This organization began to distribute literature about the Sikh faith and hold meetings. Many villagers thought that it was an attempt to revive Sikh pride, but in fact, the literature was written to show Sikhs to be a part of Hinduism. Akali Dal/BJP/RSS Alliance Badal & RSS Leaders The “Akali” party of Punjab, while claiming to represent Sikhs, is lead by the same old men who allowed the 1978 Amritsar massacre and the martyrdom of Bhai Fauja Singh and 12 other fellow Singhs. They are the same ones who let Gurbachana Narakdhari go unpunished. The Akali party, in an alliance with the Hindu BJP began to rule Punjab. The RSS activity in Punjab also increased. Sangh programs were held in places like Guru Nanak Dev Stadium (Ludhiana) with the presence of Parkash Badal and other Akali/BJP leaders. On November 16, 1997, Badal while introducing the new RSS chief sad, “I can say with confidence that the Sangh, under the leadership of Raju Bhaiya is working towards removing all its shortcomings. Whenever this country has faced either internal or external danger, the Sangh and it’s workers have been on the front lines. Today, I am feeling very lucky to be a part of this gathering.” Raju Bhaiya in his speech that day, in the presence of Badal, declared, “All Hindus are Sikhs and Sikhs Hindus. We are all one. Some grow hair and some don’t. I say that All Hindus are Sikhs and all Sikh are Hindus. Our principles are the same. With the help of unity, we become very powerful…People are right when they say that Hindus have the power to make Hindustan a leader in the world!” An RSS Poster for Punjab Under the watchful guidance of this unholy alliance, the RSS increased its parchar amongst the Sikhs. It was a perfect time to move in for the kill. The Sikhs had been beaten very badly by the Indian government and their confidence had been shaken. The RSS would give the Sikhs sweet poison. They shouted loudly that the RSS and all Hindus LOVED Sikhs. They would preach that Sikhs were after all no different than Hindus. The Sikh Gurus were true Hindus and Brahma, Shiva and Vishnu blessed the Sikh faith. The Sikhs, they claimed, should feel proud as the sword-arm of Hinduism. In this way, the RSS has tried to make the Sikh masses try to take pride in establishing a link between Sikhism and Hinduism. Once this link becomes solid, the RSS has already devised a plan to decay the foundations of the Sikh faith and history. India's "Heros": Guru Nanak an equal of Indira Gandhi? Who is the Rashtriya Sikh Sangat? The Rashtriya Sikh Sangat (RSS) was officially formed on November 23, 1986 in Amritsar. The founder was one “Shamsher Sinh” The express goals of the RSS are 1) To strengthen the bonds between Sikhs and Hindus to promote National unity, awareness and patriotism. 2) To make Guru Nanak’s “Hindustan Smaalsee Bola” a reality and maintain national patriotism and unity. 3) To promote Sri Guru Bani fro Sri Guru Granth Sahib 4) To perform seva with “Sarbat Da Bhala” in mind. The Rashtriya Sikh Sangat has 500 branches across India and publishes the magazine “Sangat Sandesh”. Other goals of this organization are the creation of a Mandar at Ayodhya’s “Ram Janam Bhoomi” and also a Gurdwara to commemorate visits by Guru Nanak, Guru Tegh Bahadur and Guru Gobind Singh. Every month, the Rashtriya Sikh Sangat has a function in which occasionally Sri Guru Granth Sahib is parkash and sometimes not. Usually the function takes place with paintings of Guru Nanak, Guru Tegh Bahadur and Guru Gobind Singh at the front. These paintings are accompanied by paintings of Ram and Krishna. The paintings are garlanded with flowers. The meeting begins with 5 readings of the Mool Mantar and then 20 minutes of keertan. After this, Sukhmani Sahib or Ram Avtar or Krishan Avtar are read. This is followed by a singing of “Vanday Matram”. The meeting concludes with a 20 minute lecture on the history the original RSS founder Golvarkar and discussion of the role of Sanskrit in Sri Guru Granth Sahib or some other similar topic. Some Quotes… * “Instead of sacrificing humans, Guru ji sacrificed goats and started the tradition of Punj Pyaaray. All five Pyaaras were followers of the Hindu faith” {Dr. Himmat Sinh in Rashtra Dharam) * “The Sikh Gurus showed faith in the Hindu faith and visited Hindu pilgrimage sites to show this” (Rashtra Dharam, p. 31) * “When Guru Arjan was doing the Kar Seva of Harimandeir, Vishnu reflected and said, “Lakshmi, the Guru is my own form. There is no difference between us. He is making my temple. Let us go and see the building of our new temple…” (Rashtra Dharam, 90) * “The difference between Hindus and Sikhs was the creation of the English mind.” (Rashtra Dharam, 98) * “If today someone were to make a portrait of Guru Nanak without a beard and turban, his life would be in danger but in fact, the practice of keeping long hair and beards began only in the 20th Century. (Madhu Kishvara, Hindustan Times Aug 21, 1999) * “Guru Arjan Dev and Guru Tegh Bahadur used to pay obeisance to the feet of the Devi” (Surindar Kumar, Jag Bani) * “Guru Gobind Singh with the blessings of the Avtars (Brahma, Vishnu, Shiva) created the Khalsa Panth.” (Sangat Sandesh, Sept 1998) * “Maharana Partap, the Rani of Jhansi and Guru Gobind Singh were all great patriots” (Rashtra Dharam) * “The Sangh [RSS] is the Khalsa” (Ravani, Dec 1997) “Guru Mati Das Sharma”??? Bhai Mati Das jee is a famous Shahid of the Sikhs who happily faced death by being sawn alive but did not forsake his faith. Bhatt Vehis record the history of this Shahid and it is known that Bhai Mati Das’s grandfather, Bhai Paraga jee was a Sikh of Guru Hargobind and also became a Shaheed in the battle of Ruhila. Bhai Mati Das jee was of course then born into a Sikh family. The family had been Sikh since the time of Guru Ram Das. Bhai Sati Das was Bhai Sahib’s brother. Bhai Mati Das accompanied Guru Tegh Bahadur in his travels to Assam, Bengal and Bihar. When Guru Sahib was arrested and brought to Delhi, Bhai Mati Das was also brought with him. When offered the choice to forsake the Sikh faith and become a Muslim or to face death, Bhai Mati Das happily accepted the latter and only asked that he die while facing the Guru. Even when Bhai Sahib’s body had been cut in two, Japji Sahib could be heard from both halves. Bhai Sati Das was also offered the choice to forsake Sikhi or death, and accepted death. He was wrapped in cotton and burnt alive. Hindu fundamentalist organizations, in an effort to demean Guru Tegh Bahadur’s Shaheedee, have appropriated Bhai Mati Das and Bhai Sati Das as Hindu heros. Yearly events are held to commemorate their martyrdoms but they are presented as Hindus who died for their faith. Bhai Hakeekat Singh jee was a young Sikh who is recorded in Bhatt Vehis as “Hakeekat Singh” but later was appropriated by Hindus as their own. Just like Bhai Hakeekat Singh is now referred to as Hakeekat Rai even by Sikhs, these groups hope Sikhs will also give up these two Sikh Shaheeds. Sikhs and Raam Another fallacy being promoted by the RSS is that the Sikh Gurus were from the family of Raam. That throughout history, Vishnu has supported the Sikhs. No Hindu text gives the family tree of Raam, and so there is no foundation for this claim. Giani Puran Singh gave this lie credence by repeating it publicly when he was Jathedar of the Akal Takhat. The only support this lie has is in a work by Kesar Singh Chhiber that has been corrupted. It claims the link between Raam and the Gurus but it also claims that Guru Gobind Singh worshipped Durga and took permission to keep his kesh from her. It also claims that the Sikh Gurus accepted Sanatan Hindu rites. Baba Banda Singh Bahadur or Veer Banda Bairagi? "Veer Bandai Bairagi" One of the RSS’s early targets has been Baba Banda Singh Bahadur. Baba Banda Singh is a Sikh hero who first created a Sikh Rule in Punjab and struck a Sikh coin. Baba Banda Singh is also a great Sikh martyr who sacrificed his life but did not compromise his faith. The RSS has attempted to turn this great Sikh hero, into a Hindu Patriot. In the book “Veer Banda Bairagi” by Bhai Parmanand, Guru Gobind Singh was a defeated man who went to Nander in sadness. There he met the Hindu, Banda Bairagi who agreed to help Guru Sahib take revenge for the death of his sons. Banda Baigragi had with him Rajput warriors and a he gathered a Hindu army to punish the evil Wazir Khan. Guru Gobind Singh giving "Veer Bairagi" arms The new Hindu history claims that Banda Bairagi never became a Sikh and was an example of a pious Hindu helping his Sikh friend. This story is of course utterly false. There was never any character named “Banda Bairagi”. Baba Banda Singh was known as Madho Das. He became a Sikh of Guru Gobind Singh by receiving Khanday Kee Pahul. This fact is confirmed by the oldest sources including Tavarikh-Iradat Khan (1714) and Panj Sau Sakhi (1734). The Bhatt Vehis mention how Guru Gobind Singh himself gave Baba Banda Singh the five kakaars and tied a keski on his head. Baba Banda Singh’s own hukumnamas all make clear that he was a Sikh of the Guru and call upon [gurbani]“srbqR Akwl purK jIE dw Kwlsw”[[/gurbani]. The question arises, if “Banda Bairagi” had an army of Hindu warriors, why wouldn’t he have taken revenge for the Mughal excesses at Kanshi and Mathura? Why are none of the famous Hindus in his army recorded in history? Why were the Faujdars of conquered areas always Sikhs? Why do even his own family accounts (Bansavalinama) refer to him and his sons with the name “Singh”? It is a blatant lie by the RSS to appropriate a Sikh hero and make him into a Hindu. A 25-Point of Attack The RSS has 25 points with which it hopes to attack the Sikh faith and lead to its eventual assimilation. All 25 points are very easily refuted but lack of education and knowledge coupled with the RSS’s organized attack make this a serious danger. These points are already being incorporated into school text books and taught as real history. This skewed history is already taught in many areas. 1) Sikhs are an inseparable part of Hindu society. 2) If Hinduism is a tree, Sikhism is a fruit on that tree. 3) Gurbani is like the Ganga, it emerges from the Gangotri of the Vedas 4) The Khalsa was crated to protect Hinduism and Hindustan 5) Japji Sahib is a summary of the Gita 6) The Failure of the 1857 “War of Independence” [in reality an unorganized uprising by Poorbiya soldiers who 8 years earlier helped the British conquer Punjab] was defeated only by the Sikhs 7) Banda Singh Bahadur was really Veer Banda Bairagi 8) The Sikh Gurus worshipped the cow 9) Condemning Bhai Kanh Singh Nabha and Bhai Veer Singh 10) Use examples from Trumpp and other anti-Sikh western scholars 11) The Sikh Gurus used Vedic ceremonies 12) Guru Gobind Singh worshipped the Goddess Durga 13) Guru Sahib was from the family or Ram and his devotee 14) Sikhs are from Lav-Kush 15) Baba Ram Singh was the legitimate Guru of the Sikhs 16) Create posters which challenge Sikh principles but appear to be pro-Sikh 17) Insist on using the Bikrami calendar and share Hindu festivals 18) Call Bhai Hakeekat Singh, Hakeekat Rai and illustrate him as a clean- shaven Hindu 19) Claim [with no historical basis] that Guru Gobind Singh sent his army to liberate Ram Janam Bhumi in Ayodhya from the Mughals 20) To create the Khalsa, Guru Gobind Singh seeked blessing from the gods and goddesses and used Hindu mantras. The Kakaars were also blessings from the gods. 21) Equate [gurbani]ÅÆ[/gurbani] with “OM” 22) Call Bhai Mati Das “Guru Mati Das Sharma” 23) To do parkash of Sree Guru Granth Sahib in Mandirs and put pictures of Hindu Gods in Sikh Gurdwaras 24) Project Guru Gobind Singh as having taken a different ideology from Guru Nanak and to make him into a Patriotic Hero of India Guru Gobind Singh with Rana Partap and other Hindu "Heros" 25) Make all of Sikh history take a Hindu tint. Small Steps to Oblivion The RSS recognizes that Hinduism is many hundreds of years old and it can slowly assimilate the Sikhs with time. By establishing links between Vishnu/Raam and the Gurus, they hope that Sikhs will see these Hindu gods as their own. With time, perhaps pictures of Raam and Vishnu will find their way into Gurdwaras. The RSS has commissioned paintings and posters that mix Hinduism and Sikhism and present Sikh figures receiving blessings from Hindu gods. Idol worship, which is taboo in Sikhism is also being slowly introduced. Idols of Guru Gobind Singh and Guru Nanak can now be purchased from many stores. Some Nanaksar Thaats have also installed these idols. If idols of Sikh Gurus are acceptable, then perhaps with time Hindu idols can be accepted. Gurdwara Manikaran is a good example of what the RSS would like to see more common. By putting Guru Granth Sahib in Hindu mandirs, simple Sikh villagers will begin to go to pay obeisance regularly. With Sikhs attending Hindu Mandirs, they will also offer worship to the Hindu gods and goddesses there. Sikh marriages may also begin to take place in Mandirs. Eventually, Hinduism in Punjab will be a mish/mash of Sikhism and Hinduism and the Sikhs will lose their distinct identity. Given a few generations, Guru Nanak will be an Avtar of Vishnu just like the Buddha has become and the Sikhs will be eliminated. Today, Hindu Mandirs and idols again surround Sree Darbaar Sahib in Amritsar. In total, nine mandirs surround the Darbar Sahib complex, with some even in the galleria. When will these small mandirs be turned into massive buildings? When they are, what will the Sikhs have to say? The Sikhs today are facing dark days. The Sikh Liberation Movement has been destroyed along with Sikh self-confidence. Hindu Fundamentalist organizations are making deep inroads into the community and still there is no reaction. We will be remembered as the first generation of Sikhs to have accepted defeat and subjugation from an adversary. Will we wake up when it is too late?

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

Balpreet Singh · 04 Jul 2005

Does it seem too unlikely that people would fall for this type of nonsense? Isn't it obvious that Sikhs are not Hindus? You don't have to look too far to see some victims of this disgusting ideology. A lot of Youth are buying into this "Sanatan" Sikhi which is exactly what the RSS have in mind and want. We have a series of websites that promote this corrupt propoganda. Using a Sikh appearance, they are pushing Hinduism. The creative work below (out of the UK) shows how hard these bigots will try to make Sikhs seem like Hindus. It's time to say we will no longer tolerate this rubbish.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

JSGyani "Arshi" · 04 Jul 2005

and dont forget the SADH-SANT derawallahs Tolla...they also Fight tooth and nail to prove we are HINDUS....and they twist and turn gurbani any which way to show this. These "snakes in the grass" are even worse than the openly hindu rss bjp vhp..the SANT SAMAAJ is the ghar da bhetee lanka dhaveh....and they managed to get up to Akal takhat itself through pooran singh and likes...

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

charanjeev singh · 04 Jul 2005

This is truly a case of 'Sant Kee Ninda', and the attributes of such an action is outlined in Sri Sukhmani Sahib. They will not only be punished by the Panth, they will also be punished by Waheguruu.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

sandeep · 04 Jul 2005

I THINK HINDU SIKH AND ALSO MUSLIM ARE EQUALS.IN GURUBANITHERE IS *EK NOOR SE SAB JAG UPJEA KOIN BHALE KOIN MANDE*.........SANDEEP

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

mnm · 05 Jul 2005

deeply disturbing to say the least! however we must also not forget that many fake sikhs who attend these mandirs or become muslims or purposely venture off into other religions, do kanjrapoona and drink do drugs were "opportunist sikhs". They become sikhs when there was something in it for them. When we have no political power to weild these subjects want to express themselves in multi colourful forms ready to blend themselves to fit in instead of finding shanti in naam ras. I have not found many sikhs who really want to give their mind and bodies for sikhi. In delhi chandigarh many sikhs wear hindu attire and saris cut their hair to flow like hindus. In uk and america punjabi sikhs wear these american attire showing their bust sizes legs and backs. . But the biggest problem the panth is facing truly is hindu fundamentalists due to the sikh concentration in punjab. The saddest reality is that despite the whole khadku time, panthic elimination, punjab being surgically decimated by both hindu india and pakistan the rehitvan sikhs were comparitevly small in number compared to the sikh masses. The sikh masses only supported khadkus in the vain hope that khadkus were on their way to rule punjab. When the punjab poilice changed their plan to pave way for a complete genocide the masses themselves turned against very sikh principle betrayed the panth and sold out their sikhi informed on khadkus and supported goi efforts to get khadkus done. Now we are in such a situation where we have to ask how do we deal with this? i think of some ways 1) armed struggle 2) singh sabha style 3) sikh charities uplifting sikhi through central daswand armed struggle some may feel is an option, i myself see that will get more sikhs killed and defeat the cause to start with making sikhs even more weaker. However sikhs always have a right to defend their lives property community gurdwaras and most definatly must begin to act like a community and a panth. the british reported that each village they could not enter because they were fortified. Well sikhs why do you want to live in high class areas dressed in seht babu suits in a minority? come and join the panth, live in sikh areas, so if ever a time comes when anyone tries to destroy sikhs they are at least in one family together they may fight back strongly. Singh sabha style will only work if the masses respond to it. I see little signs even of that, as the past struggle singh sabha lehar was one about confusion , rehetvan sikhs set the record straight, sikhs still with some anakh finally carved their identity on a socio religious level. Where is the anakh today? If there is no thirst on that level then what do we do? Punjab is suffering from resource losses, water, poverty, food, essential things. I believe sikhs should campaign from canada america uk australia in all financially rich countries. Establish a big charity drive like band aid . Collect daswand for the panth and create programmes that will help feed sikhs, clothe them, unite them, bring shelter to them, build educational instituitions so sikhs in punjab may develop and churn out a new generation of doctors nurses lawyers proffesionals. Sikhs in other regions utside punjab should consider relocating to punjab for their own safety and bring their economic clout to help punjab. the biggest problem is we think we are a panth but we certainly dfo not act like one. If we are not a panth we cannot challange all these evil things in socviety especially rss and hindu fanatics. we have to arrest athiesm amongst the youth and somehow find a way to make sikhi appealing to the youth and define the perfect state of khalsa not only in spirit but in terms of what we want to establish on earth here and now. as many khalsa sikhi camps , rensbhais, smagams that shoukld be double treble ten times the ratios in punjab where our population is much more. [%sig%]

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

search for tat · 05 Jul 2005

amazing how everything RSS are teaches fits exactly with the idelogue that Niddar teaches in UK.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

Dave Floyd · 05 Jul 2005

All prophets come from one source, so put your hatred behind you and practice what ye preach [%sig%]

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

Dave Floyd · 05 Jul 2005

Why so much hate ?

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

look at the last pic · 05 Jul 2005

these hindu faces they look like they have inferiority complex issues. why would a normal man look so freaked out holding a blade like that when hindus already own and influence india? they must be insecure in themselves. These freaks should try to study sikhi and become sikhs and not listen to rss. Rss is succesful because it has resources that are funded globally from vhp america and europe under the name of disaster, famine, disease and development projects. The money really goes to rss training, shaka camps and trishuls for inferiority ridden hindus with no life direction. The very main social lifestream of india aka "bollywood" is a mere fantasy that these inferior hindus realise late is something out of their reach then they get vexed and lash out because their butterz and feel inferior. Just look at the guys face, it has no authority, no confidence, a skinny bony little DIP. If that little blade came out of his hand i bet you he would turn into a mouse first wet his nappy and run bloody burnt toast da tookra he hasnt even got any shoulders. It looks like these trishul trained chimps have never really expressed or developed themselves their lives have not evolved properly and now their at their feelins gonna explode into inferior rage and direct it towards the minorities. thats the difference between sikhs and other asians, we teach our kids to express grow strong and be bold for their own future, these hindus try to control their kids with fear, threats, lieing, black majic and stuff and stop them growing inside as normal people. But maybe i live in an ideal world too much, the reality appears to be we just simply cannot live with these hindu fanatics pulling blades out like that with absolutly no moral conviction but singh only meant to pulls a kirpan when all means fail and here you have a chimp holding a blade when they already own india after crushing minorities? like what else do they want? thats just so aurangzebified and will put all smaller religions on high alert if sikhs decide to wake up. all over the world media talks about terrorists, well here you have a bunc of hindu 0 terrorists but why are they not on rupert murdochs papers? because murdoch does not care about hindus holding blades because they have no doctrine to spread a religio political doctrine to spread globally and challange the states confined only to india. hats why the world stays silent on sikh atrocities the papers dont publish them because rupert and blue blooded dna obsessed gora bloodlines have given their hindu friends a pat on the back to do what they want. if these hindus are going to do that then they themselves are responsible for everything that happens. But fear not despair not, everything happens how God wants it. millions of trees plants grows it dies because God wanted it to. So when their time is up god will push the khalsa at the front to take charge with the reigns in their hands if we can first control our own reigns (panj chors) then god will grant us more shakti to wipe all evil out once and for all. part of the struggle initially is inside us first then guru kirpa as he wishes He takes us where He wants us to go so long we keep complete faith with no divisions, no politics between ourselves.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

... · 05 Jul 2005

arshi ... you are really losing the plot. every single real sant mahapursh highlights the distinct entity the khalsa panth is

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

singh · 05 Jul 2005

I remember when my cousin in India made a comparison between Guru Nanak and Rajiv Gandhi. He said Gandhi was good, but maybe not as good as Guru Nanak. To hear the two names on the same breath was disgusting.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

... · 05 Jul 2005

Dave Floyd, it's not about hate. It's about not wanting someone to corrupt your principles. I also don't think all "prophets" are divine. Not all prophets have taught the way to meet God. Only Guru Nanak is a total prophet/messanger of God in my eyes.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

article · 05 Jul 2005

an article: Slowly and steadily the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh is growing across Punjab. JAGTAR SINGH reports on the Sangh's attempt to co-opt the Sikhs. IT is the khaki invasion of Punjab. The Rashtriya Swayamsewak Sangh did not go the Akali way once it joined the tercentenary celebrations of the birth of the Khalsa in April last. The Akalis virtually forgot all about it and continued to be busy with their infighting. It was the RSS which took upon itself the responsibility of propagating the ideas and ideals of Guru Gobind Singh, the 10th Guru who founded the Khalsa, in the interiors of Punjab countryside. It is a different matter that the radical Akalis have demanded a ban on this organization. Till date, the RSS has covered 4,000 of about 12,000 villages and by the time the state-level function is organised at Amritsar as part of the tercentenary celebrations on April 2, the target is to establish contacts in about 8,000 villages. According to the RSS leaders, out of the 500 shakhas being organised in this border state, about 250 are in villages. Not only that, huge quantity of publicity material has been brought out, including one lakh calenders. They have been distributed all over the country. For the people in Punjab, the literature is in Punjabi in Devnagari script. "For us, Guru Gobind SIngh is a national hero. He integrates the Punjabi society. What we are doing is also for the integration of that society," explained an RSS leader. Radical Sikh leaders interpret the RSS designs as an attack on the exclusive Sikh identity. "In this integration, there is negation of a seperate Sikh identity," said an Akali leader. These leaders go back to earlier similar attempts when Bhai Kahan Singh Nabha, a Sikh scholar, brought out a pamplhet, "Hum Hindu Nahin." At one stage in Punjab, the Punjabi Hindus disowned their mother tongue to confront the Akali demand for a Punjabi suba. The RSS move is now being seen as an attempt to decommunalise that sectino of Hindu society also. The members of the Rashtriya Sikh Sangat, an organisation affiliated to the RSS, recently approached the Damdami Taksal, the Sikh seminary once headed by Sant Jarnail SIngh Bhinderanwale, to get their men trained in Sikh religion and philosophy. "We told them we admit only Amritdhari Sikhs. They did not approach us again," said Taksal spokeseman Mohkam Singh. "We will become Amritdhari also," says the RSS leader. The RSS treats the Khalsa as a sect of the Hindus created by Guru Gobind Singh to confront Islam, as apparent from the literature. Hence the objection by the radical Sikhs to the designs of the RSS in this border state who assert their exclusive identity. The agend of RSS in Punjab is: "The RSS is actively pursuing the philosophy and the path shown by Guru Nanak and Guru Gobind Singh. The RSS has the same perception of a healthy society and an ideal nation as that of the Guru Khalsa. Both these streams are flowing to get assimilated in the same ocean. The need is to integrate both these streams for speedier flow of the national mainstream." The RSS extensively quotes Guru Gobind Singh to hammer the point that the Khalsa was created to strengthen the Hindu society. The Sikhs are described as yet another Hindu shakti kendra. Even the setting up of the RSS is claimed to be in accordance with the ideals of Guru Gobind Singh. RSS leaders say the Panj Piaras (five beloved ones) who were the first to partake amrit were rom all over the country on the analogy of the Hindu maths set up by the Shankaracharaya earlier. The RSS writings also refer to Bachittar Natak, considered to be an autobiography of the 10th Guru to point out that the Sikh Gurus were Suryavanshi and descendants of Lav and Kush, the sons of Bhagwan Ram. Giani Puran Singh, the Jathedar of Akal TAkhat, the supreme temporal seat of the Sikhs, received a lot of flak from Sikh scholars when he dwelt on the theme of the Sikh gurus being descendants of Lav and Kush. Then there is the questionnaire prepared by RSS for the school-level competitions which has generated a lot of controversy. Now some of the questions: -To which caste Bhai Mardana belonged? -Which of the Sikh Gurus were Sodhis? -What was the name of the Pathan who stabbed Guru Gobind Singh? -Which Mughal emperor detained Guru nanak? -Name the Guru who deputed forces to liberate Ram Janambhumi. -Name India's first bachelor Prime Minister. -In which war with Pakistan not an inch of land was allowed to be occupied? CPI veteran Satya Pal Dang has expressed strong reservation about the questionnaire and has brought under the notice of Cheif Minister Parkash Badal. Meanwhile, the attempt of "assimilation" continues.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

Singh M · 05 Jul 2005

this is very sad. Something must be done fast before our individuality is extinct.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

sorry but · 05 Jul 2005

those pictures are so horrible...

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

gross · 05 Jul 2005

disgusting singh m , our individuality will never become extinct. look how hard people have tried in the past, even when there were only a handful of sikhs left, they still rose and the panth still flourished and there will never be a day when maharaj will let his panth fail or fall from glory. raaj karega khalsa. No one can break the Panth no one at all, even if there's only one Singh left standing in the whole world, no one can or will ever break Sikhi.. no matter HOW hard they try but we all need to make our jeevans strong, just like those old school shaheed singhs, if we want to serve the panth and help sikhi flourish

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

one_more_singh · 05 Jul 2005

David, I don't think you understand why the material in the first post of this thread is at the very least, offensive. It shows propoganda aimed at confusing uninformed Sikhs into thinking that Sikhism is a sect of Hinduism and that the Sikh gurus were devotees of Hindu gods/goddesses. That in spite of the fact that the theological doctrine is very different from that of Hinduism and the scriptures are adamant about the Gurus only being devotees of One God and no one else. Sikhs don't have anything against Hindus, however the group putting forth this propoganda is known as a Hindu extremist group that would like to see the elimination (or at least suppression) of other faiths in India to maintain Brahmin rule. Minorities such as Sikhs, Muslims, Christians and Dalits are targeted by this group and others like it partly because of their opposition to the caste system that is prevalent in India. Hardline groups such as the RSS see the demise of Hindutva (Hinduism under their control) if the caste system ceases to exist. Buddhism originated in India and is one of the largest world religions population wise, but nearly no Buddhists are found in India today. Similar Hindu-chauvinistic groups orchestrated the demise of Buddhism in India long ago. Today Buddhists are found all over Asia and have spread to the rest of the globe but are not found in the country of the faiths origin - India. This is not a coincidence.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

jagjit singh · 05 Jul 2005

waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh pyare jio, the SGPC has more funding than RSS. If it wished it could easily counter this threat. It needs to also set up parchaar projects village by village in all the 12000 villages in punjab. It is not hard for them to have one parcharak per village. however this will only happen when Badal is gone. The quicker he goes, the better for Punjab. waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

article · 05 Jul 2005

RSS enlisting activists in rural Punjab By Sarabjit Pandher AMRITSAR, JUNE 14. The Rashtriya Swayamsewak Sangh (RSS) and its affiliate, Rashtriya Sikh Sangat, are trying to spread their activities in rural areas of the once terrorism-infested border districts of Punjab. After organising public meetings in gurdwaras and schools, the organisations have now begun a door-to-door and personal-level contact programme to enlist activists to spread their ``agenda''. The RSS and its allies have during the past year been trying to impress on villagers in Gurdaspur and Amritsar districts that Sikhs are only a sword arm of the Hindu faith. Attempts were being made to ``educate'' the villagers to guard against attempts by those seeking to institutionalise the separate identity of the Sikhs, who have been dubbed ``Pakistan- sponsored terrorists''. According to the latest edition of the Statistical Abstract of Punjab, its population comprises 62.9 per cent Sikhs, 34.5 per cent Hindus, 1.2 per cent Muslims and 1.1 per cent Christians. Among the Christian population, calculated at around 2.25 lakhs, more than 1.78 lakhs live in the rural areas. A majority of the Christians live in Gurdaspur district, where they form nearly seven per cent of the population. In Amritsar, the community constitutes 1.70 per cent of the population. According to observers, the RSS and its affiliates began contacting people in these areas before the celebrations of the 300th anniversary of the Khalsa in April last. It is being pointed out that the RSS initiated an exercise in late 1996 and early 1997, when the Shiromani Akali Dal (SAD) and the BJP came to power after jointly contesting the elections for the Vidhan Sabha. During the electioneering, the RSS cadre got an opportunity to identify influential persons in rural areas. Under the banner of the Rashtriya Sikh Sangat, the RSS approached these persons on the eve of Khalsa celebrations. The RSS also organised a march from Patna, birthplace of Guru Gobind Singh, to Anandpur Sahib. Top Akali leaders and the then Jathedar of the Akal Takht, Giani Puran Singh, received the processionists. In January and February last, Sikh Sangat activists began testing the waters by approaching influential Akali leaders in the border districts. They organised public meetings and even distributed literature criticising the preaching of Christianity and Islam. At the meetings, the activists would dwell on ``history'' to draw out how ``Muslims'' had tormented the Sikh Gurus and their followers. The martyrdom of Guru Arjan Dev and Guru Tegh Bahadur would be highlighted. A tour of Amritsar and Gurdaspur districts made it clear that the Sikh Sangat had conducted meetings in villages, which were close to the border. The organisation set up headquarters in Fatehgarh Churian town. At Verka town, on the outskirts of Amritsar, it was found that the RSS and its allies had conducted tests in the schools to gauge the knowledge of the children on religion. After the tests in April 1999, a prize distribution function was held. Giani Puran Singh, retired Deputy Commissioner of Amritsar, Mr. Sarabjit Singh, and the former CBI Director, Mr. Joginder Singh, were the guests of honour. The SGPC, whose then secretary was also present, had agreed to provide Rs. 1 lakh for getting RSS literature printed. It is believed that the Sikh Sangat planned to filter ``potential'' students at the school level for further contacting them and their families. They also began compiling data on educated unemployed youth as well as those who had joined the Army, central security forces and the State police. Experts in Punjab affairs are of the opinion that the RSS programme was aimed at co-opting wayward sections of the Sikh youth, which in the late 1970s and 1980s had provided recruits to various pro-Khalistan militant organisations.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

Nav · 05 Jul 2005

The above article said "The SGPC, whose then secretary was also present, had agreed to provide Rs. 1 lakh for getting RSS literature printed" I think it should be clear to everyone that the SGPC is undermining Sikhi and has been for years.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

daaas · 05 Jul 2005

gyani arshi ji , its my nimrata sahit benti that please dont' look the fake and true saints with the same eye . all the dera wale saints are not corrupted . a little bunch of nakli people have brought bad name to whole sant community . i guess you are a mature person and you do path of sukhmani sahib , and you know the mahima of sants , brahmgyanis , and the fruit if you do their ninda . its just my benti , no hard feelings . waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

LondonSingh · 05 Jul 2005

The need is for a two pronged strategy. For the Sikhs in the UK we need to first start to clear that gandh of Nidder and his gang. Its not surprising that their propagand tallies with the RSS because no matter how much they deny it they are part of the RSS effort to undermine Sikhi. Apart from dealing with Nidder the UK Sikhs need to then laise with Sikh organisations such as Akali Dal Amritsar, Dal Khalsa, Khalra Mission Committee, Khalsa Panchayat who unlike the SGPC and Badal Akalis have the will to counter the RSS propaganda. The only thing they lack is the resources.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

......................... · 05 Jul 2005

no single group is strong enough to combat this ideology alone. I have seen how sikhs are first hand in india. In delhi monei who used to be sikhs walk around with tilaks pretending to be hindus poojing devis. young monei in amritsar you cant even tell the difference bwteen them and bhaiyas when they cut their kes off. Ths serious growth of radaswami cult in the duab region amongst sikhs is very disturbing, middel step towards rss. We can no longer afford to say only the strongest sikhs will be left or we want quality over quantity. what strentgh lies in allowing more people to slip away from sikhi? i for certain would lik to see our confused brothers and sisters having some attachement to theuir identity than allow them become hindus. Sikh youths drive around with indian flags, and national emblems on their cars and bikes like "india is best". Most sikhs are already on their way out in india from being real sikhs with a minority left who understand sikhi. We need a list of all panthic organisations excluding sgpc who can work together and have a bullet point agenda in bringing sikhi back with parchar. let us face the sgpc has been infiltrated for a long time, it is highly unlikely it would serve the panth now given its glorious past there are too many corrupt leaders the corruption culture has set in. In fact sgpc has turned into half the problem itself by draining the much needed resources of the panth which devoted sikhs put down in the form of daswand to gurughars. Something parralel to the sgpc is now needed to challange it so the resources are being utilised in the upkeep of sikhism and its panth. One sikh group alone does not have the resources, manpower, skills to tackle the problem due to the sheer changes sikh mass themselves are undergoing. Khalsa panchayt, dal khalsa, ddt, akj, any other panthic groups need a combine amongst themselves with a uniform strategy. Pit their resources together on the same platform and sikhs from the west need to utilise their skills to hit the message into punjab. some members of These groups need to stop infighting and agree a base platform. Parchar itself will not end the misery sikhs face economically, socially, and gender inequality. We need to identity all weak areas and eradicate problems which the sarkar was meant to do we will have to take onto our shoulders which can only happen if we all pull together. [%sig%]

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

jagjit singh · 06 Jul 2005

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, the above article shows how technical the RSS is in its approach, and it is working towards its goal of ensuring no khalisatn ever exists, or its is ever mentioned. It is cleverly using sikh institutions and resources against it. Youth abroad have this fantasy that khalistan will be built one day, that some great leader will bring it us. The cold hard reality is that khalistan is further away than it was in 1984, and until we do not start using our resources from abroad in Punjab doing Gurmat parchaar in punjab. Until then we have no hope of khalistan. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

drd · 06 Jul 2005

Guru Piyario wjkk wjkf If anyone is interested in forming a strategic group of like minded Panth dardi, to counteract and arrest this anti sikh propaganda and try to eliminate this adultrization of Sikhi, please get in touch with me. I cant promise anything, but together we can make a difference. We need intellectuals, social anthrapologists, PR specialists, those who can help with funding, those who have ties with the rich and famous/infuential people as well as those who are just commited to the cause and are willing to help in any way. Nodoubt, some will forward themselves just to infilterate such a group, and to try and undermine its activities.But we'll be waiting, I promise! Lets put aside our personal likes and dislikes of Sikh personalities. In this battle we all need to fight and stand together as one. This trully is a battle of epic proportions. Truth is being adultrated. The very foundations of the creed of Guru Nanak are being hacked at. For how much longer will we just sit and talk about it? Its already too little and too late. I shall wait eagerly to see who comes forward. das drd

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

Nav · 06 Jul 2005

Its high time Sikhs in the West get organized. With over 1.5 million Sikhs in Western countries, there is plenty of money, brains, organizational skills, and other resources that could be put to use to combat the RSS threat. In order to do this we need to get rid of the usual nasty petty politicking that goes on in Sikh orgs and join hands with orgs like Dal Khalsa and not the mainstream SGPC or Akali Dal (Badal) and as the two later orgs are aligned with the RSS types. Will the Sikhs step up to the plate and do something before its too late?

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

jas · 06 Jul 2005

yes its true those pictures are horrible, but why are all of you so scared and afraid? do you think these attacks are anything new? lots of communities have been persecuted, but what makes us different is that the other communities have had times of peace we are the only ones that have been persecuted every single day of our existence, first it was on the battlefield, and we crushed our enemies, then they took a different approach and tried to destroy our Sikhi by corrupting it, and they succeded to a certain extent, but Sikhi goes in cycles, when it is down, we come together and become stronger, then it goes up and we become egotistical and Waheguru brings us down again, those that are worried by the rss and these other ants have no faith in Waheguru because if we were not meant not mean to be here, we would have been destroyed centuries ago the problem is that many Sikhs today are uneducated in Sikhi, instead of refering to Gurbani, they refer to fake sants as a result, many Sikhs have succumb to Bipran Ki Reet Maharaj says "Jab Lag Khalsa Rahe Niara, Tab Lag Tej Dioon Mein Sara Jab Eh Gaye Bipran Ki Reet, Mein Na Karoon In Ki Parteet" Basically, as long as the Khalsa follow only Maharaj, Guru Gobind Singh Ji will always be with the Khalsa. But if the Khalsa starts following Bipran Ki Reet then Guru Ji will not help the Khalsa because a Sikh is not allowed to follow Bipars (Brahmans). so when we stop with this Bipran ki Reet, we will be fine, these ants are confidant now at insulting our faith, but thats because Sikhi is down right now and they havnt met a true Gursikh but when Sikhi comes back it will be a different story

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

SINGH · 06 Jul 2005

KHALISTAN ZINDABDAD RISE UP BRUVAZ ATTAIN UR FREEDOM THROUGH THE SWORD ALL MEANS HAVE NOW FAILED GURU FATEH

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

Min Singh · 06 Jul 2005

Is it just a coincidence that the UK Sanatanists believe in very similar philosophies as their Sanatan counterparts in India i.e. RSS, VHP? Take a look at the pictures by the Indian Sanatanists and the one created by the UK Sanatanists on Udasi.org posted above by Balpreet Singh. They are so similar in trying to paint Sikhi as part of Hindu Dharm. They both like to promote Baba Banda Singh Bahadur as a non-amritdhari. Some Sanatanists even go the extent of nitpicking on miner details of Baba Banda Singh Jee’s jeevan and criticize him. What a disgrace!

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

... · 06 Jul 2005

I think it's important to bring this discussion to the UK Sanatanists. On one of their websites, they quote: "Their reality depicts a diminishing truth, while the rest of the modernist world has been unknowingly duped into the duality of these two artificial and until recently, non-existent religious categories viz. ‘Hindu-ism’ and ‘Sikh-ism’ created by British Colonialists. This is not how it used to be. After all the suffix ism which is the crux of our problem of understanding the truth as it stood before the time of the Raj, conceptually and linguistically belongs to the Western world, and is alien to the traditional Indian mind. To understand the reality of religiosity before the intellectual impact of the British Raj in Panjab, and thus the world of the Udasis and other puratan (ancient) traditions, one must understand it from its own perspective, not from the foreign concepts and categories of western thought." This is a total lie that the distinct path of Gurmat was created by British Colonialists. I believe that the Nidder clan have quite a few young people who now revere Shiva and Durga. I don't think it's shere coincidence that the UK Nangs and the RSS share a philosophy. I think it's clear that there is a link. Who is behind this? What is the goal? These questions need to be answered.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

email · 06 Jul 2005

This is with reference to your article in your website about RSS. I just wanted to aski a simple question? what's wrong if RSS is propagating Teachings of rev. Gurus all over India. Why today Sikhs have limited themselves only upto Punjab and Punjabi language. I belongs to Utter Pradesh, do not speak Punjabi and in my Village Guru Nanak dev ji maharaj visted once upon a time and in every house you'll find his staute even today though they are not declared sikhs? For me Guru Govind Sing is my hero since my childhood and same case is with many youths who are not declared sikhs. Don'nt you feel that narrow issue of Sikh identity is denegrating these greatest leaders of Humanity. If I propgate there teachings and call them as Guru of the whole humanity then what's wrong in It. Guru Teg Bahadur was having followers upto Assam. Gur Govinsing was having followers even in Tamil Naadu (South India). as such the whole India is the land of Gurus and why these guys want to narrow down there area of influence only upto Punjab. Please elighten me if there is any specific reason in all this narrow propagabda? Either we have forgotton the ultimate aim of `Raj Karega Khalasa' or `Sare jagat me khalasa Panth raje jage Dhrama Hindu sakal Dhundh Bhaaje" or we intentionally are playing the game of somebody else. In my opinion RSS is doind a great service to the panth by making it acceptable all over India and in place of joining hands with them I wonder how a Sikh youth can even think of killing their people. Let'l kill the supporters of those who killed the innocent children of Gurus or supporters of those who shown brutallity toward the noblest soul ever took birth on India soil after mythological Dadhichi. Ohhh I am becoming emotional and can not write further? Please forgive me. Besrt regards Man Singh

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

LondonSingh · 06 Jul 2005

Man Singh You are right, we Sikhs have singularly failed to propogate the message of the Gurus outside Punjab. This is in marked constrast to the Sikh parchar that took place during the days of the Gurus. There is a very big difference between propogating the teachings of the Gurus to the rest of India and what the RSS are doing. To the RSS Guru Gobind Singh is just a Indian patriot defending 'Hindu Dharma' against the Muslims. They have never propogated the spiritual message of Guru Gobind Singh. Where ever the Guru is mentioned in their literature it is almost always with reference to the other 'Hindu heroes' Prithviraj Chauhan and Shivaji. If the choice is between teh rest of India not knowing about Guru Gobind Singh or knowing about the Guru but have the wrong impression of his message then I think we should choose the former.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

one_more_singh · 06 Jul 2005

Man Singh Ji, I would ask you to do some research on the RSS and how they came to be. Note their philosophy and attitudes towards minority communities in India. I would also ask you to read, contemplate and understand Gurbani. Familiarize yourself with the philosophy contained within the saroop of our Guru Granth Sahib ji. >>>what's wrong if RSS is propagating Teachings of rev. Gurus all over India<<< It would be wonderful for any group to teach the philosophy of the Gurus all over India. Is the RSS doing this by showing Gurus as worshippers of gods/goddesses? This is totally false as per the philosophy of Gurbani. >>>Guru Nanak dev ji maharaj visted once upon a time and in every house you'll find his staute even today though they are not declared sikhs<<< By you mentioning this, I would assume that you and many others in your village would have great respect for Guru Nanak Dev Ji. Guru Nanak Dev ji taught us not to worship any idols. What's the use of keeping his statue if you haven't listened and followed his message? You and your fellow villagers are in fact disrepecting Guru sahib by keeping his statue. If you would like to follow the path of Guru Nanak, worship through Gurbani, worship Waheguru. >>> For me Guru Govind Sing is my hero since my childhood and same case is with many youths who are not declared sikhs.<<< Don'nt you feel that narrow issue of Sikh identity is denegrating these greatest leaders of Humanity<<< Its admirable that you consider Guru Gobind Singh your hero. The Sikh identity was given to us as a gift by Guru Gobind Singh ji. I wouldn't call it a narrow issue. By not protecting these gifts (this identity), don't you feel you are denigrating your hero? >>>In my opinion RSS is doind a great service to the panth by making it acceptable all over India<<< This assertion astounds me. Which panth is getting served here? Only the Brahmin panth. If the Sikh way isn't acceptable to someone, should we tailor it according to their needs? Do we have this kind of moral authority? Sikhi is Sach. It doesn't need me or you or anyone else to make it acceptable. A) Please, research the RSS. You can 'Google' the names Sarvarkar, Godse, Gowalkar as well as the RSS bible "Bunch of Thoughts". B) Please read and understand Gurbani. C) Do this and tell us who is responsible for the propaganda. [%sig%]

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

one_more_singh · 06 Jul 2005

... oh yeah. Watch this if you already haven't: http://www.khalsa.tv/?view=19/ [%sig%]

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 07 Jul 2005

this was a very eye-opening post for me. i was always knowledgeable about the work rss brahmins are doing but some of the posters in this thread have shocked me. and the even sadder thing is, this is just a sample of those posters. who knows what other evil things kal jug has gotten made from the rss brahmins. guru sahib kirpa karan. khalsa will always be vaaheguroo's and vaaheguroo will always have fatheh.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

singh · 08 Jul 2005

i think badal needs to go

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

T.O.Singh · 12 Jul 2005

In regards to the last picture in the first post: Bajrang Dal Party of Hanuman The militant wing of the VHP, it was formed "to counter `Sikh militancy' " during the Sikh Genocide of 1983-84 [ Bajrang ]. Created with the objective of the eradication of Sikhs which it has termed "Muslims in disguise", its cadres fought alongside Congress-backed Hindutva militias during the mcracksacre of 200,000 Sikhs under Indira Gandhi and Rajiv Gandhi. Recruits carry a " knife-like trident to be slung across the shoulder - an answer to the Sikh kirpan " [ Bajrang ]. It has subsequently expanded its targets to include Muslims and Christians as well. http://carolinanavy.com/fleet2/f2/zreligion/Hinduismhall/cas/83.html

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

A Singh · 13 Jul 2005

Gur Fateh! I glad to see this item discussed, let’s consider the following items, before we start jumping on the anti-brahmin bandwagon (since not all RSS are Brahmins first of all and secondly many reputable Sikhs come from the Brahmin community). Hate is not the answer, but that is all that Sikh websites and ‘leaders’ have managed to achieve in the past 50 years with claims to “kill 50,000 Hindus” and such like –it is no wonder that so many are choosing to reject the Khalsa ideals, as the only impression and exposure they are given is one of hatred and hostility by some of today’s ‘leaders’, rather the ideal Sant-Siphai manners of the Khalsa pristine. First of all, if one looks at the RSS, it is very very easy, as I have said many times before on this forum, to undermine their pathetic ideology using their own arguments. They claim to be upholders of Hindutva and in its puritan traditions –go and visit a “Shaka” of the RSS next time any of you are in India and you’ll see the following things: 1. Western attire (and quite funny at that too –short shorts and tucked in shirts –bunch of jokers!) and ladies wearing similar items (i.e. skirts and blouse) or salwar kameez (which is Muslim bana to be precise). 2. Presentation by leaders and preachers who all tend to be graduates and/or Doctors and very articulate in their manners (compare this to our Gyani institutions and characters –I believe Gyani Arshi on this forum has made mention of this issue many times) 3. Men training in fencing, boxing and karate (oh that’s so Indian I must say!) and using workout exercises such as military push ups and sit ups (what’s wrong with Dands, Baithaks and Yoga?) 4. Much hyped talk about leaders like Shiva Ji and others and of course Guru Gobind Singh, with twisted renditions of Dasam Bani for good measure, but also of Jesus Christ and other western figures. The key point here is there is very little, if anything, within the RSS which would support their claims to revive ‘Sanatan’ Dharma, they are purely a post-colonial outfit with some very questionable political views. To defeat any opponent, one really needs to get to know them and it is thereafter very easy to destroy their petty arguments –rather than doing this, all we can see is people shouting “we are not Hindus” or “don’t wear saris!” and more frequently doing the utmost behzati to Dasam Bani by rejecting large portions of Guru Sahibs writings –to the extent, as covered by someone on the sikhawareness or sikhsangat forum (can’t remember where I saw it), certain Gurdwaras here in Canada have forbidden the recitation of the Benti Chaupai Sahib and now also sought to change the Ardas to “Prithum Akal Simar Ke”. Such is the sad state of our community leaders -paranoid and uneducated. See my other posts concerning Guru Sahib and the Suryavanshi claims, if the RSS are so keen to observe this, then let them but let’s get some parchaar solid – if we are Suryavanshi, we are the true destined rulers of India and as Veer Kulbir Singh has said many times, the true Dharm for Kulyug which Hindus will need to accept. All this talk of “Sikhi khatre mai hai” is weak minded, how can the Akal Purakh Ki Fauj be in khatra!!! As far as Niddar Singh and company are concerned, they’re outlook is no different to that of the Buddha Dal itself (have a listen to the katha by Baba Santa Singh on the Sarabloh Granth) and matches somewhat with the RSS (Sikh Sangh), however I don’t believe them to be linked personally, since the RSS is extremely anti-Muslim and as one can gather from the “Sanatan Sikhs” in the UK and their love for Shias and Sufi ideals as per the Seva Panthi website, I doubt from this one critical point that they are in fact linked in any big way –but there is an issue here as well, which is very similar to the RSS. The Sanatan Sikhi title comes from one diluted quote from the Bhagat Kabeer Jee (see the opening pages of the sarabloh.info website) and from the misunderstood works of Harjot Oberoi (whose example again shows what Sikhs do when provide with a little challenge –issue death threats to this wife and children and write pathetic responses to this works –to date there not been a single valuable critique of his work, the text by Mr Mann is simply useless at addressing the situation, which is why it receives no credibility outside of Sikh circles –this is the KEY POINT, it’s all very well writing material to counter RSS or other thoughts, but it really needs to be proper material that will be respected by the Academic authorities to effectively counter the original material from continued and preferential circulation). Like the RSS, these arguments are built upon sand walls, the continued reference to ‘modern day Sikhs’ being an invention of the British and British influenced texts (in the process insulting Bhai Vir Singh and other celebrated scholars)–have a look into the history surrounding Prachin Panth Parkash –the Nihang Singh “bible”, this is a text full of pro-Jat caste references and itself written under the influence of British Officer Captain Murray! So how is this text ‘ancient’? Besides there are many earlier texts conveniently ignored in their arguments and moreover, just because some 18 / 19th century text speaks of certain practices in vogue amongst the Sikhs, how does this override the teachings of Gurbani? Its rather like taken contemporary accounts of Sikhs today in 200 years and future historians deeming it acceptable for Singhs to have trimmed beards and regarding the singing/shouting of Gurbani to pankandhi tunes as authentic Sikh practice of Kirtan. I have made much mention before regarding Banda Singh Bahadur and his betrayal and the subsequent propaganda against him by the “Tat” Khalsa who even take away his Sikh identity! Also “bana” that is propagated as being that ordained by Guru Sahib is nothing of the sort, just like the reverence for Durga in the Khanda, Sarabloh Chandi Puja etc –have a look into the history and attire of Shiva Ji Maratha and his warriors and it is easy to see where these ideas arise from. Rather than shouting and fearing these elements, one needs to really understand fully the view point and mindset behind these thoughts and counter “where necessary” using educated tools and not prehistoric violence and shouting –have a look at the Nirankaris, we Sikhs have ostracised them, even killed their “gurus” yet they are now bigger than ever their own line of Martyrs. The worst thing is that the offending article amongst these heretics was their texts, which despite these killings, vocal protests and other actions, Sikhs to date have not managed to have those removed –that too after the Nirankaris offered to remove them if the Singhs could show why, instead we have preferred to exercise our Brawn more than our Brains. As master Yoda says, “fear leads to anger, anger to hate and hate is the path to the dark side”.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

A Singh · 13 Jul 2005

T O Singhm, These Bajrang Dal idiots also began to distribute a "Hindu" Amrit during the 1980s using the Trisul (Trident) instead of the Khanda.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

jagjit Singh · 13 Jul 2005

waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru jike fateh Pyare jio, always up for a bit of seva. Sorry veer Ji i have not got your email. Mine is [address removed] waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru jike fateh drd wrote: > Guru Piyario > > wjkk > wjkf > > If anyone is interested in forming a strategic group of like > minded Panth dardi, to counteract and arrest this anti sikh > propaganda and try to eliminate this adultrization of Sikhi, > please get in touch with me. > > I cant promise anything, but together we can make a difference. > > We need intellectuals, social anthrapologists, PR specialists, > those who can help with funding, those who have ties with the > rich and famous/infuential people as well as those who are just > commited to the cause and are willing to help in any way. > > Nodoubt, some will forward themselves just to infilterate such > a group, and to try and undermine its activities.But we'll be > waiting, I promise! > > > Lets put aside our personal likes and dislikes of Sikh > personalities. In this battle we all need to fight and stand > together as one. This trully is a battle of epic proportions. > Truth is being adultrated. The very foundations of the creed of > Guru Nanak are being hacked at. For how much longer will we > just sit and talk about it? Its already too little and too > late. > > I shall wait eagerly to see who comes forward. > > das > > drd

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

Humlae · 18 Jul 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ka Fateh Does anyone have the picture of Parkash Badal where he is sitting down with the BJP leader Atal Vajpayee and picture shows Badal throwing ***admin cut*** into fire. I think its called Havan a hindu ritual and naamdharis do it. Please provide picture. Look forward to it. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ka Fateh [%sig%]

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

A Singh · 18 Jul 2005

Humlae, what is exactly is an "Admin-Cut" -why do we have to be so offensive? IS the Khalsa not supposed to be 'ucha'??? Besides, the Havan is a vedic tradition and so not stictly Hindu as it is also done by Buddhists and Jains (and of course the Namdharis and Nihangs).

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

Singhnature · 21 Jul 2005

Does anyone have the image, if so, pass it on.... Humlae's looking forward to it and so am I.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

**- · 23 Jul 2005

Humlae & Singhnature I wouldn't take Badal's actions too seriously. Just this morning I switched on the Star News, where the main headline is that Dawood Ibrahim's daughter is to marry the son of former Pakistan cricketer Javid Miandad. In the pictures they have been showing, you can't help but notice the big fat red tilak slapped on Dawood Ibrahim's forehead. Also they are showing footage of Javid Miandad's meeting with Bal Thakery in his visit to Mumbai. In case you don't know who Bal Thakery is, he is the leader of the Shiv Sena. Regards Sitara [%sig%]

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

manjh payara guru ko · 23 Jul 2005

khalsa ji gurbani da furman hai j jive pat lathi jae ' sab haram jeta kish kae khalsa ji jkar guru sehban hindu de janeoo lee kurbani de sakde han ta guru de sikh sikhi laee kurbani v denge. bole so nihal sat siri akallllllllllllll guru sidhi karu teri mat nu siri sahib tere nak nu tutha tere hath nu mangda piren tu jagat nu hindu ki lehna khalse nal larke din kat andar varke babar khalsa aoo char ke landi buchi nu lejaoo farke

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

Dr. sukhpreet Singh Udhoke · 25 Jul 2005

Respected balpreet Singh veer jeeo, wahe guru ji ka khalsa Wahe guru ji ki fateh with the grace of guru i m in high spirits and hope same for u .veer i m very happy that u published a very important portion of my book and translated in english on ur site.thanks again Dr.Sukhpreet Singh udhoke

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

khalsa_force · 28 Jul 2005

############################################ Author: Dr. sukhpreet Singh Udhoke Date: 07-25-05 07:07 Respected balpreet Singh veer jeeo, wahe guru ji ka khalsa Wahe guru ji ki fateh with the grace of guru i m in high spirits and hope same for u .veer i m very happy that u published a very important portion of my book and translated in english on ur site.thanks again Dr.Sukhpreet Singh udhoke ############################################ WOW !!!!!!! Sukhpreet SIngh Veerji replied himself.please share more info with sangat and create awareness among us.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

jolbras · 28 Jul 2005

get in touch with reuben singh for finances. i think american sikhs can play a part in promoting sikhi in punjab. punjab is very backard i think most will be more concerned about filling their tummy first. get the thinktank rolling first.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

brahmin · 06 Aug 2005

I am a 'normal' Hindu Brahmin, and stand by you in your attempt to maintain Sikhi. Yes, that's right, I stand by you . For you should note that extremist Hindus like RSS represent a small minority, like 0.0002% of Hindus. Also note that change will occur over time. Like, the caste system is a corruption of the original caste system which had nothing to do with one's social STATUS, rather it was used to divide labour. Now the old ideas of caste system are fading, and in fact caste is illegal in India and shunned by majority of modern Hindus. Brahmins like me do not believe in the caste system. Mainstream Hindus see Sikhs and Buddhists as a distinct (although related) religions, we are all brothers. We are related by the common beliefs of reincarnation, oneness of God, Karma, Nirvana/Nibana/Moksha and tolerance of other beliefs. So, whatever you do, don't become angry at Hindus... rather, be angry at Hindu extremists. And don't do anything violently, that would be really bad. Change occurs over time, and as an old and backward generation dies, a fresh, new one arises. So the whole RSS thing is temporary. Also, recognize that you should have nothing against Hinduism... recognize that we have a common history and homeland and distinct religions, and we must unite against the real threat of christianity. [%sig%]

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

M Singh · 06 Aug 2005

I agree with veer brahman jee. Most Hindus do not follow the RSS. RSS and such extremist organizations are on the fringes of Hindu society and do not represent majority of Hindus or even Hinduism for that matter. Also, veer Brahman Jee mentioned Christian evangelists being a threat. That is true for the Sikhs to an extent because in the last couple of decades many Mazbi Sikhs have been converted to Christianity by Christians of South India who come to Punjab to convert Sikhs. In some cases, the entire Mazbi Sikh population in a village has embraced Christianity. But I think that currently the Sikhs face even bigger dangers from fake Gurus (Radhaswami, Noormahalia etc) and Saadh dera culture which is to a large extent is reverting Sikhs back to un-sikh rituals while they are getting wealthier day after day.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

singh · 06 Aug 2005

Brahmin, i was okay with everything you said except to unite against the real threat of chrisitianity. How is christianity a threat? If people want to convert, let them. The caste system, regardless of how it came about, has left all minority segments in India starving for civil rights. Religions free of caste empower them. If you want them to remain hindu, first abolish caste and slavery and allow everyone to be on the same level socially, religiously and politically. There are christian missionaries who are over-zealous and manipulative in their approach just like there are in all religions. Brahminism is the cancer which allows them to thrive.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

charanjeev singh · 06 Aug 2005

"Brahmins like me do not believe in the caste system." hhhhmmmm

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

khalsa · 10 Aug 2005

it is not right to blame the RSS or any other such organisation....it is the sikhs themselves that are at fault. we are following 'bipran ki reet' that is why we may as well be hindus and sikhi an extension to hinduism. sikhs celebrate diwali which in reality has no connection with our relegion...just a folk story without historical foundation, lohri - absolutely nothing to do with sikhism and yet villages still have a huge bonfire on this night, rakhri - which fair enough, people say is to celebrate the bond between brother and sister - but do you not show it on any other day? people still go to see 'ram leela/krishan leela' and dasehra in punjab and holi to name a few. there are sikh bibi's who still fast on 'karavachauth' etc. when fasting is not allowed in sikhi on religious grounds- only for your health. uneducated granthis and jathaas interpret the mention of Ram in gurbani as in direct relation to being Ram of Sita. sikhs still worship durga as 'chandhi' and continue idol worship with the hanging of pictures of gurus in their homes and gurdwaras even though this was forbidden by guru nanak dev ji. sikh have historically been reported to not like the muslim way of life but murti pooja is forbidden in islam and no body in the whole world has ever dared to make a picture/painting of hazrat mohammed and sikhs justify their paintings as aides to teach their children who the gurus were. funnily enough muslims manage to do this - why can't we? and statues of guru nanak dev ji and dasam pita have started to appear in sikh homes and especially in sikh taxi's in india. sikhs are trying to fight RSS and their propoganda with sword not with pen. and it has long been said that the pen is mighteir than the sword - this is especially true in today's world. however sikhs are still thinking that fists are the answer. how many sikh children know about the char sahibzyadey and their life history -apart from their deaths? strange how every sikh child knows the story or Ram and Sita. how many grown sikhs know that sikhi never had 'pheras' in our wedding ceremonies? it only started about 50 years ago - before that it was only lavan being read from the holy scriptures and the 'jai mala' has also become a popular addition to weddings in the punjab. it is said that charity begins at home...so does reform. we must first educated ourselves and our granthis to the facts. those who try to expose 'bipran ki reet' like Kala afgana are turned against, have threats made against them and their work banned BY SIKHS THEMSELVES. we must change ourselves and follow the true path shown by gurbani before we can acuse others of infiltrating our religion with hindu myths and practices. right now we are not the sikhs of guru granth sahib we are sikhs of this baba or jatha and against followers of other babas and jathas. where it is most important to show who is better and a greater believer. finally did guru gobind singh not specifically say that from this day forward there will be no caste - but when looking for prospective sons/duaghters in law do we not specifically ask for a ramgarhia or jatt sikh? guru ji said 'jo eh gahe bipran ki reet mein na karon in ki parteet' and this is what is happening. we have turned our backs towards our father. what do we expect for showing such disrespect?

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

Singh · 10 Aug 2005

"We are related by the common beliefs of reincarnation, oneness of God," I don’t know which Hinduism is being discussed here but its obvious that mainstream Hinduism does not believe in One God, as does Sikhi.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

A Singh · 10 Aug 2005

Dear “khalsa” Yes, we have a lot to look inside ourselves about, but you appear to be suffering from mega-retraction, what is wrong with “Divali” – which is tied in with Guru Hargobind Sahib? I see paranoid Sikhs have first tried to rename this to “bandi-chor-nivas” and now like you are keen to eradicate the practice altogether!!! In any event celebrating Divali is NOT bipran ki reet, BHAI MANI SINGH SHAHEED is accredited with calling the Sikhs for Gurmatta on Divali day! As per Lohri – no one is claiming this to be a Religious Festival, it is purely cultural and PURELY PUNJABI as implied by the name, it’s hardly Bipran Ki Reet to enjoy conversation with your pendoos (fellow villagers) and/or family whilst roasting nuts over a bonfire – or is that something confined to Dhoti-wearing Brahmins??? Having pictures of the Guru Sahibs is hardly equated to Idolatry!!! Come on!!! And Chandi is not worshipped by Sikhs, the Chandi di Var or Var Sri Durga Ki is a ballad which clearly speaks of the power of Akal in the first two pauris. What Mohammedans do is their business, we are not a semetic people and have no issue in adhering to principles (i.e. do reduce Akal Purakh to a mere form) without having to adhere to rigid rules like Muslims, as per “” sikhs still thinking that fists are the answer” you’ll probably find they prefer on this account to ape their mohammedan counterparts and rely on bombs and plane hijacking – given the glorification of such activities by certain people on this forum alone. Your point on Lava Phera is incorrect too – if you really wish to take this back, you’ll probably find that the Lavan were not originally meant for the wedding ceremony and there are numerous accounts and rehitnamas describing further variations in the Sikh wedding ceremony, the point for today is set, the Akal Thakt ruling is clear and there is no issue of Bipran ki Reet with the current Sikh Anand Karaj. In short, whilst I agree with you that reform must begin at home, your pro-Kala Afghana views will only make you head down the same path as those who you are speaking out against – and that is certainly not Gurmat. Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

Singh · 11 Aug 2005

Bhamin wrote "we must unite against the real threat of christianity" And what happens when Hindu’s begin becoming Sikhs again. This rubbish of lets stick together against a common enemy (Muslims, Christians etc) has been spat out by Hindu’s for centuries. Sikhs should learn from our history and never trust such futile words, as they have a tendency of stabbing us in the back! Today they say Christians are the enemy, tomorrow if Hindu’s become Sikhs as in the past they shall target us. No religion can ever be a threat to Sikhi, Gurmat is in a league of it's own. Our only threat is not following the Guru and getting more and more caught up into Bhaminism type practises, due to our own ignorance, wrong preaching and blatant Hindu influence (although they may deny this.) The first step is to sort out ourselves which since the Singh Sabha movment is long over due. Obvously the RSS types and Indian goverment at large would not like this and would try and get involved, as a strong Khalsa Panth is not in thier interests.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

**- · 11 Aug 2005

Veer A Singh Ji Correction, Lohiri is a pre-Sikhi Hindu festival I am 150% sure but I cannot remember the story behind it at the moment. It is also celibrated by Hindus in Tamil Nadu but it is called Pongol. Lohiri is an ancient festival of India where unlike the West in which most fesitvals are based in gratifying the senses, almost all festivals in India are attached to the Hindu religion. Look at Lahore Pakistan, they still celibrate Basant Panchami with the traditional kite flying - which again can be traced to Hinduism. Even the Jumiat-e-Islami has said that it is a Hindu festival and wanted to stop it immediately. Lohiri has only recently been termed a ‘cultural festival’ in order to please Sikhs who want to maintain distance from Hinduism but at the same time a still very fond of aspects of ancient pre-Sikh Hindu culture. A classic example of this is Bhangra and Giddha dancing. Best wishes Sitara [%sig%]

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

A Singh · 11 Aug 2005

Dear Sitara, Lohri and Vaisakhi etc have NOT been termed "cultural" festivals by SIKHS or to please SIKHS. They may well have roots and relevance for others, but just like the Vaisakhi of Guru Gobind Singh is distinctly a Sikh feature and the Vaisakhi Mela (i.e. Folk pratice) is a cultural one, Lohri is nothing to do with SIKHI (full stop), it is simply a part of Punjabi Folk Culture. Please bring forth the story that you feel is attached to Lohri from a Hindu perspective - no doubt, like other festivals, there will be more than one, clearly pointing to the fact that ALL festival dates have been in vogue as cultural practices for time long forgotten and different traditions have utilised the dates for their purposes, as people would be gathered in large numbers on those occasions - for Sikhs, specifically this has been the case with Vaisakhi, Pooranmashi, Divali etc - as people would traditionally congregate on those dates, they provided suitable points for the raising of particular religious events, which we are now familiar with, the same is visible elsewhere such as Christmas for Christians etc etc - in all cases, where they have religious import, the traditional folk or pagan elements are discarded or adapted as appropriate [In the Sikh way, mostly discarded and new association made with the festival, as is the case with Vaisakhi]. Lohri on the other hand, as practiced in Punjab is simply a social event in the cold season when a fire is lit and nuts roasted - I have not come across any religious connotations when witnessing Sikhs participating in this, unless they, as described above, use the day as a means to congregate in the Gurdwara - as is the case with Pooranmashi, in the West Labor Days(here in Canada) Bank Holidays (in the UK), Christmas, CE new year day etc etc can and often are used as days on which to congregate in large sangat, not however to celebrate Christmas in the Gurdwara or the holiday! Nonetheless, please bring forth your account of Lohri from a Hindu perspective, as even Hindu Punjabis who I know either do the bonfire and nuts for social gathering or attend the Gurdwara divan - so they haven't mentioned any 'religious' aspect to Lohri, so I'd be keen to know more about it. Gur Fateh! A Singh.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

Singh · 11 Aug 2005

I personally do not waste time on Lohri. However its amazingly ignorant to say as implied by Sitara that all pre-Sikh customs should be regarded as Hindu customs. Things like Bhangrs/Gidda have nothing to do with the Hindu faith but are the customs of the people of Panjab. Such things do not have a copy right that they belong to Hinduism (most Hindu’s don’t know the first thing about Bhangra etc) but belong to the people of the land i.e. Punajabi’s. All things in South Asia are not the properly of Hinduism, nor can they be regarded as Hindu culture. Just because most Punjabi’s are now Sikhs or Muslims who gave up Hinduism centuries ago it does not mean they have to give up their traditional and cultural heritage, as such things belong to the cultural people of the land.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

**- · 11 Aug 2005

A Singh, I will try and get back to you however you should note that Khushwant Singh defines Lohiri as a Hindu festival. I have witnessed Sikhs and Hindus celebrate Lohiri in India. They did a clockwise parikrama around the fire (Hindu custom) and offered sesame to the fire and folding their palms in front of the fire. Now I don’t know about you, but this sounds like ‘bipran kee reet’. This is not directed at you but I have noticed how Sikhs conveniently blame all the negative aspects of Punjabi/Indian culture on Hinduism (e.g. cast, female infanticide, dowry etc) but nevertheless like to disassociate other elements which they like from Hinduism. I see the pattern now. If it is good = Nothing to do with Hindus If it is bad = Hindusim. Sitara [%sig%]

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

A Singh · 11 Aug 2005

Dear Sitara (apologies, but I’m uncertain if you are a Veer or a Bhain, please clarify), I note your sentiments at the end of your post. Khuswant Singh says a lot of things, lately he’s even been pro-RSS in his interviews with our local man J Tiwana – so let’s leave his comments aside for now. As per your witnessing the parkarma during Lohri – I will not dispute this as being some form of practice, however I reiterate, in my ‘personal’ experience, I have only seen Lohri performed as a bonfire with people (Sikhs and Hindus alike) sharing the warmth and roasting nuts – the only other common theme I have witnessed has been the increasing presence of old timer males who share their stories of by gone youth and how us youngsters should get married or select our wives – but that’s hardly surprising for any Punjabi occasion! I look forward to learning more about your accounts of Lohri and what exactly makes it Hindu. As you have indicated in your post, that this is not aimed at me, I shall not take it personally, however to argue that everything pre-Sikhi is a “Hindu” custom is a fallacy and sadly one that certain Sikhs who are anti-Bhangra, anti-Raag, anti-culture of any sort (be it classical music, classical art or textiles, classical or folk dance etc etc ) fall prey to time and again, which is why the majority of those in India are not surprised when actors like Sunny Deol makes comments like “ONLY JATT” because that is the impression, takes to a number of insecure Sikhs, we have created – “the only culture is AGRIculture!”. Nonetheless, as “Singh” Veer has pointed out, these things are not “Hindu” simply because they existed pre-Sikhi, next you’ll argue that Aloo Paranthas and Ghee are Hindu! They are certainly Indian and we are of the same cultural and racial (mix) stock. The good – bad scenario you depict is not accurate, if those who I have described above like to pigeon hole things in this manner, that is their view, but as even, more staunch Sikh members of this forum have indicated, in this instance Bhai Kulbir Singh, we have full respect for Hindu scriptures and thought, although our allegiance lies with the Sri Guru Granth Sahib which is here for the period of Kulyug. Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

**- · 11 Aug 2005

Veer A Singh I think I agree with you now actually. I used the arguement that it is Hindu simply because these practices were in place before Sikhism and that the only people who celibrated these festivals were Hindus. When Punjabi Hindus converted to Islam, they rejected these festivals (read the works of the Indian Muslim historian Professor Muhammad Habib). I hope you can see where I am comming from. If I have time I will try and get back to you on the Hindu link with Lohiri but I am sure that you will come up with arguements to debase my claims. Sitara PS I am a Veer.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

A Singh · 11 Aug 2005

Thanks for getting back to me Veera. If Muslims rejected these practices, that is hardly surprising given their negative stance on music, dance, (living) art etc, yet when they do contribute to such themes, for instance Hindustani Classical Sangeet, whilst the Muslim artists themselves will only speak of Sangeet, Muslim Historians are quick to claim that this art form was ‘refined’ or ‘developed’ by the Moghuls!

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

**- · 11 Aug 2005

A Singh Muslim classical artists are the most 'Hindufied' people I have ever met. Some seem to be more Hindu than the Hindus themselves. The only thing Muslim about them is their name.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

no one · 11 Aug 2005

ref. lohri do not beat around the bushes to justify lorhi or other hindu festivals sikhs need complete and clean divorce from hindu customs and festivals and not from hindu/sikh friendship. sikhs have to love whole humanity. [%sig%]

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

A Singh · 12 Aug 2005

Dear “No-One” No one is trying to justify any festivals, let alone Hindu festivals – perhaps you should consider this statement you’re making more carefully. Such blanket statements are exactly what leads us to the conclusions drawn out by the well known Kala Afghana, unless of course you are one of his ardent supporters. People with such mind set have a inkling to rewrite history and invent new traditions to satisfy their egos when it comes to these matters, for instance, many Sikhs have any issue with Coconuts and 5 Paisa – however itihas shows that Guru Sahib performed this custom when bestowing Gurguddi from one Guru to another including Guru Granth Sahib Jee! Such people see this and have the nerve to say IT IS HINDOO!!! For crying out loud it’s simply a cultural custom, same thing with the Chaur Sahib – it is not a uniquely Sikh thing, its been the custom of Royal Darbars for years – both Hindu and predominantly Muslim, as is the Takht Post which we commonly see the Guru Granth Sahib placed upon, so too is the custom of standing up during Ardas (i.e. petition in front of the True Emperor – Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib) and for the same reason that ALL must cover their heads and remove their shoes when inside the Gurdwara, regardless of their religious affiliation – they, be they Sikhs or visitors etc, are in the Darbar of our Emperor, but “No One” the customs of this Darbar mirror exactly those of any other (Hindu or Muslim) Darbar, so how far are you going to take your thought???!!! AND how many people will agree with you on everything? All this does is the opposite effect of what you desire, we have seen how many splits have occurred in the Panth when the Nanakshahi Calendar was introduced, similarly when the chairs and tables issue arose and the list goes on…let’s understand that cultural items such as fireworks, congregating on harvest festival or other key dates are simply a cultural item, which can be used for a get together with family and friends or more preferably, depending on your stance, meeting at the Gurdwara and using the free time to listen to Kirtan and Katha. This is the same issue with Pooranmashi and Masia - people have a problem if Sikhs congregate on these days in the Gurdwara! Why? Because they consider these to be a Hindoo custom – in fact, they are nothing but agricultural customs, which I would have hoped that all the proud Jatts on this forum would have been able to recognise, shame when it comes to the crunch they are only Jatt in name. Commonly in the villages, such days would be reserved for congregation or for early leave from work – this for the Gursikhs provides an ideal opportunity to congregate in the Gurdwara. The best one I’ve come across is from the openly Kala-Afghana supportive PREET MOHAN SINGH AHLUWALIA, who has the nerve to suggest that reading Barahmaha on the beginning of each month is a HIndoo custom!!! What’s with these people??? Even on this forum, we had not long ago, very die-hard AKJers suggesting that “blessed” food (i.e. parshad) was a mimick of a Hindoo custom! Perhaps Sikhs need to be a little bit more secure in themselves, rather than following the path of Mohammedans for whom every damn little thing is haraam and Islam is always in kathra!!! COME ON!!! Are we Akal Purakh Ki Fauj or some one hit wonder???

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

A Singh · 12 Aug 2005

Dear Sitara Veer, I beg to differ with some of your recent assertions, firstly the pattern you observe: If it is good = Nothing to do with Hindus If it is bad = Hindusim. This is patently incorrect. If some insecure individuals wish to be this shallow, that’s their issue. At the same time, I hope we can agree that “Hinduism” is such a blanket statement for a vast number of traditions (Shaiva, Vaisha etc) that continued use of this ‘modern’ term (for no reference can be found in the Vedas or Upanishads of “hindu”) will naturally need to take the wrap for both the positive and negative elements associated with it. As mentioned above, even staunch and extremely proud Sikhs like our veer Kulbir Singh has indicated the respect that he holds, as do I, for the Hindu scriptures etc, however we ourselves align ourselves solely with our own traditions and way of life, namely Gurmat and Guru Granth Sahib. Secondly, your comment that “Muslim classical artists are the most 'Hindufied' people” is also a huge blanket statement, I know many personally from the late Ustad Valait Khand and Ustad Alla Rakha Khan Sahib (of course his son Ustad Zakir Hussain) and what you’re saying is simply not true. My association with other “hindu” classical musicians like Pandit Sanka Chatterjee, Sankha Gosh and others, all of whom have had Muslim Ustads and pretty damn strict ones at that too (like Karamat Ulla Khan Sahib etc), fondly relay account to me of how in class with multi-religious students, who would be Mulism, Sikh, Hindu and Christian, the Muslim Ustad would always speak of effort and predominantly the Will of God, but always use neutral terms for God, like Bhagwan, Kudha, Rubb, Ishvar etc etc to ensure a cohesive class room structure and ultimately understand that Sangeet has a powerful role in all true religions. Similarly, Pandit Jee once recalled how the late and formidable Amir Khan Sahib, who was regular with his Nimaz, performed a “Hari Om” bhajan when invited as a guest to a family function – which is no different to the Shabds and/or bhajans performed by Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan and others – and one can hardly claim they are “hindu” or “sikh” suddenly because of this!!! Again, please don’t suggest that because Indian Classicial Music or Carnatic Music existed pre-Sikhi that somehow it is “Hindoo” – of course, people like “No One” above would love to hear this as it gives him an excuse to not bother with Raags and stick with his little vaja and dholki for singing Sahbds to the GT Road tune and others…perhaps one day, he like Teja Singh Bhasauria and others who share such a weak and timid mindset, will publish a bir of Guru Granth Sahib without references to Raag to appease their insecure minds. Music, Food, Clothing, Language, Poetry, Life cycles customs etc are NOT tied in their own right to any religion, they are TOOLS, which man has employed for his own wayward mind, which can be used destructively (Obscene Songs, Unhealthy Food / Diet / Gluttony, Inappropriate Clothing, Foul Language etc etc) or positively (Kirtan/Bhajan/Choirs, Langar/Offerings/Charity, Robes of honour, Shabd, Itihas, Knowledge etc etc). Gur Fateh! A Singh.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

**- · 12 Aug 2005

Veer A Singh, You seem very upset with my comments. If I have upset you I sincerely apologise and I will retract what I have said previously; and leave this discussion where it is. Kind Regards, Sitara

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

A Singh · 12 Aug 2005

Relax, Veera, not upset at all! Just discussing!!! What's the point of getting upset??? When discussing, it is important to assess all sides regardless of how uncomfortable they maybe, we are not simply through discussion seeking to change precedent or the world, only explore ideas, views etc and hopefully take from them what benefits us positively – no need to get emotional! I’ve enjoyed the few discussions I’ve had with you, please keep it up, you bring a new angle on certain things which is always interesting to consider. Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

... · 12 Aug 2005

A Singh wrote: "What’s with these people??? Even on this forum, we had not long ago, very die-hard AKJers suggesting that “blessed” food (i.e. parshad) was a mimick of a Hindoo custom!" What are you talking about?? Degh is prepared with more care and attention in Jatha smagams than anywhere else. The importance of degh is very high in the Jatha. Which "die-hard" people are you talking about? Utter nonsense.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

khalsa · 12 Aug 2005

dear A Singh what is wrong with “Divali” – which is tied in with Guru Hargobind Sahib? I see paranoid Sikhs have first tried to rename this to “bandi-chor-nivas” and now like you are keen to eradicate the practice altogether!!! Baba budda ji celebrated guru hargobind ji's arrival at amritsar with fire work he was over joyed he must have mourned guru arjan dev's shaheede accordingly. he must have grieved for many days if not months. baba ji was a bramhgyani and had full understanding of gurbani sikh gurus and bramhgyanis never greive when they lose something or celebrate when gain something.as gurbani describes gurmqI hir mMin vswieAw ] Pleasure and pain, and all emotional attachments are gone. guramathee har mann vasaaeiaa || hrKu sogu sBu mohu gvwieAw ] Pleasure and pain, and all emotional attachments are gone. harakh sog sabh mohu gavaaeiaa || ieksu isau ilv lwgI sd hI hir nwmu mMin vswvixAw ]] Your devotees are attuned to Your Love; they are always joyful. eikas sio liv laagee sadh hee har naam mann vasaavaniaa ||4|| 12 Maajh Guru Amar Das (panna 122) again hrK sog duhhUM qy mukqy ] They are free of both pleasure and pain. harakh sog dhuhehoon thae mukathae || sdw Ailpqu jog Aru jugqy ] Your servant prays to You, O Lord and Master. ||3|| sadhaa alipath jog ar jugathae || dIsih sB mih sB qy rhqy ] They are seen among all, and yet they are distinct from all. dheesehi sabh mehi sabh thae rehathae || pwrbRhm kw Eie iDAwnu Drqy ]3] They focus their meditation on the Supreme Lord God. ||3|| paarabreham kaa oue dhhiaan dhharathae ||3|| (page181) and again pRB kI AwigAw Aatum ihtwvY ] One who, in his soul, loves the Will of God, prabh kee aagiaa aatam hithaavai || jIvn mukiq soaU khwvY ] is said to be Jivan Mukta - liberated while yet alive. jeevan mukath sooo kehaavai || qYsw hrKu qYsw ausu sogu ] As is joy, so is sorrow to him. thaisaa harakh thaisaa ous sog || sdw Anµdu qh nhI ibEgu ] He is in eternal bliss, and is not separated from God. sadhaa anandh theh nehee bioug || qYsw suvrnu qYsI ausu mwtI ] As is gold, so is dust to him. thaisaa suvaran thaisee ous maattee || qYsw AMimRqu qYsI ibKu KwtI ] As is ambrosial nectar, so is bitter poison to him. thaisaa anmrith thaisee bikh khaattee || qYsw mwnu qYsw AiBmwnu ] As is honor, so is dishonor. thaisaa maan thaisaa abhimaan || qYsw rMku qYsw rwjwnu ] As is the beggar, so is the king. thaisaa rank thaisaa raajaan || jo vrqwey sweI jugiq ] Whatever God ordains, that is his way. jo varathaaeae saaee jugath || nwnk Ehu purKu khIAY jIvn mukiq ]7] O Nanak, that being is known as Jivan Mukta. ||7|| naanak ouhu purakh keheeai jeevan mukath ||7|| Gaurhee Sukhmanee Guru Arjan Dev (page 275) there are so many gurshabads to illustrate this point. ordinary people like me and you celebrate somebody's release from the prison but not the bramhgyanies. even guru ji rejected emperor's offer of release by demanding the releas of 52 princes. is there any historical fact or date that guru ji arrived at amritsar on devali day? In any event celebrating Divali is NOT bipran ki reet, BHAI MANI SINGH SHAHEED is accredited with calling the Sikhs for Gurmatta on Divali day! if sikhs decided to celebrate shaheede of bhai mani singh with fire work why don't sikh celerbate shaheede of guru arjan dev ji the first sikh shaheed, guru teg bahadur ji, bhai matti dass ji, bhai taroo singh ji, bhai diyalla ji why not? why did bhai mani singh ji accepted mugal's terms to pay guru's bhetta to mugal sarkar. these false stories are only concocted by bipper (bhamin) do you know that there were hindu idols at 7 different places around the parkarma of harminder sahib before 1920. do you know that all walls of akal tkhat had painting of ram lella and krishan lella before it was demoloishd in 1984. 95% of sikh population know the story of ram and sita but how many sikhs know the story of bandi chhod. 90% of the sikhs keep their front door open on devali night for lakshmi devi to come in. please please do not belive in these bipper stories [%sig%]

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

**- · 13 Aug 2005

Veer A Singh Ji You seem to take a scientific/anthropological view on Indian culture where as I (and many other Hindus) have been brought up differently. All aspects of our (Hindu-Indian) culture are linked with the Veds, puranas and bhakti. Our scriptures contain a plethora of subjects, examples of which include: music, dance, yoga, astonomy, science, mathematics, poetry, art, sex, metaphysics, philosophy, festivals, food, sculpture, architecture, economics and civil governance. The whole aim of these subjects is to create a God-centred civilisation where everyone lives in peace and harmony. You said that you align yourself with the Vedas similarly I align myself with the Vedic scriptures. The topics that have been expounded by our scriptures form the basis of Indian culture that we are witnessing today - good and bad. When Guru Sahib speaks about Hindus, who is he talking about? Are they not including peoples who worship idols, eat aloo parantha, celibrate Lohiri and sing bhajans in rag? A Singh Ji the only people who have managed to preserve Indian culture are mostly Hindus. Many Hindus in the past converted to other religions and proceeded to reject and deride lot of aspects of Indian culture and our way of life. It is the Hindus that are largely responsible for maintaining this culture (both good and bad aspects) up to the time of the Guru Sahibaan and beyond. Give credit where credit is due. You are entitled to your own opinion on the matter and I respect that. Even in 'Hinduism' their are a vast array of opinions on different subjects (e.g. Swaminarayan, ISKCON, Pushti-Marg, Ramanuja vaishnavas, Shaiviates, Shakti/Devi poojaks, Advaitya vaadis, Arya-Samaajis) and we recognise and infact celibrate these differing views, why? Because when their Sadhus and acharayas meet each other they know that our iccha (objective) is the same and that is to glorify and praise God in all of his/her forms etc. I hope you will also be able to share these same sentiments with me. Regards, Sitara [%sig%]

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

Gurukasikh · 13 Aug 2005

That was so GROSSSSSSSSSS!

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 13 Aug 2005

The RSS/militant Hindu pic makes me laugh- look at those sukkey, sarrey baiyyas - are they supposed to prose a real threat to the fearless Khalsa? Trusth is, Hindu's crapped themselves so much, they had to bring in helicopters, tanks, all the top of the range weapons to get rid of Sant Jarnail Singh ji Khalsa and a few Singhs.... Take a look at a picture of a Singh like Bhai Fauja Singh Shaheed, Sant Bhindranwalay, Baba Manochahal, Bhai Amrik Singh and you can FEEL the anakh...are these skeletal, dhoti, lagoti, tilak wearing bahmans any contest? Singh soormay Gobind de piaray, Khalsay di dhan zindagi!!!!!!

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

**- · 13 Aug 2005

Veer Pardeep Singh Bilga Ji, One thing I have learnt in life is to never underestimate someone simply because of their appearence. Go to East end of London and see how those skinny sukkey Bangladeshis control things. I have personally seen them defeat big 6ft Pakistani Punjabi Jats in a one to one street fight. Even if you got to the Far-East you will see skinny oriental marshal artists, but they probably have more josh and taakhat than a built Kaala (black guy) like Mike Tyson or Lenox Lewis. Regards Sitara PS When I have worked in London, I have personally seen bana and dumalla wearing Sikh boys crap themselves in front of kaaley.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

khalsa · 13 Aug 2005

What are you talking about?? Degh is prepared with more care and attention in Jatha smagams than anywhere else. The importance of degh is very high in the Jatha. ture but it is not degh which is in question. it is when gyani who is saying the arddas says "bhog lagge" or " hun labbo bhog har rai" bhog laao is hindu ritual. shabad guru can not eat food. shabad guru only blesses the food. [%sig%]

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 13 Aug 2005

Sitara- bring them on!!!...you are seriously getting on my nerves, what are you even doing on a Sikh site anyway? Haven't you got any fires to worship, any suns to offer water to, you ridiculous bahamani I tell you- Singhs do not fear ANYONE- be they kaaley, goray, bangladeshi etc etc...AND CERTAINLY NOT BAHMANIS LIKE YOU...and what are you talking about when you say pakistani jats have been beaten up by so and so- I am not talking about pakistanis, or even jats for that matter- I AM TALKING ABOUT THE KHALSA.....so go and buy some saris or bindis, which is what bahmans do

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

khalistani · 13 Aug 2005

a khalsa is also shaant peacefull first peacefull we use shastar and violennce only as a last resort we have not hate for anyone only pyaar for evryone, guru je is in everyone we shud try to be like bhai kineyea je, even though its hard we shdunt call that guy sukka ja, who knows how strong he is? who cares? and we also dont start calling hindus stupid bhamins they also are b rothers to khalsa will fight agaisnt tyranny, and defend dharm, and fight if it needs to but we arnt made to kill, this world shud be a place where pnly peace reigns, but because of maya we see hatred, and because of that, well never have a peaceful wrld, until we see vaheguru in eevryone were bth sant and sipai saints and soldiers saint comes first if i said somethin wrong, prob did, maafi, just wat i thought bhula chuka maf

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

Siddharth · 13 Aug 2005

Bilga - Why is he getting on your nerves? He is telling you the truth unlike you. Are you saying the truth bothers you? You still seem to be stuck in the 17th century talking about Brahmins in the way that you do. The Khalsa does not fear anyone and the true Khalsa does not talk ill about anyone either which is what you seem to be doing. Regards, Sid.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

**- · 14 Aug 2005

Veer Pardeep Singh Ji, Chill out! I didn't mean to upset you. If I did I apologise. The point I was making is that you shouldn't judge a persons physical prowess purely based on their appearence, thats all. Maybe I should have got my point accross in a better way. Regarding the rest of your insulting comments you have made to me, I will ignore them because I know in your heart you didn't really mean them - since if it one thing I have learnt, you Sikhs have a good heart. Once again my apologies, Sitara [%sig%]

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

Singh · 14 Aug 2005

Pardeep bhaji just chill. You said "Singhs do not fear ANYONE- be they kaaley, goray, bangladeshi..." This kinda sounds racist since there are goray and kaley sikhs and ya bangladeshi can be sikhs too.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

Observer · 15 Aug 2005

Sikhs should be working towards Breaking away From the 5 evil vices, then they are true khalsa, Judging by the comments written by some sikhs here, it seems not all sikh are working towards becoming khalsa. True Sikhs Activley breaks away from: Kaam or Lust. Krodh or anger. lobh or Greed. moh or attachment to worldly things. Hankaar or Ego. True Sikhs activley works towards: Satt or Truth. Santokh or Contentment. Sabr or Patience. Daya or Compassion. Dharam or Righteousness. Anger pride and Ego is taking over some of these so called sikhs, and because of that your Giving sikhs a bad name. Dont do that. please.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

A Singh · 15 Aug 2005

Dear Khalsa Thanks for your post. Perhaps you have misunderstood some part of it, when I mentioned “Bhai Mani Singh Shaheed” I included the word Shaheed as his title, not as a reference to his Saheedi being celebrated!!! In other words, Bhai Mani Singh, who we both agree was a great Gursikh, summoned the Sikhs on Divali Day for a Gurmatta. So your question as to why “sikhs … don't celerbate shaheede of guru arjan dev ji the first sikh shaheed, guru teg bahadur ji, bhai matti dass ji, bhai taroo singh ji, bhai diyalla ji etc” is invalid, as I have not suggested anything of the sort. Yes, I am very much aware of the Hindu Idols in the parkarma of Harimandir Sahib – I do not see how this has anything to do with Divali as practised by Sikhs the worldover INCLUDING the Harimandir Sahib. The paintings of the ram lila and krishan lila at the Akal Thakt is a different matter to the Idols (which were incorrect to be placed in the complex), of course they are no longer there, due to the fantastic job done by the Kar Seva Babas in white washing them or covering them with green tiles and of course the reconstruction of the Akal Thakt by the Taksal which now resembles nothing of the original – Veer Amandeep Singh Madra has spelt this out many times on various forums. Back to the matter at hand, this has nothing to do with Divali as per Sikhs – moreover, most of the painting depicting Hindu Deities also showed them ultimately bowing to Guru Nanak, a crucial point in the pictures. Your claim that “95% of sikh population know the story of ram and sita” but how many sikhs know the story of bandi chhod is a little far fetched - attend any Gurdwara on Divali night and you’ll find many kathavachiks relaying accounts of Guru Hargobind and the Bandi Chhod. Khalsa, you appear to be extremely paranoid, as highlighted by your claim that “90% of the Sikhs keep their front door open on devali night for lakshmi devi to come in” - this is simply a gross exaggeration! However I agree, I do not believe in Bipar stories, unfortunately many other Sikhs do, when it comes to matters such as belief in soocham and religious and non- religious colours. Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

A Singh · 15 Aug 2005

Sitara Veer, I will not discount my anthropological outlook, I work in a similar field to yourself, so “analyst” mindset retains, however, I haven’t been brought too differently from you either. We have lived outside India for four generations, yet upon all my travels to India, people consider it strange that I still retain interest and still practice many things wholly Indian from my religious beliefs (as a Sikh) and cultural customs (from simple family relations, dress, food, language to music, literature, arts and all the items you have listed below). These are part of my family upbringing, where sangeet in particular and the various subjects you mention below were openly discussed, for the very same reason: “to create a God-centred civilisation where everyone lives in peace and harmony.” I simply take issue that these factors are labelled as “Hindu”, be they good or bad, that would be akin to labelling Economics as Christian because Adam Smith is accredited with its origins or various western scientific disciplines as belonging to a particular religion, instead they are acknowledged as coming from Greek and Roman civilisations. Likewise, all the items you mentioned are firstly pre-dating those of Greece and Rome and secondly from the great “Indian” culture – if you term this “Hindu” on the basis that today “Hindustan” is used as a geographical term and “Hindu” is a term of nationality then fine, we’ll rest the matter here – however please understand that given how politically loaded this term (Hindu) has become in the last century alone I personally cannot look to describe it as a solely national term, it is without doubt referring to a religious community and is clearly an foreign term – otherwise it would openly be used time and time again the Vedas and Upanishads. [Also one correction: I align myself with the Sri Guru Granth Sahib, not the Vedas, although I hold the latter with respect and high regard]. When Guru Sahib refers to “Hindu”, he does do in the same manner in which he refers to “Turk” that should address all matters on this front. I disagree that the only people who have managed to preserve Indian culture are mostly Hindus, if that was the case, then you would not see the majority of the Hindustani Classical Sangeet scene dominated by Muslims, likewise for the painting and arts, one would not see martial aspects of India retained by Nihang Singhs or wrestling as dominated again by Muslims and Sikhs alike – the contributions of non-“hindu” communities to India far outweigh their proportional representation, the important thing to bear in mind is that these individuals regard themselves as part of the Indian cultural heritage and not as people alien to India, although they may have religious belief systems which are different from the majority mainstream “Hindus”. I have no problem in giving credit where it due and I would have hoped that Veer Jee, you would have noted this about me. I do not have an issue in being Sikh and of “Indian” descent and particularly of Punjabi background – certainly I do not reduce Punajbiyat to simply drinking, bhangra, womanizing, caste and pagan rituals as others may do so, and likewise with being “Indian” as contrary to western perceptions its not all about arranged/forced marriages, dowry, sati, caste, empty rituals, polygamy and sexist attitudes. I am happy, as always to agree to disagree, however it is not only 'Hinduism' in which “a vast array of opinions on different subjects” exists, the same is true of all faiths including Sikhs, where one can find Sanatanis (Hazoor Sahib and Patna Sahib) co-existing with the Singh Sabha (Akal Thakt, SGCP and DGMC) and all the variations that exist within them (Khalsa Singhs / Tat Khalsa, Nirmalas, Udasis, Nihangs, Sevapanthis, Rara Sahib Taksal, Sato-Gali Taksal, Damdami Taksal etc etc) come to meet with the same attitude to engage in Akal Ustat. It is only predominantly on the internet where fiery personalities such as those evidenced here, lead to a contrary view much like one would find in the counterpart “Hindu” setting if at a “Arya Samaj” meeting. As per sharing sentiments, yes we are on the same page, but perhaps interpreting things slightly differently. Gur Fateh! A Singh.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

**- · 15 Aug 2005

A Singh Ji ----- Also one correction: I align myself with the Sri Guru Granth Sahib, not the Vedas, although I hold the latter with respect and high regard]. ----- Sorry that was my mistake, that is what I was meant to say - honest! I am in no way trying to Hindufy you :-<>. They may need to change the title of this thread to 'Hinduisation of A Singh' LOL! Anyway it has been good to speak with you. I have still not been able to come up with the Hindu origins of Lohri. Again if I have time I will try and find out. God bless, Sitara [%sig%]

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 15 Aug 2005

Siddarthio- what TRUTH is there in any of the crap Sitara is posting on this forum?

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

khalsa · 16 Aug 2005

A Singh you have missed the point when you wrote about hindu idols and painting in harminder sahib complex my point is that all sikh gurdwaras were under the control of uddasis nirmallee and mahants and they were hindus they hindunised the sikhi sikh history and started all bipran ki reets and we believe them as gospal truth. what i m saying is that we should follow the gurbani word for word day in day out "no to bipran ki reet". that's all nothing more to say. [%sig%]

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

A Singh · 16 Aug 2005

Dear “Khalsa” Veer, I am very much aware that the impact of the Udasis and Nirmalas brought with them much in the way of Bipar thought – sadly today we only see this externally (i.e. historical idols and such) and are unaware of the impact it has had on Sikh Thought vis-à-vis much of the parchar that goes on today and much of the rituals blinded followed in the name of Tat Maryada – very many of which have their origins in what is being continually referred to as “Bipran ki reet”. The thread on Bana was about the same thing, however insecure people, who cannot read fully before jumping to conclusions have taken it as an attack on all sorts of things! Perhaps you could look at some of the thoughts that filter through perhaps three of the great modern era Sikh institutions: AKJ, SGPC and Taksal? For example, and this is not in any way exhaustive, check out the Rehit Maryada as issued by the Damdami Taksal (see http://www.damdamitaksal.com/rehat.pdf) where the following lines from Bhai Gurdas Jee: "Be faithful to your one wife, see others as your daughters and sisters, (for women you must be faithful to one husband and see others as your sons and brothers)." (Var. 6, Pauri 8, Bhai Gurdas Jee) are interpreted as follows: A Singh must look upon his wife as his faithful Singhni and a SINGHNI SHOULD LOOK UPON HER HUSBAND AS PARMESHWAR(GOD). This is not unique only to DDT, Nanaksar also adopt the same advice as do the Nishkam Sevak Jatha. Please tell me if this is not Bipran ki Reet and a direct quotation of the “Pati-Parmeshvar” ideology of the “Hindus”? Similarly, we are all aware of the SGPC stance on Sikh Women and their participation in the Punj Pyare and even during kirtan and other seva, albeit some of these restrictions were recently lifted. Then we have others, like the Sarablohis and the Nihangs who have carved out distinct maryada for themselves based upon secondary and tertiary sources to make others believe they are the true upholders of “tat gurmat maryada” and as a consequence are the only ones rather like Brahmins, entitled to undertake management and control of religious functions and ceremonies. As I mentioned, this is not an exhaustive list, there are far more serious issues to consider here – particularly that of Pati-Parmeshvar. Gur Fateh! A Singh.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

khalsa · 16 Aug 2005

veer A Singh ji I 'm very disappointed with your comments about maryada no body talked about being faithful to your life partner you are going of the real point " bipran ki reet" as for few of the maryadas you have mentioned by different institutes according to my knowledge and beliefe there is only one i mean only one khalsa panth revealed by guru gobind singh ji and there is one maryada for whole khalsa panth. WHY there are 4/5 different maryadas are there more than one types of khalsas. i think you are one of them "Maain na manoooo" waheguru ji ka khasla waheguru ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

A Singh · 17 Aug 2005

Dear “Khalsa” Veer, VahegurooJeeKaKhalsa VahegurooJeeKeeFateh! It is a shame to see you disappointed, however I hope you can see the difference between being “Faithful to One’s Life Partner” and the statement that a Woman should see her husband as God – Pati Parmeasur is a total Brahmin concept and one that goes quite contrary to the teachings of Guru Nanak Dev Ji (see his extensive works within the Asa Ki Var in which he discusses women and the attitudes one should have towards them – I’m not so learned, so admit that I may have misunderstood this, in which case please could you correct me). Please could also you help me understand your other comments, as it wasn’t too clear for me, namely: << you are going of the real point " bipran ki reet">> Please could you indicate how I am doing this, am I advocating, like Brahmins that our Women worship us as God? Am I insisting that our Amritdhari Brothers and Sisters refuse to sit alongside us in Langar? Perhaps I am doing something else which I am unaware of, in which case, again please elucidate and allow me to correct myself. <> This is really a separate discussion, if you are asking for my take on it, I’ll try and keep it short as I have various views on this subject however here’s one of them: In 1699, Guru Sahib inaugurated the Khalsa Panth, the rehit provided therein was quite simple if we go by original texts (i.e. 5 Banis and 5 Kakkars etc). ith this ruling, Guru Sahib also divested power unto to the 5 Pyare – such that they would carry out the rehit by oral means. This oral means was not initiated in order to make various Jathas exist, for each maryada ultimately centres around the same basic theme (i.e. 5 Banis, 5 Kakkars – as today enshrined in the Sikh Rehit Maryada from the Akal Thakt, which forms the back bone of all Sikh Maryada at present, that is minimum standards), instead the Punj as the representatives of the Guru Panth were permitted to incorporate various socio-political factors within the rehit as they arose (i.e. overtime, the initial Punj Mel of Guru Sahib’s time have expanded to include Nakli Nirankaris and Radhasoamis – groups who were not initially around at the time of Guru Sahib, however the Punj in their wisdom have decreed the precedent set by the initial ruling to have substantial ground for ostracizing these groups as well – similar to what happened with the Nakli-Bandai Khalsa and the associated ban on red clothing and the rulings within other historical rehitnamas on various, essentially socio-political points). Like this, using the flexibility provided within the oral transmission, the Punj Pyare were able to ensure that the essential tenents of the 5Ks and 5 Banis remain intact as well as ensuring that non-Sikh or non-Gurmat elements could not interfere the lifestyle of the Khalsa (read the 6 puratan rehitnamas and you’ll see clear indication of this). In conclusion, variation in rehit is nothing bad nor does it imply somehow that there are various Khalsas – at the end of the day, if we are happy to see numerous Gursikhs who recite way in excess of the 5 mandatory Banis as their Nitnem, why are struggling to deal with factors such as additional requirements within certain groups over and above the minimum standards set by the Akal Thakt? Unless of course, if these reek of Bipran influence, such as that above where Sikh Women are being instructed to treat their Husband as God. Hope this helps. Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

khalsa · 17 Aug 2005

veer A Singh JI waheguruji ka khalsa waheguruji ke fateh the thread started as hinduization of sikh faith and history not about pati parmeshwer you brought in the rahit maryada. panj payare amended the maryada as they saw necassary but sticking to the original maryada. but some jathas are saying kes was not in the 5Ks but it was keski. according to you guru did not see into the future of khalsa when HE made the maryada. i better stop here and say no more. bhul chuk muaff. waheguruji ka khalsa waheguruji ke fateh [%sig%]

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

Singh · 17 Aug 2005

Singh’s I think you both agree that to some extent there has been enrodes made by Hinduism into the Sikh faith. We all accept this and hence hopefully this can be combated. The fist step being working together based on common ground under the umbrella of the Sikh Rehat Maryada. If this happens the Panth would be so much stronger.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

A Singh · 17 Aug 2005

Veer “Khalsa”, Sorry to see that you have felt the need to twist my words (re: “according to you guru did not see into the future of khalsa when HE made the maryada”) This is NOT something I ascribe to and nor is it something that I indicated in my statement, this your feeble attempt to discredit a simple statement I made, that too at your asking. GURU SAHIB conferred Gurgaddi to Guru Granth Sahib and Guru Panth – there are numerous references for this occurring and the Guru Panth (Akal Thakt) has made clear its stance on Maryada. If we were to follow your line of thought in the accusation you file against me, presumably Guru Sahib didn’t see into the future of the Khalsa on all the issues that face the Panth today, internally and externally??? Hinduization was indeed the topic of the thread and I don’t see how we’ve gone outside of that, you begun with the proposition that there have been many attempts by Udasi and Nirmalas to incorporate Hindu elements into the Panth and showed your support for the heritage destroying Kar Seva Babas who white washed the historical paintings at the Akal Thakt and also covered others with Green Bathroom tiles because they showed the Ram Lila and Krishna Lila. HOWEVER, YOU now cannot see the link between a TOTOALLY HINDU BIPAR concept of PATI-PARMEASUR and how this has made in roads into some of institutions – no doubt historically at the hands of the same groups. We are still on the same topic, please address this question – or at least explain to me where I am incorrect in my understanding of the “Pati-Parmeasur” concept and its acceptability within Gurmat? Likewise for other issues such as prohibition of women doing kirtan etc. Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

khalsa · 17 Aug 2005

veer A singh i do not believe in hindu concept of "patti parmeshwer" gurbani does not accept this. i donot remember the exect wording but according to gurbani there is only one purkh "patti" and that is "Akalpurkh". as for women not allowed to perform kirtan this is the first time i have heard or read this. please excuse me for this. i do not know. [%sig%]

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

dont know · 17 Aug 2005

kalyug is behind all of this the khalsa panth is always going to have enemies because we live in kalyugs age and he doesnt like us lets not look around at each other keeps your eyes on the path that we are on and the real enemies of the panth that stand before us and not look at each other

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

Prabhjot(guru da sikh) · 26 Jan 2006

i think badal has corrupted our society......our leaders r dead... ....SGPC 's budget is almost equalll to punjabs government budget.....our leaders need to wake up n counter the RSS and not shake hands with them.....Take out these old freaks from being our leader put some fresh blood in SGPC then i think sikhi will progreess. WAHEGURU JI DA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI DI FATEH

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

t dot jatt · 22 Jun 2006

hindus are ashamed of their own history so they have to try stealing ours, the sad thing is in the punjab many sikhs have begun thinking sikhism and hinduism is the same.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

t dot jatt · 22 Jun 2006

this needs to be emailed to every sikh out their.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

A Singh · 22 Jun 2006

Dear "Khalsa" - The matter concerning women and not being allowed to perform Kirtan or be part of the Punj Pyare is well known and details can be found on various threads on this forum. The DDT and Sant Samaj are particularly well known for this views on not having women as part of the Punj, albeit they dress this up with supposed 'rationale'. In the same way, the concept of Pati-Parmesur I have shown exists in the DDT rehitmaryada which can be downloaded from the website www.damdamitaksal.com and also be evidenced from various sermons delivered at many Gurdwaras affiliated with the DDT, Nanaksar, Niskaamsevak Jatha and others - of course, people will now accuse me of insulting these institutions, however all I am stating is observation of reality - for mainstream references, check out the recording by Balwinder Singh Rangila of the shabad "Galee Usi Changeeya" sung to the usual bollywood tune rip offs and his veechar throughout the recording which is replete with many sexist references. t dot jatt, let's be clear here - Hindus have a history that many Sikhs as a bid to prove their points have unwisely chosen to insult or degrade as a result what we witness now is a "reaction" from the Hindus - that doesn't justify it in anyway, however the solution to this onslaught by the RSS is not going to assisted in anyway by slagging off Hindu traditions or history, which is something we see a lot of today together with many people styling themselves as "Khalsa" "Singh" etc using all sorts of obsenities - Khalsa is supposed to spiritually elevated and in chardi kala, using obsenities or dropping to the level of the supposed 'opposition' or 'enemy' is not the custom of the Khalsa of Guru Gobind Singh.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

PTE SINGH · 22 Jun 2006

Mr Bilga, Making fun of, insulting and disrespecting others religion is not part of Sikhi. I take exception to the Hindu bashing on this thread. I am a Sikh and respecting others religions and sentiments is my duty. The two Hindu chaps have shown themselves to be better men then you. They have not insulted Sikhism in anyway, but you have in the way you have expressed yourself. [%sig%]

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

jason · 29 Jun 2006

hey chandra singh you may ask a question or reply with your viewpoint but i don't see any need to close this thread as it brings out the trush about how india is trying to destroy are history.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

jason · 01 Jul 2006

sikhism is dieing in the punjab but in the west we don't have to worry about sikhs becomming hindus and worshipping statues and cows, itleast in the west if sikhs know anything they know they are definitely no hindus.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

jason · 01 Jul 2006

looks like chandra singh has nothing left to say i guess he relized the truth.

Re: Illustrated: Hinduization of Sikh Faith & History

Balpreet Singh · 26 Oct 2006

I'm especially bumping this for Man Singh. Enjoy.